Misplaced Pages

Grinding (video games): Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 00:27, 25 December 2005 editElonka (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Administrators70,958 edits Added link to White Paper editor's wikipedia page← Previous edit Latest revision as of 23:48, 22 November 2024 edit undoTJBdale (talk | contribs)10 edits Restructured to reflect the pageTags: references removed Visual edit 
(697 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Performing repetitive tasks for gameplay or cosmetic advantage}}
{{mergefrom|Catassing}}
{{redirect-distinguish|Farming (video gaming)|gold farming}}
{{Multiple issues|
{{Original research|section|date=November 2022}}
{{More citations needed|date=August 2024}}
}}
Grinding is a term within video game culture that describes time spent in the game in which a player repeats a general task in order to gain rewards like ], in-game experience, player stats or other reward types. The method was first seen in '']''<ref>{{Cite web |date=2020-01-22 |title=How "grinding" came to dominate video game culture |url=https://www.inverse.com/gaming/how-grinding-came-to-dominate-video-game-culture |access-date=2024-11-22 |website=Inverse |language=en}}</ref>'','' and though there are many adaptations of it, it has since become an entire category of gameplay.


The term "grinding" itself comes from the general human culture of working hard, or "putting the axe to grind." A related term in gaming is "farming," which is a similar act of repeated action with intention to get a reward.
'''Grinding''', in the computer gaming sense, is a pejorative term used to describe the process of engaging in repetitive and/or non-entertaining gameplay (More often than not, battles in RPGS) in order to gain access to other features within the game. The most common usage is in the context of ]s, in which it is often necessary for a character to repeatedly kill monsters, using basically the same strategy over and over again, in order to advance their character level to be able to access newer content. Grinding can also appear in other games in which features can be unlocked.


== Motivation ==
Synonyms for grinding include '''treadmilling''' and '''pushing the bar''' (a reference to ] in which animals, having learned that pushing a bar will sometimes produce a treat, will devote time to pushing the bar over and over again).
A player is commonly motivated to grind due to a desire to earn rewards, gather resources, or increase their ]. Alternatively, some people may enjoy repetitive tasks for the purpose of relaxation, especially if the task has a consistently positive result.<ref>{{cite web |author=Lawley, Liz |date=2006-08-05 |title=In Praise of the Grind |url=http://terranova.blogs.com/terra_nova/2006/08/in_praise_of_th.html |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090206212317/http://terranova.blogs.com/terra_nova/2006/08/in_praise_of_th.html |archive-date=2009-02-06 |access-date=2009-03-06 |work=Terra Nova |quote= I want to relax, to clear my mind, to do something repetitive that provides visible (to me, not to you) and lasting evidence of my efforts }}</ref>


] often require grinding, which is achieved through a progression system. These systems vary from game to game but tend to involve some form of point allocation.
Used as a noun, a '''grind''' (or a '''treadmill''') is a designed-in game aspect which requires the player to engage in grinding. The idea of having a designed-in game aspect which requires a player to not be entertained for a period of time seems contradictory to good sense, but has been justified in several different ways. The most common of these is that requiring a player to spend long periods of time to gain game power ensures a level playing field: a players will not have an advantage from the very start as a result of having better aim, faster reactions, or better tactical knowledge. If they did, then via the ] the top players in these fields would quickly dominate the entire game. Although the ] will still apply to the amount of time spent grinding, at least every player will have the potential to reach the top 20%. This was explored further in Raph Koster's presentation '']''.


==Level treadmill== == Approaches ==
=== Regular grinding ===
The '''level treadmill''' is a term used by fans of ]s (MMORPGs) to describe the uninteresting ] of endlessly gaining ]s and levels by performing repetitive tasks. It compares this kind of play with exercise ]s. This practice is also known as '''level grinding'''. It is one of the most common criticisms about MMORPGs.
For some games, grinding is an integral part of the gameplay and is required if the player wants to make significant progress. In some cases, progression may be entirely negated if the player does not grind enough, for example an area necessary for the story may be locked until a certain action is repeated a certain amount of time to prove the experience of the player. Examples of games with grinding include:


'']'' requires the player to partake in repetitive tasks to level up skills. An example would be the "Slayer" skill, which requires players to defeat a certain number of a specific type of creature. The monsters are chosen based on the player's combat level. Players gain experience while fighting the monsters, which increases both their Slayer level and their combat skills. Because the effort is repetitive and time-consuming, it is considered "grinding".
The most common form of level treadmill is the practice of killing monsters for experience points. The player constantly chases after the next level in order to be able to defeat the next slightly stronger monster. The outcome of MMORPG combat tends to depend more on the character's numerical statistics than the player's skill. Thus there is usually little for a player to do beyond clicking an attack button until he or she wins, or is forced to flee when nearing death. So whether fighting small rats or large demons, the player is performing essentially the same actions, the only difference being the larger numbers in his character and the monster's attributes. In other words, running forward while going nowhere, as on an exercise ].


'']'' requires players to repeatedly kill specific enemies to acquire Legendary items. Legendary drops are not guaranteed to be dropped the first time, therefore the enemy who drops the desired item will likely have to be fought multiple times.
Players often critcize level treadmills as an obvious method of requiring the player to play the game longer. They argue that the most interesting ] comes when their character is at the highest levels, where they can effectively participate in raids or ] combat. They believe that the MMORPG provider's motivation to add treadmills is to slow the time it takes to reach the highest levels so that the player pays more subscription fees along the way.


'']'' allows players to gather materials by exploring in caves, on the surface, and by other means. However, some materials are harder to find than others, such as diamond or ]. The most common strategy for finding these materials is to obtain the fastest tools possible, that being a diamond or netherite pickaxe, shovel and axe (depending on the material that the player wants to grind for) that has been enchanted with Efficiency V and using this pickaxe in tandem with a Haste beacon. With this combination, most common blocks can be mined immediately, massively decreasing the time it takes to find rare materials.
Some enthusiasts of the genre have objected to the term ''level treadmill'' as an oversimplification of an MMORPG's gameplay. They argue that, like traditional ]s, there is no goal in MMORPGs other than to enjoy the experience. However, some would argue that in traditional RPGs, players play for enjoyment, and to act out their character; in fact, some players deliberately create weak characters because they find them interesting to play.


=== Advanced rewards ===
It has also observed that intense grinding can actively damage the role-playing aspect of a game by making a nonsense of the simulated world. A classic example of this occured in '']'', where skills were improved by using them. It was therefore possible to see groups of three people, in which:
'']'' features a "title system" in which players are awarded special titles, and often new abilities, for killing large quantities of specific types of enemies. This can make grinding worthwhile, as the player benefits from the added experience points and can receive a title they can show off to other players. For example, killing a large number of Wargs grants the player the "Warg-Slayer" title. Killing even more Wargs results in more advanced titles, such as "Warg Foe". This system also existed in '']''/''City of Villains'', where these titles were named "badges".


'']'' features a "Chain" effect, which occurs when a player repeatedly kills the same monster; doing so increases the number in the Chain and improves the quality of the items dropped by the killed enemy. With a maximum of 999 chained kills, the Chain can only be broken by killing a different monster or leaving the area.
* One person was repeatedly deliberately falling over, taking a small amount of damage each time.
* A second person was healing the first, increasing their healing skill, and taking "stress" damage themselves.
* A third person was dancing for the second, relieving their "stress" damage and increasing their dancing skill.


'']'' features grinding in one of its purest forms, but also in a quite developed fashion. Every ''Warframe''{{'}}s parts are acquired differently - most drop from boss fights within the game, others can be easily purchased from a Clan's Dojo, while certain parts have a percentage chance of dropping from certain game modes once the player spends enough time in them. ''Warframe'' supports "endless" and "non-endless" missions - with "non-endless" having a set objective, such as capturing a VIP target for interrogation, and "Endless" being infinitely replayable, such as defending an important piece of equipment or intercepting and decrypting enemy communications. Endless missions use a Rotation system, with three different "Drop Tables", one for each. The rule of thumb for Endless missions is AABC, meaning that on rounds 1 and 2, the item that is granted to the player will be selected from Drop Table A, for round 3 it will be chosen from Drop Table B, and round 4, Drop Table C. The cycle repeats every four rounds until the player leaves the mission. "Non-endless" missions may function in two ways: First, missions such as capturing an enemy will have a single drop table and semi-randomly draw an item from it each time, with a certain chance for each item. Missions with more objectives, such as infiltrating three "Data Vaults", will have multiple drop tables, one for each objective. Completing more objectives in "non-endless" missions will allow the player to have a chance at the rarest items included in the last drop table.
The ] Online Games Special Interest Group has noted that level treadmills are part of the addictive quality of MMORPGs that caters to those who play more than 25 hours a week (]). Gamers originally used the term '']'' to describe someone who is obsessively playing an MMORPG.


=== Limited rewards ===
⚫ ==References==
'']'' attempts to reduce grinding by using a very low maximum level (20). Equipment with maximum statistics becomes easy to obtain at a maximum level. Players can still improve themselves by acquiring new and different skills so they can create more varied combinations of skills, or they can gather points for titles that improve certain skills usable only in ]. The game was designed to be difficult even for players who have reached the maximum level and obtained the best equipment, but without creating huge gaps between the hardcore and casual players so that both could enjoy the same challenges. Play past the level cap usually provides rewards in the form of tokens and specific in-game currencies that contribute to rarer and often visually superior cosmetic items for player avatars compared to the most easily acquired sets. The focus in these late-game areas is therefore usually aimed at effective teamwork and how the players approach a problem as opposed to the degree of statistics acquired by playtime.
# ] (ed.). "". (PDF)

===AFK or inactive grinding ===
'']'' features a system that does not require continuous play to increase character skill. Characters are plugged into their ship's computer and are trained at a rate based on their attributes. Attributes can be enhanced to decrease training time, but training occurs continuously whether the player is logged in or not. Some of the advanced skills can take as long as a month or more to reach the next level. Players generally have to grind for ISK (money), minerals, and NPC faction standing. However, the in-game alliance CODE. protests grinding, by attacking or 'ganking' anyone suspected of 'illegal' grinding.<ref>{{cite web |title=MinerBumping |url=http://www.minerbumping.com}}</ref>

'']'' allows structures called ] grinders which automates the process of killing monsters. This is usually done by gathering them using flowing water and killing them with a large fall at the end of the water flow. When built, a mob grinder removes the need to fight or work for the mob drops as they become generated passively. The game also allows the players to create other AFK (away from keyboard) farms to aid in fishing, growing sugarcane and other crops, or even generating moss blocks. Utilising redstone and 'TNT duping', a player is able to create a "world eater", a machine that is capable of duplicating TNT in such a manner that a large space of land can be cleared out without player intervention.

'']'' contains the literal definition of grinding in the most simplistic sense, as the methods of making money are through any of the several "life skills" such as cooking, or combat through killing monsters. A cooking session consists of cooking the same dish several hundred or even thousand times for several hours, over and over. This may be performed completely AFK at a lower efficiency and is popular among players who can only attend to their character periodically. It may also be performed more actively, with as little as 8 minutes before the cooking stove, or utensil as it is called in game, is depleted depending on the utensil, gear, and various consumable buffs used.

'']'' features passive businesses that produce various types of cargo automatically that can be later sold for profit. The player is only required to resupply the businesses and do a sell mission once the production is finished. An exception is the "Nightclub" business that can produce goods without the need to resupply. While the game has a mechanic that kick out of the game players who stay AFK for more than 15 minutes, various methods bypass this. Later game additions add police raids after long AFK sessions.

=== Shorter time commitments ===
'']'' features dungeons that can be played in segments, so that players can play the game in smaller chunks of time, allowing ones who can't afford to dedicate several hours of continuous playing time to complete them.<ref name="widowmaker">{{cite news |author=Christian Stöcker |date=2006-08-25 |title=An Interview with the Maker of "World of Warcraft" |work=] |url=https://www.spiegel.de/international/real-time-gaming-an-interview-with-the-maker-of-world-of-warcraft-a-433643-amp.html |url-status=live |access-date=2009-12-17 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110716030159/http://www.spiegel.de/international/0,1518,433643,00.html |archive-date=2011-07-16}}</ref> The game also includes a "resting system" which increases the rate of experience gain for casual players, based on the amount of time spent out of the game. Similar systems exist in other games, including ''Lord of the Rings Online'' and ''City of Heroes''.

=== Other ===
'']'' features a party quest, called the Dojo PQ, that can be done with several players or solo. It is available to all players level 25 or above. It is a boss rush, in which the player or players revisit many bosses, one by one, all in a row. Beating every boss gets the player Dojo points, which, when accumulated in large numbers, can be used to get equipment for the player's character which boosts stats. Players can also get a title for 24 hours when they beat a certain boss 100 times.<ref>{{cite web |title=MapleStory - A Free Massively Multiplayer Online Role-playing Game |url=http://maplestory.nexon.net/WZ.ASPX?PART=/Event/View&boardNo=200&contentNo=005aqW&pageIndex=1 |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100112105319/http://maplestory.nexon.net/WZ.ASPX?PART=%2FEvent%2FView&boardNo=200&contentNo=005aqW&pageIndex=1 |archive-date=2010-01-12 |access-date=2010-05-28 |publisher=Maplestory.nexon.net}}</ref>

===Parody===
The repetitiveness of grinding has given birth to early iterations of ],<ref>{{cite AV media |url=https://www.gdcvault.com/play/1022065/Idle-Games-The-Mechanics-and |title=Idle Games: The Mechanics and Monetization of Self-Playing Games |date=February 2015 |medium=Recorded presentation with slides. |publisher=Game Developer Conference (GDC) 2015 |location= |people=Anthony Pecorella}}</ref> such as ''Ayumilove's HackerQuest V1'' (2008),<ref name="kongregate-idle">{{cite web |last= |first= |date= |title=Earliest idle games on Kongregate |url=https://www.kongregate.com/idle-games?sort=oldest |access-date=2021-02-16 |website=Kongregate |publisher= |quote=}}</ref> which parodies a bot grinding for items and avoiding GMs (Game Masters) in '']'', a famous MMORPG from Korea.

== Criticism ==
Grinding is a controversial subject among video game players. Some consider grinding to be a result of poor game design, while others embrace it as an inherent feature in all video games.<ref name="frans">{{cite book |last=Mäyrä |first=Frans |title=An Introduction to Game Studies |publisher=SAGE |year=2008 |isbn=978-1849205399 |page=132}}</ref>

Another criticism of the ] and level playing field approach is that it often allows the player to avoid difficult strategic or reflexive challenges that one might encounter when fighting powerful opponents. By spending a large amount of time battling easily defeated characters (a practice known as ''bottom feeding''), players can gain levels to have little difficulty vanquishing more difficult enemies.<ref>{{cite web |author=The Luddite |year=2014 |title=A Brief History of Leveling Systems |url=http://theludite.com/2014/08/03/a-brief-history-of-leveling-systems/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20141207182439/http://theludite.com/2014/08/03/a-brief-history-of-leveling-systems/ |archive-date=2014-12-07 |access-date=2014-12-09}}</ref>

To solve the grinding issue, E. McNeill proposes that "the most effective path to victory should also be the most fun".<ref> {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140722051050/http://gamasutra.com/blogs/EMcNeill/20140721/221443/Grinding_and_the_Burden_of_Optimal_Play.php |date=2014-07-22}} - E McNeill, Gamasutra, 21 July 2014</ref> For example, challenging tasks should always give better rewards than easy tasks.

Another alternative to grinding is to remove designer-defined objectives, leaving players free to do whatever they want. This creates a new problem where many players might be confused about what they are supposed to do, or they might lack the motivation to do much of anything in the virtual world.<ref name="Koster 07">{{cite web |author=Koster, Raph |author-link=Raph Koster |date=2007-04-23 |title=The game without treadmills |url=http://www.raphkoster.com/2007/04/23/the-game-without-treadmills/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080512231715/http://www.raphkoster.com/2007/04/23/the-game-without-treadmills/ |archive-date=2008-05-12 |access-date=2007-09-05}}</ref>

Players of subscription-based online games often criticize grinds as a heavy-handed attempt to gain profit. The most interesting and challenging gameplay is often only available to characters at the highest levels, who are those strong enough to participate in ] or ] combat. Grinding is seen as a reason to increase the amount of time it takes to reach these levels, forcing the player to pay more subscription fees along the way.

The ] Online Games Special Interest Group has noted that level treadmills are part of the addictive quality of ]s or MMORPGs that cater to those who play more than 25 hours a week.<ref name="IGDA">{{cite web|date=March 2003|editor=Dunin, Elonka|editor-link=Elonka Dunin|title=IGDA Online Games White Paper, 2nd Edition|url=http://www.igda.org/online/IGDA_Online_Games_Whitepaper_2003.pdf|url-status=live|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20040920100604if_/http://www.igda.org/online/IGDA_Online_Games_Whitepaper_2003.pdf|archive-date=2004-09-20}}</ref>


==See also== ==See also==
*] * ]
* ]s
*]
*] * ]
* ]
* ]

==Notes==
{{Reflist|group="note"}}

⚫ ==References==
{{Reflist|30em}}
{{MUDs|state=collapsed}}


{{DEFAULTSORT:Grinding (Gaming)}}
]
]
]
]

Latest revision as of 23:48, 22 November 2024

Performing repetitive tasks for gameplay or cosmetic advantage "Farming (video gaming)" redirects here. Not to be confused with gold farming.
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
This section possibly contains original research. Please improve it by verifying the claims made and adding inline citations. Statements consisting only of original research should be removed. (November 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.
Find sources: "Grinding" video games – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (August 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
(Learn how and when to remove this message)

Grinding is a term within video game culture that describes time spent in the game in which a player repeats a general task in order to gain rewards like in-game currency, in-game experience, player stats or other reward types. The method was first seen in dnd, and though there are many adaptations of it, it has since become an entire category of gameplay.

The term "grinding" itself comes from the general human culture of working hard, or "putting the axe to grind." A related term in gaming is "farming," which is a similar act of repeated action with intention to get a reward.

Motivation

A player is commonly motivated to grind due to a desire to earn rewards, gather resources, or increase their level. Alternatively, some people may enjoy repetitive tasks for the purpose of relaxation, especially if the task has a consistently positive result.

MMORPGs often require grinding, which is achieved through a progression system. These systems vary from game to game but tend to involve some form of point allocation.

Approaches

Regular grinding

For some games, grinding is an integral part of the gameplay and is required if the player wants to make significant progress. In some cases, progression may be entirely negated if the player does not grind enough, for example an area necessary for the story may be locked until a certain action is repeated a certain amount of time to prove the experience of the player. Examples of games with grinding include:

RuneScape requires the player to partake in repetitive tasks to level up skills. An example would be the "Slayer" skill, which requires players to defeat a certain number of a specific type of creature. The monsters are chosen based on the player's combat level. Players gain experience while fighting the monsters, which increases both their Slayer level and their combat skills. Because the effort is repetitive and time-consuming, it is considered "grinding".

Borderlands 2 requires players to repeatedly kill specific enemies to acquire Legendary items. Legendary drops are not guaranteed to be dropped the first time, therefore the enemy who drops the desired item will likely have to be fought multiple times.

Minecraft allows players to gather materials by exploring in caves, on the surface, and by other means. However, some materials are harder to find than others, such as diamond or netherite. The most common strategy for finding these materials is to obtain the fastest tools possible, that being a diamond or netherite pickaxe, shovel and axe (depending on the material that the player wants to grind for) that has been enchanted with Efficiency V and using this pickaxe in tandem with a Haste beacon. With this combination, most common blocks can be mined immediately, massively decreasing the time it takes to find rare materials.

Advanced rewards

The Lord of the Rings Online features a "title system" in which players are awarded special titles, and often new abilities, for killing large quantities of specific types of enemies. This can make grinding worthwhile, as the player benefits from the added experience points and can receive a title they can show off to other players. For example, killing a large number of Wargs grants the player the "Warg-Slayer" title. Killing even more Wargs results in more advanced titles, such as "Warg Foe". This system also existed in City of Heroes/City of Villains, where these titles were named "badges".

Final Fantasy XII features a "Chain" effect, which occurs when a player repeatedly kills the same monster; doing so increases the number in the Chain and improves the quality of the items dropped by the killed enemy. With a maximum of 999 chained kills, the Chain can only be broken by killing a different monster or leaving the area.

Warframe features grinding in one of its purest forms, but also in a quite developed fashion. Every Warframe's parts are acquired differently - most drop from boss fights within the game, others can be easily purchased from a Clan's Dojo, while certain parts have a percentage chance of dropping from certain game modes once the player spends enough time in them. Warframe supports "endless" and "non-endless" missions - with "non-endless" having a set objective, such as capturing a VIP target for interrogation, and "Endless" being infinitely replayable, such as defending an important piece of equipment or intercepting and decrypting enemy communications. Endless missions use a Rotation system, with three different "Drop Tables", one for each. The rule of thumb for Endless missions is AABC, meaning that on rounds 1 and 2, the item that is granted to the player will be selected from Drop Table A, for round 3 it will be chosen from Drop Table B, and round 4, Drop Table C. The cycle repeats every four rounds until the player leaves the mission. "Non-endless" missions may function in two ways: First, missions such as capturing an enemy will have a single drop table and semi-randomly draw an item from it each time, with a certain chance for each item. Missions with more objectives, such as infiltrating three "Data Vaults", will have multiple drop tables, one for each objective. Completing more objectives in "non-endless" missions will allow the player to have a chance at the rarest items included in the last drop table.

Limited rewards

Guild Wars attempts to reduce grinding by using a very low maximum level (20). Equipment with maximum statistics becomes easy to obtain at a maximum level. Players can still improve themselves by acquiring new and different skills so they can create more varied combinations of skills, or they can gather points for titles that improve certain skills usable only in PvE. The game was designed to be difficult even for players who have reached the maximum level and obtained the best equipment, but without creating huge gaps between the hardcore and casual players so that both could enjoy the same challenges. Play past the level cap usually provides rewards in the form of tokens and specific in-game currencies that contribute to rarer and often visually superior cosmetic items for player avatars compared to the most easily acquired sets. The focus in these late-game areas is therefore usually aimed at effective teamwork and how the players approach a problem as opposed to the degree of statistics acquired by playtime.

AFK or inactive grinding

Eve Online features a system that does not require continuous play to increase character skill. Characters are plugged into their ship's computer and are trained at a rate based on their attributes. Attributes can be enhanced to decrease training time, but training occurs continuously whether the player is logged in or not. Some of the advanced skills can take as long as a month or more to reach the next level. Players generally have to grind for ISK (money), minerals, and NPC faction standing. However, the in-game alliance CODE. protests grinding, by attacking or 'ganking' anyone suspected of 'illegal' grinding.

Minecraft allows structures called mob grinders which automates the process of killing monsters. This is usually done by gathering them using flowing water and killing them with a large fall at the end of the water flow. When built, a mob grinder removes the need to fight or work for the mob drops as they become generated passively. The game also allows the players to create other AFK (away from keyboard) farms to aid in fishing, growing sugarcane and other crops, or even generating moss blocks. Utilising redstone and 'TNT duping', a player is able to create a "world eater", a machine that is capable of duplicating TNT in such a manner that a large space of land can be cleared out without player intervention.

Black Desert Online contains the literal definition of grinding in the most simplistic sense, as the methods of making money are through any of the several "life skills" such as cooking, or combat through killing monsters. A cooking session consists of cooking the same dish several hundred or even thousand times for several hours, over and over. This may be performed completely AFK at a lower efficiency and is popular among players who can only attend to their character periodically. It may also be performed more actively, with as little as 8 minutes before the cooking stove, or utensil as it is called in game, is depleted depending on the utensil, gear, and various consumable buffs used.

Grand Theft Auto Online features passive businesses that produce various types of cargo automatically that can be later sold for profit. The player is only required to resupply the businesses and do a sell mission once the production is finished. An exception is the "Nightclub" business that can produce goods without the need to resupply. While the game has a mechanic that kick out of the game players who stay AFK for more than 15 minutes, various methods bypass this. Later game additions add police raids after long AFK sessions.

Shorter time commitments

World of Warcraft features dungeons that can be played in segments, so that players can play the game in smaller chunks of time, allowing ones who can't afford to dedicate several hours of continuous playing time to complete them. The game also includes a "resting system" which increases the rate of experience gain for casual players, based on the amount of time spent out of the game. Similar systems exist in other games, including Lord of the Rings Online and City of Heroes.

Other

MapleStory features a party quest, called the Dojo PQ, that can be done with several players or solo. It is available to all players level 25 or above. It is a boss rush, in which the player or players revisit many bosses, one by one, all in a row. Beating every boss gets the player Dojo points, which, when accumulated in large numbers, can be used to get equipment for the player's character which boosts stats. Players can also get a title for 24 hours when they beat a certain boss 100 times.

Parody

The repetitiveness of grinding has given birth to early iterations of idle games, such as Ayumilove's HackerQuest V1 (2008), which parodies a bot grinding for items and avoiding GMs (Game Masters) in Maple Story, a famous MMORPG from Korea.

Criticism

Grinding is a controversial subject among video game players. Some consider grinding to be a result of poor game design, while others embrace it as an inherent feature in all video games.

Another criticism of the leveling concept and level playing field approach is that it often allows the player to avoid difficult strategic or reflexive challenges that one might encounter when fighting powerful opponents. By spending a large amount of time battling easily defeated characters (a practice known as bottom feeding), players can gain levels to have little difficulty vanquishing more difficult enemies.

To solve the grinding issue, E. McNeill proposes that "the most effective path to victory should also be the most fun". For example, challenging tasks should always give better rewards than easy tasks.

Another alternative to grinding is to remove designer-defined objectives, leaving players free to do whatever they want. This creates a new problem where many players might be confused about what they are supposed to do, or they might lack the motivation to do much of anything in the virtual world.

Players of subscription-based online games often criticize grinds as a heavy-handed attempt to gain profit. The most interesting and challenging gameplay is often only available to characters at the highest levels, who are those strong enough to participate in raids or player versus player combat. Grinding is seen as a reason to increase the amount of time it takes to reach these levels, forcing the player to pay more subscription fees along the way.

The IGDA Online Games Special Interest Group has noted that level treadmills are part of the addictive quality of role-playing games or MMORPGs that cater to those who play more than 25 hours a week.

See also

Notes

References

  1. "How "grinding" came to dominate video game culture". Inverse. 2020-01-22. Retrieved 2024-11-22.
  2. Lawley, Liz (2006-08-05). "In Praise of the Grind". Terra Nova. Archived from the original on 2009-02-06. Retrieved 2009-03-06. I want to relax, to clear my mind, to do something repetitive that provides visible (to me, not to you) and lasting evidence of my efforts
  3. "MinerBumping".
  4. Christian Stöcker (2006-08-25). "An Interview with the Maker of "World of Warcraft"". Spiegel Online. Archived from the original on 2011-07-16. Retrieved 2009-12-17.
  5. "MapleStory - A Free Massively Multiplayer Online Role-playing Game". Maplestory.nexon.net. Archived from the original on 2010-01-12. Retrieved 2010-05-28.
  6. Anthony Pecorella (February 2015). Idle Games: The Mechanics and Monetization of Self-Playing Games (Recorded presentation with slides.). Game Developer Conference (GDC) 2015.
  7. "Earliest idle games on Kongregate". Kongregate. Retrieved 2021-02-16.
  8. Mäyrä, Frans (2008). An Introduction to Game Studies. SAGE. p. 132. ISBN 978-1849205399.
  9. The Luddite (2014). "A Brief History of Leveling Systems". Archived from the original on 2014-12-07. Retrieved 2014-12-09.
  10. Grinding and the Burden of Optimal Play Archived 2014-07-22 at the Wayback Machine - E McNeill, Gamasutra, 21 July 2014
  11. Koster, Raph (2007-04-23). "The game without treadmills". Archived from the original on 2008-05-12. Retrieved 2007-09-05.
  12. Dunin, Elonka, ed. (March 2003). "IGDA Online Games White Paper, 2nd Edition" (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on 2004-09-20.
Multi-user dungeons (MUDs)
Major branches
Minor branches,
codebases, libraries
Concepts,
terminology
Publications
Companies,
organizations
List Category
Categories: