| Revision as of 12:25, 11 April 2007 editSmackBot (talk | contribs)3,734,324 editsm Date/fix the maintenance tags← Previous edit | Revision as of 15:50, 11 April 2007 edit undoHodja Nasreddin (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Pending changes reviewers31,217 edits rv to Piotrus (Talk | contribs) at 05:22, 10 April 2007. Let's keep this article as it was until the end of AfD discussion (see talk page)Next edit → | ||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
| </div> | </div> | ||
| {{{category|]}}} | {{{category|]}}} | ||
| <!-- End of AfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point --> | <!-- End of AfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point --> | ||
| {{POV}} | |||
| {{Disputed title}} | {{Disputed title}} | ||
| {{totallydisputed}} | |||
| The '''internet brigades''' (]: Веб-бригады) | |||
| <ref name="China"> , by Jonathan Watts in Beijing, ], ], ]</ref> <ref name="Polyanskaya"/> are real and alleged state-sponsored ] teams that conduct ] ]. Such teams may be affiliated with state propaganda departments, military, or ] forces. They are said to disseminate ] and prevent free discussions of undesirable subjects in ]s and ] by using ], ] and other ] methods against ]s.<ref name="Bagryansky"> {{ru icon}} by ] and Vladimur Bagryansky, publication of the Russian Center for Extreme Journalism </ref> Since the existence of internet brigades is often officially denied, such activities may be defined as "]", ] or ] operations (or "]" according to Russian terminology). | |||
| ==Internet brigades in Russia== | ==Internet brigades in Russia== | ||
| ===First publications=== | ===First publications=== | ||
| This alleged phenomenon in ] was first |
This alleged phenomenon in ] was first written about in 2003 by a group of ]s led by ],<ref>, MAOF publishing group</ref> a former assistant to assassinated ] politician ].<ref>{{ru icon}} , by Anna Polyanskaya</ref> The allegations of Polyanskaya and her colleagues have been supported by writer ] and psychologist Vladimir Bagryansky.<ref name="Bagryansky"/> They claimed the appearance of organized and fairly professional "brigades", composed of ideologically and methodologically identical personalities, who were working in practically every popular ] and pro-] blogs and internet newspapers of RuNet in the Russian ]. These Internet teams appeared suddenly on Russian language forums in ]. They have been allegedly organized by the Russian ] service, the main successor of the ].<ref name="Bagryansky"/><ref name="Polyanskaya"> by Anna Polyanskaya, Andrei Krivov, and Ivan Lomko, Vestnik online, ], ] ()</ref> | ||
| ===Criticism and discussions=== | ===Criticism and discussions=== | ||
| Alexander Usupovski, head of the analytical department of the ] |
The work of the FSB brigades has been extensively debated in ]. The discussion began in the ] of the "Russian Journal", just a few days after the first publication by Polyanskaya and others, and it lasted for two months.<ref name="Bagryansky"/> One group of bloggers was led by Alexander Usupovski, head of the analytical department of the ]. He dismissed the existence of such brigades as a ] and noted that defamation of Russian secret services may force them to work "beyond the law" <ref> , by Alexander Usupovsky, Russian Journal, ], ]</ref>. Other bloggers claimed that Usupovsky and his supporters ''are'' the governmental "internet brigade." The discussion ended by a series of personal threats from the first group with address to Ivan Lomko, one of authors of the original publication. According to ], "the internet brigade led by Alexander Usupovski is probably the most incompetent team of Russian state security services in RuNet" <ref name="Bagryansky"/>. A discussion was also conducted on the internet forum of ].<ref name="Bagryansky"/> | ||
| ⚫ | ===Brigades on the Polish internet=== | ||
| According to Usupovski: "We would never make our country's military organizations and security services work under the rule of law and legal control, if won't learn to recognize rationally and objectively their necessity and usefullness of functions performed by them for the country, state, society and citizens. Sweepeing defamation and intentional discreditation with the help of "arguments", which are obviously false, only contribute to the extrusion of security services outside of rule of law and instigates them to chaos".<ref> , by Alexander Usupovsky, Russian Journal, ], ]</ref>. | |||
| ⚫ | Russian "internet brigades" reportedly resurfaced in ] in 2005. According to the Polish newspaper ], "at least a dozen active Russian agents work in Poland, also investigating the Polish internet. Not only do they scrutinize Polish websites (like those supporting ] opposition), but also perform such actions, as—for instance—contributing to internet forums on large portals (like Gazeta.pl, Onet.pl, WP.pl). Labeled as Polish Internet users, they incite anti-Semitic or anti-Ukrainian discussions or disavow articles published on the web."<ref name="Tygodnik"> , ], 13/2005</ref> | ||
| ⚫ | ===Recent developments=== | ||
| The work of the FSB brigades has been debated in ]{{Fact|date=April 2007}}. The discussion began in the ] of the "Russian Journal", just a few days after the first publication by Polyanskaya and others, and it lasted for two months.<ref name="Bagryansky"/> A discussion was also conducted on the internet forum of ].<ref name="Bagryansky"/> ] claimed that Usupovsky and his supporters ''are'' "incompetent" "internet propaganda brigade" "unfit for serious intellectual discussions" and "agitators of ]".<ref name="Bagryansky"/> ] also claimed that Alexander Usupovski "internet propaganda brigade" threatened to kill him.<ref name="Bagryansky"/> The discussion ended by a series of personal threats from the first group with address to Ivan Lomko, one of authors of the original publication.{{Fact|date=April 2007}} According to the allegations of ], "the internet brigade led by Alexander Usupovski is probably the most incompetent team of Russian state security services in RuNet".<ref name="Bagryansky"/> | |||
| The teams of "] fighters" are claimed to be created by organization "Russia the young", directed and paid from the Kremlin.<ref>{{ru icon}} , grani.ru, ], ]</ref> Their ideological work in Live Journal is extremely important, said ], a top aide to ].<ref>, '']'', ], ]</ref> | |||
| ⚫ | ===Brigades on the Polish |
||
| ⚫ | Russian " |
||
| ⚫ | ===Recent developments=== | ||
| ===Behavior=== | ===Behavior=== | ||
| The postings from people supposed to be part of the Internet brigades have certain distinct features some of which are the following <ref name="Polyanskaya"/>: | |||
| *Propaganda of the ], and constant attempts to present in a positive light the entire history of Russia and the ], minimizing the number of people who died in repressions. | *Propaganda of the ], and constant attempts to present in a positive light the entire history of Russia and the ], minimizing the number of people who died in repressions. | ||
| *Boundless loyalty to ] and his circle. | *Boundless loyalty to ] and his circle. | ||
| Line 41: | Line 41: | ||
| ===Tactics=== | ===Tactics=== | ||
| ⚫ | *'''Individual work on opponents.''' "As soon as an opposition-minded liberal arrives on a forum, expressing a position that makes them a clear "ideological enemy”, he is immediately cornered and subjected to “]” by the unified web-brigade. Without provocation, the opponent is piled on with abuse or vicious “arguments” of the sort that the average person cannot adequately react to. As a result, the liberal either answers sharply, causing a scandal and getting himself labeled a “boor” by the rest of the brigade, or else he starts to make arguments against the obvious absurdities, to which his opponents pay no attention, but simply ridicule him and put forth other similar arguments." <ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | ||
| According to the allegations of Polyanskaya, Krivov and Lomko, tactics of Internet brigades include: | |||
| ⚫ | *'''Individual work on opponents.''' "As soon as an opposition-minded liberal arrives on a forum, expressing a position that makes them a clear "ideological enemy”, he is immediately cornered and subjected to “]” by the unified web-brigade. Without provocation, the opponent is piled on with abuse or vicious “arguments” of the sort that the average person cannot adequately react to. As a result, the liberal either answers sharply, causing a scandal and getting himself labeled a “boor” by the rest of the brigade, or else he starts to make arguments against the obvious absurdities, to which his opponents pay no attention, but simply ridicule him and put forth other similar arguments."<ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | ||
| *'''Accusations that opponents are working for “enemies”'''. The opponents are accused of taking money from ], the ], the ], ], the ], or the ] rebels. | *'''Accusations that opponents are working for “enemies”'''. The opponents are accused of taking money from ], the ], the ], ], the ], or the ] rebels. | ||
| *'''Making personally offensive comments''', especially of sexual nature. | *'''Making personally offensive comments''', especially of sexual nature. | ||
| *'''Remarkable ability to reveal personal information''' about their opponents and their quotes from old postings, sometimes more than a year old. | *'''Remarkable ability to reveal personal information''' about their opponents and their quotes from old postings, sometimes more than a year old. | ||
| *'''Teamwork'''. "They unwaveringly support each other in discussions, ask each other leading questions, put fine points on each other’s answers, and even pretend not to know each other. If an opponent starts to be hounded, this hounding invariably becomes a team effort, involving all of the three to twenty nicknames that invariably are present on any political forum 24 hours a day."<ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | *'''Teamwork'''. "They unwaveringly support each other in discussions, ask each other leading questions, put fine points on each other’s answers, and even pretend not to know each other. If an opponent starts to be hounded, this hounding invariably becomes a team effort, involving all of the three to twenty nicknames that invariably are present on any political forum 24 hours a day." <ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | ||
| *'''Appealing to the Administration'''. The members of teams often "write mass collective complaints about their opponents to the editors, site administrators, or the electronic “complaints book”, demanding that one or another posting or whole discussion thread they don’t like be removed, or calling for the banning of individuals they find problematic."<ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | *'''Appealing to the Administration'''. The members of teams often "write mass collective complaints about their opponents to the editors, site administrators, or the electronic “complaints book”, demanding that one or another posting or whole discussion thread they don’t like be removed, or calling for the banning of individuals they find problematic." <ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | ||
| *'''Destruction of inconvenient forums'''. For example, on the site of the ], all critics of ] and the FSB "were suddenly and without any explanation banned from all discussions, despite their having broken none of the site’s rules of conduct. All the postings of this group of readers, going back a year and a half, were erased by the site administrator."<ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | *'''Destruction of inconvenient forums'''. For example, on the site of the ], all critics of ] and the FSB "were suddenly and without any explanation banned from all discussions, despite their having broken none of the site’s rules of conduct. All the postings of this group of readers, going back a year and a half, were erased by the site administrator." <ref name="Polyanskaya"/> | ||
| ===Internet brigades in Russian |
===Internet brigades in Russian literature=== | ||
| The alleged ] activities on the Internet have been described in the short story "Anastasya" by Russian writer |
The alleged ] activities on the Internet have been described in the short story "Anastasya" by Russian writer ], who was interested in the moral aspects of their work.<ref name="Svirsky>" ] </ref> He wrote: ''"It seems that offending, betraying, or even "murdering" people in the virtual space is easy. This is like killing an enemy in a video game: one does not see a disfigured body or the eyes of the person who is dying right in front of you. However, the human soul lives by its own basic laws that force it to pay the price for the virtual crime in his real life"''. <ref name="Bagryansky"/> | ||
| ==Internet police teams in mainland China== | ==Internet police teams in mainland China== | ||
| ] leader ] ordered to "maintain the initiative in opinion on the Internet and raise the level of guidance online,"<ref> , ], ], ]</ref> "An internet police force - reportedly numbering 30,000 - trawls websites and chat rooms, erasing anti-Communist comments and posting pro-government messages" |
] leader ] ordered to "maintain the initiative in opinion on the Internet and raise the level of guidance online," <ref> , ], ], ]</ref> "An internet police force - reportedly numbering 30,000 - trawls websites and chat rooms, erasing anti-Communist comments and posting pro-government messages" <ref> by ], ], ]</ref>, although the exact numbers of Internet police personnel was challenged by Chinese authorities <ref> ]</ref> It was reported that departments of provincial and municipal governments in ] began creating "teams of internet commentators, whose job is to guide discussion on public bulletin boards away from politically sensitive topics by posting opinions anonymously or under false names" in 2005.<ref name="China" /> Applicants for the job were drawn mostly from the propaganda and police departments. Successful candidates have been offered classes in ], ] techniques, and the ]. "They are actually hiring staff to curse online," said ], a Chinese student who was arrested for posting her comments in ].<ref name="China"/> | ||
| ==Miscellaneous== | ==Miscellaneous== | ||
| Organized teams of information fighters become an increasingly common phenomenon. Some of them are not sponsored by the state, but can push different ]s |
Organized teams of information fighters become an increasingly common phenomenon. Some of them are not sponsored by the state, but can push different ]s <ref> , by Samvel Martirosyan, ], ], </ref>, be involved in ] <ref>], ''The Guardian'' (UK) (posted by Norfolk Genetic Information Network), ], ],</ref>, or participate in ]s <ref> Jeffrey H. Birnbaum, '']'', ], ].</ref>. | ||
| ==References== | ==References== | ||
| Line 83: | Line 80: | ||
| ] | ] | ||
| ] | ] | ||
Revision as of 15:50, 11 April 2007
This article is being considered for deletion for the 2nd time in accordance with Misplaced Pages's deletion policy.
Please share your thoughts on the matter at this article's entry on the Articles for deletion page.
You are welcome to edit this article, but please do not blank this article or remove this notice while the discussion is in progress. For more information, particularly on merging or moving the article during the discussion, read the Guide to deletion.
 | The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (Learn how and when to remove this message) |
The internet brigades (Russian: Веб-бригады) are real and alleged state-sponsored information warfare teams that conduct psychological operations on-line. Such teams may be affiliated with state propaganda departments, military, or secret police forces. They are said to disseminate disinformation and prevent free discussions of undesirable subjects in political blogs and internet forums by using cyberstalking, cyber-bullying and other psychological warfare methods against political bloggers. Since the existence of internet brigades is often officially denied, such activities may be defined as "black", covert or false flag operations (or "active measures" according to Russian terminology).
Internet brigades in Russia
First publications
This alleged phenomenon in RuNet was first written about in 2003 by a group of investigative journalists led by Anna Polyanskaya, a former assistant to assassinated Russian politician Galina Starovoitova. The allegations of Polyanskaya and her colleagues have been supported by writer Grigory Svirsky and psychologist Vladimir Bagryansky. They claimed the appearance of organized and fairly professional "brigades", composed of ideologically and methodologically identical personalities, who were working in practically every popular liberal and pro-democracy blogs and internet newspapers of RuNet in the Russian blogosphere. These Internet teams appeared suddenly on Russian language forums in 1999. They have been allegedly organized by the Russian FSB service, the main successor of the KGB.
Criticism and discussions
The work of the FSB brigades has been extensively debated in RuNet. The discussion began in the internet forum of the "Russian Journal", just a few days after the first publication by Polyanskaya and others, and it lasted for two months. One group of bloggers was led by Alexander Usupovski, head of the analytical department of the Federation Council of Russia. He dismissed the existence of such brigades as a conspiracy theory and noted that defamation of Russian secret services may force them to work "beyond the law" . Other bloggers claimed that Usupovsky and his supporters are the governmental "internet brigade." The discussion ended by a series of personal threats from the first group with address to Ivan Lomko, one of authors of the original publication. According to Grigory Svirsky, "the internet brigade led by Alexander Usupovski is probably the most incompetent team of Russian state security services in RuNet" . A discussion was also conducted on the internet forum of Moscow News.
Brigades on the Polish internet
Russian "internet brigades" reportedly resurfaced in Poland in 2005. According to the Polish newspaper Tygodnik Powszechny, "at least a dozen active Russian agents work in Poland, also investigating the Polish internet. Not only do they scrutinize Polish websites (like those supporting Belarusian opposition), but also perform such actions, as—for instance—contributing to internet forums on large portals (like Gazeta.pl, Onet.pl, WP.pl). Labeled as Polish Internet users, they incite anti-Semitic or anti-Ukrainian discussions or disavow articles published on the web."
Recent developments
The teams of "Live Journal fighters" are claimed to be created by organization "Russia the young", directed and paid from the Kremlin. Their ideological work in Live Journal is extremely important, said Vladislav Surkov, a top aide to Vladimir Putin.
Behavior
The postings from people supposed to be part of the Internet brigades have certain distinct features some of which are the following :
- Propaganda of the Communist ideology, and constant attempts to present in a positive light the entire history of Russia and the Soviet Union, minimizing the number of people who died in repressions.
- Boundless loyalty to Vladimir Putin and his circle.
- Respect and admiration for the KGB and FSB.
- Hatred of dissidents and human rights organizations and activists, political prisoners and journalists, especially Anna Politkovskaya and Sergei Kovalev.
- Anti-Americanism and anti-Westernism.
- Accusation of Russophobia against everyone who disagrees with them.
- tendency to accuse their opponents of being insane during arguments.
- Round-the-clock presence on forums. At least one of the uniform members of the team can be found online at all times, always ready to repulse any “attack” by a liberal.
Tactics
- Individual work on opponents. "As soon as an opposition-minded liberal arrives on a forum, expressing a position that makes them a clear "ideological enemy”, he is immediately cornered and subjected to “active measures” by the unified web-brigade. Without provocation, the opponent is piled on with abuse or vicious “arguments” of the sort that the average person cannot adequately react to. As a result, the liberal either answers sharply, causing a scandal and getting himself labeled a “boor” by the rest of the brigade, or else he starts to make arguments against the obvious absurdities, to which his opponents pay no attention, but simply ridicule him and put forth other similar arguments."
- Accusations that opponents are working for “enemies”. The opponents are accused of taking money from Berezovskiy, the CIA, the MOSSAD, Saudi Arabia, the Zionists, or the Chechen rebels.
- Making personally offensive comments, especially of sexual nature.
- Remarkable ability to reveal personal information about their opponents and their quotes from old postings, sometimes more than a year old.
- Teamwork. "They unwaveringly support each other in discussions, ask each other leading questions, put fine points on each other’s answers, and even pretend not to know each other. If an opponent starts to be hounded, this hounding invariably becomes a team effort, involving all of the three to twenty nicknames that invariably are present on any political forum 24 hours a day."
- Appealing to the Administration. The members of teams often "write mass collective complaints about their opponents to the editors, site administrators, or the electronic “complaints book”, demanding that one or another posting or whole discussion thread they don’t like be removed, or calling for the banning of individuals they find problematic."
- Destruction of inconvenient forums. For example, on the site of the Moscow News, all critics of Putin and the FSB "were suddenly and without any explanation banned from all discussions, despite their having broken none of the site’s rules of conduct. All the postings of this group of readers, going back a year and a half, were erased by the site administrator."
Internet brigades in Russian literature
The alleged FSB activities on the Internet have been described in the short story "Anastasya" by Russian writer Grigory Svirsky, who was interested in the moral aspects of their work. He wrote: "It seems that offending, betraying, or even "murdering" people in the virtual space is easy. This is like killing an enemy in a video game: one does not see a disfigured body or the eyes of the person who is dying right in front of you. However, the human soul lives by its own basic laws that force it to pay the price for the virtual crime in his real life".
Internet police teams in mainland China
Chinese Communist Party leader Hu Jintao ordered to "maintain the initiative in opinion on the Internet and raise the level of guidance online," "An internet police force - reportedly numbering 30,000 - trawls websites and chat rooms, erasing anti-Communist comments and posting pro-government messages" , although the exact numbers of Internet police personnel was challenged by Chinese authorities It was reported that departments of provincial and municipal governments in mainland China began creating "teams of internet commentators, whose job is to guide discussion on public bulletin boards away from politically sensitive topics by posting opinions anonymously or under false names" in 2005. Applicants for the job were drawn mostly from the propaganda and police departments. Successful candidates have been offered classes in Marxism, propaganda techniques, and the Internet. "They are actually hiring staff to curse online," said Liu Di, a Chinese student who was arrested for posting her comments in blogs.
Miscellaneous
Organized teams of information fighters become an increasingly common phenomenon. Some of them are not sponsored by the state, but can push different political agendas , be involved in astroturfing , or participate in election campaigns .
References
- ^ China's secret internet police target critics with web of propaganda, by Jonathan Watts in Beijing, June 14, 2005, Guardian Unlimited
- ^ Commissars of the Internet. The FSB at the Computer by Anna Polyanskaya, Andrei Krivov, and Ivan Lomko, Vestnik online, April 30, 2003 (English translation)
- ^ Template:Ru icon Eye for an eye by Grigory Svirsky and Vladimur Bagryansky, publication of the Russian Center for Extreme Journalism
- Articles by Anna Polyanskaya, MAOF publishing group
- Template:Ru icon "They are killing Galina Starovoitova for the second time", by Anna Polyanskaya
- Conspiracy theory, by Alexander Usupovsky, Russian Journal, 25 April, 2003
- Operation "Disinformation" - The Russian Foreign Office vs "Tygodnik Powszechny", Tygodnik Powszechny, 13/2005
- Template:Ru icon Interview with Roman Sadykhov, grani.ru, 3 April, 2007
- Military wing of Kremlin (Russian), The New Times, 19 March, 2007
- " Grigory Svirsky Anastasya. A story on-line (Full text in Russian)
- China's Hu vows to "purify" Internet, Reuters, January 24, 2007
- War of the words by Guardian Unlimited, February 20, 2006
- Ｗho are China's Top Internet Cops? China Digital Times
- Internet as a field of information war against Armenia, by Samvel Martirosyan, 18 October, 2006,
- George Monbiot, "The Fake Persuaders. Corporations are inventing people to rubbish their opponents on the internet," The Guardian (UK) (posted by Norfolk Genetic Information Network), May 14, 2002,
- Jeffrey H. Birnbaum, "For Activist Constituents, Click Here," The Washington Post, September 19, 2005.
See also
- Information warfare
- Harassment by computer
- Jingjing and Chacha
- Computer crime
- Internet censorship in the People's Republic of China
- Astroturfing