| Revision as of 02:31, 19 April 2006 editPatCheng (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users3,062 edits →Post-visa statements and activities← Previous edit | Revision as of 08:17, 4 June 2006 edit undoTJive (talk | contribs)4,555 edits npov-izeNext edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| '''Chen Yonglin''' (Chinese Traditional: 陳用林, Simplified: 陈用林) is a former ] diplomat who sparked fears of a diplomatic incident through his defection to ] in the summer of ]. The episode | '''Chen Yonglin''' (Chinese Traditional: 陳用林, Simplified: 陈用林) is a former ] diplomat who sparked fears of a diplomatic incident through his defection to ] in the summer of ]. The episode highlighted the tensions faced by China's trade partners when concerns arise from that nation's ]. The episode was compared to the ] by such observers as Shadow Minister for Immigration ] and trade unionist ]. | ||
| highlighted the tensions faced by China's trade partners when concerns arise from that nation's ]. The episode was compared to the ] by such observers as Shadow Minister for Immigration ] and trade unionist ]. | |||
| ==Background== | ==Background== | ||
| Chen had been a university student in ] during the pro-democracy movement that ultimately led to the ] |
Chen had been a university student in ] during the pro-democracy movement that ultimately led to the ]. Several of his friends were wounded in the ensuing repression by the government. He was said to have underwent political ] after the subsequent crackdown on ]s, and joined the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs in ]. This culminated in his posting as the consul for political affairs in the Chinese consulate in ], ]. In this position, Chen has stated that he was responsible for monitoring Chinese political dissidents, especially ], living in Australia. He also reportedly had access to highly classified information on Chinese intelligence activities in Australia. Chen has claimed that he had "gone easy" on dissidents and Falun Gong practitioners and had not reported some actions, to protest China's policies towards political dissent. He has also suggested that the Chinese government was becoming suspicious of his activities, and that as a result, he fears for his safety if returned to China. Chen remains unapologetic over his defection, insisting that he betrayed the ], not China. | ||
| One factor contributing to the defection, according to Chen, is the torture and death of his father during the ], of which he has been quoted as saying: | One factor contributing to the defection, according to Chen, is the torture and death of his father during the ], of which he has been quoted as saying: | ||
| :"e was kidnapped on his way home by the village government and imprisoned in a narrow staircase. They did not give him anything to eat and beat him regularly. After two weeks, they beat him to death. My father’s death had a huge impact on my family. We lost support and stability. I was only three years old at that time and had two brothers and a sister. My mother brought us up by herself. You can imagine how hard our life was. |
:"e was kidnapped on his way home by the village government and imprisoned in a narrow staircase. They did not give him anything to eat and beat him regularly. After two weeks, they beat him to death. My father’s death had a huge impact on my family. We lost support and stability. I was only three years old at that time and had two brothers and a sister. My mother brought us up by herself. You can imagine how hard our life was. | ||
| ==Defection and allegations== | ==Defection and allegations== | ||
| In late May 2005 (there have been conflicting reports as to the exact day), Chen walked out of the consulate and went into hiding with his wife and six-year old daughter. On ] he reportedly met an officer from the ] who contacted the Chinese consulate to verify Chen's identity. A ] inquiry later criticized the government for this action, citing Chen's stated concern that such contact would put his life in danger. | In late May 2005 (there have been conflicting reports as to the exact day), Chen walked out of the consulate and went into hiding with his wife and six-year old daughter. On ] he reportedly met an officer from the ] who contacted the Chinese consulate to verify Chen's identity. A ] inquiry later criticized the government for this action, citing Chen's stated concern that such contact would put his life in danger. | ||
| On ] he met with a representative from the ]. Chen has stated that he was told at this meeting that his request for political asylum had been rejected, but that he could apply for a protection visa. The story broke to the international media on ], when Chen contacted '']'' newspaper, sparking fears of a serious diplomatic incident between the two nations. | On ] he met with a representative from the ]. Chen has stated that he was told at this meeting that his request for political asylum had been rejected, but that he could apply for a protection visa. The story broke to the international media on ], when Chen contacted '']'' newspaper, sparking fears of a serious diplomatic incident between the two nations. | ||
| On ], though he allegedly feared being kidnapped, Chen came out of hiding to address a rally commemorating the 16th anniversary of the |
On ], though he allegedly feared being kidnapped, Chen came out of hiding to address a rally commemorating the 16th anniversary of the bloody suppression of the Tiananmen Square protests. During his speech, he claimed that he would "reveal everything he knows" if he was allowed to remain in Australia. He also claimed that the Chinese government had more than a thousand agents in Australia, and that they were responsible for kidnapping Chinese dissidents and returning them to China. Furthermore, Chen claimed that in one particular case in early 2000, Chinese agents in Sydney had kidnapped a student to force his dissident father, ], to return to China. Later investigations concluded that Lan Fu had not been kidnapped. | ||
| After the June 4th rally, Chen once again went into hiding, having claimed that he was under constant surveillance and in fear of his life. |
After the June 4th rally, Chen once again went into hiding, having claimed that he was under constant surveillance and in fear of his life. | ||
| On ], the Chinese embassy released a statement claiming that Chen was due to return home and had invented allegations of wrongdoing in the hope that he would be allowed to stay. |
On ], the Chinese embassy released a statement claiming that Chen was due to return home and had invented allegations of wrongdoing in the hope that he would be allowed to stay. The statement was intended to alleviate fears for Chen's safety if he returned to China. | ||
| ==Support, opposition, and ultimate success== | ==Support, opposition, and ultimate success== | ||
| On ] Chen's claims of a thousand-strong spy network were supported by ], a former police officer with the ], a special security force established to eradicate ] by whatever means they deem necessary. The Chinese government responded by claiming that documents seized from Hao's home in China had shown that he was a low-level policeman suspected of corruption. Hao's lawyer, ], attacked the claims, however, arguing that they were "standard tactics." Hao was granted a protection visa by the Australian government in late July 2005. | On ] Chen's claims of a thousand-strong spy network were supported by ], a former police officer with the ], a special security force established to eradicate ] by whatever means they deem necessary. The Chinese government responded by claiming that documents seized from Hao's home in China had shown that he was a low-level policeman suspected of corruption. Hao's lawyer, ], attacked the claims, however, arguing that they were "standard tactics." Hao was granted a protection visa by the Australian government in late July 2005. | ||
| On ], a Chinese defector in ] using the name ] emerged to support Chen and Hao's spying allegations. During his interview on the ] show ], Han explained "I do know that the Chinese Communist Party sent people to collect intelligence information, including Chinese Embassy and Consulate staff. Some of the reporters coming from state Chinese media and visiting scholars are also given special spying tasks to carry out." The fifty-two-year-old defector has been denied political asylum and ruled ineligble to remain in Canada, because the federal Immigration and Refugee Board found him a "willing accomplice" in prior human rights abuses. This appears consistent with Han's claim that he was in charge of ]'s public security and labor camps before his defection. |
On ], a Chinese defector in ] using the name ] emerged to support Chen and Hao's spying allegations. During his interview on the ] show '']'', Han explained "I do know that the Chinese Communist Party sent people to collect intelligence information, including Chinese Embassy and Consulate staff. Some of the reporters coming from state Chinese media and visiting scholars are also given special spying tasks to carry out." The fifty-two-year-old defector has been denied political asylum and ruled ineligble to remain in Canada, because the federal Immigration and Refugee Board found him a "willing accomplice" in prior human rights abuses. This appears consistent with Han's claim that he was in charge of ]'s public security and ] before his defection. | ||
| China's ambassador in ], ], condemned Chen for "attacking his motherland" with "allegations and noise" for what she claimed was the sole purpose of living in a wealthier country. She warned that many more would follow Chen, if he was allowed to relocate to Australia. | |||
| On ] |
On ], Chen Yonglin, his wife, and his 6-year-old daughter were granted permanent protection visas by the Immigration Department, despite the opposition of the Chinese government. | ||
| ==Post-visa statements and activities== | ==Post-visa statements and activities== | ||
| Following the granting of protection visas to Chen and his family, he has met with Australian intelligence officials to discuss his earlier claims of a thousand-strong Chinese spy network. On July 21 Chen testified before the ] ] as part of a panel discussing "Falun Gong and China’s Continuing War on Human Rights." Here Chen broadened his earlier charges, stating: "I am aware there are over 1,000 Chinese secret agents and informants in Australia, and the number in the United States should not be less." He also testified that "The United States and Australia are considered by the CCP as the base of the Falun Gong overseas" and that "Chinese diplomats are required to denounce the Falun Gong and to distribute anti-Falun Gong materials whenever it is possible." | Following the granting of protection visas to Chen and his family, he has met with Australian intelligence officials to discuss his earlier claims of a thousand-strong Chinese spy network. On July 21 Chen testified before the ] ] as part of a panel discussing "Falun Gong and China’s Continuing War on Human Rights." Here Chen broadened his earlier charges, stating: "I am aware there are over 1,000 Chinese secret agents and informants in Australia, and the number in the United States should not be less." He also testified that "The United States and Australia are considered by the CCP as the base of the Falun Gong overseas" and that "Chinese diplomats are required to denounce the Falun Gong and to distribute anti-Falun Gong materials whenever it is possible." | ||
| On July 28, |
On July 28, '']'' published accusations made by Chen regarding China's build-up of a ] arsenal capable of a pre-emptive attack on the United States. | ||
| On July 31, Chen attended a meeting of the ] without invitation. There he defended and repeated his earlier spying allegations, and went on to claim that the VFCA was "controlled by the Chinese Consulate in Melbourne". The vice president of the federation, Sheng Wang, denied these claims and accused Chen of damaging the reputation of all Chinese Australians as well as undermining relations between China and Australia. | On July 31, Chen attended a meeting of the ] without invitation. There he defended and repeated his earlier spying allegations, and went on to claim that the VFCA was "controlled by the Chinese Consulate in Melbourne". The vice president of the federation, Sheng Wang, denied these claims and accused Chen of damaging the reputation of all Chinese Australians as well as undermining relations between China and Australia. | ||
| On August 5, Chen was invited to a seminar at the ]. There he answered media questions and criticism from Chinese students. Chen was accused of betraying China and |
On August 5, Chen was invited to a seminar at the ]. There he answered media questions and criticism from Chinese students. Chen was accused of betraying China and of stoking anti-Asian sentiment. | ||
| On August 16, Chen accused the Chinese government of sending a three-member assassination squad into Australia, claiming he was alerted to their presence by a close friend in the foreign ministry. Chen told ABC TV, "they want to shut me up and ... they want to send a warning example to others who want to defect." Foreign Minister ] called this "highly improbable." | On August 16, Chen accused the Chinese government of sending a three-member assassination squad into Australia, claiming he was alerted to their presence by a close friend in the foreign ministry. Chen told ABC TV, "they want to shut me up and ... they want to send a warning example to others who want to defect." Foreign Minister ] called this "highly improbable." | ||
| In late September, Chen contended that the man in charge of |
In late September, Chen contended that the man in charge of China's spy network continued to operate out of the consulate-general in Sydney. As reported by '']'', this individual works independently of the consulate, complete with his own budget. Chen did not name this alleged spymaster. | ||
| In October and November, Chen addressed |
In October and November, Chen addressed the ], the ] of ], and the ] on the issue of humans rights in China. The Chinese Mission at the European Parliament sent three diplomats and three official media reporters to hear Chen's testimony at the European Parliament. While Chen was addressing to the British All Party Parliamentary Group on Human Rights at the ], ] ] was visiting Westminster. ] ] was forced to raise the human rights issue with Hu under the pressure of overwhelming media attention. | ||
| On March 30, 2006, Chen joined ] and 4200 others in a signature campaign, asking ] ] to question ] ] regarding Shenyang Thrombosis Hospital. According to claims of a Chinese doctor now living in the United States, ] practioners haved been killed at this facility since 2001, with their organs harvested for sale. | On March 30, 2006, Chen joined ] and 4200 others in a signature campaign, asking ] ] to question ] ] regarding Shenyang Thrombosis Hospital. According to claims of a Chinese doctor now living in the United States, and as reported in such publications as '']'', ] practioners haved been killed at this facility since 2001, with their organs harvested for sale. Chinese officials deny the existence of any such practice. While doubts have been cast on the existence of this practice at the site in question, many remain concerned about reports of organ harvesting. | ||
| Chinese officials deny the existence of any such practice. The claim is however doubted by an US congressional researcher and the US State Department. | |||
| ==External links== | ==External links== | ||
| Line 50: | Line 49: | ||
| * | * | ||
| * | * | ||
| * |
* | ||
| * | |||
| * | * | ||
Revision as of 08:17, 4 June 2006
Chen Yonglin (Chinese Traditional: 陳用林, Simplified: 陈用林) is a former Chinese diplomat who sparked fears of a diplomatic incident through his defection to Australia in the summer of 2005. The episode highlighted the tensions faced by China's trade partners when concerns arise from that nation's human rights record. The episode was compared to the Petrov Affair by such observers as Shadow Minister for Immigration Laurie Ferguson and trade unionist Bill Shorten.
Background
Chen had been a university student in Beijing during the pro-democracy movement that ultimately led to the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. Several of his friends were wounded in the ensuing repression by the government. He was said to have underwent political reeducation after the subsequent crackdown on dissidents, and joined the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs in 1991. This culminated in his posting as the consul for political affairs in the Chinese consulate in Sydney, Australia. In this position, Chen has stated that he was responsible for monitoring Chinese political dissidents, especially Falun Gong, living in Australia. He also reportedly had access to highly classified information on Chinese intelligence activities in Australia. Chen has claimed that he had "gone easy" on dissidents and Falun Gong practitioners and had not reported some actions, to protest China's policies towards political dissent. He has also suggested that the Chinese government was becoming suspicious of his activities, and that as a result, he fears for his safety if returned to China. Chen remains unapologetic over his defection, insisting that he betrayed the Chinese Communist Party, not China.
One factor contributing to the defection, according to Chen, is the torture and death of his father during the Cultural Revolution, of which he has been quoted as saying:
- "e was kidnapped on his way home by the village government and imprisoned in a narrow staircase. They did not give him anything to eat and beat him regularly. After two weeks, they beat him to death. My father’s death had a huge impact on my family. We lost support and stability. I was only three years old at that time and had two brothers and a sister. My mother brought us up by herself. You can imagine how hard our life was.
Defection and allegations
In late May 2005 (there have been conflicting reports as to the exact day), Chen walked out of the consulate and went into hiding with his wife and six-year old daughter. On May 26 he reportedly met an officer from the Department of Immigration who contacted the Chinese consulate to verify Chen's identity. A Senate inquiry later criticized the government for this action, citing Chen's stated concern that such contact would put his life in danger.
On May 31 he met with a representative from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. Chen has stated that he was told at this meeting that his request for political asylum had been rejected, but that he could apply for a protection visa. The story broke to the international media on June 3, when Chen contacted The Australian newspaper, sparking fears of a serious diplomatic incident between the two nations.
On June 4, though he allegedly feared being kidnapped, Chen came out of hiding to address a rally commemorating the 16th anniversary of the bloody suppression of the Tiananmen Square protests. During his speech, he claimed that he would "reveal everything he knows" if he was allowed to remain in Australia. He also claimed that the Chinese government had more than a thousand agents in Australia, and that they were responsible for kidnapping Chinese dissidents and returning them to China. Furthermore, Chen claimed that in one particular case in early 2000, Chinese agents in Sydney had kidnapped a student to force his dissident father, Lan Meng, to return to China. Later investigations concluded that Lan Fu had not been kidnapped.
After the June 4th rally, Chen once again went into hiding, having claimed that he was under constant surveillance and in fear of his life.
On June 5, the Chinese embassy released a statement claiming that Chen was due to return home and had invented allegations of wrongdoing in the hope that he would be allowed to stay. The statement was intended to alleviate fears for Chen's safety if he returned to China.
Support, opposition, and ultimate success
On June 7 Chen's claims of a thousand-strong spy network were supported by Hao Fengjun, a former police officer with the 610 Office, a special security force established to eradicate Falun Gong by whatever means they deem necessary. The Chinese government responded by claiming that documents seized from Hao's home in China had shown that he was a low-level policeman suspected of corruption. Hao's lawyer, Bernard Collary, attacked the claims, however, arguing that they were "standard tactics." Hao was granted a protection visa by the Australian government in late July 2005.
On July 7, a Chinese defector in Canada using the name Han Guangsheng emerged to support Chen and Hao's spying allegations. During his interview on the ABC show Lateline, Han explained "I do know that the Chinese Communist Party sent people to collect intelligence information, including Chinese Embassy and Consulate staff. Some of the reporters coming from state Chinese media and visiting scholars are also given special spying tasks to carry out." The fifty-two-year-old defector has been denied political asylum and ruled ineligble to remain in Canada, because the federal Immigration and Refugee Board found him a "willing accomplice" in prior human rights abuses. This appears consistent with Han's claim that he was in charge of Shenyang's public security and labor camps before his defection.
China's ambassador in Canberra, Fu Ying, condemned Chen for "attacking his motherland" with "allegations and noise" for what she claimed was the sole purpose of living in a wealthier country. She warned that many more would follow Chen, if he was allowed to relocate to Australia.
On July 8, Chen Yonglin, his wife, and his 6-year-old daughter were granted permanent protection visas by the Immigration Department, despite the opposition of the Chinese government.
Post-visa statements and activities
Following the granting of protection visas to Chen and his family, he has met with Australian intelligence officials to discuss his earlier claims of a thousand-strong Chinese spy network. On July 21 Chen testified before the U.S. Congressional Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights and International Operations as part of a panel discussing "Falun Gong and China’s Continuing War on Human Rights." Here Chen broadened his earlier charges, stating: "I am aware there are over 1,000 Chinese secret agents and informants in Australia, and the number in the United States should not be less." He also testified that "The United States and Australia are considered by the CCP as the base of the Falun Gong overseas" and that "Chinese diplomats are required to denounce the Falun Gong and to distribute anti-Falun Gong materials whenever it is possible."
On July 28, The Washington Times published accusations made by Chen regarding China's build-up of a nuclear arsenal capable of a pre-emptive attack on the United States.
On July 31, Chen attended a meeting of the Victorian Federation of Chinese Associations without invitation. There he defended and repeated his earlier spying allegations, and went on to claim that the VFCA was "controlled by the Chinese Consulate in Melbourne". The vice president of the federation, Sheng Wang, denied these claims and accused Chen of damaging the reputation of all Chinese Australians as well as undermining relations between China and Australia.
On August 5, Chen was invited to a seminar at the University of Melbourne. There he answered media questions and criticism from Chinese students. Chen was accused of betraying China and of stoking anti-Asian sentiment.
On August 16, Chen accused the Chinese government of sending a three-member assassination squad into Australia, claiming he was alerted to their presence by a close friend in the foreign ministry. Chen told ABC TV, "they want to shut me up and ... they want to send a warning example to others who want to defect." Foreign Minister Alexander Downer called this "highly improbable."
In late September, Chen contended that the man in charge of China's spy network continued to operate out of the consulate-general in Sydney. As reported by The Bulletin, this individual works independently of the consulate, complete with his own budget. Chen did not name this alleged spymaster.
In October and November, Chen addressed the European Parliament, the Flemish Parliament of Belgium, and the British Parliament on the issue of humans rights in China. The Chinese Mission at the European Parliament sent three diplomats and three official media reporters to hear Chen's testimony at the European Parliament. While Chen was addressing to the British All Party Parliamentary Group on Human Rights at the Palace of Westminster, President Hu Jintao was visiting Westminster. Prime Minister Tony Blair was forced to raise the human rights issue with Hu under the pressure of overwhelming media attention.
On March 30, 2006, Chen joined Hao Fengjun and 4200 others in a signature campaign, asking Australian Prime Minister John Howard to question Premier Wen Jiabao regarding Shenyang Thrombosis Hospital. According to claims of a Chinese doctor now living in the United States, and as reported in such publications as The Epoch Times, Falun Gong practioners haved been killed at this facility since 2001, with their organs harvested for sale. Chinese officials deny the existence of any such practice. While doubts have been cast on the existence of this practice at the site in question, many remain concerned about reports of organ harvesting.
External links
- Pictures of Chen Yonglin's defection
- Chen participating at refugee rally
- 'Secret documents exchanged' for asylum, Sydney Morning Herald, June 8, 2005
- Hao Fengjun's claims
- Chinese claims of Hao's corruption
- Additional testimony before the U.S. Congress (.pdf format)