| Revision as of 19:37, 11 August 2008 editPiotrus (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Event coordinators, Extended confirmed users, File movers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers285,857 editsm →United States← Previous edit | Revision as of 19:45, 11 August 2008 edit undoMalik Shabazz (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers106,163 edits →United States: response to Rosenbaum's review doesn't make sense if the review isn't mentionedNext edit → | ||
| Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
| Elie Wiesel, reviewing the book in '']'', rejected the notion of collective guilt for all of Poland but noted that Gross' book impels Poland to confront its past.<ref name=Wiesel>Elie Wiesel. . ''The Washington Post'', June 25, 2006.</ref> In response to Wiesel's review, Polish-Jewish journalist ] wrote in a leading Polish daily, '']'' (of which he is editor-in-chief), that "Wiesel's review conveys the image of a country unable to confront the plague of anti-Semitism... Anyone who writes about anti-Semitism in Poland and ignores those facts, falsifies — even if unintentionally — the truth about Poland."<ref name=Reiter/> The ''Washington Post'' printed a letter to the editor by ], the Polish ambassador to the United States, who cited Michnik.<ref name=Reiter>Janusz Reiter, , '']'' July 9, 2006.</ref> | Elie Wiesel, reviewing the book in '']'', rejected the notion of collective guilt for all of Poland but noted that Gross' book impels Poland to confront its past.<ref name=Wiesel>Elie Wiesel. . ''The Washington Post'', June 25, 2006.</ref> In response to Wiesel's review, Polish-Jewish journalist ] wrote in a leading Polish daily, '']'' (of which he is editor-in-chief), that "Wiesel's review conveys the image of a country unable to confront the plague of anti-Semitism... Anyone who writes about anti-Semitism in Poland and ignores those facts, falsifies — even if unintentionally — the truth about Poland."<ref name=Reiter/> The ''Washington Post'' printed a letter to the editor by ], the Polish ambassador to the United States, who cited Michnik.<ref name=Reiter>Janusz Reiter, , '']'' July 9, 2006.</ref> | ||
| The ], a ] think tank, published an analysis of ''Fear'' and its reception. The Piast Institute was critical of the book itself, writing that "the thesis of the book is highly controversial and many Poles and others also find it unfair and tendentious."<ref name="purpose"></ref> The Piast Institute also wrote that "reviewers in major newspapers such as the '']'', '']'' and the '']'', none of whom has any expertise in Polish or East Central European history, have reacted to the book with uncritical acclaim and considerable ] rhetoric. As such, it is clear already that ''Fear'' will have a serious and negative effect on ]."<ref name="intro"></ref> With regard to Rosenbaum's review, the Piast Institute wrote that Rosenbaum "presented the argument in highly emotional and hyperbolic prose and is given to exaggeration."<ref></ref> | The ], a ] think tank, published an analysis of ''Fear'' and its reception. The Piast Institute was critical of the book itself, writing that "the thesis of the book is highly controversial and many Poles and others also find it unfair and tendentious."<ref name="purpose"></ref> The Piast Institute also wrote that "reviewers in major newspapers such as the '']'', '']'' and the '']'', none of whom has any expertise in Polish or East Central European history, have reacted to the book with uncritical acclaim and considerable ] rhetoric. As such, it is clear already that ''Fear'' will have a serious and negative effect on ]."<ref name="intro"></ref> | ||
| David Engel wrote that, unlike Gross' earlier work '']'', in which Gross posited a continuity in the actions of a community of people over generations, in ''Fear'' "Gross himself appears to have bracketed off the Nazi era from the longer course of Polish history and by doing so to have altered the terms for reflecting on transgenerational Polish responsibility for past deeds that he set forth in his earlier work." Engel wrote that Gross now sees World War II as a radical break in the history of Polish behavior towards Jews.<ref>David Engel, On Continuity and Discontinuity in Polish-Jewish Relations: Observations on Fear: Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz—An Essay in Historical Interpretation by Jan T. Gross. New York: Random House, 2006, East European Politics & Societies, Vol. 21, No. 3, 534-548 (2007)</ref> | David Engel wrote that, unlike Gross' earlier work '']'', in which Gross posited a continuity in the actions of a community of people over generations, in ''Fear'' "Gross himself appears to have bracketed off the Nazi era from the longer course of Polish history and by doing so to have altered the terms for reflecting on transgenerational Polish responsibility for past deeds that he set forth in his earlier work." Engel wrote that Gross now sees World War II as a radical break in the history of Polish behavior towards Jews.<ref>David Engel, On Continuity and Discontinuity in Polish-Jewish Relations: Observations on Fear: Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz—An Essay in Historical Interpretation by Jan T. Gross. New York: Random House, 2006, East European Politics & Societies, Vol. 21, No. 3, 534-548 (2007)</ref> | ||
Revision as of 19:45, 11 August 2008
| An editor has nominated this article for deletion. You are welcome to participate in the deletion discussion, which will decide whether or not to retain it.Feel free to improve the article, but do not remove this notice before the discussion is closed. For more information, see the guide to deletion. Find sources: "Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR%5B%5BWikipedia%3AArticles+for+deletion%2FFear%3A+Anti-Semitism+in+Poland+after+Auschwitz%5D%5DAFD |
Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz is a book by Jan T. Gross, published by Random House and Princeton University Press in 2006. An edited Polish version was published in 2008 by Znak Publishers in Krakow as Strach: antysemityzm w Polsce tuż po wojnie: historia moralnej zapaści ("Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland shortly after the war: the history of a moral fall"). In the book, Gross explores the issues concerning incidents of post-war anti-Jewish violence in Poland, with particular focus on the 1946 Kielce pogrom. Fear has received international attention and reviews in major newspapers; it has also been the subject of criticism, especially in Poland.
Content
Gross begins the English version of Fear with a chapter summarizing the devastation of Poland during World War II, including the physical destruction of Poland's Jews; the initial partition of the country between Stalin and Hitler; the subsequent Nazi crimes; the Katyn massacre of Polish army officers by the Soviets; the Warsaw uprising of 1944; the Soviet decision to postpone their advance until the German army had defeated the Polish Armia Krajowa, which resulted in the destruction of Warsaw "reduced to a pile of rubble"; and the abandonment of Poland by Britain and America at the Yalta Conference, knowingly consigning it to Soviet communist domination.
Gross estimates that 250,000 Polish Jews returned home at the end of the war. In his chapter "The Unwelcoming of Jewish Survivors," Gross describes how returning Polish Jews were subjected to a wave of violence and hostility, with up to 1500 murdered either individually or in pogroms. Often they would find their property occupied by their non-Jewish Polish neighbors or taken over by the communist government, which nationalized much of the Polish economy. According to Gross, the expropriation of Jewish property continued a trend that occurred throughout the war years, with non-Jewish Poles acquiring the property of Polish Jews who were sent off to extermination camps, and in some instances, (such as the Jedwabne pogrom), carrying out the killings themselves. Gross describes how the looting of property extended to digging through the ashes of Treblinka for gold fillings. He discusses the alienation, hostile atmosphere, and violence experienced by some Jews and the inability of Polish elites to prevent it. Gross makes additional claims about the Kielce pogrom, arguing that the crime was initiated not by a mob, but by the police, and that it involved people from every walk of life except the highest level of government officials in the city.
According to a Piast Institute's online summary, Gross concludes by writing that some Poles, especially in rural areas, participated in the Nazi wartime effort to annihilate and despoil the Jews, and this was the cause of postwar anti-Semitism in Poland. The fear of punishment for their own crimes, according to Gross, was what drove them to continue attacking Jews after the war. Historian David Engel describes the following quote as a "summation of basic thesis:"
We must seek the reasons for the novel, virulent quality of postwar anti-Semitism in Poland not in collective hallucinations nor in prewar attitudes, but in actual experiences acquired during the war years.... Living Jews embodied the massive failure of character and reason on the part of their Polish neighbors and constituted by mere presence both a reminder and a threat that they might need to account for themselves.
The Polish version of Fear differed from its English language original because Gross assumed that his Polish readers were familiar with the tragic history of wartime Poland. The first chapter of the English version was replaced by a chapter documenting Polish awareness of the Nazi genocide of the Jews.
Reception
United States
Fear received praise in reviews in a number of popular magazines and newspapers including The New York Times, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, and the Boston Globe.
Elie Wiesel, reviewing the book in The Washington Post, rejected the notion of collective guilt for all of Poland but noted that Gross' book impels Poland to confront its past. In response to Wiesel's review, Polish-Jewish journalist Adam Michnik wrote in a leading Polish daily, Gazeta Wyborcza (of which he is editor-in-chief), that "Wiesel's review conveys the image of a country unable to confront the plague of anti-Semitism... Anyone who writes about anti-Semitism in Poland and ignores those facts, falsifies — even if unintentionally — the truth about Poland." The Washington Post printed a letter to the editor by Janusz Reiter, the Polish ambassador to the United States, who cited Michnik.
The Piast Institute, a Polish-American think tank, published an analysis of Fear and its reception. The Piast Institute was critical of the book itself, writing that "the thesis of the book is highly controversial and many Poles and others also find it unfair and tendentious." The Piast Institute also wrote that "reviewers in major newspapers such as the New York Times, The Baltimore Sun and the Los Angeles Times, none of whom has any expertise in Polish or East Central European history, have reacted to the book with uncritical acclaim and considerable anti-Polish rhetoric. As such, it is clear already that Fear will have a serious and negative effect on Polish-Jewish relations."
David Engel wrote that, unlike Gross' earlier work Neighbors: The Destruction of the Jewish Community in Jedwabne, Poland, in which Gross posited a continuity in the actions of a community of people over generations, in Fear "Gross himself appears to have bracketed off the Nazi era from the longer course of Polish history and by doing so to have altered the terms for reflecting on transgenerational Polish responsibility for past deeds that he set forth in his earlier work." Engel wrote that Gross now sees World War II as a radical break in the history of Polish behavior towards Jews.
Poland
In Poland Fear caused controversy and what the German magazine Der Spiegel described as a "right wing backlash;" with the book coming under strong criticism by Polish historians, nationalists, and the country's conservative establishment. Polish rabbi Burt Schuman, quoted in Der Spiegel, said he welcomed the debate Fear had begun, but described the book as unfairly depicting the country as anti-Semitic thus "harming our goal of reconciliation."
In a letter to the Polish publishers of Fear, Znak, Cardinal Stanisław Dziwisz, secretary to the late Pope John Paul II, said Gross' book "awakened the demon" of anti-Semitism. A Znak spokesperson responded to the complaint by asserting that the issues should be talked about. Znak spokesman Tomasz Miedzik told Der Spiegel "We have the freedom to ask difficult questions about our history and we should do that."
In a televised discussion with Gross, historian Andrzej Paczkowski expressed his discomfort about the speed with which Gross makes generalizations. "Memory and history are two different things," Paczkowski said. "Memory is black and white while history is about shades of gray."
Fear has been criticized by historians such as Paweł Machcewicz, Piotr Gontarczyk, Thaddeus Radzilowski, Janusz Kurtyka, Dariusz Stola, and Marek Jan Chodakiewicz. Gross has been accused of using imperfect methodology, making generalizations, stereotyping, ignoring works which did not confirm his views, neglecting the wider context of the events in that Jews were not a unique subject of persecution and banditry which occurred throughout postwar Europe, misinterpreting or distorting data, relying mostly on Jewish sources, using inflammatory and emotional language, and drawing unsubstantiated conclusions.
Janusz Kurtyka, the president of the Institute of National Remembrance, in an interview with journalist Konrad Piasecki, stated that Fear has serious methodological errors and omissions and that it makes emotive use of political epithets, and therefore will not be accepted — even conditionally — in the historical community.
Marcin Zaremba, a historian at Warsaw University, described Fear as an important publication. Zaremba told Network Europe radio that he "agree with argument that Poles had their share in the Holocaust," and that "anti-Semitism was a kind of cultural code which Poles used at that time, and that Jews were not responsible for the introduction of communist rule in Poland."
In response to the coverage of Fear in the Polish daily Rzeczpospolita, Marek Beylin, a columnist for the competing daily Gazeta Wyborcza, called for a "sincere debate about the dark secrets of the Polish past."
Feliks Tych, head of Warsaw's Jewish Historical Institute, criticized Gross for being more of a judge than an analyst, neglecting the impact of the post-war collapse of state institutions, and selectively using facts to support his thesis. Tych also said that "after book, it is no longer possible to escape from the question why there were killings of Jews after the war, and that is is his undeniable achievement."
Polish prosecutors reviewed accusations that Fear is slanderous against the Polish nation, but rejected the claims and refused to launch an investigation. The fact that such requests were made became the subject of additional media controversy. The article of the Polish law that allowed the case to be made in the first place has been criticized by some as infringing upon the right to free speech and will be reviewed by the Polish Constitutional Court.
Gross' book was denounced at a special church service held in February 2008 at the Basilica of the Sacred Heart of Jesus in Kraków. The gathering, which was organized by the Committee Against Defamation of the Church and For Polishness and the Catholic radio station Radio Maryja and attended by 1,000 people, was described as having strong overtones of anti-semitism. The event and its organizers have been criticized by the Polish press and Church officials, including the Vatican, for anti-Semitic overtones and for allowing a Roman Catholic Church to be used as a stage for an impromptu political debate.
See also
Citations
- ^ David Margolick. Postwar Pogrom. The New York Times Book Review, July 23, 2006
- ^ Symposium: Analysis of Fear - Summary of the Essay
- Fear, pp. 83-166
- ^ Piotr Gontarczyk, Far From Truth, Rzeczpospolita, January 12, 2008 Template:En icon
- Jan T. Gross. Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz. An Essay in Historical Interpretation. New York, Random House, 2006. Quoted in: David Engel, On Continuity and Discontinuity in Polish-Jewish Relations: Observations on Fear: Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz—An Essay in Historical Interpretation by Jan T. Gross. New York: Random House, 2006, East European Politics & Societies, Vol. 21, No. 3, 534-548 (2007)
- ^ Elie Wiesel. The Killing After The Killing. The Washington Post, June 25, 2006.
- Thane Rosenbaum, "A Lethal Homecoming" (pdf), book review of Fear, Los Angeles Times, June 25, 2006.
- Susan Rubin Suleiman. Aftershocks. The Boston Globe, July 02, 2006
- ^ Janusz Reiter, Anti-Semitism in Poland, Washington Post July 9, 2006.
- Symposium: Analysis of Fear - Symposium's Purpose
- Symposium: Analysis of Fear - Introduction
- David Engel, On Continuity and Discontinuity in Polish-Jewish Relations: Observations on Fear: Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz—An Essay in Historical Interpretation by Jan T. Gross. New York: Random House, 2006, East European Politics & Societies, Vol. 21, No. 3, 534-548 (2007)
- ^ Sleeping dogs that won't lie: book on Poland's anti-Semitic record triggers fierce controversy. The Economist, January 31, 2008.
- ^ Siobhán Dowling. Fear and Slander in Poland. Anti-Semitism Book Could Land Historian in Jail. Spiegel International. January 18, 2008.
- ^ Craig Whitlock, A Scholar's Legal Peril in Poland, Washington Post Foreign Service, Friday, January 18, 2008; Page A14
- TVN24 2008, "Gross chce zmusić Polaków do zmiany świadomości", 2008-19-1, TVN24, PAP
- ^ THADDEUS RADZILOWSKI, Review of FEAR
- ^ Template:Pl iconKonrad Piasecki, "Gross to wampir historiografii," interview with historian Janusz Kurtyka, RMF FM, 10 January 2008
- ^ Dariusz Stolam Review of Fear, in The English Historical Review 2007 CXXII(499):1460-1463; doi:10.1093/ehr/cem344
- ^ Marek Jan Chodakiewicz: People’s past has to be reviewed critically on individual basis, Rzeczpospolita, January 11, 2008 Template:En icon
- Michael Kubicki. New books on afterwar Polish-Jewish relations provoke heated debate in Poland. Network Europe, January 18, 2008.
- Siobhán Dowling. Fear and Slander in Poland. Anti-Semitism Book Could Land Historian in Jail. Spiegel International. January 18, 2008.
- Template:En icon Marek Beylin, Jews, Poles, Fear, Gazeta Wyborcza, January 13, 2008.
- Beats Pasek. Confronting Poland's Anti-Semitic Demons. Time, Jan. 23, 2008.
- Template:Pl icon Nie będzie śledztwa ws. książki Grossa Wprost 24
- Aviva Lori, Krakow church holds service against 'kikes who spit on us'. Haaretz, February 12, 2008.
- Anti-Semitism watchdog urges Polish church to denounce lecture. Agence France Presse. February 14, 2008.
- Template:Pl icon Małgorzata I. Niemczyńska, Żydzi nas atakują ! Trzeba się bronić, Gazeta Wyborcza, February 11, 2008.
- Template:Pl icon Katarzyna Wiśniewska, Jerzy Robert Nowak wchodzi do Kościoła, Gazeta Wyborcza, February 12, 2008.
- Template:Pl icon Ludwik Grzebień, Ignatianum odcina się od Jerzego R. Nowaka, Gazeta Wyborcza, February 16, 2008.
Further reading
- David Engel, On Continuity and Discontinuity in Polish-Jewish Relations: Observations on Fear: Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz—An Essay in Historical Interpretation by Jan T. Gross. New York: Random House, 2006, East European Politics & Societies, Vol. 21, No. 3, 534-548 (2007),
External links
- Chasing Away the Memory of Guilt: The End of Jewish Life in Poland H-Net review of Fear
- "Polish criminal investigation into the book Fear" European Jewish Press
- Fear and Slander in Poland. Anti-Semitism Book Could Land Historian in Jail. Siobhán Dowling, Spiegel International, January 18, 2008.