Misplaced Pages

Circumcision: Revision history

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
View logs for this page (view filter log)
Filter revisionsshowhide
External tools:

For any version listed below, click on its date to view it. For more help, see Help:Page history and Help:Edit summary. (cur) = difference from current version, (prev) = difference from preceding version, m = minor edit, → = section edit, ← = automatic edit summary

(newest | oldest) View ( | ) (20 | 50 | 100 | 250 | 500)

2 June 2024

  • curprev 01:1401:14, 2 June 2024 Prcc27 talk contribs 146,214 bytes +124 Please quit lying. MrOllie did not !vote and BonCourage would like to see different wording, but has not explicitly expressed opposition to some sort of mention on ethics. Tag: Undo
  • curprev 00:2500:25, 2 June 2024 KlayCax talk contribs 146,090 bytes −124 What consensus? Current opinion on the talk page is 4-3 in the *opposite* direction. (Pro: Prcc27, Piccco, RakdosWitch; Anti: Me, MrOllie, Bon Courage, and FootballRocker) Controversies should only be in the lead if there is substantial, long-lasting notability. We already include differing perspectives on medical value/culture in the same paragraph. We intentionally exclude it on articles surrounding gender-affirming surgery, labiaplasty, , and other related subjects. Tags: Undo Reverted

1 June 2024

23 May 2024

9 May 2024

8 May 2024

2 May 2024

22 April 2024

13 April 2024

6 April 2024

  • curprev 02:5202:52, 6 April 2024 Bon courage talk contribs 146,089 bytes −124 Restored revision 1217460370 by KlayCax (talk): This is still nothing-y; any proposed text should be workshopped on Talk Tags: Twinkle Undo Reverted
  • curprev 01:3701:37, 6 April 2024 Prcc27 talk contribs 146,213 bytes +124 Please see the archives on past discussions, and the current discussion where there isn’t really any strong opposition to including ethics, aside from you. That’s a medical viewpoint on efficacy (and does not really say anything about ethics or controversy). Cultural, societal, and ethical viewpoints are also relevant, and a concise sentence in contrast to a whole paragraph on the medical viewpoint is WP:DUE. Saying there are various ethical views hardly suggests there’s a controversy. Tags: Undo Reverted

5 April 2024

  • curprev 23:4823:48, 5 April 2024 KlayCax talk contribs 146,089 bytes −124 Where's the consensus at? We already *do* include it. ". Some medical organizations take the position that it carries prophylactic health benefits which outweigh the risks, while other medical organizations generally hold the belief that in these situations its medical benefits are not counterbalanced by risk" Tags: Undo Reverted

4 April 2024

31 March 2024

30 March 2024

29 March 2024

28 March 2024

26 March 2024

21 March 2024

16 March 2024

13 March 2024

7 March 2024

6 March 2024

5 March 2024

2 March 2024

  • curprev 07:0807:08, 2 March 2024 Wikipedialuva talk contribs 146,431 bytes −249 Removing WP:POV material that circumcision is "not required for a life directed by Allah". The statement is not supported by the source given, and viewpoint is debated, as many sects do in fact require circumcision. Replacing the quote that Islamic scholars have diverse opinions on whether it is required supported by WP:RS.

29 February 2024

26 February 2024

  • curprev 08:4608:46, 26 February 2024 Sirfurboy talk contribs 146,479 bytes −457 Undid revision 1210348290 by Prcc27 (talk) You say to go to talk, but don't do so yourself. You re-asserted challenged material, which is against WP:ONUS. The lead is a summary per MOS:LEAD and the disputed text is not a helpful or clear summary of the section "Ethical and legal issues". I think it needs discussion in talk before being put back. Tag: Undo
  • curprev 05:1505:15, 26 February 2024 Prcc27 talk contribs 146,936 bytes +457 “Theological circles” covers more than just Northern Europe. Bioethical concerns are not just limited to northern Europe. There was already a consensus to include controversies like ethics in the lead. Please go to talk before starting an edit war. Tags: Undo Reverted
(newest | oldest) View ( | ) (20 | 50 | 100 | 250 | 500)