Misplaced Pages

Well poisoning: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 22:34, 27 June 2016 edit77.180.189.136 (talk) →Contemporary accusations: ad EU BloodLibel speech on June 23 2016 Brussels← Previous edit Latest revision as of 14:02, 27 December 2024 edit undoRogerborg (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users595 edits →Instances of modern usage: Removing uncited weasel worded claims 
(197 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Malicious manipulation of potable water resources}}
{{for|the logical fallacy|Poisoning the well}}
{{For|the logical fallacy|Poisoning the well}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=January 2011}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=August 2022}}


'''Well-poisoning''' is the act of malicious manipulation of ] resources in order to cause illness or death, or to deny an opponent access to fresh water resources. '''Well poisoning''' is the act of malicious manipulation of ] resources in order to cause illness or death, or to deny an opponent access to fresh water resources.


Well poisoning has been historically documented as strategy during wartime since ], and was used both offensively (as a ] to disrupt and depopulate a target area) and defensively (as a ] tactic to deny an invading army sources of clean water). Rotting ]s (both animal and human) thrown down wells were the most common implementation; in one of the earliest examples of ], corpses known to have died from common ]s of the ] era such as ] or ] were especially favored for well-poisoning. Well poisoning has been historically documented as a strategy during wartime since ], and was used both offensively (as a ] to disrupt and depopulate a target area) and defensively (as a ] tactic to deny an invading army sources of clean water). Rotting ]s (both animal and human) thrown down ] were the most common implementation; in one of the earliest examples of ], corpses known to have died from common ]s of the ] era such as ] or ] were especially favored for well-poisoning.


== History of implementation==
Additionally, well poisoning was one of the three gravest ] ] (the other two being ] and ]). Similar accusations were also made of ] living in ] in the aftermath of the ]. In both cases the accusation was never substantiated, but did lead to widescale persecution and ]s against the group so accused.
{{Expand section|date=June 2008}}


===Instances of medieval usage===
==History==
Well poisoning has been used as an important ] tactic at least since medieval times. In 1462, for example, Prince ] of ] utilized this method to delay his pursuing adversaries. Nearly 500 years later during the ], the Finns rendered wells unusable by planting animal carcasses or feces in them in order to ] invading Soviet forces.<ref>{{cite book|title=The Winter War, the Russo-Finnish War of 1939–40 |first=William R. |last=Trotter |year=2003 |publisher=Aurum Press Ltd |location=London 2003 |isbn=1-85410-932-4}}</ref>


===In warfare=== ===Instances of modern usage===
{{Expand section|date=June 2008}}
Well poisoning has been used as an important ] tactic at least since ancient times. In 1462, for example, Prince ] of ] utilized this method to delay his pursuing ] Turk adversaries. Whilst retreating through Turkish-controlled ], across the ] River and back to the capital of Wallachia that same year, Vlad's army employed the poisoning of wells and other sources of water, as well as other scorched earth tactics en route to his country on both sides of the Danube, meaning that he deliberately polluted the water supplies of his fellow Romanians even at the cost of their lives if it slowed down his Muslim foes. Nearly 500 years later during the ], the Finns rendered wells unusable by planting animal carcasses or feces in them in order to ] invading Soviet forces.<ref>''The Winter War, the Russo-Finnish War of 1939-40'', William R. Trotter, Aurum Press Ltd, London 2003, ISBN 1-85410-932-4</ref> During the 20th century, the practice of poisoning wells has lost most of its potency and practicality against an organized force as modern ] ensure secure and decontaminated supplies and resources. Nevertheless, German forces during First World War poisoned wells in France as part of ].<ref>The Making of Peace: Rulers, States, and the Aftermath of War edited by Williamson Murray, Jim Lacey Cambridge University Press page 218</ref> A few religions have laws condemning such ] tactics. Most notably ], in its scripture, dictates that water-bodies may not be poisoned even during a battle and enemies must be allowed access to water.{{Citation needed|date=November 2014}}


During the 20th century, the practice of poisoning wells has lost most of its potency and practicality against an organized force as modern ] ensure secure and decontaminated supplies and resources. Nevertheless, German forces during ] poisoned wells in France as part of ].<ref>{{cite book|title=The Making of Peace: Rulers, States, and the Aftermath of War |editor1-first=Williamson |editor1-last=Murray |editor2-first=Jim |editor2-last=Lacey |publisher=] |page=218}}</ref>
===Medieval accusations against Jews===

{{see also|Antisemitic canard|Black Death Jewish persecutions}}
After ] ], a ] organisation of about fifty ], sought revenge for the murder of six million Jews during the ]. The group's leader ] went to ] in order to secure large quantities of poison for poisoning water mains to kill large numbers of Germans. His followers infiltrated the water system of ]. However, Kovner was arrested upon arrival in the ] and had to throw the poison overboard.<ref>{{cite news |url=https://jweekly.com/1998/03/27/survivor-reveals-1945-plan-to-kill-6-million-germans/ |access-date=25 September 2024 |agency=The Jewish News of Northern California |date=27 March 1998}}</ref>
{{Antisemitism}}

Despite some vague understanding of how diseases could spread, the existence of viruses and bacteria was unknown in medieval times, and the outbreak of disease could not be scientifically explained. Any sudden deterioration of health was often blamed on poisoning. Europe was hit by several waves of ] (often identified as ]) throughout the late Middle Ages. Crowded cities were especially hard hit by the disease, with death tolls as high as 50% of the population. In their distress, emotionally distraught survivors searched desperately for an explanation. The city-dwelling Jews of the Middle Ages, living in walled-up, segregated ] districts, aroused ]. An outbreak of plague thus became the trigger for ], with hundreds of Jews burned at the stake, or rounded up in synagogues and private houses that were then set aflame. With the decline of plague in Europe, these accusations lessened, but the term "well-poisoning" remains a loaded one that continues to crop up even today among anti-Semites around the world.
Israel poisoned the wells and water supplies of certain Palestinian towns and villages as part of their ] program during the ], including a successful operation that caused a ] epidemic in ] in early May 1948, and an unsuccessful attempt in ] that was foiled by the Egyptians in late May.<ref>{{harvnb |Morris |Kedar |2023 |pp=752-776 |ps=, " Taken together, these documents revealed that the Acre and Gaza episodes were merely the tip of the iceberg in a prolonged campaign ... But bulldozing or blowing up houses and wells was deemed insufficient. With its back to the wall, the Haganah upped the ante and unleashed a clandestine campaign of poisoning certain captured village wells with bacteria – in violation of the Geneva Protocol ... The aim of ''Cast Thy Bread'' ... like the demolitions, was to hamper an Arab return. Over the weeks, the well-poisoning campaign was expanded to regions beyond the Tel Aviv-Jerusalem road and included Jewish settlements captured or about to be captured by Arab troops, and then to inhabited Arab towns, to facilitate their prospective conquest by the Haganah or to hinder the progress of the invading Arab armies ... The Yishuv’s decision to use the bacteriological weapons was taken at the highest level of the government and military and was, indeed, steered by these officers, with Ben-Gurion’s authorization, through the campaign ... The use of the bacteria was apparently fairly limited in Israel/Palestine during April-December 1948, and apart from Acre, seems to have caused no epidemic and few casualties. At least, that is what emerges from the available documentation."}};
{{harvnb |Nashef |2018 |ps=, p. 143 n. 4 (quoting Pappe 2006)}};
{{harvnb |Carus |2017 |p=145 |ps=, "Some BW programs relied on extremely crude methods, about as sophisticated as those employed by some terrorist groups or criminals ... The same was true of the reported activities associated with the early Israeli program in 1948."}};
{{harvnb |Docker |2012 |pp=19-20 |ps=, "The urbicide of May 1948 directed against the old Crusader city of Acre involved biological warfare, including poisoning of water, Pappé writing that it seems clear from Red Cross reports that the Zionist forces besieging the city injected ‘typhoid germs’ into the water supply, which led to a ‘sudden typhoid epidemic’. There was a similar attempt to ‘poison the water supply in Gaza’ on 27 May 1948 by injecting typhoid and dysentery viruses into wells; this attempt was fortunately foiled."}};
{{harvnb |Martin |2010 |p=7 |ps=, "Israeli biological warfare activities included Operation Shalach, which was an attempt to contaminate the water supplies of Egyptian Army. Egypt reports capture of four ‘Zionists’ trying to infect wells with dysentery and typhoid. There are also allegations that a typhoid outbreak in Acre in 1948 resulted from a biological attack and that there were attacks in Egypt in 1947 and in Syria in 1948."}};
{{harvnb |Sayigh |2009 |p= |ps=, "A unit had been formed to develop biological weapons, and there is evidence that these were used during 1948 to poison the water supplies of Akka and Gaza with typhoid bacteria."}};
{{harvnb |Ackerman |Asal |2008 |p=191 |ps=, "Egyptian Ministry of Defense and, later, Israeli historians, contend that Israeli soldiers contaminated Acre’s water supply."}};
{{harvnb |Pappe |2006 |ps=, pp. 73–4 ("The flame-thrower project was part of a larger unit engaged in developing biological warfare under the directorship of a physical chemist called Ephraim Katzir ... The biological unit he led together with his brother Aharon, started working seriously in February . Its main objective was to create a weapon that could blind people.") and 100–101 ("During the siege typhoid germs were apparently injected into the water. Local emissaries of the International Red Cross reported this to their headquarters and left very little room for guessing whom they suspected: the Hagana. The Red Cross reports describe a sudden typhoid epidemic and, even with their guarded language, point to outside poisoning as the sole explanation for this outbreak ... A similar attempt to poison the water supply in Gaza on 27 May was foiled.")}};
{{harvnb |Abu Sitta |2003 |ps=, "The Zionists injected typhoid in the aqueduct at some intermediate point which passes through Zionist settlements ... The city of Acre, now burdened by the epidemic, fell easy prey to the Zionists. ... Two weeks later, after their "success" in Acre, the Zionists struck again. This time in Gaza, where hundreds of thousands of refugees had gathered after their villages in southern Palestine were occupied. The end however was different. ... The biological crimes perpetrated against the Palestinians in Acre and Gaza in 1948 are still being enacted today."}};
{{harvnb |Leitenberg |2001 |p=289 |ps=, "As early as April 1948, Ben Gurion directed one of his operatives in Europe (Ehud Avriel) to seek out surviving East European Jewish scientists who could “either increase the capacity to kill masses or to cure masses: both things are important.” At that time, that ‘capacity’ meant chemical and biological weapons ... These were ultimate weapons that could be used either for offense or defense (and the context of the immediate military operations, as well as those that had preceded it, would be the critical factors in that categorization)."}};
{{harvnb |Cohen |2001 |p=31 |ps=, "It is believed that one of the largest operations in this campaign was in the Arab coastal town of Acre, north of Haifa, shortly before it was conquered by the IDF on May 17,1948. According to Milstein, the typhoid epidemic that spread in Acre in the days before the town fell to the Israeli forces was not the result of wartime chaos but rather a deliberate covert action by the IDF—the contamination of Acre's water supply ... The success of the Acre operation may have persuaded Israeli decisionmakers to continue with these activities. On May 23, 1948, Egyptian soldiers in the Gaza area caught four Israeli soldiers disguised as Arabs near water wells ... It seems that many people knew something about these operations, but both the participants and later historians chose to avoid the issue, which gradually became a national taboo ... Despite the official silence, it appears there is little doubt now about the mission of the failed Gaza operation."}}</ref>

In the late 20th century, accusations of well-poisoning were brought up, most notoriously in relation to the Kosovo Liberation War.<ref>{{cite web |url=https://www.un.org/icty/transe54/050228IT.htm |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20050407161717/http://www.un.org/icty/transe54/050228IT.htm |archive-date=7 April 2005 |title=050228IT}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.icty.org/ |title=International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia – United Nations International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia |website=www.icty.org}}</ref> <ref>{{cite web|first=David |last=Rohde |url=http://www.columbia.edu/itc/journalism/nelson/rohde/p-10242.html |title=Bosnian Serbs Poisoned Streams To Capture Refugees, Muslims Say |website=]}}</ref> In the 21st century, ] have been condemned due to accusations in the ].<ref>{{cite news|url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3891531.stm |title=Settlers suspected of well attack |work=] |date=13 July 2004}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.maarivintl.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=article&articleID=9734 |title=Settlers suspected of polluting wells |access-date=22 August 2004 |url-status=bot: unknown |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20040822135907/http://www.maarivintl.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=article&articleID=9734 |archive-date=22 August 2004 }}, Maariv, 13 July 2004, retrieved from ] on 18 August 2008.</ref> <ref>{{cite news|url=https://www.theguardian.com/society/2006/mar/01/guardiansocietysupplement4 |title=Running on empty |first=Fred |last=Pearce |work=] |date=1 March 2006}}</ref>

==As libel against Jews==
=== Medieval accusations against Jews ===
]
]
{{See also|Persecution of Jews during the Black Death|Antisemitic tropes}}
Despite some vague understanding of how diseases could spread, the existence of viruses and bacteria was unknown in medieval times, and the outbreak of disease could not be scientifically explained. Any sudden deterioration of health was often blamed on poisoning. Europe was hit by several waves of ] throughout the late Middle Ages. Crowded cities were especially hard hit by the disease, with death tolls as high as 50% of the population. In their distress, emotionally distraught survivors searched desperately for an explanation. The city-dwelling Jews of the Middle Ages, living in walled-up, segregated ] districts, aroused ].<ref>Barzilay, Tzafrir. ''Poisoned Wells: Accusation, Persecution and Minorities in Medieval Europe, 1321-1422,'' Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2022.</ref> An outbreak of plague thus became the trigger for ], with hundreds of Jews burned at the stake, or rounded up in synagogues and private houses that were then set aflame.


] writes in his book ''The Changing Face of Anti-Semitism: From Ancient Times to the Present Day'': ] writes in his book ''The Changing Face of Anti-Semitism: From Ancient Times to the Present Day'':
<blockquote>There were no mass attacks against "Jewish poisoners" after the period of the Black Death, but the accusation became part and parcel of antisemitic dogma and language. It appeared again in early 1953 in the form of the "]" in Stalin's last days, when hundreds of Jewish physicians in the Soviet Union were arrested and some of them killed on the charge of having caused the death of prominent Communist leaders... Similar charges were made in the 1980s and 1990s in radical Arab nationalist and Muslim fundamentalist propaganda that accused the Jews of spreading ] and other ]s.<ref>] (2006) ''The Changing Face of Antisemitism: From Ancient Times to the Present Day'', Oxford University Press, ISBN 0-19-530429-2. p.62</ref></blockquote> <blockquote>There were no mass attacks against "Jewish poisoners" after the period of the Black Death, but the accusation became part and parcel of antisemitic dogma and language. It appeared again in early 1953 in the form of the "]" in Stalin's last days, when hundreds of Jewish physicians in the Soviet Union were arrested and some of them killed on the charge of having caused the death of prominent Communist leaders... Similar charges were made in the 1980s and 1990s in radical Arab nationalist and Muslim fundamentalist propaganda that accused the Jews of spreading ] and other ]s.<ref>{{cite book|first=Walter |last=Laqueur |author-link=Walter Laqueur |date=2006 |title=The Changing Face of Antisemitism: From Ancient Times to the Present Day |publisher=] |isbn=0-19-530429-2 |page=62}}</ref></blockquote>

===Modern instances of antisemitic libel===

Allegations of well poisoning entwined with antisemitism have also emerged in the discourse around modern epidemics and pandemics such as ], ], ], ], and ].<ref>{{Cite web |last=Angelika Königseder/Carl-Eric Linsler/Juliane Wetzel |title=From Medieval Well-Poisoning Myths to COVID-19: Antisemitic Conspiracy Fantasies during Epidemics (From our Holdings, 31/03/2021) |url=https://arthur-langerman-foundation.org/en/from-our-holdings-1/ |access-date=28 February 2023 |website=arthur-langerman-foundation.org}}</ref>{{bsn|date=January 2023}}

;EU address by Mahmoud Abbas


In his address to the ] on 23 June 2016, in Brussels, ] president and ] chairman ] made an unsubstantiated allegation, "accusing rabbis of poisoning Palestinian wells".<ref name="HAARETZ-PA-Abbas-Bloodlible">{{cite news|last1=Khoury |first1=Jack |title=Abbas Retracts Claim That Rabbis Called for Poisoning of Palestinian Wells |url=http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.726989 |access-date=27 June 2016 |publisher=] |date=25 June 2016}}</ref> This was based on false media reports saying Israeli rabbis were inciting the poisoning of water of Palestinians, led by a rabbi Shlomo Mlma or Mlmad from the Council of Rabbis in the West Bank settlements. A rabbi by that name could not be located, nor is such an organization listed.<ref name="HaaretzPA-Abbas-BloodLibelAgain">{{cite news|last1=Ravid |first1=Barak |last2=Khoury |first2=Jack |title=Abbas Repeats Debunked Claim That Rabbis Called to Poison Palestinian Water in Brussels Speech |url=http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.726657 |access-date=27 June 2016 |agency=] and ] |publisher=] Daily Newspaper Ltd. |date=23 June 2016}}</ref>
===Contemporary accusations===
At the end of World War II, Lithuanian Jew ] was one of the founders of a secret organization ] (revenge), also known as Dam Yisrael Noter ("the blood of Israel avenges", with the acronym DIN meaning "judgement") whose purpose was to seek revenge for the ]. Two plans were formulated. Plan A was to kill a large number of German citizens by poisoning the water supplies of Hamburg, Frankfurt, Munich, and Nuremberg. Plan B was to kill SS prisoners held in Allied POW camps. In pursuit of Plan A, members of the group were infiltrated into water and sewage plants in several cities, while Kovner went to Palestine in search of a suitable poison. Kovner discussed ] with Yishuv leaders, though it is not clear how much he told them and he doesn't seem to have received much support. According to Kovner's own account, ] approved the idea and put him in touch with the scientist Ernst Bergmann, who gave the job of preparing poison to ] (later president of Israel) and his brother Aharon. Historians have expressed doubt over Weizmann's involvement, since he was overseas at the time Kovner specified. The Katzir brothers confirmed that they gave poison to Kovner, but said that he only mentioned Plan B and they denied that Weizmann could be involved. As Kovner and an accomplice were returning to Europe on a British ship, they threw the poison overboard when Kovner was arrested. He was imprisoned for a few months in Cairo and Plan A was abandoned, meaning no well poisoning had actually occurred.<ref>]</ref>


Abbas said: "Only a week ago, a number of rabbis in Israel announced, and made a clear announcement, demanding that their government poison the water to kill the Palestinians ... Isn't that clear incitement to commit mass killings against the Palestinian people?"<ref name="Algemeiner-BloodLibelPA-Abbas">{{cite news|last1=Speyer |first1=Lea |title=State Department Refuses to Condemn Abbas's Blood Libel in Speech to European Parliament (VIDEO) |url=https://www.algemeiner.com/2016/06/26/us-state-department-refuses-to-condemn-abbas-blood-libel-in-european-parliament-speech/ |access-date=27 June 2016 |publisher=] |date=26 June 2016}}</ref>
In recent years, unconfirmed reports of ] in the ] have surfaced. Cases include that of ] found in a well at ] near ] in 2004, although suspected settlers blamed Arab infighting.<ref>, BBC News, 13 July 2004.</ref><ref>{{Wayback |df=yes|date=20040822135907 |url=http://www.maarivintl.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=article&articleID=9734 |title=Settlers suspected of polluting wells }}, Maariv, 13 July 2004, retrieved from ] on 18 August 2008.</ref> In the following years, various ]s reported similar occurrences, accusing settlers of deliberately contaminating cisterns.<ref>, CPTnet, 19 January 2008.</ref><ref>, Channel 4, retrieved on 18 August 2008.</ref><ref>, by Fred Pearce, The Guardian, 1 March 2006</ref>
The speech received a standing ovation.<ref name="HAARETZ-PA-Abbas-Bloodlible"/><ref name="HaaretzPA-Abbas-BloodLibelAgain"/><ref name="NYT-WellPoisoning-PA-PLO-Abbas">{{cite news|url=https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/24/world/middleeast/mahmoud-abbas-claims-rabbis-urged-israel-to-poison-palestinians-water.html |title=Mahmoud Abbas Claims Rabbis Urged Israel to Poison Palestinians' Water |website=] |last1=Hadid |first1=Diaa |date=24 June 2016 |access-date=27 June 2016}}</ref> The speech was described as "echoing anti-Semitic claims".<ref name="NYT-WellPoisoning-PA-PLO-Abbas" /> A day later, on Saturday 26 June, Abbas admitted that "his claims at the EU were baseless".<ref name="AlJazeera-PA-Abbas-BloodLibel">{{cite news|title=Abbas retracts rabbis 'water poisoning' comment |url=http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2016/06/abbas-retracts-rabbis-water-poisoning-comment-160625132534138.html |access-date=27 June 2016 |agency=Source: Agencies |publisher=] Media Network |date=26 June 2016}}</ref><ref name="Jpost-AbbasBloodLibelRetraction">{{cite news|url=http://www.jpost.com/Arab-Israeli-Conflict/Abbas-retracts-charge-that-rabbis-called-for-poisoning-Palestinian-water-457690 |title=Abbas retracts charge that rabbis called to poison Palestinian water |date=25 June 2016 |publisher=] |agency=] |access-date=27 June 2016}}</ref> Abbas' further said that he "didn't intend to do harm to Judaism or to offend Jewish people around the world."<ref name="NYT-AbbasRetactsBloodLibel">
{{cite news|last1=Hadid |first1=Diaa |title=Abbas Retracts Claim That Israeli Rabbis Called for Poisoning Water |url=https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/25/world/middleeast/mahmoud-abbas-israel-rabbis-poison-palestinian-water.html?_r=0 |access-date=27 June 2016 |newspaper=] |date=24 June 2016}}</ref> Israeli Prime Minister ] stated in reaction, that Abbas had spread a "]" in his European Parliament address.<ref name="NYT-AbbasRetactsBloodLibel"/><ref name="Reuters-Abbas-BloodLibel">{{cite news|last1=Emmott |first1=Robin |last2=Williams |first2=Dan |title=Abbas says some Israeli rabbis called for poisoning Palestinian water |url=https://www.reuters.com/article/us-palestinians-israel-idUSKCN0Z91J8 |access-date=27 June 2016 |agency=] |work=] |date=23 June 2016}}</ref>


== See also ==
Accusations of well-poisoning have also been brought up against ]. Most notoriously, Serbs were accused of poisoning ].<ref>, </ref> There are also accusations of well-poisoning as a part of the ].<ref>David Rohde: </ref>
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]


== References ==
In his address to the ] on June 23, 2016, in Brussels—"echoing anti-Semitic claims"<ref name="NYT-WellPoisoning-PA-PLO-Abbas">
{{Reflist|30em}}
{{cite web|
last1=Hadid|
first1=Diaa|
title=Mahmoud Abbas Claims Rabbis Urged Israel to Poison Palestinians’ Water|
url=http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/24/world/middleeast/mahmoud-abbas-claims-rabbis-urged-israel-to-poison-palestinians-water.html|website=The New York Times|
publisher=The New York Times Company|
accessdate=27 June 2016
}}</ref>—] president and ] chairman ] made the unsubstantiated allegation, "accusing rabbis of poisoning Palestinian wells".<ref name="HAARETZ-PA-Abbas-Bloodlible">
{{cite news|
last1=Khoury|
first1=Jack|
title=Abbas Retracts Claim That Rabbis Called for Poisoning of Palestinian Wells|
url=http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.726989|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
publisher=Haaretz.com|
date=Jun 25, 2016}}</ref>
Invoked by "false media reports to claim Israelis are inciting for mass murder of Palestinians",<ref name="HaaretzPA-Abbas-BloodLibelAgain">
{{cite news|
last1=Ravid|first1=Barak|
last2=Khoury|first2=Jack|
title=Abbas Repeats Debunked Claim That Rabbis Called to Poison Palestinian Water in Brussels Speech|
url=http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.726657|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
agency=Reuters and The Associated Press|
publisher=Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd.|date=Jun 23, 2016}}</ref>
Abbas said: "Only a week ago, a number of rabbis in Israel announced, and made a clear announcement, demanding that their government poison the water to kill the Palestinians (..) Isn’t that clear incitement to commit mass killings against the Palestinian people?"<ref name="Algemeiner-BloodLibelPA-Abbas">
{{cite news|
last1=Speyer|first1=Lea|
title=State Department Refuses to Condemn Abbas’s Blood Libel in Speech to European Parliament (VIDEO)|
url=https://www.algemeiner.com/2016/06/26/us-state-department-refuses-to-condemn-abbas-blood-libel-in-european-parliament-speech/|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
publisher=the algemeiner, Algemeiner.com|
date=June 26, 2016}}</ref>
The speech to the European Parliament, he began saying “We are against incitement,”<ref name="NYT-WellPoisoning-PA-PLO-Abbas"/> received a standing ovation.<ref name="HaaretzPA-Abbas-BloodLibelAgain"/><ref name="HAARETZ-PA-Abbas-Bloodlible"/><ref name="NYT-WellPoisoning-PA-PLO-Abbas"/><ref name="Jpost-AbbasBloodLibelRetraction">
{{cite news|
title=Abbas retracts charge that rabbis called to poison Palestinian water|
url=http://www.jpost.com/Arab-Israeli-Conflict/Abbas-retracts-charge-that-rabbis-called-for-poisoning-Palestinian-water-457690|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
agency=Reuters|
publisher=The Jerusalem Post, Jpost Inc.|
date=June 25, 2016}}</ref>
A day later, on Saturday June 26, Abbas admited that "his claims at the EU were baseless".<ref name="AlJazeera-PA-Abbas-BloodLibel">
{{cite news|
title=Abbas retracts rabbis 'water poisoning' comment|
url=http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2016/06/abbas-retracts-rabbis-water-poisoning-comment-160625132534138.html|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
agency=Source: Agencies|
publisher=Al Jazeera Media Network|
date=June 26, 2016}}</ref>
Abbas' further claimed that he "didn't intend to do harm to Judaism or to offend Jewish people around the world."<ref name="NYT-AbbasRetactsBloodLibel">
{{cite news|
last1=Hadid|first1=Diaa|
title=Abbas Retracts Claim That Israeli Rabbis Called for Poisoning Water|
url=http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/25/world/middleeast/mahmoud-abbas-israel-rabbis-poison-palestinian-water.html?_r=0|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
publisher=The New York Times|
date=June 24, 2016}}</ref>
In an reaction to president and chairman Mahmoud Abbas, Israeli Prime Minister ] stated that Mr. Abbas had spread a “]” in his European Parliament address.<ref name="NYT-AbbasRetactsBloodLibel"/><ref name="Reuters-Abbas-BloodLibel">
{{cite news|
last1=Emmott|first1=Robin|
last2=Williams|first2=Dan|
title=Abbas says some Israeli rabbis called for poisoning Palestinian water|
url=http://www.reuters.com/article/us-palestinians-israel-idUSKCN0Z91J8|
accessdate=27 June 2016|
agency=Reuters|
publisher=Reuters|date=June 23, 2016}}</ref>


==See also== == Works cited ==
* {{Cite news |last=Abu Sitta |first=Salman |authorlink=Salman Abu Sitta |title=Traces of Poison–Israel's Dark History Revealed |work=] |date=2003 |url=https://www.plands.org/en/articles-speeches/articles/2003/traces-of-poison%E2%80%93israels-dark-history-revealed |access-date=2024-01-30 |via=Palestine Land Society}}
*]
* {{Cite book |first1=Gary |last1=Ackerman |first2=Victor |last2=Asal |chapter=A Quantitative Overview of Biological Weapons: Identification, Characterization, and Attribution |chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=IUNpSkB510EC&pg=PA186 |pages=186–213 |title=Terrorism, War, or Disease?: Unraveling the Use of Biological Weapons |editor1-last=Clunan |editor1-first=Anne |editor-last2=Lavoy |editor-first2=Peter R. |editor-link2=Peter Lavoy |editor-last3=Martin |editor-first3=Susan B. |date=2008 |publisher=] |isbn=978-0-8047-7981-4 |language=en}}
*]
* {{Cite journal |last=Carus |first=W. Seth |date=2017 |title=A century of biological-weapons programs (1915–2015): reviewing the evidence |url=https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10736700.2017.1385765 |journal=] |language=en |volume=24 |issue=1–2 |pages=129–153 |doi=10.1080/10736700.2017.1385765 |s2cid=148814757 |issn=1073-6700}}
*]
* {{Cite journal |last=Cohen |first=Avner |authorlink=Avner Cohen |date=2001 |title=Israel and chemical/biological weapons: History, deterrence, and arms control |url=http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10736700108436862 |journal=] |language=en |volume=8 |issue=3 |pages=27–53 |doi=10.1080/10736700108436862 |s2cid=219623831 |issn=1073-6700}}
* {{Cite journal |last=Docker |first=John |date=2012 |title=Instrumentalising the Holocaust: Israel, Settler-Colonialism, Genocide (Creating a Conversation between Raphaël Lemkin and Ilan Pappé) |url=https://www.euppublishing.com/doi/10.3366/hls.2012.0027 |journal=] |language=en |volume=11 |issue=1 |pages=1–32 |doi=10.3366/hls.2012.0027 |issn=1474-9475}}
* {{cite journal |last=Martin |first=Susan B. |date=2010 |title=The Battlefield Use of Chemical, Biological and Nuclear Weapons from 1945 to 2008: Structural Realist Versus Normative Explanations |url=https://ssrn.com/abstract=1643305 |journal=American Political Science Association 2010 Annual Meeting Paper}}
* {{Cite journal |last=Leitenberg |first=Milton |authorlink=Milton Leitenberg |date=2001 |title=Biological Weapons in the Twentieth Century: A Review and Analysis |url=https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/20014091096774 |journal=] |language=en |volume=27 |issue=4 |pages=267–320 |doi=10.1080/20014091096774 |pmid=11791799 |s2cid=33988479 |issn=1040-841X}}
* {{Cite journal |last1=Morris |first1=Benny |authorlink1=Benny Morris |last2=Kedar |first2=Benjamin Z. |authorlink2=Benjamin Z. Kedar |date=2023-09-03 |title='Cast thy bread': Israeli biological warfare during the 1948 War |url=https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00263206.2022.2122448 |journal=] |language=en |volume=59 |issue=5 |pages=752–776 |doi=10.1080/00263206.2022.2122448 |s2cid=252389726 |issn=0026-3206}}
* {{cite book|last=Nashef|first=Hania A.M.|title=Palestinian Culture and the Nakba: Bearing Witness|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=QMV1DwAAQBAJ|date=30 October 2018|publisher=Taylor & Francis|isbn=978-1-351-38749-1|access-date=2 April 2021|archive-date=14 January 2023|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20230114054418/https://books.google.com/books?id=QMV1DwAAQBAJ|url-status=live}}
* {{Cite book |authorlink=Ilan Pappe |last=Pappe |first=Ilan |url=https://archive.org/details/pappe-ilan-the-ethnic-cleansing-of-palestine/ |title=The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine |date=2006 |publisher=] |isbn=978-1-78074-056-0 |language=en}}
* {{cite journal |last=Sayigh |first=Rosemary |authorlink=Rosemary Sayigh |date=2009 |title=Hiroshima, al-Nakba: Markers of New Hegemonies |journal=Kyoto Bulletin of Islamic Area Studies |volume=3 |issue=1 |pages=151–169 |url=https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/87462/1/10saigh.pdf}}


== External links ==
==References==
* (])
<references/>
*
{{refbegin|2}}
*http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/3891531.stm
* (])
*
{{refend}}
<big>'''Contemporary accusations'''</big>
{{refbegin|2}}
* (])
*
*
{{refend}}


{{DEFAULTSORT:Well Poisoning}} {{DEFAULTSORT:Well Poisoning}}
] ]
] ]
] ]
] ]
] ]
] ]
]
]
]

Latest revision as of 14:02, 27 December 2024

Malicious manipulation of potable water resources For the logical fallacy, see Poisoning the well.

Well poisoning is the act of malicious manipulation of potable water resources in order to cause illness or death, or to deny an opponent access to fresh water resources.

Well poisoning has been historically documented as a strategy during wartime since antiquity, and was used both offensively (as a terror tactic to disrupt and depopulate a target area) and defensively (as a scorched earth tactic to deny an invading army sources of clean water). Rotting corpses (both animal and human) thrown down wells were the most common implementation; in one of the earliest examples of biological warfare, corpses known to have died from common transmissible diseases of the Pre-Modern era such as bubonic plague or tuberculosis were especially favored for well-poisoning.

History of implementation

This section needs expansion. You can help by adding to it. (June 2008)

Instances of medieval usage

Well poisoning has been used as an important scorched earth tactic at least since medieval times. In 1462, for example, Prince Vlad III the Impaler of Wallachia utilized this method to delay his pursuing adversaries. Nearly 500 years later during the Winter War, the Finns rendered wells unusable by planting animal carcasses or feces in them in order to passively combat invading Soviet forces.

Instances of modern usage

During the 20th century, the practice of poisoning wells has lost most of its potency and practicality against an organized force as modern military logistics ensure secure and decontaminated supplies and resources. Nevertheless, German forces during First World War poisoned wells in France as part of Operation Alberich.

After World War 2 Nakam, a paramilitary organisation of about fifty Holocaust survivors, sought revenge for the murder of six million Jews during the Holocaust. The group's leader Abba Kovner went to Mandatory Palestine in order to secure large quantities of poison for poisoning water mains to kill large numbers of Germans. His followers infiltrated the water system of Nuremberg. However, Kovner was arrested upon arrival in the British zone of occupied Germany and had to throw the poison overboard.

Israel poisoned the wells and water supplies of certain Palestinian towns and villages as part of their biological warfare program during the 1948 Palestine war, including a successful operation that caused a typhoid epidemic in Acre in early May 1948, and an unsuccessful attempt in Gaza that was foiled by the Egyptians in late May.

In the late 20th century, accusations of well-poisoning were brought up, most notoriously in relation to the Kosovo Liberation War. In the 21st century, Israeli settlers have been condemned due to accusations in the Occupied Territories.

As libel against Jews

Medieval accusations against Jews

2000 Jews burned to death in Strasbourg 1349 during the Black Death
A medieval picture showing the libel of a jew poisoning a well and so causing the black death
See also: Persecution of Jews during the Black Death and Antisemitic tropes

Despite some vague understanding of how diseases could spread, the existence of viruses and bacteria was unknown in medieval times, and the outbreak of disease could not be scientifically explained. Any sudden deterioration of health was often blamed on poisoning. Europe was hit by several waves of Black Death throughout the late Middle Ages. Crowded cities were especially hard hit by the disease, with death tolls as high as 50% of the population. In their distress, emotionally distraught survivors searched desperately for an explanation. The city-dwelling Jews of the Middle Ages, living in walled-up, segregated ghetto districts, aroused suspicion. An outbreak of plague thus became the trigger for Black Death persecutions, with hundreds of Jews burned at the stake, or rounded up in synagogues and private houses that were then set aflame.

Walter Laqueur writes in his book The Changing Face of Anti-Semitism: From Ancient Times to the Present Day:

There were no mass attacks against "Jewish poisoners" after the period of the Black Death, but the accusation became part and parcel of antisemitic dogma and language. It appeared again in early 1953 in the form of the "doctors' plot" in Stalin's last days, when hundreds of Jewish physicians in the Soviet Union were arrested and some of them killed on the charge of having caused the death of prominent Communist leaders... Similar charges were made in the 1980s and 1990s in radical Arab nationalist and Muslim fundamentalist propaganda that accused the Jews of spreading AIDS and other infectious diseases.

Modern instances of antisemitic libel

Allegations of well poisoning entwined with antisemitism have also emerged in the discourse around modern epidemics and pandemics such as swine flu, Ebola, avian flu, SARS, and COVID-19.

EU address by Mahmoud Abbas

In his address to the European Parliament on 23 June 2016, in Brussels, Palestinian Authority president and PLO chairman Mahmoud Abbas made an unsubstantiated allegation, "accusing rabbis of poisoning Palestinian wells". This was based on false media reports saying Israeli rabbis were inciting the poisoning of water of Palestinians, led by a rabbi Shlomo Mlma or Mlmad from the Council of Rabbis in the West Bank settlements. A rabbi by that name could not be located, nor is such an organization listed.

Abbas said: "Only a week ago, a number of rabbis in Israel announced, and made a clear announcement, demanding that their government poison the water to kill the Palestinians ... Isn't that clear incitement to commit mass killings against the Palestinian people?" The speech received a standing ovation. The speech was described as "echoing anti-Semitic claims". A day later, on Saturday 26 June, Abbas admitted that "his claims at the EU were baseless". Abbas' further said that he "didn't intend to do harm to Judaism or to offend Jewish people around the world." Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated in reaction, that Abbas had spread a "blood libel" in his European Parliament address.

See also

References

  1. Trotter, William R. (2003). The Winter War, the Russo-Finnish War of 1939–40. London 2003: Aurum Press Ltd. ISBN 1-85410-932-4.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location (link)
  2. Murray, Williamson; Lacey, Jim (eds.). The Making of Peace: Rulers, States, and the Aftermath of War. Cambridge University Press. p. 218.
  3. . The Jewish News of Northern California. 27 March 1998 https://jweekly.com/1998/03/27/survivor-reveals-1945-plan-to-kill-6-million-germans/. Retrieved 25 September 2024. {{cite news}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  4. Morris & Kedar 2023, pp. 752–776, " Taken together, these documents revealed that the Acre and Gaza episodes were merely the tip of the iceberg in a prolonged campaign ... But bulldozing or blowing up houses and wells was deemed insufficient. With its back to the wall, the Haganah upped the ante and unleashed a clandestine campaign of poisoning certain captured village wells with bacteria – in violation of the Geneva Protocol ... The aim of Cast Thy Bread ... like the demolitions, was to hamper an Arab return. Over the weeks, the well-poisoning campaign was expanded to regions beyond the Tel Aviv-Jerusalem road and included Jewish settlements captured or about to be captured by Arab troops, and then to inhabited Arab towns, to facilitate their prospective conquest by the Haganah or to hinder the progress of the invading Arab armies ... The Yishuv’s decision to use the bacteriological weapons was taken at the highest level of the government and military and was, indeed, steered by these officers, with Ben-Gurion’s authorization, through the campaign ... The use of the bacteria was apparently fairly limited in Israel/Palestine during April-December 1948, and apart from Acre, seems to have caused no epidemic and few casualties. At least, that is what emerges from the available documentation."; Nashef 2018, p. 143 n. 4 (quoting Pappe 2006); Carus 2017, p. 145, "Some BW programs relied on extremely crude methods, about as sophisticated as those employed by some terrorist groups or criminals ... The same was true of the reported activities associated with the early Israeli program in 1948."; Docker 2012, pp. 19–20, "The urbicide of May 1948 directed against the old Crusader city of Acre involved biological warfare, including poisoning of water, Pappé writing that it seems clear from Red Cross reports that the Zionist forces besieging the city injected ‘typhoid germs’ into the water supply, which led to a ‘sudden typhoid epidemic’. There was a similar attempt to ‘poison the water supply in Gaza’ on 27 May 1948 by injecting typhoid and dysentery viruses into wells; this attempt was fortunately foiled."; Martin 2010, p. 7, "Israeli biological warfare activities included Operation Shalach, which was an attempt to contaminate the water supplies of Egyptian Army. Egypt reports capture of four ‘Zionists’ trying to infect wells with dysentery and typhoid. There are also allegations that a typhoid outbreak in Acre in 1948 resulted from a biological attack and that there were attacks in Egypt in 1947 and in Syria in 1948."; Sayigh 2009, "A unit had been formed to develop biological weapons, and there is evidence that these were used during 1948 to poison the water supplies of Akka and Gaza with typhoid bacteria."; Ackerman & Asal 2008, p. 191, "Egyptian Ministry of Defense and, later, Israeli historians, contend that Israeli soldiers contaminated Acre’s water supply."; Pappe 2006, pp. 73–4 ("The flame-thrower project was part of a larger unit engaged in developing biological warfare under the directorship of a physical chemist called Ephraim Katzir ... The biological unit he led together with his brother Aharon, started working seriously in February . Its main objective was to create a weapon that could blind people.") and 100–101 ("During the siege typhoid germs were apparently injected into the water. Local emissaries of the International Red Cross reported this to their headquarters and left very little room for guessing whom they suspected: the Hagana. The Red Cross reports describe a sudden typhoid epidemic and, even with their guarded language, point to outside poisoning as the sole explanation for this outbreak ... A similar attempt to poison the water supply in Gaza on 27 May was foiled."); Abu Sitta 2003, "The Zionists injected typhoid in the aqueduct at some intermediate point which passes through Zionist settlements ... The city of Acre, now burdened by the epidemic, fell easy prey to the Zionists. ... Two weeks later, after their "success" in Acre, the Zionists struck again. This time in Gaza, where hundreds of thousands of refugees had gathered after their villages in southern Palestine were occupied. The end however was different. ... The biological crimes perpetrated against the Palestinians in Acre and Gaza in 1948 are still being enacted today."; Leitenberg 2001, p. 289, "As early as April 1948, Ben Gurion directed one of his operatives in Europe (Ehud Avriel) to seek out surviving East European Jewish scientists who could “either increase the capacity to kill masses or to cure masses: both things are important.” At that time, that ‘capacity’ meant chemical and biological weapons ... These were ultimate weapons that could be used either for offense or defense (and the context of the immediate military operations, as well as those that had preceded it, would be the critical factors in that categorization)."; Cohen 2001, p. 31, "It is believed that one of the largest operations in this campaign was in the Arab coastal town of Acre, north of Haifa, shortly before it was conquered by the IDF on May 17,1948. According to Milstein, the typhoid epidemic that spread in Acre in the days before the town fell to the Israeli forces was not the result of wartime chaos but rather a deliberate covert action by the IDF—the contamination of Acre's water supply ... The success of the Acre operation may have persuaded Israeli decisionmakers to continue with these activities. On May 23, 1948, Egyptian soldiers in the Gaza area caught four Israeli soldiers disguised as Arabs near water wells ... It seems that many people knew something about these operations, but both the participants and later historians chose to avoid the issue, which gradually became a national taboo ... Despite the official silence, it appears there is little doubt now about the mission of the failed Gaza operation."
  5. "050228IT". Archived from the original on 7 April 2005.
  6. "International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia – United Nations International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia". www.icty.org.
  7. Rohde, David. "Bosnian Serbs Poisoned Streams To Capture Refugees, Muslims Say". Columbia University.
  8. "Settlers suspected of well attack". BBC News. 13 July 2004.
  9. "Settlers suspected of polluting wells". Archived from the original on 22 August 2004. Retrieved 22 August 2004.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link), Maariv, 13 July 2004, retrieved from Wayback Machine on 18 August 2008.
  10. Pearce, Fred (1 March 2006). "Running on empty". The Guardian.
  11. Barzilay, Tzafrir. Poisoned Wells: Accusation, Persecution and Minorities in Medieval Europe, 1321-1422, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2022.
  12. Laqueur, Walter (2006). The Changing Face of Antisemitism: From Ancient Times to the Present Day. Oxford University Press. p. 62. ISBN 0-19-530429-2.
  13. Angelika Königseder/Carl-Eric Linsler/Juliane Wetzel. "From Medieval Well-Poisoning Myths to COVID-19: Antisemitic Conspiracy Fantasies during Epidemics (From our Holdings, 31/03/2021)". arthur-langerman-foundation.org. Retrieved 28 February 2023.
  14. ^ Khoury, Jack (25 June 2016). "Abbas Retracts Claim That Rabbis Called for Poisoning of Palestinian Wells". Haaretz. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  15. ^ Ravid, Barak; Khoury, Jack (23 June 2016). "Abbas Repeats Debunked Claim That Rabbis Called to Poison Palestinian Water in Brussels Speech". Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. Reuters and The Associated Press. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  16. Speyer, Lea (26 June 2016). "State Department Refuses to Condemn Abbas's Blood Libel in Speech to European Parliament (VIDEO)". Algemeiner Journal. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  17. ^ Hadid, Diaa (24 June 2016). "Mahmoud Abbas Claims Rabbis Urged Israel to Poison Palestinians' Water". The New York Times. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  18. "Abbas retracts rabbis 'water poisoning' comment". Al Jazeera Media Network. Source: Agencies. 26 June 2016. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  19. "Abbas retracts charge that rabbis called to poison Palestinian water". The Jerusalem Post. Reuters. 25 June 2016. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  20. ^ Hadid, Diaa (24 June 2016). "Abbas Retracts Claim That Israeli Rabbis Called for Poisoning Water". The New York Times. Retrieved 27 June 2016.
  21. Emmott, Robin; Williams, Dan (23 June 2016). "Abbas says some Israeli rabbis called for poisoning Palestinian water". Reuters. Reuters. Retrieved 27 June 2016.

Works cited

External links

Categories: