| Revision as of 20:20, 14 May 2008 editRandom832 (talk | contribs)12,146 edits clarify← Previous edit | Latest revision as of 15:42, 21 August 2008 edit undoCBDunkerson (talk | contribs)Administrators15,422 edits Adding NOINDEX | ||
| (2 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| {{NOINDEX}} | |||
| Note also no evidence is provided of a community ban discussion having been held. | |||
| This page has been blanked as a courtesy. | |||
| ==Evidence of recruiting, directing meatpuppets to continue campaign from WikipediaReview== | |||
| * Example of Moulton's original editing campaign at ]: | |||
| * Moulton's article at WikipediaReview advocating continuing his campaign at ] and ]: | |||
| **Cannot be reasonably read as advocating anything. | |||
| *Moulton recruiting meat puppets at WikipediaReview: , and so on for 4 more pages... {{verify source}} | |||
| **Links 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11 verified as not supporting this assertion - they don't even contain any vague thoughts about what he thinks articles or other wikipedia pages should look like. | |||
| **Link 10 contains a vague statement that he believes an article has undue weight and ] issues - but does not propose any particular changes. | |||
| **Link 13 is an explanation of a proposal he made before being blocked - it could reasonably be misinterpreted as advocating that edit be made. | |||
| * Moulton stating he intends to bring the matter to the press: | |||
| **This link goes to a post by ]. To be fair, another post on the same page (link 8 above) does mention the press. | |||
| * A WikipediaReview editor arrives at ] walking in Moulton's footsteps, making the edits he's advocated: | |||
| * Moulton advising meatpuppets on edits on his behalf to scuttle a hard-won consensus{{fact}}: {{verify source}} | |||
| **Link is to a post about NotTheWikipediaWeekly. TBF, the comment at link 13 above (see above though for problems with this characterization of the comment) is on the same page. | |||
| * Brand new user making his first two edits matching Moulton's above requested content word-for-word within hours of Moulton's request: Same, acknowledging he's acted in response to Moulton's call: | |||
| * Acknowledgements of directing meatpuppets: {{verify source}} | |||
| **Acknowledges correspondence, does not state or imply that the nature of the correspondence includes directing anyone to edit articles. | |||
Latest revision as of 15:42, 21 August 2008
This page has been blanked as a courtesy.