Misplaced Pages

Derek Smart: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 22:15, 12 December 2006 view sourceKerr avon (talk | contribs)1,186 edits Mael-num - please take your view to the talk page. Also do not delete cited content such as the Take2 lawsuit. Stop deleting without a consensus.← Previous edit Revision as of 22:44, 12 December 2006 view source Mael-Num (talk | contribs)944 edits Hiding Sections up for discussion until consensus can be reached. Any attempts to revert this information beyond this point will be regarded as WP:Vandalism.Next edit →
Line 14: Line 14:


The initial release of the game was "a train wreck", according to a reviewer who later commented that "Smart consistently overrates his own products and his own abilities."<ref name=Gamespy25Dumbest/> The initial release of the game was "a train wreck", according to a reviewer who later commented that "Smart consistently overrates his own products and his own abilities."<ref name=Gamespy25Dumbest/>
<!-- This section hidden because there is a debate going on as to the relevance of this information, and the quality of the source

During one particularly heated exchange with Take2 subsequent to the release of the game, Smart was alleged to have started tearing up the Take 2 office, attacking a ] machine in the lobby. This is denied by Smart <ref>{{cite web During one particularly heated exchange with Take2 subsequent to the release of the game, Smart was alleged to have started tearing up the Take 2 office, attacking a ] machine in the lobby. This is denied by Smart <ref>{{cite web
| url = http://archive.gamespy.com/articles/june03/dumbestmoments/readers/index2.shtml | url = http://archive.gamespy.com/articles/june03/dumbestmoments/readers/index2.shtml
Line 20: Line 22:
| publisher = GameSpy | publisher = GameSpy
}}</ref> and at least one Take2 employee <ref name="Troublemaker" />. }}</ref> and at least one Take2 employee <ref name="Troublemaker" />.
End hidden section -->

The early release would lead to a lawsuit filed by Smart, alleging breach of contract on the part of Take-Two.<ref name=Loonygames/> The lawsuit would later be settled out of court. In late 1998, both parties released statements of resolution.<ref name="GamespotLawsuitFinal>{{cite web|url=http://www.gamespot.com/news/1998/12/23/news_2465926.html|title=Smart, Take-Two Settle differences - News at GameSpot|accessdate=2006-10-21}}</ref> Take-Two became a ] and in its SEC filings on February 10th, 1997 stated that ''Battlecruiser 3000AD'' accounted for 14.2% of revenue for the fiscal year ending October 31, 1996.<ref name=Take2SECFiling /> Also in the filing Take-Two Interactive stated they "made advances in the aggregate amount of approximately $618,000" to Smart's company, 3000AD<ref name=Take2SECFiling />. The early release would lead to a lawsuit filed by Smart, alleging breach of contract on the part of Take-Two.<ref name=Loonygames/> The lawsuit would later be settled out of court. In late 1998, both parties released statements of resolution.<ref name="GamespotLawsuitFinal>{{cite web|url=http://www.gamespot.com/news/1998/12/23/news_2465926.html|title=Smart, Take-Two Settle differences - News at GameSpot|accessdate=2006-10-21}}</ref> Take-Two became a ] and in its SEC filings on February 10th, 1997 stated that ''Battlecruiser 3000AD'' accounted for 14.2% of revenue for the fiscal year ending October 31, 1996.<ref name=Take2SECFiling /> Also in the filing Take-Two Interactive stated they "made advances in the aggregate amount of approximately $618,000" to Smart's company, 3000AD<ref name=Take2SECFiling />.
Line 64: Line 66:
In December 2006, Smart announced ] a new franchise based on his IP. He also announced a collectors edition consisting of his Battlecruiser and Universal Combat games. <ref name=GALCOM>{{cite web | url=http://www.firingsquad.com/news/newsarticle.asp?searchid=13419|title=Galactic Command (PC/XB360)|accessdate=2006-12-04}}</ref> In December 2006, Smart announced ] a new franchise based on his IP. He also announced a collectors edition consisting of his Battlecruiser and Universal Combat games. <ref name=GALCOM>{{cite web | url=http://www.firingsquad.com/news/newsarticle.asp?searchid=13419|title=Galactic Command (PC/XB360)|accessdate=2006-12-04}}</ref>


<!-- This section hidden because there is a debate going on as to the relevance of this information, and the quality of the source
Ben Kuchera from the prominent technology related website ] was critical of Smart's intention to create games for the console, commenting "Derek Smart has a long reputation of releasing buggy, unfinished games and then screaming at anyone who calls them things like 'buggy' and 'unfinished.'"<ref> Ben Kuchera from the prominent technology related website ] was critical of Smart's intention to create games for the console, commenting "Derek Smart has a long reputation of releasing buggy, unfinished games and then screaming at anyone who calls them things like 'buggy' and 'unfinished.'"<ref>
{{cite web {{cite web
Line 73: Line 76:
| date = ] | date = ]
}}</ref> }}</ref>
End hidden section -->

==Online controversy== ==Online controversy==
Derek Smart has become known among the gaming community not only for having engaged in various controversial and lengthy discussions on ]<!-- citation removed per ] As Usenet posts are not "a reliable source". Will be replaced upon approval of ], Misplaced Pages's upcoming attribution policy. <ref name=GoogleGroupsDSmart> {{cite web Derek Smart has become known among the gaming community not only for having engaged in various controversial and lengthy discussions on ]<!-- citation removed per ] As Usenet posts are not "a reliable source". Will be replaced upon approval of ], Misplaced Pages's upcoming attribution policy. <ref name=GoogleGroupsDSmart> {{cite web

Revision as of 22:44, 12 December 2006

Page semi-protectedEditing of this article by new or unregistered users is currently disabled until December 9, 2027 at 22:36 UTC.
See the protection policy and protection log for more details. If you cannot edit this article and you wish to make a change, you can submit an edit request, discuss changes on the talk page, request unprotection, log in, or create an account.
This article or section recently underwent a major revision or rewrite and may need further review. You can help Misplaced Pages by assisting in the revision. If this article or section has not been edited in several days, please remove this template.
This article was last edited by Mael-Num (talk | contribs) 18 years ago. (Update timer)

Derek Smart is a noted video game designer and is currently the president and lead developer of 3000AD, Inc., a video game developer based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. He is known for creating the Battlecruiser 3000AD and Universal Combat video game series, personally involving himself in controversial discussions about himself and his games, and being an independent video game software developer. Smart is also a boardmember of the Miami chapter of the IGDA..

Game development

Battlecruiser 3000AD

Smart began his independent games development in the late eighties with the vision of creating an all-encompassing space simulation game featuring strategy elements along with space, planetary, air and ground combat. His first game, Battlecruiser 3000AD, was covered through its development process by gaming magazines such as Strategy Plus. It was marketed as "The last thing you'll ever desire" in pre-release ads in computer gaming magazines. As the game's development continued, it went through multiple publishers, with the rights eventually being bought by Take-Two Interactive. They later released the game in what could be described as an unfinished state in October of 1996. The game as it was released contained many bugs that made it unstable.

The initial release of the game was "a train wreck", according to a reviewer who later commented that "Smart consistently overrates his own products and his own abilities." The early release would lead to a lawsuit filed by Smart, alleging breach of contract on the part of Take-Two. The lawsuit would later be settled out of court. In late 1998, both parties released statements of resolution. Take-Two became a publicly traded company and in its SEC filings on February 10th, 1997 stated that Battlecruiser 3000AD accounted for 14.2% of revenue for the fiscal year ending October 31, 1996. Also in the filing Take-Two Interactive stated they "made advances in the aggregate amount of approximately $618,000" to Smart's company, 3000AD.

Smart issued several patches and upgrades for the product over the next few months and, eventually, a final patch was released to fix some of the major bugs. In February of 1998, after securing publishing rights back from Take-Two, Smart released the game for download from the internet free of charge.

Development of the game continued throughout 1998 towards version 2.0, and Interplay was announced as the publisher for an improved version (dubbed Battlecruiser 3000AD v2.0) through its Value Product Division. After its retail run, Smart also released that product on the Internet for free.

Battlecruiser Millennium

From 1998 to 2001, Smart developed his next game in the Battlecruiser franchise, Battlecruiser Millennium. The game was to be exclusively distributed at Electronics Boutique locations and was self-published by his company 3000AD, Inc. The deal made with EB was a first of its kind merchant exclusivity deal for a game's release, with an independent developer paying for all materials to publish the game for distribution through the retailer. When asked by the gaming media about his thoughts on the deal, Smart stated "I'm paying for everything. I bear all the risk. I pay for the cost of goods, including the boxes and manuals."

The game was released on November 19th of 2001 and received 65% and 68% at aggregate review sites Game Rankings and Metacritic respectively. According to some reviews of the game, it was as encompassing and strategically pleasing as the developer had set out to make, but lacked in user interface design friendliness and atmosphere.

After its retail run Smart released Battlecruiser Millennium on the Internet for free as he had done with his previous titles. He has mentioned that he intends to keep up this practice of releasing his products for free once their "shelf life" has expired.

Like Battlecruiser 3000AD, Battlecruiser Millennium was also followed by an updated release titled Battlecruiser Millennium Gold.

Universal Combat

Development had started in 2002 on the new game in the Battlecruiser franchise under the name Battlecruiser Generations. As part of its design, the upcoming game would make use of newer technology. With the new publisher on board offering more oversight, discussions between Smart and the Dreamcatcher Games resulted in a change of direction towards more action-based game play than the Battlecruiser series had previously been known for. The changes warranted a new title, and the name was changed to Universal Combat.

Although expected to be, Universal Combat was not ready in time for the 2003 holidays. It was shipped in early 2004 by the publisher, Dreamcatcher Games, at half of the originally announced price. Much like the situation which happened between Smart and Take-Two Interactive, Smart pursued legal action against his publisher. A cease and desist letter was issued on behalf of 3000AD to Dreamcatcher alleging, among other things, that the price reduction was "clearly calculated to inflict economic harm on 3000AD". In the hearing, Dreamcatcher Games claimed that the game's quality did not justify a midrange price, citing the graphics as a example of the overall quality of the game. A hearing was held to determine if Dreamcatcher would be prevented from shipping the title at the reduced price. The presiding judge denied the injunction stating that 3000AD "made bold but unsupported assertions regarding the irreparable harm to it", allowing Dreamcatcher Games to ship the game and 3000AD to proceed with their lawsuit. The matter was later settled out of court under undisclosed terms.

The game was reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazines. Gamespot, in its 59% review score, summarized its experience with the game by saying "This wildly ambitious simulation is torpedoed by an almost incomprehensible interface, the absence of a tutorial, numerous bugs, and many fit and finish issues, including dated production values." PC Gamer, in its 75% review said of its experience with the game, "...for the latter niche of hardcore space-simmers, Derek Smart's Battlecruiser series has been going strong for eight solid years. Over that time, the idiosyncratic space-combat franchise has transformed itself from a bug-ridden lemon to a respected genre contender. Universal Combat is the latest chapter in this recently rebranded series (with new publisher Dreamcatcher), and though the game remains an acquired taste, it's better than ever."

After terminating a publishing deal with Dreamcatcher Games., Smart released an updated release titled Universal Combat Gold. Starting with this release, Smart has made a policy of releasing games through online resellers.

In 2005 Turner Broadcasting licensed both Battlecruiser Millennium and Universal Combat Gold for their games on demand system, GameTap. In 2005, Smart also released Universal Combat: A World Apart, a full sequel to the original Universal Combat with a variety of revisions and enhancements. Game Rankings and Metacritic have given aggregate review scores of 54% and 48%, respectively, for the game.

In October 2006 Smart released Universal Combat: Special Edition.

Current projects

Template:Future game

On 25 January, 2006, 3000AD announced two upcoming projects for the XBox 360, Hostile Intent - Planetfall and KnightBlade - Line Of Defense. Both titles have a projected release in Q1 of 2008.

In December 2006, Smart announced Galactic Command a new franchise based on his IP. He also announced a collectors edition consisting of his Battlecruiser and Universal Combat games.

Online controversy

Derek Smart has become known among the gaming community not only for having engaged in various controversial and lengthy discussions on Usenet and game forums, but also for his writing style when responding to his critics, which may be perceived as dismissive or condescending. His notoriety for this was such that GameSpy lampooned Smart's online social interactions in its Daily Victim column.

In an interview which was featured on the cover page of Computer Gaming World, Smart said of his online persona: "Sometimes when I get online, and it's quiet, and I see something that attracts my attention, I'll post just to piss these guys off. That's why I do it. Because I'm in a good mood that day, I go in there and I start trouble."

Freespace licensing

Smart was reported to be seeking to license the Freespace IP to develop a game based on the popular space-sim previously published by Interplay. This sparked a controversy between Smart and his critics. The rumor was debunked by Yahoo video game news: "Following Bethesda Softworks' acquisition of the Fallout license earlier this week, word spread that cash-strapped publisher Interplay is having a franchise fire sale. The rumors of Smart's involvement started when he posed the question, "Would you buy Freespace 3 if I made it?" on the Adrenaline Vault forums. In the next paragraph, though, Smart clarified his supposition stating that he was only "seriously considering" licensing the Freespace engine. However, the very possibility of Smart taking over the series has generated a strong reaction, prompting him to post a typically verbose response to his critics." The controversy was further discussed in a Slashdot article.


Published games

Title Released Publisher
Battlecruiser 3000AD (U.S.) 1996 Take-Two Software
Battlecruiser 3000AD (UK) 1997 GameTek
Battlecruiser 3000AD v2.0 1999 Interplay
Battlecruiser Millennium 2001 3000AD
Battlecruiser Millennium Gold 2003 Dreamcatcher Games
Universal Combat 2004 Dreamcatcher Games
Universal Combat Gold 2005 3000AD
Universal Combat: A World Apart 2005 3000AD
Universal Combat: Special Edition 2006 3000AD

References

  1. ^ "GameSpy.com - Daily Victim: A tribute to online gaming dementia". Retrieved 2006-12-05. Cite error: The named reference "victim" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
  2. "IGDA Miami - Chapter Meeting: June 2002". Retrieved 2006-11-28.
  3. ^ "loonygames' Guest Editorial: Derek Smart". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  4. ^ "Take2 SEC 1998 10KSB Filing". Retrieved 1998-02-06. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |accessdate= (help)
  5. "Get in the Game: Battlecruiser Millennium". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  6. "Battlecruiser 3000 A.D. for PC Review - PC Battlecruiser 3000 A.D. Review". Retrieved 2006-10-20.
  7. ^ "GameSpy.com - Article: The 25 Dumbest Moments in Gaming". Retrieved 2006-10-20.
  8. "Smart, Take-Two Settle differences - News at GameSpot". Retrieved 2006-10-21.
  9. "Battlecruiser 3000 A.D. Set Free - News at GameSpot". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  10. "Press Release: Interplay Value Products Division to distribute Battlecruiser 3000AD v2.0". Interplay. August 5, 1998.
  11. ^ "Battlecruiser series". Retrieved 2006-10-21.
  12. "IGN: EB Signs Pact with Derek Smart". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  13. "GameSpy.com - GameSpin: Volume 2 -- Battlecruiser Millennium, Tropico and Anarchy Online". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  14. "Battlecruiser Millennium Reviews". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  15. "Battlecruiser Millennium (pc: 2001): Reviews". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  16. "Battlecruiser Millennium - It's much improved over the previous release but it still asks for too much from the player". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  17. "AusGamers.com - Australia's Games Community: Battlecruiser Millenium Now Freeware". Retrieved 2006-10-21.
  18. "UC Version Control". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  19. "Battlecruiser Generations rechristened - PC News at GameSpot". Retrieved 2006-12-05.
  20. "3000AD Issues Cease & Desist Letter to Dreamcatcher" (PDF). Retrieved 2004-02-04.
  21. "3000AD Final Factum Filed Against Dreamcatcher" (PDF). Retrieved 2004. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |accessdate= (help)
  22. "Canadian Judge Rules On 3000AD Injunction Against Dreamcatcher". Retrieved 2004. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |accessdate= (help)
  23. "Universal Combat ships despite lawsuit". Retrieved 2004-02-05.
  24. "DreamCatcher to publish another 3000AD title". Retrieved 2005-01-13.
  25. "Universal Combat Reviews". Retrieved 2006-10-20.
  26. "Universal Combat for PC Review - PC Universal Combat Review". Retrieved 2006-10-20.
  27. "PC Gamer review of Universal Combat" (PDF). Retrieved 2006-10-20.
  28. "3000AD announces trio of new titles, breaks ties with publisher - PC News at GameSpot". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  29. "BATTLECRUISER Online - Sales and Order Information". Retrieved 2006-10-20.
  30. "Turner licenses 3000AD titles for GameTap". Retrieved 2005-08-05.
  31. "UCAWA Dev Version Control". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  32. "Universal Combat: A World Apart (pc: 2005): Reviews". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  33. GameRankings.com aggregate review of Universal Combat: A World Apart
  34. "3000 A.D. Completely Sells Out to Xbox 360". TeamXbox. 2006-01-25. Retrieved 2006-12-01.
  35. "Hostile Intent - Planetfall (X360)". GameSpy. Retrieved 2006-12-01.
  36. "KnightBlade -- Line Of Defense (X360)". GameSpy. Retrieved 2006-12-01.
  37. "Galactic Command (PC/XB360)". Retrieved 2006-12-04.
  38. "Computer Gaming World Interview". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  39. ^ "Rumor Control: $179 DS in November and $29.99 GameCube games - PC News at GameSpot". Retrieved 2006-12-06.
  40. "Slashdot - Derek Smart Lusting Rights to Freespace?". Retrieved 2006-12-06.

External links

Categories: