Misplaced Pages

Centre Against Expulsions: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 17:35, 21 March 2009 editSkäpperöd (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers18,457 edits Gdanzig foundation date and ralph giordano are far out of the scope of this article. no valid npov violatiobn gibven at talk← Previous edit Latest revision as of 11:36, 27 October 2024 edit undoMonkbot (talk | contribs)Bots3,695,952 editsm Task 20: replace {lang-??} templates with {langx|??} ‹See Tfd› (Replaced 6);Tag: AWB 
(134 intermediate revisions by 57 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Planned Nazi German documentation centre}}
{{ future product }}
The '''Centre Against Expulsions''' ({{lang-de|Zentrum gegen Vertreibungen}}, ZgV) is a planned ] documentation centre for ]s and ], particularly the ].<ref name=tasks/> The centre will open in the ''Deutschlandhaus'' building, ]-].<ref name=pr3sept08/>


The '''Centre Against Expulsions''' ({{langx|de|Zentrum gegen Vertreibungen}}, ZgV) was a planned ] documentation centre for ]s and ], particularly the ].<ref name=tasks /><ref>Michael Levitin, Telegraph.uk, 26 Feb 2009, "plans to build a museum dedicated to German refugees who fled or were expelled from Poland after the Second World War."</ref><ref name=ggov /> Since March 19, 2008 the name of the project is Sichtbares Zeichen gegen Flucht und Vertreibung.<ref>{{Dead link|date=November 2019 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref>
⚫ The project was initiated by the ], who dedicated a "Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" to the centre.<ref name=of/> This foundation is based in ], and headed by CDU politician and president of the Federation of Expellees, ]. The other head of the foundation was SPD politician ] who died in 2005.


⚫ The project was initiated by the ], who dedicated a "Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" to the centre.<ref name=of /> This foundation is based in ], and headed by ] politician and president of the Federation of Expellees, ]. The other head of the foundation was ] politician ] who died in 2005. The head of the foundation ZgV since 2018 is Christean Wagner, a politician of the Christian Democratic Union in Germany.
Since late 2008, the project is forwarded by the Federal Republic of Germany, when the federal government and parliament passed a law calling for the constitution of a ''Foundation German Historical Museum'' subordinate to the federal government, which in turn shall hold a ''Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation'' which shall take on the actual documentation in Berlin.<ref name=DHMlaw/>

Since late 2008, the project is forwarded by the Federal Republic of Germany, when the federal government and parliament passed a law calling for the constitution of a ''Foundation German Historical Museum'' subordinate to the federal government, which in turn shall hold a ''Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation'' which shall take on the actual documentation in Berlin.<ref name=ggov>{{Dead link|date=June 2019 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref><ref name=DHMlaw /> The project has been subject to criticism, especially in Poland.<ref></ref><ref></ref>


=="Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" of the Federation of Expellees== =="Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" of the Federation of Expellees==


The ] ({{lang-de|Bund der Vertriebenen, BdV)}} is the German non-governmental head organization of various organized groups of German refugees and expellees. The federation is committed to document the ]<ref name=tasks/> as well as other forced displacements, and maintains an exhibition for this purpose shown in changing locations of Germany.<ref>Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Permanent exhibition" </ref> To expand this exhibition and to find a permanent place for it, the Federation of Expellees set up the "Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" ({{lang-de|Stiftung Zentrum gegen Vertreibungen, ZgV)}}) on 6 September 2000.<ref name=of>Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Our Foundation" </ref> The ] ({{langx|de|Bund der Vertriebenen, BdV)}} is the German non-governmental head organization of various organized groups of German refugees and expellees. The federation is committed to document the ]<ref name=tasks /> as well as other forced displacements, and maintains an exhibition for this purpose shown in changing locations of Germany.<ref>{{Cite web |url=http://www.z-g-v.de/english/aktuelles/?id=49 |title=Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Permanent exhibition" |access-date=2009-03-17 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110514101857/http://www.z-g-v.de/english/aktuelles/?id=49 |archive-date=2011-05-14 |url-status=dead }}</ref> To expand this exhibition and to find a permanent place for it, the Federation of Expellees set up the "Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" ({{langx|de|Stiftung Zentrum gegen Vertreibungen, ZgV)}}) on 6 September 2000.<ref name=of> {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090801185047/http://www.z-g-v.de/english/aktuelles/?id=34 |date=2009-08-01 }}</ref>


=== Objectives === === Objectives ===


The foundation Centre Against Expulsions defines four objectives:<ref name=tasks>Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Tasks and Objectives" </ref> The foundation Centre Against Expulsions defines four objectives:<ref name=tasks>{{Cite web |url=http://www.z-g-v.de/english/aktuelles/?id=35 |title=Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Tasks and Objectives" |access-date=2009-03-16 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110514101409/http://www.z-g-v.de/english/aktuelles/?id=35 |archive-date=2011-05-14 |url-status=dead }}</ref>


# To document the ], culture, ], forced labour, torture, and later emigration of Germans from various countries of ], ] and ], in a modern museum.<ref name=tasks/> The museum shall provide room for the documentation and "additional space for sadness, sympathy and forgiveness" in a requiem rotunda.<ref name=tasks/> # To document the ], culture, ], forced labour, torture, and later emigration of Germans from various countries of ], ] and ], in a modern museum.<ref name=tasks /> The museum shall provide room for the documentation and "additional space for sadness, sympathy and forgiveness" in a requiem rotunda.<ref name=tasks />
# To document and to evaluate the impact of the integration of millions of uprooted Germans into the post-World War II German society.<ref name=tasks/> # To document and to evaluate the impact of the integration of millions of uprooted Germans into the post-World War II German society.<ref name=tasks />
# To document the "expulsion and genocide of other peoples, especially in Europe",<ref name=tasks/> arguing that "''displacement, expulsion and genocide can never be justified, are always a crime, contradicting human rights and carried out by following the archaic thinking of the bloody vendetta.''"<ref name=tasks/> # To document the "expulsion and genocide of other peoples, especially in Europe",<ref name=tasks /> arguing that "''displacement, expulsion and genocide can never be justified, are always a crime, contradicting human rights and carried out by following the archaic thinking of the bloody vendetta.''"<ref name=tasks />
# To donate a ''] Human Rights Award''<ref name=award>Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Franz-Werfel-Human Rights Award" </ref> to people who "sharpen the sense of responsibility through their actions is one of the foundation's tasks".<ref name=tasks/> # To donate a '']''<ref name=award>Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "]" {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140413181448/http://www.z-g-v.de/english/aktuelles/?id=45%2F |date=2014-04-13 }}</ref> to people who "sharpen the sense of responsibility through their actions is one of the foundation's tasks".<ref name=tasks />


=="Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation"== =="Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation"==


On 11 November 11 2005, the largest German political parties ] and ] signed a coalition. One stated goal of the coalition is the establishment of a centre termed "Visible Sign" ({{lang-de|Sichtbares Zeichen}}).<ref name=govpressrelease>German Federal Government, Appointee for Culture and Media, center conception, press release 19 March 2008 </ref> On 11 November 2005, the largest German political parties ] and ] signed a coalition. One stated goal of the coalition is the establishment of a centre termed "Visible Sign" ({{langx|de|Sichtbares Zeichen}}).<ref name=govpressrelease>German Federal Government, Appointee for Culture and Media, center conception, press release 19 March 2008 {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090228174823/http://bundesregierung.de/nsc_true/Content/DE/__Anlagen/BKM/2008-04-09-sichtbares-zeichen-konzeption-barrierefrei,templateId=raw,property=publicationFile.pdf/2008-04-09-sichtbares-zeichen-konzeption-barrierefrei |date=2009-02-28 }}</ref>


On 3 September 2008 the German federal government passed a law calling for the establishment of a center against expulsions in the ''Deutschlandhaus'' building of the ] site in ]-].<ref name=pr3sept08>German Federal Government, press release, 3 September 2008 (including link to the law (pdf file)</ref> The law passed the ] and was enacted on 29 December 2008.<ref name=DHMlaw>full text of German law to establish a foundation "German Historical Museum": Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Stiftung „Deutsches Historisches Museum“ (DHMG) vom 21. Dezember 2008 in der Fassung der Bekanntmachung vom 29.Dezember 2008 (BGBl. I Nr. 64, S. 2891) </ref> The center is to be run by a "Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation" ({{lang-de|Stiftung Flucht, Vertreibung, Versöhnung}}) subordinate to the governmental "Foundation German Historical Museum" ({{lang-de|Stiftung Deutsches Historisches Museum}}), both foundations are yet to be created.<ref name=DHMlaw/> On 3 September 2008 the German federal government passed a law calling for the establishment of a center against expulsions in the ''Deutschlandhaus'' building of the ] site in ]-].<ref name=pr3sept08>German Federal Government, press release, 3 September 2008 {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090310034820/http://www.bundesregierung.de/Content/DE/Pressemitteilungen/BPA/2008/09/2008-09-03-pm-stiftung-flucht-vertreibung.html |date=2009-03-10 }} (including link to the law (pdf file)</ref> The law passed the ] and was enacted on 29 December 2008.<ref name=DHMlaw>full text of German law to establish a foundation "German Historical Museum": Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Stiftung „Deutsches Historisches Museum“ (DHMG) vom 21. Dezember 2008 in der Fassung der Bekanntmachung vom 29.Dezember 2008 (BGBl. I Nr. 64, S. 2891) {{Dead link|date=November 2019 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }} {{dead link|date=September 2024|bot=medic}}</ref> The center is to be run by a "Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation" ({{langx|de|Stiftung Flucht, Vertreibung, Versöhnung}}) subordinate to the governmental "Foundation German Historical Museum" ({{langx|de|Stiftung Deutsches Historisches Museum}}).<ref name=DHMlaw />


==="Foundation German Historical Museum" of the German federal government=== ==="Foundation German Historical Museum" of the German federal government===


The purpose of this foundation is stated in §16 of the above mentioned law<ref name=para16/> as follows: The purpose of this foundation is stated in §16 of the above-mentioned law<ref name=para16 /> as follows:


(1) The purpose of the non-autonomous foundation is to ensure in the spirit of reconciliation the remembrance of flight and expulsion in the 20th century in the historical context of the Second World War and the Nazi expansion and extermination policy and their aftermaths.<ref name=para16/> (1) The purpose of the non-autonomous foundation is to ensure in the spirit of reconciliation the remembrance of flight and expulsion in the 20th century in the historical context of the Second World War and the Nazi expansion and extermination policy and their aftermaths.<ref name=para16 />


(2) This purpose shall be fullfilled especially by the following measures: (2) This purpose shall be fulfilled especially by the following measures:
*(2.1) Establishment, maintenance and expansion of a permanent exhibition documenting flight and expulsion in the 20th century, the historical background and contexts as well as the European dimension and effects.<ref name=para16/> *(2.1) Establishment, maintenance and expansion of a permanent exhibition documenting flight and expulsion in the 20th century, the historical background and contexts as well as the European dimension and effects.<ref name=para16 />
*(2.2) Development of singular exhibitions for special aspects of the overall context.<ref name=para16/> *(2.2) Development of singular exhibitions for special aspects of the overall context.<ref name=para16 />
*(2.3) Distribution of research results and scientific findings.<ref name=para16/> *(2.3) Distribution of research results and scientific findings.<ref name=para16 />
*(2.4) Gathering, documentation and scientific evaluation of respective sources and materials, also and especially eyewitness accounts.<ref name=para16/> *(2.4) Gathering, documentation and scientific evaluation of respective sources and materials, also and especially eyewitness accounts.<ref name=para16 />
*(2.5) Cooperation with German and international museums and research centers.<ref name=para16>full text of §16, law for establishment of a foundation "German Historical Museum": Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Stiftung „Deutsches Historisches Museum“ § 16 *(2.5) Cooperation with German and international museums and research centers.<ref name=para16>full text of §16, law for establishment of a foundation "German Historical Museum": Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Stiftung „Deutsches Historisches Museum“ § 16
Stiftungszweck Stiftungszweck<br />
(1) Zweck der unselbständigen Stiftung ist es, im Geiste der Versöhnung die *(1) Zweck der unselbständigen Stiftung ist es, im Geiste der Versöhnung die Erinnerung und das Gedenken an Flucht und Vertreibung im 20. Jahrhundert im historischen Kontext des Zweiten Weltkrieges und der nationalsozialistischen Expansions- und Vernichtungspolitik und ihrer Folgen wachzuhalten.
⚫ *(2) Der Erfüllung dieses Zweckes dienen insbesondere:
Erinnerung und das Gedenken an Flucht und Vertreibung im 20. Jahrhundert im
**1. Errichtung, Unterhaltung und Weiterentwicklung einer Dauerausstellung zu Flucht und Vertreibung im 20. Jahrhundert, den historischen Hintergründen und Zusammenhängen sowie europäischen Dimensionen und Folgen;
historischen Kontext des Zweiten Weltkrieges und der nationalsozialistischen
⚫ **2. Erarbeitung von Einzelausstellungen zu speziellen Aspekten der Gesamtthematik;
Expansions- und Vernichtungspolitik und ihrer Folgen wachzuhalten.
⚫ **3. Vermittlung von Forschungsergebnissen und wissenschaftlichen Erkenntnissen;
⚫ (2) Der Erfüllung dieses Zweckes dienen insbesondere:
⚫ **4. Sammlung, Dokumentation und wissenschaftliche Auswertung einschlägiger Unterlagen und Materialien, insbesondere auch von Zeitzeugenberichten;
1. Errichtung, Unterhaltung und Weiterentwicklung einer Dauerausstellung zu Flucht
⚫ **5. Zusammenarbeit mit deutschen und internationalen Museen und Forschungseinrichtungen</ref>
und Vertreibung im 20. Jahrhundert, den historischen Hintergründen und
Zusammenhängen sowie europäischen Dimensionen und Folgen;
⚫ 2. Erarbeitung von Einzelausstellungen zu speziellen Aspekten der Gesamtthematik;
⚫ 3. Vermittlung von Forschungsergebnissen und wissenschaftlichen Erkenntnissen;
⚫ 4. Sammlung, Dokumentation und wissenschaftliche Auswertung einschlägiger
Unterlagen und Materialien, insbesondere auch von Zeitzeugenberichten;
⚫ 5. Zusammenarbeit mit deutschen und internationalen Museen und
Forschungseinrichtungen</ref>


== Perception == == People and supporters ==


The scientific advisory board includes or included ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ], ] and ].
=== Support ===
⚫ The Centre Against Expulsions has been supported by a number of ] activists, historians, political scientists and authors as well as other people. Among these supporters are the United Nations' first ] Dr. ], German chancellor ]<ref></ref>, ] and Holocaust survivor ], ], ], former ]n crown prince ], prominent German rabbis ], ], and historians such as ], Hungarian novelist ], historian ], ], ] and ].


⚫ The United Nations' first ] Dr. ], German chancellor ],<ref></ref> ] and Holocaust survivor ], ], ], former ]n crown prince ], and historians such as ], Hungarian novelist ], and ], have also voiced their support for the centre.
⚫ === Criticism ===


⚫ ==Criticism==
In a petition initiated by Hans Henning Hahn, Eva Hahn, Alexandra Kurth, Samuel Salzborn and Tobias Weger in 2003, signed by several hundred people, primarily German, Czech, and Polish historians, opponents of the proposed form of Centre expressed concerns the centre would "establish and popularize a one-sided image of the past, without historical context", and see the dangers of "de-contexualizing the past" and "ethnification of social conflicts".<ref></ref>


In a petition initiated by Hans Henning Hahn, Eva Hahn, Alexandra Kurth, Samuel Salzborn and Tobias Weger in 2003, signed by several hundred people, primarily German, Czech, and Polish historians, opponents of the proposed form of Centre expressed concerns the centre would "establish and popularize a one-sided image of the past, without historical context", and see the dangers of "de-contexualizing the past" and "ethnification of social conflicts".<ref></ref> German-Jewish writer ] withdrew his initial support for the same reason,<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.rp.pl/artykul/73756-Chcialem-zmienic-pania-Steinbach-.html|title=Chciałem zmienić panią Steinbach|website=www.rp.pl|language=pl|access-date=2019-09-23}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|url=http://wyborcza.pl/1,76842,4732284.html?disableRedirects=true|title=Wyborcza.pl|website=wyborcza.pl|access-date=2019-09-23}}</ref> but defended Steinbach against the latest personal accusations from Poland, which he called defamation.<ref></ref> Former German Foreign minister ] said "This can't be a museum of German war victims. Germans can't point fingers at others".<ref>http://serwisy.gazeta.pl/swiat/1,34181,1642833.html{{Dead link|date=November 2019 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref>
Critics in Poland oppose the idea of a research centre in Berlin led by ] because it equates Germans with Jews and Poles, and attempts to suggest a moral equivalence between the victims of war and their oppressors.<ref>Mark Landler, ], 31 August 2006, (</ref> The Polish government opposes the involvement of Steinbach in Polish-German relations regarding historical issues and at the same time supports an international net of centres dedicated to remembrance of totalitarian regimes and their victims called "Memory and Solidarity".<ref></ref> Steinbach has relinquished her seat in the panel of the "Foundation German Historical Museum" in March 2009.<ref>], ERIKA STEINBACH AND GERMAN VICTIMS OF WWII, 'I Want the Truth, and Nothing But' </ref>

===Criticism in Poland===

Critics in Poland oppose the idea of the centre claiming that it would equate German suffering with that of the Jews and Poles and will suggest a moral equivalence between the victims of war and their oppressors.<ref>Mark Landler, ], 31 August 2006, (</ref> ], the last living leader of ], criticized the project as nationalistic, arrogant and serving to realize political ambitions of the backers of the project. According to Edelman other nations subject to German expulsions didn't establish any comparable monuments, even as they faced a harsher fate than Germans.<ref name="tygodnik2003-2007.onet.pl">{{Cite web |url=http://tygodnik2003-2007.onet.pl/1544,5549,1131042,1,tematy.html |title=Onet.pl - Tygodnik Powszechny - Tematy miesiąca - Centrum przeciw Wypędzeniom - Nie litować się nad Niemcami |access-date=2009-03-21 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110807214750/http://tygodnik2003-2007.onet.pl/1544,5549,1131042,1,tematy.html |archive-date=2011-08-07 |url-status=dead }}</ref>

The Polish government opposes the involvement of ] in any issues related to Polish-German history and at the same time supports an international net of centers dedicated to remembrance of totalitarian regimes and their victims called "European Network Remembrance and Solidarity".


==See also== ==See also==
*]
*]
*] *]

== Weblinks ==
*


==References== ==References==
Line 72: Line 74:


==External links== ==External links==
* *
*{{de icon}} *{{in lang|de}}
* (2003) * (2003)
*
{{coord missing|Berlin}}


{{Authority control}}
]
]
]
]
]
]
]
]
]
]

Latest revision as of 11:36, 27 October 2024

Planned Nazi German documentation centre

The Centre Against Expulsions (German: Zentrum gegen Vertreibungen, ZgV) was a planned German documentation centre for expulsions and ethnic cleansing, particularly the expulsion of Germans after World War II. Since March 19, 2008 the name of the project is Sichtbares Zeichen gegen Flucht und Vertreibung.

The project was initiated by the Federation of Expellees, who dedicated a "Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" to the centre. This foundation is based in Wiesbaden, and headed by CDU politician and president of the Federation of Expellees, Erika Steinbach. The other head of the foundation was SPD politician Peter Glotz who died in 2005. The head of the foundation ZgV since 2018 is Christean Wagner, a politician of the Christian Democratic Union in Germany.

Since late 2008, the project is forwarded by the Federal Republic of Germany, when the federal government and parliament passed a law calling for the constitution of a Foundation German Historical Museum subordinate to the federal government, which in turn shall hold a Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation which shall take on the actual documentation in Berlin. The project has been subject to criticism, especially in Poland.

"Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" of the Federation of Expellees

The Federation of Expellees (German: Bund der Vertriebenen, BdV) is the German non-governmental head organization of various organized groups of German refugees and expellees. The federation is committed to document the post- World War II flight and expulsion of Germans as well as other forced displacements, and maintains an exhibition for this purpose shown in changing locations of Germany. To expand this exhibition and to find a permanent place for it, the Federation of Expellees set up the "Foundation Centre Against Expulsions" (German: Stiftung Zentrum gegen Vertreibungen, ZgV)) on 6 September 2000.

Objectives

The foundation Centre Against Expulsions defines four objectives:

  1. To document the history of settlement, culture, post-World War II deportation and expulsion, forced labour, torture, and later emigration of Germans from various countries of Central, Eastern and Southeastern Europe, in a modern museum. The museum shall provide room for the documentation and "additional space for sadness, sympathy and forgiveness" in a requiem rotunda.
  2. To document and to evaluate the impact of the integration of millions of uprooted Germans into the post-World War II German society.
  3. To document the "expulsion and genocide of other peoples, especially in Europe", arguing that "displacement, expulsion and genocide can never be justified, are always a crime, contradicting human rights and carried out by following the archaic thinking of the bloody vendetta."
  4. To donate a Franz Werfel Human Rights Award to people who "sharpen the sense of responsibility through their actions is one of the foundation's tasks".

"Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation"

On 11 November 2005, the largest German political parties SPD and CDU signed a coalition. One stated goal of the coalition is the establishment of a centre termed "Visible Sign" (German: Sichtbares Zeichen).

On 3 September 2008 the German federal government passed a law calling for the establishment of a center against expulsions in the Deutschlandhaus building of the Anhalter Bahnhof site in Berlin-Kreuzberg. The law passed the German parliament and was enacted on 29 December 2008. The center is to be run by a "Foundation Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation" (German: Stiftung Flucht, Vertreibung, Versöhnung) subordinate to the governmental "Foundation German Historical Museum" (German: Stiftung Deutsches Historisches Museum).

"Foundation German Historical Museum" of the German federal government

The purpose of this foundation is stated in §16 of the above-mentioned law as follows:

(1) The purpose of the non-autonomous foundation is to ensure in the spirit of reconciliation the remembrance of flight and expulsion in the 20th century in the historical context of the Second World War and the Nazi expansion and extermination policy and their aftermaths.

(2) This purpose shall be fulfilled especially by the following measures:

  • (2.1) Establishment, maintenance and expansion of a permanent exhibition documenting flight and expulsion in the 20th century, the historical background and contexts as well as the European dimension and effects.
  • (2.2) Development of singular exhibitions for special aspects of the overall context.
  • (2.3) Distribution of research results and scientific findings.
  • (2.4) Gathering, documentation and scientific evaluation of respective sources and materials, also and especially eyewitness accounts.
  • (2.5) Cooperation with German and international museums and research centers.

People and supporters

The scientific advisory board includes or included Jörg Baberowski, Arnulf Baring, Peter Becher, Lothar Gall, Bernhard Graf, Helga Hirsch, Walter Homolka, Eckart Klein, Hilmar Kopper, Rudolf Kucera, Otto Graf Lambsdorff, Horst Möller, Christoph Pan, Rüdiger Safranski, Christoph Stölzl, Christian Tomuschat, Krisztián Ungváry, Georg Wildmann, Michael Wolffsohn, Alfred-Maurice de Zayas and Zoran Ziletic.

The United Nations' first High Commissioner for Human Rights Dr. José Ayala Lasso, German chancellor Angela Merkel, Nobel literature laureate and Holocaust survivor Imre Kertész, Joachim Gauck, Milan Horáček, former Austrian crown prince Otto von Habsburg, and historians such as Guido Knopp, Hungarian novelist György Konrád, and Christian Tomuschat, have also voiced their support for the centre.

Criticism

In a petition initiated by Hans Henning Hahn, Eva Hahn, Alexandra Kurth, Samuel Salzborn and Tobias Weger in 2003, signed by several hundred people, primarily German, Czech, and Polish historians, opponents of the proposed form of Centre expressed concerns the centre would "establish and popularize a one-sided image of the past, without historical context", and see the dangers of "de-contexualizing the past" and "ethnification of social conflicts". German-Jewish writer Ralph Giordano withdrew his initial support for the same reason, but defended Steinbach against the latest personal accusations from Poland, which he called defamation. Former German Foreign minister Joschka Fischer said "This can't be a museum of German war victims. Germans can't point fingers at others".

Criticism in Poland

Critics in Poland oppose the idea of the centre claiming that it would equate German suffering with that of the Jews and Poles and will suggest a moral equivalence between the victims of war and their oppressors. Marek Edelman, the last living leader of Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, criticized the project as nationalistic, arrogant and serving to realize political ambitions of the backers of the project. According to Edelman other nations subject to German expulsions didn't establish any comparable monuments, even as they faced a harsher fate than Germans.

The Polish government opposes the involvement of Erika Steinbach in any issues related to Polish-German history and at the same time supports an international net of centers dedicated to remembrance of totalitarian regimes and their victims called "European Network Remembrance and Solidarity".

See also

Weblinks

References

  1. ^ "Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Tasks and Objectives"". Archived from the original on 2011-05-14. Retrieved 2009-03-16.
  2. Michael Levitin, Telegraph.uk, 26 Feb 2009, "plans to build a museum dedicated to German refugees who fled or were expelled from Poland after the Second World War."
  3. ^ German federal government release of 03.09.2008
  5. ^ Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Our Foundation" Archived 2009-08-01 at the Wayback Machine
  6. ^ full text of German law to establish a foundation "German Historical Museum": Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Stiftung „Deutsches Historisches Museum“ (DHMG) vom 21. Dezember 2008 in der Fassung der Bekanntmachung vom 29.Dezember 2008 (BGBl. I Nr. 64, S. 2891) (pdf file) (html file)
  7. Michael Levitin, Telegraph.uk, 26 Feb 2009
  8. Tony Paterson, The Independent, 21 February 2009
  9. "Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Permanent exhibition"". Archived from the original on 2011-05-14. Retrieved 2009-03-17.
  10. Centre Against Expulsions, foundation website, "Franz-Werfel-Human Rights Award" Archived 2014-04-13 at the Wayback Machine
  11. German Federal Government, Appointee for Culture and Media, center conception, press release 19 March 2008 Archived 2009-02-28 at the Wayback Machine
  12. German Federal Government, press release, 3 September 2008 Archived 2009-03-10 at the Wayback Machine (including link to the law (pdf file)
  13. ^ full text of §16, law for establishment of a foundation "German Historical Museum": Gesetz zur Errichtung einer Stiftung „Deutsches Historisches Museum“ § 16 Stiftungszweck
    • (1) Zweck der unselbständigen Stiftung ist es, im Geiste der Versöhnung die Erinnerung und das Gedenken an Flucht und Vertreibung im 20. Jahrhundert im historischen Kontext des Zweiten Weltkrieges und der nationalsozialistischen Expansions- und Vernichtungspolitik und ihrer Folgen wachzuhalten.
    • (2) Der Erfüllung dieses Zweckes dienen insbesondere:
      • 1. Errichtung, Unterhaltung und Weiterentwicklung einer Dauerausstellung zu Flucht und Vertreibung im 20. Jahrhundert, den historischen Hintergründen und Zusammenhängen sowie europäischen Dimensionen und Folgen;
      • 2. Erarbeitung von Einzelausstellungen zu speziellen Aspekten der Gesamtthematik;
      • 3. Vermittlung von Forschungsergebnissen und wissenschaftlichen Erkenntnissen;
      • 4. Sammlung, Dokumentation und wissenschaftliche Auswertung einschlägiger Unterlagen und Materialien, insbesondere auch von Zeitzeugenberichten;
      • 5. Zusammenarbeit mit deutschen und internationalen Museen und Forschungseinrichtungen
  14. tagesschau:Merkel supports center against expulsions in Berlin
  15. For a critical and enlightened debate about the past
  16. "Chciałem zmienić panią Steinbach". www.rp.pl (in Polish). Retrieved 2019-09-23.
  17. "Wyborcza.pl". wyborcza.pl. Retrieved 2019-09-23.
  18. Giordano:Erika Steinbach ist keine Revanchistin
  19. http://serwisy.gazeta.pl/swiat/1,34181,1642833.html
  20. Mark Landler, International Herald Tribune, 31 August 2006, (Poles riled by Berlin exhibition, Germans’ expulsion after the war is its focus
  21. "Onet.pl - Tygodnik Powszechny - Tematy miesiąca - Centrum przeciw Wypędzeniom - Nie litować się nad Niemcami". Archived from the original on 2011-08-07. Retrieved 2009-03-21.

External links

Categories: