Misplaced Pages

Latest revision as of 14:29, 24 December 2024

Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine (SEGM)

Abbreviation	SEGM
Established	2019; 5 years ago (2019)
Type	Nonprofit
Affiliations	Genspect
Website	segm.org

The Society For Evidence-Based Gender Medicine (SEGM) is a non-profit organization that is known for its opposition to gender-affirming care for transgender youth and for engaging in political lobbying. The group routinely cites the unproven concept of rapid-onset gender dysphoria and mistakenly claimed that conversion therapy techniques are only practiced on the basis of sexual orientation rather than gender identity. SEGM is often cited in anti-transgender legislation and court cases, sometimes filing court briefs.

Researchers at the Yale School of Medicine issued a report which described SEGM as a small group of anti-trans activists and not "a recognized scientific organization". A spokesperson for the Endocrine Society described them as outside the medical mainstream. A paper published in March 2024 described them as a "fringe medical organization".

SEGM is closely affiliated with Genspect. Seven advisors to SEGM are on Genspect's team of advisors, including Stella O'Malley, Genspect's founder. The Southern Poverty Law Center has designated SEGM and Genspect as anti-LGBTQ+ hate groups since 2023 and described SEGM as "a hub of pseudoscience".

Activities

The Society for Evidence-based Gender Medicine (SEGM) was founded in 2019 as an international group of clinicians and researchers. Its co-founders include William Malone, an American endocrinologist; Julia Mason, an American pediatrician; and Zhenya Abbruzzese, an American healthcare researcher. Psychiatrist Stephen B. Levine, who has testified in nearly every case on gender-affirming care in the United States and argues transgender people are pathologically narcissistic, is an advisor. SEGM, among other affiliated groups, was formed through connections in the "Pediatric and Adolescent Gender Dysphoria Working Group", a group of 17 academics and researchers including Kenneth Zucker, Ray Blanchard, and J. Michael Bailey. Several SEGM members collaborated with the CAMH Gender Identity Clinic which was directed by Zucker.

SEGM advocates and funds systematic reviews and literature reviews, organizes academic events, and occasionally submits positions to courts and lawmakers.

SEGM made a submission in defense of the state of Arizona's ban on Medicaid coverage for transgender healthcare. Lambda Legal and Cooley LLP filed an amicus brief opposing the ban on behalf of LGBT advocacy organizations such as PFLAG. The Pediatric Endocrine Society and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health also filed amicus briefs opposing the ban. SEGM members also contributed expert defense testimony to Florida's ban on medicaid for transgender healthcare.

In March 2022, Julia Mason, a board member of SEGM who also works with Genspect, proposed Resolution 27 along with four other members of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), stating the AAP should reconsider hormone therapy as a first line of treatment and called for an evidence review to update AAP's 2018 policy statement on gender affirmative care. The AAP said that the resolution mischaracterized its policy, which instead promotes "following a systematic, collaborative evaluation by clinicians and mental health professionals". The resolution was not passed. After the resolution's proposers said that the AAP changed procedures to block discussion of the resolution, the AAP said that their processes worked normally and that Resolution 27 did not pass because it received no co-sponsorship and the majority of AAP members did not agree with the resolution. The AAP stated the guidelines were already under review as part of a routine procedure and that "there is strong consensus among the most prominent medical organizations worldwide that evidence-based, gender-affirming care for transgender children and adolescents is medically necessary and appropriate".

In April, the Florida Department of Health wrote a memo which misrepresented the scientific consensus to stop minors in the state from socially or medically transitioning and cited Malone. The same month, SEGM met with White House officials in the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs to argue that a rule on "nondiscrimination in health programs and activities" from the Department of Health and Human Services' Office for Civil Rights would "effectively force physicians to provide hormonal and surgical interventions".

In September 2023, SEGM members and advisors filed a petition with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration calling for them to end prescriptions of puberty blockers to transgender youth. SEGM claims to have over 100 members but removed their membership list and organizational structure from the site in late 2023.

Conversion therapy

The Trans Safety Network stated "SEGM's public members include ... outspoken critics of regulation against conversion therapy on transgender people." The SPLC has stated SEGM is part of a network of groups which "support conversion therapy for transgender people and banning medical transition, beginning with people under age 25"

SEGM called for amending a criminal code outlawing conversion therapy in Canada, based on the mistaken claim that conversion therapy can only be applied to lesbian, gay, and bisexual people, a position not supported by any major medical organization.

Positions

SEGM has indicated its belief that exploratory psychotherapy should be a first-line treatment for those age 25 and under. Malone has opposed the informed consent model for transgender healthcare, where adults older than 18 can start hormones after signing an informed consent document without requiring an evaluation by a mental health professional. He told Medscape that "cognitive maturity doesn’t occur until the age of 25".

SEGM has advanced the controversial idea of rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD), which suggests a subtype of gender dysphoria caused by peer influence and social contagion. ROGD has been described as lacking evidence or sound empirical studies by the majority of major psychological bodies in the USA.

Citations in anti-trans legislation

Proponents of gender-affirming care bans often cite letters to the editors of scientific journals from leaders and members of SEGM Multiple letters were co-authored by SEGMs board secretary since inception, William J Malone, and members of the American College of Pediatricians such as Quentin Van Meter, Paul Hruz, and Michael Laidlaw. Yale University's Integrity Project estimated that 75% of SEGM's publications are letters to the editor and comments, as opposed to peer reviewed scientific articles.

In March 2020, SEGM was cited in an Idaho bill barring transgender people from changing their sex on their birth certificate. A SEGM spokesperson said they never expressed support for the bill. The legislation stated SEGM "has declared that the conflation of sex and gender in health care is alarming, subjects hundreds of thousands of individuals to the risk of unintended medical harm, and will greatly impede medical research" without providing evidence for the claims. The ACLU condemned the state for their actions. Malone also testified to the legislature in favor of a bill that would make it a felony to prescribe hormone blockers to people under 18 or refer them to gender-reassignment surgery.

In Texas, reports from SEGM were used to justify the Governor's directive that the state department of family and protective services investigate the parents of all children accessing gender-affirming care and treat the cases as child abuse.

Affiliations

A report by the Southern Poverty Law Center described SEGM as a hub of the "anti-LGBT pseudoscience network", and specified that the relationship was strongest between SEGM, Genspect, and the Gender Exploratory Therapy Association (GETA), who shared over 24 personnel connections. The report also stated SEGM members are affiliated with the "anti-LGBTQ+ far right". SEGM is closely affiliated with the non-profit organization Genspect: Julia Mason, Marcus Evans, Roberto D’Angelo, Sasha Ayad, Stella O'Malley, Lisa Marchiano, and Avi Ring are advisors for SEGM and are on Genspect's team or advisors; O'Malley is the founder of Genspect. GETA is a group of therapists founded in 2021 by four SEGM members and a Genspect advisor to market, gender exploratory therapy, which experts believe is transgender conversion therapy.

Marchiano and O'Malley are on the board of Lisa Littman's Institute for Comprehensive Gender Dysphoria Research (ICGDR). SEGM members O'Malley and Robert P. George are also advisors to the Foundation Against Intolerance and Racism.

A report by seven people in various departments of the Yale School of Medicine stated that the 14 core members of SEGM regularly worked together on the boards of other organizations that oppose gender-affirming healthcare and "feature biased and unscientific content."

South Dakota House Bill 1057, which was launched in 2020 to prohibit gender-affirming care for transgender youth, relied on a document created and distributed within a secret working group including multiple members of the American College of Pediatricians (ACPeds), representatives from other conservative groups, and founders of SEGM. SEGM members have repeatedly co-authored papers and letters to the editor with members of ACPeds. SEGM director Julia Mason tweeted that SEGM would not work with members of ACPeds and denied knowing ACPeds member Paul Hruz despite co-authoring papers and co-hosting symposia with him. ACPeds has explicitly promoted the work of SEGM; Quentin Van Meter encouraged audience members to work with SEGM at a conference held by “ex-gay” ministry First Stone Ministries.

Reception

In August 2021, Trans Safety Network described SEGM as "an anti-trans psychiatric and sociological think tank" and fringe group and reported that most of SEGM's funding in 2019 came in donations greater than $10,000. In 2020, SEGM received a $100,000 donation from the Edward Charles Foundation, and in 2021 SEGM's annual revenue grew to nearly $800,000, the largest of which was a $350,000 donation from Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund.

In August 2022, Vice News characterized William Malone as an "anti-trans activist" and stated that SEGM use the same tactics and citations as a Florida Department of Health memo, which claimed to provide a scientific basis for banning gender-affirming care and had been criticized by USPATH, a regional chapter of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. Vice reached out to authors cited in the memo, who said it took their research out of context as the research, and later research, supported gender-affirming care.

In 2023, US lawyer and transgender rights activist Alejandra Caraballo described SEGM as "the most prominent of the pseudo-scientific organizations in the anti-trans space" and stated they use "teach the controversy" tactics and cite the results of their advocacy efforts in the United Kingdom NHS and Swedish Karolinska Hospital to build momentum to restrict care for trans youth globally.

BuzzFeed News said SEGM "effectively accomplished for gender dysphoria what anti-vaxxer medical professionals have sought to do for their cause: give credence to the notion that no scientific or medical consensus exists regarding the relative safety and efficacy of a given treatment, despite the clear and growing evidence to the contrary."

The Southern Poverty Law Center wrote in 2023 that "Since its founding, members of SEGM have undertaken a global media and public policy blitz to challenge the affirming care model, advocate against gender-affirming care, and lend scientific credibility to legal claims against LGBTQ+ civil rights." The Southern Poverty Law Center added SEGM and Genspect to its list of anti-LGBTQ+ hate groups in its 2023 "Year in Hate & Extremism" Report.

GLAAD described SEGM as "known for mischaracterizing standards of care for transgender youth and engaging in political lobbying using misinformation which contradicts the evidence base around transgender healthcare."

In March 2024, a paper examining the scientists, clinicians, and political organizations that promote bans on gender-affirming care described SEGM as a "fringe medical association".

Medical community

In April 2021, Medscape Medical News asked Joshua Safer – an endocrinologist from Mount Sinai Hospital acting as a spokesperson for the Endocrine Society on transgender issues – about SEGM, SEGM member Will Malone, and their concerns about treatment for transgender youth, he stated: "This is a relatively small group that has been making the same arguments for a number of years, and they are very much outside the mainstream".

In March 2022, SEGM funded a paper by Stephen Levine, Zhenya Abbruzzese, and Julia Mason titled "Reconsidering Informed Consent for Trans-Identified Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults" which appeared in the Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. The paper questioned the quality of the evidence base for paediatric and adolescent gender-affirming care, and the process of establishing informed consent, which they suggested suffered from "erroneous professional assumptions; poor quality of the initial evaluations; and inaccurate and incomplete information shared with patients and their parents". In June, the journal published four invited responses from academics. Two responses, one of which was authored by a SEGM affiliated academic, agreed with the paper, while the other two offered criticism. A critical response by Annelou de Vries stated the current evidence base supported gender-affirming interventions and that the Dutch protocol had always included careful assessment including mental health, family environment and capacity for informed consent. A response by Jack Drescher compared SEGM to the National Association for Research & Therapy of Homosexuality (NARTH), a prominent conversion therapy advocacy organization focused on opposition to lesbian and gay rights, and questioned whether SEGM was "following a parallel path regarding transgender rights". In a further reply in 2023, Levine, Abbruzzese and Mason criticised Drescher's commentary for referencing "an anonymous libelous blog" and making "baseless insinuations by inventing a non-existent association between SEGM and anti-homosexual groups".

In April 2022, researchers at the Yale School of Medicine issued a report in response to the attacks on transgender healthcare in Arizona and Texas which described SEGM as "an ideological organization without apparent ties to mainstream scientific or professional organizations", and help lawmakers criminalize transgender care.

In October 2022, writing in Science-Based Medicine, AJ Eckert described SEGM as a "transphobic organization" which is closely affiliated with Genspect, who they described as "an anti-trans gender critical (GC) organization", and stated they "both regularly peddle anti-trans pseudoscience". Referring to 2019 statements from Malone that "No child is born in the wrong body, but for a variety of reasons some children and adolescents become convinced that they were" in a Christian Post interview, and that "counseling can resolve any trauma or thought processes that have caused them to desire an opposite sexed body" in a Quillette article with fellow SEGM member Colin Wright, Eckert opined that the statements were "transphobic and reductive" and favor a model where children are encouraged to live as their sex assigned at birth. Eckert indicated that the American Academy of Pediatrics have said that "conversion" or "reparative" treatment models such as this are used to deter youth from displaying non-cisgender identities or expressions, and the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration has said that any therapeutic interventions that seek to change a youth's gender identity or expression are inappropriate and may cause harm.

Kaiser Health News while fact checking a political campaign ad by America First Legal, said the leaders of SEGM are "wholly skeptical of the acceleration in gender-affirming care".

See also

• Standards of Care for the Health of Transgender and Gender Diverse People
• Healthcare and the LGBT community

References

1. ^ Eckert, AJ (17 October 2021). "Conclusions Not So NICE: A Critical Analysis of the NICE Evidence review of puberty blockers for children and adolescents with gender dysphoria". Science-Based Medicine. Retrieved 24 October 2022.
2. Beck, Madelyn (2 February 2023). "Health experts: Gender-affirming care saves lives". WyoFile. Archived from the original on 2 February 2023. Retrieved 2 February 2023.
3. ^ Greenspan, Sam (3 August 2022). "How Florida Twisted Science to Deny Healthcare to Trans Kids". Vice News. Archived from the original on 18 August 2022. Retrieved 22 August 2022.
4. ^ "Biased Science in Texas & Alabama". medicine.yale.edu. Archived from the original on 29 July 2022. Retrieved 26 June 2022.
5. ^ Ring, Trudy (5 May 2022). "'Science' Behind Texas/Alabama Anti-Trans Policy Is 'Full of Errors'". The Advocate. Archived from the original on 16 June 2022. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
6. ^ McCall, Becky; Nainggolan, Lisa (26 April 2021). "Transgender Teens: Is the Tide Starting to Turn?". Medscape Medical News. Archived from the original on 20 October 2022. Retrieved 20 October 2022.
7. ^ Meloche-Holubowski, Mélanie (28 October 2024). "These "merchants of doubt" at the heart of the debate on transitional care". Radio Canada (in Canadian French). Retrieved 1 November 2024.
8. ^ Wuest, Joanna; Last, Briana S. (1 March 2024). "Agents of scientific uncertainty: Conflicts over evidence and expertise in gender-affirming care bans for minors". Social Science & Medicine. 344: 116533. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2023.116533. ISSN 0277-9536.
9. ^ Eckert, AJ; McLamore, Quinnehtukqut (22 October 2022). "Cutting through the Lies and Misinterpretations about the Updated Standards of Care for the Health of Transgender and Gender Diverse People". Science Based Medicine. Archived from the original on 24 October 2022. Retrieved 24 October 2022.
10. Dixon, Hayley (26 June 2021). "CBBC's trans messaging is damaging children, says mother". The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on 23 September 2021. Retrieved 30 May 2023.
11. ^
    • "Hate Map". Southern Poverty Law Center. Archived from the original on 20 May 2024. Retrieved 5 June 2024.
    • "Extremist Files: Anti-LGBTQ". Southern Poverty Law Center. Archived from the original on 5 September 2021. Retrieved 5 June 2024.
    • Reed, Erin (5 June 2024). "Genspect, SEGM designated anti-LGBTQ hate groups by SPLC". Los Angeles Blade. Archived from the original on 5 June 2024. Retrieved 7 June 2024.
    • Lazine, Mira (6 June 2024). "Anti-trans organizations Genspect & SEGM are now listed as hate groups by the SPLC". LGBTQ Nation. Archived from the original on 7 September 2024. Retrieved 7 June 2024.
12. ^ Klotz, Frieda (21 May 2024). "Pediatric Transgender Care and the Contentious Rise of SEGM". Undark Magazine. Archived from the original on 25 June 2024. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
13. ^ Cravens, R.G.; McLamore, Quinnehtukqut; Leveille, Lee; Hodges, Emerson; Wunderlich, Sophie; Bates, Lydia (12 December 2023). "Group dynamics and division of labor within the anti-LGBTQ+ pseudoscience network". Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
14. Block, Jennifer (23 May 2024). "Gender medicine in the US: how the Cass review failed to land". The BMJ: q1141. doi:10.1136/bmj.q1141.
15. Miroshnychenko, Anna; Roldan, Yetiani M.; Ibrahim, Sara; Kulatunga-Moruzi, Chan; Dahlin, Kristen; Montante, Steven; Couban, Rachel; Guyatt, Gordon; Brignardello-Petersen, Romina (10 September 2024). ""Mastectomy for individuals with gender dysphoria below 26 years of age: A systematic review and meta-analysis"". Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000011734. ISSN 1529-4242. PMID 39252149.
16. "Brief of Amicus Curiae Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine in Support of the Defendant Appellee" (PDF). 7 July 2021. Archived (PDF) from the original on 27 March 2022. Retrieved 7 October 2022.
17. Rochman, Joseph Hayes (April 2022). "9th Circuit Panel Affirms Arizona District Court's Denial of a Preliminary Injunction Against the State's Categorical Medicaid Exclusion for Gender Confirmation Surgeries". LGBT Law Notes. Archived from the original on 29 September 2022. Retrieved 29 September 2022.
18. D'Ambrosio, Amanda (23 August 2022). "AAP Stands By Policy on Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Youth". MedPage Today. Archived from the original on 29 August 2022. Retrieved 29 August 2022.
19. Ault, Alicia; Nainggolan, Lisa (16 August 2022). "Pediatricians at Odds Over Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Kids". Medscape Medical News. Archived from the original on 20 October 2022. Retrieved 20 October 2022.
20. Baitinger, Brooke (3 August 2022). "Showdown: LGBTQ+ rights vs. state ban on transition-related medical care for trans kids". Florida Phoenix. Archived from the original on 23 August 2022. Retrieved 24 August 2022.
21. ^ Moore, Mallory. "SEGM uncovered: large anonymous payments funding dodgy science". transsafety.network. Archived from the original on 7 June 2022. Retrieved 26 June 2022.
22. "ROGD Statement". Coalition for the Advancement & Application of Psychological Science. Archived from the original on 4 August 2021. Retrieved 4 August 2021.
23. ^ Cravens, R. G.; McLamore, Quinnehtukqut; Leveille, Lee; Hodges, Emerson; Wunderlich, Sophie; Bates, Lydia (12 December 2023). "Manufacturing the doubt that fuels the network". Southern Poverty Law Center. Archived from the original on 28 December 2023. Retrieved 31 December 2023.
24. ^ Stahl, Aviva (16 April 2021). "The Science Behind Those Anti-Trans Healthcare Bills Is Bullsh*t, According To Experts". BuzzFeedNews. Archived from the original on 22 August 2022. Retrieved 22 August 2022.
25. Jones, Tiffany (2024). "United States of hate: mapping backlash Bills against LGBTIQ+ youth". Sex Education. 24 (6): 816–835. doi:10.1080/14681811.2023.2241136. ISSN 1468-1811.
26. Tracy, Matt (1 April 2020). "Idaho Bans Trans Girls' Sports, Bars Birth Certificate Changes – Gay City News". Gay City News. Archived from the original on 8 October 2022. Retrieved 22 August 2022.
27. Turner, Jackie (9 March 2023). "Anti-trans disinformation is rife in Australia — and it's being spread by a small group of organisations". Retrieved 1 November 2024.
28. ^ Ferreyra-Carroll, Lilith (21 October 2021). "A state of collapse: Trans healthcare in Ireland is a national emergency". Gay Community News. Archived from the original on 4 July 2022. Retrieved 28 June 2022.
29. Caraballo, Alejandra (2022). "The Anti-Transgender Medical Expert Industry". Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics. 50 (4): 687–692. doi:10.1017/jme.2023.9. ISSN 1073-1105. PMID 36883410.
30. ^ "Julia Mason". GLAAD. 3 August 2023. Retrieved 24 October 2024.
31. Levine, Stephen B.; Abbruzzese, E.; Mason, Julia W. (3 October 2022). "Reconsidering Informed Consent for Trans-Identified Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults". Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 48 (7): 706–727. doi:10.1080/0092623X.2022.2046221. ISSN 0092-623X. PMID 35300570. S2CID 247521800.
32. • Clayton, Alison (2 January 2023). "Commentary on Levine et al.: A Tale of Two Informed Consent Processes". Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 49 (1): 88–95. doi:10.1080/0092623X.2022.2070565. ISSN 0092-623X.
    • Balon, Richard (17 November 2022). "Commentary on Levine et al: Festina Lente (Rush Slowly)". Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 48 (8): 775–778. doi:10.1080/0092623X.2022.2055686. ISSN 0092-623X.
    • Drescher 2022
    • de Vries 2023
    • Levine, Abbruzzese & Mason 2023
33. ^ Levine, Abbruzzese & Mason 2023.
34. de Vries 2023.
35. Drescher 2022.
36. Rafferty, Jason; Yogman, Michael; Baum, Rebecca; Gambon, Thresia B.; Lavin, Arthur; Mattson, Gerri; Wissow, Lawrence Sagin; Breuner, Cora; Alderman, Elizabeth M.; Grubb, Laura K.; Powers, Makia E.; Upadhya, Krishna; Wallace, Stephenie B.; Hunt, Lynn; Gearhart, Anne Teresa; Harris, Christopher; Lowe, Kathryn Melland; Rodgers, Chadwick Taylor; Sherer, Ilana Michelle (1 October 2018). "Ensuring Comprehensive Care and Support for Transgender and Gender-Diverse Children and Adolescents". Pediatrics. 142 (4). American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). doi:10.1542/peds.2018-2162. ISSN 0031-4005. PMID 30224363.
37. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (October 2015). Ending Conversion Therapy: Supporting and Affirming LGBTQ Youth (PDF) (Report). Rockville, MD. p. 27. Archived (PDF) from the original on 14 October 2021. Retrieved 30 June 2023.
38. Farmer, Blake (9 November 2022). "Ad Goes Too Far With Claim That Joe Biden Promotes Surgery for Trans Teens". Kaiser Health News. Archived from the original on 15 February 2023. Retrieved 27 February 2023.

Works cited

• de Vries, Annelou L. C. (2 January 2023). "Ensuring Care for Transgender Adolescents Who Need It: Response to 'Reconsidering Informed Consent for Trans-Identified Children, Adolescents and Young Adults'". Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 49 (1): 108–114. doi:10.1080/0092623X.2022.2084479. ISSN 0092-623X.
• Drescher, Jack (1 June 2022). "Informed Consent or Scare Tactics? A Response to Levine et al.'s "Reconsidering Informed Consent for Trans-Identified Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults"". Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 49 (1): 99–107. doi:10.1080/0092623X.2022.2080780. ISSN 0092-623X. PMID 35642738. S2CID 249235587.
• Levine, Stephen B.; Abbruzzese, E.; Mason, Julia W. (2 January 2023). "What Are We Doing to These Children? Response to Drescher, Clayton, and Balon Commentaries on Levine et al., 2022". Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 49 (1): 115–125. doi:10.1080/0092623X.2022.2136117. ISSN 0092-623X.

External links

• Official website

• Organizations that oppose transgender rights
• Alternative medicine
• Advocacy groups in the United States
• 2020 establishments in the United States