Revision as of 22:28, 16 November 2008 view sourceLocke Cole (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, File movers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers18,893 edits →Dates: disputed per WP:MOSNUM← Previous edit | Latest revision as of 11:31, 25 December 2024 view source MichaelMaggs (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users, File movers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers43,924 edits Changing short description from "Guideline that is part of the English Misplaced Pages's Manual of Style" to "English Misplaced Pages guideline"Tag: Shortdesc helper | ||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|English Misplaced Pages guideline}} | |||
{{Mergefrom-multiple | CONTEXT | BUILD | discuss=WT:Only_make_links_that_are_relevant_to_the_context#Break 1 |date=October 2008 }} | |||
<noinclude>{{pp-move-indef}}</noinclude> {{For|technical information about link formatting|Help:Link}} | |||
{{style-guideline|WP:MOSLINK|MOS:LINK}} | |||
{{For|information on adding external links to articles|Misplaced Pages:External links}} | |||
{{pp-semi-indef|small=yes}} | |||
{{Style-guideline|MOS:L|WP:LINK|MOS:LINK|WP:MOSLINK}} | |||
{{Style}} | {{Style}} | ||
{{Linking and page manipulation|linking and diffs}} | |||
Linking |
'''Linking''' through ]s is an important feature of Misplaced Pages. ]s bind the project together into an ]. ] bind the project to sister projects such as ], ] and ] in other languages, and external links bind Misplaced Pages to the ]. | ||
Appropriate links provide instant pathways to locations within and outside the project that can increase readers' understanding of the topic at hand. Whenever writing or editing an article, consider not only what to put in the article, but what links to include to help the reader find related information, and also which other pages should have links {{em|to}} the article. Avoid both ] and ], as described below. | |||
== Internal links == | |||
{{see also|Misplaced Pages:Build the web}} | |||
Items in Misplaced Pages articles can be linked to other Misplaced Pages articles that provide information that significantly adds to readers' understanding of the topic. This can be done directly ("<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>", which results in "]"), or through a ''piped link'' ("<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>", which results in "]" in the text, but still links to the article "]"). | |||
This page provides guidelines as to when links should and should not be used, and how to format links. For information about the syntax used to create links, see ]. For links on ] pages, see ]. | |||
Internal links add to the cohesion and utility of Misplaced Pages by allowing readers to deepen their understanding of a topic by conveniently accessing other articles. These links should be included where it is most likely that readers might want to use them; for example, in article leads, the beginnings of new sections, table cells, and image captions. | |||
==<span id="General principles"></span> Principles== | |||
*Do not link items in the ] or headings. | |||
<!-- This span tag (subst'ed Anchor template) serves to provide a permanent target for incoming section links. Please do not move it out of the section heading. Please do not modify it, even if you modify the section title. It is always best to anchor an old section header that has been changed so that links to it won't be broken. See ] for details. (This text was substituted from ]) --> | |||
*Do not pipe links in ]. | |||
{{Redirect|WP:BUILD|the behavioral guideline|Misplaced Pages:Here to build an encyclopedia}} | |||
*Avoid placing two links next to each other in the text so that they look like one link (such as ] ]). | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:BTW|MOS:BUILD}} | |||
<!--* Individual words when a phrase has its own article. For example, link to "the ]" instead of "the ] of ]". Such a link is more likely to be interesting and helpful to the user, and almost certainly contains links to the more general terms, in this case, "flag" and "Tokelau". | |||
* A page that ] back to the page the link is on. These circular redirects are frustrating to readers. | |||
* Words in a ] ] other than to the disambiguation target itself. The general rule is "one link per entry" on a disambiguation page; additional links tend to confuse the reader. | |||
*A technical term, whether linked or unlinked, should usually be defined on its first occurrence if this can be worked into the sentence neatly and concisely. Do not rely on linking a term for its basic definition; the purpose of the link should be to ''more fully'' define it.--> | |||
Misplaced Pages is based on ], and aims to "build the web" to enable readers to access relevant information on other Misplaced Pages pages easily. The page from which the hyperlink is activated is called the ''anchor''; the page the link points to is called the ''target''. | |||
=== Overlinking and underlinking === | |||
{{main|Misplaced Pages:Only make links that are relevant to the context}} | |||
In adding or removing links, consider an article's place in the ]. Internal links can add to the cohesion and utility of Misplaced Pages, allowing readers to deepen their understanding of a topic by conveniently accessing other articles. Ask yourself, "How likely is it that the reader will also want to read that other article?" Consider including links where readers might want to use them; for example, in article ], at the openings of new sections, in the cells of ], and in ]. But as a rule of thumb, ] in the text of the article. | |||
Many articles are '']'' or '']''. An article is likely to be considered underlinked if subjects are not linked that are necessary to the understanding of the article. An article may be overlinked if any of the following is true: | |||
* There are links to articles that are not likely to exist, or if they did would have little significance in the context of the article; | |||
* Low added-value items are linked without reason—such as ], ], and ]. | |||
* A link for any single term is excessively repeated in the same article. "Excessive" typically means more than once for the same term in an article. The purpose of links is to direct the reader to a new spot at a point where the reader is most likely to take a temporary detour due to a need for more information; this is usually on the first occurrence of the term, although the subsequent linking of an important item distant from its previous occurrence in an article may occasionally be appropriate in a table or in a subsection to which readers may jump directly, either within the article or via a section-link from another article. | |||
=== |
===General points on linking style=== | ||
{{Shortcut|MOS:LINKSTYLE|MOS:INTERNAL}} | |||
{{shortcut|WP:EGG}} | |||
* As explained in more detail at {{section link|Help:Link|Wikilinks}}, linking can be ''direct'' (<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>, which results in {{xt|]}}), or ''piped'' (<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>, which results in {{xt|]}} in the text, but still links to the article "]"—although the ] is an easier way to create this particular link). | |||
It is possible to ] that are not exactly the same as the linked article title—for example, <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>. However, make sure that it is still clear what the link refers to without having to follow the link. | |||
* {{Shortcut|MOS:HEADINGLINK}}{{anchor|No links in headers}}Section headings should not themselves contain links; instead, a {{tl|main}} or {{tl|see also}} template should be placed immediately after the heading. | |||
* Links should not be placed in the ] in the opening sentence of a lead.{{efn|1=Many, but not all, articles repeat the article title in bold face in the first line of the article. Linking the article to itself produces '''boldface text'''; this practice is discouraged as page moves result in a useless circular link through a redirect. Linking ''part'' of the bolded text is also discouraged because it changes the visual effect of bolding; some readers can miss the visual cue which is the purpose of using bold face in the first place.}} | |||
* {{Shortcut|MOS:NOLINKQUOTE}}{{anchor|Linking quotations}}Be conservative when linking within quotations; link only to targets that correspond to the meaning clearly intended by the quote's author. Where possible, link from text outside of the quotation instead – either before it or soon after.{{efn|1=If quoting hypertext that includes a Misplaced Pages link particularly salient to the quote's use, a {{xt|}} editorial note may be added. {{xt|}} notes should generally be avoided, because if the clarification is needed badly enough to justify disrupting the flow of text, the link is probably not conservative and should be omitted.}} | |||
* {{Shortcut|MOS:SOB|MOS:SEAOFBLUE|MOS:WINGSUIT}}{{anchor|Sea of blue|Dribbles of blue|Wingsuit combat}}When possible, do not place links next to each other, to avoid appearing like a single link, as in ] ] (<code><nowiki>] ]</nowiki></code>). Instead, consider rephrasing the sentence (] of ]), omitting one of the links (] tournament), or using a single, more specific link as in ] (<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>). | |||
* {{Shortcut|MOS:GEOLINK}}{{anchor|Geographic places}}For a geographical location expressed as a sequence of two or more territorial units, link only the first unit. | |||
**For example, avoid | |||
*:{{cross}}], ] (<code><nowiki>], ]</nowiki></code>) | |||
*::or | |||
*:{{cross}}], ], ] (<code><nowiki>], ], ]</nowiki></code>) | |||
*::or | |||
*:{{cross}}], ], ] (<code><nowiki>], ], ]</nowiki></code>) | |||
**Instead, use | |||
*:{{tick}}], Australia (<code><nowiki>], Australia</nowiki></code>) | |||
*::or | |||
*:{{tick}}], South Lanarkshire, Scotland (<code><nowiki>], South Lanarkshire, Scotland</nowiki></code>) | |||
*::or | |||
*:{{tick}}], United States (<code><nowiki>], United States</nowiki></code>) | |||
* Linked text should avoid leading and trailing spaces. Punctuation, including spaces, should be external to the linked items. | |||
* Articles on technical subjects might demand a higher density of links than general-interest articles, because they are likely to contain more technical terms that general dictionaries are unlikely to explain in context. | |||
* Beware of linking to an article without first confirming that the target article covers the appropriate topic. For example, an article mentioning the physics unit "barn" should link to ], not ]. | |||
* {{Shortcut|MOS:DRAFTNOLINK}}{{anchor|Draft space}}In articles, do not link to pages outside the article ], except in articles about Misplaced Pages itself (and even in that case with care{{snd}}see ]). | |||
* Do not unnecessarily make a reader chase links: if a highly technical term can be simply explained with very few words, do so. | |||
* {{Shortcut|MOS:NOFORCELINK|MOS:FORCELINK|}}{{anchor|Forced links}} Use a link when appropriate, but as far as possible do not force a reader to use that link to understand the sentence. The text needs to make sense to readers who cannot follow links. Users may print articles or read offline, and Misplaced Pages content may be encountered in ], often without links. | |||
* Refrain from implementing ] that may impede user ability to distinguish links from regular text, or color links for purely aesthetic reasons. | |||
===<span id="Internal links: overlinking and underlinking"></span> Overlinking and underlinking=== | |||
When forming plurals, do so thus: <code><nowiki>]s</nowiki></code>. This is clearer to read in wiki form than<code><nowiki> ]</nowiki></code>—and easier to type. This syntax is also applicable to adjective constructs such as <code><nowiki>]n</nowiki></code> and the like. Hyphens and apostrophes must be included in the link to show as part of the same word. For example, <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> or <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>. Keeping possessive apostrophes inside the link, where possible, makes for more readable text and source, though either form is acceptable for possessive forms of links such as <code><nowiki>]'s</nowiki></code> or <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>. | |||
<!-- The span tags (subst'ed Anchor templates) in this section serve to provide a permanent target for incoming section links. Please do not move them out of the subsection headings. Please do not modify them, even if you modify the subsection titles. It is always best to anchor an old section header that has been changed so that links to it won't be broken. See ] for details. (This text: ]) --> | |||
{{redirect|WP:CONTEXT|context in the lead of a biography|MOS:CONTEXTBIO|subject context in articles|WP:AUDIENCE}} | |||
{{For|notices that can be added to articles|Template:Overlinked|Template:Underlinked}} | |||
====<span id="Underlinking"></span>What generally should be linked==== | |||
Links are not sensitive to initial capitalization (see below), so pipe-linking to fix a capitalization problem should never be necessary. Rather, it is most simple to directly use the form that is most readable in the clear text. | |||
{{Redirect|MOS:UL|unordered lists|Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Lists#Embedded lists|underlining|Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Text formatting#How not to apply emphasis}} | |||
<!-- This span tag (subst'ed Anchor template) serves to provide a permanent target for incoming section links. Please do not move it out of the section heading. Please do not modify it, even if you modify the section title. It is always best to anchor an old section header that has been changed so that links to it won't be broken. See ] for details. (This text: ]) --> | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:UL|MOS:UNDERLINK}} | |||
An article is said to be ''underlinked'' if unlinked words are needed to aid understanding of the article. In general, links should be created for: | |||
Avoid ] links from "year" to "year ''something''" or "''something'' year" (e.g., <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>) in the main prose of an article in most cases. Use an explicit cross-reference, e.g., <code><nowiki>''(see ])''</nowiki></code>, if it is appropriate to link a year to such an article at all. However, piped links may be useful: | |||
* Relevant connections to the subject of another article that help readers understand the article more fully (see ] below). This can include people, events, and topics that already have an article or that clearly deserve one, as long as the link is relevant to the article in question. | |||
*in places where compact presentation is important (some tables, infoboxes and lists); and | |||
* Articles with relevant information, for example: "{{xt|see ] for relevant background}}" | |||
*in the main prose of articles in which such links are used heavily, as is often the case with sports biographies that link to numerous season articles. | |||
* Articles explaining words of technical terms, jargon or slang expressions or phrases—but you could also give a concise definition instead of or in addition to a link. If there is no appropriate Misplaced Pages article, an ] to ] could be used. | |||
* ]s that are likely to be unfamiliar to readers | |||
If you feel that a link is relevant to the topic of the article but does not belong in the body of an article, consider moving it to a ]. | |||
Do not use a ] to avoid otherwise legitimate redirect targets that fit well within the scope of the text. This assists in determining when a significant number of references to redirected links warrant more detailed articles. | |||
Links may be created to potential articles that do not yet exist (see {{section link||Red links}}). If an article exists on a non-English language Misplaced Pages but not yet in English, consider a red link that also links to the non-English language article (see {{section link|Help:Interlanguage links|Inline links}}). | |||
Automated processes should not pipe links to redirects. Instead, the link should always be examined in context. For more information, see ], ], and ]. | |||
==== <span id="Overlinking"></span> What generally should not be linked ==== | |||
Keep piped links as intuitive as possible. Do not use piped links to create "] links", that require the reader to follow them before understanding what's going on. Also remember that there are people who print the articles. For example, do not write this: | |||
<!-- This span tag (subst'ed Anchor template) serves to provide a permanent target for incoming section links. Please do not move it out of the section heading. Please do not modify it, even if you modify the section title. ---> | |||
:...and by mid-century the puns and sexual humor were (with only a few <nowiki>]</nowiki>) back in to stay. | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:OL|MOS:OVERLINK}} | |||
The readers will not see the hidden reference to ] unless they click or hover over the piped ] link—in a print version, there is no link to select, and the reference is lost. Instead, reference the article explicitly by using a "see also" or by rephrasing: | |||
:...and by mid-century the puns and sexual humor were (with only a few exceptions; <nowiki>see ]</nowiki>) back in to stay. | |||
:...and by mid-century the puns and sexual humor were back in to stay, <nowiki>]</nowiki> being an exception. | |||
An article is said to be ''overlinked'' if it contains an excessive number of links, making it difficult to identify those likely to aid a reader's understanding.<ref>{{cite magazine |author-link= John C. Dvorak |last=Dvorak |first=John C. |title=Missing Links |work=] |date=April 16, 2002 |url= https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1759,33326,00.asp |access-date=August 16, 2021 |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20110806041207/https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,33326,00.asp |archive-date=August 6, 2011}}</ref>{{efn|1=A ] found that "in the English Misplaced Pages, of all the 800,000 links added ... in February 2015, the majority (66%) were not clicked even a single time in March 2015, and among the rest most links were clicked only very rarely", and that "simply adding more links does not increase the overall number of clicks taken from a page. Instead, links compete with each other for user attention." This was reported in: {{cite conference |first1=Ashwin |last1=Paranjape |first2=Bob |last2=West |first3=Jure |last3=Leskovec |first4=Leila |last4=Zia |contribution=Improving Website Hyperlink Structure Using Server Logs |title=WSDM'16: Proceedings of the Ninth ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining |date=February 22–25, 2016 |publisher=] |location=San Francisco |url= http://infolab.stanford.edu/~west1/pubs/Paranjape-West-Leskovec-Zia_WSDM-16.pdf |isbn=9781450337168 |doi=10.1145/2835776.2835832}} }} <span id="Familiar terms"></span>A good question to ask yourself is whether reading the article you're about to link to would help someone understand the article you are linking from. Unless a term is particularly relevant to the context in the article, words and terms understood by most readers in context are usually not linked. Be conscious of your own ] when determining whether certain terms have this level of recognizability{{snd}}what is well known in your age group, line of work, or country may be less so for others. Examples include: | |||
Similarly, use: | |||
* Everyday words (e.g., education, violence, aircraft, river) | |||
:After an earlier disaster (''see ]''),... | |||
* Common occupations (e.g., accountant, politician, actor) | |||
:"After the earlier ],... | |||
* ], often those relating to time, temperature, length, area, or volume. If both non-metric and metric equivalents are given, as in {{xt|{{convert|5|cm|in|0}}}}, usually neither unit needs to be linked, because almost all readers understand at least one of the units. | |||
'''not''' | |||
* Dates {{crossref|(see {{section link||Chronological items}}, below)}} | |||
:After an ],... | |||
* ] pages should not be linked from articles unless ], such as in a hatnote. Instead, use a ] to the appropriate article. For example, use {{mxt|{{y}}<nowiki>]</nowiki>}} for the Disney character, which appears as ] and leads to the intended page{{emdash}}instead of {{!mxt|{{n}}<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}, which appears identical but leads to a disambiguation page. | |||
In addition, {{em|major}} examples of the following categories should generally not be linked: | |||
* Countries (e.g., Brazil/Brazilian, Canada/Canadian, China/Chinese) | |||
* Geographic features (e.g., the Himalayas, Pacific Ocean, South America) | |||
* Settlements or municipalities (e.g., New Delhi; New York City, or just New York if the city context is already clear; London, if the context rules out ]; Southeast Asia) | |||
* Languages (e.g., English, Arabic, Korean, Spanish) | |||
* Nationalities, ethnicities or identities (e.g., British, Japanese, Turkish, African American, Nigerian) | |||
* Religions (e.g., Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism) | |||
Links may be excessive even if they are informative. For example, because inline links present relatively small tap targets on touchscreen devices, placing several separate inline links close together within a section of text can make navigation more difficult for readers, especially if they have limited dexterity or coordination. Balance readability, information, and accessibility when adding multiple links in one section of text. As of 2024, most stub articles average two links per sentence, or about 10 to 20 links total. Most longer articles average somewhere around one link per 20 words. The lead of an article usually has a greater density of links than later parts of the article. | |||
Piped links should be honest, rather than introducing "subtext". For example, the two sentences: | |||
:"He ] the allegation." | |||
and | |||
:"He denied the ]." | |||
are identical on the surface, but the links imply two opposite readings. In this example, neither link is appropriate. | |||
{{Anchor|Circular|Circ}} | |||
Linking to ] can be useful, since it can take the reader immediately to the information that is most focused on the original topic. Links to a subheading on a page are denoted by a # symbol between the page title and the subheading (<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>). For example, to link to the "Culture" subsection of the ] article, type <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>. When naming a ], think about what the reader will believe the link is about; in this example, the piped section-link should not be named "Oman", because the reader will think that link goes to the general article on Oman. | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:CIRCULAR|MOS:CIRC}} | |||
Do not link to pages that ] the link is on (unless the link is to a ] that links to an appropriate ''section'' of the current article). | |||
The purpose of linking is to clarify and to provide reasonable navigation opportunities, not to emphasize a particular word. Do not link solely to draw attention to certain words or ideas, or as a mark of respect. | |||
=== Precision === | |||
Links should use the most precise target that arises in the context, even where the target is a simple redirect to a less specific page. For example, link to "]" rather than "] engine". | |||
External links normally should not be placed in the body of an article (see ]). | |||
=== Red links === | |||
====<span id="Repeated links"></span><span id="DUPLINK"></span> Duplicate and repeat links==== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:REPEATLINK|MOS:LINKONCE|MOS:DUPLICATELINK|MOS:DUPLINK|MOS:DL|MOS:REFLINK|WP:LINKFIRST}} | |||
Link a term at most once per major section,{{efn|1=Major sections are generally detailed sections with a level-2 heading, but consensus at an article may determine a lower-level subsection is major, especially when a preceding subsection is especially long, when an article's structure puts most content under level-3 headings with level-2 ones primarily used for thematic grouping, or when a subsection is a link target at which many readers arrive directly.}} at first occurrence. Common sense applies; do not re-link in other sections if not contextually important there. Other mentions may be linked if helpful, such as in ], ], ], ], and ]. | |||
] stand alone in their usage, so there is no problem with repeating the same link in many citations within an article; e.g. <code><nowiki>|work=]</nowiki></code>. | |||
In ], which are primarily referred to for encyclopedic entries on specific terms rather than read from top to bottom like a regular article, it is usually desirable to repeat links (including to other terms in the glossary) that were not already linked in the same entry {{crossref|(see ])}}. | |||
Duplicate linking in ] is permissible if it significantly aids the reader. This is most often the case when the list is presenting information that could just as aptly be formatted in a table, and is expected to be parsed for particular bits of data, not read from top to bottom. If the list is normal article prose that happens to be formatted as a list, treat it as normal article prose. | |||
Duplicate links in an article can be found using the ] sidebar tool. | |||
====Lead section==== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:LEADLINK}} | |||
{{for|links in the first sentence|Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Lead section#Contextual links}} | |||
Too many links can make the lead hard to read. In technical articles that use uncommon terms, a higher-than-usual link density in the ] may be necessary. In such cases, try to provide an informal explanation in the lead, avoiding using too many technical terms until later in the article. (See ] and ].) | |||
Most ] contain about 12 to 25 links in the lead, with an average of about 1.5 links per sentence, or one link for every 16 words.<ref>{{cite web |title=User:WhatamIdoing/Sandbox 3 |date=January 30, 2023 |url= https://en.wikipedia.org/search/?title=User:WhatamIdoing/Sandbox_3&oldid=1136368242 |work=Misplaced Pages |edition=English |access-date=August 31, 2023}}</ref> | |||
====<span class="anchor" id="An example article"></span>An example article==== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:LE|MOS:LINKEXAMPLES|MOS:EXAMPLELINKS|MOS:COMMONWORDS}} | |||
For example, in the article on ]: | |||
* Almost certainly link "]" and "]", as these are technical terms that many readers are unlikely to understand at first sight. | |||
* Consider linking "]" and "]" only if these common words have technical dimensions that are specifically relevant to the topic. | |||
* Do not link to the "United States", because that is an article on a very broad topic with no direct connection to supply and demand. | |||
* Definitely do not link "wheat", because it is a common term with no particular relationship to the article on supply and demand, beyond its arbitrary use as an example of traded goods in that article. | |||
* Make sure that the links are directed to the correct articles: in this example, you should link ], not ], which goes to a page on the philosophical concept. Many common dictionary words are ambiguous terms in Misplaced Pages and linking to them is often unhelpful to readers; "Good" is a surname and the name of albums, companies, etc., and the article title ] is used to index those. | |||
===Link clarity=== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:LINKCLARITY}} | |||
{{See also|#Piped links}} | |||
The article linked to should correspond as closely as possible to the term showing as the link, given the context. | |||
For example, a link to the article ] should be clear that it is Mozart's Requiem in particular, rather than requiems in general. The link target and the link label do not have to match exactly, but the link must be as intuitive as possible (see {{slink||Intuitiveness}}). | |||
{| class="wikitable" | |||
! | |||
! Article text | |||
! ] | |||
! Note | |||
|- | |||
|{{tick}} | |||
| When Mozart wrote ] | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>When Mozart wrote ]</syntaxhighlight> | |||
| Includes the word "his" to specify | |||
|- | |||
|{{cross}} | |||
| When Mozart wrote his ] | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>When Mozart wrote his ]</syntaxhighlight> | |||
| Only word "Requiem" | |||
|- | |||
|{{tick}} | |||
| Previn conducted ] | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>Previn conducted ]</syntaxhighlight> <br/> '''or''' <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>Previn conducted ]</syntaxhighlight> | |||
| Specifying that it is "Mozart's" | |||
|- | |||
|{{cross}} | |||
| Previn conducted Mozart's ] | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>Previn conducted Mozart's ]</syntaxhighlight> | |||
| Only word "Requiem" | |||
|} | |||
===Link specificity=== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:SPECIFICLINK}} | |||
Always link to the article on the most specific topic appropriate to the context from which you link: it generally contains more focused information, as well as links to more general topics. | |||
{| class="wikitable" | |||
! What you type | |||
! How it appears | |||
! Specificity | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>]</syntaxhighlight> || ] | |||
| Specific (preferred) | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>] orthography</syntaxhighlight> || ] orthography | |||
| Related but less specific | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>Icelandic ]</syntaxhighlight> || Icelandic ] | |||
| Unspecific | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>the ]</syntaxhighlight>|| the ] | |||
| Specific (preferred) | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>the ] of ]</syntaxhighlight> || the ] of ] | |||
| Unspecific | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>]</syntaxhighlight>|| ] | |||
| Specific (preferred) | |||
|- | |||
| <syntaxhighlight lang="wikitext" inline>]</syntaxhighlight>|| ] | |||
| Unspecific | |||
|} | |||
If there is no article about the most specific topic, do one of the following things: | |||
* Consider ] yourself. | |||
* If an article on the specific topic does not yet exist, create a redirect page to the article about a more general topic, as described in section {{section link||Redirects}}. For example, if no article yet exists on the song "Sad Statue" from the album ''Mezmerize'', create a new article called ] that is a redirect to the article '']''. | |||
* If there is no article on a more general topic either, then create a ], but first, read {{section link||Red links}} below. | |||
When neither a redirect nor a red link appears appropriate, consider linking to a more general article instead. | |||
For example, instead of | |||
<p>{{cross}}{{xt|]}} (an article which, as of 2023, had never been created),</p> | |||
write | |||
<p>{{tick}}{{xt|] hairstyles}} (which provides a link to the Baroque era),</p> | |||
<p>{{tick}}{{xt|Baroque ]s}} (which provides a link to the article on hairstyle),</p> | |||
<p>{{tick}}{{xt|Baroque hairstyles}} (which provides no link at all, and which may be preferable depending on context),</p> | |||
or | |||
<p>{{tick}}{{xt|]s of the ]}} (which provides separate links to both topics);</p> | |||
however, do not create | |||
<p>{{cross}}{{xt|] ]s}} as ] because they may be misinterpreted as linking to a single article on that topic.</p> | |||
====Section links==== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:SECTIONLINKS|MOS:SECLINK|MOS:SL}} | |||
{{Further|Help:Link#Section linking (anchors)|Help:Section#Section linking}} | |||
If an existing article has a section specifically about a topic, linking to that section takes the reader directly to the relevant information. Section-linking options are ], ], and the {{tlx|Section link}} template, which also generates the {{char|§}} character. | |||
====<span id="Broken section links"><span id="RENAMESECTION">Avoiding broken section links</span></span>==== | |||
{{shortcut |MOS:RENAMESECTION |MOS:BROKENSECTIONLINKS}} | |||
A problem can arise if the title of the section is changed for any reason, because this action breaks any incoming section links or ]. (If this occurs, incoming links default to the top of the linked article.) The ] to prevent this breakage is to use a {{tlxs|Anchor}} template specifying the section's prior name. | |||
{{anchor|HIDDENLINKADVICE}}{{shortcut|MOS:HIDDENLINKADVICE}} | |||
An alternative, supplementary method has been to add a hidden comment to the target section such as {{nowrap|<code><nowiki><!-- "Quark" links here --></nowiki></code>}}{{efn|1=The hidden message (<code><nowiki><!-- "Article" links here --></nowiki></code>) must be added to the target section with a break between the header and the hidden message, or problems arise. Note the two lines:<br /> | |||
<code><nowiki>==Target section==</nowiki></code><br /> | |||
<code><nowiki><!-- "Article" links here --></nowiki></code><br /> | |||
See ] for further information about valid and invalid placement of heading comments.}} so that someone changing the title of that section can fix the incoming links. This method is weaker, since it puts the workload on the editor seeking to change the section title. | |||
There are some bots aimed to fix broken anchors: ], {{U|Dexbot}}, and {{U|FrescoBot}}. | |||
==Techniques== | |||
===Redirects=== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:RDR|MOS:REDIR}} | |||
{{Main|Misplaced Pages:Redirect}} | |||
Suppose you need to link ''poodle'', and there is no such article yet. You might want to create a redirect from "poodle" to "dog" as follows: Link as usual: <code><nowiki>She owned a ]</nowiki></code>. When you save or preview this, you see: {{xt|She owned a ]}}. Follow the red link, and you are invited to create a new page for ''poodle''; enter (perhaps) <code><nowiki>#REDIRECT ]</nowiki></code>, so that readers clicking on ''poodle'' are taken, for now, to the dog article. | |||
The redirect ] in a case like this than a direct link like <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>, because when an actual ''poodle'' article is eventually created (replacing the redirect), readers following the ''poodle'' link are taken there automatically without anyone needing to review all the links to ''dog'' to see which ones should actually go to ''poodle''. | |||
To link to a redirect page without following the underlying redirect, use e.g. <code><nowiki>{{no redirect|poodle}}</nowiki></code>. | |||
Avoid linking redirects that are ] (]). | |||
===Piped links=== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:PIPE|MOS:PIPEDLINK}} | |||
{{Further information|Misplaced Pages:Piped link}}<!--not a policy or guideline--> | |||
Though a wikilink defaults to displaying the title of the target article, it is possible to choose more specific or more appropriate display text for the intended context. This can be done with the use of the pipe character ('''|'''). For example, {{xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}} displays as {{xt|]}}. However, make sure that it is still clear what the link is about without having to follow the link. Think about what the reader may believe the text refers to. For example, when seeing the link {{xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}}, which displays as {{xt|]}}, the reader would probably expect this link to go to a general article on ], rather than {{xt|]}} specifically. An exception to this is when it is clear from the context that a link refers to a specific article; for instance, in {{xt|]}} all links go to articles about these particular games. | |||
====Style==== | |||
{{shortcut|MOS:PIPESTYLE}} | |||
* '''Plurals and other derived names.''' {{xt|<code><nowiki>]s</nowiki></code>}} displays as {{xt|]s}}, and this is simpler and clearer than {{xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}}. Similarly: {{xt|<code><nowiki>]ing</nowiki></code>}}, {{xt|<code><nowiki>]ed</nowiki></code>}}, {{xt|<code><nowiki>]dest</nowiki></code>}}. Some characters do not work after the link; see ] for more details. | |||
* '''Case sensitivity.''' Links are not sensitive to initial capitalization, so there is no need to use the pipe character where the case of the initial letter is the only difference between the link text and the target page. (Misplaced Pages article titles almost always begin with a capital, whereas the linked words in context often do not.) However, links are case-sensitive for all characters after the initial one. | |||
====Intuitiveness==== | |||
{{redirect|MOS:EGG|text=You may also be looking for ]}} | |||
{{shortcut|MOS:EGG|MOS:EASTEREGG|MOS:SUBMARINE}}{{Anchor|EGG|SUBMARINE|ASTONISH}} | |||
] | |||
Keep piped links as intuitive as possible. Per the ], make sure that the reader knows what to expect when following a link. You should plan your page structure and links so that everything appears reasonable and makes sense. | |||
A link's visible label does not need to match the exact title of the article being linked, such as in {{Mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}} or {{Mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}. However, avoid "]" or "submarine" links, which are links that unexpectedly hide relevant information underneath the link's label. For example, do not write:<br />{{in5}}<code>{{!mxt|Richard Feynman was also known for work in <nowiki>]</nowiki>.}}</code><br />Here readers would see the link displayed as {{xt|]}}, not the hidden reference to the page {{xt|]}}, unless they followed the link or inspected the target title e.g. by ] it. If a physical copy of the article were printed, or the article saved as an audio file, the reference to the parton model would be lost. | |||
Instead, refer to the separate article with an explicit ''see also X'', or by rephrasing the sentence, as in:<br />{{in5}}<code>{{mxt|Richard Feynman was also known for work in <nowiki>]</nowiki>, especially the <nowiki>]</nowiki> model.}}</code> | |||
====More words into a link==== | |||
{{shortcut|MOS:MORELINK|MOS:MORELINKWORDS}}{{Anchor|MORELINK|MORELINKWORDS}} | |||
Sometimes moving other words into the bluelinked text avoids surprise. | |||
For example, in an article on the history of Texas:<br />{{in5}}<code>{{!mxt|In 1845, the Republic of Texas was <nowiki>]</nowiki> by the United States.}}</code><br>appears as:<br>{{in5}}In 1845, the Republic of Texas was ] by the United States.<br> | |||
which looks the same as a link to the generic topic of ] would.<br />However:<br>{{in5}}<code>{{mxt|In 1845, the <nowiki>]</nowiki> by the United States.}}</code><br> | |||
appears as:<br>{{in5}}In 1845, the ] by the United States.<br> | |||
and is clear that the 1845 annexation of Texas is linked. | |||
====Names in names==== | |||
{{shortcut|MOS:LINKINNAME|MOS:PARTIALNAMELINK}} | |||
Do not place a link to a name within another name. For example: | |||
{| style="text-align:right; margin-left:44.8px" | |||
! Write: | |||
| <code>{{mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code> || → ] | |||
|- | |||
! Do not write: | |||
| <code>{{!mxt|<nowiki>] Avenue</nowiki>}}</code> || → ] Avenue | |||
|- | |||
! Write: | |||
| <code>{{mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code> || → ] | |||
|- | |||
! Do not write: | |||
| <code>{{!mxt|<nowiki>] diagram</nowiki>}}</code> || → ] diagram | |||
|} | |||
The above applies regardless of whether linking to the full name creates a ]; for example, even if there is no article titled ]: | |||
{| style="text-align:right; margin-left:44.8px" | |||
! Do not write: | |||
| <code>{{!mxt|<nowiki>] Avenue</nowiki>}}</code> || → ] Avenue | |||
|} | |||
See also {{slink||Link clarity}}. | |||
====Piping and redirects<span class="anchor" id="NOPIPE"></span><span class="anchor" id="Piping and redirects"></span>==== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:NOPIPE|MOS:DYKPIPE}} | |||
As per ] and {{section link||Link specificity}} above, do not use a piped link where it is possible to use a redirected term that fits well within the scope of the text. For example, the page {{xt|]}} is a redirect to the article about Mozart's opera '']'' (since Papageno is a character in The Magic Flute). While editing some other article, you might want to link the term {{xt|Papageno}}; here, you might be tempted to avoid the redirect by using a pipe within the link, as in {{!xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}}. Instead, write simply {{xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}} and let the system handle the rest. This has two advantages: first, if an article is written later about the more specific subject (in this case, "Papageno", the character), fewer links need to be changed to accommodate the new article; second, it indicates that the article is ]. | |||
An exception to this rule is when linking to articles in ] (DYK) "]" ], where piping links to prevent readers from seeing a redirect notice is preferable, and the hook is live only for a short time. {{crossref|(See also {{section link|WP:Piped link#When not to use}}.)}} | |||
====<span id="Linking to sections of articles"></span> Piped links and redirects to sections of articles==== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:SECTLINK}} | |||
{{See|#Section links|Help:Link#Section linking (anchors)|Misplaced Pages:Redirect#Targeted and untargeted redirects}} | |||
As ], links to sections can take the reader directly to relevant information. | |||
'''''Piped links.''''' | |||
Using a piped link to sections avoids the unsightly ''Article name#Section name'' in the display text. | |||
The format for a piped link is <code>{{mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code>. For example, to link to the "Culture" subsection of the article ], type | |||
* <code>{{mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code> (note that the section name is case-sensitive), | |||
which displays as {{xt|]}}. Then add a ] to the target section such as <code><nowiki><!--</nowiki> The article {{var|ArticleName}} links here. <nowiki>--></nowiki></code> so that if another user edits the title of that section, they can fix the incoming links (or, in cases where a section has a large number of incoming links, use {{tlx|Anchor}} on the anchor page). | |||
To link to a section within the same article, write: <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>. | |||
'''''Redirects to sections which may become articles.''''' | |||
Many topics useful for linking may currently appear only as sections of other Misplaced Pages articles, but are potentially notable enough to become articles on their own. For example, the article {{xt|Eastern Anyshire}} might have a small "History" section, but this does not prevent the article {{xt|History of Eastern Anyshire}} being written eventually. A ] page from such a sub-topic to a general topic may exist already; if not, a redirect can be created when the occasion arises. It is bad practice to create links in article text using the format <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>; navigation then becomes difficult if the section is expanded into a new article. Instead, link using a redirect to the main topic; ] and makes improvements easier. Thus: | |||
* In a redirect page named "<samp>History of {{var|Topic}}</samp>", use <code>{{mxt|#REDIRECT <nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code>. | |||
* In another article, use <code>{{mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code>. | |||
* Avoid: <code>{{!mxt|<nowiki>]</nowiki>}}</code>. | |||
==== Links to non-English language pages ==== | |||
See {{section link|Help:Interlanguage links|Inline links}}. | |||
===Links to Misplaced Pages's categories=== | |||
{{See also|Misplaced Pages:Colon trick}} | |||
Misplaced Pages has categories of articles; for example, "Phrases". Adding the wikitext {{xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}} to an article will add that article to the category "Phrases". (This will not create any visible addition to the body text of the article.) | |||
If you instead want to create a visible link to a category, add a colon in front of the word "Category". For example, {{xt|<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code>}} creates the link ]. As with other links, piping can be used: ]. | |||
The {{tl|See also cat}} template can be used instead: | |||
{{xt|<code><nowiki>{{See also cat|Phrases}}</nowiki></code>}} creates: {{See also cat|Phrases}} | |||
===Red links=== | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:REDLINKS|MOS:REDLINK|MOS:RL}} | |||
{{Main|Misplaced Pages:Red link}} | {{Main|Misplaced Pages:Red link}} | ||
An internal link that displays <font color=#CC2200>]</font> points to a page that does not exist by that name. This will be for one of the following reasons: | |||
#an article has not yet been created there; or | |||
#there is a misspelling or plural left inside the link brackets; <!--example needed--> | |||
#an article on that topic has a different title and needs a ], or (more commonly) an easy and intuitive ]. <!--example needed--> | |||
Overlinking in general is a style issue partly because of the undesirable effect upon readability. But if too many ''blue'' links is distracting, then a ''red'' link is even more so. The ''unassuming'' coloration of the text (probably black) is the most productive. | |||
Thus, many red links point to "buds" from which Misplaced Pages will grow in the future (Number 1), while others signify fixable problems (Numbers 2 and 3). | |||
An example would be <font color=#CC2200>]</font>, which can be easily changed via piped link to the correct ]. If a red link is within the context of the article, and it is a topic with the potential to eventually be a ], ] ], then the link should be kept as an invitation for an editor to begin the appropriate article with this title. Such links do not have an expiration date, beyond which they must be "fixed". | |||
In prose, if it seems that the level of red linking is overlinking, remember that red links have been found to be a driving force that encourages contributions,{{efn|1=Academic research has suggested that red links may be a driving force in Misplaced Pages growth; see: {{cite journal |title=The collaborative organization of knowledge |last1=Spinellis |first1=Diomidis |author1-link=Diomidis Spinellis |last2=Louridas |first2=Panagiotis |date=2008 |journal=] |volume=51 |issue=8 |pages=68–73 |publisher=] |doi=10.1145/1378704.1378720 |s2cid=77400 |quote=Most new articles are created shortly after a corresponding reference to them is entered into the system}} See also ].}} and then use that fact to balance the perceived stylistic issues of "overlinking" the red links. | |||
Note that the color of such links depends on the settings of the individual Misplaced Pages reader, and red is only the default; a reader can change his or her personal style so this internal link class shows up in another color. | |||
(Legitimate red links are titles to unfulfilled coverage of topics that do not violate "]" policy.) Given a certain number of red links needed, if marking {{em|all}} of them could be overlinking, then just {{em|how many}} should be marked could be a style issue, and just {{em|which ones}} are priority is a helpful contribution. | |||
In ], overlinking red links can occur when every item on a list is a red link. If the list is uniform, where each item is obviously qualified for an article, a {{em|single}} red link (or blue link) could indicate that. If the list is not uniform, the research effort to mark all possible red links is a risky investment: while red means "approved" status, "black" remains ambiguous, even though it meant "disapproved" {{em|after research}}. Valid ] for the future creation of each title in a list, or in prose, may also be a risky investment when the number of red links could be perceived by ''other'' editors as overlinking, and then removed before the investment was fruitful. The removal of massive numbers of red links from an overlinked list is best handled by an editor skilled in the automation of ]. | |||
== External links == | |||
{{main|Misplaced Pages:External links}} | |||
Misplaced Pages is not a link collection and an article comprising only links is contrary to the ]. | |||
Red links can also be removed if they violate policy or the ], but otherwise red links do not have an expiration date. If you remain convinced there is overlinking of red links, consider turning some of them blue. The methods to do so are by creating a simple ], a ], or a ] page. All of these require the certainty that the red link was legitimate in the first place, such as the conventions on ]. | |||
=== Syntax === | |||
The syntax for referencing a ] is simple. Just enclose it in single brackets: | |||
====Colored links==== | |||
:<code><nowiki></nowiki></code> | |||
{{main|Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Text formatting#Color}} | |||
In prose, refrain from implementing colored links, as these may impede user ability to distinguish links from regular text. See the guides to editing articles for accessibility at ] and ]. | |||
===Checking links as they are created=== | |||
The URL must begin with<code><nowiki> http:// </nowiki></code>or another common protocol, such as<code><nowiki> ftp:// </nowiki></code>or<code><nowiki> news://</nowiki></code>. | |||
{{Shortcut|WP:TESTLINK}} | |||
It's easy to create an erroneous link without realizing it. When adding a new link, it's a good idea to use the "Show preview" button and then (from the preview) open the link in a new browser tab to check that it goes where you intend. | |||
In addition, putting URLs in plain text with no markup automatically produces a link, for example http://www.example.org/. However, this feature may disappear in a future release. Therefore, in cases where you wish to display the URL because it is intrinsically valuable information, it is better to use the short form of the URL (host name) as the optional text:<code><nowiki> </nowiki></code>produces . | |||
By following ], an internal link is much more likely to lead to an existing article. When there is not yet an article about the subject, a good link makes it easier to create a correctly named article later. | |||
=== Link titles === | |||
{{main|Misplaced Pages:Embedded citations}} | |||
You should not add a descriptive title to an embedded HTML link within an article. Instead, when giving an embedded link as a source within an article, simply enclose the URL in square brackets, like this: . However, you should add a descriptive title when an external link is offered in the References, Further reading, or External links section. This is done by supplying descriptive text after the URL, separated by a space and enclosing it all in square brackets. | |||
==Specific cases== | |||
For example, to add a title to a bare URL such as<code><nowiki> http://en.wikipedia.org/ </nowiki></code>(this is rendered as "http://en.wikipedia.org/"), use the following syntax:<code><nowiki> </nowiki></code>(this is rendered as ""). | |||
===<span id="Chronological items"></span><span id="Year linking"></span><span id="Month-and-day linking"></span>Linking month-and-day or year=== | |||
{{Shortcut|WP:DATELINK|WP:YEARLINK|WP:LINKYEAR}} | |||
Month-and-day articles (e.g. ] and ]) and year articles (e.g. ], ], ]) should not be linked unless the linked date or year has a significant connection to the subject of the linking article, beyond that of the date itself, so that the linking enhances the reader's understanding of the subject. | |||
Generally, URLs are ugly and uninformative; it is better for a meaningful title to be displayed rather than the URL itself. For example, "" is much more reader-friendly than "http://www.esa.int/export/esaCP/index.html". There may be exceptions where the URL is well known or is the company name. In this case, putting both the url and a valid title will be more informative: for example, "". | |||
For example: | |||
* The date (or year) should not be linked in a sentence such as (from ]): "{{xt|The Sydney Opera House was made a UNESCO World Heritage Site on 28 June 2007}}", because little if any content of either ] or ] pertains to either UNESCO, World Heritage Sites, or the Sydney Opera House. | |||
* The years of birth and death of architect ] should not be linked, because little if any content of ] or ] enhances the reader's understanding of Johnson or his work. | |||
* <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> might be linked from another article about WWII. | |||
* <code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> might be linked from a passage discussing a particular development in the metric system which occurred in that year. | |||
However, in intrinsically chronological articles (], ], and ]), links to specific month-and-day, month-and year, or year articles are not discouraged. | |||
Commemorative days (]) are not considered month-and-day items for the purposes of the above. | |||
If the URL ''is'' displayed, make it as simple as possible; for example, if the ''index.html'' is superfluous, remove it (but be sure to check in preview mode first). | |||
===<span id="Units"></span> Units of measurement that are not obscure=== | |||
The "printable version" of a page displays all URLs in full, including those given a title, so no information is lost. | |||
Generally, a unit should be linked only if it is likely to be obscure to many readers or is itself being discussed. For example, the ], ], ], ], ], ], or ] might be considered obscure even if they are well-known ''within their field of use''. Other units may be obscure in some countries even if well known in others. | |||
== |
==External links section== | ||
{{Main|Misplaced Pages:External links}} | |||
Without the optional text, external references appear as automatically numbered links: For example, | |||
:<code><nowiki></nowiki></code> | |||
is displayed like this: | |||
: | |||
Misplaced Pages is not a link collection, and an article comprising only links is contrary to what the ] dictates. | |||
When an embedded HTML link is used to provide an inline source in an article, a numbered link should be used after the punctuation, like this, with a full citation given in the References section. See ] and ] for more information. | |||
===Syntax=== | |||
When placed in the References and External links sections, these links should be expanded with link text, and preferably a full citation, including the name of the article, the author, the journal or newspaper the article appeared in, the date it was published, and the date retrieved. | |||
The syntax for referencing a web address is simple. Just enclose it in single brackets with a space between the URL and the text that is displayed when the page is previewed or saved: | |||
:<code><nowiki></nowiki></code> | |||
The text appears as: | |||
: | |||
The URL must begin with either <code><nowiki>http://</nowiki></code> or <code><nowiki>https://</nowiki></code> (preferring <code><nowiki>https://</nowiki></code>, where available), or another common protocol, such as <code><nowiki>ftp://</nowiki></code> or <code><nowiki>news://</nowiki></code>. If no protocol is used, the square brackets display normally – – and can be used in the standard way. | |||
=== Position in article === | |||
Embedded links are positioned after the sentence or paragraph they are being used as a source for, and after the punctuation, like this. | |||
In addition, putting URLs in plain text with no markup automatically produces a link, for example <code><nowiki>https://www.example.org/</nowiki></code> → {{xt|https://www.example.org/}}. However, this feature may disappear in a future release. Therefore, in cases where you wish to display the URL because it is intrinsically valuable information, it is better to use the short form of the URL (domain name) as the optional text: <code><nowiki></nowiki></code> produces {{xt|}}. | |||
A full citation should then be added to the References section. Links not used as sources can be listed in the External links section: | |||
] such as {{tlx|cite web}} should not be used in the <code>==External links==</code> section. ] such as {{tlx|official website}} are used instead of citation templates. | |||
: <code><nowiki>== External links ==</nowiki></code> | |||
: <code><nowiki>* [http:// </nowiki></code> | |||
: <code><nowiki>* [http:// </nowiki></code> | |||
As with other top-level headings, two equal signs should be used to mark up the external links heading (see ''Headings'' elsewhere in the article). | |||
===Link titles=== | |||
If there is a dispute on the position of an embedded link, consider organizing alphabetically. | |||
{{Main|Misplaced Pages:Embedded citations}} | |||
Embedded HTML links within an article are a now-deprecated way to supply a bare URL as a source within an article, by simply enclosing the URL in square brackets, like this: <code><nowiki></nowiki></code> → {{xt|}}. However, you should add a descriptive title when an external link is offered in the ], ], or ] sections. This is done by supplying descriptive text after the URL, separated by a space and enclosing it all in square brackets. | |||
See ] for how to format these, and ], which is policy. | |||
For example, to add a title to a bare URL such as <code><nowiki>https://en.wikipedia.org/</nowiki></code> (this is rendered as {{xt|https://en.wikipedia.org/}}), use the following syntax: <code><nowiki></nowiki></code> (this is rendered as "{{xt|}}"). | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:URL|MOS:DOMAINNAME}}{{anchor|URL|reason=This is the target of the shortcuts.}} | |||
Generally, URLs and domain names are ugly and uninformative; it is better for a meaningful title or description to be displayed rather than the URL or domain itself. For example, {{xt|}} is much more reader-friendly than {{xt|http://www.esa.int/ESA}}. There may be exceptions where the domain name is well known or is also the company or publication name. When a URL or domain name is given, putting both a plain-English title or description and the URL is often more informative: for example, {{xt|}}. | |||
If the URL or domain name {{em|is}} displayed, make it as simple as possible; for example, if the <code>index.html</code> is superfluous, remove it (but be sure to check in preview mode first). Many but not all sites can be trimmed of a leading "www."; test it to be sure. Use ] to make a displayed domain more readable, e.g. {{xt|WashingtonPost.com}} versus {{xt|washingtonpost.com}}. | |||
The "printable version" of a Misplaced Pages article displays all URLs in full, including those given a title, so no information is lost. | |||
===URLs as embedded (numbered) links=== | |||
Without the optional text, external references appear as automatically numbered links: For example, | |||
:<code><nowiki></nowiki></code> | |||
is displayed like this: | |||
: | |||
Numbered links of this type used to be used after the punctuation, like this, with a full citation given in the References section. This style of referencing is now deprecated, because such links are susceptible to ]. See ] and ] for more information. | |||
===Position in article=== | |||
{{Main|MOS:ORDER}} | |||
Embedded links that support information in an article are positioned in the same manner as any other reference in the article, following the usual standards about ] and ]. | |||
Links that are '''not''' used as sources can be listed in the External links section, like this: | |||
: <code><nowiki>==External links==</nowiki></code> | |||
: <code><nowiki>* </nowiki></code> | |||
: <code><nowiki>* </nowiki></code> | |||
As with other top-level headings, two equal signs should be used to mark up the external links heading (see {{section link|Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Layout|Headings}}). ''External links'' should always be the last section in an article. It precedes categories and some kinds of ]. | |||
If there is a dispute on the position of an embedded link, consider organizing alphabetically. | |||
=== |
===Non-English-language sites=== | ||
Webpages in English are highly preferred. Linking to non-English pages may still be useful for readers in the following cases: | Webpages in English are highly preferred. Linking to non-English pages may still be useful for readers in the following cases: | ||
* When the website is the subject of the article | |||
* When linking to pages with maps, diagrams, photos, tables (explain the key terms with the link, so that people who do not know the language can interpret them) | |||
* When the webpage contains information found on no English-language site of comparable quality, and is used as a citation (or when translations on English-language sites are not authoritative). | |||
If the language is one that most readers could not be expected to recognize, or is for some other reason unclear from the name of the publication or the book or article or page title, consider indicating what language the site is in. | |||
* when the website is the subject of the article | |||
* Example: {{xt|, an Albanian-language newspaper from ]}} | |||
* when linking to pages with maps, diagrams, photos, tables (explain the key terms with the link, so that people who do not know the language can interpret them) | |||
* Example: {{Xt|, a Spanish-language newspaper from ]}} | |||
* when the webpage contains key or authoritative information found on no English-language site and is used as a citation (or when translations on English-language sites are not authoritative). | |||
You can also indicate the language by putting a language template after the link. This is done using ] by typing {{Tlx|In lang|<{{var|language code}}>}}. For example, {{Tlx|In lang|es}} displays as: {{xt|{{in lang|es}}}}. See ]. | |||
In such cases, indicate what language the site is in. For example: | |||
When using one of the {{cs1}} or {{cs2}} templates, instead of the {{tld|In lang}} template, use the {{para|language}} parameter. This parameter accepts language names or language codes; see ]. (Use of language codes is to be preferred because cs1|2 automatically renders language names in the language of the local Misplaced Pages.) | |||
*, a Spanish-language newspaper from ] | |||
===File type and size=== | |||
You can also indicate the language by putting a language icon after the link. This is done using ] by typing <nowiki>{{Languageicon|<language code>|<language name>}}</nowiki>. Alternatively, type <nowiki>{{xx icon}}</nowiki>, where xx is the language code. See ] for a list of these templates and the ]. | |||
If the link is not to an ] or ] file (the latter is identified automatically by the software with an icon like this: {{xt|}}), identify the file type. Useful templates are available: {{tl|DOClink}}, {{tl|RTFlink}}. If a ] is required to view the file, mention that as well. If a link is to a PDF file but doesn't end with <code>.pdf</code>, you can put a <code>#.pdf</code> at the end to flag it as a PDF. | |||
If the link is to a very large page (considering all its elements, including images), a note about that is useful since someone with a slow or expensive connection may decide not to visit it. | |||
=== File type === | |||
If the link is not to an ] file, identify the file type. Useful templates are available: {{tl|PDFlink}}, {{tl|DOClink}}, {{tl|RTFlink}}. If a browser plugin is required to view to the file, mention that as well. | |||
==Interwiki links== | |||
=== File size === | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:IWL|MOS:INTERWIKI|MOS:INTERLINK}} | |||
If the link is to a large file (in the case of HTML, including the images), a note about that is useful. Someone with a slow connection may decide not to use it. | |||
{{Main|Help:Interlanguage links|Help:Interwiki linking}} | |||
{{further|Misplaced Pages:Wikimedia sister projects}} | |||
===Linking=== | |||
=== Alternative styles of link === | |||
Using links to ] as an example, interwiki links can take the form of: | |||
Links to articles in other Wikimedia Foundation projects such as Wiktionary and Wikiquote can be done with special link templates such as ]. These will display as a blue box with a logo. Similar templates exist for some free content resources that are not run by the Wikimedia Foundation. These boxes are formatted in light green to distinguish them from Misplaced Pages's official sister projects. A list of such templates can be found at ]. | |||
:<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> which appears as: ] | |||
The pipe symbol suppresses the prefix: | |||
== Other considerations == | |||
:<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> → ] | |||
=== Capitalization === | |||
Wikilinking is not case-sensitive, so editors should generally choose upper or lower case for the initial character of the linked article title or the piped text as would normally apply in the sentence. The same applies for piped external links that occur in running prose. | |||
Adding text after the pipe allows either the same or a different text (with no prefix): | |||
=== Quotations === | |||
:<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> → ] | |||
In general, do not include links in quotations; links can alter the form or emphasis of the original. | |||
:<code><nowiki>]</nowiki></code> → ] | |||
To avoid reader confusion, inline interlanguage, or interwiki, linking within an article's body text is generally discouraged. Exceptions: ] and ] entries may be linked inline (e.g. to an unusual word or the text of a document being discussed), and {{tl|Interlanguage link}} template may be helpful to show a ] accompanied by an interlanguage link if no article exists in English Misplaced Pages. | |||
=== Dates === | |||
{{disputedtag|section=yes}} | |||
For guidance on the linking of dates, see ]. In most cases, date items (days, years, centuries and so on) are not linked. In particular, the day and year links that were formerly recommended to make the ] function work are no longer considered desirable.<ref>This change was made on August 24, 2008, on the basis of ].</ref> | |||
=== |
===Floating boxes=== | ||
{{wikiquote|Jimmy Wales}}Floating boxes for links to articles in other Wikimedia Foundation projects such as Wiktionary and Wikiquote can be added using ], for example <code><nowiki>{{Wikiquote|Jimmy Wales}}</nowiki></code>. These display as a shaded box with a logo. | |||
In tables and infoboxes, units should not be internally linked to Misplaced Pages pages. | |||
(There is a related set of templates for some free content resources that are not run by the Wikimedia Foundation. Rather than creating a sidebar link, they create text suitable for using as a bulleted entry in an "External links" section. A list of such templates can be found at ].) | |||
=== Checking links as they are created === | |||
One of the commonest errors in linking occurs when editors do not check to see whether a link they have created goes to the intended location. This is especially true when a mistake is not obvious to the reader or to other editors. The text of links needs to be exact, and many Misplaced Pages destinations have a number of similar titles. To avoid such problems, which can be irritating for readers, the following procedure is recommended, especially for editors who are new to creating links. | |||
#Carefully key in the link. | |||
#Click on "Show preview". | |||
#In the display-mode, click on the links to check they go where you intend; if they do not, fix them. If a destination page does not appear to exist, do a quick search to determine whether the article has a differently worded title or the subject is treated in a section of another article. Adjust the link accordingly, or leave it as a red link. | |||
#Return to the "Show preview" page using your browser's return button. | |||
#Click on "Save page". | |||
==Link maintenance== | |||
By following ], an internal link will be much more likely to lead to an existing article. When there is not yet an article about the subject, a good link will make the creation of a correctly named article much easier for subsequent writers. | |||
Linking and continual change are both central features of Misplaced Pages. However, continual change makes linking vulnerable to acquired technical faults, and to the later provision of different information from that which was originally intended. This is true of both "outgoing" links (''from'' an article) and "incoming" links (''to'' an article). | |||
* ''Outgoing links:'' These should be checked from time to time for unintended changes that are undesirable. If the opportunity arises to improve their formatting, appropriateness, and focus, this should be done. | |||
* ''Incoming links:'' Creating an article turns blue any existing red links to its title. Proper redlinks are created only in the hope that an article will eventually be written. Therefore, when creating an article, it is wise to check "What links here" to identify such redlinks, if any, and that they are appropriate. | |||
<!--==Transclusion in talk pages via linking== | |||
] means the inclusion of the content of one document in another document by reference, such as by linking. It is best to use transclusion linking rather than copying entire sections, such as in talk page discussions, so as to avoid ].--> | |||
==Buttons== | |||
=== Link maintenance === | |||
{{Shortcut|MOS:BUTTONS}} | |||
Linking and continual change are both central features of Misplaced Pages; however, continual change makes linking vulnerable to acquired technical faults and the provision of different information from that which was originally intended. This is true of both "outgoing" links (''from'' an article) and "incoming" links (''to'' an article). | |||
] should not be used in articles. If the desire is to "navigate" a reader to a new page, taking them away from the current page, a link is preferred. Buttons are used within Misplaced Pages to trigger an "action", such as {{Clickable button|]|color=blue}} or {{Clickable button|]|color=blue}} or {{Clickable button|]|color=blue}} or {{Clickable button|]|color=blue}}.<ref>{{cite web |url= https://doc.wikimedia.org/codex/latest/components/demos/button.html |title=Codex: Wikimedia Design System |at="Components: Button" section |date=2024 |work=Doc.Wikimedia.org |publisher=]}}</ref> | |||
*''Outgoing links:'' These should be checked from time to time for unintended changes that are undesirable; if the opportunity arises to improve their formatting, appropriateness and focus, this should be done. | |||
*''Incoming links:'' Creating an article will turn blue any existing red links to its title (redlinks are usually created in the hope that an article will eventually be written). Therefore, when creating an article, it is wise to check "What links here" to identify such redlinks, if any, and that they are appropriate. | |||
== |
==See also== | ||
{{Columns-list|colwidth=30em| | |||
* ] | |||
* ] (information page summarizing the key points of this guideline) | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ], pages without internal links | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* ], pages without incoming links | |||
* ] | |||
* ] | |||
* {{Section link|Misplaced Pages:What Misplaced Pages is not|Misplaced Pages is not an indiscriminate collection of information}} | |||
* ], the idea that every single word should be a link | |||
* ], editors dedicated to clearing up the immense backlog of orphaned articles | |||
* ], a tutorial on high-quality linking with practice questions | |||
* ], a script to highlight links occuring more than once in an article | |||
}} | |||
==Notes== | ==Notes== | ||
{{ |
{{Notelist}} | ||
==References== | |||
{{Reflist}} | |||
==External links== | |||
] | |||
* | |||
] | |||
* {{cite journal | |||
|last1=Silvers |first1=V. L. | |||
|last2=Kreiner |first2=D. S. | |||
|date=1997 | |||
|title=The Effects of Pre-existing Inappropriate Highlighting on Reading Comprehension | |||
|journal=Reading Research and Instruction | |||
|volume=36 | |||
|issue=3 | |||
|pages=217–223 | |||
|doi=10.1080/19388079709558240 | |||
|id={{MASID|3889799}} | |||
}} | |||
* for automatic detection of ] in Misplaced Pages | |||
{{Style wide}} | |||
] | |||
<noinclude> | |||
] | |||
] | ] | ||
] | ] | ||
</noinclude> | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] |
Latest revision as of 11:31, 25 December 2024
English Misplaced Pages guideline For technical information about link formatting, see Help:Link. For information on adding external links to articles, see Misplaced Pages:External links.
This guideline is a part of the English Misplaced Pages's Manual of Style. It is a generally accepted standard that editors should attempt to follow, though occasional exceptions may apply. Any substantive edit to this page should reflect consensus. When in doubt, discuss first on the talk page. | Shortcuts |
Manual of Style (MoS) | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Content | ||||||||||
Formatting | ||||||||||
Images | ||||||||||
Layout | ||||||||||
Lists | ||||||||||
By topic area
|
||||||||||
Related guidelines | ||||||||||
Linking and page manipulation |
---|
Linking and diffs |
Categorization |
Moving and redirecting |
Merging |
Splitting |
Importing and copying |
Protecting |
Additional |
Linking through hyperlinks is an important feature of Misplaced Pages. Internal links bind the project together into an interconnected whole. Interwikimedia links bind the project to sister projects such as Wikisource, Wiktionary and Misplaced Pages in other languages, and external links bind Misplaced Pages to the World Wide Web.
Appropriate links provide instant pathways to locations within and outside the project that can increase readers' understanding of the topic at hand. Whenever writing or editing an article, consider not only what to put in the article, but what links to include to help the reader find related information, and also which other pages should have links to the article. Avoid both underlinking and overlinking, as described below.
This page provides guidelines as to when links should and should not be used, and how to format links. For information about the syntax used to create links, see Help:Link. For links on disambiguation pages, see Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Disambiguation pages.
Principles
"WP:BUILD" redirects here. For the behavioral guideline, see Misplaced Pages:Here to build an encyclopedia. ShortcutsMisplaced Pages is based on hypertext, and aims to "build the web" to enable readers to access relevant information on other Misplaced Pages pages easily. The page from which the hyperlink is activated is called the anchor; the page the link points to is called the target.
In adding or removing links, consider an article's place in the knowledge tree. Internal links can add to the cohesion and utility of Misplaced Pages, allowing readers to deepen their understanding of a topic by conveniently accessing other articles. Ask yourself, "How likely is it that the reader will also want to read that other article?" Consider including links where readers might want to use them; for example, in article leads, at the openings of new sections, in the cells of tables, and in file captions. But as a rule of thumb, link only the first occurrence of a term in the text of the article.
General points on linking style
Shortcuts- As explained in more detail at Help:Link § Wikilinks, linking can be direct (
]
, which results in Riverside, California), or piped (]
, which results in Riverside in the text, but still links to the article "Riverside, California"—although the pipe trick is an easier way to create this particular link). - ShortcutSection headings should not themselves contain links; instead, a {{main}} or {{see also}} template should be placed immediately after the heading.
- Links should not be placed in the boldface reiteration of the title in the opening sentence of a lead.
- ShortcutBe conservative when linking within quotations; link only to targets that correspond to the meaning clearly intended by the quote's author. Where possible, link from text outside of the quotation instead – either before it or soon after.
- ShortcutsWhen possible, do not place links next to each other, to avoid appearing like a single link, as in chess tournament (
] ]
). Instead, consider rephrasing the sentence (tournament of chess), omitting one of the links (chess tournament), or using a single, more specific link as in chess tournament (]
). - ShortcutFor a geographical location expressed as a sequence of two or more territorial units, link only the first unit.
- For example, avoid
- NSydney, Australia (
], ]
)- or
- NQuothquan, South Lanarkshire, Scotland (
], ], ]
)- or
- NBuffalo, New York, United States (
], ], ]
)
- Instead, use
- YSydney, Australia (
], Australia
)- or
- YQuothquan, South Lanarkshire, Scotland (
], South Lanarkshire, Scotland
)- or
- YBuffalo, New York, United States (
], United States
)
- Linked text should avoid leading and trailing spaces. Punctuation, including spaces, should be external to the linked items.
- Articles on technical subjects might demand a higher density of links than general-interest articles, because they are likely to contain more technical terms that general dictionaries are unlikely to explain in context.
- Beware of linking to an article without first confirming that the target article covers the appropriate topic. For example, an article mentioning the physics unit "barn" should link to barn (unit), not barn.
- ShortcutIn articles, do not link to pages outside the article namespace, except in articles about Misplaced Pages itself (and even in that case with care – see Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Self-references to avoid).
- Do not unnecessarily make a reader chase links: if a highly technical term can be simply explained with very few words, do so.
- Shortcuts Use a link when appropriate, but as far as possible do not force a reader to use that link to understand the sentence. The text needs to make sense to readers who cannot follow links. Users may print articles or read offline, and Misplaced Pages content may be encountered in republished form, often without links.
- Refrain from implementing colored links that may impede user ability to distinguish links from regular text, or color links for purely aesthetic reasons.
Overlinking and underlinking
"WP:CONTEXT" redirects here. For context in the lead of a biography, see MOS:CONTEXTBIO. For subject context in articles, see WP:AUDIENCE. For notices that can be added to articles, see Template:Overlinked and Template:Underlinked.What generally should be linked
"MOS:UL" redirects here. For unordered lists, see Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Lists § Embedded lists. For underlining, see Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Text formatting § How not to apply emphasis. ShortcutsAn article is said to be underlinked if unlinked words are needed to aid understanding of the article. In general, links should be created for:
- Relevant connections to the subject of another article that help readers understand the article more fully (see the example below). This can include people, events, and topics that already have an article or that clearly deserve one, as long as the link is relevant to the article in question.
- Articles with relevant information, for example: "see Fourier series for relevant background"
- Articles explaining words of technical terms, jargon or slang expressions or phrases—but you could also give a concise definition instead of or in addition to a link. If there is no appropriate Misplaced Pages article, an interwikimedia link to Wiktionary could be used.
- Proper names that are likely to be unfamiliar to readers
If you feel that a link is relevant to the topic of the article but does not belong in the body of an article, consider moving it to a "See also" section.
Links may be created to potential articles that do not yet exist (see § Red links). If an article exists on a non-English language Misplaced Pages but not yet in English, consider a red link that also links to the non-English language article (see Help:Interlanguage links § Inline links).
What generally should not be linked
ShortcutsAn article is said to be overlinked if it contains an excessive number of links, making it difficult to identify those likely to aid a reader's understanding. A good question to ask yourself is whether reading the article you're about to link to would help someone understand the article you are linking from. Unless a term is particularly relevant to the context in the article, words and terms understood by most readers in context are usually not linked. Be conscious of your own demographic biases when determining whether certain terms have this level of recognizability – what is well known in your age group, line of work, or country may be less so for others. Examples include:
- Everyday words (e.g., education, violence, aircraft, river)
- Common occupations (e.g., accountant, politician, actor)
- Common units of measurement, often those relating to time, temperature, length, area, or volume. If both non-metric and metric equivalents are given, as in 5 centimetres (2 in), usually neither unit needs to be linked, because almost all readers understand at least one of the units.
- Dates (see § Chronological items, below)
- Disambiguation pages should not be linked from articles unless the link is purposeful, such as in a hatnote. Instead, use a piped link to the appropriate article. For example, use Y] for the Disney character, which appears as Moana and leads to the intended page—instead of N], which appears identical but leads to a disambiguation page.
In addition, major examples of the following categories should generally not be linked:
- Countries (e.g., Brazil/Brazilian, Canada/Canadian, China/Chinese)
- Geographic features (e.g., the Himalayas, Pacific Ocean, South America)
- Settlements or municipalities (e.g., New Delhi; New York City, or just New York if the city context is already clear; London, if the context rules out London, Ontario; Southeast Asia)
- Languages (e.g., English, Arabic, Korean, Spanish)
- Nationalities, ethnicities or identities (e.g., British, Japanese, Turkish, African American, Nigerian)
- Religions (e.g., Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism)
Links may be excessive even if they are informative. For example, because inline links present relatively small tap targets on touchscreen devices, placing several separate inline links close together within a section of text can make navigation more difficult for readers, especially if they have limited dexterity or coordination. Balance readability, information, and accessibility when adding multiple links in one section of text. As of 2024, most stub articles average two links per sentence, or about 10 to 20 links total. Most longer articles average somewhere around one link per 20 words. The lead of an article usually has a greater density of links than later parts of the article.
Shortcuts
Do not link to pages that redirect back to the page the link is on (unless the link is to a redirect with possibilities that links to an appropriate section of the current article).
The purpose of linking is to clarify and to provide reasonable navigation opportunities, not to emphasize a particular word. Do not link solely to draw attention to certain words or ideas, or as a mark of respect.
External links normally should not be placed in the body of an article (see Misplaced Pages:External links).
Duplicate and repeat links
ShortcutsLink a term at most once per major section, at first occurrence. Common sense applies; do not re-link in other sections if not contextually important there. Other mentions may be linked if helpful, such as in infoboxes, tables, image captions, footnotes, and hatnotes.
Citations stand alone in their usage, so there is no problem with repeating the same link in many citations within an article; e.g. |work=]
.
In glossaries, which are primarily referred to for encyclopedic entries on specific terms rather than read from top to bottom like a regular article, it is usually desirable to repeat links (including to other terms in the glossary) that were not already linked in the same entry (see Template:Glossary link).
Duplicate linking in stand-alone and embedded lists is permissible if it significantly aids the reader. This is most often the case when the list is presenting information that could just as aptly be formatted in a table, and is expected to be parsed for particular bits of data, not read from top to bottom. If the list is normal article prose that happens to be formatted as a list, treat it as normal article prose.
Duplicate links in an article can be found using the duplinks-alt sidebar tool.
Lead section
Shortcut For links in the first sentence, see Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Lead section § Contextual links.Too many links can make the lead hard to read. In technical articles that use uncommon terms, a higher-than-usual link density in the lead section may be necessary. In such cases, try to provide an informal explanation in the lead, avoiding using too many technical terms until later in the article. (See Misplaced Pages:Make technical articles understandable and Misplaced Pages is not a scientific journal.)
Most Featured Articles contain about 12 to 25 links in the lead, with an average of about 1.5 links per sentence, or one link for every 16 words.
An example article
ShortcutsFor example, in the article on supply and demand:
- Almost certainly link "microeconomics" and "general equilibrium theory", as these are technical terms that many readers are unlikely to understand at first sight.
- Consider linking "price" and "goods" only if these common words have technical dimensions that are specifically relevant to the topic.
- Do not link to the "United States", because that is an article on a very broad topic with no direct connection to supply and demand.
- Definitely do not link "wheat", because it is a common term with no particular relationship to the article on supply and demand, beyond its arbitrary use as an example of traded goods in that article.
- Make sure that the links are directed to the correct articles: in this example, you should link goods, not good, which goes to a page on the philosophical concept. Many common dictionary words are ambiguous terms in Misplaced Pages and linking to them is often unhelpful to readers; "Good" is a surname and the name of albums, companies, etc., and the article title Good (disambiguation) is used to index those.
Link clarity
Shortcut See also: § Piped linksThe article linked to should correspond as closely as possible to the term showing as the link, given the context.
For example, a link to the article Requiem (Mozart) should be clear that it is Mozart's Requiem in particular, rather than requiems in general. The link target and the link label do not have to match exactly, but the link must be as intuitive as possible (see § Intuitiveness).
Article text | Wikitext | Note | |
---|---|---|---|
Y | When Mozart wrote his Requiem | When Mozart wrote ]
|
Includes the word "his" to specify |
N | When Mozart wrote his Requiem | When Mozart wrote his ]
|
Only word "Requiem" |
Y | Previn conducted Mozart's Requiem | Previn conducted ] or Previn conducted ]
|
Specifying that it is "Mozart's" |
N | Previn conducted Mozart's Requiem | Previn conducted Mozart's ]
|
Only word "Requiem" |
Link specificity
ShortcutAlways link to the article on the most specific topic appropriate to the context from which you link: it generally contains more focused information, as well as links to more general topics.
What you type | How it appears | Specificity |
---|---|---|
] |
Icelandic orthography | Specific (preferred) |
] orthography |
Icelandic orthography | Related but less specific |
Icelandic ] |
Icelandic orthography | Unspecific |
the ] |
the flag of Tokelau | Specific (preferred) |
the ] of ] |
the flag of Tokelau | Unspecific |
] |
Requiem | Specific (preferred) |
] |
Requiem | Unspecific |
If there is no article about the most specific topic, do one of the following things:
- Consider creating the article yourself.
- If an article on the specific topic does not yet exist, create a redirect page to the article about a more general topic, as described in section § Redirects. For example, if no article yet exists on the song "Sad Statue" from the album Mezmerize, create a new article called Sad Statue that is a redirect to the article Mezmerize.
- If there is no article on a more general topic either, then create a red link, but first, read § Red links below.
When neither a redirect nor a red link appears appropriate, consider linking to a more general article instead.
For example, instead of
NBaroque hairstyles (an article which, as of 2023, had never been created),
write
YBaroque hairstyles (which provides a link to the Baroque era),
YBaroque hairstyles (which provides a link to the article on hairstyle),
YBaroque hairstyles (which provides no link at all, and which may be preferable depending on context),
or
Yhairstyles of the Baroque (which provides separate links to both topics);
however, do not create
NBaroque hairstyles as two adjacent links because they may be misinterpreted as linking to a single article on that topic.
Section links
Shortcuts Further information: Help:Link § Section linking (anchors), and Help:Section § Section linkingIf an existing article has a section specifically about a topic, linking to that section takes the reader directly to the relevant information. Section-linking options are piped links, redirects, and the {{Section link}}
template, which also generates the § character.
Avoiding broken section links
ShortcutsA problem can arise if the title of the section is changed for any reason, because this action breaks any incoming section links or excerpts. (If this occurs, incoming links default to the top of the linked article.) The recommended way to prevent this breakage is to use a {{subst:Anchor}}
template specifying the section's prior name.
An alternative, supplementary method has been to add a hidden comment to the target section such as <!-- "Quark" links here -->
so that someone changing the title of that section can fix the incoming links. This method is weaker, since it puts the workload on the editor seeking to change the section title.
There are some bots aimed to fix broken anchors: cewbot, Dexbot, and FrescoBot.
Techniques
Redirects
Shortcuts Main page: Misplaced Pages:RedirectSuppose you need to link poodle, and there is no such article yet. You might want to create a redirect from "poodle" to "dog" as follows: Link as usual: She owned a ]
. When you save or preview this, you see: She owned a poodle. Follow the red link, and you are invited to create a new page for poodle; enter (perhaps) #REDIRECT ]
, so that readers clicking on poodle are taken, for now, to the dog article.
The redirect is better in a case like this than a direct link like ]
, because when an actual poodle article is eventually created (replacing the redirect), readers following the poodle link are taken there automatically without anyone needing to review all the links to dog to see which ones should actually go to poodle.
To link to a redirect page without following the underlying redirect, use e.g. {{no redirect|poodle}}
.
Avoid linking redirects that are self links (WP:SELFRED).
Piped links
Shortcuts Further information: Misplaced Pages:Piped linkThough a wikilink defaults to displaying the title of the target article, it is possible to choose more specific or more appropriate display text for the intended context. This can be done with the use of the pipe character (|). For example, ]
displays as Henry II. However, make sure that it is still clear what the link is about without having to follow the link. Think about what the reader may believe the text refers to. For example, when seeing the link ]
, which displays as Archery, the reader would probably expect this link to go to a general article on archery, rather than Archery at the 2008 Summer Olympics specifically. An exception to this is when it is clear from the context that a link refers to a specific article; for instance, in Template:Events at the 2008 Summer Olympics all links go to articles about these particular games.
Style
Shortcut- Plurals and other derived names.
]s
displays as apples, and this is simpler and clearer than]
. Similarly:]ing
,]ed
,]dest
. Some characters do not work after the link; see Help:Link for more details. - Case sensitivity. Links are not sensitive to initial capitalization, so there is no need to use the pipe character where the case of the initial letter is the only difference between the link text and the target page. (Misplaced Pages article titles almost always begin with a capital, whereas the linked words in context often do not.) However, links are case-sensitive for all characters after the initial one.
Intuitiveness
"MOS:EGG" redirects here. You may also be looking for WP:EASTEREGG. Shortcuts
Keep piped links as intuitive as possible. Per the principle of least astonishment, make sure that the reader knows what to expect when following a link. You should plan your page structure and links so that everything appears reasonable and makes sense.
A link's visible label does not need to match the exact title of the article being linked, such as in ] or ]. However, avoid "Easter egg" or "submarine" links, which are links that unexpectedly hide relevant information underneath the link's label. For example, do not write:
Richard Feynman was also known for work in ].
Here readers would see the link displayed as particle physics, not the hidden reference to the page Parton (particle physics), unless they followed the link or inspected the target title e.g. by mousing over it. If a physical copy of the article were printed, or the article saved as an audio file, the reference to the parton model would be lost.
Instead, refer to the separate article with an explicit see also X, or by rephrasing the sentence, as in:
Richard Feynman was also known for work in ], especially the ] model.
More words into a link
Shortcuts
Sometimes moving other words into the bluelinked text avoids surprise.
For example, in an article on the history of Texas:
In 1845, the Republic of Texas was ] by the United States.
appears as:
In 1845, the Republic of Texas was annexed by the United States.
which looks the same as a link to the generic topic of annexation would.
However:
In 1845, the ] by the United States.
appears as:
In 1845, the Republic of Texas was annexed by the United States.
and is clear that the 1845 annexation of Texas is linked.
Names in names
ShortcutsDo not place a link to a name within another name. For example:
Write: | ] |
→ Columbus Avenue |
---|---|---|
Do not write: | ] Avenue |
→ Columbus Avenue |
Write: | ] |
→ Feynman diagram |
Do not write: | ] diagram |
→ Feynman diagram |
The above applies regardless of whether linking to the full name creates a red link; for example, even if there is no article titled Lafayette Avenue (Brooklyn):
Do not write: | ] Avenue |
→ Lafayette Avenue |
---|
See also § Link clarity.
Piping and redirects
ShortcutsAs per WP:NOTBROKEN and § Link specificity above, do not use a piped link where it is possible to use a redirected term that fits well within the scope of the text. For example, the page Papageno is a redirect to the article about Mozart's opera The Magic Flute (since Papageno is a character in The Magic Flute). While editing some other article, you might want to link the term Papageno; here, you might be tempted to avoid the redirect by using a pipe within the link, as in ]
. Instead, write simply ]
and let the system handle the rest. This has two advantages: first, if an article is written later about the more specific subject (in this case, "Papageno", the character), fewer links need to be changed to accommodate the new article; second, it indicates that the article is wanted.
An exception to this rule is when linking to articles in Did you know (DYK) "hooks" on the Main Page, where piping links to prevent readers from seeing a redirect notice is preferable, and the hook is live only for a short time. (See also WP:Piped link § When not to use.)
Piped links and redirects to sections of articles
Shortcut Further information: § Section links, Help:Link § Section linking (anchors), and Misplaced Pages:Redirect § Targeted and untargeted redirectsAs explained above, links to sections can take the reader directly to relevant information.
Piped links.
Using a piped link to sections avoids the unsightly Article name#Section name in the display text.
The format for a piped link is ]
. For example, to link to the "Culture" subsection of the article Oman, type
]
(note that the section name is case-sensitive),
which displays as culture of Oman. Then add a hidden comment to the target section such as <!-- The article ArticleName links here. -->
so that if another user edits the title of that section, they can fix the incoming links (or, in cases where a section has a large number of incoming links, use {{Anchor}}
on the anchor page).
To link to a section within the same article, write: ]
.
Redirects to sections which may become articles.
Many topics useful for linking may currently appear only as sections of other Misplaced Pages articles, but are potentially notable enough to become articles on their own. For example, the article Eastern Anyshire might have a small "History" section, but this does not prevent the article History of Eastern Anyshire being written eventually. A redirect page from such a sub-topic to a general topic may exist already; if not, a redirect can be created when the occasion arises. It is bad practice to create links in article text using the format ]
; navigation then becomes difficult if the section is expanded into a new article. Instead, link using a redirect to the main topic; it costs little and makes improvements easier. Thus:
- In a redirect page named "History of Topic", use
#REDIRECT ]
. - In another article, use
]
. - Avoid:
]
.
Links to non-English language pages
See Help:Interlanguage links § Inline links.
Links to Misplaced Pages's categories
See also: Misplaced Pages:Colon trickMisplaced Pages has categories of articles; for example, "Phrases". Adding the wikitext ]
to an article will add that article to the category "Phrases". (This will not create any visible addition to the body text of the article.)
If you instead want to create a visible link to a category, add a colon in front of the word "Category". For example, ]
creates the link Category:Phrases. As with other links, piping can be used: Phrases.
The {{See also cat}} template can be used instead:
{{See also cat|Phrases}}
creates:
Red links
Shortcuts Main page: Misplaced Pages:Red linkOverlinking in general is a style issue partly because of the undesirable effect upon readability. But if too many blue links is distracting, then a red link is even more so. The unassuming coloration of the text (probably black) is the most productive.
In prose, if it seems that the level of red linking is overlinking, remember that red links have been found to be a driving force that encourages contributions, and then use that fact to balance the perceived stylistic issues of "overlinking" the red links. (Legitimate red links are titles to unfulfilled coverage of topics that do not violate "What Misplaced Pages is not" policy.) Given a certain number of red links needed, if marking all of them could be overlinking, then just how many should be marked could be a style issue, and just which ones are priority is a helpful contribution.
In lists, overlinking red links can occur when every item on a list is a red link. If the list is uniform, where each item is obviously qualified for an article, a single red link (or blue link) could indicate that. If the list is not uniform, the research effort to mark all possible red links is a risky investment: while red means "approved" status, "black" remains ambiguous, even though it meant "disapproved" after research. Valid requests for the future creation of each title in a list, or in prose, may also be a risky investment when the number of red links could be perceived by other editors as overlinking, and then removed before the investment was fruitful. The removal of massive numbers of red links from an overlinked list is best handled by an editor skilled in the automation of text processing.
Red links can also be removed if they violate policy or the guideline for red links, but otherwise red links do not have an expiration date. If you remain convinced there is overlinking of red links, consider turning some of them blue. The methods to do so are by creating a simple stub, a redirect, or a disambiguation page. All of these require the certainty that the red link was legitimate in the first place, such as the conventions on article titles.
Colored links
Main page: Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Text formatting § ColorIn prose, refrain from implementing colored links, as these may impede user ability to distinguish links from regular text. See the guides to editing articles for accessibility at contrast and navbox colors.
Checking links as they are created
ShortcutIt's easy to create an erroneous link without realizing it. When adding a new link, it's a good idea to use the "Show preview" button and then (from the preview) open the link in a new browser tab to check that it goes where you intend.
By following naming conventions, an internal link is much more likely to lead to an existing article. When there is not yet an article about the subject, a good link makes it easier to create a correctly named article later.
Specific cases
Linking month-and-day or year
ShortcutsMonth-and-day articles (e.g. February 24 and 10 July) and year articles (e.g. 1795, 1955, 2007) should not be linked unless the linked date or year has a significant connection to the subject of the linking article, beyond that of the date itself, so that the linking enhances the reader's understanding of the subject. For example:
- The date (or year) should not be linked in a sentence such as (from Sydney Opera House): "The Sydney Opera House was made a UNESCO World Heritage Site on 28 June 2007", because little if any content of either June 28 or 2007 pertains to either UNESCO, World Heritage Sites, or the Sydney Opera House.
- The years of birth and death of architect Philip Johnson should not be linked, because little if any content of 1906 or 2005 enhances the reader's understanding of Johnson or his work.
]
might be linked from another article about WWII.]
might be linked from a passage discussing a particular development in the metric system which occurred in that year.
However, in intrinsically chronological articles (1789, January, and 1940s), links to specific month-and-day, month-and year, or year articles are not discouraged.
Commemorative days (Saint Patrick's Day) are not considered month-and-day items for the purposes of the above.
Units of measurement that are not obscure
Generally, a unit should be linked only if it is likely to be obscure to many readers or is itself being discussed. For example, the troy ounce, bushel, hand, candela, knot, mho, or millibarn might be considered obscure even if they are well-known within their field of use. Other units may be obscure in some countries even if well known in others.
External links section
Main page: Misplaced Pages:External linksMisplaced Pages is not a link collection, and an article comprising only links is contrary to what the "what Misplaced Pages is not" policy dictates.
Syntax
The syntax for referencing a web address is simple. Just enclose it in single brackets with a space between the URL and the text that is displayed when the page is previewed or saved:
The text appears as:
The URL must begin with either http://
or https://
(preferring https://
, where available), or another common protocol, such as ftp://
or news://
. If no protocol is used, the square brackets display normally – – and can be used in the standard way.
In addition, putting URLs in plain text with no markup automatically produces a link, for example https://www.example.org/
→ https://www.example.org/. However, this feature may disappear in a future release. Therefore, in cases where you wish to display the URL because it is intrinsically valuable information, it is better to use the short form of the URL (domain name) as the optional text: produces example.org.
Citations templates such as {{cite web}}
should not be used in the ==External links==
section. External link templates such as {{official website}}
are used instead of citation templates.
Link titles
Main page: Misplaced Pages:Embedded citationsEmbedded HTML links within an article are a now-deprecated way to supply a bare URL as a source within an article, by simply enclosing the URL in square brackets, like this: → . However, you should add a descriptive title when an external link is offered in the References, Further reading, or External links sections. This is done by supplying descriptive text after the URL, separated by a space and enclosing it all in square brackets.
For example, to add a title to a bare URL such as https://en.wikipedia.org/
(this is rendered as https://en.wikipedia.org/), use the following syntax: (this is rendered as "an open-content encyclopedia").
Generally, URLs and domain names are ugly and uninformative; it is better for a meaningful title or description to be displayed rather than the URL or domain itself. For example, European Space Agency website is much more reader-friendly than http://www.esa.int/ESA. There may be exceptions where the domain name is well known or is also the company or publication name. When a URL or domain name is given, putting both a plain-English title or description and the URL is often more informative: for example, European Space Agency website, www.esa.int.
If the URL or domain name is displayed, make it as simple as possible; for example, if the index.html
is superfluous, remove it (but be sure to check in preview mode first). Many but not all sites can be trimmed of a leading "www."; test it to be sure. Use camel case to make a displayed domain more readable, e.g. WashingtonPost.com versus washingtonpost.com.
The "printable version" of a Misplaced Pages article displays all URLs in full, including those given a title, so no information is lost.
URLs as embedded (numbered) links
Without the optional text, external references appear as automatically numbered links: For example,
is displayed like this:
Numbered links of this type used to be used after the punctuation, like this, with a full citation given in the References section. This style of referencing is now deprecated, because such links are susceptible to link rot. See Misplaced Pages:Citing sources and Misplaced Pages:Verifiability for more information.
Position in article
Main page: MOS:ORDEREmbedded links that support information in an article are positioned in the same manner as any other reference in the article, following the usual standards about citation formatting and placement in relation to punctuation.
Links that are not used as sources can be listed in the External links section, like this:
==External links==
*
*
As with other top-level headings, two equal signs should be used to mark up the external links heading (see Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style/Layout § Headings). External links should always be the last section in an article. It precedes categories and some kinds of navigation templates.
If there is a dispute on the position of an embedded link, consider organizing alphabetically.
Non-English-language sites
Webpages in English are highly preferred. Linking to non-English pages may still be useful for readers in the following cases:
- When the website is the subject of the article
- When linking to pages with maps, diagrams, photos, tables (explain the key terms with the link, so that people who do not know the language can interpret them)
- When the webpage contains information found on no English-language site of comparable quality, and is used as a citation (or when translations on English-language sites are not authoritative).
If the language is one that most readers could not be expected to recognize, or is for some other reason unclear from the name of the publication or the book or article or page title, consider indicating what language the site is in.
- Example: Koha Jonë, an Albanian-language newspaper from Tirana
- Example: El País, a Spanish-language newspaper from Madrid
You can also indicate the language by putting a language template after the link. This is done using Template:In lang by typing {{In lang|<language code>}}
. For example, {{In lang|es}}
displays as: (in Spanish). See list of ISO 639 codes.
When using one of the Citation Style 1 or Citation Style 2 templates, instead of the {{In lang}}
template, use the |language=
parameter. This parameter accepts language names or language codes; see this list of supported names and codes. (Use of language codes is to be preferred because cs1|2 automatically renders language names in the language of the local Misplaced Pages.)
File type and size
If the link is not to an HTML or PDF file (the latter is identified automatically by the software with an icon like this: ), identify the file type. Useful templates are available: {{DOClink}}, {{RTFlink}}. If a browser plugin is required to view the file, mention that as well. If a link is to a PDF file but doesn't end with .pdf
, you can put a #.pdf
at the end to flag it as a PDF.
If the link is to a very large page (considering all its elements, including images), a note about that is useful since someone with a slow or expensive connection may decide not to visit it.
Interwiki links
Shortcuts Main pages: Help:Interlanguage links and Help:Interwiki linking Further information: Misplaced Pages:Wikimedia sister projectsLinking
Using links to wiktionary as an example, interwiki links can take the form of:
]
which appears as: wikt:article
The pipe symbol suppresses the prefix:
]
→ article
Adding text after the pipe allows either the same or a different text (with no prefix):
To avoid reader confusion, inline interlanguage, or interwiki, linking within an article's body text is generally discouraged. Exceptions: Wiktionary and Wikisource entries may be linked inline (e.g. to an unusual word or the text of a document being discussed), and {{Interlanguage link}} template may be helpful to show a red link accompanied by an interlanguage link if no article exists in English Misplaced Pages.
Floating boxes
Floating boxes for links to articles in other Wikimedia Foundation projects such as Wiktionary and Wikiquote can be added using interwiki link sidebar templates, for example {{Wikiquote|Jimmy Wales}}
. These display as a shaded box with a logo.
(There is a related set of templates for some free content resources that are not run by the Wikimedia Foundation. Rather than creating a sidebar link, they create text suitable for using as a bulleted entry in an "External links" section. A list of such templates can be found at Misplaced Pages:List of templates linking to other free content projects.)
Link maintenance
Linking and continual change are both central features of Misplaced Pages. However, continual change makes linking vulnerable to acquired technical faults, and to the later provision of different information from that which was originally intended. This is true of both "outgoing" links (from an article) and "incoming" links (to an article).
- Outgoing links: These should be checked from time to time for unintended changes that are undesirable. If the opportunity arises to improve their formatting, appropriateness, and focus, this should be done.
- Incoming links: Creating an article turns blue any existing red links to its title. Proper redlinks are created only in the hope that an article will eventually be written. Therefore, when creating an article, it is wise to check "What links here" to identify such redlinks, if any, and that they are appropriate.
Buttons
ShortcutButtons should not be used in articles. If the desire is to "navigate" a reader to a new page, taking them away from the current page, a link is preferred. Buttons are used within Misplaced Pages to trigger an "action", such as Show preview or Create account or Reply or Ask a question.
See also
- Misplaced Pages:Linking dos and don'ts (information page summarizing the key points of this guideline)
- Help:Interwikimedia links
- Help:Menu/Links
- Template:Dead end
- Template:Dead link
- Template:Underlinked
- Misplaced Pages:Dead-end pages, pages without internal links
- Misplaced Pages:Integrate
- Misplaced Pages:Links to (disambiguation) pages
- Misplaced Pages:Orphan, pages without incoming links
- Misplaced Pages:Red link
- Misplaced Pages:Walled garden
- Misplaced Pages:What Misplaced Pages is not § Misplaced Pages is not an indiscriminate collection of information
- Misplaced Pages:Misplaced Pages doesn't use Allwiki, the idea that every single word should be a link
- Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Orphanage, editors dedicated to clearing up the immense backlog of orphaned articles
- User:Tony1/Build your linking skills, a tutorial on high-quality linking with practice questions
- User:Evad37/duplinks-alt, a script to highlight links occuring more than once in an article
Notes
- Many, but not all, articles repeat the article title in bold face in the first line of the article. Linking the article to itself produces boldface text; this practice is discouraged as page moves result in a useless circular link through a redirect. Linking part of the bolded text is also discouraged because it changes the visual effect of bolding; some readers can miss the visual cue which is the purpose of using bold face in the first place.
- If quoting hypertext that includes a Misplaced Pages link particularly salient to the quote's use, a editorial note may be added. notes should generally be avoided, because if the clarification is needed badly enough to justify disrupting the flow of text, the link is probably not conservative and should be omitted.
- A 2015 study of log data found that "in the English Misplaced Pages, of all the 800,000 links added ... in February 2015, the majority (66%) were not clicked even a single time in March 2015, and among the rest most links were clicked only very rarely", and that "simply adding more links does not increase the overall number of clicks taken from a page. Instead, links compete with each other for user attention." This was reported in: Paranjape, Ashwin; West, Bob; Leskovec, Jure; Zia, Leila (February 22–25, 2016). "Improving Website Hyperlink Structure Using Server Logs". WSDM'16: Proceedings of the Ninth ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining (PDF). San Francisco: Association for Computing Machinery. doi:10.1145/2835776.2835832. ISBN 9781450337168.
- Major sections are generally detailed sections with a level-2 heading, but consensus at an article may determine a lower-level subsection is major, especially when a preceding subsection is especially long, when an article's structure puts most content under level-3 headings with level-2 ones primarily used for thematic grouping, or when a subsection is a link target at which many readers arrive directly.
- The hidden message (
<!-- "Article" links here -->
) must be added to the target section with a break between the header and the hidden message, or problems arise. Note the two lines:
==Target section==
<!-- "Article" links here -->
See MOS:HEADINGS for further information about valid and invalid placement of heading comments. - Academic research has suggested that red links may be a driving force in Misplaced Pages growth; see: Spinellis, Diomidis; Louridas, Panagiotis (2008). "The collaborative organization of knowledge". Communications of the ACM. 51 (8). Association for Computing Machinery: 68–73. doi:10.1145/1378704.1378720. S2CID 77400.
Most new articles are created shortly after a corresponding reference to them is entered into the system
See also Misplaced Pages:Inflationary hypothesis of Misplaced Pages growth.
References
- Dvorak, John C. (April 16, 2002). "Missing Links". PC Magazine. Archived from the original on August 6, 2011. Retrieved August 16, 2021.
- "User:WhatamIdoing/Sandbox 3". Misplaced Pages (English ed.). January 30, 2023. Retrieved August 31, 2023.
- "Codex: Wikimedia Design System". Doc.Wikimedia.org. Wikimedia Foundation. 2024. "Components: Button" section.
External links
- The Wikimedia Design Style Guide (Links)
- Silvers, V. L.; Kreiner, D. S. (1997). "The Effects of Pre-existing Inappropriate Highlighting on Reading Comprehension". Reading Research and Instruction. 36 (3): 217–223. doi:10.1080/19388079709558240. MASID 3889799.
- Internal link analyzer for automatic detection of redundant links in Misplaced Pages
Manual of Style | |||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Content | |||||||||||||||||
Formatting | |||||||||||||||||
Images | |||||||||||||||||
Layout | |||||||||||||||||
Lists | |||||||||||||||||
By topic area |
| ||||||||||||||||
Related guidelines | |||||||||||||||||
Search | |||||||||||||||||