Misplaced Pages

:Suspected sock puppets/Dereks1x: Difference between revisions - Misplaced Pages

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
< Misplaced Pages:Suspected sock puppets Browse history interactivelyNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 20:20, 25 March 2007 editJersyko (talk | contribs)14,671 edits started  Revision as of 21:18, 25 March 2007 edit undoDereks1x (talk | contribs)355 edits →[]Next edit →
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:


;Suspected sockpuppets ;Suspected sockpuppets
{{user5|1=HumanThing}}<br> {{user5|1=Ecostaz}}<br>,
{{user5|1=DelloJello}}<br> {{user5|1=HumanThing}}<br>,
{{user5|1=TL500}} {{user5|1=Tvoz}}<br>,
{{user5|1=DelloJello}}<br>,
{{user5|1=TL500}},
{{user5|1=Bobblehead}}<br>,


<!--If there are additional suspected sockpuppets to be included, add them above this comment using the form {{user5|1=SOCKPUPPET}}<br>, replacing SOCKPUPPET in each case with the user name that you suspect is a sockpuppet of the puppetmaster. (Leave out the "User:" prefix.) Leave the <br> tag after each one and add or remove lines as necessary. Remove this comment once completed. --> <!--If there are additional suspected sockpuppets to be included, add them above this comment using the form {{user5|1=SOCKPUPPET}}<br>, replacing SOCKPUPPET in each case with the user name that you suspect is a sockpuppet of the puppetmaster. (Leave out the "User:" prefix.) Leave the <br> tag after each one and add or remove lines as necessary. Remove this comment once completed. -->
Line 17: Line 20:
;Evidence ;Evidence
*] (and related comments) *] (and related comments)
Jersyko and Bobbelhead and Tvoz are also talkers about this. Even Ecostaz talked about cancer.
The main dispute seems to be that Jersyko doesn't like Dereks1x discussion about Edwards and Obama even though everything is logical, civil, and not disruptive.] 21:04, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
*:, , , etc, see *:, , , etc, see
*] *]
*:, , , etc, see *:, , , etc, see
*Three of them appear to have taken an interest in ] *Three of them appear to have taken an interest in ]
Actually, add Bobblehead under the talk page (Lake City)
*:, , , etc, see *:, , , etc, see
*Two have edited and its talk page (though there was no content dispute). *Two have edited and its talk page (though there was no content dispute). This guy was on all the network news shows and on the internet because he just died. Millions of people knew the guy.] 21:04, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
*However, Dereks1x is unique in writing about some very, very obscure topics and articles such as
Glaxo, Surrender Document, United States, Carrasco, Parke-Davis, Dunlop Tyres, Sidley Austin, Kathryn Kuhlmann, Oral Roberts, Oral Roberts University, George Washington, Commonwealth of Nations, Paula Jones, Jim McDermott, etc.
*This TL500 person is pretty much an airline person and stays away from politics. TL500 isn't involved in any argument with ANYONE.
*DelloJello just writes about Illinois topics and doesn't seem to be very political. Only once wrote on Obama and that was just the discussion page, not the acutal article.
*HumanThing writes about Florida topics and Sarah Palin. Only had 2 minor John Edwards entries.
*Tvoz and Dereks1x both write a comment on Steve Dufour's user talk page.



;Comments ;Comments
I am making this report because I suspect, but am by no means certain, that Dereks1x is using sockpuppets to attempt to gain advantages in content disputes. The alleged socks have advanced positions remarkably similar to Dereks1x's on relevant talk pages while most other editors that have participated in the relevant discussions have reached opposite conclusions. · '''<font color="#709070">]</font>''' ''<font color="#007BA7" size="1">]</font>'' · 20:20, 25 March 2007 (UTC) I am making this report because I suspect, but am by no means certain, that Dereks1x is using sockpuppets to attempt to gain advantages in content disputes. The alleged socks have advanced positions remarkably similar to Dereks1x's on relevant talk pages while most other editors that have participated in the relevant discussions have reached opposite conclusions. · '''<font color="#709070">]</font>''' ''<font color="#007BA7" size="1">]</font>'' · 20:20, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

This comment is not relevant because all editing has been done by consensus and compromise. For example, the part about Senator Obama's legal career was edited many times but has stabilized. So has Mrs. Edwards' cancer. So there is no evidence of disruption, just good old fashioned discussion and revisions. Misplaced Pages editing has been done by consensus (in the articles named, not voting)] 21:18, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

I, Dereks1x, have never voted in any of the roughly 12 Obama polls (in the discussion page) under whether something is notable or not. Sock puppets are bad for multiple voting. In fact, nobody has voted in those polls, except Bobblehead (about 4 times), and TL500 once.] 21:18, 25 March 2007 (UTC)


;Conclusions ;Conclusions
*1. This is aggression by Jerseyko because nothing bad has been done.
*2. Jersyko, Bobblehead, Tvoz have made some nasty comments about me regarding the John Edwards article. Maybe that's why Jersyko and her friends are mad? Are they the same person???? That's very suspicious, the link between Jersyko, Tvoz, and to some extent, Bobblehead.
*3. People look at each others' contributions and then think "oh, I have an idea about that subject". I've done that.
*4. I generally don't vote in polls regarding if a political issue is or is not notable.
*5. '''Bold text'''I've done nothing disruptive. All contributions have been sensible, not radical or communist.'''Bold text'''
*6. I don't have control over others at work who may or may not be contributing.
*7. I contribute to some very obscure wikipedia articles that I suspect nobody else does. Such as Falklands Surrender Document, Glaxo, Kathryn Kulmann, Dunlop tires.
*8. Jersyko should be banned for at least 48 hours because of disruptive comments and disruptive accusations, which take a long time to defend.






Revision as of 21:18, 25 March 2007

User:Dereks1x

Suspected sockpuppeteer

Dereks1x (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)

Suspected sockpuppets

Ecostaz (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)
, HumanThing (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)
, Tvoz (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)
, DelloJello (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)
, TL500 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log), Bobblehead (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)
,

Report submission by

· j e r s y k o talk · 20:20, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

Evidence

Jersyko and Bobbelhead and Tvoz are also talkers about this. Even Ecostaz talked about cancer. The main dispute seems to be that Jersyko doesn't like Dereks1x discussion about Edwards and Obama even though everything is logical, civil, and not disruptive.Dereks1x 21:04, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

Actually, add Bobblehead under the talk page (Lake City)

  • , , , etc, see history
  • Two have edited Calvert DeForest and its talk page (though there was no content dispute). This guy was on all the network news shows and on the internet because he just died. Millions of people knew the guy.Dereks1x 21:04, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
  • However, Dereks1x is unique in writing about some very, very obscure topics and articles such as

Glaxo, Surrender Document, United States, Carrasco, Parke-Davis, Dunlop Tyres, Sidley Austin, Kathryn Kuhlmann, Oral Roberts, Oral Roberts University, George Washington, Commonwealth of Nations, Paula Jones, Jim McDermott, etc.

  • This TL500 person is pretty much an airline person and stays away from politics. TL500 isn't involved in any argument with ANYONE.
  • DelloJello just writes about Illinois topics and doesn't seem to be very political. Only once wrote on Obama and that was just the discussion page, not the acutal article.
  • HumanThing writes about Florida topics and Sarah Palin. Only had 2 minor John Edwards entries.
  • Tvoz and Dereks1x both write a comment on Steve Dufour's user talk page.


Comments

I am making this report because I suspect, but am by no means certain, that Dereks1x is using sockpuppets to attempt to gain advantages in content disputes. The alleged socks have advanced positions remarkably similar to Dereks1x's on relevant talk pages while most other editors that have participated in the relevant discussions have reached opposite conclusions. · j e r s y k o talk · 20:20, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

This comment is not relevant because all editing has been done by consensus and compromise. For example, the part about Senator Obama's legal career was edited many times but has stabilized. So has Mrs. Edwards' cancer. So there is no evidence of disruption, just good old fashioned discussion and revisions. Misplaced Pages editing has been done by consensus (in the articles named, not voting)Dereks1x 21:18, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

I, Dereks1x, have never voted in any of the roughly 12 Obama polls (in the discussion page) under whether something is notable or not. Sock puppets are bad for multiple voting. In fact, nobody has voted in those polls, except Bobblehead (about 4 times), and TL500 once.Dereks1x 21:18, 25 March 2007 (UTC)

Conclusions
  • 1. This is aggression by Jerseyko because nothing bad has been done.
  • 2. Jersyko, Bobblehead, Tvoz have made some nasty comments about me regarding the John Edwards article. Maybe that's why Jersyko and her friends are mad? Are they the same person???? That's very suspicious, the link between Jersyko, Tvoz, and to some extent, Bobblehead.
  • 3. People look at each others' contributions and then think "oh, I have an idea about that subject". I've done that.
  • 4. I generally don't vote in polls regarding if a political issue is or is not notable.
  • 5. Bold textI've done nothing disruptive. All contributions have been sensible, not radical or communist.Bold text
  • 6. I don't have control over others at work who may or may not be contributing.
  • 7. I contribute to some very obscure wikipedia articles that I suspect nobody else does. Such as Falklands Surrender Document, Glaxo, Kathryn Kulmann, Dunlop tires.
  • 8. Jersyko should be banned for at least 48 hours because of disruptive comments and disruptive accusations, which take a long time to defend.