Revision as of 12:10, 9 July 2008 edit82.17.186.168 (talk) →Trial and verdict← Previous edit | Revision as of 14:03, 7 August 2008 edit undo210.131.61.24 (talk)No edit summaryNext edit → | ||
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{dated prod|concern = <nowiki>My name is Junichiro Hironaka, a licensed Japanese attorney, and I am writing to the administrators on behalf of my client, Mr. Joji Obara. Please be advised that Mr. Obara is the subject of a false, misleading and libelous article appearing on Misplaced Pages at http://en.wikipedia.org/Joji_Obara. The administrators are hereby requested to remove in its entirety without delay. Kindly note that a similar request was made regarding a substantially identical article on Mr. Obara appearing in Japanese on the Misplaced Pages Japan site. In response to my request, the administrators reviewed the article and have deleted it in its entirety from the site. Since the English article contains essentially the same false, misleading and libelous information, it should also be deleted in its entirety. Without going into all of the false, misleading and libelous statements in the article, administrators should be aware of the undisputed and verifiable fact that the Tokyo District Court has acquitted Mr. Obara on the charge of murdering Ms. Lucie Blackman. The article makes it appear as if Mr. Obara is guilty of this tragic crime, even though he has been found not guilty. Moreover, the article implies that Mr. Obara has raped as many as 400 women. This is completely false and not supported by any reliable evidence. There are many additional specific statements that are false, misleading and libelous in the English article.</nowiki> | |||
Examples of statements I propose to delete and the reasons:<br /> | |||
1) At opening, ‘Joji Obara is a convicted rapist.’<br /> | |||
The Tokyo District Court has acquitted Mr. Obara on the charge of murdering Ms. Lucie Blackman. | |||
2) Under the paragraph of Background, 2)-1: about ‘Korean family’ and 2)-2: about money laundering front for the yakuza syndicate, Sumiyoshi-kai.’<br /> | |||
2)-1 describes in detail about Mr. Obara’s origin and other conditions which are specific enough to identify him. Referring to <br />his origin with unnecessarily extensive detail like this and in the first paragraph reveals sense of discrimination against people with <br />specific origin. In this regard, this portion is extremely inappropriate and also runs counter to the ideal of Wiki.<br /> | |||
2)-2 description about his activities also misleads general viewers to believe that he was involved in the crime. | |||
3) Under the paragraph of Crimes, about 4000 to 5000 filthy videos and 400 women raped by Mr. Obara.<br /> | |||
Implying 150-400 women he raped and 4000 to 5000 objectionable videos he collected has totally no basis in fact. | |||
4) Under the paragraph of Trial and verdict, about prosecutors’ failure to prove.<br /> | |||
The statements 4) here could be understood that he was acquitted of the charges just because the Japanese prosecutors <br />failed to prove enough. These statements are based on the assumption that he was guilty, therefore, general readers would think <br />that he did commit the crime. | |||
5) Under the paragraph of Trial and verdict, about the comments by former prosecutor.<br /> | |||
The case against Masumi Hayashi has nothing to do with this case. Referring to his irrelevant statement like this is <br />intended to give impression to the views as if he was guilty of Blakman’s case. | |||
For the reasons stated above, the administrators are requested to remove the article in English on Mr. Joji Obara from Misplaced Pages without delay. I will continue to monitor Misplaced Pages. | |||
The administrators' prompt and affirmative response to this request will be greatly appreciated.|month = August|day = 7|year = 2008|time = 13:11|timestamp = 20080807131119}} | |||
<!-- Do not use the "dated prod" template directly; the above line is generated by "subst:prod|reason" --> | |||
{{nihongo|'''Joji Obara'''|織原 城二|Obara Jōji|extra=born 1952 in ], ]}} is a convicted rapist who was accused of the ] and subsequent deaths of two women, ] ] Lucie Blackman in the summer of 2000 and ] Carita Ridgeway in 1992, and the rapes of six other women. | {{nihongo|'''Joji Obara'''|織原 城二|Obara Jōji|extra=born 1952 in ], ]}} is a convicted rapist who was accused of the ] and subsequent deaths of two women, ] ] Lucie Blackman in the summer of 2000 and ] Carita Ridgeway in 1992, and the rapes of six other women. | ||
Revision as of 14:03, 7 August 2008
It is proposed that this article be deleted because of the following concern:
If you can address this concern by improving, copyediting, sourcing, renaming, or merging the page, please edit this page and do so. You may remove this message if you improve the article or otherwise object to deletion for any reason. Although not required, you are encouraged to explain why you object to the deletion, either in your edit summary or on the talk page. If this template is removed, do not replace it. This message has remained in place for seven days, so the article may be deleted without further notice. Find sources: "Joji Obara" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTORPRODExpired+%5B%5BWP%3APROD%7CPROD%5D%5D%2C+concern+was%3A+%0A%0AExamples+of+statements+I+propose+to+delete+and+the+reasons%3A%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A1%29+At+opening%2C+%E2%80%98Joji+Obara+is+a+convicted+rapist.%E2%80%99%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A+The+Tokyo+District+Court+has+acquitted+Mr.+Obara+on+the+charge+of+murdering+Ms.+Lucie+Blackman.%0A2%29+Under+the+paragraph+of+Background%2C+2%29-1%3A+about+%E2%80%98Korean+family%E2%80%99+and+2%29-2%3A+about+money+laundering+front+for+the+yakuza+syndicate%2C+Sumiyoshi-kai.%E2%80%99%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A+2%29-1+describes+in+detail+about+Mr.+Obara%E2%80%99s+origin+and+other+conditions+which+are+specific+enough+to+identify+him.++Referring+to+%3Cbr+%2F%3Ehis+origin+with+unnecessarily+extensive+detail+like+this+and+in+the+first+paragraph+reveals+sense+of+discrimination+against+people+with+%3Cbr+%2F%3Especific+origin.++In+this+regard%2C+this+portion+is+extremely+inappropriate+and+also+runs+counter+to+the+ideal+of+Wiki.%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A+2%29-2+description+about+his+activities+also+misleads+general+viewers+to+believe+that+he+was+involved+in+the+crime.%0A3%29+Under+the+paragraph+of+Crimes%2C+about+4000+to+5000+filthy+videos+and+400+women+raped+by+Mr.+Obara.%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A+Implying+150-400+women+he+raped+and+4000+to+5000+objectionable+videos+he+collected+has+totally+no+basis+in+fact.%0A4%29+Under+the+paragraph+of+Trial+and+verdict%2C+about+prosecutors%E2%80%99+failure+to+prove.%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A+The+statements+4%29+here+could+be+understood+that+he+was+acquitted+of+the+charges+just+because+the+Japanese+prosecutors+%3Cbr+%2F%3Efailed+to+prove+enough.++These+statements+are+based+on+the+assumption+that+he+was+guilty%2C+therefore%2C+general+readers+would+think+%3Cbr+%2F%3Ethat+he+did+commit+the+crime.%0A5%29+Under+the+paragraph+of+Trial+and+verdict%2C+about+the+comments+by+former+prosecutor.%3Cbr+%2F%3E%0A+The+case+against+Masumi+Hayashi+has+nothing+to+do+with+this+case.++Referring+to+his+irrelevant+statement+like+this+is+%3Cbr+%2F%3Eintended+to+give+impression+to+the+views+as+if+he+was+guilty+of+Blakman%E2%80%99s+case.%0A%0AFor+the+reasons+stated+above%2C+the+administrators+are+requested+to+remove+the+article+in+English+on+Mr.+Joji+Obara+from+Misplaced Pages+without+delay.+I+will+continue+to+monitor+Misplaced Pages.+%0A%0AThe+administrators%27+prompt+and+affirmative+response+to+this+request+will+be+greatly+appreciated.Expired ], concern was: My name is Junichiro Hironaka, a licensed Japanese attorney, and I am writing to the administrators on behalf of my client, Mr. Joji Obara. Please be advised that Mr. Obara is the subject of a false, misleading and libelous article appearing on Misplaced Pages at http://en.wikipedia.org/Joji_Obara. The administrators are hereby requested to remove in its entirety without delay. Kindly note that a similar request was made regarding a substantially identical article on Mr. Obara appearing in Japanese on the Misplaced Pages Japan site. In response to my request, the administrators reviewed the article and have deleted it in its entirety from the site. Since the English article contains essentially the same false, misleading and libelous information, it should also be deleted in its entirety. Without going into all of the false, misleading and libelous statements in the article, administrators should be aware of the undisputed and verifiable fact that the Tokyo District Court has acquitted Mr. Obara on the charge of murdering Ms. Lucie Blackman. The article makes it appear as if Mr. Obara is guilty of this tragic crime, even though he has been found not guilty. Moreover, the article implies that Mr. Obara has raped as many as 400 women. This is completely false and not supported by any reliable evidence. There are many additional specific statements that are false, misleading and libelous in the English article. Examples of statements I propose to delete and the reasons: The Tokyo District Court has acquitted Mr. Obara on the charge of murdering Ms. Lucie Blackman. 2) Under the paragraph of Background, 2)-1: about ‘Korean family’ and 2)-2: about money laundering front for the yakuza syndicate, Sumiyoshi-kai.’ 2)-1 describes in detail about Mr. Obara’s origin and other conditions which are specific enough to identify him. Referring to 3) Under the paragraph of Crimes, about 4000 to 5000 filthy videos and 400 women raped by Mr. Obara. Implying 150-400 women he raped and 4000 to 5000 objectionable videos he collected has totally no basis in fact. 4) Under the paragraph of Trial and verdict, about prosecutors’ failure to prove. The statements 4) here could be understood that he was acquitted of the charges just because the Japanese prosecutors 5) Under the paragraph of Trial and verdict, about the comments by former prosecutor. The case against Masumi Hayashi has nothing to do with this case. Referring to his irrelevant statement like this is For the reasons stated above, the administrators are requested to remove the article in English on Mr. Joji Obara from Misplaced Pages without delay. I will continue to monitor Misplaced Pages. The administrators' prompt and affirmative response to this request will be greatly appreciated.Nominator: Please consider notifying the author/project: {{subst:proposed deletion notify|Joji Obara|concern=My name is Junichiro Hironaka, a licensed Japanese attorney, and I am writing to the administrators on behalf of my client, Mr. Joji Obara. Please be advised that Mr. Obara is the subject of a false, misleading and libelous article appearing on Misplaced Pages at http://en.wikipedia.org/Joji_Obara. The administrators are hereby requested to remove in its entirety without delay. Kindly note that a similar request was made regarding a substantially identical article on Mr. Obara appearing in Japanese on the Misplaced Pages Japan site. In response to my request, the administrators reviewed the article and have deleted it in its entirety from the site. Since the English article contains essentially the same false, misleading and libelous information, it should also be deleted in its entirety. Without going into all of the false, misleading and libelous statements in the article, administrators should be aware of the undisputed and verifiable fact that the Tokyo District Court has acquitted Mr. Obara on the charge of murdering Ms. Lucie Blackman. The article makes it appear as if Mr. Obara is guilty of this tragic crime, even though he has been found not guilty. Moreover, the article implies that Mr. Obara has raped as many as 400 women. This is completely false and not supported by any reliable evidence. There are many additional specific statements that are false, misleading and libelous in the English article.
Examples of statements I propose to delete and the reasons:<br />
1) At opening, ‘Joji Obara is a convicted rapist.’<br />
The Tokyo District Court has acquitted Mr. Obara on the charge of murdering Ms. Lucie Blackman.
2) Under the paragraph of Background, 2)-1: about ‘Korean family’ and 2)-2: about money laundering front for the yakuza syndicate, Sumiyoshi-kai.’<br />
2)-1 describes in detail about Mr. Obara’s origin and other conditions which are specific enough to identify him. Referring to <br />his origin with unnecessarily extensive detail like this and in the first paragraph reveals sense of discrimination against people with <br />specific origin. In this regard, this portion is extremely inappropriate and also runs counter to the ideal of Wiki.<br />
2)-2 description about his activities also misleads general viewers to believe that he was involved in the crime.
3) Under the paragraph of Crimes, about 4000 to 5000 filthy videos and 400 women raped by Mr. Obara.<br />
Implying 150-400 women he raped and 4000 to 5000 objectionable videos he collected has totally no basis in fact.
4) Under the paragraph of Trial and verdict, about prosecutors’ failure to prove.<br />
The statements 4) here could be understood that he was acquitted of the charges just because the Japanese prosecutors <br />failed to prove enough. These statements are based on the assumption that he was guilty, therefore, general readers would think <br />that he did commit the crime.
5) Under the paragraph of Trial and verdict, about the comments by former prosecutor.<br />
The case against Masumi Hayashi has nothing to do with this case. Referring to his irrelevant statement like this is <br />intended to give impression to the views as if he was guilty of Blakman’s case.
For the reasons stated above, the administrators are requested to remove the article in English on Mr. Joji Obara from Misplaced Pages without delay. I will continue to monitor Misplaced Pages.
The administrators' prompt and affirmative response to this request will be greatly appreciated.}} ~~~~ Timestamp: 20080807131119 13:11, 7 August 2008 (UTC) Administrators: delete |
Joji Obara (織原 城二, Obara Jōji, born 1952 in Osaka, Japan) is a convicted rapist who was accused of the rape and subsequent deaths of two women, British hostess Lucie Blackman in the summer of 2000 and Australian Carita Ridgeway in 1992, and the rapes of six other women.
Background
Joji Obara was born Kim Sung Jong to a poor Korean family in Osaka in 1952. During his youth, his father worked his way from scrap collector to taxi driver to immensely wealthy owner of a string of pachinko parlours. At 15, Obara enrolled in one of Japan's most elite high schools, a prep school affiliated with Keio University. Two years later, upon his father's death, he inherited holdings in Osaka and Tokyo. After graduating from Keio University with degrees in politics and law, he became a naturalized Japanese citizen and legally changed his name to Joji Obara.
During the late 1980s and early 1990s Obara invested heavily in real estate speculation. After losing his fortune when the bubble burst and his firm collapsed, he reportedly used his business as a money laundering front for the yakuza syndicate, Sumiyoshi-kai.
Crimes
A prolific diarist, police revealed that he believed "Women are only good for sex" and stated that he "cannot do women who are conscious." His personal video tapes, 4,000 to 5,000 of which were recovered by police, confirm this, leading them to believe that he may have raped anywhere from 150 to 400 women.
In October 2000, Obara was arrested and charged with the drugging, raping and death of Blackman and another hostess, 21-year-old Australian model Carita Ridgeway, who died in 1992. He was also charged with raping six other women. According to the indictment, he made Blackman a drink containing a drug before raping her at a condominium in Zushi, Kanagawa Prefecture. She subsequently died.
Obara has maintained his innocence, claiming the drugs that caused her to die were self-administered.
Tim Blackman, Lucie Blackman's father, accepted £450,000 in mimaikin—or condolence money—from a friend of Joji Obara. The other members of the family were against the acceptance of the money.
Trial and verdict
Obara was charged with drugging, raping and killing Blackman, as well as raping of six other women and manslaughter of another hostess.
On April 24, 2007 Obara was jailed for life on multiple rape charges and one manslaughter, but he was acquitted of the crime of Blackman's rape and murder.
Evidence supporting his guilt in regard to charge of rape included the approximately 400 videos he took in which he engaged in date rape activities. For the charge of manslaughter of Carita Ridgeway, the prosecutor produced an autopsy report showing traces of chloroform in Ridgeway's liver and a paper trail showing that the accused accompanied Ridgeway to the hospital before she died. In Blackman's case, however, the prosecutor could not produce any forensic evidence linking the accused to her death. Even the cause of her death could not be determined, as discussed below.
The judge stated that in deciding on the sentence he did not attach much importance to Mr Obara’s payment of “consolation money” to a number of his victims.
The Japanese judicial system has received some criticism for its handling of the case. It is believed that the police did not take this missing person case seriously "because Lucie was working illegally in a job from which women often flee without notice". As a result, the discovery of the body came too late to determine the cause of the death. The verdict by a panel of three judges cited the lack of forensic evidence as a reason for acquittal. Some foreign media from common law countries also criticized the police for having leaked information in the case to the press that could cause a mistrial. However, as Japanese civil law system does not use juries, this cannot be grounds for a mistrial.
Former prosecutor Takeshi Tsuchimoto, now a professor of criminal procedure law at Hakuoh University Law School, criticized the decision to acquit Joji Obara for the murder of Lucie Blackman by pointing to the conviction of Masumi Hayashi due to circumstantial evidence.
The public prosecutor has appealed the Blackman-related verdicts and on March 25, 2008 an appeal trial commenced in the Tokyo High Court.
See Also
References
- ^ Richard Lloyd Parry (August 17, 2005). "How the bubble burst for Lucie's alleged killer". The Times. Retrieved 2007-11-29.
- "Death of a Hostess". TIME. 2001-05-07. Retrieved 2008-03-28.
- 60 Minutes Transcript – Night Stalkers Retrieved December 21, 2006
- ^ Peter Martin (April 9, 2001). "PM –Japanese businessman arrested over rape of Australian woman". ABC News. Retrieved 2007-11-29.
- brisbanetimes.com.au "Evil behind Tokyo's lights"
- This is London - Lucie's father 'helped killer by accepting blood money'
- How the bubble burst for Lucie's alleged killer The Times, Timesonline August 17, 2005
- Man cleared over death of Lucie BBC News retrieved April 24, 2007
- Joji Obara: Not Guilty of Lucie Blackman Killing The Times, April 24, 2007
- Matt Weaver (April 24, 2007). "Sevenoaks girl who hoped to spin blonde to go". The Guardian. Retrieved 2007-11-29.
- "Oddly, raft of circumstantial evidence not enough". The Japan Times. 2007-04-25. Retrieved 2008-02-04.
- Obara pleads not guilty in appeal trial over killing of Blackman]