| Revision as of 13:29, 5 January 2002 editRitaBijlsma (talk | contribs)0 editsNo edit summary← Previous edit | Revision as of 20:13, 5 January 2002 edit undoMav (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users77,874 edits comment to the Greek thread.Next edit → | ||
| Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
| ::: I don't remember such from the book, but I now found that there are in fact in the book photographs of ancient Greek vases with pictures of homosexual conduct between youths. But most are between erastes and eromenos. This book does not give the answer to your question. It shows how different that society was and proves some weird details, but can not give a complete view. | ::: I don't remember such from the book, but I now found that there are in fact in the book photographs of ancient Greek vases with pictures of homosexual conduct between youths. But most are between erastes and eromenos. This book does not give the answer to your question. It shows how different that society was and proves some weird details, but can not give a complete view. | ||
| OK -- I leave this on the back burner until I am able to find substantiation.Thanks! ] | |||
Revision as of 20:13, 5 January 2002
I'd like to see some references for the anthropological study of homosexuality. It seems to me that every one of the alleged "forms" of homosexuality also exist in heterosexuality. --Dmerrill
My intuition tells me that this article is pro-homosexuality. Was that the author's intent? --Ed Poor
- Who knows. Who cares, as long as it's NPOV.
- - also, the statistical estimate of "percent of the population that is gay" has been changed on this page a few times. Can anybody get us a hard cite for a number here?
- Seconding the latter! The best way to counter endless arguments and suspicions about bias is to contextualize assertions by saying such things as, "According to a widely-cited survey by so-and-so, N% of Americans are homosexuals. There have been a number of attempts to estimate the percentage of homosexuals worldwide, such as..." Etc. --LMS
- By the way, re "People whose sexual desire and activities are strongly channelled toward members of their own sex are a minority of the population (variously estimated to be anywhere from 2% to 10%)." Of what population? --Yours for scientific precision, LMS
- Why on earth should americans be specially mentioned? Should we specially mention every single country where there has been survey's percentages? ;) arcade
Concerning the Greek additions:
- I remember from a program I saw on the Discovery Channel (which doesn't constitute proof, BTW), that young men in Classical Greece where almost expected to engage in peer-to-peer homosexual activity so as not to defile the female population with pre-marital sex (a bride HAD to be a virgin at that time).
- This peer-to-peer male sexual activity was in addition to the type of relationship described in the article and it was expected to end upon marriage to a virgin bride (although, in later life, the man could take on a eromenos).
- Can someone verify this? I don't like posting additions to articles based upon what I saw in a single TV program. Maveric149
- I don't remember such from the book, but I now found that there are in fact in the book photographs of ancient Greek vases with pictures of homosexual conduct between youths. But most are between erastes and eromenos. This book does not give the answer to your question. It shows how different that society was and proves some weird details, but can not give a complete view.
OK -- I leave this on the back burner until I am able to find substantiation.Thanks! maveric149