Revision as of 01:22, 22 March 2010 editTheSoundAndTheFury (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users3,994 edits →Critics and protests: Removing paragraph with numerous problems; explanation to follow.← Previous edit | Latest revision as of 23:53, 6 September 2024 edit undoGreenC bot (talk | contribs)Bots2,547,813 edits Rescued 1 archive link. Wayback Medic 2.5 per WP:URLREQ#weeklystandard.com | ||
(214 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|none}} | |||
{{Pp-protected|small=yes}} | |||
{{ |
{{Use dmy dates|date=May 2023}} | ||
] Gong adherents practice the fifth exercise, a meditation, in ]]] | |||
{{main|Falun Gong}} | |||
], also called Falun Dafa, is a spiritual practice and ] that combines the practice of meditation with the moral philosophy articulated by its leader and founder, ]. It emerged on the public radar in the Spring of 1992 in the northeastern Chinese city of ], and was classified as a system of ] identifying with the Buddhist tradition. Li claimed to have both supernatural powers like the ability to prevent illness, as well having eternal youth and promised that others can attain supernatural powers and eternal youth by following his teachings.<ref>{{Cite news |last=Yoffe |first=Emily |date=2001-08-10 |title=The Gong Show |language=en-US |work=Slate |url=https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2001/08/the-gong-show.html |access-date=2023-02-13 |issn=1091-2339}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date=2019-04-25 |title=Were human organs stolen in 20-year conflict between Beijing and Falun Gong? |url=https://www.rfi.fr/en/asia-pacific/20190418-were-human-organs-stolen-20-year-conflict-between-beijing-and-falun-gong |access-date=2023-02-13 |website=RFI |language=en}}</ref> Falun Gong initially enjoyed official sanction and support from Chinese government agencies, and the practice grew quickly on account of the simplicity of its exercise movements, impact on health, the absence of fees or formal membership, and moral and philosophical teachings.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
'''Falun Gong''' is a spiritual movement based on a '']'' method devised in 1992 by ], the movement's founder.<ref name="Lewis124-125">{{cite book|last=Lewis |first=James R.|title=Cults: a reference handbook|publisher=]|year=2005|pages=124–125|isbn=9781851096183|url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=aqmbnfXCzn0C&pg=PA124&lpg=PA124&dq=%22established+his+peculiar+brand+of+Qi+Gong+in+1992%22&source=bl&ots=9V1dfnaH8j&sig=aV5gqL8M_e_WE25CbpG2kKdqBZU&hl=en&ei=z9DYSurROcKz4QbarJz1Bg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CA0Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22established%20his%20peculiar%20brand%20of%20Qi%20Gong%20in%201992%22&f=false}}</ref> Its history can be roughly divided into three parts - questions surrounding its phenomenal growth in China, the Chinese government's crackdown and suppression of the movement, and the movement's response to the Chinese government from abroad. | |||
In the mid-1990s, however, Falun Gong became estranged from the state-run qigong associations, leading to a gradual escalation of tensions with ] (CCP) authorities that culminated in the Spring of 1999. Following a protest of 10,000 Falun Gong practitioners near the ] government compound on 25 April 1999 to request official recognition, then-] ] ordered Falun Gong be crushed. A campaign of propaganda, large-scale extrajudicial imprisonment, torture and coercive reeducation ensued. {{Citation needed|date=May 2024}} | |||
Falun Gong become immensely popular amongst the Chinese public in the mid 1980s due to its perceived health benefits and its philosophy which gives followers a sense of security in an increasingly uncertain world. However, the movement's teachings were questioned by skeptics and academics, and its sensitivity to outside criticism led to various protests around the country, culminating in a 10,000 person silent protest at Zhongnanhai on 25 April 1999, which was generally seen as the pivotal event leading to the movement's ban.<ref name=XIX>Julia Ching, "The Falun Gong: Religious and Political Implications," ''American Asian Review'', Vol. XIX, no. 4, Winter 2001, p. 12</ref> On 20 July 1999, the government of the People's Republic of China banned Falun Gong, and began a nationwide crackdown against the practice, except in the special administrative regions of Hong Kong and ],<ref>Faison, Seth (27 April 1999) ''New York Times''. Retrieved 10 June 2006.</ref><ref>Kahn, Joseph (27 April 1999) ''New York Times''. Retrieved 14 June 2006.</ref> and in late 1999, legislation was created to outlaw "heterodox religions" and retroactively applied.<ref name="Leung">Leung, Beatrice (2002) 'China and Falun Gong: Party and society relations in the modern era', Journal of Contemporary China, 11:33, 761 – 784</ref> | |||
Falun Gong practitioners have responded to the campaign with protests on ], the creation of their own media companies overseas, international lawsuits targeting Chinese officials, and the establishment of a network of underground publishing sites to produce literature on the practice within China. Falun Gong has emerged as a prominent voice for an end to one-party rule in China. | |||
Li Hongzhi has lived in New York City since 1996, and his scriptures since then have been delivered by Internet on Clearwisdom, the movement's website. After the ban, Falun Gong's activities have been largely conducted from abroad, with the group having a particularly strong presence on the Internet, in Canada, the United States, Australia, and several European countries. While some practitioners continue to protest, these have largely dwindled since five individuals set themselves on fire in Tiananmen Square on the eve of Chinese New Year 2001{{emdash}}together with the government's full media assault associating Falun Gong with the self-immolations, the event is regarded by most observers as pivotal to ending domestic support for the movement. Falun Gong leaders in exile and the government of the People's Republic of China have been engaged in a protracted, large-scale media war that is still on-going. While the Chinese government has attempted to paint Falun Gong as an "evil cult", Falun Gong and its associated media have responded with large amounts of political rhetoric against the ] and its former President Jiang Zemin. | |||
==Timeline of major events== | |||
== Beginnings == | |||
{{See also|Li Hongzhi}} | |||
], ], 1998]] | |||
Falun Gong was founded by Li Hongzhi (b. 1952 or 1951), a former trumpet player in a forest police unit in Jilin Province, and later a grain clerk at the Grain and Oil Procurement Company of ].<ref name="Ownby81">Ownby (2008) p. 81</ref><ref name="Chang3-4">{{cite book|last=Chang|first=Maria Hsia|title=Falun Gong – The End of Days|publisher=Yale University Press|year=2004|pages=3–4|isbn=9780300102277}}</ref> A hagiographical account of his life which appeared in early Falun Gong sources states that Li Hongzhi was taught the ways of spiritual cultivation by Quan Jue, a tenth-generation Buddhist master, from age four to twelve, and Baji Zhenren, a ] master, from age twelve onwards.<ref name="Ownby81-82">Ownby (2008) pp. 81–82; the biography itself, which follows the style of the hagiographies of other ''qigong'' masters and Chinese "holy men", is available online here: , Chinese Law and Government v. 32 no. 6 (Nov./Dec. 1999) p. 14-23 ISSN: 0009-4609</ref> The biography also stated that Li possessed various supernormal abilities from early childhood, such as changing location by the power of thought, and Li continues to claim that he possesses such powers, due to his existence at an exalted spiritual level.<ref name="Ownby115-116">{{cite book|last=Ownby|first=David|title=Falun Gong and the future of China|publisher=]|location=New York, NY|year=2008|pages=115–116|isbn=9780195329056}}</ref> Many facts in the official biography have been disputed by Chinese state sources, which assert that government research efforts, including interviews with Li's school teachers and childhood friends, showed his early years to have been entirely unremarkable.<ref name="Ownby83">{{cite book|last=Ownby|first=David|title=Falun Gong and the future of China|publisher=Oxford University Press|location=New York, NY|year=2008|page=83|isbn=9780195329056}}</ref> According to Palmer, Li's biography is very similar to that of other qigong masters, all of whom learned apprenticed from mystic/mysterious masters, acquired their Extraordinary powers, and 'came down from the mountain' when their ''shifu'' considered them ready.<ref>Palmer (2007), pg. 95</ref> | |||
===Before 1992=== | |||
Li Hongzhi established the Falun Gong method in 1992, after having studied with a number of ''qigong'' masters in the mid-1980s,<ref name="Lewis124-125" /><ref name="Ownby85">{{cite book|last=Ownby|first=David|title=Falun Gong and the future of China|publisher=Oxford University Press|location=New York, NY|year=2008|page=85|isbn=9780195329056}}</ref> Li popularised his method through mass speaking events with low fees that were open to all comers,<ref name="Porter79">{{cite book|last=Porter|first=Noah|title=Falun Gong in the United States: An Ethnographic Study|publisher=Universal-Publishers|year=2003|page=79|isbn=9781581121902}}, also available in </ref> and began to attract followers who viewed him as their spiritual master.<ref name="Chang4">{{cite book|last=Chang|first=Maria Hsia|title=Falun Gong – The End of Days|publisher=Yale University Press|year=2004|page=4|isbn=9780300102277}}</ref> According to Ownby (2008), neither Li nor Falun Gong were particularly controversial in the beginning.<ref name="Ownbyworld">David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sept 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p 306</ref> Although his followers' demographic were weighted to the middle-to-elderly in the agricultural and industrial heartlands,<ref name="zhao">{{cite book |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=tiFY59xGHBkC&pg=PA209&dq=Falun+Gong,+Identity,+and+the+Struggle+over+Meaning+Inside+and+Outside+China&client=firefox-a&cd=1#v=onepage&q=Falun%20Gong%2C%20Identity%2C%20and%20the%20Struggle%20over%20Meaning%20Inside%20and%20Outside%20China&f=false |last=Zhao |first=Yuezhi |title=Falun Gong, Identity, and the Struggle over Meaning Inside and Outside China |pages=209–223 in Contesting Media Power: Alternative Media in a Networked World, ed. Nick Couldry and James Curran |publisher=Rowman & Littlefield publishers, inc. |year=2003 }}</ref> his first generation of disciples included members of the local political elite. Four Party members, of which one was the local police chief and another a university professor, were named as vice-presidents of the Falun Dafa Research Society. Falun Gong was welcomed into the Scientific Qigong Research Association.<ref name="Ownbyworld"/> In the latter half or 1992, Li gave a series of workshops in Beijing sponsored by the CQRS attended by some 9,000 participants.<ref name=palmer.fever220>Palmer (2007), pp 220-2</ref> Li hired his own booth at Beijing Oriental Health Expos of both 1992 and 1993 where he would give workshops to thousands, and would heal sick people with his powerful Qi. Palmer wrote: "Under the effects of his qi, paraplegics cast aside their crutches and their wheelchairs: the public mobbed his stand."<ref name=palmer.fever220/> In total, Li gave 54 large-scale lectures throughout China in most major cities to an audience thought to be around 20,000.<ref name="Ownbyworld"/> In 1993, Li founded the Falun Xiulian Dafa Research Society to coordinate Falun Gong activities and translate his works into foreign languages.<ref name="Porter79" /> | |||
Falun Gong has been classified variously as a form of spiritual cultivation practice in the tradition of Chinese antiquity, as a ] discipline, or as a religion or new religious movement.<ref name=Penny2012>], '']'', (], 2012.</ref> Qigong refers to a broad set of exercises, meditation and breathing methods that have long been part of the spiritual practices of select Buddhist sects, of ] alchemists, martial artists, and some ] scholars.<ref name=Palmer/><ref>Kenneth S. Cohen, "The Way of Qigong: The Art and Science of Chinese Energy Healing" (Random House, Inc., 1999)</ref> | |||
Although qigong-like practices have a long history, the modern qigong movement traces its origins only to the late 1940s and 1950s. At that time, CCP ] began pursuing qigong as a means of improving health, and regarded it as a category of traditional ].<ref name=Palmer/> With official support from the party-state, qigong grew steadily in popularity, particularly in the period following the ]. The state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985 to administer and oversee qigong practice across the country. Thousands of qigong disciplines emerged, some of them headed by "grandmasters" with millions of adherents<ref name=Palmer>David Palmer. '']''. New York: ], 2007</ref><ref>Zhu Xiaoyang and ] (ed.), "The Qigong Boom," Chinese Sociology and Anthropology, Vol. 27, No. 1 (1994)</ref> | |||
== Growth in China == | |||
Against the backdrop of a crisis of confidence of the public in Qigong due to rampant 'quackery' and commercialisation, Li Hongzhi condemned the commercialisation and embraced a doctrine which Palmer (2007) describes as "moralistic, messianic and apocalyptic". In 1994, Li de-emphasised the physical benefits of Qigong in his teachings, and emphasised spiritual salvation. Li further distanced Falun Gong from Qigong and repositioned into a law of the universe unto itself complete with its own superior scripture, ''Zhuan Falun'', which was to become "the only path of salvation from the apocalyptic end ".<ref name=palmer.fever220/> | |||
From his youth, Li Hongzhi claims to have been tutored by a variety of Buddhist and Daoist masters, who, according to his spiritual biography, imparted to him the practice methods and moral philosophy that would come to be known as Falun Gong.<ref name=Penny2003/> | |||
Falun Gong was taught at the Chinese consulate in New York as part of the Party's "cultural propaganda to the West", alongside Chinese silk craft and cooking.<ref name=rn>Phillip Adams, , Late Night Live, Radio National Australia</ref> The consulate at that time also set up Falun Gong clubs at MIT and Columbia University which are active to this day. Starting in 1995, Li himself taught the practice outside of China, chairing a series of conferences at the Chinese embassy in Paris, upon invitation by China's ambassador to France.<ref name=rn/><ref name=Ownbyfuture>David Ownby, Falun Gong and the Future of China (2008) Oxford University Press</ref> | |||
*1951 or 1952 – Falun Gong asserts that ], founder of Falun Gong, was born on 13 May 1951 in Gongzhuling, ] Province.<ref name=Penny2003>], "," '']'', Vol. 175 (2003), pp. 643–661. Hosted by the ]. Cambridge University Databases. ].</ref> Official Chinese birth dates for Li have been given as 7 or 27 July 1952. | |||
] | |||
*1955 – According to his spiritual biography, Li begins learning under the tutelage of master Quan Je, a tenth-generation master of Buddhist cultivation who imparts to Li the principles of Zhen, Shan, Ren (truth, compassion, forbearance). The instruction lasts eight years.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1963 – According to his spiritual biography, Daoist master Baji Zhenren begins training Li in Daoist martial arts disciplines and physical skills training.<ref name=Penny2003/> | |||
*1970 – Li begins working at a military horse farm in northeast China, and in 1972 works as a trumpet player with a division of the provincial forestry police.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1972 – Li continues his spiritual training under the instruction of a master Zhen Daozhi, who imparts methods of ]. According to Li's spiritual biography, his training in this period mostly took place under cover of night, possibly due to the political environment of the ].<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1974 – Li's biography states that he begins studying the instruction of a female Buddhist master. Throughout the next several years, Li continued his studies and observations of spiritual cultivation systems.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*Early 1980s – Having had his middle and high school education interrupted by the Cultural Revolution, Li completes his high school education via correspondence courses.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1984 – According to his spiritual biography, to Li creates Falun Gong with his masters as a more accessible version of Falun Fofa, based on other qigong.<ref name=Penny2003/> | |||
*Mid-1980s – Li begins studying and observing a variety of other qigong disciplines, apparently in preparation for establishing and publicizing his own qigong system.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1985 – Chinese authorities create a national organization to oversee the great variety of qigong disciplines that were proliferating across the country. The China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985, and convened its first meeting in Beijing in 1986. The organization counted among its leadership several eminent members and former members of the Politburo and National People's Congress, as well as former ministers of health and education.<ref>Benjamin Penny, Qigong boom, pp. 13–20.</ref> | |||
*1989 – Li begins private instruction of Falun Gong to select students.<ref name=Penny2012/><ref name=zeng>Zeng, Jennifer. ''Witnessing history: one Chinese woman's fight for freedom'', Soho Press, 2006, pp. 329–335</ref> | |||
===1992–1995=== | |||
After teaching publicly in Changchun, Li began to make his lectures more widely accessible and affordable, charging less than competing ''qigong'' systems for lectures, tapes, and books.<ref name="Schechter66">Schechter (2001) p. 66</ref> On 4 January 1995, '']'', the main book on Falun Gong, was published and became a best-seller in China.<ref name="Schechter62">Schechter (2001) p. 62</ref> In the face of Falun Gong's rise in popularity, a large part of which was attributed to its low cost, competing ''qigong'' masters accused Li of unfair business practices. | |||
Falun Gong was publicly founded in the Spring of 1992, toward the end of China's "qigong boom," a period which saw the proliferation of thousands of disciplines. Li Hongzhi and his Falun Gong became an "instant star" of the qigong movement, and were welcomed into the government-administered China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS).<ref name="Ownbyworld">David Ownby, "," '']'', Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306</ref> From 1992 to 1994, Li traveled throughout China giving 54 lecture seminars on the practice and beliefs of Falun Gong.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> Seminars typically lasted 8–10 days, and attracted as many as 6,000 participants per class.<ref name=Schechter>Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China: Spiritual Practice of "Evil Cult"? (New York: Akashic Books, 2000), pp. 42.</ref> The practice grew rapidly based on its purported efficacy in improving health and its moral and philosophical elements, which were more developed than those of other qigong schools.<ref>Scott Lowe, Chinese and InternationalContexts for the Rise of Falun Gong. Nova Religio 6 (2 April 2003)</ref> | |||
Commentators agree that Falun Gong's spread and popularity was reflective of the wider social transformation taking place in China in the early 1990s and growing sense of insecurity of the population. As Deng Xiaoping urged the pursuit of material wealth, the security for life model based around the work-unit was coming under threat; corruption was on the rise.<ref name="zhao" /><ref name=lamendgame/><ref name=Lowe/><ref name=Palmer220>Palmer (2007), p 220</ref> Lowe (2003) acknowledges sociological "macro-issues," such as economic insecurity, free time, the collapse of moral standards, worries about health and medical care, the desire for existential certitude, and other factors as explanations for Falun Gong's rise.<ref name=Lowe/> Zhao points to a comparative lack of spiritual fulfilment, and "a worldwide backlash against capitalist modernity".<ref name="zhao" /> Palmer (2007) attributes it in part to a desire for security in an uncertain world.<ref name=Palmer220/> This contrasted with Falun Gong's insistence on the "search for meaning" and its calls for a "radical transcendence of materialism in both the mundane and philosophical senses."<ref name="zhao" /> | |||
*1992 – On 13 May, Li begins public teaching of Falun Gong at the No. 5 Middle School in Changchun, Jilin Province, lecturing to a crowd of several hundred.<ref name=Porter>Noah Porter, "Falun Gong in the United States: An Ethnographic Study," 2003, p. 70</ref> The seminar ran for nine days at a cost of 30 Yuan per person.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
These were merely secondary considerations to the growth of Falun Gong. According to Lowe, other ''qigong'' practices were unable to provide "clear, unambiguous explanations of life’s deepest mysteries" and such a "complete and intellectually satisfying picture of the universe," as practitioners see it.<ref name=Lowe/> | |||
*1992 – June, Li is invited by the China Qigong Scientific Research Society to lecture in ]. | |||
*1992 – In September, Falun Gong is recognized as a qigong branch under the administration of the state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS).<ref name="Ownby (2003)">David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306.</ref> | |||
*1992 – Li is formally declared a "Master of Qigong" by the CQRS, and received a permit to teach nationwide.<ref name=faluninfotime>Falun Dafa Information Center, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20170502142634/http://faluninfo.net/topic/22/ |date=2 May 2017 }} accessed 24 November 2010</ref> | |||
*1992 – Li and several Falun Gong students participate in the 1992 Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 12 to 21 December. The organizer of the health fair remarked that Falun Gong and Li "received the most praise at the fair, and achieved very good therapeutic results."<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> The event helped cement Li's popularity in the qigong world, and journalistic reports of Falun Gong's healing powers spread.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1992 – By the end of the year, Li had given five week-long lecture seminars in Beijing, four in Changchun, one in Tayuan, and one in Shandong.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1993 – China Falun Gong (中国法轮功), the first major instructional text by Li Hongzhi, is published by Military Yiwen Press in April. The book sets forth an explanation of Falun Gong's basic cosmology, moral system, and exercises. A revised edition is released in December of the same year.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=zeng /> | |||
*1993 – In the spring and summer of 1993, a series of glowing article appear in Qigong magazines nationwide lauding the benefits of Falun Gong. Several feature images of Li Hongzhi on the cover, and asserting the superiority of the Falun Gong system.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1993 – The Falun Xiulian Dafa Research Society is established as a branch of the CQRS on 30 July.<ref>James Tong (2002), p. 670.</ref> | |||
*1993 – In August, an organization under ] sends a letter to the CQRS thanking Li Hongzhi for providing his teachings to police officers injured in the line of duty. The letter claimed that of the 100 officers treated by Li, only one failed to experience "obvious improvement" to their health.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1993 – On Sept 21, The People's Public Security Daily, a publication of the Ministry of Public Security, commends Falun Gong for "promoting the traditional crime-fighting virtues of the Chinese people, in safeguarding social order and security, and in promoting rectitude in society."<ref name=faluninfotime /> | |||
*1993 – Li again participates in the Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 11 to 20 Dec, this time as a member of the organizing committee. He wins several awards at the event,<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> and is proclaimed the "Most Acclaimed Qigong Master." Falun Gong also received the "Special Gold Award" and award for "Advancing Frontier Science."<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1994 – The Jilin Province Qigong Science Research Association proclaims Li Hongzhi a "Grandmaster of Qigong" on 6 May.<ref name=zeng /> | |||
*1994 – Li gives two lectures on Falun Gong at the ] in Beijing, and contributes profits from the seminars to a foundation for injured police officers.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1994 – On 3 August, the City of Houston, Texas, declares Li Hongzhi an honorary citizen for his "unselfish public service for the benefit and welfare of mankind."<ref name=faluninfotime /> | |||
*1994 – As revenues from the sale of his publications grew, Li ceased to charge fees for his classes, and thereafter insists that Falun Gong must be taught free of charge.<ref name=Ownbyfuture /> | |||
*1994 – The last full seminar on Falun Gong practice and philosophy takes place from 21 to 29 December in the southern city of Guangzhou.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1995 – ''Zhuan Falun'' (转法轮), the complete teachings of Falun Gong, is published in January by the China Television Broadcasting Agency Publishing Company. A publication ceremony is held in the Ministry of Public Security auditorium on 4 January.<ref name=Ownbyfuture>David Ownby, '']'' (2008) ], p. 89.</ref> | |||
*1995 – In February, Li is approached by the Chinese National Sports Committee, Ministry of Public Health, and China Qigong Science Research Association to jointly establish a Falun Gong association. Li declines the offer.<ref name=Palmer /> | |||
*1995 – Official attitudes towards the Qigong movement within some segments of the government begin to change, as criticisms of qigong begin appearing in the state-run press.<ref name=Palmer/> | |||
*1995 – Li leaves China and begins spreading his practice overseas.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> | |||
*1995 – At the invitation of the Chinese embassy in Paris, Li begins teaching Falun Gong abroad. On 13 March, he gives a seven-day class in Paris, followed by another lecture series in Sweden in April (Gothenburg, Stockholm and Uddevalla).<ref name=Ownbyfuture /><ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
===1996–June 1999=== | |||
By 1995, Falun Gong had established a clear competitive advantage over alternative ''qigong'' groups with its emphasis on morality and life philosophies, low cost, and its benefits to practitioners' health, rapidly spreading via word-of-mouth.<ref name=Lowe>{{cite journal |first=Scott |last=Lowe |title=Chinese and International Contexts for the Rise of Falun Gong |journal=Nova Religio |date= April 2003 |vol:Vol. 6, No. 2}}</ref> In a reversal from the 1989 outpouring of desire for political participation, many Chinese turned to Falun Gong precisely because they saw it as an apolitical response to existing individual and social concerns.<ref name=zhao/> Its rapid growth within China was also related to family ties and community relationships, which still retain great power in contemporary China.<ref name=Lowe/> Falun Gong attracted a wide range of adherents from all walks of life.<ref name=lum>Thomas Lum, , Congressional Research Service, 11 August 2006</ref> | |||
Having announced that he was finished teaching his practice in China, Li Hongzhi begins teaching his practice in Europe, Oceania, North America and Southeast Asia. In 1998, Li relocates permanently to the United States.<ref name=Ownbyfuture /> | |||
As the practice continues to grow within China, tensions emerge between Falun Gong and Chinese authorities. In 1996, Falun Gong withdraws from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society, and thereafter finds itself the subject of growing scrutiny and criticism in the state-run press.<ref name=Palmer/><ref name=Porter/> The practice becomes a subject of high-level debates within the government and CCP, with some ministries and government authorities expressing continued support for the practice, and others becoming increasingly wary of the group.<ref name=Palmer/><ref name=Tong/> This tension also played out in the media, as some outlets continued to laud the effects of Falun Gong, while others criticized it as pseudoscience.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
'']'' asserts that much of Falun Gong's success in the 1990s was due to claims that it could heal without costly medicine, as many citizens had lost medical benefits and services due to changing economic conditions.<ref>, The Economist, 1 Feb 2007</ref> Some{{Who|date=October 2009}} in China maintained that Falun Gong was the most popular ''qigong'' practice in the country, and that many professors from Peking University practiced the exercises every day on the campus grounds until the crackdown in 1999.<ref name=XIX/><!-- Commented out because this matter is treated in the intro: The exact number of Falun Gong practitioners is not known. Falun Gong consistently states that there are no practitioner registers or membership. According to a ''New York Times'' article published in 1999, the PRC government estimated there were 70 million practitioners.<ref>{{cite news |last=Faison |first=Seth |date=27 April 1999 |url=http://partners.nytimes.com/library/world/asia/042799china-protest.html |title=In Beijing: A Roar of Silent Protesters |work=The New York Times |accessdate= 10 June 2006}}</ref><ref>Kahn, Joseph (27 April 1999) ''New York Times''. Retrieved 14 June 2006.</ref> --> | |||
Tensions continue to escalate over this period, culminating in a demonstration on 25 April 1999 near the ] government compound, where over ten thousand Falun Gong practitioners gather to request official recognition. Following the event, ], then-CCP general secretary, quietly prepares for the launch of a nationwide campaign to persecute the practice. | |||
=== Official registration issues === | |||
Østergaard states that the FDRS was expelled from the China Qigong Research Association, the umbrella ''qigong'' association to which Li and other masters belonged, in November 1996 because Li was "posing as a god, spreading feudalistic superstition, and fabricating political rumours."<ref name="Jude Howell215">Jude Howell (2003) pages=215</ref> However, according to Schechter, Li had refused a request of the CQRS to hike his fees.<ref name="Schechter66"/> Palmer also stated that Li had disagreements with the CQRS, and that Li objected to the new policy of the CQRS to formalise the structure of FDRS through which to pass on Falun Gong revenues; he also objected to the requirement to start up a party branch.<ref name=palmer247>Palmer (2007), p. 247.</ref> Palmer notes that the qigong movement had by that time become a profiteering industry which was beginning to acquire a bad name in the eyes of the public, and advances the hypothesis that Li may have withdrawn FDRS membership to distance his movement from the CQRS; Li officially maintained that he was no longer interested in teaching Falun Gong.<ref name=palmer247/> In a possible attempt to maintain legitimacy without affiliation to the CQRS whilst preserving control of its own revenue streams,<ref name=palmer248>Palmer (2007), pp. 248-9.</ref> the movement attempted to register the Falungong Cultivators' Research Society, a new 'association of practitioners' (without the master, through whom flowed the revenues).<ref name=palmer248/> However, after it was rejected in turn by the CQRS, the Ministry of Civil Affairs, the Minority Nationalities' Affairs Commission of the ], the China Buddhist Association, the United Front Department of the CCP Central Committee. In 1997, Falun Gong informed the Civil Administration and Public Security ministries that it had not succeeded in applying for recognition.<ref name=palmer248/> Palmer notes from Falun Gong documents that, contrary to contention of Porter (2003) that the FDRS had disbanded after 1997, practice notices continued to be issued in its name until July 1999.<ref name=palmer248/> | |||
*1996 – The book Zhuan Falun is listed as a bestseller by Beijing Youth Daily (北京青年报) in January, March, and April.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=faluninfotime /> | |||
== Critics and protests == | |||
*1996 – Falun Gong files for withdrawal from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society in March. Li later explains that he had found the state-run CQRS to be more concerned with profiting from qigong than engaging in genuine research.<ref name=Porter/> Li had also apparently rejected a new CQRS policy that mandated that all qigong practices create CCP branches within their organizations.<ref name=Palmer/><ref name=Tong/> Falun Gong is left entirely without government oversight or sanction.<ref>Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China, p. 66.</ref> | |||
Following Li's prohibition of commercialising Falun Gong in 1994, a faction in Changchun which wanted to open a clinic where they would presumably hold their own fee-charging workshops were rebuffed by Li, and its members were expelled from the movement.<ref name=palmer246>Palmer (2007), p. 246.</ref> This group would send a three-volume report to several government ministries in late 1994, denouncing Li and Falun Gong and saying that Li had no superpowers and was unable to cure people — including the first time allegation that Li had altered his birthdate to that of ] — the contents were to be found subsequently reused when the government's own anti-Falun Gong campaign was launched. Falun Gong replied to the various recipients in detail on 2 February 1995.<ref name=palmer246/> | |||
*1996 – At Li's direction, administrators of the Falun Gong Research Association of China apply for registration with three other government organizations, including the ] and ]. All applications are ultimately denied.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 248</ref> | |||
*1996 – The first major state-run media article criticizing Falun Gong appears in the '']'' newspaper on 17 June. The article writes that Falun Gong represents a manifestation of feudal superstition, and that its core text Zhuan Falun is a work of "pseudo-science" that swindles the masses.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 249</ref> Falun Gong practitioners responded to the article's publication with a letter-writing campaign to the newspaper and national qigong association.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1996 – Several Buddhist journals and magazines start to write articles criticizing Falun Gong as a "heretical sect".<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 262</ref> | |||
*1996 – On 24 July, Falun Gong books are banned from further publication by the China News Publishing Bureau, a branch of the CCP ]. The reason cited for the ban is that Falun Gong is "spreading superstition." Pirated and copied versions of Falun Gong books proliferate, with Li Hongzhi's approval.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 180</ref> | |||
*1996 – Li begins another international lecture tour in the summer of 1996, traveling to Hong Kong, Sydney, Bangkok, Houston, New York, and Beijing.<ref name=Ownbyfuture /> | |||
*1996 – The China Qigong Scientific Research Society issues a resolution on the cancellation of Falun Gong's membership with the society. The resolution stated that although practitioners of Falun Gong had "attained unparalleled results in terms of fitness and disease prevention," Li Hongzhi "propagated theology and superstition," failed to attend association meetings, and departed from the association's procedures.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1997 – The Ministry of Public Security launches an investigation into whether Falun Gong should be deemed xie jiao ("heretical religion"). The report concludes that "no evidence has appeared thus far."<ref name="Palmer 2007, p. 265">Palmer 2007, p. 265</ref> | |||
*1997–1999 – Criticism of Falun Gong escalates in state-run media. With the encouragement of Li, Falun Gong practitioners respond to criticisms by peacefully petitioning outside media offices seeking redress against perceived unfair reporting. The tactic succeeds frequently, often resulting in the retraction of critical articles and apologies from the news organizations.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/> Not all media coverage was negative in this period, however, and articles continued to appear highlighting Falun Gong's health benefits.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1998 - On 13 January, the China Buddhist Association held a meeting on how to react to Falun Gong.<ref name=Palmer/> | |||
*1998 – On 21 July, the Ministry of Public Security issues Document No. 555, "Notice of the Investigation of Falun Gong." The document asserts that Falun Gong is an "evil religion," and mandates that another investigation be launched to seek evidence of the conclusion. The faction hostile toward Falun Gong within the ministry was reportedly led by ].<ref name=Palmer/> Security agencies began monitoring and collecting personal information on practitioners;<ref name=Tong/> Falun Gong sources reported authorities were tapping phone lines, harassing and tailing practitioners, ransacking homes, and closing down Falun Gong meditation sessions.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1998 – According to Falun Gong sources, ], the former Chairman of the ], lead his own investigation into Falun Gong and concluded that "Falun Gong has hundreds of benefits for the Chinese people and China, and does not have one single bad effect."<ref name=Penny2012/><ref name="Palmer 2007, p. 265"/> | |||
*1998 – China's National Sports Commission launches its own investigation in May, and commissions medical professionals to conduct interviews of over 12,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Guangdong province. 97.9 percent of respondents say Falun Gong improved their health.<ref name="Palmer"/> By October the investigation concludes, noting "We're convinced the exercises and effects of Falun Gong are excellent. It has done an extraordinary amount to improve society's stability and ethics. This should be duly affirmed."<ref name=faluninfotime /> | |||
*1998 – Estimates provided by the State Sports Commission suggest there are upwards of 60 to 70 million Falun Gong practitioners in China.<ref>Seth Faison, "," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Joseph Kahn, "," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Renee Schoff, "Growing group poses a dilemma for China," Associated Press, 26 April 1999.</ref> | |||
*1999 – Li Hongzhi continues to teach Falun Gong internationally, with occasional stops in China. By early 1999, Li had lectured in Sydney, Bangkok, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Hong Kong, Taipei, Frankfurt, Toronto, Singapore, Geneva, Houston and New York, as well as in Changchun and Beijing.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1999 – Wu Shaozu, An official from China's National Sports Commission, says in an interview with U.S. News & World Report on 14 February that as many as 100 million may have taken up Falun Gong and other forms of qigong. Wu notes that the popularity of Falun Gong dramatically reduces health care costs, and "Premier Zhu Rongji is very happy about that."<ref>"An opiate of the masses?," U.S. News & World Report, 22 February 1999.</ref><ref name=rn>Phillip Adams, , Late Night Live, Radio National Australia</ref> | |||
*1999 – In April, physicist He Zuoxiu from the Chinese Academy of Sciences publishes an article in Tianjin Normal University's Youth Reader magazine criticizing Falun Gong as superstitious and potentially harmful for youth and stating that he knew someone who died because of it.<ref>Palmer 2007, p. 266</ref> At that time, some countries near China had people practicing, like Vietnam.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://moitruongphapluancongvn.org|title=Trang chủ {{!}} Việt Nam {{!}} Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công|website=Trang chủ {{!}} Việt Nam {{!}} Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công|language=en|access-date=2018-08-30}}</ref> | |||
*1999 – Tianjin Falun Gong practitioners respond to the article by peacefully petitioning in front of the editorial offices. Editors initially agree to publish a retraction of the He Zuoxiu article, then renege.<ref>Palmer 2007, pp. 266-267</ref> | |||
*1999 – On 23 April, some 300 security forces are called in to break up ongoing Falun Gong demonstration. Forty-five Falun Gong practitioners are beaten and detained.<ref name=gutmannfuyou>Ethan Gutmann, An Occurrence on Fuyou Street, ''National Review'' 13 July 2009</ref><ref name="Schechter 2000, p.69">Schechter (2000), p.69</ref> | |||
*1999 – Falun Gong practitioners petition Tianjin City Hall for the release of the detained practitioners. They are reportedly told that the order to break up the crowd and detain protesters came from central authorities in Beijing, and that further appeals should be directed at Beijing.<ref name=gutmannfuyou /><ref name="Schechter 2000, p.69"/> | |||
] government compound in April 1999 to request official recognition.]] | |||
While ''Zhuan Falun II'' was enjoying a week as the tenth best-seller on the ''Beijing Daily'' book list, it received a scathing review in the 17 June 1996 edition of '']'' which attacked it as a "pseudo-scientific book propagating feudal superstitions".<ref name=palmer.fever249>Palmer (2007), pg249</ref><ref name=own168>Ownby (2008), p. 168</ref> Twenty major journals then wrote articles critical of Falun Gong. Responding to the ''Guangming'' article's concern that the title was being published legally, the ] issued a directive banning its official publication on 24 July 1996.<ref name=palmer.fever249/><ref name=own168/> Thousands of practitioners wrote in to the paper and to the China Qigong Research Society at the instigation of Li Hongzhi to protest at the violation of the ] policy.<ref name=palmer.fever249/> ''Guangming'' stood firm; the state machine did nothing. With the qigong movement in trouble, the CQRS did not come to Falun Gong's defence.<ref name=own168/> On 28 August, in an internet post, Li further admonished followers who practised at home without doing anything to defend Falun Gong;<ref name=palmer.fever249/><ref name=own168/> he referred to the incident as a test of moral stature for practitioners.<ref name=own168/> | |||
*1999 – On 25 April 10,000–20,000 Falun Gong practitioners quietly assemble outside the Central Appeals Office, adjacent to the Zhongnanhai leadership compound in Beijing. Five Falun Gong representatives meet with Premier ] to request official recognition and an end to escalating harassment against the group. Zhu agrees to release the Tianjin practitioners, and assures the representatives that the government does not oppose Falun Gong. The same day, however, at the urging of Luo Gan, CCP general secretary Jiang Zemin issues a letter stating his intention to suppress the practice.<ref>Tong (2009), pp. 3–10</ref> | |||
In 1996, Buddhist journals were issuing in-depth critiques of Falun Gong.<ref name="Penny2005">Penny, Benjamin, “The Falun Gong, Buddhism and ‘Buddhist qigong’”, ''Asian Studies Review'' March 2005, Vol 29, pp.35-46.</ref> Palmer observed that the Buddhists were the earliest to employ the term "邪教" (heretical sect) to describe the movement.<ref name=palmer.fever262>Palmer (2007), pg262-3</ref> In January 1998, the Buddhist Association convened a meeting to discuss how to deal with the slow growth of Buddhism compared to Falun Gong; the association magazine, ''Fayin'', weighed in by March to denounce Falun Gong as a heretical popular religion, saying that its doctrines were opposed to Buddhism, and that Falun Gong denigrated the Buddhist clergy. The article also compared Falun Gong to sects like ]. In response, Falun Gong practitioners wrote to ] Chairman ] in protest, arguing that the attacks by the Buddhists were threatening social stability. The standoff between the two groups resulted in at least one documented conflict — a Chonqing monastery called on the police remove a Falun Gong demonstration outside its front gates in March 1999.<ref name=palmer.fever249/> | |||
*1999 – On 26 April, Jiang Zemin convenes a meeting of the Politburo Standing Committee to discuss the Falun Gong demonstration. Some Politburo members reportedly favored a conciliatory position towards Falun Gong, while others – such as Jiang and security czar Luo Gan – favored a decisive suppression of the group.<ref name=Zong>Zong Hairen, Zhu Rongji in 1999, (Ming Jing, 2001), pp. 60–61.</ref> | |||
*1999 – Authorities increased surveillance on Falun Gong, tapping telephones of practitioners and monitoring practitioners in several cities.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1999 – On 2 May, Li Hongzhi gives a press conference to journalists in Sydney, Australia. When asked by a reporter whether he believed the government would kill or imprison his disciples to maintain social order, Li responded that " practitioners will never go against the law. In terms of the scenario you describe, I don't think it will happen. since the economic reform and opening up, the Chinese government has been quite tolerant in this respect."<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1999 – In May and June, just as preparations are quietly underway for a crackdown, Falun Gong practitioners continue their public meditation sessions.<ref name=Penny2012/> The Far Eastern Economic Review wrote "in a park in western Beijing, 100 or so Falun Gong practitioners exercised under a bold yellow banner proclaiming their affiliation... far from running scared."<ref>Susan V. Lawrence, "Religion: Pilgrim's Protest," Far Eastern Economic Review, 13 May 1999.</ref> | |||
*1999 – On 2 June, Li purchases space in several Hong Kong newspapers to publish an article defending Falun Gong, and urging Chinese leaders not to "risk universal condemnation" and "waste manpower and capital" by antagonizing the group.<ref name=Penny2012/><ref>Li Hongzhi, , 2 June 1999.</ref> | |||
*1999 – On 3 June, 70,000 practitioners from Jilin and ] travel to Beijing in an attempt to appeal to authorities. They were intercepted by security forces, sent home, and placed under surveillance.<ref name=Penny2012/><ref>Sing Tao Jih Pao, "Police Break Up Falun Gong Gathering of 70,000 in Beijing," 7 June 1999.</ref> | |||
*1999 – On 7 June 1999, Jiang Zemin convened a meeting of the ] to address the Falun Gong issue. In the meeting, Jiang described Falun Gong as a grave threat to CCP authority – "something unprecedented in the country since its founding 50 years ago"<ref name=Jamestown>Sarah Cook and Leeshai Lemish, , China Brief, Volume 11 Issue 17 (9 November 2011).</ref> – and ordered the creation of a special leading group within the party's ] to "get fully prepared for the work of disintegrating ."<ref name=Jamestown/> | |||
*1999 – On 10 June, the ] was formed to handle day-to-day coordination of the anti-Falun Gong campaign. Luo Gan was selected to helm of the office, whose mission at the time was described as studying, investigating, and developing a "unified approach...to resolve the Falun Gong problem"<ref name=Tong>James Tong, '']'', ] (2009).</ref> The office was not created with any legislation, and there are no provisions describing its precise mandate.<ref name=Jamestown/> | |||
*1999 – On 17 June 1999, On 17 June, Jiang Zemin declared in a Politburo meeting that Falun Gong is "the most serious political incident since the '4 June' political disturbance in 1989."<ref name=Zong/> The 610 Office came under the newly created Central Leading Group for Dealing with Falun Gong, headed by ]. Both Li and Luo were members of the ], and the four other deputy directors of the Central Leading Group also held high-level positions in the CCP, including minister of the propaganda department.<ref name=Tong/> | |||
*1999 – On 26 June, thirteen Falun Gong exercise sites in public parks are shut down by Beijing security officials.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
=== |
===July 1999–2001 === | ||
] following the ban]] | |||
On 11 May 1998, He Zuoxiu, a physicist from the ] and opponent of supernatural and "unscientific thinking", denounced Falun Gong in an interview on ].<ref name=SP1>, Zhonghu Yan, Center for the Study of Religion, University of Toronto, 13 December 2001</ref> Falun Gong practitioners inundated the station with letters of protest; some 2,000 of them demonstrated peacefully in front of its offices.<ref name=blind>Ian Johnson, , Page A1, The Wall Street Journal, 13 December 2000</ref> They besieged the station for a month.<ref name="Jude Howell215"/> Under pressure from the Central Government to end the protest at the station "at any cost",<ref name=blind/> the Beijing Television reporter responsible for the interview was dismissed and a report favourable towards Falun Gong was telecast a few days later.<ref>{{cite web |first=Craig S. |last=Smith |title=Revered by Millions, a Potent Mystic Rattles China's Communist Leaders |page=1 |work=Wall Street Journal |date=26 April 1999 |url=http://www.tibet.ca/en/newsroom/wtn/archive/old?y=1999&m=5&p=5_3 }}c/o third party link</ref> | |||
In July 1999, a nationwide campaign is rolled out to "eradicate" Falun Gong. The persecution campaign is characterized by a "massive propaganda campaign" against the group, public burnings of Falun Gong books, and imprisonment of tens of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners in prisons, reeducation through labor camps, psychiatric hospitals and other detention facilities. Authorities are given the broad mandate of 'transforming' practitioners, resulting in the widespread use of torture against Falun Gong practitioners, sometimes resulting in death. | |||
In April 1999, He Zuoxiu published an article in the ]’s ''Youth Reader'' magazine, entitled "I Do Not Agree with Youth Practicing ''qigong''," and criticized all forms of "fake qigong". Describing some of the symptoms of 'Qigong deviation', He cited one of his students who refused to "eat, drink, sleep, or speak", and who was eventually sent to a mental institution as the result of practising Falun Gong, and alluded to the student's reverence for founder Li Hongzhi.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.faluninfo.net/article/518/ |title=The Truth Behind the 25 April Incident (Abridged version) |publisher=Faluninfo.net |date= |accessdate=2009-12-18}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.cnfxj.org/Html/lgxd/2007-6/24/165513641.html#|title=I do not agree with Youth Practicing ''Qigong'' (我不赞成青少年炼气功)|author=]|language=Chinese|date=1999-04}}</ref> | |||
From late 1999 to early 2001, hundreds of Falun Gong practitioners per day travel to Tiananmen Square to stage peaceful protests against the persecution. The protests take the form of performing Falun Gong exercises or meditation, or holding banner proclaiming Falun Gong's innocence. The protests are broken up, often violently, by security forces. | |||
Drawing on the effectiveness of earlier protests in censoring criticism of Falun Gong, some 6,000 practitioners gathered in Tianjin, in front of the municipal office and the magazine editorial office, to protest the article, demanding an apology.<ref name=own171>Ownby (2008), p. 171</ref> Falun Gong organisers sent an appeal to the Tianjin Municipal party headquarters and government, reiterating claims that Falun Gong was a "harmless Qigong group" that benefits the nation. The Tianjin government, however, did not respond favourably. The local police were called, and a number of practitioners were arrested.<ref name="Schechter">p. 66</ref> | |||
*1999 – During a 19 July meeting of senior CCP cadres, Jiang Zemin's decision to eradicate Falun Gong was announced. The campaign was originally intended to have begun on 21 July, but as the document was apparently leaked, the crackdown started on 20 July.<ref name=Penny2012/> A nationwide propaganda campaign is launched to discredit Falun Gong.<ref>Tong 2009, p. 44</ref> | |||
=== Zhongnanhai incident === | |||
*1999 – Just after midnight on 20 July, Falun Gong practitioners and "assistants" are abducted and detained across numerous cities in China.<ref name=dangerous>{{cite book |first=Mickey |last=Spiegel |url=http://hrw.org/reports/2002/china/ |title=Dangerous Meditation: China's Campaign Against Falungong |publisher=Human Rights Watch |year=2002 |isbn=1-56432-270-X|access-date=28 September 2007}}</ref> In response, tens of thousands of practitioners petition local, provincial and central appeals offices.<ref name=Penny2012/> In Beijing and other cities, protesters are detained in sports stadiums.<ref name=dangerous/> | |||
As the incident in Tianjin did not give rise to a satisfactory outcome for Falun Gong, it led to a much larger protest on 25 April. Around ten thousand practitioners lined the streets near ], the residence compound of the Communist Party's central leadership,<ref name=Amnesty1>, The Amnesty International</ref> where they stayed in silence for 12 hours. | |||
*1999 – On 22 July, The Ministry of Civil Affairs declared the "Research Society of Falun Dafa and the Falun Gong organization under its control" to be unregistered, and therefore illegal, organizations.<ref name=Tong/> The same day, the Ministry of Public Security issues a notice prohibiting 1) the display of Falun Gong images or symbols; 2) the public distribution of Falun Gong books or literature; 3) assembling to perform group Falun Gong exercises; 4)using sit-ins, petitions, and other demonstrations in defense of Falun Gong; 5) the spreading of rumors meant to disturb social order; and 6) taking part in activities opposing the government's decision.<ref name=Penny2012/> | |||
*1999 – The 19 July circular is released publicly on 23 July.<ref name=Tong/> In it, Falun Gong is declared the "most serious political incident" since 1989. The ] forbids party members from practicing Falun Gong, and launches study sessions to ensure cadres understand that Falun Gong is incompatible with the belief system of ].<ref name=dangerous/> | |||
*1999 – on 26 July, the authorities begin the process of confiscating and destroying all publications related to Falun Gong, including "books, pictures, audio-video products, and electronic publications."<ref name=dangerous/> Within one week, two million copies of Falun Gong literature are confiscated and destroyed by steam-rollers and public ].<ref name=Schechter/><ref name=dangerous/> | |||
*1999 – In late July, overseas Falun Gong websites are hacked or subject to ].<ref name=dangerous/> According to Chinese internet expert Ethan Gutmann, the attacks originated from servers in Beijing and Shenzhen, and was among the first serious attempts at network disruption by China.<ref name=HackerNation>Ethan Gutmann, {{usurped|}}, World Affairs Journal, May/June 2010.</ref> | |||
*1999 – 29 July, Chinese authorities ask ] to seek the arrest of Li Hongzhi. Interpol declines. The following week, Chinese authorities offer a substantial cash reward for the extradition of Li from the United States. The U.S. government similarly declines to follow up.<ref name=dangerous/> | |||
*1999 – On 29 July, the Beijing Bureau of Justice issues a notice requiring all lawyers and law firms to obtain approval before providing consultation or representation to Falun Gong practitioners. According to Human Rights Watch, the notice was "inconsistent with international standards which call on governments to ensure that lawyers are able to perform their professional functions without intimidating hindrance, harassment, or improper interference."<ref name=dangerous/> | |||
*1999 – In October, 30 Falun Gong practitioners hold a secret press conference for foreign media in Beijing to tell of the violence and persecution they are suffering. At the end of the press briefing, participants are arrested, and some of the foreign reporters present are questioned and briefly detained. Ten of the organizers were detained almost immediately afterwards, and one of them, a 31-year-old hairdresser names Ding Yan, is later tortured to death in custody, according to Falun Gong sources.<ref>Falun Gong Human Rights Working Group, , accessed 04-05-2012</ref> During the press conference, some of the first allegations of Falun Gong torture deaths in custody are made.<ref>Erik Eckholm, "China Sect Members Covertly Meet Press and Ask World's Help," New York Times, 29 October 1999</ref> | |||
*1999 – On 30 October, the ] issues a resolution on article 300 of the criminal code. The resolution elaborates on the identification and punishments for individuals who use "heretical religions" to undermine the implementation of the law.<ref name=AI>Amnesty International, "China: The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called 'heretical organizations,'" 23 March 2000</ref> | |||
*1999 – On 5 November 1999, the ] issues a circular giving instruction to the people's courts that Falun Gong should be prosecuted as a 'heretical religion' under article 300.<ref name=dangerous/><ref name=AI/> The notice, sent to all local courts in China, stressed that it was their ''political duty'' to ''severely'' punish Falun Gong, and to handle these cases ''under the leadership of the Party committees.''<ref name=AI/> | |||
*1999 – On 27 December, four high-profile Falun Gong practitioners are put on trial for "undermining the implementation of the law" and illegally obtaining state secrets. They include Beijing engineer and prominent Falun Gong organizer Zhiwen Wang, sentenced to 16 years in prison, and Li Chang, an official of the Ministry of Public Security, sentenced to 18 years.<ref name=AI/> According to ], in these prosecutions and others, "the judicial process was biased against the defendants at the outset and the trials were a mere formality."<ref name=AI/> | |||
*2000 – During Lunar New Year celebrations in early February, at least 2,000 Falun Gong practitioners are detained on Tiananmen Square while attempting to peacefully protest the ban against the group. | |||
*2000 – On 20 April, '']'' reporter ] publishes the first article in a series on Falun Gong. The article details the torture death of 58-year-old grandmother in ] city, who was beaten, shocked, and forced to run barefoot through the snow because she refused to denounce Falun Gong. Johnson went on to win the 2001 ] for the series.<ref>Ian Johnson, , Wall Street Journal, 20 April 2000.</ref> | |||
*2000 – On 21 April, ] admits for the first time the difficulty the Central authorities have had in stamping out Falun Gong, noting that since "22 July 1999, Falun Gong members have been causing trouble on and around Tiananmen Square in Central Beijing nearly every day."<ref>"China Admits Banned Sect Is Continuing Its Protest" Elisabeth Rosenthal. New York Times, 21 April 2000</ref> | |||
*2000 – Zhao Ming, a graduate student at Ireland's Trinity College, is sent to the Tuanhe ] in Beijing in May. He spends two years in the camp amidst international pressure for his release, and is reportedly tortured with electric batons.<ref>Irish Times, 3 March 2002</ref> | |||
*2000 – On 1 October, thousands of Falun Gong practitioners travel to Tiananmen Square to stage protests against the persecution. Foreign media correspondents witness security officers beating and practitioners on the square.<ref>Washington Post Foreign Service, "Falun Gong Protests Mar Chinese Holiday," 1 October 2000</ref> | |||
*2000 – In November, Zhang Kunlun, a Canadian citizen and professor of art, is detained while visiting his mother in China and held in a forced labor camp where he reported being beaten and shocked with electric batons. Canadian politicians intervene on his behalf, eventually winning his release to Canada.<ref>Human Rights Watch, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20071101022047/http://china.hrw.org/book/export/html/50332 |date=1 November 2007 }}, accessed 18 March 2011</ref> | |||
*2001 – On 23 January, five individuals ] on Tiananmen Square. State-run media claim they are Falun Gong practitioners, driven to suicide by the practice. Falun Gong sources deny involvement, saying that Falun Gong forbids suicide and violence, and arguing that the event was staged by the government to turn public opinion against the practice.<ref name=Ownbyfuture/><ref name=Schechter/> Authorities seize on the event to escalate a media campaign against the group, and support for Falun Gong wanes.<ref name=Pomfret/> | |||
*2001 – As sympathy for Falun Gong erodes in Mainland China, authorities for the first time openly sanction the "systematic use of violence" against the group, establishing a network of brainwashing classes and rooting out Falun Gong practitioners "neighborhood by neighborhood and workplace by workplace."<ref name=Pomfret>John Pomfret and Philip P. Pan. "Torture is Breaking Falun Gong." Washington Post, 5 August 2001.</ref> | |||
*2001 – By February, international concern grows over psychiatric abuses committed against Falun Gong practitioners, several hundred of whom had reportedly been held and tortured in psychiatric facilities for refusing to denounce the practice.<ref>Khabir Ahmad, "International concern grows over psychiatric abuses in China", The Lancet, Volume 356, Issue 9233, Page 920, 9 September 2000</ref> | |||
*2001 – On 20 November, a group of 35 Falun Gong practitioners from 12 different countries gathers on Tiananmen Square to meditate under a banner that reads: "Truth, Compassion, Tolerance" – Falun Gong's core moral tenets. They are arrested within minutes, and some are beaten while resisting arrest.<ref>Vancouver Falun Dafa Practitioners' Protest Site, , accessed 19 March 2011</ref> | |||
*2001 – On 23 December, a New York District Court hands down a default judgement against Zhao Zhifei, Public Security Bureau chief for Hubei Province, for his role in the wrongful death and torture of Falun Gong practitioners.<ref name="Direct Litigation">Human Rights Law Foundation, {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20111111144251/http://www.hrlf.net/direct.html |date=11 November 2011 }}, accessed 19 March 2011</ref> | |||
===2002–2004 === | |||
Chinese state media held Li Hongzhi personally responsible for orchestrating the protest.<ref name=atimes/> Li, a US resident at the time, boarded ] flight NW087 in New York and arrived in Beijing on 22 April,<ref name=atimes/> taking a stopover on his way to Sydney.<ref name="own172">Ownby (2008), pg 171</ref> The authorities allege he contacted Ji Liewu, a key member of the Falun Dafa Research Society, in advance,<ref name=atimes/> and met with Li Chang and Ji Liewu in his ] home the following morning to plan the demonstration.<ref name=peoples8>{{cite web|url=http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/special/fagong/1999081900A103.html|title=Li Hongzhi's Role in Illegal Gathering at Zhongnanhai |work=People's Daily |date=19 August 1999}}</ref> On the morning of 24 April, Li reportedly purchased a ticket for Air China Flight CA111 to fly to Hong Kong. The flight was delayed, and he changed his ticket to Flight CA109, which departed at 1:30 pm. He stayed in Hong Kong until 10:15 p.m. on 27 April, before flying back to the United States.<ref name=peoplesdaily>{{cite web |url=http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/special/fagong/1999072200A106.html |title=Life and Times of Li Hongzhi |work=] |date=22 July 1999}}</ref> Li had insisted that Falun Gong had no political objectives, and initially said that the gathering was "spontaneous". He added that he was on a stopover on route to Australia, but "was not aware of what was going on in Beijing,"<ref name=briefstate>Li Hongzhi, , 22 July 1999, accessed 31/12/07</ref> although observers such as HRW<ref name=Spiegel19>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 19</ref> and Ownby criticised his comments as "disingenuous".<ref name=own191>Ownby (2008), pg 191</ref> Li, however, admitted to a journalist one month later what ''Xinhua'' had been reporting about his movements.<ref>''ibid'' Kavan (2008) pg8, citing Paul Flatin (1999b)</ref> Ownby says it was impossible to imagine the planned demonstration was not discussed, and that Li must have at least tacitly endorsed the plan.<ref name="own172"/> According to state media, Falun Gong leaders left Beijing before 25 April in order to avoid blame.<ref name=peoples8/> | |||
By 2002, Falun Gong practitioners had all but completely abandoned the approach of protesting on Tiananmen Square, and coverage in Western news outlets declined precipitously.<ref name=lemish>Leeshai Lemish, Media and New Religious Movements: The Case of Falun Gong, A paper presented at The 2009 CESNUR Conference, Salt Lake City, Utah, 11–13 June 2009</ref>{{better source needed|date=December 2019}} | |||
Falun Gong practitioners continued adopting more novel approaches to protesting, including the establishment of a vast network of underground 'material sites' that create and distribute literature,<ref name=dangerous/> and tapping into television broadcasts to replace them with Falun Gong content.<ref>Ethan Gutmann: "The Chinese Internet: A dream deferred?" Tiananmen 20 years on Laogai Research Foundation/NED Panel 1: Refinement of Repression, 9:15 am, 2 June 2009</ref> Practitioners outside China established a television station to broadcast into China, designed censorship-circumvention tools to break through Internet censorship and surveillance, and filed dozens of largely symbolic lawsuits against Jiang Zemin and other Chinese officials alleging genocide and crimes against humanity.<ref name="Direct Litigation"/> | |||
While Falun Gong's pre-1999 political involvement is difficult to verify, no other disenfranchised social group has ever staged a mass protest near the ] compound in PRC history. Ostergaard sees it as Li's unresolved dilemma between the claimed transcendental and metaphysical nature of the conflict, and the political nature of his demands in reality.<ref name="Jude Howell221">Jude Howell (2003) p. 221</ref> Ownby believes Li is naive in trying to deny the political character of the demonstration, "which by its very location and object was inevitably destined to be interpreted as political, no matter what the 'true' motivations of Li and his followers..."<ref name=own190>Ownby (2008), pg 190</ref> At the time of the Zhongnanhai Incident, Falun Gong had evolved to become a politicised and highly mobilised form of social dissent. Their demands were summed up by Østergaard as being: (1)the right to a nation-wide theocratic organisation, (2)freedom from interference from authorities and media, (3)replacement of the corrupt political system with one made up of Falun Gong practitoners, (4)a slower pace of reforms, (5)equal status for science, para-science and medicine.<ref name="Jude Howell216">Jude Howell (2003) p. 216</ref> Premier ] met with representatives and the crowd dispersed. One of the three practitioners received by Zhu listed their demands as "liberation of the practitioners arrested at Tianjin, a lawful environment in which to 'cultivate', and to be allowed to publish Falun Gong literature via normal channels."<ref name=own171>Ownby (2008), pg 172</ref><ref name=own172>Ownby (2008), pg 171</ref> | |||
From 2002 to 2004, the ] of power in China were transferred from Jiang Zemin to ]. Annual Falun Gong deaths in custody continued to grow through 2004, according to reports published by Falun Gong sources, but coverage of Falun Gong declined over the period.<ref name=lemish/>{{better source needed|date=December 2019}} | |||
The incident raised questions about the Communist Party's control over the country,<ref name=lestz>Michael Lestz, , Religion in the News, Fall 1999, Vol. 2, No. 3, Trinity College, Massachusetts</ref> and led fear and animosity towards the movement amongst China's central leadership.<ref name=XIX/> There reportedly were rifts in the ] at the time of the incident, with some members advocating for a crackdown and others opposing it. President Jiang Zemin is held by Falun Gong to be largely personally responsible for the final decision.<ref name=peerman>Dean Peerman, , Christian Century, 10 August 2004</ref><ref name=Saich>Tony Saich, ''Governance and Politics in China,'' Palgrave Macmillan; 2nd Ed edition (27 Feb 2004)</ref> Some reports indicate that Zhu Rongji, in his compromise to Falun Gong practitioners, was criticized by Jiang for being too soft.<ref name=Schechter/> | |||
] compound]] | |||
] | |||
The Chinese Communist Party later declared the gathering on 25 April to be "the most serious political incident" since the ].<ref name="HRW1">, Human Rights Watch</ref> According to some analysts, the government was alarmed after the gathering at the possibility of such a large number of people amassing so close to the seat of power without the security forces being aware.<ref name="Amnesty1"/><ref name=atimes>Francesco Sisci,, Asia Times, 27 January 2001</ref> According to some estimates there were more than 100,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Beijing at the time, and the scale of the protest pointed to the Communist Party losing its tight control on the people while it tinkered with political and economic reforms.<ref name="ReidG">Reid, Graham (29 April-5 May 2006) , ''New Zealand Listener''. Retrieved 6 July 2006.</ref> Ownby and Ostergaard<ref name="Jude Howell221"/> commented that the demonstration was a "deadly miscalculation" by Li Hongzhi; Ownby suggested the decision to authorise the gathering had "its roots in some combination of calculation and arrogance."<ref name=own173>Ownby (2008), pg 173</ref> | |||
*2002 – On 14 February, 53 Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia attempt to stage a demonstration on Tiananmen Square. They are detained, and several reportedly assaulted by security forces before being expelled from China.<ref>CNN, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121007090314/http://articles.cnn.com/2002-02-14/world/china.falungong_1_falun-gong-chinese-police-tiananmen-square?_s=PM:asiapcf |date=7 October 2012 }}, 14 February 2002</ref> | |||
*2002 – On 5 March, a group of six Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun city intercept television broadcasts, replacing them with content about Falun Gong and the persecution. Apparently believing that it to be a signal that the ban on Falun Gong had been lifted, citizens gather in public squares to celebrate.<ref name=airwaves/> The Falun Gong broadcasts run for 50 minutes before the city goes black. Over the next three days, security forces arrest some 5,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun. Amnesty International reports that "police 'stop-and-search' checkpoints have reportedly been established across the city." All six individuals involved in the television hijacking are later tortured to death.<ref name=airwaves>Ethan Gutmann, "", Weekly Standard 6 DEC 2010, VOL. 16, NO. 12</ref> | |||
*2002 – In June, Jiang Zemin visits ]. Dozens of Falun Gong practitioners from around the world attempt to travel to the country to protest, but find their names on an international blacklist organized at the behest of Chinese authorities, suggesting extensive espionage against foreign Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Philip Shenon. "Iceland Bars American Falun Gong Followers." New York Times, 15 June 2002. pg. A.7</ref> | |||
*2002 – Falun Gong practitioners in New York establish ], a Chinese-language station created to present an alternative to state-run Chinese media.<ref>Chen, Kathy, , The Wall Street Journal, 15 November 2007</ref> | |||
*2002 – On 24 July, U.S. House of Representatives passes a unanimous resolution (House Concurrent Resolution 188) condemning the persecution of Falun Gong in China.<ref>Clearwisdom.net, "", 19 March 2011</ref> | |||
*2002 – On 21 October, Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia file a legal case against Jiang Zemin, ], and ] to the United Nations Human Rights Committee and the International Criminal Court for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong.<ref>Clearwisdom.net, "", accessed 19 March 2011</ref> | |||
*2002 – In November, ] begins the process of taking over China's leadership from Jiang Zemin, assuming the position General Secretary of the CCP. | |||
*2003 – On 22 January, Falun Gong practitioner and American citizen Dr. Charles Lee is arrested by security forces in Nanjing immediately upon his arrival in China. Lee is sentenced to three years in prison.<ref>, 22 July 2004</ref> | |||
*2003 – On 1 May, Pan Xinchun, Deputy Consul General at the Chinese consulate in Toronto, published a letter in the Toronto Star in which he said that local Falun Gong practitioner Joel Chipkar is a member of a "sinister cult." In February 2004, the Ontario Superior Court found Pan liable for libel, and demanded he pay $10,000 in compensation to Chipkar. Pan refused to pay, and left Canada.<ref>John Turley-Ewart, "Falun Gong persecution spreads to Canada," The National Post, 20 March 2004.</ref> | |||
*2003 – June, A San Francisco District Court issues a default ruling against Beijing Party Secretary and former Beijing Mayor Liu Qi and Deputy Governor of Liaoning Province Xia Deren, who had been accused of overseeing the torture of Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Falun Dafa Information Center, "", 20 June 2003</ref> | |||
*2003 – On 26 December, Liu Chengjun, one of the leaders behind the Changchun television broadcasts, is tortured to death while serving out a 19-year prison sentence.<ref name=airwaves /> | |||
*2004 – In October, U.S. House of Representatives passed a unanimous resolution detailing and condemning the Chinese government's attempts to interfere with and intimidate Falun Gong practitioners in the United States.<ref>United States Congressional Resolution, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100704174143/http://old.faluninfo.net/displayAnArticle.asp?ID=8960 |date=4 July 2010 }}, 10-6-2004</ref> | |||
*2004 – In December, prominent ] lawyer ] writes to the National People's Congress detailing torture and sexual abuse against Falun Gong practitioners in custody. In response to his letter, Gao's law firm is shut down, his legal license is revoked, and he is put under house arrest.<ref>Gao Zhisheng, "A China More Just: My Fight As a Rights Lawyer in the World's Largest Communist State," Broad Pr U.S.A, 2007</ref> | |||
===2005–2007 === | |||
From a PR viewpoint, Østergaard recognised that Li Hongzhi, previously unknown to the West, had been interviewed by ''Time magazine'' for the first time just weeks before Zhongnanhai; he further asserted ''Time'' was tipped off on the day about the size and location of the demonstration.<ref name="Jude Howell224">Jude Howell (2003) p. 224 (note 18)</ref> | |||
As Falun Gong becomes more overt in its rhetorical charges against CCP rule, allegations emerge that Chinese security agencies engage in large-scale overseas spying operations against Falun Gong practitioners, and that Falun Gong prisoners in China are killed to supply China's organ transplant industry. | |||
The ''Wall Street Journal'' suggested a network of high-ranking political figures, which include PLA Generals and many members of China's National People's Congress, helped organise the 10,000-strong demonstration.<ref>{{cite web |first=Craig S. |last=Smith |title=Chinese Spiritual Group Draws Strength From Retired Elite, Some Party Members |work=Wall Street Journal |date=30 April 1999 |url=http://www.valdostamuseum.org/hamsmith/FalunDafa99Apr.html |publisher=c/o third party link]<!-- this link is a personal website, and the contents need verification against actual journal -->}}</ref> A 74-year-old retired general, Yu Changxin, was arrested for organising the gathering, and sentenced to 17 years in prison in January 2000.<ref name=atimes/> Although Julia Ching from the ] says it is not certain where practitioners wanted to protest,<ref name=XIX/> many Falun Gong practitioners believe the police directed them to Zhongnanhai in order to create an incident that could later be held against Falun Gong.<ref name=own172>Ownby (2008), p. 172</ref> | |||
*2005 – On 15 February, Li Hongzhi issues a statement renouncing his earlier membership in the Communist Youth League. | |||
== The ban and crackdown == | |||
*2005 – On 4 June, Chinese diplomat Chen Yonglin, a political consul at the Chinese consulate in Sydney, defects to Australia. He reports that a large part of his job was to monitor and harass Falun Gong practitioners in Australia. Days later, on 8 June, Hao Fengjun, a former member of the Tianjin city 610 office, goes public with his story of defection, and tells of abuse against Falun Gong in China.<ref name="cyber assault">Gutmann, Ethan. "Hacker Nation: China's Cyber Assault," World Affairs MAY/JUNE 2010</ref> | |||
Three days after Zhongnanhai, ''Xinhua'' published an interview with an official who warned against similar protests: "Those who jeopardize social stability under the pretext of practising any type of 'qigong' will be dealt with according to the law."<ref>{{cite news |url=http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0WDQ/is_1999_May_3/ai_54563003/?tag=content;col1 |title=Chinese gov't warns cult not to repeat protest | |||
*2005 – On 16 June, ] is reported tortured to death in Shenyang at the age of 37.<ref>Amnesty International, 27 June 2005</ref> | |||
|work=Asian Political News |date=3 May 1999 }}</ref> In early May, reports were circulating that Jiang Zemin had established a high-level task force to deal with the threat, with ] and ] in charge.<ref name=Spiegel17>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 17</ref> Authorities began to round up Falun Gong leaders. According to the BBC, Falun Gong mobilised "tens of thousands of followers in some 30 cities" in mid June after the arrests.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/400772.stm |date=22 July 1999 |work=BBC News |title=China bans sect}}</ref> On 22 July 1999, the government of the People's Republic of China (PRC) issued a statement banning Falun Gong: {{cquote| | |||
*2005 – In June, the number of Falun Gong practitioners allegedly killed as a result or torture and abuse in custody exceeds 2,500.<ref>Falun Dafa Information Center, " {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110501233445/http://faluninfo.net/topic/4/ |date=1 May 2011 }}", 17 May 2008</ref> | |||
''China today banned the Research Society of Falun Dafa and the Falun Gong organization under its control after deeming them to be illegal. In its decision on this matter issued today, the Ministry of Civil Affairs said that according to investigations, the Research Society of Falun Dafa had not been registered according to law and had been engaged in illegal activities, advocating superstition and spreading fallacies, hoodwinking people, inciting and creating disturbances, and jeopardizing social stability. The decision said that therefore, in accordance with the Regulations on the Registration and Management of Mass Organizations, the Research Society of Falun Dafa and the Falun Gong organization under its control are held to be illegal and are therefore banned.''<ref name=ban>], , People's Daily, 22 July 1999</ref>}} In another commentary, ''Xinhua'' said that Falun Gong was opposed to the Party, that "It preaches idealism, theism and feudal superstition, and that its leaders were "a small number of behind-the-scenes plotters and organizers who harbor political intentions".<ref>, People's Daily, 2 August 1999</ref> ''Xinhua'' asserted that the actions taken against Falun Gong were essential to maintaining the "vanguard role and purity" of the Communist Party, and that "In fact, the so-called `truth, kindness and forbearance' principle preached by Li has nothing in common with the socialist ethical and cultural progress we are striving to achieve."<ref>Gayle M.B. Hanson, , Insight on the News, 23 August 1999, accessed 31/12/07</ref> | |||
*2006 – UN special rapporteur on torture ] releases the findings of his 2005 investigation on torture in China. He reports that two-thirds of reported torture cases are against Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Manfred Nowak (2006). "Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment: MISSION TO CHINA". United Nations. p. 13.</ref> | |||
*2006 – In July 2006, former Canadian Member of Parliament ] and international human rights attorney ] release the findings of their investigation into ]. Although their evidence was largely circumstantial, they conclude that involuntary organ extractions from Falun Gong practitioners are widespread and ongoing. Chinese officials deny the allegations.<ref>David Kilgour and David Kilgour (2007) (in 22 languages)</ref> | |||
*2006 – Falun Gong practitioners in the United States establish ], a classical Chinese dance company that begins touring internationally in 2007.<ref></ref> | |||
*2007 – Falun Gong sources report that the number of persecution deaths exceeds 3,000.<ref name=faluninfotime /> | |||
*2007 – August, practitioners of Falun Gong launch the ], which toured to over 35 of countries in 2007 and 2008 ahead of the ].<ref name=Eriksen>Alanah May Eriksen, New Zealand Herald. . 17 December 2007.</ref><ref>The Calgary Herald, {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121107003127/http://www.canada.com/calgaryherald/news/city/story.html?id=4b4fd555-3455-40ba-b594-3cd16aa28624 |date=7 November 2012 }}. 20 May 2008.</ref> The relay was intended to draw attention to a range of human rights issues in China in connection with the Olympics, especially those related to Falun Gong and ], and received support from hundreds of elected officials, past Olympic medallists, human rights groups and other concerned organizations.<ref name=Eriksen/> | |||
=== 2008–2014 === | |||
Li Hongzhi issued a "''Brief Statement of Mine''" on the same day, which dealt with a number of issues. On the ban, he said: | |||
Top-level Chinese authorities continue to launch strike-hard campaigns against Falun Gong surrounding sensitive events and anniversaries, and step up efforts to coercively "transform" Falun Gong practitioners in detention facilities and reeducation centers. ] who seek to represent Falun Gong defendants continue to face punishment from Chinese authorities, including harassment, disbarment, and imprisonment. | |||
{{cquote| | |||
''Falun Gong is simply a popular qigong activity. It does not have any particular organization, let alone any political objectives. We have never been involved in any anti-government activities... We are not against the government now, nor will we be in the future... We are calling for all governments, international organizations, and people of goodwill worldwide to extend their support and assistance to us in order to resolve the present crisis that is taking place in China.<ref name=briefstate/>}} | |||
*2008 – On 6 February, ] 11 days after being taken into custody in Beijing. His wife, artist Xu Na, is sentenced to 3 years in prison for possessing Falun Gong literature.<ref>New York Times, , accessed 19 March 2011</ref> | |||
=== Speculation on rationale === | |||
HRW notes that the crackdown on Falun Gong reflects historical efforts by the Chinese Communist Party to eradicate religion, which the government believed was inherently subversive. Only when eradication proved impossible, it would allow citizens to "enjoy freedom of religious belief" and to protect "normal religious activities," with the caveat of being under state control.<ref name=Spiegel14>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 14</ref> Chinese leaders suspended its hard-line atheist stance in the early 1980s to gain cooperation from all sectors of society to advance their development agenda. HRW suggests that this official policy and suspicion that Falun Gong was a vehicle for external and domestic anti-China forces contributed to the crackdown on it. Furthermore, it notes that Qigong is not one of the recognised religions, thus not entitled to constitutional protection.<ref name=Spiegel14/> Some journalists believe that Beijing's reaction exposes its authoritarian nature and its intolerance for competing loyalty.<ref name=atimes/> '']'' wrote : "...any group that does not come under the control of the Party is a threat"; secondly, the 1989 protests may have heightened the leaders' sense of losing their grip on power, making them live in "mortal fear" of popular demonstrations.<ref name=atimes/><ref>The Globe and Mail, Beijing v. falun gong, Metro A14, 01/26/2001</ref> Craig Smith of ''the Wall Street Journal'' suggests that the government which has by definition no view of spirituality, lacks moral credibility with which to fight an expressly spiritual foe; the party feels increasingly threatened by any belief system that challenges its ideology and has an ability to organize as well.<ref name=nyt20000430>{{cite news |url=http://www.nytimes.com/2000/04/30/weekinreview/the-world-rooting-out-falun-gong-china-makes-war-on-mysticism.html?pagewanted=all |title=Rooting Out Falun Gong; China Makes War on Mysticism |first=Craig S. |last=Smith | |||
|work=New York Times |date=April 30, 2000}}</ref> Citing Kiplis (2001) that institutional boundaries between 'religion' and 'science' are constantly renegotiated, and that practitioners of 'apolitical activities' must focus on their relations with the state, Østergaard implies that Li neglected this, and was relying solely on the government's reaction.<ref name="Jude Howell220"/> Lestz also agrees that unwritten rules of engagement had been violated by Falun Gong protests, and the government's fear of Falun Gong lay in the potential for it to turn itself into a political organisation on the backs of its nationwide organizational infrastructure, as has happened before in China's history; allied to that, is the strength and level of infiltration into the Communist Party intimated in Li's messages.<ref name="lestz"/> Citing Lee (1987), Østergaard suggests that the movement had undoubtedly become political, and that Li had underestimated the party's reaction to the Zhongnanhai "siege".<ref name="Jude Howell220">Jude Howell (2003) pages=220</ref> | |||
] | |||
Reports suggest that certain high-level Communist Party officials had wanted to crackdown on the practice for some years, but lacked pretext or support until Zhongnanhai, which Ching suggested was pivotal in elevating "fear, animosity and suppression" of the movement.<ref name=XIX/> Reportedly many high-ranking members of the politburo were opposed to a nationwide persecution of the movement, and Falun Gong considers ] personally responsible for the final decision and the ensuing political campaign."<ref name="Saich"/><ref name=lamsupp /> Jiang Zemin had allegedly received a letter from the former director of the ], "a doctor with considerable standing among the political elite," endorsing Falun Gong and advising high-level cadres to start practising it.<ref name=XIX/> Jiang also found out that Li's book, ''Zhuan Falun'', had been published by ], and that possibly seven hundred thousand Communist Party members were practitioners. "Jiang accepts the threat of Falun Gong as an ideological one: spiritual beliefs against militant atheism and historical materialism. He to purge the government and the military of such beliefs".<ref name=XIX/> | |||
] scenes in ]]] | |||
'']'' reported that sources indicated not all of the ] shared Jiang's view that Falun Gong should be eradicated.<ref name="ReidG"/> The size and reach of Jiang's anti-Falun Gong campaign surpassed that of many previous mass-movements.<ref name=lamsupp>Willy Wo-Lap Lam, , CNN.com, 9 February 2001</ref> Through a Mao-style purge of Falun Gong, Jiang forced senior cadres "to pledge allegiance to his line", thus boosting his authority to enable him to dictate events at the pivotal ], according to a Communist Party veteran. "As with 1960s-style campaigns, the standard ritual of ideological sessions held in party units, factories, and colleges the past few years is that participants make public declarations of support for the Beijing line—and for the top leader."<ref name=lamsupp /> Lam reports a mid-level official saying that "The leadership is obsessed with the Falun Gong and have put its eradication as a top priority this year."<ref name=lamendgame>CNN.com, , 21 August 2001</ref> | |||
*2008 – In the first six months of the year, over 8,000 Falun Gong practitioners are abducted by security forces under the pretext of preventing protests during the Beijing Olympics.<ref>Congressional-Executive Commission on China, {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121212041846/http://www.cecc.gov/pages/annualRpt/annualRpt08/CECCannRpt2008.pdf |date=12 December 2012 }}, 31 October 2008.</ref> | |||
=== The crackdown=== | |||
*2009 – CCP heir apparent ] is put in charge of ], a strike hard effort to crack down on Tibetans, democracy activists and Falun Gong practitioners around sensitive anniversaries. ] heads a parallel effort to crack down on Falun Gong practitioners, ethnic separatism, and protests.<ref>Ching Cheong. {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120320124326/http://www.hkej.com/template/blog/php/blog_details.php?blog_posts_id=2277 |date=20 March 2012 }}. Singapore Straits Times. 3 March 2009</ref> | |||
On 10 June 1999 the Party established the ']', an extra-constitutional body to lead the suppression of groups which the government considered 'cults'.<ref name=CER>{{cite web|url=http://www.cecc.gov/pages/annualRpt/annualRpt08/CECCannRpt2008.pdf |title=Congressional-Executive commission on China, Annual Report 2008. |format=PDF |date= |accessdate=2009-12-18}}</ref> Representatives were selected in every province, city, county, university, government department and state-owned business in China.<ref name="ReidG"/> On 20 July 1999, the crackdown officially began. Public security officers throughout China quietly detained numerous Falun Gong leaders just after midnight,<ref name=Spiegel21>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 21</ref> although Porter states this took place "within days". Across the country, police began arresting Falun Gong leaders from hundreds of homes, and hauling them to prison. Falun Gong's four Beijing "arch-leaders" were arrested, and quickly tried.<ref name="Porter">Noah Porter (Masters thesis for the University of South Florida), '''', 2003, p 98</ref> ] ordered churches, temples, mosques, newspapers, media, courts and police to suppress Falun Gong.<ref name=wildgrass>Johnson, Ian, ''Wild Grass: three portraits of change in modern china'', Vintage (8 March 2005)</ref> Three days of massive demonstrations by practitioners in some thirty cities followed. In Beijing and other cities, protesters were detained in sports stadia.<ref name=Spiegel21/> | |||
*2009 – In March, U.S. House of Representatives passes a resolution on recognizing and condemning the ongoing persecution of Falun Gong in China.<ref>Einhorn, Bruce. "Congress Challenges China on Falun Gong & Yuan", Business Week, 17 March 2010</ref> | |||
*2009 – On 13 May, ] Zhang Kai(张凯) and Li Chunfu(李春富) are violently beaten and detained in ] for investigating the death of Jiang Xiqing(江锡清), a 66-year-old Falun Gong practitioner killed in a labor camp.<ref>Human Rights in China, , 13 May 2009.</ref> | |||
*2009 – On 4 July, Dalian city lawyer Wang Yonghang(王永航) is taken from his home by security agents, interrogated, and beaten for defending Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Amnesty International. . 28 July 2009</ref> In November 2009, Wang was sentenced in a closed court to seven years in prison for his advocacy on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners. When his lawyers were permitted to see him in January 2010, they reported that he had been tortured.<ref>Congressional Executive Commission on China. , 10 October 2010, p. 104.</ref> | |||
*2009 – In November, Jiang Zemin and other high-ranking Chinese officials are indicted by a Spanish court on charges of genocide and crimes against humanity for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong.<ref>, 14 November 2009</ref> A month later, an Argentine judge concludes that top Chinese officials Jiang Zemin and Luo Gan had adopted a "genocidal strategy" in pursuing the eradication of Falun Gong, and asks Interpol to seek their arrest<ref>Luis Andres Henao, "," 22 December 2009</ref> | |||
*2010 – Over 100 Falun Gong practitioners in Shanghai are abducted and detained in connection with the Shanghai World Expo. Some reportedly face torture for their refusal to disavow Falun Gong.<ref name=CECC>Congressional Executive Commission on China, , 2010.</ref> | |||
*2010 – In the Spring of 2010, Chinese authorities launch a new, three-year campaign whose goal is to coercively transform large portions of the known Falun Gong population through attendance in reeducation classes.<ref>CECC, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20111202130133/http://www.cecc.gov/pages/virtualAcad/index.phpd?showsingle=154369 |date=2 December 2011 }}, 22 March 2011, accessed 19 March 2011</ref> | |||
*2010 – On 22 April 2010, Beijing lawyers ] and ] were permanently disbarred for defending Falun Gong practitioners.<ref>Amnesty International, 05-10-2010</ref> | |||
*2011 – In February, a Falun Gong practitioner named Qin Yueming dies in custody at the Jiamusi Prison. His family state that his body was covered with extensive bruising, with blood in his nose, though authorities said the cause of death was heart attack. A petition seeking redress for his death garners over 15,000 signatures. Qin's wife and daughter are subsequently imprisoned and reportedly tortured for their efforts to draw attention to the case.<ref name=AmnestyQin>Amnesty International, , 22 August 2012.</ref> | |||
*2011 – In May, a lawsuit is filed on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners against ]. The suit alleges, based mainly on internal Cisco documents, that the technology company "designed and implemented a surveillance system for the Chinese Communist Party, knowing it would be used to root out members of the Falun Gong religion and subject them to detention, forced labor and torture."<ref>Terry Baynes, , Reuters, 20 May 2011.</ref> | |||
*2011 – In Hebei province, 3,000 Chinese citizens sign a petition calling for the release of detained Falungong practitioners Zhou Xiangyang and Li Shanshan, who were being held at the Gangbei Prison and Tangshan reeducation center, respectively.<ref>Amnesty International, , 14 November 2011.</ref> | |||
*2012 – In June 2012, 15,000 people in Heilongjiang Province signed and affixed their fingerprints to a petition requesting that the government investigate the death of Qin Yueming, a Falun Gong practitioner who died in custody.<ref name=AmnestyQin/> | |||
*2012 – In early June, Falun Gong practitioner Li Lankui was detained and sent to a reeducation-through-labour camp in Hebei province. Hundreds of villagers mobilized to call for Li's release, including by signing petitions calling for an end to the persecution of Falun Gong. This prompted further crackdowns by security agents, leading to the arrest of at least 16 villagers. Some reported that they were tortured for expressing their support for Li Lankui.<ref>Amnesty International, , 22 October 2012.</ref><ref></ref> | |||
*2012 – in December, a woman in ] finds a letter written in both Chinese and English in a box of Halloween decorations purchased from Kmart. The letter said that the decorations were assembled in Unit 8, Department 2 of ]. It went on to describe forced labor conditions in the camp, and noted that many of the detainees were Falun Gong practitioners being held without trial. The letter's author, a Falun Gong practitioner from Beijing, was later identified by ''The New York Times''.<ref name=NYT61113>{{cite news|title=Behind Cry for Help From China Labor Camp|url=https://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/12/world/asia/man-details-risks-in-exposing-chinas-forced-labor.html|access-date=12 June 2013|newspaper=The New York Times|date=11 June 2013|author=]}}</ref> | |||
*2013 – Central 610 Office authorities launch a new three-year campaign calling for the ideological "transformation" of Falun Gong practitioners. Local governments issue quotas and targets for the number of Falun Gong practitioners to reeducate, and prescribe the appropriate means for doing so.<ref name=Amnesty2013/> | |||
*2013 – A photojournalism magazine in China publishes an exposé detailing human rights abuses committed by female detainees at the ] in ], where Falun Gong practitioners were estimated to comprise approximately half the detainees. The article was promptly removed from the magazine's website, but not before galvanizing nationwide opposition to and condemnation of the labor camp system. Soon thereafter, New York Times photographer ] releases a documentary on the Masanjia labor camp.<ref name=Amnesty2013/> | |||
*2013 – Chinese officials begin dismantling the nationwide network of reeducation-through-labour camps, in which Falun Gong practitioners comprised a significant portion of detainees. Human rights groups expressed skepticism at the scope of reforms, however, noting that other forms of extralegal detention were still being used to detain Falun Gong practitioners and political dissidents.<ref name=Amnesty2013>{{cite book|publisher=Amnesty International|title=Changing the soup but not the medicine: Abolishing re-education through labor in China|date=Dec 2013|location=London, UK|url=https://www.amnesty.org/es/documents/asa17/042/2013/es/}}</ref><ref>Freedom House, , January 2015. Quote: "...for Falun Gong practitioners, the abolition of the RTL camp system coincided with an increased use of prison sentences on the one hand, and detention in extra-legal "legal education centers" for forced conversion on the other."</ref> | |||
*2013 – On 12 December, European Parliament adopts a resolution on organ harvesting in China, where it "Calls for the EU and its Member States to raise the issue of organ harvesting in China"<ref>European Parliament, . Quote: "Expresses its deep concern over the persistent and credible reports of systematic, state‑sanctioned organ harvesting from non-consenting prisoners of conscience in the People's Republic of China, including from large numbers of Falun Gong practitioners imprisoned for their religious beliefs, as well as from members of other religious and ethnic minority groups"</ref> | |||
*2014 – In August, investigative journalist ] publishes his book "The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem," in which he writes that ].<ref>Barbara Turnbull, , Toronto Star, 21 October 2014.</ref><ref>Thomas Nelson, {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150206213828/http://iar-gwu.org/content/slaughter-mass-killings-organ-harvestings-and-china%E2%80%99s-secret-solution-its-dissident-problem |date=6 February 2015 }}, International Affairs Review.</ref> | |||
*2014 – Four lawyers in ] are detained and reportedly tortured by the police while investigating abuses against Falun Gong practitioners held at the Qinglongshan farm reeducation centre.<ref>Amnesty International, , 4 April 2014.</ref> | |||
==References== | |||
On 22 July, the Ministry of Civil Affairs and the Ministry of Public Security together dissolved the Falun Dafa Research Society and banned "the propagation of Falungong in any form" and to prohibit anyone from disrupting social order or confronting the government.<ref name=Spiegel21/> Other qigong groups, such as ], were similarly forced to disband. HRW notes that Chinese officials did not hesitate to apply the same harsh tactics to Falun Gong that it had employed previously against other sects it sought to control – to illustrate its power over all religious expression, " who inspired extraordinary loyalty from worshippers or who resisted government edicts went to prison or simply were 'disappeared'".<ref name=Spiegel15>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 15</ref> HRW and Amnesty stated that the official directives and legal documents issued for the purge fall short of international standards.<ref name=dangerous>Mickey Spiegel, , Human Rights Watch, 2002. Retrieved Sept 28, 2007.</ref><ref name=heretical>(23 March 2000) , Amnesty International</ref> | |||
<!--- This section should only contain items that are referenced in the article. ---> | |||
{{Reflist}} | |||
<!--- References above this have been verified and placed in order. ---> | |||
==Further reading== | |||
On 26 July, several state bureaux and the Ministry of Public Security jointly issued a circular calling for confiscation and destruction of all publications related to Falun Gong;<ref name=Spiegel20>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 20</ref> it was condemned in the media, with books shredded and videotapes bulldozed for TV cameras.<ref name="Leung"/><ref name=Spiegel21/> Three days later, an arrest warrant was issued for Li Hongzhi for "spreading superstition, deception, and organising gatherings to disturb public order", which was filed with but declined by Interpol.<ref name=Spiegel21/> Protests continued, and thousands of practitioners entered Beijing for a demonstration in Tiananmen Square on {{nowrap|25 October}}. Politburo member Li Lanqing reported that up to the end of October, there had been 35,792 instances when followers were stopped by police and either taken away or told to leave Beijing; a large number are believed to have been stopped from reaching the capital.<ref name=Spiegel22>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 22</ref> | |||
* {{cite journal|last=Li|first=Junpeng|url=https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/politics-and-religion/article/abs/religion-of-the-nonreligious-and-the-politics-of-the-apolitical-the-transformation-of-falun-gong-from-healing-practice-to-political-movement/721645CB0ED458B1540460F1D99F0B89|title=The Religion of the Nonreligious and the Politics of the Apolitical: The Transformation of Falun Gong from Healing Practice to Political Movement|journal=]|publisher=]|date=2013-11-01|volume=7|issue=1|pages=177–208|doi=10.1017/S1755048313000576|s2cid=145591972 }} | |||
* {{cite journal|last=Ownby|first=David|url=https://online.ucpress.edu/nr/article-abstract/6/2/223/71159/A-History-for-Falun-Gong-Popular-Religion-and-the?redirectedFrom=fulltext|title=A History for Falun Gong: Popular Religion and the Chinese State Since the Ming Dynasty|journal=]|publisher=]|volume=6|issue=2|date=April 2003|pages=223–243|doi=10.1525/nr.2003.6.2.223|jstor=10.1525/nr.2003.6.2.223}} | |||
==External links== | |||
The government enacted a statute (article 300 of the Criminal Law), passed by the ] on 30 October 1999, with retrospective application to suppress thousands of "heterodox religions" across China,<ref name=lum/> thus legitimising the persecution of Falun Gong and any other spiritual groups deemed "dangerous to the state."<ref name=Leung/> Arrested leaders had been formally charged on October 19 with various offences ranging from organizing a cult to "stealing, illegally possessing and leaking state secrets" and "running an illegal business." The State Council Information Office announced that at least 150 people had been detained or were being sought on similar charges by November 22; forty-four people had been indicted by November 28.<ref name=Spiegel27>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 27</ref> Upon the sentencing of two key Falun Gong leaders to heavy prison terms (16 to 18 years') in late December, the protests which had abated resumed immediately.<ref name=Spiegel28>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 28</ref> | |||
{{commons category|Falun Gong}} | |||
Despite Beijing's heavy hand against practitioners, protests continued well into 2000. According to ''Time'', a Falun Gong website editorial instructed followers to "step up , especially in Tiananmen Square". Founder ] urged followers to immobilize the police and other "evil scoundrels" through use of supernatural powers.<ref name=breakingpoint>{{cite news |first=Matthew |last=Gornet |url=http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,165163,00.html |title=The Breaking Point |work=] |date=25 June 2001}}</ref> ] thus became one of the prime locations where practitioners routinely demonstrated despite government deterrence.<ref name="johnson2000"/> HRW observed that state's efforts to stop demonstrations were met by "orchestrated defiance" and daily protests throughout 2000. Daily protesters usually numbered in the hundreds, perhaps 1,000 protesters or more would gather on holidays and important dates; practitioners from around the country would "court detention" on Tiananmen Square by unfurling banners or meditating. In anticipation of their arrests by police, Falun Gong ensured international media were on hand to witness how their peaceful protest was met by violent responses from authorities; they would draw attention to arrests and suspicious deaths in custody, issue media alerts, and post information on the internet.<ref name=Spiegel289>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pp 28-29</ref> According to Leung, 5,000 were detained across China by February 2000.<ref name="Leung"/> By 25 April 2000, within one year after the massive demonstration at Zhongnanhai, a total of more than 30,000 practitioners had been arrested there.<ref name="johnson2000">{{cite web |url=http://www.pulitzer.org/archives/6464 |title=Defiant Falun Dafa Members Converge on Tiananmen |first=Ian |last=Johnson |date=25 April 2000 |work=The Wall Street Journal |publisher=Pulitzer.org |page= A21}}</ref> Seven hundred Falun Gong followers were arrested during a demonstration in the Square on 1 January 2001.<ref name="Perry">{{cite book |first=Elizabeth J. |last=Selden |coauthor=Perry, Mark |title=Chinese Society: Change, Conflict and Resistance |publisher=Routledge |year=2003 |ISBN=041530170X}}</ref> Officials grew impatient with the constant flow of protesters into Beijing,<ref name=wildgrass>ibid., Ian Johnson, ''Wildgrass'' (2005) p 285</ref> and decided to implement a cascading responsibility system to push the responsibility for meeting central orders down onto those enforcing them: central authorities would hold local officials personally responsible for stemming the flow of protesters.<ref name=breakingpoint/> The provincial government would fine mayors for each Falun Gong practitioner from their district who made it to Beijing; the mayors would in turn fine the heads of the Political and Legal commissions, who would in turn fine village chiefs, who fined police officers who administered the punishment. According to Johnson, police in turn extorted money illegally from Falun Gong practitioners, and the order was only relayed orally at meetings, “because they didn't want it made public.” A chief feature in the testimony of Falun Gong torture victims was that they were “constantly being asked for money to compensate for the fines.”<ref name="wildgrass"/> | |||
* | |||
HRW reported that some work units would summarily fire people identified as practitioners, meaning they would lose housing, schooling, pensions, and be reported to the police. Whereas places remote from Beijing once turned a blind eye to solitary exercise and meditation, restrictions were tightened in 2001 after the ].<ref name=Spiegel43>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 43</ref> Local officials would detain active practitioners and those unwilling to recant, and were expected to "make certain" that families and employers keep them isolated.<ref name=Spiegel36>Mickey Spiegel (2002), pg 36</ref> | |||
On the eve of ] on 23 January 2001, seven people attempted to set themselves ablaze at Tiananmen Square. Although the Falun Dafa Information Center disputed that ] were practitioners,<ref name="FDI_PressRelease">{{cite web |url=http://www.clearwisdom.net/eng/2001/jan/23/vsf012301_3.html |title=Press Statement |publisher=Falun Dafa Information Center |publisher=Clearwisdom |date=23 January 2001 |accessdate=9 February 2007}}</ref> on the grounds that the movement's teachings explicitly forbid suicide and killing,<ref name="TheIssueOfKilling">{{cite web |url=http://falundafa.org/book/eng/zfl_new_7.html#1 |title=The Issue of Killing |first=Hongzhi |last=Li |work=] |publisher=Falun Dafa}}</ref> the official Chinese press agency, ], and other state media asserted that they were practitioners. The incident received international news coverage, and video footage of the burnings were broadcast later inside China by ] (CCTV). Images of a 12 year old girl, Liu Siying, burning and interviews with the other participants in which they stated their belief that self-immolation would lead them to paradise were shown.<ref name=oneway>{{cite news |first=Philip P. |last=Pan |url= |title=One-Way Trip to the End in Beijing |work=International Herald Tribune |date=5 February 2001|accessdate = 9 February 2007}}</ref> ''Time'' reported that prior to the self-immolation incident, many Chinese had felt that Falun Gong posed no real threat, and that the state's crackdown had gone too far. After the event, however, China's media campaign against Falun Gong gained significant traction.<ref name=breakingpoint>Matthew Gornet, , ], 25 June 2001</ref><ref>{{cite book |url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=H80YZqSj7EEC&pg=PA208&dq=Ostergaard+falun&client=firefox-a&cd=3#v=onepage&q=New%20Year%27s%20Day%202001&f=false |title=Governance in China |editor= Jude Howell |first=Clemens Stubbe |last=Østergaard |pages=220 (Governance and the Political Challenge of Falun Gong) |year=2003 |isbn=0742519880}}</ref> | |||
=== Use of the cult label === | |||
The government re-used may of the arguments which had been advanced by critics of the movement prior to the ban, including allegations that Falun Gong was "propagating feudal superstition", that Li had changed his birthdate, and that the practice exploited spiritual cultivation to engage in seditious politics. In exposés such as "''Falun Gong is a Cult''",<ref name="FG is a cult">Embassy of the People's Republic of China (1 November 1999) . Retrieved 10 June 2006.</ref> "''Exposing the Lies of the 'Falun Gong' Cult''", and "''Cult of Evil''", they alleged that Falun Gong engaged in mind control and manipulation via "lies and fallacies," causing "needless deaths of large numbers of practitioners." State media seized upon Li's writing in which he expressed that illnesses are caused by karma, and that Li has stated on several occasions that the sign of a true practitioner is to refuse medicine or medical care.<ref name=Kavan10>Kavan (2008), pg10 (citing Li, 1998b; 1998c; 1999; 2001a; | |||
2003b)</ref> The authorities claimed over 1,000 deaths because practitioners followed Li's teachings and refused to seek medical treatment, that several hundred practitioners had cut their stomachs open "looking for the ]" or committed suicide, and that over 30 innocent people had been killed by "mentally deranged practitioners of Falun Gong."<ref>, Embassy of the People's Republic of China in the United States, 2005(?)</ref> Li was portrayed as a charlatan, while snapshots of accounting records were shown on television, "purporting to prove that made huge amounts of money off his books and videos."<ref name=wildgrass/> | |||
Ching (2001) states that "evil cult" was defined by an atheist government "on political premises, not by any religious authority", and was used by the authorities to make previous arrests and imprisonments constitutional.<ref name=XIX/> Most social scientists and scholars of religion reject "brainwashing" theories and do not use the term "cult" to describe Falun Gong. Chan claims that Falun Gong is neither a cult nor a sect, but a ] with cult-like characteristics.<ref name=chan2004>Chan, Cheris Shun-ching (2004). The Falun Gong in China: A Sociological Perspective. The China Quarterly, 179 , pp 665-683</ref> Other scholars avoid the term "cult" altogether because "of the confusion between the historic meaning of the term and current pejorative use"<ref name=bainbridge97>Bainbridge, William Sims 1997 The sociology of religious movements, Routledge, 1997, page 24, ISBN 0-415-91202-4</ref><ref name=rich93>Richardson, James T. 1993 "Definitions of Cult: From Sociological-Technical to Popular-Negative", , Review of Religious Research, Vol. 34, No. 4 pp. 348-356</ref> These scholars prefer terms like "spiritual movement" or "new religious movement" to avoid the negative connotations of "cult" or to avoid mis-categorizing Falun Gong as a "cult" if it doesn't fit mainstream definitions.<ref name=frank2004>Frank, Adam. (2004) Falun Gong and the threat of history. in ''Gods, guns, and globalization: religious radicalism and international political economy'' edited by Mary Ann Tétreault, Robert Allen Denemark, Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2004, ISBN 1-58826-253-7, pp 241-243</ref> | |||
Nevertheless, many scholars, including notably Palmer (2007) and Ownby (2008), use the words "moralistic" and "apocalyptic" to describe its philosophy.<ref name=palmer.fever220/> | |||
== References == | |||
*{{cite book |first=Mickey |last=Spiegel |url=http://books.google.ca/books?hl=en&lr=&id=klyC1eH97pQC&oi=fnd&pg=PA1&dq=He+Zuoxiu+%22beijing+television%22&ots=Us-tQbKfPT&sig=5NI1Z1PLT4QuKYm89HmMu23D_1Q#v=onepage&q=isbn&f=false |title=Dangerous Meditation: China's Campaign Against Falungong |publisher=Human Rights Watch |year=2002 |accessdate= 28 December 2009 |isbn=1-56432-269-6}} | |||
* {{cite book |url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=H80YZqSj7EEC&pg=PP1&dq=Jude+Howell+Governance+in+China.#v=onepage&q=After%20seven%20years%20of%20toleration&f=false |title=Governance in China |editor= Jude Howell |first=Clemens Stubbe |last=Østergaard |pages=214–223 (Governance and the Political Challenge of Falun Gong) |year=2003 |isbn=0742519880}} | |||
* {{cite book |url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RXeuibmD2dsC&pg=PA241&dq=%22Falun+Gong+challenges+the+CCP%22&lr=&client=firefox-a#v=onepage&q=&f=false |title=9. Falun Gong challenges the CCP |pages=241–295 |work=Qigong fever: body, science, and utopia in China | |||
|first= David A. |last=Palmer |year=2007 |isbn=0231140665 }} | |||
* {{cite web |url=http://atimes.com/china/CA27Ad01.html |title=Part 1: From sport to suicide |first=Francesco |last=Sisci |work=Asia Times |date=27 January 2001}}; ; | |||
* {{cite journal |url=http://molta.massey.ac.nz/massey/fms/Colleges/College%20of%20Business/Communication%20and%20Journalism/ANZCA%202008/Refereed%20Papers/Kavan_ANZCA08.pdf |title=Falun Gong in the media: What can we believe? |first=Heather |last=Kavan |author=Department of Communication, Journalism and Marketing |work=Massey University |page=13 |journal=E. Tilley (Ed.) Power and Place: Refereed Proceedings of the Australian & New Zealand Communication Association Conference, Wellington. |date=July 2008}} | |||
* {{cite book |url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=v20J18hL1MAC&printsec=frontcover&dq=schechter+falun#v=onepage&q=&f=false |title=Falun Gong's challenge to China: spiritual practice or 'evil cult'? |first=Danny |last=Schechter |date=November 2001 |isbn=1888451270}} | |||
* {{cite book|last=Ownby|first=David|url=http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=Bwqkwx4SWS0C&printsec=frontcover&dq=ownby+falun&client=firefox-a&cd=1#v=onepage&q=&f=false |title=Falun Gong and the future of China|publisher=Oxford University Press|location=New York, NY|year=2008|page=81|isbn=9780195329056}} | |||
== Footnotes == | |||
<!--- This section should only contain items that are referenced in the article. ---> | |||
{{reflist|2}} | |||
<!--- References above this have been verified and placed in order. ---> | |||
== External links == | |||
{{portal|Falun Gong|Falun Gong Logo.svg}} | |||
* | |||
{{Falun Gong}} | {{Falun Gong}} | ||
{{use dmy dates}} | |||
{{DEFAULTSORT:History of Falun Gong}} | {{DEFAULTSORT:History of Falun Gong}} | ||
] | ] | ||
] | |||
] | |||
] |
Latest revision as of 23:53, 6 September 2024
Falun Gong, also called Falun Dafa, is a spiritual practice and system of beliefs that combines the practice of meditation with the moral philosophy articulated by its leader and founder, Li Hongzhi. It emerged on the public radar in the Spring of 1992 in the northeastern Chinese city of Changchun, and was classified as a system of qigong identifying with the Buddhist tradition. Li claimed to have both supernatural powers like the ability to prevent illness, as well having eternal youth and promised that others can attain supernatural powers and eternal youth by following his teachings. Falun Gong initially enjoyed official sanction and support from Chinese government agencies, and the practice grew quickly on account of the simplicity of its exercise movements, impact on health, the absence of fees or formal membership, and moral and philosophical teachings.
In the mid-1990s, however, Falun Gong became estranged from the state-run qigong associations, leading to a gradual escalation of tensions with Chinese Communist Party (CCP) authorities that culminated in the Spring of 1999. Following a protest of 10,000 Falun Gong practitioners near the Zhongnanhai government compound on 25 April 1999 to request official recognition, then-CCP general secretary Jiang Zemin ordered Falun Gong be crushed. A campaign of propaganda, large-scale extrajudicial imprisonment, torture and coercive reeducation ensued.
Falun Gong practitioners have responded to the campaign with protests on Tiananmen Square, the creation of their own media companies overseas, international lawsuits targeting Chinese officials, and the establishment of a network of underground publishing sites to produce literature on the practice within China. Falun Gong has emerged as a prominent voice for an end to one-party rule in China.
Timeline of major events
Before 1992
Falun Gong has been classified variously as a form of spiritual cultivation practice in the tradition of Chinese antiquity, as a qigong discipline, or as a religion or new religious movement. Qigong refers to a broad set of exercises, meditation and breathing methods that have long been part of the spiritual practices of select Buddhist sects, of Daoist alchemists, martial artists, and some Confucian scholars.
Although qigong-like practices have a long history, the modern qigong movement traces its origins only to the late 1940s and 1950s. At that time, CCP cadres began pursuing qigong as a means of improving health, and regarded it as a category of traditional Chinese medicine. With official support from the party-state, qigong grew steadily in popularity, particularly in the period following the Cultural Revolution. The state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985 to administer and oversee qigong practice across the country. Thousands of qigong disciplines emerged, some of them headed by "grandmasters" with millions of adherents
From his youth, Li Hongzhi claims to have been tutored by a variety of Buddhist and Daoist masters, who, according to his spiritual biography, imparted to him the practice methods and moral philosophy that would come to be known as Falun Gong.
- 1951 or 1952 – Falun Gong asserts that Li Hongzhi, founder of Falun Gong, was born on 13 May 1951 in Gongzhuling, Jilin Province. Official Chinese birth dates for Li have been given as 7 or 27 July 1952.
- 1955 – According to his spiritual biography, Li begins learning under the tutelage of master Quan Je, a tenth-generation master of Buddhist cultivation who imparts to Li the principles of Zhen, Shan, Ren (truth, compassion, forbearance). The instruction lasts eight years.
- 1963 – According to his spiritual biography, Daoist master Baji Zhenren begins training Li in Daoist martial arts disciplines and physical skills training.
- 1970 – Li begins working at a military horse farm in northeast China, and in 1972 works as a trumpet player with a division of the provincial forestry police.
- 1972 – Li continues his spiritual training under the instruction of a master Zhen Daozhi, who imparts methods of internal cultivation. According to Li's spiritual biography, his training in this period mostly took place under cover of night, possibly due to the political environment of the Cultural Revolution.
- 1974 – Li's biography states that he begins studying the instruction of a female Buddhist master. Throughout the next several years, Li continued his studies and observations of spiritual cultivation systems.
- Early 1980s – Having had his middle and high school education interrupted by the Cultural Revolution, Li completes his high school education via correspondence courses.
- 1984 – According to his spiritual biography, to Li creates Falun Gong with his masters as a more accessible version of Falun Fofa, based on other qigong.
- Mid-1980s – Li begins studying and observing a variety of other qigong disciplines, apparently in preparation for establishing and publicizing his own qigong system.
- 1985 – Chinese authorities create a national organization to oversee the great variety of qigong disciplines that were proliferating across the country. The China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985, and convened its first meeting in Beijing in 1986. The organization counted among its leadership several eminent members and former members of the Politburo and National People's Congress, as well as former ministers of health and education.
- 1989 – Li begins private instruction of Falun Gong to select students.
1992–1995
Falun Gong was publicly founded in the Spring of 1992, toward the end of China's "qigong boom," a period which saw the proliferation of thousands of disciplines. Li Hongzhi and his Falun Gong became an "instant star" of the qigong movement, and were welcomed into the government-administered China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS). From 1992 to 1994, Li traveled throughout China giving 54 lecture seminars on the practice and beliefs of Falun Gong. Seminars typically lasted 8–10 days, and attracted as many as 6,000 participants per class. The practice grew rapidly based on its purported efficacy in improving health and its moral and philosophical elements, which were more developed than those of other qigong schools.
- 1992 – On 13 May, Li begins public teaching of Falun Gong at the No. 5 Middle School in Changchun, Jilin Province, lecturing to a crowd of several hundred. The seminar ran for nine days at a cost of 30 Yuan per person.
- 1992 – June, Li is invited by the China Qigong Scientific Research Society to lecture in Beijing.
- 1992 – In September, Falun Gong is recognized as a qigong branch under the administration of the state-run China Qigong Scientific Research Society (CQRS).
- 1992 – Li is formally declared a "Master of Qigong" by the CQRS, and received a permit to teach nationwide.
- 1992 – Li and several Falun Gong students participate in the 1992 Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 12 to 21 December. The organizer of the health fair remarked that Falun Gong and Li "received the most praise at the fair, and achieved very good therapeutic results." The event helped cement Li's popularity in the qigong world, and journalistic reports of Falun Gong's healing powers spread.
- 1992 – By the end of the year, Li had given five week-long lecture seminars in Beijing, four in Changchun, one in Tayuan, and one in Shandong.
- 1993 – China Falun Gong (中国法轮功), the first major instructional text by Li Hongzhi, is published by Military Yiwen Press in April. The book sets forth an explanation of Falun Gong's basic cosmology, moral system, and exercises. A revised edition is released in December of the same year.
- 1993 – In the spring and summer of 1993, a series of glowing article appear in Qigong magazines nationwide lauding the benefits of Falun Gong. Several feature images of Li Hongzhi on the cover, and asserting the superiority of the Falun Gong system.
- 1993 – The Falun Xiulian Dafa Research Society is established as a branch of the CQRS on 30 July.
- 1993 – In August, an organization under Ministry of Public Security sends a letter to the CQRS thanking Li Hongzhi for providing his teachings to police officers injured in the line of duty. The letter claimed that of the 100 officers treated by Li, only one failed to experience "obvious improvement" to their health.
- 1993 – On Sept 21, The People's Public Security Daily, a publication of the Ministry of Public Security, commends Falun Gong for "promoting the traditional crime-fighting virtues of the Chinese people, in safeguarding social order and security, and in promoting rectitude in society."
- 1993 – Li again participates in the Asian Health Expo in Beijing from 11 to 20 Dec, this time as a member of the organizing committee. He wins several awards at the event, and is proclaimed the "Most Acclaimed Qigong Master." Falun Gong also received the "Special Gold Award" and award for "Advancing Frontier Science."
- 1994 – The Jilin Province Qigong Science Research Association proclaims Li Hongzhi a "Grandmaster of Qigong" on 6 May.
- 1994 – Li gives two lectures on Falun Gong at the Public Security University in Beijing, and contributes profits from the seminars to a foundation for injured police officers.
- 1994 – On 3 August, the City of Houston, Texas, declares Li Hongzhi an honorary citizen for his "unselfish public service for the benefit and welfare of mankind."
- 1994 – As revenues from the sale of his publications grew, Li ceased to charge fees for his classes, and thereafter insists that Falun Gong must be taught free of charge.
- 1994 – The last full seminar on Falun Gong practice and philosophy takes place from 21 to 29 December in the southern city of Guangzhou.
- 1995 – Zhuan Falun (转法轮), the complete teachings of Falun Gong, is published in January by the China Television Broadcasting Agency Publishing Company. A publication ceremony is held in the Ministry of Public Security auditorium on 4 January.
- 1995 – In February, Li is approached by the Chinese National Sports Committee, Ministry of Public Health, and China Qigong Science Research Association to jointly establish a Falun Gong association. Li declines the offer.
- 1995 – Official attitudes towards the Qigong movement within some segments of the government begin to change, as criticisms of qigong begin appearing in the state-run press.
- 1995 – Li leaves China and begins spreading his practice overseas.
- 1995 – At the invitation of the Chinese embassy in Paris, Li begins teaching Falun Gong abroad. On 13 March, he gives a seven-day class in Paris, followed by another lecture series in Sweden in April (Gothenburg, Stockholm and Uddevalla).
1996–June 1999
Having announced that he was finished teaching his practice in China, Li Hongzhi begins teaching his practice in Europe, Oceania, North America and Southeast Asia. In 1998, Li relocates permanently to the United States.
As the practice continues to grow within China, tensions emerge between Falun Gong and Chinese authorities. In 1996, Falun Gong withdraws from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society, and thereafter finds itself the subject of growing scrutiny and criticism in the state-run press. The practice becomes a subject of high-level debates within the government and CCP, with some ministries and government authorities expressing continued support for the practice, and others becoming increasingly wary of the group. This tension also played out in the media, as some outlets continued to laud the effects of Falun Gong, while others criticized it as pseudoscience.
Tensions continue to escalate over this period, culminating in a demonstration on 25 April 1999 near the Zhongnanhai government compound, where over ten thousand Falun Gong practitioners gather to request official recognition. Following the event, Jiang Zemin, then-CCP general secretary, quietly prepares for the launch of a nationwide campaign to persecute the practice.
- 1996 – The book Zhuan Falun is listed as a bestseller by Beijing Youth Daily (北京青年报) in January, March, and April.
- 1996 – Falun Gong files for withdrawal from the China Qigong Scientific Research Society in March. Li later explains that he had found the state-run CQRS to be more concerned with profiting from qigong than engaging in genuine research. Li had also apparently rejected a new CQRS policy that mandated that all qigong practices create CCP branches within their organizations. Falun Gong is left entirely without government oversight or sanction.
- 1996 – At Li's direction, administrators of the Falun Gong Research Association of China apply for registration with three other government organizations, including the Buddhist Association of China and United Front Work Department. All applications are ultimately denied.
- 1996 – The first major state-run media article criticizing Falun Gong appears in the Guangming Daily newspaper on 17 June. The article writes that Falun Gong represents a manifestation of feudal superstition, and that its core text Zhuan Falun is a work of "pseudo-science" that swindles the masses. Falun Gong practitioners responded to the article's publication with a letter-writing campaign to the newspaper and national qigong association.
- 1996 – Several Buddhist journals and magazines start to write articles criticizing Falun Gong as a "heretical sect".
- 1996 – On 24 July, Falun Gong books are banned from further publication by the China News Publishing Bureau, a branch of the CCP Central Propaganda Department. The reason cited for the ban is that Falun Gong is "spreading superstition." Pirated and copied versions of Falun Gong books proliferate, with Li Hongzhi's approval.
- 1996 – Li begins another international lecture tour in the summer of 1996, traveling to Hong Kong, Sydney, Bangkok, Houston, New York, and Beijing.
- 1996 – The China Qigong Scientific Research Society issues a resolution on the cancellation of Falun Gong's membership with the society. The resolution stated that although practitioners of Falun Gong had "attained unparalleled results in terms of fitness and disease prevention," Li Hongzhi "propagated theology and superstition," failed to attend association meetings, and departed from the association's procedures.
- 1997 – The Ministry of Public Security launches an investigation into whether Falun Gong should be deemed xie jiao ("heretical religion"). The report concludes that "no evidence has appeared thus far."
- 1997–1999 – Criticism of Falun Gong escalates in state-run media. With the encouragement of Li, Falun Gong practitioners respond to criticisms by peacefully petitioning outside media offices seeking redress against perceived unfair reporting. The tactic succeeds frequently, often resulting in the retraction of critical articles and apologies from the news organizations. Not all media coverage was negative in this period, however, and articles continued to appear highlighting Falun Gong's health benefits.
- 1998 - On 13 January, the China Buddhist Association held a meeting on how to react to Falun Gong.
- 1998 – On 21 July, the Ministry of Public Security issues Document No. 555, "Notice of the Investigation of Falun Gong." The document asserts that Falun Gong is an "evil religion," and mandates that another investigation be launched to seek evidence of the conclusion. The faction hostile toward Falun Gong within the ministry was reportedly led by Luo Gan. Security agencies began monitoring and collecting personal information on practitioners; Falun Gong sources reported authorities were tapping phone lines, harassing and tailing practitioners, ransacking homes, and closing down Falun Gong meditation sessions.
- 1998 – According to Falun Gong sources, Qiao Shi, the former Chairman of the National People's Congress, lead his own investigation into Falun Gong and concluded that "Falun Gong has hundreds of benefits for the Chinese people and China, and does not have one single bad effect."
- 1998 – China's National Sports Commission launches its own investigation in May, and commissions medical professionals to conduct interviews of over 12,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Guangdong province. 97.9 percent of respondents say Falun Gong improved their health. By October the investigation concludes, noting "We're convinced the exercises and effects of Falun Gong are excellent. It has done an extraordinary amount to improve society's stability and ethics. This should be duly affirmed."
- 1998 – Estimates provided by the State Sports Commission suggest there are upwards of 60 to 70 million Falun Gong practitioners in China.
- 1999 – Li Hongzhi continues to teach Falun Gong internationally, with occasional stops in China. By early 1999, Li had lectured in Sydney, Bangkok, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Hong Kong, Taipei, Frankfurt, Toronto, Singapore, Geneva, Houston and New York, as well as in Changchun and Beijing.
- 1999 – Wu Shaozu, An official from China's National Sports Commission, says in an interview with U.S. News & World Report on 14 February that as many as 100 million may have taken up Falun Gong and other forms of qigong. Wu notes that the popularity of Falun Gong dramatically reduces health care costs, and "Premier Zhu Rongji is very happy about that."
- 1999 – In April, physicist He Zuoxiu from the Chinese Academy of Sciences publishes an article in Tianjin Normal University's Youth Reader magazine criticizing Falun Gong as superstitious and potentially harmful for youth and stating that he knew someone who died because of it. At that time, some countries near China had people practicing, like Vietnam.
- 1999 – Tianjin Falun Gong practitioners respond to the article by peacefully petitioning in front of the editorial offices. Editors initially agree to publish a retraction of the He Zuoxiu article, then renege.
- 1999 – On 23 April, some 300 security forces are called in to break up ongoing Falun Gong demonstration. Forty-five Falun Gong practitioners are beaten and detained.
- 1999 – Falun Gong practitioners petition Tianjin City Hall for the release of the detained practitioners. They are reportedly told that the order to break up the crowd and detain protesters came from central authorities in Beijing, and that further appeals should be directed at Beijing.
- 1999 – On 25 April 10,000–20,000 Falun Gong practitioners quietly assemble outside the Central Appeals Office, adjacent to the Zhongnanhai leadership compound in Beijing. Five Falun Gong representatives meet with Premier Zhu Rongji to request official recognition and an end to escalating harassment against the group. Zhu agrees to release the Tianjin practitioners, and assures the representatives that the government does not oppose Falun Gong. The same day, however, at the urging of Luo Gan, CCP general secretary Jiang Zemin issues a letter stating his intention to suppress the practice.
- 1999 – On 26 April, Jiang Zemin convenes a meeting of the Politburo Standing Committee to discuss the Falun Gong demonstration. Some Politburo members reportedly favored a conciliatory position towards Falun Gong, while others – such as Jiang and security czar Luo Gan – favored a decisive suppression of the group.
- 1999 – Authorities increased surveillance on Falun Gong, tapping telephones of practitioners and monitoring practitioners in several cities.
- 1999 – On 2 May, Li Hongzhi gives a press conference to journalists in Sydney, Australia. When asked by a reporter whether he believed the government would kill or imprison his disciples to maintain social order, Li responded that " practitioners will never go against the law. In terms of the scenario you describe, I don't think it will happen. since the economic reform and opening up, the Chinese government has been quite tolerant in this respect."
- 1999 – In May and June, just as preparations are quietly underway for a crackdown, Falun Gong practitioners continue their public meditation sessions. The Far Eastern Economic Review wrote "in a park in western Beijing, 100 or so Falun Gong practitioners exercised under a bold yellow banner proclaiming their affiliation... far from running scared."
- 1999 – On 2 June, Li purchases space in several Hong Kong newspapers to publish an article defending Falun Gong, and urging Chinese leaders not to "risk universal condemnation" and "waste manpower and capital" by antagonizing the group.
- 1999 – On 3 June, 70,000 practitioners from Jilin and Liaoning travel to Beijing in an attempt to appeal to authorities. They were intercepted by security forces, sent home, and placed under surveillance.
- 1999 – On 7 June 1999, Jiang Zemin convened a meeting of the Politburo to address the Falun Gong issue. In the meeting, Jiang described Falun Gong as a grave threat to CCP authority – "something unprecedented in the country since its founding 50 years ago" – and ordered the creation of a special leading group within the party's Central Committee to "get fully prepared for the work of disintegrating ."
- 1999 – On 10 June, the 6-10 Office was formed to handle day-to-day coordination of the anti-Falun Gong campaign. Luo Gan was selected to helm of the office, whose mission at the time was described as studying, investigating, and developing a "unified approach...to resolve the Falun Gong problem" The office was not created with any legislation, and there are no provisions describing its precise mandate.
- 1999 – On 17 June 1999, On 17 June, Jiang Zemin declared in a Politburo meeting that Falun Gong is "the most serious political incident since the '4 June' political disturbance in 1989." The 610 Office came under the newly created Central Leading Group for Dealing with Falun Gong, headed by Li Lanqing. Both Li and Luo were members of the Politburo Standing Committee, and the four other deputy directors of the Central Leading Group also held high-level positions in the CCP, including minister of the propaganda department.
- 1999 – On 26 June, thirteen Falun Gong exercise sites in public parks are shut down by Beijing security officials.
July 1999–2001
In July 1999, a nationwide campaign is rolled out to "eradicate" Falun Gong. The persecution campaign is characterized by a "massive propaganda campaign" against the group, public burnings of Falun Gong books, and imprisonment of tens of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners in prisons, reeducation through labor camps, psychiatric hospitals and other detention facilities. Authorities are given the broad mandate of 'transforming' practitioners, resulting in the widespread use of torture against Falun Gong practitioners, sometimes resulting in death.
From late 1999 to early 2001, hundreds of Falun Gong practitioners per day travel to Tiananmen Square to stage peaceful protests against the persecution. The protests take the form of performing Falun Gong exercises or meditation, or holding banner proclaiming Falun Gong's innocence. The protests are broken up, often violently, by security forces.
- 1999 – During a 19 July meeting of senior CCP cadres, Jiang Zemin's decision to eradicate Falun Gong was announced. The campaign was originally intended to have begun on 21 July, but as the document was apparently leaked, the crackdown started on 20 July. A nationwide propaganda campaign is launched to discredit Falun Gong.
- 1999 – Just after midnight on 20 July, Falun Gong practitioners and "assistants" are abducted and detained across numerous cities in China. In response, tens of thousands of practitioners petition local, provincial and central appeals offices. In Beijing and other cities, protesters are detained in sports stadiums.
- 1999 – On 22 July, The Ministry of Civil Affairs declared the "Research Society of Falun Dafa and the Falun Gong organization under its control" to be unregistered, and therefore illegal, organizations. The same day, the Ministry of Public Security issues a notice prohibiting 1) the display of Falun Gong images or symbols; 2) the public distribution of Falun Gong books or literature; 3) assembling to perform group Falun Gong exercises; 4)using sit-ins, petitions, and other demonstrations in defense of Falun Gong; 5) the spreading of rumors meant to disturb social order; and 6) taking part in activities opposing the government's decision.
- 1999 – The 19 July circular is released publicly on 23 July. In it, Falun Gong is declared the "most serious political incident" since 1989. The Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party forbids party members from practicing Falun Gong, and launches study sessions to ensure cadres understand that Falun Gong is incompatible with the belief system of Marxism.
- 1999 – on 26 July, the authorities begin the process of confiscating and destroying all publications related to Falun Gong, including "books, pictures, audio-video products, and electronic publications." Within one week, two million copies of Falun Gong literature are confiscated and destroyed by steam-rollers and public book burning.
- 1999 – In late July, overseas Falun Gong websites are hacked or subject to denial-of-service attack. According to Chinese internet expert Ethan Gutmann, the attacks originated from servers in Beijing and Shenzhen, and was among the first serious attempts at network disruption by China.
- 1999 – 29 July, Chinese authorities ask Interpol to seek the arrest of Li Hongzhi. Interpol declines. The following week, Chinese authorities offer a substantial cash reward for the extradition of Li from the United States. The U.S. government similarly declines to follow up.
- 1999 – On 29 July, the Beijing Bureau of Justice issues a notice requiring all lawyers and law firms to obtain approval before providing consultation or representation to Falun Gong practitioners. According to Human Rights Watch, the notice was "inconsistent with international standards which call on governments to ensure that lawyers are able to perform their professional functions without intimidating hindrance, harassment, or improper interference."
- 1999 – In October, 30 Falun Gong practitioners hold a secret press conference for foreign media in Beijing to tell of the violence and persecution they are suffering. At the end of the press briefing, participants are arrested, and some of the foreign reporters present are questioned and briefly detained. Ten of the organizers were detained almost immediately afterwards, and one of them, a 31-year-old hairdresser names Ding Yan, is later tortured to death in custody, according to Falun Gong sources. During the press conference, some of the first allegations of Falun Gong torture deaths in custody are made.
- 1999 – On 30 October, the National People's Congress of the People's Republic of China issues a resolution on article 300 of the criminal code. The resolution elaborates on the identification and punishments for individuals who use "heretical religions" to undermine the implementation of the law.
- 1999 – On 5 November 1999, the Supreme People's Court of the People's Republic of China issues a circular giving instruction to the people's courts that Falun Gong should be prosecuted as a 'heretical religion' under article 300. The notice, sent to all local courts in China, stressed that it was their political duty to severely punish Falun Gong, and to handle these cases under the leadership of the Party committees.
- 1999 – On 27 December, four high-profile Falun Gong practitioners are put on trial for "undermining the implementation of the law" and illegally obtaining state secrets. They include Beijing engineer and prominent Falun Gong organizer Zhiwen Wang, sentenced to 16 years in prison, and Li Chang, an official of the Ministry of Public Security, sentenced to 18 years. According to Amnesty International, in these prosecutions and others, "the judicial process was biased against the defendants at the outset and the trials were a mere formality."
- 2000 – During Lunar New Year celebrations in early February, at least 2,000 Falun Gong practitioners are detained on Tiananmen Square while attempting to peacefully protest the ban against the group.
- 2000 – On 20 April, Wall Street Journal reporter Ian Johnson publishes the first article in a series on Falun Gong. The article details the torture death of 58-year-old grandmother in Weifang city, who was beaten, shocked, and forced to run barefoot through the snow because she refused to denounce Falun Gong. Johnson went on to win the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for International Reporting for the series.
- 2000 – On 21 April, Xinhua News Agency admits for the first time the difficulty the Central authorities have had in stamping out Falun Gong, noting that since "22 July 1999, Falun Gong members have been causing trouble on and around Tiananmen Square in Central Beijing nearly every day."
- 2000 – Zhao Ming, a graduate student at Ireland's Trinity College, is sent to the Tuanhe forced labor camp in Beijing in May. He spends two years in the camp amidst international pressure for his release, and is reportedly tortured with electric batons.
- 2000 – On 1 October, thousands of Falun Gong practitioners travel to Tiananmen Square to stage protests against the persecution. Foreign media correspondents witness security officers beating and practitioners on the square.
- 2000 – In November, Zhang Kunlun, a Canadian citizen and professor of art, is detained while visiting his mother in China and held in a forced labor camp where he reported being beaten and shocked with electric batons. Canadian politicians intervene on his behalf, eventually winning his release to Canada.
- 2001 – On 23 January, five individuals set themselves on fire on Tiananmen Square. State-run media claim they are Falun Gong practitioners, driven to suicide by the practice. Falun Gong sources deny involvement, saying that Falun Gong forbids suicide and violence, and arguing that the event was staged by the government to turn public opinion against the practice. Authorities seize on the event to escalate a media campaign against the group, and support for Falun Gong wanes.
- 2001 – As sympathy for Falun Gong erodes in Mainland China, authorities for the first time openly sanction the "systematic use of violence" against the group, establishing a network of brainwashing classes and rooting out Falun Gong practitioners "neighborhood by neighborhood and workplace by workplace."
- 2001 – By February, international concern grows over psychiatric abuses committed against Falun Gong practitioners, several hundred of whom had reportedly been held and tortured in psychiatric facilities for refusing to denounce the practice.
- 2001 – On 20 November, a group of 35 Falun Gong practitioners from 12 different countries gathers on Tiananmen Square to meditate under a banner that reads: "Truth, Compassion, Tolerance" – Falun Gong's core moral tenets. They are arrested within minutes, and some are beaten while resisting arrest.
- 2001 – On 23 December, a New York District Court hands down a default judgement against Zhao Zhifei, Public Security Bureau chief for Hubei Province, for his role in the wrongful death and torture of Falun Gong practitioners.
2002–2004
By 2002, Falun Gong practitioners had all but completely abandoned the approach of protesting on Tiananmen Square, and coverage in Western news outlets declined precipitously.
Falun Gong practitioners continued adopting more novel approaches to protesting, including the establishment of a vast network of underground 'material sites' that create and distribute literature, and tapping into television broadcasts to replace them with Falun Gong content. Practitioners outside China established a television station to broadcast into China, designed censorship-circumvention tools to break through Internet censorship and surveillance, and filed dozens of largely symbolic lawsuits against Jiang Zemin and other Chinese officials alleging genocide and crimes against humanity.
From 2002 to 2004, the paramount position of power in China were transferred from Jiang Zemin to Hu Jintao. Annual Falun Gong deaths in custody continued to grow through 2004, according to reports published by Falun Gong sources, but coverage of Falun Gong declined over the period.
- 2002 – On 14 February, 53 Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia attempt to stage a demonstration on Tiananmen Square. They are detained, and several reportedly assaulted by security forces before being expelled from China.
- 2002 – On 5 March, a group of six Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun city intercept television broadcasts, replacing them with content about Falun Gong and the persecution. Apparently believing that it to be a signal that the ban on Falun Gong had been lifted, citizens gather in public squares to celebrate. The Falun Gong broadcasts run for 50 minutes before the city goes black. Over the next three days, security forces arrest some 5,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun. Amnesty International reports that "police 'stop-and-search' checkpoints have reportedly been established across the city." All six individuals involved in the television hijacking are later tortured to death.
- 2002 – In June, Jiang Zemin visits Iceland. Dozens of Falun Gong practitioners from around the world attempt to travel to the country to protest, but find their names on an international blacklist organized at the behest of Chinese authorities, suggesting extensive espionage against foreign Falun Gong practitioners.
- 2002 – Falun Gong practitioners in New York establish New Tang Dynasty Television, a Chinese-language station created to present an alternative to state-run Chinese media.
- 2002 – On 24 July, U.S. House of Representatives passes a unanimous resolution (House Concurrent Resolution 188) condemning the persecution of Falun Gong in China.
- 2002 – On 21 October, Falun Gong practitioners from North America, Europe and Australia file a legal case against Jiang Zemin, Zeng Qinghong, and Luo Gan to the United Nations Human Rights Committee and the International Criminal Court for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong.
- 2002 – In November, Hu Jintao begins the process of taking over China's leadership from Jiang Zemin, assuming the position General Secretary of the CCP.
- 2003 – On 22 January, Falun Gong practitioner and American citizen Dr. Charles Lee is arrested by security forces in Nanjing immediately upon his arrival in China. Lee is sentenced to three years in prison.
- 2003 – On 1 May, Pan Xinchun, Deputy Consul General at the Chinese consulate in Toronto, published a letter in the Toronto Star in which he said that local Falun Gong practitioner Joel Chipkar is a member of a "sinister cult." In February 2004, the Ontario Superior Court found Pan liable for libel, and demanded he pay $10,000 in compensation to Chipkar. Pan refused to pay, and left Canada.
- 2003 – June, A San Francisco District Court issues a default ruling against Beijing Party Secretary and former Beijing Mayor Liu Qi and Deputy Governor of Liaoning Province Xia Deren, who had been accused of overseeing the torture of Falun Gong practitioners.
- 2003 – On 26 December, Liu Chengjun, one of the leaders behind the Changchun television broadcasts, is tortured to death while serving out a 19-year prison sentence.
- 2004 – In October, U.S. House of Representatives passed a unanimous resolution detailing and condemning the Chinese government's attempts to interfere with and intimidate Falun Gong practitioners in the United States.
- 2004 – In December, prominent Weiquan lawyer Gao Zhisheng writes to the National People's Congress detailing torture and sexual abuse against Falun Gong practitioners in custody. In response to his letter, Gao's law firm is shut down, his legal license is revoked, and he is put under house arrest.
2005–2007
As Falun Gong becomes more overt in its rhetorical charges against CCP rule, allegations emerge that Chinese security agencies engage in large-scale overseas spying operations against Falun Gong practitioners, and that Falun Gong prisoners in China are killed to supply China's organ transplant industry.
- 2005 – On 15 February, Li Hongzhi issues a statement renouncing his earlier membership in the Communist Youth League.
- 2005 – On 4 June, Chinese diplomat Chen Yonglin, a political consul at the Chinese consulate in Sydney, defects to Australia. He reports that a large part of his job was to monitor and harass Falun Gong practitioners in Australia. Days later, on 8 June, Hao Fengjun, a former member of the Tianjin city 610 office, goes public with his story of defection, and tells of abuse against Falun Gong in China.
- 2005 – On 16 June, Gao Rongrong is reported tortured to death in Shenyang at the age of 37.
- 2005 – In June, the number of Falun Gong practitioners allegedly killed as a result or torture and abuse in custody exceeds 2,500.
- 2006 – UN special rapporteur on torture Manfred Nowak releases the findings of his 2005 investigation on torture in China. He reports that two-thirds of reported torture cases are against Falun Gong practitioners.
- 2006 – In July 2006, former Canadian Member of Parliament David Kilgour and international human rights attorney David Matas release the findings of their investigation into allegations of organ harvesting. Although their evidence was largely circumstantial, they conclude that involuntary organ extractions from Falun Gong practitioners are widespread and ongoing. Chinese officials deny the allegations.
- 2006 – Falun Gong practitioners in the United States establish Shen Yun Performing Arts, a classical Chinese dance company that begins touring internationally in 2007.
- 2007 – Falun Gong sources report that the number of persecution deaths exceeds 3,000.
- 2007 – August, practitioners of Falun Gong launch the Human Rights Torch Relay, which toured to over 35 of countries in 2007 and 2008 ahead of the 2008 Beijing Olympics. The relay was intended to draw attention to a range of human rights issues in China in connection with the Olympics, especially those related to Falun Gong and Tibet, and received support from hundreds of elected officials, past Olympic medallists, human rights groups and other concerned organizations.
2008–2014
Top-level Chinese authorities continue to launch strike-hard campaigns against Falun Gong surrounding sensitive events and anniversaries, and step up efforts to coercively "transform" Falun Gong practitioners in detention facilities and reeducation centers. Lawyers who seek to represent Falun Gong defendants continue to face punishment from Chinese authorities, including harassment, disbarment, and imprisonment.
- 2008 – On 6 February, popular folk musician Yu Zhou is tortured to death 11 days after being taken into custody in Beijing. His wife, artist Xu Na, is sentenced to 3 years in prison for possessing Falun Gong literature.
- 2008 – In the first six months of the year, over 8,000 Falun Gong practitioners are abducted by security forces under the pretext of preventing protests during the Beijing Olympics.
- 2009 – CCP heir apparent Xi Jinping is put in charge of 6521 Project, a strike hard effort to crack down on Tibetans, democracy activists and Falun Gong practitioners around sensitive anniversaries. Zhou Yongkang heads a parallel effort to crack down on Falun Gong practitioners, ethnic separatism, and protests.
- 2009 – In March, U.S. House of Representatives passes a resolution on recognizing and condemning the ongoing persecution of Falun Gong in China.
- 2009 – On 13 May, Weiquan lawyers Zhang Kai(张凯) and Li Chunfu(李春富) are violently beaten and detained in Chongqing for investigating the death of Jiang Xiqing(江锡清), a 66-year-old Falun Gong practitioner killed in a labor camp.
- 2009 – On 4 July, Dalian city lawyer Wang Yonghang(王永航) is taken from his home by security agents, interrogated, and beaten for defending Falun Gong practitioners. In November 2009, Wang was sentenced in a closed court to seven years in prison for his advocacy on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners. When his lawyers were permitted to see him in January 2010, they reported that he had been tortured.
- 2009 – In November, Jiang Zemin and other high-ranking Chinese officials are indicted by a Spanish court on charges of genocide and crimes against humanity for their involvement in the persecution of Falun Gong. A month later, an Argentine judge concludes that top Chinese officials Jiang Zemin and Luo Gan had adopted a "genocidal strategy" in pursuing the eradication of Falun Gong, and asks Interpol to seek their arrest
- 2010 – Over 100 Falun Gong practitioners in Shanghai are abducted and detained in connection with the Shanghai World Expo. Some reportedly face torture for their refusal to disavow Falun Gong.
- 2010 – In the Spring of 2010, Chinese authorities launch a new, three-year campaign whose goal is to coercively transform large portions of the known Falun Gong population through attendance in reeducation classes.
- 2010 – On 22 April 2010, Beijing lawyers Liu Wei and Tang Jitian were permanently disbarred for defending Falun Gong practitioners.
- 2011 – In February, a Falun Gong practitioner named Qin Yueming dies in custody at the Jiamusi Prison. His family state that his body was covered with extensive bruising, with blood in his nose, though authorities said the cause of death was heart attack. A petition seeking redress for his death garners over 15,000 signatures. Qin's wife and daughter are subsequently imprisoned and reportedly tortured for their efforts to draw attention to the case.
- 2011 – In May, a lawsuit is filed on behalf of Falun Gong practitioners against Cisco. The suit alleges, based mainly on internal Cisco documents, that the technology company "designed and implemented a surveillance system for the Chinese Communist Party, knowing it would be used to root out members of the Falun Gong religion and subject them to detention, forced labor and torture."
- 2011 – In Hebei province, 3,000 Chinese citizens sign a petition calling for the release of detained Falungong practitioners Zhou Xiangyang and Li Shanshan, who were being held at the Gangbei Prison and Tangshan reeducation center, respectively.
- 2012 – In June 2012, 15,000 people in Heilongjiang Province signed and affixed their fingerprints to a petition requesting that the government investigate the death of Qin Yueming, a Falun Gong practitioner who died in custody.
- 2012 – In early June, Falun Gong practitioner Li Lankui was detained and sent to a reeducation-through-labour camp in Hebei province. Hundreds of villagers mobilized to call for Li's release, including by signing petitions calling for an end to the persecution of Falun Gong. This prompted further crackdowns by security agents, leading to the arrest of at least 16 villagers. Some reported that they were tortured for expressing their support for Li Lankui.
- 2012 – in December, a woman in Oregon finds a letter written in both Chinese and English in a box of Halloween decorations purchased from Kmart. The letter said that the decorations were assembled in Unit 8, Department 2 of Masanjia forced labour camp. It went on to describe forced labor conditions in the camp, and noted that many of the detainees were Falun Gong practitioners being held without trial. The letter's author, a Falun Gong practitioner from Beijing, was later identified by The New York Times.
- 2013 – Central 610 Office authorities launch a new three-year campaign calling for the ideological "transformation" of Falun Gong practitioners. Local governments issue quotas and targets for the number of Falun Gong practitioners to reeducate, and prescribe the appropriate means for doing so.
- 2013 – A photojournalism magazine in China publishes an exposé detailing human rights abuses committed by female detainees at the Masanjia forced labour camp in Shenyang, where Falun Gong practitioners were estimated to comprise approximately half the detainees. The article was promptly removed from the magazine's website, but not before galvanizing nationwide opposition to and condemnation of the labor camp system. Soon thereafter, New York Times photographer Du Bin releases a documentary on the Masanjia labor camp.
- 2013 – Chinese officials begin dismantling the nationwide network of reeducation-through-labour camps, in which Falun Gong practitioners comprised a significant portion of detainees. Human rights groups expressed skepticism at the scope of reforms, however, noting that other forms of extralegal detention were still being used to detain Falun Gong practitioners and political dissidents.
- 2013 – On 12 December, European Parliament adopts a resolution on organ harvesting in China, where it "Calls for the EU and its Member States to raise the issue of organ harvesting in China"
- 2014 – In August, investigative journalist Ethan Gutmann publishes his book "The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem," in which he writes that large number of Falun Gong practitioners and ethnic Uyghurs have been killed for their organs in China.
- 2014 – Four lawyers in Northeast China are detained and reportedly tortured by the police while investigating abuses against Falun Gong practitioners held at the Qinglongshan farm reeducation centre.
References
- Yoffe, Emily (10 August 2001). "The Gong Show". Slate. ISSN 1091-2339. Retrieved 13 February 2023.
- "Were human organs stolen in 20-year conflict between Beijing and Falun Gong?". RFI. 25 April 2019. Retrieved 13 February 2023.
- ^ David Ownby, Falun Gong and the Future of China (2008) Oxford University Press, p. 89.
- ^ Benjamin Penny, The Religion of Falun Gong, (University of Chicago Press, 2012.
- ^ David Palmer. Qigong Fever: Body, Science and Utopia in China. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2007
- Kenneth S. Cohen, "The Way of Qigong: The Art and Science of Chinese Energy Healing" (Random House, Inc., 1999)
- Zhu Xiaoyang and Benjamin Penny (ed.), "The Qigong Boom," Chinese Sociology and Anthropology, Vol. 27, No. 1 (1994)
- ^ Benjamin Penny, "The Life and Times of Li Hongzhi: Falun Gong and Religious Biography," The China Quarterly, Vol. 175 (2003), pp. 643–661. Hosted by the Friedrich Ebert Foundation. Available at Cambridge University Databases. Available at JSTOR.
- Benjamin Penny, Qigong boom, pp. 13–20.
- ^ Zeng, Jennifer. Witnessing history: one Chinese woman's fight for freedom, Soho Press, 2006, pp. 329–335
- David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306
- ^ Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China: Spiritual Practice of "Evil Cult"? (New York: Akashic Books, 2000), pp. 42.
- Scott Lowe, Chinese and InternationalContexts for the Rise of Falun Gong. Nova Religio 6 (2 April 2003)
- ^ Noah Porter, "Falun Gong in the United States: An Ethnographic Study," 2003, p. 70
- David Ownby, "The Falun Gong in the New World," European Journal of East Asian Studies, Sep 2003, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p. 306.
- ^ Falun Dafa Information Center, "Overview of Falun Gong," Archived 2 May 2017 at the Wayback Machine accessed 24 November 2010
- James Tong (2002), p. 670.
- ^ James Tong, Revenge of the Forbidden City, Oxford University Press (2009).
- Danny Schechter, Falun Gong's Challenge to China, p. 66.
- Palmer 2007, p. 248
- Palmer 2007, p. 249
- Palmer 2007, p. 262
- Palmer 2007, p. 180
- ^ Palmer 2007, p. 265
- Seth Faison, "In Beijing: A Roar of Silent Protestors," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Joseph Kahn, "Notoriety Now for Movement's Leader," New York Times, 27 April 1999; Renee Schoff, "Growing group poses a dilemma for China," Associated Press, 26 April 1999.
- "An opiate of the masses?," U.S. News & World Report, 22 February 1999.
- Phillip Adams, Media and Internet Censorship in China, Late Night Live, Radio National Australia
- Palmer 2007, p. 266
- "Trang chủ | Việt Nam | Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công". Trang chủ | Việt Nam | Sự thật môi trường Pháp Luân Công. Retrieved 30 August 2018.
- Palmer 2007, pp. 266-267
- ^ Ethan Gutmann, An Occurrence on Fuyou Street, National Review 13 July 2009
- ^ Schechter (2000), p.69
- Tong (2009), pp. 3–10
- ^ Zong Hairen, Zhu Rongji in 1999, (Ming Jing, 2001), pp. 60–61.
- Susan V. Lawrence, "Religion: Pilgrim's Protest," Far Eastern Economic Review, 13 May 1999.
- Li Hongzhi, 'Some Thoughts of Mine', 2 June 1999.
- Sing Tao Jih Pao, "Police Break Up Falun Gong Gathering of 70,000 in Beijing," 7 June 1999.
- ^ Sarah Cook and Leeshai Lemish, 'The 610 Office:Policing the Chinese Spirit', China Brief, Volume 11 Issue 17 (9 November 2011).
- Tong 2009, p. 44
- ^ Spiegel, Mickey (2002). Dangerous Meditation: China's Campaign Against Falungong. Human Rights Watch. ISBN 1-56432-270-X. Retrieved 28 September 2007.
- Ethan Gutmann, 'Hacker Nation: China's Cyber Assault', World Affairs Journal, May/June 2010.
- Falun Gong Human Rights Working Group, Ding Yan Tortured to Death in the "Water Cage", accessed 04-05-2012
- Erik Eckholm, "China Sect Members Covertly Meet Press and Ask World's Help," New York Times, 29 October 1999
- ^ Amnesty International, "China: The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called 'heretical organizations,'" 23 March 2000
- Ian Johnson, 'A Deadly Exercise', Wall Street Journal, 20 April 2000.
- "China Admits Banned Sect Is Continuing Its Protest" Elisabeth Rosenthal. New York Times, 21 April 2000
- Irish Times, "Freed student has not applied for Dublin yet," 3 March 2002
- Washington Post Foreign Service, "Falun Gong Protests Mar Chinese Holiday," 1 October 2000
- Human Rights Watch, "ZHANG KUNLUN -- AN ILLUSTRATIVE CASE" Archived 1 November 2007 at the Wayback Machine, accessed 18 March 2011
- ^ John Pomfret and Philip P. Pan. "Torture is Breaking Falun Gong." Washington Post, 5 August 2001.
- Khabir Ahmad, "International concern grows over psychiatric abuses in China", The Lancet, Volume 356, Issue 9233, Page 920, 9 September 2000
- Vancouver Falun Dafa Practitioners' Protest Site, Timeline of Persecution, accessed 19 March 2011
- ^ Human Rights Law Foundation, Direct Litigation Archived 11 November 2011 at the Wayback Machine, accessed 19 March 2011
- ^ Leeshai Lemish, Media and New Religious Movements: The Case of Falun Gong, A paper presented at The 2009 CESNUR Conference, Salt Lake City, Utah, 11–13 June 2009
- Ethan Gutmann: "The Chinese Internet: A dream deferred?" Tiananmen 20 years on Laogai Research Foundation/NED Panel 1: Refinement of Repression, 9:15 am, 2 June 2009
- CNN, China detains 40 Western Falun Gong activists Archived 7 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine, 14 February 2002
- ^ Ethan Gutmann, "Into Thin Airwaves", Weekly Standard 6 DEC 2010, VOL. 16, NO. 12
- Philip Shenon. "Iceland Bars American Falun Gong Followers." New York Times, 15 June 2002. pg. A.7
- Chen, Kathy, "Different Wavelength: Chinese Dissidents Take On Beijing Via Media Empire", The Wall Street Journal, 15 November 2007
- Clearwisdom.net, "U.S. House of Representatives Unanimously Passes Resolution Urging Chinese Government to Cease Its Persecution of Falun Gong Practitioners", 19 March 2011
- Clearwisdom.net, "Table of Lawsuits Filed Against Former Chinese Leader Jiang Zemin and His Followers by Falun Gong Practitioners around the World", accessed 19 March 2011
- Congressional Record Senate, 22 July 2004
- John Turley-Ewart, "Falun Gong persecution spreads to Canada," The National Post, 20 March 2004.
- Falun Dafa Information Center, "High-Level Chinese Officials Found Guilty of Crimes Against Humanity", 20 June 2003
- United States Congressional Resolution, Expressing sense of Congress Regarding Oppression by China of Falun Gong in the United States Archived 4 July 2010 at the Wayback Machine, 10-6-2004
- Gao Zhisheng, "A China More Just: My Fight As a Rights Lawyer in the World's Largest Communist State," Broad Pr U.S.A, 2007
- Gutmann, Ethan. "Hacker Nation: China's Cyber Assault," World Affairs MAY/JUNE 2010
- Amnesty International, "China: People's Republic of China–Abolishing 'Re-education through Labour'". 27 June 2005
- Falun Dafa Information Center, "Persecution: Timeline Archived 1 May 2011 at the Wayback Machine", 17 May 2008
- Manfred Nowak (2006). "Report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment: MISSION TO CHINA". United Nations. p. 13.
- David Kilgour and David Kilgour (2007) "Bloody Harvest: Kilgour Matas Report on Allegation of Organ Harvesting from Falun Gong Practitioners in China" (in 22 languages)
- About the company
- ^ Alanah May Eriksen, New Zealand Herald. Human rights marchers want Olympic boycott. 17 December 2007.
- The Calgary Herald, City rally hears student's tale of torture, imprisonment in China Archived 7 November 2012 at the Wayback Machine. 20 May 2008.
- New York Times, Falun Gong, accessed 19 March 2011
- Congressional-Executive Commission on China, Annual Report 2008 Archived 12 December 2012 at the Wayback Machine, 31 October 2008.
- Ching Cheong. "China Acts to Defuse 'Crisis Year'" Archived 20 March 2012 at the Wayback Machine. Singapore Straits Times. 3 March 2009
- Einhorn, Bruce. "Congress Challenges China on Falun Gong & Yuan", Business Week, 17 March 2010
- Human Rights in China, 'Beijing Lawyers Beaten for Representing Falun Gong Case', 13 May 2009.
- Amnesty International. 'Human Rights Lawyer Detained, Tortured'. 28 July 2009
- Congressional Executive Commission on China. '2010 Annual Report', 10 October 2010, p. 104.
- La Audiencia pide interrogar al ex presidente chino Jiang por genocidio, 14 November 2009
- Luis Andres Henao, "Argentine judge asks China arrests over Falun Gong," 22 December 2009
- Congressional Executive Commission on China, Annual Report, 2010.
- CECC, "Communist Party Calls for Increased Efforts To 'Transform' Falun Gong Practitioners as Part of Three-Year Campaign" Archived 2 December 2011 at the Wayback Machine, 22 March 2011, accessed 19 March 2011
- Amnesty International, "China: No Rule of Law when Defence Lawyers Cannot Perform their Legitimate Role," 05-10-2010
- ^ Amnesty International, Document – China: Further information: Falun Gong practitioners tortured, 22 August 2012.
- Terry Baynes, 'Suit claims Cisco helped China repress religious group', Reuters, 20 May 2011.
- Amnesty International, China: Local residents petition for Falun Gong releases, 14 November 2011.
- Amnesty International, China: Villagers detained, at risk of torture, 22 October 2012.
- "Over 700 People Join in Effort to Rescue Mr. Li Lankui (Photos)"
- Andrew Jacobs (11 June 2013). "Behind Cry for Help From China Labor Camp". The New York Times. Retrieved 12 June 2013.
- ^ Changing the soup but not the medicine: Abolishing re-education through labor in China. London, UK: Amnesty International. December 2013.
- Freedom House, The Politburo's Predicament: Confronting the Limitations of Communist Party Repression, January 2015. Quote: "...for Falun Gong practitioners, the abolition of the RTL camp system coincided with an increased use of prison sentences on the one hand, and detention in extra-legal "legal education centers" for forced conversion on the other."
- European Parliament, European Parliament resolution of 12 December 2013 on organ harvesting in China (2013/2981(RSP)). Quote: "Expresses its deep concern over the persistent and credible reports of systematic, state‑sanctioned organ harvesting from non-consenting prisoners of conscience in the People's Republic of China, including from large numbers of Falun Gong practitioners imprisoned for their religious beliefs, as well as from members of other religious and ethnic minority groups"
- Barbara Turnbull, , Toronto Star, 21 October 2014.
- Thomas Nelson, The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvestings, and China's Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem by Ethan Gutmann: A Review by Thomas Nelson Archived 6 February 2015 at the Wayback Machine, International Affairs Review.
- Amnesty International, "Document – Amnesty International calls for an investigation into the allegations of torture of four lawyers in China", 4 April 2014.
Further reading
- Li, Junpeng (1 November 2013). "The Religion of the Nonreligious and the Politics of the Apolitical: The Transformation of Falun Gong from Healing Practice to Political Movement". Politics and Religion. 7 (1). Cambridge University Press: 177–208. doi:10.1017/S1755048313000576. S2CID 145591972.
- Ownby, David (April 2003). "A History for Falun Gong: Popular Religion and the Chinese State Since the Ming Dynasty". Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions. 6 (2). University of California Press: 223–243. doi:10.1525/nr.2003.6.2.223. JSTOR 10.1525/nr.2003.6.2.223.
External links
Falun Gong | |
---|---|
Main articles | |
Media | |
Related topics | |
Books |