Misplaced Pages

Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 16:21, 15 August 2007 editAlex Bakharev (talk | contribs)49,616 edits →Life: +img← Previous edit Revision as of 19:07, 15 August 2007 edit undoIrpen (talk | contribs)32,604 edits this image does not add anything to the content, anyway not enough to justify the shocking view of the tortured and dead girlNext edit →
Line 5: Line 5:
Kosmodemyanskaya joined the ] in ]. In October of ], still a ] student in ], she volunteered for a partisan unit. At the village of Obukhovo near ], Kosmodemyanskaya and other partisans crossed the front line and entered territory occupied by the ]. She was arrested by the ] on a combat assignment near the village of ] (]) on ], ]. Details of the assignment and the arrest were classified for sixty years due to the fact that there was a treachery in this case. Kosmodemyanskaya joined the ] in ]. In October of ], still a ] student in ], she volunteered for a partisan unit. At the village of Obukhovo near ], Kosmodemyanskaya and other partisans crossed the front line and entered territory occupied by the ]. She was arrested by the ] on a combat assignment near the village of ] (]) on ], ]. Details of the assignment and the arrest were classified for sixty years due to the fact that there was a treachery in this case.


]
The ] was declassified in 2002. The case was then reviewed by ]'s Chief Military Prosecutor Office, and it decided that Vasily Klubkov, who betrayed Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya, is not the subject for rehabilitation. According to the criminal case 16440, three Soviet combatants: Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya, Vasily Klubkov, and their commander ] had to perform acts of sabotage on the Soviet territory occupied by the Nazis. They had the task of setting fire to houses in the village of Petrishchevo, where the Nazis were quartered. Krainov should operate in the central part of the village, Kosmodemyanskaya in the southern and Klubkov in the northern one. Krainov had carried out the task first and returned to the base. Zoya had performed her task too, as was evidenced by three tongues of flame in the southern part of Petrischevo seen from the base. Only the northern part was not set to fire at all. According to Klubkov he was captured by two Nazi soldiers and brought into their staff. The Nazi officer threatened to kill him and Klubkov told names of Kosmodemyanskaya and Krainov, who had similar tasks to Klubkov's one. After this Kosmodemyanskaya was captured by the Nazis.<ref name="RIAN">{{cite web |date = ], ] | url = http://www.rian.ru/zabytoe/20061116/55692377.html | title = The Truth on Zoya and Shura| publisher = ] |language = Russian | accessdate = 2006-11-22 }}</ref><ref>{{cite web |date = ], ] | url = http://www.mk.ru/numbers/14/article206.htm | title = Agent is not the subject for rehabilitation | publisher = ] |language = Russian | accessdate = 2006-11-22 }}</ref> The ] was declassified in 2002. The case was then reviewed by ]'s Chief Military Prosecutor Office, and it decided that Vasily Klubkov, who betrayed Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya, is not the subject for rehabilitation. According to the criminal case 16440, three Soviet combatants: Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya, Vasily Klubkov, and their commander ] had to perform acts of sabotage on the Soviet territory occupied by the Nazis. They had the task of setting fire to houses in the village of Petrishchevo, where the Nazis were quartered. Krainov should operate in the central part of the village, Kosmodemyanskaya in the southern and Klubkov in the northern one. Krainov had carried out the task first and returned to the base. Zoya had performed her task too, as was evidenced by three tongues of flame in the southern part of Petrischevo seen from the base. Only the northern part was not set to fire at all. According to Klubkov he was captured by two Nazi soldiers and brought into their staff. The Nazi officer threatened to kill him and Klubkov told names of Kosmodemyanskaya and Krainov, who had similar tasks to Klubkov's one. After this Kosmodemyanskaya was captured by the Nazis.<ref name="RIAN">{{cite web |date = ], ] | url = http://www.rian.ru/zabytoe/20061116/55692377.html | title = The Truth on Zoya and Shura| publisher = ] |language = Russian | accessdate = 2006-11-22 }}</ref><ref>{{cite web |date = ], ] | url = http://www.mk.ru/numbers/14/article206.htm | title = Agent is not the subject for rehabilitation | publisher = ] |language = Russian | accessdate = 2006-11-22 }}</ref>

Revision as of 19:07, 15 August 2007

File:Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya.jpg
Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya

Zoya Anatolyevna Kosmodemyanskaya, alternatively Romanised as Kosmodem'yanskaya (Template:Lang-ru) (September 13, 1923 in the village of Osino-Gay, Gavrilovsky District, Tambov Oblast – November 29, 1941) was a Soviet partisan, and a well-known posthumously declared Hero of the Soviet Union.

Life

Kosmodemyanskaya joined the VLKSM in 1938. In October of 1941, still a high school student in Moscow, she volunteered for a partisan unit. At the village of Obukhovo near Naro-Fominsk, Kosmodemyanskaya and other partisans crossed the front line and entered territory occupied by the Germans. She was arrested by the Nazis on a combat assignment near the village of Petrishchevo (Moscow Oblast) on November 27, 1941. Details of the assignment and the arrest were classified for sixty years due to the fact that there was a treachery in this case.

The criminal case number 16440 was declassified in 2002. The case was then reviewed by Russia's Chief Military Prosecutor Office, and it decided that Vasily Klubkov, who betrayed Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya, is not the subject for rehabilitation. According to the criminal case 16440, three Soviet combatants: Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya, Vasily Klubkov, and their commander Boris Krainov had to perform acts of sabotage on the Soviet territory occupied by the Nazis. They had the task of setting fire to houses in the village of Petrishchevo, where the Nazis were quartered. Krainov should operate in the central part of the village, Kosmodemyanskaya in the southern and Klubkov in the northern one. Krainov had carried out the task first and returned to the base. Zoya had performed her task too, as was evidenced by three tongues of flame in the southern part of Petrischevo seen from the base. Only the northern part was not set to fire at all. According to Klubkov he was captured by two Nazi soldiers and brought into their staff. The Nazi officer threatened to kill him and Klubkov told names of Kosmodemyanskaya and Krainov, who had similar tasks to Klubkov's one. After this Kosmodemyanskaya was captured by the Nazis.

Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya was tortured and humiliated. In particular, she was undressed and beaten with rubber sticks for two or three hours by several Nazis. But Kosmodemyanskaya did not give away the names of her comrades or her real name (claiming that it was Tanya). She said: "Kill me, I'll tell you nothing" (Template:Lang-ru). She was hanged on November 29, 1941. It was claimed that before her death Kosmodemyanskaya had made a speech with the closing words, “There are two hundred million of us, you can’t hang us all!” Kosmodemyanskaya was the first woman to become Hero of the Soviet Union (February 16, 1942).

Bringing her story to the public eye

The story of Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya became widely known from the Pravda article by Pyotr Lidov published on January 27, 1942. The journalist heard about the execution of Zoya accidentally, from the elderly peasant shaken by the valor of the young girl. The witness recounted: "They were hanging her and she was giving a speech. They were hanging her, and she was hectoring them." Lidov traveled to Petrishchevo, collected the details from the residents and published them in an article about yet unknown partisan girl. Reportedly, the article was noticed by Stalin who pronounced: "here is the people's heroine" which started the Soviet propaganda campaign of praising Kosmodemyanskaya. She was soon identified (in February of the same year) and awarded the title of the Hero of the Soviet Union (posthumously.)

Legacy

Many streets, kolkhozes and pioneer organizations in the Soviet Union used to bear the name of Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya. Soviet poets, writers, artists and sculptors dedicated their works to Kosmodemyanskaya. The Soviets erected a monument in her honor not far from the village of Petrischevo (sculptors - O.A.Ikonnikov and V.A.Feodorov). Another statue is prominently located at Moscow Metro station Partizanskaya. Two asteroids were named after her: 1793 Zoya and 2072 Kosmodemyanskaya. Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya is buried at Novodevichy Cemetery in Moscow.

Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya's brother Alexander (1925 - April 13 1945), a Senior Lieutenant, died in combat in Germany and was posthumously awarded Hero of the Soviet Union in 1945.

In the 2002 book Zoya's Story: An Afghan Woman's Struggle for Freedom the narrator tells of her decision to use the name "Zoya" as one of her pseudonyms when she joined The Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan in the struggle against fundamentalism. She cites the story of Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya as an inspiration in the struggle against oppression.

Media controversy

The biography of Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya became a subject of media controversy in Perestroyka period.

In September 1991 (close to the fifty years from Zoya's death) an article by Russian writer Alexander Zhovtis was published in weekly newspaper Argumenty i Fakty . The article alleged that were no German troops in the village Petrischevo, Zoya was caught by the local peasant who were unhappy about destruction of their property. The information was sourced to an anonymous school teacher who apparently told the story to writer Nikolay Anov (already dead at the time) who passed it to Zhovtis. At the end Zhovtis blamed Stalin's policy of the scorched Earth on the unnecessary death of the young woman.

In a month the same newspaper published another article completely based on the letters from readers devoted to the Zhovtis' publication. Some authors supported the mainstream version. The letter signed P.A. Lidov's family (Lidov was the journalist who originally broke Kosmodemyanskaya's story) telling that every house in the village was filled with Nazi troops who were the target of Zoya's strike. The letter referred to the documents supporting the info including unpublished protocols of NKVD interviews with the residents of the village. The other readers shared stories contradicting the mainstream version. A resident of Moscow, Petrov told the story he heard from a Petrischevo resident in 1958 about irregularities in the identification of "Tanya"s identity. A postgraduate of the Institute of Russian History Elena Sinyavskaya published her research supporting that the true person executed in Petrischevo was not Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya but missed in action partisan woman Lila Azolina.

The "Argumenty i Fakty" articles prompted response from Pravda observer Viktor Kozhemyaka in the article named Fifty years after her death Zoya is tortured and executed again . In the article Kozhemyaka critisized the Sinyavskaya's theory and insisted on the official expert conclusion about the identity of the executed partisan. Later the Institute for Criminal Expertise an the Department of Justice of Russian Federation issued an official conclusion that the family photographs of Kosmodemyanskaya belong to the same person as the Pravda photograph of hanged partisan. The article ended by emotional sentences Lets yoour names be sacred for the centuries, Tanya, Zoya, Lila! Y So many of you gave for us the most precious you had got:your lives. And we cannot. should not, have no rights to forget you or renegade on you.

In ten years Kozhemyaka wrote another article Zoya is executed yet again . In the article Kozhemyaka told how he was shaken to discover some "absurd materials" on the internet boards. The materials alleged that Zoya hurt Russian peasants rather than German troops. They also alleged that Zoya suffered from schizophrenia, were fanatical Stalinist, etc. Kozhemyaka mistakenly attributed materials to the same Elena Sinyavskaya ( now Doctor of Historical Science). In her response (in the newspaper Patriot from 26 February 2006 Sinyavskaya stated she has no connections to the material except that a few citations are from her monograph. The real author of the internet publication seems to be an obscure "Psychoanalyst-writer" Alexnder Menyaylov.

Another important development was the publication of the newspaper Glasnost the previously unknown protocols of the official commission of residents of Petrischevo village and Gribtsovsky selsovet on 25 January 1942 (two months after Zoya's execution). . The protocol told that Kosmodemyanskaya was caught while trying to sabotage a stable with more than 300 German horses. It also quite graphically tells about her torturing and execution.

Slightly different story is told by the publications of the notes by Pyotr Lidov in Parlamentskaya Gazeta in 1999. It appeared that Lidov for years meticulously collected all the available information on Kosmodemyanskaya. The notes supported version that Kosmodemyanskaya and Vasily Klubkov were caught while sleeping in the hay on the outskirts of Petrischevo. The Germans were called by Petrischevo resident Semyon Sviridov. Lidov's notes also included an interview with a German noncommissioned officer taken prisoner by Soviet Army. The interview described the negative effect on the morale of the German soldiers caught in the burning houses.

References

  1. Kazimiera J. Cottam: Women in War and Resistance: Selected Biographies of Soviet Women Soldiers, ISBN 0968270220, page 297
  2. ^ "The Truth on Zoya and Shura" (in Russian). RIA Novosti. November 16, 2006. Retrieved 2006-11-22. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  3. "Agent is not the subject for rehabilitation" (in Russian). Moskovskiy Komsomolets. October 9, 2002. Retrieved 2006-11-22. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  4. Mikhail Gorinov, Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya (1923-1941), Otechestvennaya istoriia, №1, 2003, ISSN 0869-5687
  5. Alexander Zhovtis Corrections to the canonical versions, Argumenty i Fakty, N39, 1991
  6. ^ Legends of the Great Patriotic War. Zoya Kosomodemyanskaya Mass-media in internet. April 05 2005 Template:Ru icon
  7. Zoya Kosmodemyanskaya: A Heroine or a Symbol Argumenty i Fakty, N43, 1991
  8. Viktor Kozhemyaka. Fifty years after her death Zoya is tortured and executed again Pravda November 29 1991
  9. Viktor Kozhemyaka Zoya is executed yet again Pravda, November 29 and November 30 2001
  10. Ivan Osadchy Her name and deeds are immortal, Glasnost, 24 September 1997

Bibliography

  • Lyubov Kosmodemyanskaya:Story of Zoya and Shura, Foreign Languages Publishing House: Moscow, 1953 ("Shura" is a nickname for "Alexander", the author is Zoya's mother)

External links

Categories: