| Revision as of 05:20, 1 August 2007 editMastCell (talk | contribs)Edit filter managers, Administrators43,155 edits →Additional issues to be mediated← Previous edit | Revision as of 14:13, 4 August 2007 edit undoChido6d (talk | contribs)438 edits →Additional issues to be mediatedNext edit → | ||
| Line 37: | Line 37: | ||
| * Suppression of relevant details, such as the identity of a Justice in a high profile lawsuit, possibly in order to mislead readers of the article. | * Suppression of relevant details, such as the identity of a Justice in a high profile lawsuit, possibly in order to mislead readers of the article. | ||
| * Recurring accusations that every difference over content is motivated by a desire to mislead the reader or suppress information | * Recurring accusations that every difference over content is motivated by a desire to mislead the reader or suppress information | ||
| * In general, edits based not on accuracy or to improve the article based on Misplaced Pages's pillars. Addition of some information and suppression of other information based on seemingly fabricated objections which appear to be based on editor's own point of view and bias |
* In general, edits based not on accuracy or to improve the article based on Misplaced Pages's pillars. Addition of some information and suppression of other information based on seemingly fabricated objections which appear to be based on editor's own point of view and bias | ||
| * Avoiding the use of words like "suppression", "fabricated", etc when describing good-faith content disagreements | * Avoiding the use of words like "suppression", "fabricated", etc when describing good-faith content disagreements | ||
| * Abuse of Misplaced Pages's ] assumption policy in order to undermine ] | |||
| ===Parties' agreement to mediate=== | ===Parties' agreement to mediate=== | ||
Revision as of 14:13, 4 August 2007
Passive smoking
view
edit
delete
watch
Filed: 14:05, July 19 2007 (UTC)
Involved parties
- Mickeyklein (talk · contribs · email)
- MastCell (talk · contribs · email)
- Yilloslime (talk · contribs · email)
- John Quiggin (talk · contribs · email)
- Chido6d (talk · contribs · email)
- Dessources (talk · contribs · email)
Articles involved
Other steps in dispute resolution that have been attempted
- Talk:Passive_smoking#Edits_by_User:Mickeyklein
- http://en.wikipedia.org/Talk:Passive_smoking#Chido6d.27s_edits
- http://en.wikipedia.org/Talk:Passive_smoking#POV_tag
Issues to be mediated
- Inclusion of "non-Government-backed material"
- WP:NPOV
- Suppression of IARC/World Health Organization study conclusion to apparently preserve activist viewpoint(s)
- Article text clearly at odds with information in sources
- Statements presented as factual rather than as scientific consensus and/or being attributed to their sources
- Unnecessarily bloating section of conflicting viewpoint(s), either through attempts to thoroughly discredit them at length rather than describe them objectively, or through attempts to give undue weight to small-minority positions.
Additional issues to be mediated
- Ad Hominem exclusion of evidence
- Use of talk page and talk page guidelines, and Misplaced Pages as a soapbox
- Representation of minority views in proportion to their acceptance among experts (WP:WEIGHT)
- Suppression of relevant details, such as the identity of a Justice in a high profile lawsuit, possibly in order to mislead readers of the article.
- Recurring accusations that every difference over content is motivated by a desire to mislead the reader or suppress information
- In general, edits based not on accuracy or to improve the article based on Misplaced Pages's pillars. Addition of some information and suppression of other information based on seemingly fabricated objections which appear to be based on editor's own point of view and bias
- Avoiding the use of words like "suppression", "fabricated", etc when describing good-faith content disagreements
- Abuse of Misplaced Pages's good faith assumption policy in order to undermine WP:NPOV
Parties' agreement to mediate
- All parties should sign below, indicating that they agree to mediate the issue. If any party fails to sign, or if a party indicates they do not agree, then the mediation will be rejected. Only "agree" or "disagree" and signatures should appear here; any comments will be removed.
- Agree Mickeyklein 16:54, 19 July 2007 (UTC)
- Agree JQ 02:10, 21 July 2007 (UTC)
- Agree. MastCell 04:06, 21 July 2007 (UTC)
- Agree.Yilloslime 04:46, 21 July 2007 (UTC)
- Agree. Chido6d 22:34, 21 July 2007 (UTC)
- Agree. Dessources 23:07, 21 July 2007 (UTC)
Decision of the Mediation Committee
A member of the Mediation Committee will indicate acceptance/rejection/other relevant notes in this section. Non-mediators should not edit this section.
- Accept.
- For the Mediation Committee, Daniel 01:16, 22 July 2007 (UTC)
- Adopting case'. Vassyana 03:26, 26 July 2007 (UTC)