Misplaced Pages

Talk:Germanisation/Archive 1: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
< Talk:Germanisation Browse history interactivelyNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 12:30, 30 October 2005 editSciurinæ (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Rollbackers12,786 edits reason for pov section tag  Revision as of 23:07, 30 October 2005 edit undoMolobo (talk | contribs)13,968 editsNo edit summaryNext edit →
Line 1: Line 1:
I read "Minorities in the nation state" of my old history book, and, of course, the impression conveyed is differently than that Molobo tries to give, for it is neutral. Rather than insisting on proof of "torture", for example, and keeping the version hysterically, I'd better just translate and summarize the historical description. ] 12:30, 30 October 2005 (UTC) I read "Minorities in the nation state" of my old history book, and, of course, the impression conveyed is differently than that Molobo tries to give, for it is neutral. Rather than insisting on proof of "torture", for example, and keeping the version hysterically, I'd better just translate and summarize the historical description. ] 12:30, 30 October 2005 (UTC)

'' Rather than insisting on proof of "torture", for example''
Which can be easly found on site of the school where the events took place, that had engaged in country wide event to remember the fight to preserve Polish identity by those children.Here is a detailed account of event made by one of the organisers of the ceremonies :
http://www.sdw.icpnet.pl/historia.html
I will translate some fragments:
German teachers resorted to physical violence and repressions.Children were held up in school for several hours.Two times at 2 and 13 May flogging was used.
But the number of protestors grew. Main opponents and leaders of the children were Stanislaw Jerszynski and Smidowiczowna, who refused to be influenced by inspector Winter.They were
severely beaten.

At first the German teachers tried persuasion.Rector Fedke said to the children that they are German and should be proud of it.Then one girl stood up and said "We are subjects of the German Reich, but we are Poles".Another student Bronisław Klimas asked how does the national flag look like said "Our flag is red and white, prussina white and black"Responding to the questions of teachers why they will not speak german on religion classes students said "We are Poles and we won't speak in German during religion"


"Words of prussian director of the schoold in Malych Bartodziejach under Bydgoszcz who wrote in school chronicle with arrogance "We Germans are afraid of nobody, and this means Poles also"


A usual visitor was inspector Winter,and he tried to broke the resistence of the children. Often he would ask "Who are you". The answer remained the same "We are Poles". He tried to tell them that they should not care if they speak polish or german.Children responded -"Why aren't German children learning polish then ? "One girl said "Chancellor Bulow said that every bird should sing how his beak grow, and we have polish beaks, so we want to sing in Polish". German teachers were outraged when instead of singing Preusse the children singed "Pole". Corporal punishment followed this.On another occasion teacher heard them speaking in Polish during a break. He told them "You can speak french, english or even chinese, but not polish language.


The mass execution of punishment came at Wrzesnia school at 20th of May 1901 at 10 when Winter came-the school inspector informed by rector Fedtke. 26 pupils were arrested and ordered to learn german songs, those that did were relased. The rest-14 resisted. Then Winter ordere more flogging -from four to eight strikes.''


Prussian methods in the wrzesnia school were described by one patricipants of of the first strike Bronislawa Smidowicz Matuszewska-Flogging was used in parts.If a pupil didn't answer after several questions, he received three strikes.After that they made some promises as to his future.If that didn't work more punishment was threatened.Finally more questions were asked and if that didn't help, he received three more strikes, and such ones '''that skin on hands broke apart.'''



Laud screams and cries coming from inside gathered people before the school, that counted aprox. thousand people.People started protesting, and were even more outraged when beaten children appeared on the street crying.Teachers advised Winter to go out by the back door, but he felt(here's a quote) I was chosen to bravely defend this outpost and fight for the defence of honor of the threatend German rule



The crowd entered the school by force and 12-14 people went inside, where they demanded a stop to the beating of children. Despite this Winter told to continue flogging. As the crowd grew more violent he decided to stop.


This time prosecutor Lange spoke "the characteristic of this issues is that difference between Germans and Poles.The state had to intervene and defend german interest, defeat polishness.To achieve this means it had to use german language as teaching tool"

--] 23:07, 30 October 2005 (UTC)
Also:




Czeslaw Luczak "Od Bismarcka do Hitlera: Polsko-Niemieckie stosunki gospodarcze"Poznan 1988 ISBN 83-210-0767-8
There were ultra-nationalist, tolerated or even backed by government organisations, such as
Allgemainer Deutscher Verband, later renamed to Alldeutsched Verband, which in 1914 had 18.000
members. In Posen there was founded in 1894 Verein zur Forderung des Deutschtums in den Ostmarken,
later renamed into Deutscher Ostmarkverein, which in 1909 had 50.500, and in 1912 54.100
members, recruiting in vast majority from government clerks, teachers, officers etc - this
organisation was called by Poles HaKaTa from names of the founders, Hansemann, Kennemann and
Tiedemann. In 1911 it called eastern provinces of Germany "the battlefield" and was later
called by H.U Wehler the precursor of the Nazi party (Wehler, Krisenherde des Kaiserreichs 1817-1918,
Ottingen 1979, p-193-194) because of its pathological hatred of all things Polish (p 20-21)
Governmetn founded in 1886 Konigliche Ausiedlungskommission which was funding the German
settlement in eastern provinces, buying the land from Polish owners etc, there were also
two other organisations, in 1904 in Posen Deutsche mittlestandkasse and 1906 in Danzig/Gdansk
Bauernbank fur Westpreussen. This institutions were helped by different local
organisation such as Landgesselschaften and local settlement commission Kleinsiedlungsgenossenschaften.
In addition there was founded Deutscher Fursorgverein, Ruckwanderstelle and many, manyother
organisation with one goal: buy as many land from Poles as possible and settle as
many Germans as possible.

They were encouraging Germans from foreign lands, from Galicia, Vohlyn, Hungary, Romania etc etc.
The Commision for Settlement in 1886-1918 settled in Posen and West Prussia 21.886 German families,
counting in total 153.800 people, from which 21.683 took over their farms before the end of 1914. 25% of
them came from abroad. Many families were also helped by other organisations, which helped them buy land etc
etc. At first they were settled in countryside, hpoing that Germanisation of villages will cause
the Germanisation of cities, later also German craftsmen were settled in cities, mainly by HKT which
settled in Posen province about 30 doctors, craftsmen etc yearly. In addition to help fight "the Polish
danger in eastern provinces" the workers in factories were also settled. In period 1903-1905 325 families
came to Posen and West Prussia(1379) from abroad, including 209 fro Hungary, 89 from Galicia
and 27 from Russia, and to 1912 in Posen area there were 961 workers settlements. (p20-25)

People working in eastern Prussian provinces received an addition to their salary, so called "Ostmarkenzulage".
Some representants of local administration proposed counting the years of service by doubling, just like in the
case of the war, for the clerks working in eastern provinces.

Interesting case: in 1850 many German catholic settlers from times of XVIII, while in 1914 they considered
themselves Poles - there was from 50.000 to 75.000 such settlers. This was primary reason why vast
majority of new settlers were protestants (21.014 families from settlers recruited by Commission of Settlement,
that is 96,9%. Similarly 90% of German clerks and teachers were protestants (p26).

In total, the estimated number of Germans settled in 1871-1914 in Posen and West Prussia was higher than
250.000.

On other hand, the Polish teachers and clerks were assigned functions in western part of Germany. Such
action was taken for few thousands of Poles, amongst whom was teacher 64 years old and clerks with 40 years
of job. In addition German gvt paied for special agitation in press for encouraging emigration of Poles
for abroad. The exceptional ways were removal of Poles by force, first "Poles who were suspected of anti-German
activity" (3 February 1872 in Posen), and later of removal of all Poles without Prussian citizenship, with
exception of few who received special allowance for stay. THe mass removals started with expelling 500 Jews
from Berlin. Suprisingly, some "presidents" of provinces (of Silesia and West Prussia) say that this action has
no sense, since many of those Poles have already found new families and they are living there for sometimes
decades. On the other hand, "presidents" of Posen and Opole (region in middle Silesia) proposed the enlarged
the scope of the action. In 1884 the law was passed for removal of all Poles, who had citizenship of other states,
with exception of those, who were "by mistake" drafted to Prussian army or arrived before 1843 (in practice however
those exceptions were not honoured). In total 43.943 Poles were destined for removal, but finally, because
deficit of workforce the number was limited to about 32.000. Among the removed there were 9 to 10.000 Jews,
who admitted (with few exceptions) the belonging to Polish nation.

That actions was protested by Polish envoys to German and PRussian parliaments, which were backed by many
German (Espectially Alsatians) and Danish envoys. Many
politicians, like Karol Liebknecht, Ludwig Windthorst, Rudolf Virchov etc described this actions as either
inhuman or illegal. Finally PRussiann government
stopped the action. Amongst the removed there was 2-years old orphan adopted by Polish family in Pleszow;
98-years old woman who arrived to her grandson to Gniezno. The families were partitioned by deporting those members
who had no citizenship. The Poles "suspected for anti-German policy" were for example Pole from Wroclaw (Breslau)
who celebrated victory of Sobieski at Vienna or few Polish students from university. OTOH Bismarck received also
the letters with approval from Germans (Even from Bohemia!), and was backed by majority of German press.

Poles were almost always serving outside eastern provinces; it was believed, in words of Bismarck, that in such
way they will "know the blessing of German civilisation" (p42). German ggovernment thought, that Polish
recruits will be addicted to that civilisation and will stay in western parts of Germany and in consequence
they will Germanise. But only 0,01% Polish men have not returned to theur families after the service.

German clergy was colportating amongst the kids the religious books in German, hpoing that they will Germanise
whole families via their kids. Their actions were supported by German government, which few times gave special
funds for many of them.

Some of the German actions were ridiculous: The German clerks demanded that Polish parents will gave their newborn
kids German names, and they were sometimes even changing them without consciense of parents; so Jan was written
as Johann etc. German goverment also was warning the staying Polish teachers that "cultivating Polish language" in
PRIVATE homes could result in deportation. Ostmarkenverein was postulating, but fortunately without success, the
planned Germanisation of Polish orphans and kids from broken families. (p45)

The German view on Poles were quite simple: Poles were on lower level of civilisation. E.g. A.Dix, German writer, in
1898 said that "Slavs are typical representants of proletariat, citizens of fifth class", and "Germans in east
should be everywhere the masters". T.Schon, president of West PRussia, wrote, that main task of his administration
is to "turn ex-slaves Slavs into people and Germans". Even Wilhelm II said on occasion that "Slavs are born
to serve other nations". (p 45)


The policy of German government brought the desired results. In the years 1870-1910 the Prussian official statistics
noted 70% of raise of Germans in West Prussia and 58% in Posen, 12,2% in East Prussia and 56,3% in Opole. For comaprison,
in Posen number of Poles raised by 27,8%, in Opole in 32,4%, and was lowered in Eastern Prussia by 12% and in Western
Prussia by 5,8%. All the censuses are generally in low esteem by Polish historians, because they forced Poles to declare
themselves as bilingual or using only German, for example all Polish soldiers were counted as Germans. In Namyslow
count in SIlesia in 1910 it was reported that only those Poles who admitted that they know no German were listed
as Poles, and the rest as Germans. he separate case is so called "battle for land". It was started by Flotwell, who however was able to bought
only 30 large Polish estates. The legal basis for later actions was 1886 June law of "strengthening the Germanness
in provinces West Prussia and Posen", in short "Ansiedlungsgesetz", the Settlement law. Those act, plus
later novelisations (including 1912 "the law of strengthening Germanness in some parts of the country" etc)
included for example that Poles in countryside can build new buildings only after receving speciall allowance
from German administration, which effectively caused that Poles could not build new buildings (famous Drzymala wagon
case), made legal basis for confiscating Polish land and allotted large sums for buying out olish land, e.g
100.000 mk in 1886. The funds of Settlement Comission achieved 955 millions mk, plus another funds from economical
activity, in total about 1423 millions mk. However, because Poles - as results of well-known "longest war of
modern Europe" were boycotting the action en masse, the commission finally was mainly buying the land from.. Germans
(the total of 71.2% in 1910 and 1913 71.3%). Frustrated Germans: the organisations, profesors such as Otto Hotzsch, local admi
nistration etc postulated that
the law should be passed which would allow to buy the land without the agreement from Polish owner. Such law
was passed in 1908, march 20. Protests from around the world (the actions initiated by Polish writer Henryk Sienkiewicz,
who convinced many intellectuals to sign letters of protests, the protests by some Germans etc) caused that first
actions based on such law were in 1912, when 4 Polish estates were bought despite the protests of the owners.
The First World War stopped such actions. (p52-5Cool

The new settlers received credits for new buildings and starting new life, etc etc. Sometimes the Commission was
using low-moral Poles, who were buying the land from other Poles who otherwise were refusing to sell it to Germans;
The official end of the Comission was 1 June 1924.

In addition there were other, non-government (though with government's blessing and backing) institutions which
were giving credits on favourable terms, buing land and encouraging German settlement, and so called "land organisations"
(Landgesellchaft) which were creating new large farms, with sepcific official goal of separating Poles and dissoluting
Polish "element". (p28-66)

As mentioned earlier, Poles needed special allowance for making new building in countryside. In 1905-1913 in
region of Bydgoszcz 78% of all petitions were refused (1904, 10 VIII, ansiedlungsnovelle). In some regions
Poles had to provide the documents testifying, that they won't sell the building to other Pole, or that
their investment is not violating the "settlement law modification" (mentioned ansiedlungsnovelle).

The name "battle for land" came becasue Poles started to defend, the organisations for helping were created by Poles,
and both Germans and Poles tried to buy as much land as possible. The successes of Polish private
organisation resulted in protulates by German newspapers for passing the law (Berliner Borsen-Zeitung 22 May 1907)
which would made illegall the assistance to buying the land by private institutions. Suprisingly, the most
sold land came from rich Poles, while the ones who were most active in propaganda and less eager to sell the land
were sometimes the poorest ones...

As the result, in Posen majority of rural area (almost 60%) was in the hands of Germans (p74)

The German and public banks were refusing providing the credit for Poles, either directly or by making
conditions which were highly discouraging, especially when compared to conditions offered to Germans. Sometimes
they were gicing the credit, only suddenly demand everything back. Simultanously
goverment was backing favourable credits for "strenghtening the German economy" in eastern provinces.
The government was subsidising the self-help organisation, but since 1908 only on conditions, that such
organisation will remove all Polish members. (p81)

There were also non-returnable subsidies paid by government (Niederlassungsbeihilfe), organisations such as
HKT etc - all of which should result in limiting Polish economy and domination of Germans in economy of
eastern provinces.

German soldiers were OFFICIALLY forbidden from goinf to Polish friseurs, German public institutions from delegating
works and repairments to Polish companies etc. German organisations were printing works such as "Guide for German
shops in Posen".

OTOH, Polish organisation had their meetings monitored and sometimes disbanded because of using of Polish lanugage;
they could were refused from hiring the rooms etc etc. The economical boycott was from both sides. Both for the Poles
and Germans it was patriotic duty to buy only from their nationalities. It was started by Poles, true, and later
the German slogans were usually simply translations of earlier Polish ones, but the Poles, contrary to Germans,
had not the backing of government. (p90)
--] 23:07, 30 October 2005 (UTC)

Revision as of 23:07, 30 October 2005

I read "Minorities in the nation state" of my old history book, and, of course, the impression conveyed is differently than that Molobo tries to give, for it is neutral. Rather than insisting on proof of "torture", for example, and keeping the version hysterically, I'd better just translate and summarize the historical description. NightBeAsT 12:30, 30 October 2005 (UTC)

Rather than insisting on proof of "torture", for example Which can be easly found on site of the school where the events took place, that had engaged in country wide event to remember the fight to preserve Polish identity by those children.Here is a detailed account of event made by one of the organisers of the ceremonies  : http://www.sdw.icpnet.pl/historia.html I will translate some fragments: German teachers resorted to physical violence and repressions.Children were held up in school for several hours.Two times at 2 and 13 May flogging was used. But the number of protestors grew. Main opponents and leaders of the children were Stanislaw Jerszynski and Smidowiczowna, who refused to be influenced by inspector Winter.They were severely beaten.

At first the German teachers tried persuasion.Rector Fedke said to the children that they are German and should be proud of it.Then one girl stood up and said "We are subjects of the German Reich, but we are Poles".Another student Bronisław Klimas asked how does the national flag look like said "Our flag is red and white, prussina white and black"Responding to the questions of teachers why they will not speak german on religion classes students said "We are Poles and we won't speak in German during religion"


"Words of prussian director of the schoold in Malych Bartodziejach under Bydgoszcz who wrote in school chronicle with arrogance "We Germans are afraid of nobody, and this means Poles also"


A usual visitor was inspector Winter,and he tried to broke the resistence of the children. Often he would ask "Who are you". The answer remained the same "We are Poles". He tried to tell them that they should not care if they speak polish or german.Children responded -"Why aren't German children learning polish then ? "One girl said "Chancellor Bulow said that every bird should sing how his beak grow, and we have polish beaks, so we want to sing in Polish". German teachers were outraged when instead of singing Preusse the children singed "Pole". Corporal punishment followed this.On another occasion teacher heard them speaking in Polish during a break. He told them "You can speak french, english or even chinese, but not polish language.


The mass execution of punishment came at Wrzesnia school at 20th of May 1901 at 10 when Winter came-the school inspector informed by rector Fedtke. 26 pupils were arrested and ordered to learn german songs, those that did were relased. The rest-14 resisted. Then Winter ordere more flogging -from four to eight strikes.


Prussian methods in the wrzesnia school were described by one patricipants of of the first strike Bronislawa Smidowicz Matuszewska-Flogging was used in parts.If a pupil didn't answer after several questions, he received three strikes.After that they made some promises as to his future.If that didn't work more punishment was threatened.Finally more questions were asked and if that didn't help, he received three more strikes, and such ones that skin on hands broke apart.


Laud screams and cries coming from inside gathered people before the school, that counted aprox. thousand people.People started protesting, and were even more outraged when beaten children appeared on the street crying.Teachers advised Winter to go out by the back door, but he felt(here's a quote) I was chosen to bravely defend this outpost and fight for the defence of honor of the threatend German rule


The crowd entered the school by force and 12-14 people went inside, where they demanded a stop to the beating of children. Despite this Winter told to continue flogging. As the crowd grew more violent he decided to stop.


This time prosecutor Lange spoke "the characteristic of this issues is that difference between Germans and Poles.The state had to intervene and defend german interest, defeat polishness.To achieve this means it had to use german language as teaching tool"

--Molobo 23:07, 30 October 2005 (UTC) Also:



Czeslaw Luczak "Od Bismarcka do Hitlera: Polsko-Niemieckie stosunki gospodarcze"Poznan 1988 ISBN 83-210-0767-8 There were ultra-nationalist, tolerated or even backed by government organisations, such as Allgemainer Deutscher Verband, later renamed to Alldeutsched Verband, which in 1914 had 18.000 members. In Posen there was founded in 1894 Verein zur Forderung des Deutschtums in den Ostmarken, later renamed into Deutscher Ostmarkverein, which in 1909 had 50.500, and in 1912 54.100 members, recruiting in vast majority from government clerks, teachers, officers etc - this organisation was called by Poles HaKaTa from names of the founders, Hansemann, Kennemann and Tiedemann. In 1911 it called eastern provinces of Germany "the battlefield" and was later called by H.U Wehler the precursor of the Nazi party (Wehler, Krisenherde des Kaiserreichs 1817-1918, Ottingen 1979, p-193-194) because of its pathological hatred of all things Polish (p 20-21) Governmetn founded in 1886 Konigliche Ausiedlungskommission which was funding the German settlement in eastern provinces, buying the land from Polish owners etc, there were also two other organisations, in 1904 in Posen Deutsche mittlestandkasse and 1906 in Danzig/Gdansk Bauernbank fur Westpreussen. This institutions were helped by different local organisation such as Landgesselschaften and local settlement commission Kleinsiedlungsgenossenschaften. In addition there was founded Deutscher Fursorgverein, Ruckwanderstelle and many, manyother organisation with one goal: buy as many land from Poles as possible and settle as many Germans as possible.

They were encouraging Germans from foreign lands, from Galicia, Vohlyn, Hungary, Romania etc etc. The Commision for Settlement in 1886-1918 settled in Posen and West Prussia 21.886 German families, counting in total 153.800 people, from which 21.683 took over their farms before the end of 1914. 25% of them came from abroad. Many families were also helped by other organisations, which helped them buy land etc etc. At first they were settled in countryside, hpoing that Germanisation of villages will cause the Germanisation of cities, later also German craftsmen were settled in cities, mainly by HKT which settled in Posen province about 30 doctors, craftsmen etc yearly. In addition to help fight "the Polish danger in eastern provinces" the workers in factories were also settled. In period 1903-1905 325 families came to Posen and West Prussia(1379) from abroad, including 209 fro Hungary, 89 from Galicia and 27 from Russia, and to 1912 in Posen area there were 961 workers settlements. (p20-25)

People working in eastern Prussian provinces received an addition to their salary, so called "Ostmarkenzulage". Some representants of local administration proposed counting the years of service by doubling, just like in the case of the war, for the clerks working in eastern provinces.

Interesting case: in 1850 many German catholic settlers from times of XVIII, while in 1914 they considered themselves Poles - there was from 50.000 to 75.000 such settlers. This was primary reason why vast majority of new settlers were protestants (21.014 families from settlers recruited by Commission of Settlement, that is 96,9%. Similarly 90% of German clerks and teachers were protestants (p26).

In total, the estimated number of Germans settled in 1871-1914 in Posen and West Prussia was higher than 250.000.

On other hand, the Polish teachers and clerks were assigned functions in western part of Germany. Such action was taken for few thousands of Poles, amongst whom was teacher 64 years old and clerks with 40 years of job. In addition German gvt paied for special agitation in press for encouraging emigration of Poles for abroad. The exceptional ways were removal of Poles by force, first "Poles who were suspected of anti-German activity" (3 February 1872 in Posen), and later of removal of all Poles without Prussian citizenship, with exception of few who received special allowance for stay. THe mass removals started with expelling 500 Jews from Berlin. Suprisingly, some "presidents" of provinces (of Silesia and West Prussia) say that this action has no sense, since many of those Poles have already found new families and they are living there for sometimes decades. On the other hand, "presidents" of Posen and Opole (region in middle Silesia) proposed the enlarged the scope of the action. In 1884 the law was passed for removal of all Poles, who had citizenship of other states, with exception of those, who were "by mistake" drafted to Prussian army or arrived before 1843 (in practice however those exceptions were not honoured). In total 43.943 Poles were destined for removal, but finally, because deficit of workforce the number was limited to about 32.000. Among the removed there were 9 to 10.000 Jews, who admitted (with few exceptions) the belonging to Polish nation.

That actions was protested by Polish envoys to German and PRussian parliaments, which were backed by many German (Espectially Alsatians) and Danish envoys. Many politicians, like Karol Liebknecht, Ludwig Windthorst, Rudolf Virchov etc described this actions as either inhuman or illegal. Finally PRussiann government stopped the action. Amongst the removed there was 2-years old orphan adopted by Polish family in Pleszow; 98-years old woman who arrived to her grandson to Gniezno. The families were partitioned by deporting those members who had no citizenship. The Poles "suspected for anti-German policy" were for example Pole from Wroclaw (Breslau) who celebrated victory of Sobieski at Vienna or few Polish students from university. OTOH Bismarck received also the letters with approval from Germans (Even from Bohemia!), and was backed by majority of German press.

Poles were almost always serving outside eastern provinces; it was believed, in words of Bismarck, that in such way they will "know the blessing of German civilisation" (p42). German ggovernment thought, that Polish recruits will be addicted to that civilisation and will stay in western parts of Germany and in consequence they will Germanise. But only 0,01% Polish men have not returned to theur families after the service.

German clergy was colportating amongst the kids the religious books in German, hpoing that they will Germanise whole families via their kids. Their actions were supported by German government, which few times gave special funds for many of them.

Some of the German actions were ridiculous: The German clerks demanded that Polish parents will gave their newborn kids German names, and they were sometimes even changing them without consciense of parents; so Jan was written as Johann etc. German goverment also was warning the staying Polish teachers that "cultivating Polish language" in PRIVATE homes could result in deportation. Ostmarkenverein was postulating, but fortunately without success, the planned Germanisation of Polish orphans and kids from broken families. (p45)

The German view on Poles were quite simple: Poles were on lower level of civilisation. E.g. A.Dix, German writer, in 1898 said that "Slavs are typical representants of proletariat, citizens of fifth class", and "Germans in east should be everywhere the masters". T.Schon, president of West PRussia, wrote, that main task of his administration is to "turn ex-slaves Slavs into people and Germans". Even Wilhelm II said on occasion that "Slavs are born to serve other nations". (p 45)


The policy of German government brought the desired results. In the years 1870-1910 the Prussian official statistics noted 70% of raise of Germans in West Prussia and 58% in Posen, 12,2% in East Prussia and 56,3% in Opole. For comaprison, in Posen number of Poles raised by 27,8%, in Opole in 32,4%, and was lowered in Eastern Prussia by 12% and in Western Prussia by 5,8%. All the censuses are generally in low esteem by Polish historians, because they forced Poles to declare themselves as bilingual or using only German, for example all Polish soldiers were counted as Germans. In Namyslow count in SIlesia in 1910 it was reported that only those Poles who admitted that they know no German were listed as Poles, and the rest as Germans. he separate case is so called "battle for land". It was started by Flotwell, who however was able to bought only 30 large Polish estates. The legal basis for later actions was 1886 June law of "strengthening the Germanness in provinces West Prussia and Posen", in short "Ansiedlungsgesetz", the Settlement law. Those act, plus later novelisations (including 1912 "the law of strengthening Germanness in some parts of the country" etc) included for example that Poles in countryside can build new buildings only after receving speciall allowance from German administration, which effectively caused that Poles could not build new buildings (famous Drzymala wagon case), made legal basis for confiscating Polish land and allotted large sums for buying out olish land, e.g 100.000 mk in 1886. The funds of Settlement Comission achieved 955 millions mk, plus another funds from economical activity, in total about 1423 millions mk. However, because Poles - as results of well-known "longest war of modern Europe" were boycotting the action en masse, the commission finally was mainly buying the land from.. Germans (the total of 71.2% in 1910 and 1913 71.3%). Frustrated Germans: the organisations, profesors such as Otto Hotzsch, local admi nistration etc postulated that the law should be passed which would allow to buy the land without the agreement from Polish owner. Such law was passed in 1908, march 20. Protests from around the world (the actions initiated by Polish writer Henryk Sienkiewicz, who convinced many intellectuals to sign letters of protests, the protests by some Germans etc) caused that first actions based on such law were in 1912, when 4 Polish estates were bought despite the protests of the owners. The First World War stopped such actions. (p52-5Cool

The new settlers received credits for new buildings and starting new life, etc etc. Sometimes the Commission was using low-moral Poles, who were buying the land from other Poles who otherwise were refusing to sell it to Germans; The official end of the Comission was 1 June 1924.

In addition there were other, non-government (though with government's blessing and backing) institutions which were giving credits on favourable terms, buing land and encouraging German settlement, and so called "land organisations" (Landgesellchaft) which were creating new large farms, with sepcific official goal of separating Poles and dissoluting Polish "element". (p28-66)

As mentioned earlier, Poles needed special allowance for making new building in countryside. In 1905-1913 in region of Bydgoszcz 78% of all petitions were refused (1904, 10 VIII, ansiedlungsnovelle). In some regions Poles had to provide the documents testifying, that they won't sell the building to other Pole, or that their investment is not violating the "settlement law modification" (mentioned ansiedlungsnovelle).

The name "battle for land" came becasue Poles started to defend, the organisations for helping were created by Poles, and both Germans and Poles tried to buy as much land as possible. The successes of Polish private organisation resulted in protulates by German newspapers for passing the law (Berliner Borsen-Zeitung 22 May 1907) which would made illegall the assistance to buying the land by private institutions. Suprisingly, the most sold land came from rich Poles, while the ones who were most active in propaganda and less eager to sell the land were sometimes the poorest ones...

As the result, in Posen majority of rural area (almost 60%) was in the hands of Germans (p74)

The German and public banks were refusing providing the credit for Poles, either directly or by making conditions which were highly discouraging, especially when compared to conditions offered to Germans. Sometimes they were gicing the credit, only suddenly demand everything back. Simultanously goverment was backing favourable credits for "strenghtening the German economy" in eastern provinces. The government was subsidising the self-help organisation, but since 1908 only on conditions, that such organisation will remove all Polish members. (p81)

There were also non-returnable subsidies paid by government (Niederlassungsbeihilfe), organisations such as HKT etc - all of which should result in limiting Polish economy and domination of Germans in economy of eastern provinces.

German soldiers were OFFICIALLY forbidden from goinf to Polish friseurs, German public institutions from delegating works and repairments to Polish companies etc. German organisations were printing works such as "Guide for German shops in Posen".

OTOH, Polish organisation had their meetings monitored and sometimes disbanded because of using of Polish lanugage; they could were refused from hiring the rooms etc etc. The economical boycott was from both sides. Both for the Poles and Germans it was patriotic duty to buy only from their nationalities. It was started by Poles, true, and later the German slogans were usually simply translations of earlier Polish ones, but the Poles, contrary to Germans, had not the backing of government. (p90) --Molobo 23:07, 30 October 2005 (UTC)