Misplaced Pages

:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Civility enforcement/Evidence/Blocks: Difference between revisions - Misplaced Pages

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
< Misplaced Pages:Arbitration | Requests | Case | Civility enforcement | Evidence Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 05:14, 9 January 2012 editIndubitably (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers39,667 edits Add details of second block.← Previous edit Latest revision as of 20:43, 12 February 2012 edit undoRisker (talk | contribs)Edit filter managers, Autopatrolled, Checkusers, New page reviewers, Oversighters, Administrators28,284 edits email evidence from Sarek of Vulcan 
(26 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:

* Given that much of the evidence provided to date involves the various blocks imposed on Malleus Fatuorum, I think there is benefit to everyone to review these blocks specifically. With Courcelles' assistance, we have created a chart with all of Malleus Fatuorum's blocks, and filled in date and time, blocking admin, unblock information if applicable, original length of block, and actual length of block. I am hoping that the participants in this case will work collaboratively to provide the following information for *each* block in Malleus' block log: * Given that much of the evidence provided to date involves the various blocks imposed on Malleus Fatuorum, I think there is benefit to everyone to review these blocks specifically. With Courcelles' assistance, we have created a chart with all of Malleus Fatuorum's blocks, and filled in date and time, blocking admin, unblock information if applicable, original length of block, and actual length of block. I am hoping that the participants in this case will work collaboratively to provide the following information for *each* block in Malleus' block log:
:*Issue that led to block. Include all relevant links, including any discussions on user talk pages. :*Issue that led to block. Include all relevant links, including any discussions on user talk pages.
Line 32: Line 31:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{user|Swatjester}} |{{user|Swatjester}}
|Context ; Warned for ; Blocked for . |Context ; Warned for ; Blocked for .
|] including formal warning, block notice. Another "warning" |] including formal warning, block notice (1 min after block) for comments directed at Swat. Another "warning"
|ST47 warned for personal attacks, not blocked.
|Swat was involved as the admin the comments were directed at. No warning to ST47 for his direct personal attack on Duk.
|3 hrs 27 min |4 hrs 27 min
| 00:29, 25 May 2008 Balloonman unblocked (block inappropriately applied) | 00:29, 25 May 2008 Balloonman unblocked (block inappropriately applied)
|24 hours |24 hours
Line 43: Line 42:
|{{User|Ckatz}} |{{User|Ckatz}}
|Context ; Wikiquette opened for ; Blocked for |Context ; Wikiquette opened for ; Blocked for
|Warning and discussion ; Block notice |Warning and discussion ; Block notice (1 min after block)
| |
|14 mins |14 mins
Line 52: Line 51:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Aitias}} |{{User|Aitias}}
|Context ; Blocked for
|Discussion with warning ; AN/I discussion ; Block notice (14 mins after block)
| |
|2 mins
|
|
|
|00:38, 7 March 2009 Ddstretch unblocked (Blocking admin is involved (he/she interacted with Malleus and Malleus was brusque with him/her), the length was excessive, and no block notice was posted) |00:38, 7 March 2009 Ddstretch unblocked (Blocking admin is involved (he/she interacted with Malleus and Malleus was brusque with him/her), the length was excessive, and no block notice was posted)
|3 days |3 days
Line 72: Line 71:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Gwen Gale}} |{{User|Gwen Gale}}
| Context Blocked for
| |
| |
|1 hr 40ish min
|
|
|19:22, 10 June 2009 Gwen Gale unblocked (consensus seems to be that many admins are indeed sycophants) |19:22, 10 June 2009 Gwen Gale unblocked (consensus seems to be that many admins are indeed sycophants)
|1 week |1 week
Line 82: Line 81:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Georgewilliamherbert}} |{{User|Georgewilliamherbert}}
|Context Blocked for
| |
| |
|] warned later after being blocked for taunting MF's block
|
|ANI review
|
|
|24 hours |24 hours
|24 hr |24 hr
Line 92: Line 91:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Georgewilliamherbert}} |{{User|Georgewilliamherbert}}
|context incl. edit-warring on MF talk page
ANI thread
Blocked for and
| |
|] blocked for 5 sec
|
|5 hr
|
|
| |
|10 seconds |10 seconds
Line 102: Line 103:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|David Fuchs}} |{{User|David Fuchs}}
|
| |
|Roux blocked
|
|10 min
|
|
| |
|1 hour |1 hour
Line 112: Line 113:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|TenOfAllTrades}} |{{User|TenOfAllTrades}}
|Context Blocked for
| |
| |
|4 min
|
|03:32, 7 March 2010 Moni3 unblocked ‎ (ineffective block) )
|
|03:32, 7 March 2010 Moni3 unblocked ‎ (ineffective block)
|24 hours |24 hours
|12 min |12 min
Line 122: Line 123:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Rodhullandemu}} |{{User|Rodhullandemu}}
|Context
Discussion with warning
| |
|Rodhullandemu blocked ; block reduced
|
|
| |
|02:00, 11 July 2010 Moni3 unblocked (Oh, for Pete's sake! ) |02:00, 11 July 2010 Moni3 unblocked (Oh, for Pete's sake! )
Line 132: Line 134:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Georgewilliamherbert}} |{{User|Georgewilliamherbert}}
|Talk page led to ANI thread
| |
| |
|15 min
|
⚫ |01:42, 15 October 2010 Ucucha unblocked (borderline personal attack if any; block is not going to solve anything)
|
⚫ |01:42, 15 October 2010 Ucucha unblocked (borderline personal attack if any; block is not going to solve anything)
|12 hours |12 hours
|15 min |15 min
Line 142: Line 144:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|SarekOfVulcan}} |{{User|SarekOfVulcan}}
|
|
|none
|
|none
|
|2 min
|
|18:40, 15 October 2010 SarekOfVulcan unblocked ‎ (not in the mood) |18:40, 15 October 2010 SarekOfVulcan unblocked ‎ (not in the mood)
|12 hours |12 hours
Line 152: Line 154:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Geni}} |{{User|Geni}}
| First names or last names for underaged then married Edwardian women; per
|
| nil,
|
| nil
|
| 9h 50m
|
|13:50, 3 February 2011 Nikkimaria unblocked (per discussion at ANI and elsewhere, block was excessive) |] 13:50, 3 February 2011 Nikkimaria unblocked (per discussion at ANI and elsewhere, block was excessive) Relevant links: , ] (sections 151-156), ]
|24 hours |24 hours
|34 min |34 min
Line 162: Line 164:
! scope="row"| ! scope="row"|
|{{User|Kaldari}} |{{User|Kaldari}}
|Grammar disagreement and subsequent edit war over personal attacks
|
|Attempts to remove personal attack,
|
|Tbhotch warned for calling Malleus "narrow-minded"
|
|0 mins (discussion was ongoing)
|
|03:45, 26 October 2011 Mkativerata unblocked ‎ (ANI is clear. I made the call not to block. An editor does not get blocked because one out 2,000 administrators happens upon ANI and decides to. First come, first served.) |03:45, 26 October 2011 Mkativerata unblocked ‎ (ANI is clear. I made the call not to block. An editor does not get blocked because one out 2,000 administrators happens upon ANI and decides to. First come, first served.)
|24 hours |24 hours
Line 193: Line 195:
|{{User|28bytes}} (Reinstating prior block) |{{User|28bytes}} (Reinstating prior block)
| |
|Reinstated block at ]
|
| |
| |

Latest revision as of 20:43, 12 February 2012

  • Given that much of the evidence provided to date involves the various blocks imposed on Malleus Fatuorum, I think there is benefit to everyone to review these blocks specifically. With Courcelles' assistance, we have created a chart with all of Malleus Fatuorum's blocks, and filled in date and time, blocking admin, unblock information if applicable, original length of block, and actual length of block. I am hoping that the participants in this case will work collaboratively to provide the following information for *each* block in Malleus' block log:
  • Issue that led to block. Include all relevant links, including any discussions on user talk pages.
  • Any other dispute resolution attempted before block (warnings, discussion with user, discussion on noticeboards or elsewhere, etc). Links to these attempts.
  • Whether or not any other users were also asked to change behaviour/warned/blocked in relation to the same issue. Links to those dispute resolution steps.
  • Length of time between last discussion of precipitating issue and the block. (For example, was the last related comment several hours before the block?)


Blocks on Malleus Fatuorum
Date and time of block Blocking admin Issue that led to block (link to discussion) Dispute resolution attempts before block (link to discussion) Other users advised, warned or blocked (link to discussion) Time between end of discussion and block Unblock (with unblock reason) if applicable Intended duration of block Actual duration of block
Example: Link to discussion on Misplaced Pages talk:Requests for adminship. Example: Link to discussion on Malleus' talk page. Link to discussion on another page. Example: Link to discussion on another user's talk page. Example: Calculate time (days/hours/minutes) between end of discussion and block. (Users may add links to relevant unblock discussions)
17:26, 24 May 2008 Swatjester (talk · contribs) Context ; Warned for ; Blocked for . Full discussion including formal warning, block notice (1 min after block) for comments directed at Swat. Another "warning" ST47 warned for personal attacks, not blocked. 4 hrs 27 min 00:29, 25 May 2008 Balloonman unblocked (block inappropriately applied) 24 hours 7 hr 3 min
10:23, 19 August 2008 Ckatz (talk · contribs) Context ; Wikiquette opened for ; Blocked for Warning and discussion ; Block notice (1 min after block) 14 mins 18:33, 19 August 2008 Gwen Gale unblocked ("time served" - asking this editor to be more civil though) 24 hours 8 hr 10 min
00:28, 7 March 2009 Aitias (talk · contribs) Context ; Blocked for Discussion with warning ; AN/I discussion ; Block notice (14 mins after block) 2 mins 00:38, 7 March 2009 Ddstretch unblocked (Blocking admin is involved (he/she interacted with Malleus and Malleus was brusque with him/her), the length was excessive, and no block notice was posted) 3 days 10 min
00:46, 7 March 2009 Coren (talk · contribs) (Reinstating prior block) 2 dy 23 hr 18 min 2 dy 23 hr 18 min
18:23, 10 June 2009 Gwen Gale (talk · contribs) Context Blocked for 1 hr 40ish min 19:22, 10 June 2009 Gwen Gale unblocked (consensus seems to be that many admins are indeed sycophants) 1 week 59 min
01:14, 5 November 2009 Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs) Context Blocked for User:Who then was a gentleman? warned later after being blocked for taunting MF's block ANI review 24 hours 24 hr
08:20, 11 December 2009 Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs) context incl. edit-warring on MF talk page

ANI thread Blocked for and

User:Andrea105 blocked for 5 sec 5 hr 10 seconds 10 sec
17:21, 7 February 2010 David Fuchs (talk · contribs) Roux blocked 10 min 1 hour 1 hr
03:20, 7 March 2010 TenOfAllTrades (talk · contribs) Context Blocked for 4 min 03:32, 7 March 2010 Moni3 unblocked ‎ (ineffective block) ) 24 hours 12 min
01:49, 11 July 2010 Rodhullandemu (talk · contribs) Context

Discussion with warning

Rodhullandemu blocked AN thread; block reduced 02:00, 11 July 2010 Moni3 unblocked (Oh, for Pete's sake! ) 31 hours 11 min
01:27, 15 October 2010 Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs) Talk page led to ANI thread 15 min 01:42, 15 October 2010 Ucucha unblocked (borderline personal attack if any; block is not going to solve anything) 12 hours 15 min
16:49, 15 October 2010 SarekOfVulcan (talk · contribs) none none 2 min 18:40, 15 October 2010 SarekOfVulcan unblocked ‎ (not in the mood) 12 hours 1 hr 51 min
13:16, 3 February 2011 Geni (talk · contribs) First names or last names for underaged then married Edwardian women; for this per rationale nil, comments blanked at time of block nil 9h 50m discussion 13:50, 3 February 2011 Nikkimaria unblocked (per discussion at ANI and elsewhere, block was excessive) Relevant links: ANI, User_talk:Geni/archive_7 (sections 151-156), User_talk:Malleus_Fatuorum/Archives/2011/February#Blocked 24 hours 34 min
02:58, 26 October 2011 Kaldari (talk · contribs) Grammar disagreement and subsequent edit war over personal attacks Attempts to remove personal attack, AN/I thread Tbhotch warned for calling Malleus "narrow-minded" 0 mins (discussion was ongoing) 03:45, 26 October 2011 Mkativerata unblocked ‎ (ANI is clear. I made the call not to block. An editor does not get blocked because one out 2,000 administrators happens upon ANI and decides to. First come, first served.) 24 hours 47 min
22:34, 21 December 2011 Thumperward (talk · contribs) 23:47, 21 December 2011 John unblocked (Per consensus at AN/I; disproportionate block contravenes policy) indefinite 1 hr 13 min
07:17, 22 December 2011 Hawkeye7 (talk · contribs) 15:51, 22 December 2011 Salvio giuliano unblocked (unblocking for the limited purpose of responding to an Arbcom request) 1 week 8 hr 34 min
23:08, 22 December 2011 28bytes (talk · contribs) (Reinstating prior block) Reinstated block at Malleus request 6 dy 3 hr 19 min (user request) 6 dy 3 hr 19 min