Misplaced Pages

:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive: Difference between revisions - Misplaced Pages

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
< Misplaced Pages:Requests for comment | User conduct Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 15:18, 14 June 2007 editAnythingyouwant (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers, Template editors91,258 editsm →Archived disputes← Previous edit Latest revision as of 20:54, 7 August 2021 edit undoTrialpears (talk | contribs)Administrators33,082 editsm Change parameter name for Archives template, typo(s) fixed: bilty → bilityTag: AWB 
(470 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{historical|comment=<br>'''The ] process has been discontinued as a result of {{oldid|Misplaced Pages:Village pump (proposals)#Do Away with RFC/U|637099409|this discussion}}.'''<br>'''Other ] processes should be used for conduct issues.|brief=yes}}
{{archives|
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
|search=yes
|searchprefix=Misplaced Pages:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive}}

This page is for archiving user conduct disputes listed on ]. Archived disputes should not be added to. Disputes should be archived under any of the following circumstances: This page is for archiving user conduct disputes listed on ]. Archived disputes should not be added to. Disputes should be archived under any of the following circumstances:
# If no additional complaints are registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped. # If no additional complaints are registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
Line 5: Line 19:
If the dispute is handled in mediation or arbitration, please make a note of where the dispute resolution process continued. If the dispute is handled in mediation or arbitration, please make a note of where the dispute resolution process continued.



<!--The cases closed in need to be added to the archive.-->
==Archived disputes== ==Archived disputes==
''Newer entries towards the top'' *''Newer entries towards the top''
*''This page only displays user RFCs from the most recent year and the current year, older discussions can be found in the archives, a search box is provided above''
*'''As of March 25, 2013, the names of the certifiers are no longer a required field. You can find this information easily by clicking the link to the RFC itself.'''


{| class="wikitable" {| class="wikitable"
!Name!!Date!!Description!!First two certifiers!!Notes !Name!!Start date!!Description!!Notes
<!-- Copy and use this template <!-- Copy and use this template
|- |-
| ] | ]
| Date Filed | Date filed
| Issues. | Issues
| Outcome of the Rfc (agreement, arbitration, mediation, etc).-->
| ], ]
| Outcome if any (agreement, arbitration, mediation, etc.

;]
:Allegations: Accused of not being truthful about his background.
Add your request below this line -->

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 5 June 2007 | 24 October 2014
| Canvassing, Ownership of Articles, Battleground behavior
| accused of making false charge of harassment
| Closed due to lack of progress.
| ], ]
| No conclusion. Closed per agreement. No agreement reached about harassment charge.
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 1 April 2007 | 26 August 2014
| Copyright and sourcing issues
| edit warring, pov-pushing and -forking, spamming, making use of meat puppets, abusing Misplaced Pages processes to game the system
| 30 SW has not edited since just before the RFC was filed. RFC indefinitely suspended due to inactivity.
| ], ]
| No changes; proceeding to arbitration
|- |-
| ] | ]
| February 12, 2007 | July 29 2014
| Copyright concerns, ownership of articles
| personal attacks, edit warring, calling editors vandals, inserting the word "terrorist" inappropriately into articles about Islamic groups, inappropriate tagging.
| several participants blocked as socks, Dan56 reminded of relevant policies
| ], ]
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 25 January 2007 | 11 September 2014
| Worldedixor's problematic manner in handling disputes
| Abuse of blocking policy.
| Closed due to inactivity
| ], ]
| Trödel apologized for misuse of blocking and agreed to never block ] again, though reserves the right to request another administrator to blcok him.
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 30 January 2007 | 15 October 2014
| Page protection of template
| Use of blocking to win content disputes.
| Page protection level reduced, RFC closed per request of filer.
| ], ], ]
| No changes.
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 18 February 2007 | 22 August 2014
| Alleged POV pushing, page ownership, cherry-picking of sources
| Improper closing of AfDs.
| Further discussion is recommended, possibly followed by a topic-ban request (at ANI) or arbitration if necessary.
| ], ]
| No conclusion, though noted at time of close that Nick had stopped closing AfDs.
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 18 February 2007 | 11 March 2014
| Inability for the IP to follow policy
| Discussing edits; abiding by consensus; assuming good faith; neutrality; original research.
| Delisted for inactivity and very little comments, no edits since day 2 of RFC.
| ], ]
| Although nothing conclusively resolved, all parties seem to be willing to move forward productively; closed per agreement
|- |-
| ]
| 28 February 2014
| Aggressive lack of understanding and violations of various Misplaced Pages policies
| Involved and outside views; no response; closed due to inactivity. Uncertainty regarding whether subject retired from Misplaced Pages or not; recommendation to escalate dispute if issues persist in any case.
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 2 March 2007 | 11 January 2014
| Issues
| Community Trust issues over fake PHDs, and using them in advantage of content disputes
| "Whitewashing" not firmly established, but likely NPA violations are.
| Community certified
| Closed as Essjay since left the project
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 30 January 2007 | 26 January 2014
| Overzealous in efforts to stamp out what they consider fringe
| Self-filed RfC over "controversial" edits
| No clear consensus that user is disruptive in what is already a contentious area.
| ], no second certifier
| User opened an ER at ] as suggested.
|- |-
| ]
| ]
| 15 February 2014
| 29 December 2006
| Dispute over user signatures
| Misuse of admin powers (blocking, deletion), ]
| Nearly all comments occurred within a week of original complaint. Clear consensus was that the signature was not offensive
| ], ]
| Nothing resolved, participants tired of arguing.

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 9 February 2014
| 5 December 06
| Request for unblock, sockpuppetry issues
| ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ]
| Consensus is to leave the user blocked.
| ], ]
| ]

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 17 December 2006 | 20 November 2013
| Perform large numbers of edits, with relatively small amounts of actual changes to the articles and not using edit summaries.
| Suspicions of plagiarism need discussion.
| Closed due to inactivity and low participation.
| ], ]
| Allegation denied, no source identified, paragraph remains in article as unreferenced.

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 12 December 06 | 15 August 2013
| Long-term incivility, personal attacks, and edit-warring
| Edit conflicts, sockpuppet allegations, Notability
| No conclusive outcomes, Misplaced Pages is not a battleground, edit warring is unconstructive
| ], ]
| User in focus was indefblocked as a Sockpuppet of a banned user via ]


|- |-
|] | ]
| 18 Nov 2006 | 22 June 2013
| Uncivil behavior, edit warring, and sock puppetry, mostly related to Islam topics
| Incivility
| Discussion went stale after a few weeks, with Baboon43 refusing to participate, before the issue was taken to AN, resulting in an indefinite block.
| ], ]
|-
| ]
| ]

| 13 May 2013
| Talk page and behavioral issues
| Withdrawn after discussion on talk page of RfC/U
|- |-
|] | ]
| 7 Nov 2006 | 30 April 2013
| Problematic behaviour around AfDs and notability issues related to Dungeons & Dragons
| User:RPJ continues to violate WP:NPOV, WP:NPA, WP:OR, WP:CIVIL and WP:V.
| There was consensus that Folken's approach needs to change. The closing admin suggested that he agree to a voluntary topic ban regarding deletion issues in the problem area.
| ], ]
| ]

|- |-
|] | ]
| 29 March 2013
|26 Nov 2006
| Problematic creation of navboxes and other content
|Misuse of blocking power
| Some progress, later apparenrlty reversed. a proposal for a formal topic ban is anticipated
|], ]
|Resigned sysop position

|- |-
| ]
| ]
| 13 Aug 06 | 23 March 2013
| To discuss whether Will should be allowed back to edit
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| No consensus to overturn Arbcom decision
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 6 Aug 06 | 20 January 2013
| Tendentious editing/POV issues
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| All participants other than the certifiers felt that this dispute was about content, not conduct
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 1 Aug 06 | 21 December 2012
| Soapboxing, personal attacks, unreliable sources, canvassing
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| Closed due to inactivity
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
|}
| {{#if: |}}


|-
| ]
| 21 Aug 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}


{| class="wikitable"
!Name!!Start date!!Description!!First two certifiers!!Notes
|- |-
| ] | ]
| 21 Jul 06 | 31 January 2013
| Concerns about civility, battlegrounding, and related conduct issues
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| ], ]
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| Serious and valid problems with Cantaloupe2's conduct exist. The matter might be taken up by ArbCom.
| {{#if: |}}

|- |-
| ] | ]
| 20 Jul 06 | 15 January 2013
| Removal of unsourced content from articles
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| ], ]
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| Epeefleche is broadly correct to remove unsourced content, and Danjel has often acted wrongly in restoring unsourced content.<br />Also, Danjel's conduct is widely seen as hounding.
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 18 Jul 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 16 Jul 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 11 Jul 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]<br>({{#if: {{{user|}}} | ] | ]}})
| 11 Jul 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 2 Jul 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 29 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 26 Jul 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: Gone to arbitration |Gone to arbitration}}

|-
| ]
| 23 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 23 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 22 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: Gone to arbitration |Gone to arbitration}}

|-
| ]
| 22 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 21 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 21 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 21 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 15 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 11 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 11 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 7 Jun 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 22 May 06
| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}
| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | ]}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |<br>]}}
| {{#if: |}}

|-
| ]
| 16 Sep 2006
| User has a history of useless and/or irrelevant edits to talk pages (particularly on WikiProject Tropical cyclones), in violation of WP:NOT (a chat room).
| ], ]
| Withdrawn when the disputed conduct did not recur

|-
| ]
| 7 Aug 2006
| ], ] ], ] and ] issues.
| ], ]
| Agreement to close

|-
| ]
| 10 July 2006
| POV pushing, personal attacks
| ], ]
| Indef banned by community

|-
| ]
| 27 July 2006
| Concerns regarding the block of User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ). Note: unlike most RFCs, there is no concern about abuse but rather a concern about broader issues of process drift and precedent.
| ]
| Stale

|-
| ]
| 14 July 2006
| Nescio has frequently engaged in violations of WP:POINT to the detrement of the articles he edits.
| ], ]
| Stale; Nescio has left Misplaced Pages

|-
| ]
| 8 Aug 2006
| Forming a new policy in order to close off ongoing discussion pertaining to an issue
| ], ]
| Kelly Martin has left Misplaced Pages, also similar issues were raised in an unrelated ] case.

|-
| ]
| 20 May 2006
| POV editing, ignoring consensus
| ], ]
| ]

|-
| ]
| 2 Aug 2006
| Blocking of ]
| ], ]
| Sceptre is no longer an admin

|-
| ]
| 24 June 2006
| Misuse of blocking power
| ], ]
| ] for similar issues

|-
| ]
| 26 June 2006
| Poor or unverifiable contributions, does not respond on talk pages
| ], ]
| Indef banned by community

|-
| ]
| 19 June 2006
| POV pushing, uncivil behavior, vandalism
| ],]
| User is no longer active in Misplaced Pages

|-
| ]
| 9 June 2006
| Extremely uncooperative user; vandalism, reverts, copywrite problems, non-communication, disruption, edit warring, NPOV, disregard for policy, more.
| ], ], "Numorous '']'' other users listing complains '']'' on Hatto's talk pages", ]
| Stale

|-
| ]
| 13 May 2006
| Abuse of admin rules in ruling and POV of Soviet pre-1973 images
| ], ]
| Stale

|-
| ]
| 31 May 2006
| Imposing his own POV
| ], ]
| ]

|-
| ]
| 27 April 2006
| Revert war at ]
| ], ]
| ]

|-
|]
|5 June 2006
|POV pushing and original research
|], ]
|Sent to ]

|-
| ]
| 18 May 2006
| Bad faith nomintions at AfD, personal attacks, template misuse, assuming bad faith, and incivility
| ], ]
| Community ban

|-
|]
|17 May 2006
|Incivility
|],]
|Sent to ]

|-
| ]
| 10 May 2006
| Persistently imposes his own style preferences on scientific articles
| ], ]
| Stale

|-
|]
|5 May 2006
|Abrasiveness
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|30 April 2006
|POV pushing
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|29 April 2006
|Refusing to accept consensus
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|26 April 2006
|Adding unverifiable information
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|23 April 2006
|Personal attacks
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|23 April 2006
|Using Misplaced Pages to promote his own interests.
|], ]
|Banned for posting personal information

|-
|]
|22 April 2006
|Lack of civility
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|22 April 2006
|Trolling
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|13 April 2006
|Adding links to his own alternative medicine web site to medical topics in violation of WP:V and WP:RS
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|13 April 2006
|POV pushing
|], ]
|Banned as a reincarnation of ]

|-
|]
|4 April 2006
|POV pushing on chiropractic articles
|], ]
|

|-
|]
|2 November 2005
|POV pushing on vaccine topics
|], ]
|

|- |-
|} |}


*] RfCs brought solely to harass or subdue an adversary
*] Failing to obtain consensus for moving highways articles. Sent to arbitration.
*] Failing to interact well with another user.
*] Misuse of AfD.
*] disregards consensus, uses sockpuppets to avoid 3RR. 18:25, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] Allegations of POV pushing and soapboxing. 18:25, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] attacks others, mischaracterizes edits as vandalism. 18:25, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] Spamming. 18:25, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] Edit-warring on Libertarianism and Anarcho-capitalism. 18:25, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] 18:25, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*]. Violations of WP:POINT and WP:V on astrology-related topics. 18:09, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*]. Moved to Arbitration at ]. 18:07, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*]. Removes complaints from his talk page, personally attacks other users, ignores NPOV, countless reverts, and endless innuendo on talk pages. Moved to Arbitration ]. 18:04, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] Problems with fair use, spamming for his own web site, and retaliatory vandalism. Referred to Arbcom as ]. Filed 4 June 2006, archived 15:21, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*] Violations of ], ], ], ], ], ], ], etc. 21:09, July 21, 2006
*] Disagreement over whether Hipocrite's reversions and comments to ] based on alleged hoaxes are consistent with ], ], and ]. 00:49, 1 August 2006 (UTC)
*] Abuse of admin powers. I'm listing this here because it's really old. It's evidence in a current ArbCom case against the person who brought it, so don't delete it, plz. ] | ] 00:51, 5 July 2006 (UTC).
*] General abuse of admin powers. 16:40, 7 May 2006 (UTC)
*] - User is removing images that are fair use violations from userspace without requesting user to do so.
*] misuse of semi-bot to convert reference styles contrary to consensus.] 17:12, 24 April 2006 (UTC)
*] Image contribution issue of quality over a collection of uploads +200 and no response to comments or requests by other Wikipedians. ] 20:41, 23 April 2006 (UTC)
*] Refusing to accept consensus at ] and other policy pages and attempting to force the issue. Multiple accounts.
*]
*] – Consistently violates ] and brings his own personal/political agenda into discussions and edits. Is the cause of a number of edit wars and continuously violates ] by attacking my character. ] 04:05, 5 April 2006 (UTC)
*] - Unwilling to take wikiquette criticisms seriously. --] 06:39, 7 April 2006 (UTC)
*] - When he is in a dispute and outnumber by consensus (], ], ]), he reverts without discussion (or very little of it) and fails to ] and makes some uncivil comments. -- ]''']''' 17:40, 4 April 2006 (UTC)
*] - widespread flounting of consensus at math articles. -] <sup>] </sup> 01:17, 4 April 2006 (UTC)
*] Civility, POV, sockpuppetry, 3RR, block evasion on Ireland-related articles. 20:17, 28 March 2006 (UTC)
*] &ndash; vandalism, trolling and personal attacks; reoffending after several blocks. ]&nbsp;<sub>(])</sub><sup>]</sup> ''20:09,&nbsp;14&nbsp;March&nbsp;2006''
*] Chronic violator of the 3rr, engages in personal attacks (]), ignores consensus (]), possibly part of a Zionist movement, hijacks one or two pages by repeatedly reverting, using banners and excessive texts in the discussion page, incivil behavior (]), gaming the system (]), assuming bad faith(]), harassment (]), and engages in personal attacks (]).
*] Many violations of ] He has received three formal warnings, several informal warnings but continues to attack. Edits include obscenity and vandalism. Revision by other editors of vandalism and POV posts are met with bad-faith accusations.
*] Insistence on adding despite numerous efforts on talk page to work out solution; 3RR violations; deceptive edit summaries, impersonation, and sockpuppetry. <b><font face="Arial" color="#D47C14">]</font><font color="#7D4C0C">]</font>]</b> 01:05, 23 February 2006 (UTC)
* ], POV-pushing, revert warring by United States congressional staffers, failure to work with the community, constant vandalism. ] (]) 08:03, 30 January 2006 (UTC)
*] - reversing username blocks set by other administrators, with no prior discussion. 14:32, 12 March 2006 (UTC)
*] &ndash; out-of-process deletions of images that were tagged as "fair use" but believed not to be. 22:51, 27 February 2006 (UTC)
*] &ndash; Both admins were involved in a mass speedy deletion of userboxes this past weekend, and it appears they have only added fuel to the fire.
*] (3rd RfC) - violations of blocking and deletion policies
*] Civility and pov concerns on a number of articles. Systematic bias may also be observed. <small>]<sup>]|]</sup></small> 00:43, 25 March 2006 (UTC)
*] Civility and pov concerns on a number of articles. Systematic bias may also be observed. <small>]<sup>]|]</sup></small> 00:43, 25 March 2006 (UTC)
*] Civility and pov concerns on a number of articles. Systematic bias may also be observed. <small>]<sup>]|]</sup></small> 00:43, 25 March 2006 (UTC)
*] for excessive Personal insults in my direction, lack of wikiettiquette (title ''one contributor'') and on ] which was reverted back and forth over 50 times since December, and was locked twice as a result. Rydel refused any discussions or medition proposals.--] 18:22, 24 March 2006 (UTC)
*] Continued placement of POV material on page ]. 17:08, 23 March 2006 (UTC)
*] : This user has been unilaterally editing sensitive history related articles to conform to his POV.
*] &ndash; keeps changing the article on the ] to claim they were Turkic, even though we've worked hard to make this page show all sides of the issue; the exact ethnic identity of the Huns is disputed, and we want the page to reflect that. Nonetheless, Hakozen keeps changing all NPOV mentions of "uncertain" etc. to "Turkic" and no longer participates on the Talk page. After I contacted him on his user page, he claimed I and the other level-headed editors were anti-Turk racists serving Greek and Armenian masters. ] 01:58, 6 March 2006 (UTC)
*] - User has been disruptive at the article of her husband. She has also been editing heavily the article of his employer Answers in Genesis, and the article of a colleague of her husband, Ken Ham. Many of these edits have raised concerns over POV and the appropriateness of editors editing articles that they directly have a stake in.
*] &ndash; multiple violations of ] on multiple vote pages; violations of ]; problems with ]. ] 12:22, 20 February 2006 (UTC)
*] - accused of persistent and constant POV pushing, personal attacks, and original research. --] 17:26, 17 February 2006 (UTC)
*] Repeated pov vandal. Has been blocked several times. Problems ranging from ] to ]. Athough there has been problems with personal attacks, they are not (so far) part of this RFC, simply due to the shear amount of article-related problems.--<font color="darkgreen">]</font><font color="grey">'''|'''</font>]<font color="grey">'''|'''</font><font color="darkgreen">]</font>-- 00:36, 14 February 2006 (UTC)
*] &ndash; - Problems with ], ], ], ], ], ], and gaming of ], etc. After conducting a multi-front revert war on the ], ], and ] articles that drove all three into protection, the user then extended his attempt to about a dozen articles related to the Plame matter, repeating the very same kinds of edits in order to cast erroneous doubt on the established facts of the case. Any editor challenging him is inevitably accused by Mr j galt of whatever it is he himself has been accused, in a classic Troll style. 22:25, 4 February 2006 (UTC)
*] &ndash; '''NOTE: The IP 65.182.172.87 has been blocked for one month as of February 6, 2006.''' User shows repeated pattern of violating ], ], and ] with talk page comments. Has repeatedly posted personally identifying information about Misplaced Pages editors despite having been told not to. - ]] <sup>(] - ])</sup> 12:31, 4 February 2006 (UTC)
* ]: Mainly ], ], and ]. He has forced at least three Wikipedians to chase after every single one of his edits since April 2005. This has got to stop. -- ] (]) 18:58, 25 January 2006 (UTC)
*]: Problems with ], ], ], ], ], ], etc. (long version deleted, is listed in the actual request.) ] 17:00, 31 January 2006 (UTC)
*]: Multiple violations of various policies and guidelines (], ], ], ], ], ]). ]<font color="#008000">]</font>]] 22:22, 16 January 2006 (UTC)
* ]: Has been harrassing other editors who disagree with him on the article ]. Any edit that refutes his view sets of a tirade of insults from this editor towards other editors. He has been repeatedly warned: ,,
But he persists with the attacks in the talk pages (most of this has been archived) and in his edit summaries. Please help. ] 04:33, 29 January 2006 (UTC)
*] - regarding attitude towards new contributors unfamiliar with Misplaced Pages. ] (] | ] | ]) 20:22, 9 January 2006 (UTC)
*]: This user has repeatedly come into conflict with a wide range of other users. He has engaged in a persistent and wilful pattern of personal attacks, accusations of bad faith, making strongly POV edits, refusing to abide by consensus, misrepresenting Misplaced Pages policies to support his POV edits, making legal accusations that at the very least violate the spirit of WP:NLT, removing sources with which he doesn't agree and declining to cite sources for his own edits. He has spent much of the last two months fighting edit wars with around a dozen other users in a range of articles and one template, all concerning Scientology. A mediation attempt has failed. The matter has now been submitted to the Arbitration Committee. -- ] 18:04, 29 March 2006 (UTC)
*] : Has leveled personal attacks against another editor in spite of repeated requests to stop. ] 12:34, 17 March 2006 (UTC) Withdrawn by complaintants, who insist on their initial claims, but recognize, that RfC was an improper way to resolve the case. ] 02:25, 25 March 2006 (UTC)
* ]: Various policies including ], ], ], ] and ]. - ] <sup>]]</sup>/<sub>]]</sub> ] '']'' 11:26, 22 January 2006 (UTC) Taken to ArbCom - ] - and user blocked for one year. --] 09:18, 22 March 2006 (UTC)
*] &ndash; User had taken a break, but has now returned under an anonymous username and is continuing to promote the same activities including personal attacks and thwarting Misplaced Pages policy involving content disputes. --]
*]: Refuses to abide by long-standing rules of current-events pages at ]. -- 03:58, 16 January 2006 (UTC)
*]: revert warring against consensus at ] and ], personal attacks. 19:33, 13 January 2006 (UTC).
*] &ndash; has made anti-gay statements as well as anti-Jewish and anti-Russian ones. Refuses to apologise. ]] ''']''' ] 22:11, 11 January 2006 (UTC)
*] Repeated personal attacks, refusal to change course
*] &ndash; suspected sockpuppet of ]. Created on March 1st and dived headlong into vandalizing of Moldova-related articles, the favorite target of Bonaparte, with accusing everyone else in anti-Romanian discrimination annd with curious knowledge of wikipedia policies and places. Permanent ban requested. 20:48, 1 March 2006 (UTC)
*] Constantly revert wars without discussing changes on talk. ] 17:05, 7 January 2006 (UTC)
*] Using wikipedia as a blog to air dissatifaction with a company. ] 19:52, 3 January 2006 (UTC)
*] Spamming, incivility, refusal to accept consensus, 3rr, and more on ] --] <sup>]</sup> 04:15, 5 January 2006 (UTC)
*] Conducting a hate campaign against users.
*] Repeatedly makes vicious personal attacks, makes unsubstantiated (and libelous) accusations of illegal behavior, vandalizes articles, and engages in edit wars. In short, a menace to the wikipedia community.
*] Gaming the system (]), assuming bad faith(]), incivil behavior (]), harassment (]), ignores consensus (]), and engages in personal attacks (]).
*] Legal threats, incivil behavior, etc. relating to pushing unverified and potentially libelous allegations that ] committed sex crimes with his daughter, and then conspired with his company to cover it up.
*] - User is engaged in heated discussion on the ] page. User is currently under probation for China/Taiwan related infractions. Article ends up protected.
*] - User continues to post irrelevent entries into articles (He recently lised a Toledo, Ohio station under stations in Kansas City) and creates articles with little or no content. All articles in question pertain to radio stations in the Midwest. He's been warned and banned for vandalism in the past and probably needs some mentoring... and grammar lessons. 04:08, 16 December 2005 (UTC)
*]. User has violated numerous Misplaced Pages policies in an effort to keep legitimate criticism of veganism out of the ] and ] articles.19:12, 14 December 2005 (UTC)
* ]. ], ], ], ], ]. Besides the edit war, massive disruption of place names, thousands of moves and edits per day, immediate concern. Already tried 3rd party. ] 03:10, 14 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] &ndash; strongly biased contributions that lead to strong personal discussions. ] ] 20:01, 13 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] &ndash; repeated POV deletion of perfectly relevant links to a site he doesn't like, coupled with accusations of "linkspamming."" Deceptive editing, accusations of "coordinating attacks" from third party sites, general harrassment of me, ]. ] 05:21, 13 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] &ndash; NPoV twisting, coordinating attacks on wikipedia PoV from third party site, link spamming fisheaters.com site written by Used2BAnonymous. 00:20, 13 December 2005 (UTC)
* ]. ], ], ], ], ]. Constantly argumentative, enjoys edit warring, refuses to take responsibility for statements made, combative and insulting. -- ] 00:06, 14 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] NPOV policy, hateful and libellous edits, ] and (minor) vandalism. --] 15:34, 13 December 2005 (UTC)
*] - actions over block duration of {{user|Marsden}}.
*] - Abusive blocks made in violation of ]
*] - Dieter thinks he is above wiki law, revert wars by pushing unread references, blocks people at whim, makes racist comments towards millions of Indians and nasty towards new wikipedians unfamiliar with WP.
*] - Poor behavior in regards to content disputes, intimidates other users with admin status
* ]. Personal attacks, POV pushing, refusal to cite sources. ] 21:24, 12 December 2005 (UTC)
* ]. ], ], ], using multiple accounts and ip addresses on articles for deletion. ] 16:16, 10 December 2005 (UTC)
* ]. ], ], and ] violations. - ] <sup><small>]</small></sup> 20:30, 6 December 2005 (UTC)
* ], incivility, ethnic slurs, constant accusations of bad faith, hysteria, anti-Russian conspiracies, paranoia and bad faith, as well as numerous ad hominem remarks and personal attacks. ]] 00:02, 6 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] - Creation of racist, anti-Semitic, homophobic articles in Mainspace, vandalism of userspace, using IPs to avoid a block. Also makes productive edits. ] 03:04, 3 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] - refusal to discuss reverts, violated 3RR twice, possibly evaded IP block. -- ] ] 16:45, 2 December 2005 (UTC)
* ] &mdash; The user known as Roylee has carried out a sustained introduction of fringe theories and original research into a large number of articles since December 2004. &mdash; ] ] 10:15, 2 December 2005 (UTC)
* ]. Incivility, personal attacks, and vandalism using multiple sockpuppet accounts. ]] 00:19, 30 November 2005 (UTC)
* ]. ]. Anti-Semitic remark. Will not retract. -- ] | ] 01:49, 13 December 2005 (UTC)
*] - Unapproved deltions; incivility; revert warring - withdrawn 1 February 2006 by requestor due to cardstacking, overwhelming majority ] 05:45, 1 February 2006 (UTC)
*] - Deletion of userbox templates (this is a reformatted version by Phil Welch - the original can be found ]), Overwhelming consensus to end, see talk page.]|]
*], October 2005, grew stale.
*], October 2005, moved to arbitration.
*], October 2005, grew stale.
*] &ndash;incivility, disruption, harassment, policy violation, revert waring, personal attacks, legal threats, etc.--] 12:11, 16 October 2005 (UTC)
*] &ndash;incivility, disruption, harassment, revert waring--] | ] 19:54, 15 October 2005 (UTC)
*] &ndash; harrasment, vandalism, and policy violation. --] 09:16, 11 October 2005 (UTC)
*] &ndash; {after returning from 1 week block user is back to vandalizing talk pages}05:04, 8 October 2005 (UTC)
*]. User's repeated creation of nonsense articles and templates while being warned countless times about his disruption borders on trolling.] 05:19, 30 August 2005 (UTC)
*] &ndash; continues to revert against consensus, vandalising user Talk pages (including his own), violation of NPA, civility, and WP:POINT.
*] - Excessively and agressively reverts articles and talk pages, refuses to explain. --]<sup>(])</sup>] 04:01, 28 September 2005 (UTC)
*] - user suspected of sockpuppetry; also rude and pushing POV ] 11:30, 17 September 2005 (UTC)
*] Abuse of AFD process with short "NN, D" or "UE, D" nominations.
*] Constant push for editorial control over ], including removal of content not personally written by him without discussion. 13:51, 13 November 2005 (UTC). ''Uncertified after 48 hours, delisted.''
*] – disruption of mediation process, and incivility.
*] &ndash; Makes personal attacks for which he refuses to apologize; uses Talk pages as a chat group, with frequent, long, and irrelevant posts. ] 22:58, 2 October 2005 (UTC)
*] - users constantly disrupting ] (stale)
*] - Abuse of blocking policy
*] - POV pushing, original research, inability to reach consensus. ]|] 13:05, 18 September 2005 (UTC)
*] - Highly combative editor who ignores civility and frequently attacks those who disagree with him. --] 19:03, September 11, 2005 (UTC)
**The lot of these had been listed for over a month and a half and are assumed stale.
*]. Researcher99 has been unwilling to resolve disputes with Nereocystis on ] over many months. He has been asked multiple times over many months to discuss the text of the ] article and stop discussing what he perceives as past abuses and insults. ] 19:59, 30 August 2005 (UTC)
*] Monicasdude systematically reverts edits by all other editors of the ] article; has refused offer by administrator ] for informal mediation. See discussion at ]. 00:57, 2005 August 28 (UTC).
*]. Edit-warring, repeated 3RR violations, POV pushing, incivility, NPA, almost no discussion, use of WP as battleground. 02:17, 26 August 2005 (UTC)
*] pushing POV, ignoring consensus, vandalizing user pages
*] Defiance of NPOV policy to report views, insisting "Science is not a point of view."
*] - POV pusher, engages in aggressive personal attacks against others, misuses RfC pages to bully, intimidate and harrass
*] - Anonymous editor using multiple IP adresses in revert war, incivility, disregard for consensus
*] - Personal attacks, lack of civility, accusations of sockpuppetry, POV pushing with respect to members of the Kennedy family.
*] Gaming the system, disruption, attempting to promote his <nowiki>http://www.wikinerds.org/</nowiki> web site under the guise of "contributing" his own, copywrited material and demanding a prominent back link to his web site; plus personal attacks on ].
*] - Complete disregard for naming standards of British monarchs; was just anon IP, now has registered and is now moving pages around.
*] - Continued defiance of all editors who try to work with him, engaged in revenge reverts and filing of RfC, disruption and multiple 3RRs, trolling and stolking. --] 09:52, August 12, 2005 (UTC)
*] - Continued refusal to stop submitting single sentence articles borders on trolling. 18:03, August 9, 2005
*] - Continual defiance of Misplaced Pages style policies bordering on vandalism. 01:21, 9 August 2005 (UTC)
*] - Engaged in personal attacks, RfA fraud, article vandalism, userpage vandalism, misuse of CSD templates, sockpuppetry, insulting and/or attacking edit summaries, attacks on other users, particularly admins, who correct his actions. 23:33, August 7, 2005
*] - VfDing pages to illustrate a point, uploading copyrighted material then claiming fair use without citing source for verification, does not seem to respond to any communications left on talk page. 03:01, 29 July 2005 (UTC)
*] - Bulk VfDs, of which a large percentage are clearly not VfD material.
*] - Revert wars, 3RR violations, removing other users' comments, personal attacks. 01:52, July 27, 2005 (UTC)
*] - Lack of civility, using article talk pages as soapbox to extent of interfering with their use
*] - Disrupts Misplaced Pages to prove a point that "Admins are evil", and engages in frequent personal attacks, showing a general lack of conduct in the Wiki way. ] 14:53, 24 July 2005 (UTC) (RfA started 14:53, 24 July 2005 (UTC)
*] pushing POV, constant RV's to push POV. July 9.).
*] - Claiming ownership of article, POV pushing, 3RR violations in revert war over NPOV banner
*] - POV warrior, continual reverts and 3RR violations, refusal to work towards any kind of consensus, conflicts with multiple editors, is on a self-proclaimed crusade to purge wikipedia of what he considers improper views
*] - Edit warring on ], POV pushing, inappropriate behaviour.
*] - POV pushing, Revert-warring, Violation of 3RR, Lack of wikiquette, Not responding to constructive discussion, Ignoring comments.
*] - POV pushing, Revert-warring, Violation of 3RR, Lack of etiquette, Lack of wikiquette, Resorting to personal attacks, Abuse of (nonexistent) power, Not responding to constructive discussion, Ignoring comments and warnings, Utilizing anonymous IP addresses to further revert-war, Inability to procure evidence and support

*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - August 2005, grew stale
*] - grown stale
*] - closed due to user being perm banned for vandalism/disruption/edit warring/incivility
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - RfC closed following general agreement - WikiCivility generally improved allround.
*] - RfC closed after edits resolving NPOV problems were made on ] page
*] - no response in a number of weeks
*] - sent to RFAr.
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*]
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - grown stale
*] - sent to RFAr
*] - Sent to RFAr
*] - Went to Arbcom, but was rejected as being too obvious. User was permenantly blocked for disruptive edits.
*] - issue went to mediation, then to arbitration.
*The below were not officially concluded, but have been archived since they'd grown old and stale and nobody was adding to them any more.
**] - Ignoring attempts at dispute resolution over feelings that his recent use of VfD has been excessive
**] - disruptive behaviour, misunderstanding that WP works by consensus
**] - virulent personal attacks, lack of civility, POV warring, 3RR violations
**] - disruptive behaviour, personal attacks, misunderstanding that WP works by consensus
**] - Repeated personal attacks after being warned to stop, 3RR violations, false accusations of vandalism against other users
**] - Use of Misplaced Pages as a vehicle for self-promotion, personal attacks and general hostility towards those who have attempted to dissuade him of this practice, attempts to restore deleted article about self through use of anonymous IPs.
**] - At least two ] violations, several bits of vandalism
**] - One user alleges being constantly reverted by three experienced users who display incivility and territorial behavior about articles that have "stood the test of time". This includes asserting personal opinions over academic sources.
**] &mdash; user who has for some weeks been disrupting editing of a number of articles and making personal attacks on other editors
**] - vandal who has been banned on Hebrew Misplaced Pages, and is now trying to subvert the English Misplaced Pages. (most notable is the search engine fraud currently being committed on his user page)
** ] - ongoing disruptive behaviour, often in direct violation of Misplaced Pages policy.
**] - Repeated 3RR violations, edit warring, ignoring NPOV process, lack of civility
**] - inserting pro-Arab POV and personal attacks against users.
*] -Endless edit warring, 3RR violations, ignoring NPOV process, lack of civility - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*]
*]
*]
*] (admin)
*] (admin)
*]
*] and ] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*]
*]
*] - Allegations: Robbed ].
*]
*] -- Went to arbitration, see ]
*] (uploading of copyvio images, failure to provide source for images, attempts to defeat process for removal of images)
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*]
*]
*]
*] (personal attacks, connection with hoax article)
*] (general incivility, biting newcomer)
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] (edit warring / 3RR, false edits)
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] (image contributions with no copyright or source information)
*] (threats, personal attacks, use of anon editing and sock puppets to further disputes)
*] (blanking pages listed on VfD, incivility)
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] and ] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] (with respect to Manual of Style)
*]
*]
*]
*] - Went to arbitration under name of Jimmyvanthach, see ].
*] - Second listing also went to arbitration, see ].
*]
*]
*]
* ] - ] was blocked indefinitely.
*] (with respect to username)
*Guanaco4 - moved to ]
*]
*]
*] - matter resolved.
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*] - Bushit is no longer active.
*] (''that is not the actual username'') FoxNews appears to have left.
*] - Anti-Chen was blocked indefinitely for vandalism.
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]
*] & ] - Went to arbitration, see ].
*]
*] & ]
*]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ] and ].
*] - Went to arbitration, see ].
*]
*]
*] & ]
*]
*]
*]
*] - as per agreement of ]
*]
*]
*] - Discussion of various potentially offensive usernames.
*] (also covers ] ] and ] - other alleged identities include ] and ]).
*] - Arbitration committee has chosen to review Wik's case, see ].
*]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ].
*]
*] - Went to arbitration, see ]. Not an actual username, but the name of an individual using various IPs (see list in subpage).
*]
*]
*] (also separate pages at ] and ]) - ], but 168 has left Misplaced Pages.
*] (also earlier page at ]) - Went to arbitration, see ].
*] - Went to arbitration, see ].
*]
*]

==Earlier conflicts==
(moved here from Conflicts between users)

*] (] and ]): Moved to ]
*] (]): Moved to ]
*] (]): Moved to ]
*] (] and (Exploding Boy)): Moved to ]
*] and ] (]): Moved to ]
*] (Many users): Moved to]
*] (] and ]): Moved to ]
*] (]): Moved to ]
*] (RickK); Moved to ]
*] (Tannin and others): Moved to ]
*] (]): Moved to ]
*] (Theresa Knott and many others): Moved to ]
*] (]): Moved to ]
*] and ]: Moved to ]
*]

==Even earlier conflicts==
From ]:


]
* ]
]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]

Latest revision as of 20:54, 7 August 2021

This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference.
The WP:RFC/U process has been discontinued as a result of this discussion.
Other dispute resolution processes should be used for conduct issues.
Archiving icon
Archives

This page is for archiving user conduct disputes listed on Misplaced Pages:Requests for comment. Archived disputes should not be added to. Disputes should be archived under any of the following circumstances:

  1. If no additional complaints are registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
  2. The parties to the dispute agree.
  3. The dispute proceeds to another method of dispute resolution, such as mediation or arbitration.

If the dispute is handled in mediation or arbitration, please make a note of where the dispute resolution process continued.

Archived disputes

  • Newer entries towards the top
  • This page only displays user RFCs from the most recent year and the current year, older discussions can be found in the archives, a search box is provided above
  • As of March 25, 2013, the names of the certifiers are no longer a required field. You can find this information easily by clicking the link to the RFC itself.
Name Start date Description Notes
Atsme 24 October 2014 Canvassing, Ownership of Articles, Battleground behavior Closed due to lack of progress.
30 SW 26 August 2014 Copyright and sourcing issues 30 SW has not edited since just before the RFC was filed. RFC indefinitely suspended due to inactivity.
Dan56 July 29 2014 Copyright concerns, ownership of articles several participants blocked as socks, Dan56 reminded of relevant policies
Worldedixor 11 September 2014 Worldedixor's problematic manner in handling disputes Closed due to inactivity
Redrose64 15 October 2014 Page protection of template Page protection level reduced, RFC closed per request of filer.
Middayexpress 22 August 2014 Alleged POV pushing, page ownership, cherry-picking of sources Further discussion is recommended, possibly followed by a topic-ban request (at ANI) or arbitration if necessary.
24.0.133.234 11 March 2014 Inability for the IP to follow policy Delisted for inactivity and very little comments, no edits since day 2 of RFC.
Scholarlyarticles 28 February 2014 Aggressive lack of understanding and violations of various Misplaced Pages policies Involved and outside views; no response; closed due to inactivity. Uncertainty regarding whether subject retired from Misplaced Pages or not; recommendation to escalate dispute if issues persist in any case.
Arzel.2 11 January 2014 Issues "Whitewashing" not firmly established, but likely NPA violations are.
QuackGuru2 26 January 2014 Overzealous in efforts to stamp out what they consider fringe No clear consensus that user is disruptive in what is already a contentious area.
PrivateWiddle 15 February 2014 Dispute over user signatures Nearly all comments occurred within a week of original complaint. Clear consensus was that the signature was not offensive
Colton Cosmic 9 February 2014 Request for unblock, sockpuppetry issues Consensus is to leave the user blocked.
Oranjelo100 20 November 2013 Perform large numbers of edits, with relatively small amounts of actual changes to the articles and not using edit summaries. Closed due to inactivity and low participation.
Joefromrandb 15 August 2013 Long-term incivility, personal attacks, and edit-warring No conclusive outcomes, Misplaced Pages is not a battleground, edit warring is unconstructive
Baboon43 22 June 2013 Uncivil behavior, edit warring, and sock puppetry, mostly related to Islam topics Discussion went stale after a few weeks, with Baboon43 refusing to participate, before the issue was taken to AN, resulting in an indefinite block.
Arzel 13 May 2013 Talk page and behavioral issues Withdrawn after discussion on talk page of RfC/U
Folken de Fanel 30 April 2013 Problematic behaviour around AfDs and notability issues related to Dungeons & Dragons There was consensus that Folken's approach needs to change. The closing admin suggested that he agree to a voluntary topic ban regarding deletion issues in the problem area.
Jax 0677 29 March 2013 Problematic creation of navboxes and other content Some progress, later apparenrlty reversed. a proposal for a formal topic ban is anticipated
Will Beback 23 March 2013 To discuss whether Will should be allowed back to edit No consensus to overturn Arbcom decision
CartoonDiablo 20 January 2013 Tendentious editing/POV issues All participants other than the certifiers felt that this dispute was about content, not conduct
Apostle12 21 December 2012 Soapboxing, personal attacks, unreliable sources, canvassing Closed due to inactivity


Name Start date Description First two certifiers Notes
Cantaloupe2 31 January 2013 Concerns about civility, battlegrounding, and related conduct issues AndrewDressel, CorporateM Serious and valid problems with Cantaloupe2's conduct exist. The matter might be taken up by ArbCom.
Epeefleche 15 January 2013 Removal of unsourced content from articles Danjel, Graham87 Epeefleche is broadly correct to remove unsourced content, and Danjel has often acted wrongly in restoring unsourced content.
Also, Danjel's conduct is widely seen as hounding.
Categories: