| Revision as of 21:25, 3 December 2006 editCentrx (talk | contribs)37,287 editsm →Request comment on policy and conventions: remove emphasis← Previous edit | Revision as of 23:26, 5 December 2006 edit undoCentrx (talk | contribs)37,287 edits →Responding to RfCs: Apparently there was some uncertainty about thisNext edit → | ||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
| ==Responding to RfCs== | ==Responding to RfCs== | ||
| All editors are welcome to provide comment to assist in reaching agreements or to provide their opinions. Remember that Misplaced Pages is an encyclopedia; all articles and policies must follow ], ], and ]. This is not a vote. | All editors are welcome to provide comment to assist in reaching agreements or to provide their opinions by responding to requests for comment on an article discussion page. Remember that Misplaced Pages is an encyclopedia; all articles and policies must follow ], ], and ]. This is not a vote. | ||
| * Try not to be confrontational. Be friendly and ], and ] in other editors' actions. | * Try not to be confrontational. Be friendly and ], and ] in other editors' actions. | ||
Revision as of 23:26, 5 December 2006
| Dispute resolution (Requests) |
|---|
| Tips |
| Content disputes |
| Conduct disputes |
- ]
Requests for comment (RfC) are the open part of the dispute resolution process, by which editors can seek broad input regarding disputes over article content, user conduct, and Misplaced Pages policy and guidelines.
All editors are welcome to help resolve disputes by responding to RfCs. It will help the RfC process if everyone who lists an RfC tries to help out at least one other page listed.
| Policies and guidelines (list) |
|---|
| Principles |
| Content policies |
| Conduct policies |
| Other policy categories |
| Directories |
Responding to RfCs
All editors are welcome to provide comment to assist in reaching agreements or to provide their opinions by responding to requests for comment on an article discussion page. Remember that Misplaced Pages is an encyclopedia; all articles and policies must follow Neutral point of view, Verifiability, and No original research. This is not a vote.
- Try not to be confrontational. Be friendly and civil, and assume good faith in other editors' actions.
- Mediate where possible - identify common ground, attempt to draw editors together rather than push them apart.
- If necessary, educate users by referring to the appropriate Misplaced Pages policies.
- On user conduct RfCs, do not create "disendorsement" sections on RfCs. If you disagree with something someone else has said, you may add your own separate statement explaining why you disagree. Do not create a "Users who do not agree with this summary" section, or the equivalent. This tends to be a confrontational act that is not productive.
To comment, jump to section for RfCs on articles, users, or policies and conventions.
Request comment on articles
An RfC on article content is for helping to develop consensus or for gaining an outside perspective to help settle a deadlocked disagreement or make a better decision. Note that all Misplaced Pages articles must be written from a neutral point of view and must include only verifiable information, and no original research.
Before adding an entry here:
- Do not post an RfC before working towards a resolution with other article contributors first. Whatever the disagreement, the first step in resolving a dispute is to talk to the other parties involved. Be civil, and assume good faith in other editors' actions.
- Consider getting a third opinion on a controversy that involves only two editors.
- If you want general help in improving an article, such as to Featured status, then list it at Peer review. Note that peer review is not for content disputes.
- Consider consulting the relevant WikiProject, especially for expert subjects like at WikiProject Mathematics. For disputes over implementing Misplaced Pages policy, consider consulting the relevant policy, guideline, or style page.
Instructions
- Create a section for the RfC on the bottom of the article talk page with a brief, neutral statement of the issue. Example
- In the relevant topic area, listed below, link to that section on the Talk page.
- Sign entries with the date only. Use five tildes: ~~~~~.
- After all parties agree the issue has been resolved, strike it from the listing.
All issues related to a topic area, even if about the article title or inclusion of images, go in the section for that topic area. If an issue is miscategorized, please move it to the appropriate section. If you are not certain in which area an issue belongs, you can put it in two places if you want, but do not post the same issue more than twice. For requesting comment on style issues, consider posting at Misplaced Pages:Requests for comment/Style issues. Discussions will be removed after one month, or if they have no recent comments. If a dispute is active, you may repost.
| Issues by topic area | ||
|---|---|---|
| Further instructions are on the topic pages | ||
| Biographies | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Economy and trade | (watch) | (add entry) |
| History and geography | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Language and linguistics | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Maths, science, and technology | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Media, art and literature | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Politics | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Religion and philosophy | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Society, law, and sex | (watch) | (add entry) |
Request comment on users
To report an offensive or confusing user name in violation of Misplaced Pages username policy, see subpage User names.
To report spam, page blanking, and other blatant vandalism, see Misplaced Pages:Vandalism.
A user-conduct RfC is for discussing specific users who have violated Misplaced Pages policies and guidelines. Carefully read the following before filing an RfC.
- Before requesting community comment, at least two editors must have contacted the user on their talk page, or the talk pages involved in the dispute, and tried but failed to resolve the problem. Any RfC not accompanied by evidence showing that two users tried and failed to resolve the same dispute may be deleted after 48 hours. The evidence, preferably in the form of diffs, should not simply show the dispute itself, but should show attempts to find a resolution or compromise. The users certifying the dispute must be the same users who were involved in the attempt to resolve it.
- RfCs brought solely to harass or subdue an adversary are not permitted. Repetitive, burdensome, or unwarranted filing of meritless RfCs is an abuse of the dispute resolution process. RfC is not a venue for personal attack.
- An RfC may bring close scrutiny on all involved editors, and can lead to binding arbitration. Filing an RfC is therefore not a step to be taken lightly or in haste.
- Disputes over the writing of articles, including disputes over how best to follow the neutral point of view policy, belong in an Article RfC.
- For a mild-to-moderate conflict, you might try Misplaced Pages:Wikiquette alerts, a quick, simple way to get an outside view.
| User-related issues | ||
|---|---|---|
| Further instructions are on each page | ||
| User conduct | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Offensive or confusing user names | (watch) | (add entry) |
Request comment on policy and conventions
A policy or guideline RfC is for requesting comment on proposed policies and guidelines or proposed revisions to existing policies and guidelines. A style RfC is for requesting comment on style issues in articles, or for proposals on new or revised recommendations in the Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style. Policy and proposals are also listed at Misplaced Pages:Centralized discussion and are also discussed at Misplaced Pages:Village pump (policy) and Misplaced Pages:Village pump (proposals).
With such proposals, remember the Five pillars that fundamentally define Misplaced Pages's character. Remember the three content policies whose principles are absolute and non-negotiable: Neutral point of view, Verifiability, and No original research. Also, remember What Misplaced Pages is not.
There is also a list of current Misplaced Pages proposals at Category:Misplaced Pages proposals.
| General policy and convention issues | ||
|---|---|---|
| Further instructions are on each page | ||
| Misplaced Pages style, referencing, layout and WikiProjects | (watch) | (add entry) |
| Misplaced Pages policies, guidelines and proposals | (watch) | (add entry) |
See also
- Archives of user conduct disputes
- Special:Prefixindex/Wikipedia:Requests for comment, lists subpages of this page