Misplaced Pages

:What adminship is not: Difference between revisions - Misplaced Pages

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactivelyContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 20:23, 25 January 2006 editBorgHunter (talk | contribs)Administrators6,685 edits Creation  Latest revision as of 18:28, 22 September 2024 edit undoLakesideMiners (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers22,541 editsm Reverted edits by 62.19.125.27 (talk) (AV)Tags: AntiVandal Rollback 
(213 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{shortcut|]}} {{essay|WP:ANOT|WP:WAIN}}
{{Nutshell|Being a Misplaced Pages Administrator basically means that you have been trusted to use tools which, as a technical matter, cannot be given to just anyone.}}


== What adminship is not == This essay describes '''what adminship is and isn't'''.
⚫ ===Adminship is not a trophy===
Editors who regard being an administrator as an affirmation of their contributions as an editor or an award for good editing or other good service will generally be disappointed. Administrator status does not place you in an elevated status within Misplaced Pages. Every good-faith editor, from the newest editor to the most experienced bureaucrat, has the same status within Misplaced Pages. You will not gain respect simply by being an administrator.


== General ==
===Adminship is not a sheriff's badge===
'''Admins do not have "command authority" in the sense that some imagine'''. They can draw a line based on policies, norms and judgement, and enforce that line with the tools. They often have good insight and suggestions to users, and they should be good at gaining others' co-operation and working with people. But they do not, ever, act as "managers" to people in the business sense. They implement policies in which the community in a broad sense has agreed upon. Thus, for example:
While administrators have additional privileges within the system, such as being able to delete pages and block users, every administrator must keep in mind that administrators are servants of Misplaced Pages as a whole. This means that all policies apply equally to all admins, just as they apply to non-privileged users. Administrators should take care to follow policy at all times, especially ].


:* ''They do not "decide what people see"''. An admin who ] a page can only do so after a consensus has been reached: in accordance with the communal decision. Whilst they are implementers, they do not decide the policy. Likewise, admins implement a standard of editorship and use of blocking and protection which has already gained consensus via a discussion (in which admins have absolutely no special authority of any kind).
⚫ ===Adminship is not a reward===
High edit counts and a dedication to Misplaced Pages often demonstrate reliability and aptitude for adminship. However, contributing for a length of time as an editor does not make one entitled to adminship. Candidates with high edit counts do sometimes fail, for various reasons. Such failures should not be taken personally, and a failure to pass a RfA does not indicate that the community fails to appreciate your contributions. Sometimes users with many contributions simply do not have the proper temperament to be an admin, and these users can be equally valuable without sysop privileges. No number of edits or length of time on Misplaced Pages entitles one to adminship.


:* ''They do not need to know how "everything works"''. But they do need to know enough not to misuse what they touch, and to conduct themselves well. The emphasis is on "''not making mistakes''", not on "''doing it all''". Users do things, admins just handle the few exceptions where for practical reasons we don't let every new user do so. Even very experienced admins—including those elected to higher positions than admin—usually don't know how ''everything'' works.
⚫ ===Adminship is not diplomatic immunity===

Administrators can be blocked just as normal users can be. Administrators are expected to follow all Misplaced Pages policies, and restrictions on editing or sysop privileges can be imposed by other administrators or the Arbitration Committee, if necessary. Policies such as ] often do result in administrators being blocked if they run afoul of them.
:* ''Admins are users that the community has trusted'' to operate the tools. If an admin goes for a year without making an edit, it doesn't necessarily have an impact on their trustworthiness when they return to editing. Hence an admin's obligation isn't to "do" any specific role; rather, to act responsibly if or when they do take action.

:* ''Admins should gain broad respect'', but frankly no user is obligated to respect or listen to them (it's not a requirement of editing), and many will not. Blocking is not merely a tool to be used instead of talking to people.

High standards are required, but many people will have misconceptions of what it is that admins actually do. Mostly, admins are:
# users the community have chosen based on experience and trust.
# users who have consistently good standards on general conduct as editors.
# users who are allowed to act as custodians of the tools that for pragmatic reasons need to be restricted in access (due to the presence of many people on the Internet who would use them for purposes that don't help the project).
# users who are trusted to only use the tools provided to enact a decision within the standards that the community has decided, and not otherwise.

== More specifically==

===<span id="TROPHY" ></span>Adminship is not a trophy===
{{shortcut|WP:ANOT#TROPHY|WP:TROPHY}}
Being an administrator does not place you in an elevated ] within Misplaced Pages. It is not the user-equivalent of a ] or ]. Administrators will find they have no extra sway in policy or other decisions because of an RfA. It does not affirm a user's contributions as an editor and is not an award for good editing or other good service. You will not gain more respect simply by being an administrator. It may help to consider the other meaning of the word administrator, that is one who facilitates, rather than one who controls.

Adminship is simply a statement that the individual is a normal user whom the community views as likely to use the extra tools responsibly if given access to them. An admin is just a normal user with a mop and a bucket. It certainly does ''not'' give you any Sergeant-like authority.

===<span id="ENTITLEMENT" ></span>Adminship is not an entitlement===
{{shortcut|WP:ANOT#ENTITLEMENT}}
High ] and a dedication to Misplaced Pages often demonstrate reliability and aptitude for adminship. However, candidates with high edit counts sometimes fail to pass a ], because RfA is about a user's approach and ''attitudes'', not about "how much they do". This is not personal; it does not mean that the community fails to appreciate your contributions. A number of exceptional editors are not admins and will never be, some through choice, some through communal consensus. A number of admins regularly ask to drop their adminship, to leave behind administrative chores and get back to editing instead. Sometimes good contributors simply do not have the proper temperament to be admins; but they are still valuable. No number of edits or length of time on Misplaced Pages entitles one to adminship.

It's important to know that the administrator user right is a ''senior-level'' toolset for users who have demonstrated a ''high level'' of wisdom, knowledge, and expertise on Misplaced Pages with its ], and who demonstrate their respect for Misplaced Pages's ] at all times. They demonstrate ] with their edits to articles and ] ] with their changes that require it. They are consistently civil with other users that they interact with - even those who aren't civil towards them. They take the lead and help other users toward the correct solution, and they demonstrate experience in areas that show an abundance of knowledge of Misplaced Pages's guidelines.

⚫ ===<span id="IMMUNITY" ></span>Adminship is not diplomatic immunity===
{{shortcut|WP:ANOT#IMMUNITY}}
Every administrator must keep in mind that admins simply hold tools that aid in Misplaced Pages maintenance, and nothing more. This means that ''all policies'' apply to administrators ''exactly'' as they would to any other user – if not '']''. On top of being expected to play a lead role and set the example when it comes to areas such as ], conflict resolution, knowledge of policy, and appropriate use of their tools, they are also expected to use their tools within compliance of the relevant policies at all times. Admins who repeatedly fail to do this, or who cause significant community concerns regarding their behaviors and the expected responsibilities of administrators and their use of their tools can be readily blocked, stripped of their admin tools, or banned. Admins must follow all of Misplaced Pages policies (such as the ]) and uphold ] and a ] as if they were any other editor.

===<span id="COMPULSORY" ></span>Adminship is neither compulsory nor necessary to aid Misplaced Pages===
{{shortcut|WP:ANOT#COMPULSORY}}
Administrators have access to useful tools not available to other users, and are able to use these to serve Misplaced Pages in additional ways. However, some ] do not wish to become administrators—despite having the expected levels of experience and community support. Users may always reject the opportunity or nomination to stand for adminship. Additionally, many tools and site areas exist for ordinary users to help in ways they might not have initially considered—see ]. Users can label the ways they contribute by, for example, joining ]s and using the relevant ]es.

⚫ ===<span id="GAME" ></span>Adminship is not a game===
{{shortcut|WP:ANOT#GAME}}
Putting yourself up for or ] other Wikipedians to have an RfA is not a game and is serious. When you are an administrator, you don't just get to block and unblock who you want, delete and undelete what you want, go around editing protected pages when you want, or go protecting and unprotecting whatever you want. It's important to realize that any action you do with these functions can be reversed by another admin. Administrative actions should be used with good judgment at all times. Be sure there is a consensus that exists before you take your next action.

''Blocking in particular is one of the most contentious acts an administrator can perform and is considered a '''very''' serious matter''. Poorly placed blocks can result in you becoming unpopular with prominent members of the community, and with apparent ] being thrown towards you as justifiable under the circumstances. On some occasions, a poor blocking history can result in an admin being desysopped.

===<span id="SALE" ></span>Adminship is not for sale===
{{shortcut|WP:ANOT#SALE}}
You, and ''only you'' should have access to the extra tools that were granted onto your account. They are not to be shared in any way, shape, or form with other users. Giving another user access to your account in order to make administrative actions is '''absolutely prohibited''', and your administrative tools may be revoked if you are caught sharing your account or allowing someone else to use your account.

⚫ ===Adminship is not a big deal===

{{seealso|WP:NOBIGDEAL}}

Adminship is not meant to be anything special beyond access to extra editing tools which, pragmatically, cannot be given to every user. It does not give any extra status, weight in discussions, or special privileges beyond what is necessary to technically use those extra tools.


== See also == == See also ==
Line 19: Line 64:
*] *]
*] *]
*]
*]
*]
*]
*]


]
]

Latest revision as of 18:28, 22 September 2024

Essay on editing Misplaced Pages
This is an essay.
It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Misplaced Pages contributors. This page is not an encyclopedia article, nor is it one of Misplaced Pages's policies or guidelines, as it has not been thoroughly vetted by the community. Some essays represent widespread norms; others only represent minority viewpoints.		Shortcuts
This page in a nutshell: Being a Misplaced Pages Administrator basically means that you have been trusted to use tools which, as a technical matter, cannot be given to just anyone.

This essay describes what adminship is and isn't.

General

Admins do not have "command authority" in the sense that some imagine. They can draw a line based on policies, norms and judgement, and enforce that line with the tools. They often have good insight and suggestions to users, and they should be good at gaining others' co-operation and working with people. But they do not, ever, act as "managers" to people in the business sense. They implement policies in which the community in a broad sense has agreed upon. Thus, for example:

  • They do not "decide what people see". An admin who deletes a page can only do so after a consensus has been reached: in accordance with the communal decision. Whilst they are implementers, they do not decide the policy. Likewise, admins implement a standard of editorship and use of blocking and protection which has already gained consensus via a discussion (in which admins have absolutely no special authority of any kind).
  • They do not need to know how "everything works". But they do need to know enough not to misuse what they touch, and to conduct themselves well. The emphasis is on "not making mistakes", not on "doing it all". Users do things, admins just handle the few exceptions where for practical reasons we don't let every new user do so. Even very experienced admins—including those elected to higher positions than admin—usually don't know how everything works.
  • Admins are users that the community has trusted to operate the tools. If an admin goes for a year without making an edit, it doesn't necessarily have an impact on their trustworthiness when they return to editing. Hence an admin's obligation isn't to "do" any specific role; rather, to act responsibly if or when they do take action.
  • Admins should gain broad respect, but frankly no user is obligated to respect or listen to them (it's not a requirement of editing), and many will not. Blocking is not merely a tool to be used instead of talking to people.

High standards are required, but many people will have misconceptions of what it is that admins actually do. Mostly, admins are:

  1. users the community have chosen based on experience and trust.
  2. users who have consistently good standards on general conduct as editors.
  3. users who are allowed to act as custodians of the tools that for pragmatic reasons need to be restricted in access (due to the presence of many people on the Internet who would use them for purposes that don't help the project).
  4. users who are trusted to only use the tools provided to enact a decision within the standards that the community has decided, and not otherwise.

More specifically

Adminship is not a trophy

Shortcuts

Being an administrator does not place you in an elevated status within Misplaced Pages. It is not the user-equivalent of a good article or featured article. Administrators will find they have no extra sway in policy or other decisions because of an RfA. It does not affirm a user's contributions as an editor and is not an award for good editing or other good service. You will not gain more respect simply by being an administrator. It may help to consider the other meaning of the word administrator, that is one who facilitates, rather than one who controls.

Adminship is simply a statement that the individual is a normal user whom the community views as likely to use the extra tools responsibly if given access to them. An admin is just a normal user with a mop and a bucket. It certainly does not give you any Sergeant-like authority.

Adminship is not an entitlement

Shortcut

High edit counts and a dedication to Misplaced Pages often demonstrate reliability and aptitude for adminship. However, candidates with high edit counts sometimes fail to pass a Request for adminship, because RfA is about a user's approach and attitudes, not about "how much they do". This is not personal; it does not mean that the community fails to appreciate your contributions. A number of exceptional editors are not admins and will never be, some through choice, some through communal consensus. A number of admins regularly ask to drop their adminship, to leave behind administrative chores and get back to editing instead. Sometimes good contributors simply do not have the proper temperament to be admins; but they are still valuable. No number of edits or length of time on Misplaced Pages entitles one to adminship.

It's important to know that the administrator user right is a senior-level toolset for users who have demonstrated a high level of wisdom, knowledge, and expertise on Misplaced Pages with its policies and guidelines, and who demonstrate their respect for Misplaced Pages's founding principles at all times. They demonstrate neutrality with their edits to articles and cite reliable sources with their changes that require it. They are consistently civil with other users that they interact with - even those who aren't civil towards them. They take the lead and help other users toward the correct solution, and they demonstrate experience in areas that show an abundance of knowledge of Misplaced Pages's guidelines.

Adminship is not diplomatic immunity

Shortcut

Every administrator must keep in mind that admins simply hold tools that aid in Misplaced Pages maintenance, and nothing more. This means that all policies apply to administrators exactly as they would to any other user – if not more so. On top of being expected to play a lead role and set the example when it comes to areas such as civility, conflict resolution, knowledge of policy, and appropriate use of their tools, they are also expected to use their tools within compliance of the relevant policies at all times. Admins who repeatedly fail to do this, or who cause significant community concerns regarding their behaviors and the expected responsibilities of administrators and their use of their tools can be readily blocked, stripped of their admin tools, or banned. Admins must follow all of Misplaced Pages policies (such as the three-revert rule) and uphold consensus and a neutral point of view as if they were any other editor.

Adminship is neither compulsory nor necessary to aid Misplaced Pages

Shortcut

Administrators have access to useful tools not available to other users, and are able to use these to serve Misplaced Pages in additional ways. However, some Wikipedians do not wish to become administrators—despite having the expected levels of experience and community support. Users may always reject the opportunity or nomination to stand for adminship. Additionally, many tools and site areas exist for ordinary users to help in ways they might not have initially considered—see Contributing to Misplaced Pages. Users can label the ways they contribute by, for example, joining WikiProjects and using the relevant Userboxes.

Adminship is not a game

Shortcut

Putting yourself up for or nominating other Wikipedians to have an RfA is not a game and is serious. When you are an administrator, you don't just get to block and unblock who you want, delete and undelete what you want, go around editing protected pages when you want, or go protecting and unprotecting whatever you want. It's important to realize that any action you do with these functions can be reversed by another admin. Administrative actions should be used with good judgment at all times. Be sure there is a consensus that exists before you take your next action.

Blocking in particular is one of the most contentious acts an administrator can perform and is considered a very serious matter. Poorly placed blocks can result in you becoming unpopular with prominent members of the community, and with apparent personal attacks being thrown towards you as justifiable under the circumstances. On some occasions, a poor blocking history can result in an admin being desysopped.

Adminship is not for sale

Shortcut

You, and only you should have access to the extra tools that were granted onto your account. They are not to be shared in any way, shape, or form with other users. Giving another user access to your account in order to make administrative actions is absolutely prohibited, and your administrative tools may be revoked if you are caught sharing your account or allowing someone else to use your account.

Adminship is not a big deal

See also: WP:NOBIGDEAL

Adminship is not meant to be anything special beyond access to extra editing tools which, pragmatically, cannot be given to every user. It does not give any extra status, weight in discussions, or special privileges beyond what is necessary to technically use those extra tools.

See also

Categories: