Vandalism: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively ← Previous edit Next edit →Content deleted Content addedVisual WikitextInline

Revision as of 21:00, 25 June 2008 view sourceNese sou (talk \| contribs)19 edits Undid revision 221304692 by ivandal (talk)← Previous edit		Revision as of 21:00, 25 June 2008 view source ClueBot (talk \| contribs)1,596,818 editsm Reverting possible vandalism by Nese sou to version by Acalamari. False positive? Report it. Thanks, User:ClueBot. (425103) (Bot)Next edit →
Line 1:		Line 1:
			{{pp-semi-vandalism\|small=yes}}
	{{Title\|]}}
			{{selfref\|For vandalism-related policy on Misplaced Pages, see ].}}
			{{For\|the band\|Vandalism (band)}}
			{{Crimes}}
			{{Refimprove\|date=June 2008}}
			'''Vandalism''' is the behaviour attributed to the ]s in respect of ]: ruthless ] or spoiling of anything ] or ].<ref>{{cite web\|title=Oxford English Dictionary\|url=http://www.oed.com\|accessdate=06 May 2008\|publisher=Oxford University Press}}</ref> Such action includes ], ], ] and crass ] of an ].

			== History of the term ==
			Historically, vandalism has been justified by painter ] as destruction of monuments symbolizing "war and conquest". Therefore, it is often done as an expression of contempt, creativity, or both. Vandalism is only a meaningful concept in a culture that recognizes ] and ]. Like other similar terms (]/], and ]), the term ''Vandal'' was originally an ] referring to the ], who under ] ] ] in ]. The Vandals, like the Philistines, no longer exist as an identifiable ethnic group.
			The term in its modern acceptance was coined in January 1794 during the ], by ], ] of ], in his report directed to the Republican Convention, where he used word ''Vandalisme'' to describe some aspects of the behaviour of the republican army. ]'s attempt, during the 1871 ], to dismantle the ], a symbol of the past ] authoritarian Empire, was one of the most celebrated events of vandalism. ] himself would meditate after the Commune on the "fight against culture", taking as example the intentional burning of the ] on ] ]. "The criminal fight against culture is only the reverse side of a criminal culture" wrote ] after quoting Nietzsche.<ref name="klossowski">See ], ''Nietzsche and the Vicious Circle'', first Chapter: What is the value of culture if those who are exploited by it destroy it? ''"En sorte qu'il nous faut être bien loin de vouloir, du haut de notre sentiment de nous-mêmes, imputer le crime d'un combat contre la culture exclusivement à ces malheureux.'' Je sais ce que cela veut dire: le combat contre la culture. (...) '' je me campronnai avec une conviction sérieuse à la valeur métaphysique de l'art, lequel ne saurait exister à cause des pauvres gens, mais doit accomplir des missions plus hautes. Mais, en dépit de mon extrême douleur, je n'étais pas en état de jeter la moindre pierre à ces profanateurs qui, pour moi, n'étaient que les suppôts de la culpabilité universelle, sur laquelle il y a beaucoup à méditer!"'' (Nietzsche quoted by Klossowski pp.29-30 French edition, who adds: ''"Le combat criminel contre la culture n'est lui-même que l'envers d'une culture criminelle"'' ("The criminal fight against culture is only the reverse side of a criminal culture")</ref>

			In a proposal to the International Conference for Unification of Criminal Law held in Madrid in 1933, ] envisaged the creation of two new international crimes (delicta ]): the crime of barbarity, consisting in the extermination of racial, religious or social collectivities, and the crime of vandalism, consisting in the destruction of cultural and artistic works of these groups.<ref>]: , Anwaltsblatt Internationales (Wien), ] ].</ref> The proposal was not accepted.

			==Vandalism as crime==
			{{Cleanup\|date=February 2008}}<!-- does anyone know about a template to mark too much humor? -->
			Private citizens commit vandalism when they wilfully damage or deface the ] of others or the ]. Some vandalism qualifies as ] or ] — it is artistic in nature as well as being carried out illegally or without the property owner's permission. Examples include at least some ] art, billboard liberation and possibly ],
			] vandalism has many forms, ] on ] is common in many ] as part of a ] ], however other more devastating forms such as those involved with public unrest, such as ], involve the wilful destruction of public and ], Vandalism per se is often considered one of the least serious common crimes, but it can become quite serious and distressing when committed extensively, violently or as an expression of hatred and intimidation.

			===Examples===

			Examples of vandalism include salting lawns, cutting trees without permission, egg throwing, breaking windows, ], spraying paint on others' properties, ], placing glue into locks, tire slashing, ''keying'' (scratching) paint, ransacking a place and flooding someones house by clogging a sink and leaving the water on.

			]
	] untouched by vand...damn it...not again.]]
			]
			]
			In the case of vandalism to private property, the owner — the victim, may feel that they were specifically targeted by the perpetrator(s) — this is not necessarily the case. An example of such a crime would be the wilful destruction of a car window for no obvious purpose save to give the perpetrator(s) possibly a few seconds of entertainment, with no consideration, or empathy for the detriment to the state of mind or inconvenience of the victim.

			===Motives===
	'''Vandalism''' is any addition, deletion, or change to content made in a deliberate attempt to reduce the quality of the encyclopedia. The most common type of vandalism is the replacement of existing text with obscenities, page blanking, or the insertion of meta-jokes or other nonsense. Fortunately, this kind of vandalism <choose>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	<option>.</option>
	</choose>

			Reasoning for such actions can be attributed to anger, envy or spontaneous, opportunistic behaviour — possibly for peer acceptance or ] in ] cultures, or disgruntlement with the target (victim) person or society. Opportunistic vandalism of this nature may also be filmed, the mentality of which can be akin to ]. The large scale prevalence of gang graffiti in some inner cities has almost made it acceptable to the societies based there — so much so that it may go unnoticed, or not be removed, possibly because it may be a fruitless endeavour, to be graffitied on once again.
	Any good-faith effort to improve the encyclopedia, even if misguided or ill-considered, is not vandalism. Apparent bad-faith edits that do not make their bad-faith nature inarguably explicit are not considered vandalism at Misplaced Pages. For example, adding an opinion once is not vandalism — it's just not helpful, and should be removed or restated.

			===Reaction of authorities===
	Committing vandalism is a violation of the Misplaced Pages policy; it needs to be spotted, and then dealt harshly with — {{gender}}users are encouraged to report and revert any vandalism they see.

			In view of its incivility, ] for vandalism can be particularly severe in some countries. In ], for example, a person who attempts to cause or commits an act of vandalism may be liable to ] for up to 3 years and in conjunction may be punished with ]. The act of vandalism in UK is construed as an ] and may be dealt with an ] (Anti-Social Behavior Order).
	== Wiki Vandalism ==
	]

			Former ] ] ] made a crackdown on vandalism a centerpiece of his anti-crime agenda in the 1990s, asserting that a strong campaign against nonviolent "quality of life" crimes such as vandalism would cause a corresponding decrease in violent crime. However much credit can be given to Giuliani's anti-vandalism crusade, FBI statistics claim that New York's crime rate plummeted during his tenure.<ref>{{cite press release \| title = FBI Crime Statistics For Calendar Year 2000 Show Drop In New York City Crime \| publisher = NYC Mayor's Press Office \| date = 2001-05-30 \| url = http://www.nyc.gov/html/om/html/2001a/pr181-01.html \| accessdate = 2007-08-04 }}</ref>
	'''Wiki vandalism''' is generally defined as editing a ] in a way that is intentionally disruptive or destructive. There are four generally acknowledged types of vandalism: deletion of legitimate information, insertion of noncents or ] content, addition of unwanted commercial links (]), and policy violations specific to that wiki.

			==Vandalism as art==
	=== Spotting Vandalism ===
			{{Details\|Graffiti}}
	]
			] is a common form of vandalism]]
			]. Note the cross incised on the statue's forehead and the broken off nose. See ].<ref></ref> ]]

	I know it when I see it

			Though vandalism in itself is illegal, it is often also an integral part of modern popular culture. French painter ]'s attempt to disassemble the ] during the 1871 ] was probably one of the first artistic vandalist acts, celebrated at least since ] performances during ]. The Vendôme column was considered a symbol of the past ] empire, and dismantled as such.
	Does it really need to be defined?

			After the burning of the ] on ] ], Philosopher ] himself meditated about the "fight against culture", wondering what could justify culture if it were to be destroyed in such a "senseless" manner (the arguments are: culture is justified by works of art and scientific achievements; exploitation is necessary to those achievements, leading to the creation of exploited people who then fight against culture. In this case, culture can't be legitimised by art achievements, and Nietzsche writes: "I {also} know what it means: fighting against culture". After quoting him, ] writes: "The criminal fight against culture is only the reverse side of a criminal culture"<ref name="klossowski"/>
	It's arguable that most (identified) vandalism has consisted of really quite obvious cases. Hence, Misplaced Pages doesn't need to define an "official" policy on what constitutes vandalism at all. We can use the rule of thumb, "When a reasonable person might be in doubt as to whether something is vandalism, it would be polite not to call it vandalism."

			As destruction of ], vandalism can only have sense in a culture respecting ], ] - Nietzsche spoke of ''monumental history''. As destruction of monumental history, vandalism was assured a long ] (as ] proved): ] could make such a claim, as well as ]'s ''poetic terrorism'' or ''Destroy 2000 Years of Culture'' from ]. Gustave Courbet's declaration stated:
	Of course, that depends on the normative definitions of "obvious", "reasonable" and "polite", which are necessarily subjective, and vary from encyclopedia to uncyclopedia.

			<blockquote>"Attendu que la colonne Vendôme est un monument dénué de toute valeur artistique, tendant à perpétuer par son expression les idées de guerre et de conquête qui étaient dans la dynastie impériale, mais que réprouve le sentiment d’une nation républicaine, émet le vœu que le gouvernement de la Défense nationale veuille bien l’autoriser à déboulonner cette colonne."<ref>{{cite web \| language = French \| title = La Colonne Vendôme déboulonnée \| publisher = \| url = http://www.histoire-image.org/site/etude_comp/etude_comp_detail.php?analyse_id=60 \| accessdate = 2007-08-04 }}</ref></blockquote>
	] is vandalism where both the reader and the contributor agree that it is vandalism. This is sometimes easy to determine (e.g. vandal puts HAHAHAHAH as their edit summary or otherwise states that it is vandalism), and sometimes ].

			<blockquote>("As the Vendôme column is formally considered a monument devoid of any artistic value, tending to perpetuate with its expression ideas of war and conquest of the past imperial dynasty, that are reprobated by a republican nation's sentiment, citizen Courbet is to emit his wish that the National Defense government will allow him to dismantle this column.")</blockquote>
	== Vandalism, Otherwise ==

			Hence, painter Courbet justified the dismantlement of the Vendôme column on political grounds, downgrading its artistic value. Vandalism poses the problem of the value of art compared to life's hardships: Courbet thought that the political values transmitted by this work of art neutralized its artistic value. Anyway, his project wasn't followed, however, on ], ], the dismantlement of the imperial symbol was voted by the Commune, and the column taken down on ]. After the assault on the ] by ], Gustave Courbet was condemned to pay part of the expenses. As any good vandal, he preferred flying away to ].
	Vandalism is the act of intentionally and malevolently modifying or destroying something. (anything)

			], ], and ] are commonplace on clothing and are an influence on many of the corporate ] with which we are familiar. Many ] and similar youth-oriented venues are decorated with commissioned graffiti-style artwork, and in many others patrons are welcome to leave their own. There is still, however, a very fine line between vandalism as an artform, as a ], and as a ]. An excellent example of one who walks this threefold line is ] born guerrilla-artist ], who is revered as a cult artistic figure by many, but seen by others as a ].
	For an example of vandalism, click ]

			==See also==
	{{quote\|When in Rome, do as the Vandals do.\|Napoleon Bonaparte\|Napoleon\|Vandalism}}
			*]
			*]
			*]

	==~~See~~ ~~also~~==		== References ==
			{{Refimprove\|date=May 2007}}
	*]
			{{wiktionarypar\|vandalism}}
			{{Commons\|Category:Vandalism\|Vandalism}}
			{{reflist}}

	]		]
	]		]
			]
	]

			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
	]		]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]
			]

Revision as of 21:00, 25 June 2008

For vandalism-related policy on Misplaced Pages, see Misplaced Pages:Vandalism. For the band, see Vandalism (band).

v t e Types of crime
Note: Crimes vary by jurisdiction. Not all types are listed here.
Classes	Infraction Misdemeanor Felony Summary Indictable Hybrid Corruption	Law portal
Against the person	Assassination Assault Battery Child abuse Criminal negligence Domestic violence False imprisonment Frameup Harassment Home invasion Hate crime Homicide Human trafficking Intimidation Kidnapping Menacing Manslaughter (corporate) Mayhem Murder felony Preterintention Homicide Negligent homicide Robbery Stalking Stabbing Torture
Against property	Arson Arms trafficking Blackmail Bribery Burglary Cybercrime Embezzlement Extortion False pretenses Forgery Fraud Gambling Intellectual property violation Larceny Looting Payola Pickpocketing Possessing stolen property Robbery Smuggling Tax evasion Theft Trespass to land Vandalism Mischief
Against the public	Apostasy Begging Corruption Censorship violation Dueling Genocide Ethnic cleansing Hostage-taking Insider trading Smuggling Illegal consumption (such as prohibition of drugs, alcohol, and smoking) Miscegenation Piracy Regicide Terrorism Usurpation War crimes
Against the state	Lèse-majesté Treason Espionage Secession Sedition Subversion
Against justice	Compounding Malfeasance in office Miscarriage of justice Misprision Obstruction Perjury Perverting the course of justice
Against animals	Cruelty to animals Poaching Wildlife smuggling Bestiality
Sexual offenses	Adultery Bigamy Child sexual abuse Cybersex trafficking Fornication Homosexuality Incest Indecent exposure Masturbation Obscenity Prostitution Rape Pederasty Sex trafficking Sexual assault Sexual harassment Sexual slavery Voyeurism
Inchoate offenses	Attempt Conspiracy Incitement Solicitation
WikiSource Wikimedia Commons Wikiquote Wikinews

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.
Find sources: "Vandalism" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (June 2008) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

Vandalism is the behaviour attributed to the Vandals in respect of culture: ruthless destruction or spoiling of anything beautiful or venerable. Such action includes criminal damage, defacement, graffiti and crass erection of an eyesore.

History of the term

Historically, vandalism has been justified by painter Gustave Courbet as destruction of monuments symbolizing "war and conquest". Therefore, it is often done as an expression of contempt, creativity, or both. Vandalism is only a meaningful concept in a culture that recognizes history and archaeology. Like other similar terms (Barbarian/barbary, and Philistine), the term Vandal was originally an ethnic slur referring to the Vandals, who under Geiseric sacked Rome in 455. The Vandals, like the Philistines, no longer exist as an identifiable ethnic group. The term in its modern acceptance was coined in January 1794 during the French Revolution, by Henri Grégoire, constitutional bishop of Blois, in his report directed to the Republican Convention, where he used word Vandalisme to describe some aspects of the behaviour of the republican army. Gustave Courbet's attempt, during the 1871 Paris Commune, to dismantle the Vendôme column, a symbol of the past Napoleon III authoritarian Empire, was one of the most celebrated events of vandalism. Nietzsche himself would meditate after the Commune on the "fight against culture", taking as example the intentional burning of the Tuileries Palace on May 23 1871. "The criminal fight against culture is only the reverse side of a criminal culture" wrote Klossowski after quoting Nietzsche.

In a proposal to the International Conference for Unification of Criminal Law held in Madrid in 1933, Raphael Lemkin envisaged the creation of two new international crimes (delicta juris gentium): the crime of barbarity, consisting in the extermination of racial, religious or social collectivities, and the crime of vandalism, consisting in the destruction of cultural and artistic works of these groups. The proposal was not accepted.

Vandalism as crime

This article may require cleanup to meet Misplaced Pages's quality standards. No cleanup reason has been specified. Please help improve this article if you can. (February 2008) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

Private citizens commit vandalism when they wilfully damage or deface the property of others or the commons. Some vandalism qualifies as culture jamming or sniggling — it is artistic in nature as well as being carried out illegally or without the property owner's permission. Examples include at least some graffiti art, billboard liberation and possibly crop circles, Criminal vandalism has many forms, graffiti on public property is common in many inner cities as part of a gang culture, however other more devastating forms such as those involved with public unrest, such as rioting, involve the wilful destruction of public and private property, Vandalism per se is often considered one of the least serious common crimes, but it can become quite serious and distressing when committed extensively, violently or as an expression of hatred and intimidation.

Examples

Examples of vandalism include salting lawns, cutting trees without permission, egg throwing, breaking windows, arson, spraying paint on others' properties, tagging, placing glue into locks, tire slashing, keying (scratching) paint, ransacking a place and flooding someones house by clogging a sink and leaving the water on.

The destruction of glass windows and doors is a common form of vandalism.

A caution sign damaged by bullet holes on SR165 in near Wilkeson, Washington.

In the case of vandalism to private property, the owner — the victim, may feel that they were specifically targeted by the perpetrator(s) — this is not necessarily the case. An example of such a crime would be the wilful destruction of a car window for no obvious purpose save to give the perpetrator(s) possibly a few seconds of entertainment, with no consideration, or empathy for the detriment to the state of mind or inconvenience of the victim.

Motives

Reasoning for such actions can be attributed to anger, envy or spontaneous, opportunistic behaviour — possibly for peer acceptance or bravado in gang cultures, or disgruntlement with the target (victim) person or society. Opportunistic vandalism of this nature may also be filmed, the mentality of which can be akin to happy slapping. The large scale prevalence of gang graffiti in some inner cities has almost made it acceptable to the societies based there — so much so that it may go unnoticed, or not be removed, possibly because it may be a fruitless endeavour, to be graffitied on once again.

Reaction of authorities

In view of its incivility, punishment for vandalism can be particularly severe in some countries. In Singapore, for example, a person who attempts to cause or commits an act of vandalism may be liable to imprisonment for up to 3 years and in conjunction may be punished with caning. The act of vandalism in UK is construed as an environmental crime and may be dealt with an ASBO (Anti-Social Behavior Order).

Former New York City mayor Rudolph Giuliani made a crackdown on vandalism a centerpiece of his anti-crime agenda in the 1990s, asserting that a strong campaign against nonviolent "quality of life" crimes such as vandalism would cause a corresponding decrease in violent crime. However much credit can be given to Giuliani's anti-vandalism crusade, FBI statistics claim that New York's crime rate plummeted during his tenure.

Vandalism as art

Further information: Graffiti

Though vandalism in itself is illegal, it is often also an integral part of modern popular culture. French painter Gustave Courbet's attempt to disassemble the Vendôme column during the 1871 Paris Commune was probably one of the first artistic vandalist acts, celebrated at least since Dada performances during World War I. The Vendôme column was considered a symbol of the past Napoleon III empire, and dismantled as such.

After the burning of the Tuileries Palace on May 23 1871, Philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche himself meditated about the "fight against culture", wondering what could justify culture if it were to be destroyed in such a "senseless" manner (the arguments are: culture is justified by works of art and scientific achievements; exploitation is necessary to those achievements, leading to the creation of exploited people who then fight against culture. In this case, culture can't be legitimised by art achievements, and Nietzsche writes: "I {also} know what it means: fighting against culture". After quoting him, Klossowski writes: "The criminal fight against culture is only the reverse side of a criminal culture"

As destruction of monument, vandalism can only have sense in a culture respecting history, archeology - Nietzsche spoke of monumental history. As destruction of monumental history, vandalism was assured a long life (as Herostratus proved): Performance art could make such a claim, as well as Hakim Bey's poetic terrorism or Destroy 2000 Years of Culture from Atari Teenage Riot. Gustave Courbet's declaration stated:

"Attendu que la colonne Vendôme est un monument dénué de toute valeur artistique, tendant à perpétuer par son expression les idées de guerre et de conquête qui étaient dans la dynastie impériale, mais que réprouve le sentiment d’une nation républicaine, émet le vœu que le gouvernement de la Défense nationale veuille bien l’autoriser à déboulonner cette colonne."

("As the Vendôme column is formally considered a monument devoid of any artistic value, tending to perpetuate with its expression ideas of war and conquest of the past imperial dynasty, that are reprobated by a republican nation's sentiment, citizen Courbet is to emit his wish that the National Defense government will allow him to dismantle this column.")

Hence, painter Courbet justified the dismantlement of the Vendôme column on political grounds, downgrading its artistic value. Vandalism poses the problem of the value of art compared to life's hardships: Courbet thought that the political values transmitted by this work of art neutralized its artistic value. Anyway, his project wasn't followed, however, on April 12, 1871, the dismantlement of the imperial symbol was voted by the Commune, and the column taken down on May 8. After the assault on the Paris Commune by Adolphe Thiers, Gustave Courbet was condemned to pay part of the expenses. As any good vandal, he preferred flying away to Switzerland.

Tags, designs, and styles of writing are commonplace on clothing and are an influence on many of the corporate logos with which we are familiar. Many skateparks and similar youth-oriented venues are decorated with commissioned graffiti-style artwork, and in many others patrons are welcome to leave their own. There is still, however, a very fine line between vandalism as an artform, as a political statement, and as a crime. An excellent example of one who walks this threefold line is Bristol born guerrilla-artist Banksy, who is revered as a cult artistic figure by many, but seen by others as a criminal.

References

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.
Find sources: "Vandalism" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2007) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

"Oxford English Dictionary". Oxford University Press. Retrieved 06 May 2008. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |accessdate= (help)
^ See Pierre Klossowski, Nietzsche and the Vicious Circle, first Chapter: What is the value of culture if those who are exploited by it destroy it? "En sorte qu'il nous faut être bien loin de vouloir, du haut de notre sentiment de nous-mêmes, imputer le crime d'un combat contre la culture exclusivement à ces malheureux. Je sais ce que cela veut dire: le combat contre la culture. (...) je me campronnai avec une conviction sérieuse à la valeur métaphysique de l'art, lequel ne saurait exister à cause des pauvres gens, mais doit accomplir des missions plus hautes. Mais, en dépit de mon extrême douleur, je n'étais pas en état de jeter la moindre pierre à ces profanateurs qui, pour moi, n'étaient que les suppôts de la culpabilité universelle, sur laquelle il y a beaucoup à méditer!" (Nietzsche quoted by Klossowski pp.29-30 French edition, who adds: "Le combat criminel contre la culture n'est lui-même que l'envers d'une culture criminelle" ("The criminal fight against culture is only the reverse side of a criminal culture")
Raphael Lemkin: Akte der Barbarei und des Vandalismus als delicta juris gentium, Anwaltsblatt Internationales (Wien), November 1933.
"FBI Crime Statistics For Calendar Year 2000 Show Drop In New York City Crime" (Press release). NYC Mayor's Press Office. 2001-05-30. Retrieved 2007-08-04.
British Museum
"La Colonne Vendôme déboulonnée" (in French). Retrieved 2007-08-04.

Categories: