Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 07:10, 5 July 2021

Roshogolla (বাংলায় রসগোল্লা বা রসোগোল্লা)

Pahala rasagolas from Odisha (left) and Bengali roshogollas from West Bengal (right)
Alternative names	Roshogolla, rossogolla, rasagola, roshogolla
Course	Dessert
Place of origin	West Bengal (Rosogolla), Odisha (Rasagola)
Region or state	Indian subcontinent
Associated cuisine	India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal
Serving temperature	Hot, cold, or room temperature
Main ingredients	chhana, sugar
Variations	Bengali Roshogolla (বাংলায় রসগোল্লা বা রসোগোল্লা), Odia Rasagola
Similar dishes	Rosomalai, Khiramohana, Khondoler roshogolla
Cookbook: Rosogolla   Media: Roshogolla (বাংলায় রসগোল্লা বা রসোগোল্লা)

Rosogolla or Rasagola or Roshogolla (বাংলায় রসগোল্লা বা রসোগোল্লা) is a South Asian syrupy dessert popular in the Indian subcontinent and regions with South Asian diaspora. It is made from ball-shaped dumplings of chhena (an Indian cottage cheese, বাংলায় ছানা) and semolina dough, cooked in light syrup made of sugar. This is done until the syrup permeates the dumplings.

In 2016, the West Bengal government applied for a Geographical Indications (GI) tag for the variant called "Banglar Roshogolla" (Bengali Roshogolla) or normal Roshogolla, clarifying that the Bengal and Odisha variants were different in "both in colour, texture, taste, juice content and method of manufacturing."

In 2015, a committee formed by the government of Odisha asserted that the sweet had originated in Odisha, where it is offered at the Puri Jagannath Temple.

In 2017, when West Bengal got its Rosogolla's Geographical indication status, the Registry office of India clarified that West Bengal was given GI status for Banglar Rosogolla and Odisha can claim it too if they cite the place of origin of their variant along with colour, texture, taste, juice content and method of manufacturing.

In 2018, Odisha government applied for GI status for "Odisha Rasagola" (Odia Rasagola was declared different from normal or Bengali Roshogolla), which got approved by GI Registry of India and subsequently Odisha got its own Rasagola's GI status on 29 July 2019.

Some Bangladeshi confectioners and food historians believe Roshogolla originated in Bangladesh and later on got popularized by Nabin Chandra Das in Kolkata, but others dispute this claim.

Names

The dessert is known as Rosogolla or Roshogolla in Bengali and Rasagola in Odia. Roshogolla is derived from the words ros ("juice") and golla ("ball"). Other names for the dish include Roshgulla (Sylheti), Rasagulla, Rossogolla, Roshogolla, Roshogolla, Rasagolla, and Rasbhari or Rasbari (Nepali).

History

Claims of invention in West Bengal

The spongy white Roshogolla is believed to have been introduced in present-day West Bengal in 1868 by a Kolkata-based confectioner named Nobin Chandra Das. Das started making Roshogolla by processing the mixture of chhana and semolina in boiling sugar syrup in contrast to the mixture sans semolina in the original Roshogolla in his sweet shop located at Sutanuti (present-day Baghbazar). His descendants claim that his recipe was an original, but according to another theory, he modified the traditional Odisha Roshogolla recipe to produce this less perishable variant.

Yet another theory is that Roshogolla was first prepared by someone else in Bengal, and Das only popularized it. In Banglar Khabar (1987), food historian Pranab Ray states that a man named Braja Moira had introduced Roshogolla in his shop near Calcutta High Court in 1866, two years before Das started selling the dish. In 1906, Panchana Bandopadhyay wrote that Roshogolla was invented in the 19th century by Haradhan Moira, a Phulia-based sweetmaker who worked for the Pal Chowdhurys of Ranaghat. According to Mistikatha, a newspaper published by West Bengal Sweetmeat Traders Association, many other people prepared similar sweets under different names such as gopalgolla (prepared by Gopal Moira of Burdwan district), jatingolla, bhabanigolla and rasugolla. Food historian Michael Krondl states that irrespective of its origin, the Roshogolla likely predates Nobin Chandra Das. A sales brochure of the company run by Das' descendants also hints at this: "it is hard to tell whether or not cruder versions of similar sweets existed anywhere at that time. Even if they did, they did not match the quality of Nobin Chandra, and having failed to excite the Bengali palate, they slipped into oblivion."

Bhagwandas Bagla, a Marwari businessman and a customer of Nobin Chandra Das, popularized the Bengali Roshogolla beyond the shop's locality by ordering huge amounts.

Claims of Puri temple tradition of Odisha

According to historians of Odisha, the Roshogolla originated in Puri, as khira mohana, which later evolved into the Pahala Roshogolla. It has been traditionally offered as bhog to goddess Lakshmi at Jagannath Temple, Puri. According to the local legend, Laxmi gets upset because her husband Lord Jagannath goes on a 9-day sojourn (the ratha yatra) without her consent. So, she locks Jai Vijay Dwar, one of the temple gates and prevents his convoy from re-entering the sanctum sanctorum of the temple. To appease her, Jagannath offers her Roshogolla. This ritual, known as Bachanika, is part of the "Niladri Bije" (or "Arrival of the God") observance, which marks the return of the deities to the temple after the Ratha Yatra.

The Jagannath Temple scholars such as Laxmidhar Pujapanda and researchers like Jagabandhu Padhi state that the tradition has existed since the 12th century, when the present-day temple structure was first built. Pujapanda states that the Niladri Bije tradition is mentioned in Niladri Mahodaya, which is dated to the 18th century by Sarat Chandra Mahapatra. According to Mahapatra, several temple scriptures, which are over 300 years old, provide the evidence of Roshogolla offering ritual in Puri.

According to folklore, Pahala (a village on the outskirts of Odisha's capital Bhubaneshwar) had a large number of cows. The village would produce excess milk, and the villagers would throw it away when it became spoilt. When a priest from the Jagannath Temple saw this, he taught them the art of curdling, including the recipe for rasagulla. Pahala thus went on to become the biggest market for chhana-based sweets in the area.

According to the Bengali culinary historian Pritha Sen, in the mid-18th century, many Odia cooks were employed in Bengali homes who arguably have introduced Roshogolla along with many other Odia dishes, but there is no substantial claim to prove that. According to another theory, it is possible that the Bengali visitors to Puri might have carried the recipe for Roshogolla back to Bengal in the nineteenth century. But no substantial claim regarding that was ever found by any historian or any one else.

This claim is contested by Bengali historians. According to food historians K. T. Achaya and Chitra Banerji, there are no references to cheese (including chhana) in India before the 17th century. The milk-based sweets were mainly made up of khoa, before the Portuguese influence led to introduction of cheese-based sweets. Therefore, the possibility of a cheese-based dish being offered at Jagannath Temple in the 12th century is highly unlikely. According to Nobin Chandra Das' descendant Animikh Roy and historian Haripada Bhowmik, Roshogolla is not even mentioned as one of the chhappano bhog ("56 offerings") in the early records of the Temple; the name of the sweet was coined in Bengal. They also state that it would have been a blasphemy to offer something made from spoiled milk (chhana) to a deity. However, Michael Krondl argues that Hindu dietary rules vary from region to region, and it is possible that this restriction did not exist in present-day Odisha. But at the same time, he could not give any substantial information to uphold the claim which he was forwarding.

According to Asit Mohanty, an Odia research scholar on Jagannath cult and traditions, the sweet is mentioned as "Rasagola" in the 15th century text Jagamohana Ramayana of Balaram Das. The text mentions Rasagola, along with other sweets found in Odisha. There is also mention of many other cheese made sweets like Chhanapuri, Chhanaladu and Rasabali. Another ancient text Premapanchamruta of Bhupati also mentions cheese (Chhana, বাংলায় ছানা). It is being argued that cheese making process was well known before coming of Portuguese in Odisha.

Claims of Bangladeshi origin

Portuguese settlers made sweet curd cheese and Sandesh-like confections from milk in the sixteenth century, which they brought with them to Bengal. Bengali housewives then improvised the recipe. Late veteran recipe writer and food connoisseur Shawkat Osman told BBC Bangla that ancestors of Nobin Chandra Das, the maker of Roshogolla , were originally from Barisal and they lived near Patuakhali. It is believed that the main origin was formulated in Bangladesh and then became popular in Kolkata.

Modern popularity

In 1930, the introduction of vacuum packing by Nobin Chandra's son Krishna Chandra Das led to the availability of canned Roshogolla, which made the dessert popular outside Kolkata, and subsequently, outside India. Krishna Chandra's son Sarada Charan Das established the K.C. Das Pvt Ltd company in 1946. Sarada Charan's younger, estranged son Debendra Nath established K.C. Das Grandsons in 1956.

Today, canned Roshogollaare available throughout India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, as well as in South Asian grocery stores outside the subcontinent. In Nepal, Roshogolla became popular under the name Rasbari.

The Indian space agency, ISRO is developing dehydrated Roshogollaand other dishes for Indian astronauts in its planned manned missions.

In 2015, the Odisha government initiated a move to get Geographical indication (GI) status for the rasagulla made in Pahala. On 30 July, the people of Odisha celebrated "Rasagola Dibasa" ("Roshogolla Day") to reaffirm Odisha as the place of the dish's origin. In August, West Bengal decided to legally contest Odisha's move to obtain GI Status. In 2015 The odisha state government constituted three committees to claim over the Roshogolla. The committees submitted their interim report to the government. Noted journalist and food researcher Bhakta Tripathy and a member of the committee had submitted dossier containing historical evidence of Roshogolla origin in Odisha. The Science and Technology department of the West Bengal government also started the process to get its own GI status for the dessert.

Rasagola Dibasa

On 30 July 2015, on the day of "Niladri Bije", a social media campaign was started by using a hashtag #RasagolaDibasa and it later became a mainstream celebration as the maiden day to celebrate Roshogolla's origin to be Odisha. Odia newspaper Sambad and FM radio Radio Choklate in collaboration with the confectioners of Pahala celebrated a Roshogolla exhibition-cum-awareness event in Bhubaneswar. Sand artist Sudarshan Patnaik made a sand sculpture in Puri Beach depicting "Niladri Bije" and Jagannath offering Roshogolla to Lakshmi.

It has been agreed upon to celebrate the Rasagola Dibasa every year on the tithi of Niladri Bije in the lunar calendar. In the year 2016, the Rasagola Dibasa has been celebrated on 17 July.

Preparation

To prepare Roshogolla, the cheese (chhana) mixture is formed into small balls. These balls are then simmered in a sugar syrup. It can also be prepared using a pressure cooker or an oven. While serving add a drop of rose water (only organic and edible type of rose water, not rose perfume or synthetic flavors) to enhance the flavor and taste.

• Chhana divided into balls
• Chenna balls being boiled
• Roshogolla being taken out of the syrup

Variations

The Pahal Rasagola from the Pahala area (located between the cities of Bhubaneswar and Cuttack) is also popular in India.

• Roshogolla from Kolkata, India
• Reddish Roshogolla from Pahala, Odisha
• Bikali Kar Rasagola from Salepur, Cuttack, Odisha
• Rasagola from Bhubaneswar, Odisha
• Rajbhog - variant of jaffran Roshogolla stuffed inside with dry fruits and khoa Rajbhog - variant of jaffran Roshogolla stuffed inside with dry fruits and khoa
• Kamalabhog, an orange-flavoured Bengali Roshogolla
• Baked Roshogolla - a Bengali variation
• Rasagola from Kalahandi,Odisha
• Roshogolla and Golap Jam (mishti)

Derivatives and similar desserts

Along with chhanar gaja and chhana poda, Roshogolla is one of three traditional Odia chhana desserts. Due to Roshogolla becoming associated with the Bengali cuisine, the Odisha Milk Federation has tried to popularize chhana poda as the signature Odia dessert.

Nutrition

Typically, a 100-gram serving of Roshogolla contains 186 calories, out of which about 153 calories are in the form of carbohydrates. It also contains about 1.85 grams of fat and 4 grams of protein.

Geographical Indication (GI) tag

In 2015, West Bengal applied for a Geographical Indication (GI) status for "Banglar Rasogolla" (Bengali Roshogolla). The Government clarified that there was no conflict with Odisha, and its application was only for a specific variant which was different in "both in colour, texture, taste, juice content and method of manufacturing" from the variant produced in Odisha. And the same goes for the Odisha Roshogolla, which can be claimed as a variant of the Bengali Rasagulla. On 14 November 2017, the GI Registry of India granted West Bengal the GI status for Banglar Rasogolla.

The GI Registrar office at Chennai later specifically clarified that West Bengal was given GI status only for the Bengali version of Roshogolla ("Banglar Rasogolla"), not for the sweet's origin. The office also stated that Odisha had not by then applied for any GI tag, but it could also get Odisha Roshogolla's GI tag by presenting the necessary evidence.

In 2018 Odisha had applied for GI status in Chennai GI Registry. On 29 July 2019 the GI Registry of India granted Odisha the GI status for Odisha Rasagola.

See also

• Bangladeshi cuisine
• Bengali cuisine
• Odia cuisine
• Odisha Rasagola
• Mysore pak
• Dharwad pedha
• List of Indian sweets and desserts

References

1. ^ "Our Claim Only On A Variety Of Rasogolla, No Dispute With Odisha: West Bengal". NDTV. Press Trust Of India. 27 July 2016. Retrieved 24 August 2016.
2. "Panel seal on Roshogolla's Odisha origin". Retrieved 2 October 2016.
3. Sarat Chandra Mahapatra (1994). Car Festival of Lord Jagannath, Puri. Puri: Sri Jagannath Research Centre. p. 149. OCLC 967072714.
4. ^ "Sweet War: This GI tag is for Banglar Rosogolla, it is not about the origin". The New Indian Express. 14 November 2017.
5. "GI Certificate by Govt of India" (PDF).
6. ^ "Sweet success: Odisha's Rasagola gets GI tag". The Indian Express. 29 July 2019. Retrieved 29 July 2019.
7. ^ "Battle Over Origin of 'Roshogolla' Contines, After Odisha Files Petition Demanding Change of GI Tag". News18. Retrieved 29 July 2019.
8. "Odisha Finally Gets Geographical Indication Tag For 'Odishara Rasagola'". Outlook. Retrieved 29 July 2019.
9. Nur, Shah Alam. "War on Rasgulla". The Asian Age. Bangladesh. Retrieved 27 September 2020.
10. রসগোল্লা আবিষ্কারক বরিশাল অঞ্চলের লোক. BBC News Bangla (in Bengali). 9 March 2016. Retrieved 29 September 2020.
11. "Rasgulla@Oxford Dictionaries" (in Hindi). India: Oxford University Press. Retrieved 28 August 2015.
12. Deepika Sahu (2 July 2012). "Discover Odisha's 'sweet' magic". The Times of India.
13. "History of rossogolla now just a click away". The Times of India. 15 March 2013.
14. "Of luchi, rolls & roshogolla in Durga puja". Daily Bhaskar. 29 September 2011.
15. ^ "Rasagola originated in Odisha- Did you know?". Zee News. 30 July 2015.
16. Sonali Pattnaik (18 July 2013). "How to make…Rasagolla". The Hindu.
17. ^ Alan Davidson (21 September 2006). The Oxford Companion to Food. OUP Oxford. p. 1880. ISBN 978-0-19-101825-1.
18. Subodh Chandra, Sengupta, ed. (1976). Samsad Bangla Charitabhidhan (1st ed.). Kolkata: Sahitya Samsad. p. 240. Retrieved 23 February 2018.
19. Ghosh, Bishwanath (15 November 2014). "Kolkata Chromosome: Like KC for 'rossogolla'". mint. Retrieved 29 September 2020.
20. Sankar Ray (31 July 2011). "Where is the creativity that gave us the Rosogolla?". DNA.
21. ^ Ishita Dey (2015). Michael Krondl; et al. (eds.). The Oxford Companion to Sugar and Sweets. Oxford University Press. pp. 580–581. ISBN 978-0-19-931361-7.
22. "The sweet legacy of Durga Puja". The Times of India. 29 September 2014.
23. ^ Michael Krondl (2011). Sweet Invention: A History of Dessert. Chicago Review Press. pp. 55–59. ISBN 978-1-55652-954-2.
24. "How the rasogolla became a global name!". rediff.com. 16 November 2011.
25. ^ Mitra Bishwabijoy (6 July 2015). "Who invented the rasgulla?". Times of India. Retrieved 2 August 2015.
26. "Trinity take 'adhar pana' on raths". The New Indian Express. 5 July 2009.
27. Subhashish Mohanty (3 July 2012). "Lord placates wife with sweet delight".
28. "Sweet and sermon return for deities". The Telegraph. Calcutta. 26 July 2010.
29. ^ Mohapatra Bhattacharya; Debabrata Kajari (31 July 2015). "Citing Rath ritual, Odisha lays claim to rasagulla, WB historians don't agree". Times of India. Retrieved 1 August 2015.
30. Jagabandhu Padhi (2000). Sri Jagannatha at Puri. S.G.N. Publications.
31. Sarat Chandra Mahapatra (1994). Car Festival of Lord Jagannath, Puri. Puri: Sri Jagannath Research Centre. p. 55. OCLC 967072714.
32. Debabrata Mohapatra (29 July 2007). "Researchers Claim Roshogolla Were Born In Puri". The Times of India.
33. Madhulika Dash (11 September 2014). "The Food Story: How India's favourite sweet dish rosogulla was born". Indian Express.
34. Michael Krondl (Summer 2010). "The Sweetshops of Kolkata". Gastronomica. 10 (3): 58–65. doi:10.1525/gfc.2010.10.3.58.
35. Shoaib Daniyal (4 August 2015). "Who Deserves Credit For The Rasgulla? Bengalis, Odiyas...Or The Portuguese?". Kashmir Observer. Archived from the original on 9 October 2015.
36. ^ Jhimli Mukherjee Pandey (10 August 2015). "Maharashtra (West Bengal) takes up rosogolla battle with Odisha". The Times of India.
37. "Hopes for Rasagola Origin in Odisha Revived". The Pioneer. 15 July 2016. Retrieved 20 July 2016.
38. Ramayana, Jagamohan. Ramayana. Ajodhya Kanda: Balaram Das.
39. Typical selections from Oriya Literature. Ramayana. B.C. Mazumdar. p. 84.
40. G. C. Praharaj (1931–1940). Purnnacandra Odia Bhashakosha. Cuttack: Utkal Sahitya Press. p. 2594. Retrieved 20 July 2016.
41. রসগোল্লা আবিষ্কারক বরিশাল অঞ্চলের লোক. BBC Bangla (in Bengali). 9 March 2016.
42. "Rosogolla pride West Bengal's". Daily Star. 15 November 2017.
43. "War on Rasgulla". Daily Asian Age. 26 August 2016.
44. Piyasree Dasgupta (29 October 2011). "Sticky Sweet Success". Indian Express.
45. Bishwanath Ghosh (29 October 2014). Longing, Belonging: An Outsider At Home In Calcutta. Westland. p. 177. ISBN 978-93-84030-60-5.
46. Ram Kumar Ramaswamy (16 June 2012). "Isro astronauts to savour idlis, rasgullas in space". Asian Age.
47. ^ Ramani Ranjan Mohapatra (30 July 2015). "#RasagolaDibasa trends as Odias reclaim iconic dish". Hindustan Times.
48. Sumit Behera (16 October 2015). "Sweet Struggle - Origin of Roshogolla". rissadiary.com. Archived from the original on 18 August 2016.
49. "West Bengal and Odisha Battle Over the Invention of 'Roshogolla'". NDTV. 26 August 2015.
50. Dhrubo Jyoti (30 July 2015). "Revenge is sweet: How Bengalis made rosogolla their own". Retrieved 2 August 2015.
51. "Odisha celebrates 'Rasagola Dibasa' with great fanfare". 31 July 2015. Retrieved 2 August 2015.
52. "Odisha celebrates 'Rasagola Dibasa', state claims evidence of origin". The Times of India. Retrieved 21 July 2016.
53. Lois Sinaiko Webb (1 January 2000). Multicultural Cookbook of Life-cycle Celebrations. ABC-CLIO. pp. 309–. ISBN 978-1-57356-290-4.
54. Tarla Dalal (17 November 2003). Desserts Under Ten Minutes. Sanjay & Co. pp. 69–. ISBN 978-81-86469-84-2.
55. Tarla Dalal (2006). Low Calorie Sweets. Sanjay & Co. pp. 42–. ISBN 978-81-89491-34-5.
56. Rimli Sengupta (9 January 2012). "Kling Canoes At Tamralipta". Outlook.
57. Rajaram Satapathy (15 August 2002). "Sweet wars: Chhenapoda Vs rasagolla". The Times of India.
58. "Chew on This: Chenna poda". Metro Plus Kochi. The Hindu. 11 April 2009. Archived from the original on 16 April 2009.
59. Nutrition Information For Rasgulla. Livestrong.Com. Retrieved on 6 December 2012.
60. "Intellectual Property India". ipindiaservices.gov.in. Retrieved 15 November 2017.
61. "Certificate of Registration of Geographical Indication under section 16 (1)-or of authotised user under section 17(3)(e)" (PDF). Intellectual Property India. 14 November 2017. Retrieved 15 November 2017.
62. "Odisha Rasagola receives geographical indication tag; here's what it means". Business Today. Retrieved 29 July 2019.

v t e Culture of West Bengal
Cuisine	Baingan bharta Bori Gohona Bori Chingri malai curry Kheer Khichuri Machh bhaja Machher Jhol Mishti doi Nabadwip-er lal doi Pithe Rasogolla Rice Sandesh Sorshe Ilish Abar Khabo
Dance	Classical dance Gaudiya Nritya Rabindra Nritya Natya Folk dance Alkap Brita dance Chhau Dhamail Dhunuchi Nritya Domni Gombhira Kalikapatadi Kushan dance Raibenshe Tusu dance
Music	Cultural songs Agamani-Vijaya Atulprasadi Sangeet Bishnupur Gharana Dwijendrageeti Nazrul Geeti Prabhat Samgiita Rabindra Sangeet Shyama Sangeet Folk songs Baromasya Song Baul Bhadu Song Bhatiali Bhawaiya Bolan Song Ghatu Song Gombhira Hapu song Kirtan Patua Sangeet Shreekrishna Kirtana Tusu Song
Handlooms and handicrafts	Handloom Baluchari Sari Nakshi kantha Kantha Tant sari Tangail Saree Handicrafts Bankura horse Chhau Mask Dhokra Santiniketan Leather Goods Shital Pati Wooden dolls Madurkathi
Observations and festivals	Darjeeling Carnival Dharmathakur Dola jatra Durga Puja Durga Puja Carnival Guptipara Rathayatra Jagaddhatri Puja Joydeb-Kenduli Mela Kali Puja Lakshmi Puja Mahishadal Rathayatra Makar Sankranti Nobanno Poila Boishakh Poush Mela Rathayatra Rathayatra of Mahesh Shakta Rash Sindur Khela
Arts	Alpona Bankura horse Manasa chali Chalchitra Dashabatar Cards Durga pot Kalighat Painting Patachitra Sholapith Terracotta
Other	Barowari Bônggabdô Dakshin Rai
India portal Category

• Bangladeshi desserts
• Bengali desserts
• Geographical indications in West Bengal
• Indian cheese dishes
• Indian desserts
• Nepalese cuisine
• Odia cuisine
• Mauritian cuisine
• Vegetarian dishes of India
• Geographical indications in Odisha
• Semolina dishes
• Cheese desserts