Misplaced Pages

National-anarchism: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 18:13, 7 July 2009 edit71.241.218.107 (talk) WP: shortcuts don't appear to work properly as redirectsTag: New user changing redirect or redirecting← Previous edit Revision as of 18:13, 7 July 2009 edit undoMuZemike (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users71,084 editsm Reverted edits by 71.241.218.107 to last revision by Gpia7r (HG)Next edit →
Line 1: Line 1:
{{hatnote|This article is specifically about the National-Anarchist movement. See ] for general information about fusions of nationalist and anarchist ideas.}}
#REDIRECT ]
{{Primarysources|date=January 2009}}
</ref>]]
'''National-Anarchism''' is a ] that developed in the 1990s out of an attempt by former ]ists to reconcile ] with ] and in some cases ] and/or ].<ref name="transcending">{{cite web
| last = Southgate
| first = Troy
| authorlink = Troy Southgate
| title = Transcending the Beyond: From Third Position to National-Anarchism
| work = Synthesis
| publisher = Circle de la Rose Noire
| date = January 2002
| url = http://www.rosenoire.org/articles/transcending.php
| accessdate = 2009-02-18}}</ref> It has intellectual roots in the writings of ] and the neo-] ],<ref name=nur21>Fyodorov, Miron (February 2006). "". ''New Right''.</ref> and includes ], ], ], ], and ] among its influences.<ref name=nur21/>

The term was coined simultaneously by ] (England), Peter Töpfer (Germany) and Hans Cany (France), and was used by the now defunct ''National Revolutionary Faction'' to describe its ideology.<ref name=NAI>Unattr. "". ''Nationalanarchismus''.</ref>

==History==
Historically the term ''national anarchist'' dates back as far as the 1920s, when ], a ] writer involved with the ], used it to describe his political outlook.<ref name=NAI/> In the ] during the early 1980s, the ] group promulgated ideas which it described as ''national anarchist'' and ''anarcho-nationalist''.<ref>''Black Ram'' 1: 12, 18.</ref> However, the present usage derives from the French National-Anarchist Hans Cany, who first made use of this term in the early 1990s, along with the related terms ''national-libertarian'' and ''anarcho-identitarian''.<ref name=NAI/><ref>Cany, Hans (2004). "". ''Nationalanarchismus''.</ref> Around the same time, ] left the editorial board of '']'', due to a disagreement over political strategies, and formed his own journal, '']''.<ref name=Hunt></ref> The remaining ''Green Anarchist'' staff constantly accused Hunt of supporting ], while the left-wing writer/activist ] accused both ''Alternative Green'' and ''Green Anarchist'' of supporting ].<ref name=StewartHome></ref>

In the mid-1990s, ], a ] former member of the ] and ], began to move towards Hunt's green anarchism, and fused it with racial separatism (which Hunt did not support) to create a newer form of National-Anarchism.<ref name=Sturgeon>Sturgeon, Wayne John (2001). "". ''Synthesis''.</ref> In 1998 Southgate formed the National Revolutionary Faction (NRF), officiating as its national secretary.<ref name=nur53>{{cite journal
| last = Macklin
| first = Graham D.
| authorlink =
| title = Co-opting the counter culture: Troy Southgate and the National Revolutionary Faction
| journal = ]
| volume = 39
| issue = 3
| pages = 301-326
| date = September 2005
| url = http://www.new-right.org/?p=53
| issn = 0031-322X
| doi = 10.1080/00313220500198292
| accessdate = 2009-02-17}}</ref> For a period, he was also a member of ''Alternative Green'''s editorial board.<ref name=nur53>Co-opting the counter culture</ref> Later, Southgate disavowed the concept of the revolutionary cell-group and in 2003 the NRF disbanded, shortly after he and other NRF associates had become involved with a ]-based ] forum, the ''Cercle de la Rose Noire'', of which Southgate is president.<ref name=nur53/><ref></ref> Southgate is also an organiser for the ], a group which is inspired by the French ] movement.<ref>Macklin, Graham (n.d.). "". ''Synthesis''.</ref>

{{Third Position}}

==Views==

National-Anarchists see the hierarchies inherent in government and ] as oppressive. They advocate collective action organized along the lines of ]ality, identity, and tribes, and advocate for a ] social order wherein like-minded individuals maintain distinct communities.<ref name="transcending"/>

National-Anarchism shares with most ] a desire to reorganize human relationships, with an emphasis on replacing the hierarchical structures of government and ] with local, communal decision-making. Troy Southgate has stated:
<blockquote>
''We believe in political, social and economic decentralisation. In other words, we wish to see a positive downward trend whereby all bureaucratic concepts such as the ], ], the ], the ] and even nation-states like ] and ] are eradicated and consequently replaced by autonomous village-communities.''<ref name=WhatIsNA>Southgate, Troy. "" (in question-and-answer format). ''''.</ref></blockquote>

The revolutionary conservative concept of the ] is central to National-Anarchism.<ref name=nur53/>

National-Anarchists view ] as a primary cause of the social decline of ]s and ].<ref name=mathaba>{{Cite news
| author = Unattr.
| title = Doing the New Right thing by people: An interview with a key organiser for the New Right and National Anarchist movements in Australia
| work = Destiny
| issue = 3
| publisher = ]
| date = March 2008
| url = http://www.mathaba.net/news/?x=583629
| format = reprint}}</ref> National-Anarchists also reject ] and ] as ] and ],<ref name=nur21/> and reject ] as a failed ] of a totalitarian government.<ref name=nur21/><ref name=mathaba/>



===Autonomy and separatism===
According to ], National-Anarchists advocate a model of society in which communities that practice ] along the lines of ethnicity, religion, or sexual orientation, are able to coexist alongside mixed or integrated communities without requiring force.<ref name=ARV>{{cite web
| last = Preston
| first = Keith
| authorlink = Keith Preston
| title = National-Anarchism and Classical American Ideals: Is A Reconciliation Possible?
| work = Food for the European Mind
| date = 2003
| url = http://european-reading.blogspot.com/2007/07/national-anarchism-and-classical.html
| accessdate = 2008-02-18
| archiveurl = http://www.webcitation.org/5eek58jcD
| format = ]
| archivedate = 2008-02-18}}</ref> He claims that "autonomous zones" could exist with their own rules for permanent residence in a community without the strict ethnic divisions and violence advocated by other ] ].<ref name=ARV/> National-Anarchists consider genocide, murder, and social conformity to be unnecessary, tyrannical and an affront to "libertarian minded people".<ref name=ARV/>

Some proponents of National-Anarchism claim that ] can be achieved without ] or racial supremacy.<ref></ref> Southgate states that National Anarchists are racial separatists who oppose "miscegenation" but do not seek to impose their views on others.<ref name=WhatIsNA/> Southgate writes, "we are seeking our own space in which to live according to our own principles".<ref name=nur21/>

In terms of the practical implementation of these views, National-Anarchists believe that areas without significant human development and borderlands would be maintained collectively, and the existence of free zones allowing trade and sharing between communities would be established with the agreement of all parties involved.<ref name=TradRev>{{Harvnb|Southgate|2007|p=34}}</ref>

The Bay Area National Anarchist (BANA) network foresees the development of National Autonomous Zones (NAZ) and promotes them as a model of administration suggesting that National-Anarchists can achieve "autonomy amidst adversity." NAZ theory "makes no specific demands...that adhere to a particular political ideology" or organize in a particular way.<ref name=castles>Unattr. (May 2008). "". ''Bay Area National Anarchist''.</ref> A NAZ may contain one or more of the following characteristics:

* a homogeneous representation of spoken language, culture, religion, and ethnicity.
* the organized delegation of tasks and economy.
* a pre-defined relationship regulating behavior with outsiders of the NAZ.
* a system of standard operating procedures for self-defense.
* collective and informal decision making processes.<ref name=castles/>

A mature NAZ is considered to have one or more traits of the Vietnamese Military Fortress concept for national defense. <ref name=gates>Unattr. (May 2008). "". ''Inside the Gates''.</ref>

==Criticism==
Critics of National Anarchism argue that they are deceptive and practice ] while pretending to be anarchists.<ref name="trojan"/><ref name="trojan2">Unattr. "".</ref> '']'' published an article accusing the National-Anarchists of being fascists with the goal of discrediting mainstream anarchism.<ref>{{Citation
| last = Manson
| first = Peter
| title = No case to answer
| newspaper = ]
| issue = 363
| date = 2000-12-07
| url = http://www.cpgb.org.uk/worker/363/liddle.html
| accessdate = }}</ref> ], a militant anti-fascist network, advocates violent physical confrontation with National-Anarchists, whom it considers to be part of the far right.<ref>Unattr. "". ''''.</ref>

Anarchist Nick Griffin (not to be confused with BNP leader ]) argues that National-Anarchism's concept of racial separation is intrinsically linked to racial hatred.<ref name="trojan">Griffin, Nick. "". '']''.</ref><ref>http://www.publiceye.org/magazine/v23n4/rebranding_fascism.html</ref>

{{quote|The groupuscular right... is a constantly growing, mutating, protean counter-culture... segments of which seem to be evolving towards a synthesis of neo-anarchism.|]<ref>{{cite journal
| last = Griffin
| first = Roger
| authorlink = Roger Griffin
| title = From slime mould to rhizome: an introduction to the groupuscular right
| journal = Patterns of Prejudice
| volume = 37
| issue = 1
| pages = 27-63
| date = March 2003
| url = http://ah.brookes.ac.uk/resources/griffin/slimemould.pdf
| format = ] 285.9 KB
| issn = 0031-322X
| doi = 10.1080/0031322022000054321
| accessdate = 2008-12-18}}</ref>}}

==See also==
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ]
* ], counterpart to the NRF

==References==
{{reflist|2}}

===Bibliography===
*{{Citation
| last = Southgate
| first = Troy
| authorlink = Troy Southgate
| title = Tradition and Revolution: Collected Writings of Troy Southgate
| publisher = Integral Tradition Publishing
| year = 2007
| location = Aarhus
| isbn = 978-8792136022}}

==External links==
*
* Victoria Australia collective
* Group based in California
* Videos produced by the BANA group
* An alternative website by the East Bay Collective, part of the BANA network.
* Christian National-Anarchist group based in Idaho
*
* '''', Journal du Cercle de la Rose Noire
* essay by Spencer Sunshine


{{Nationalism}}
]
]
]
]

]
]
]
]
]
]
]
]

Revision as of 18:13, 7 July 2009

This article is specifically about the National-Anarchist movement. See Anarchism and nationalism for general information about fusions of nationalist and anarchist ideas.
This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources.
Find sources: "National-anarchism" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
The purple star of contemporary National-Anarchism.

National-Anarchism is a syncretic political current that developed in the 1990s out of an attempt by former Third Positionists to reconcile anarchism with nationalism and in some cases fascism and/or racial separatism. It has intellectual roots in the writings of Julius Evola and the neo-Spenglerian Francis Parker Yockey, and includes Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, Mikhail Bakunin, Peter Kropotkin, Leo Tolstoy, and Max Stirner among its influences.

The term was coined simultaneously by Troy Southgate (England), Peter Töpfer (Germany) and Hans Cany (France), and was used by the now defunct National Revolutionary Faction to describe its ideology.

History

Historically the term national anarchist dates back as far as the 1920s, when Helmut Franke, a German writer involved with the Conservative Revolutionary movement, used it to describe his political outlook. In the United Kingdom during the early 1980s, the Black Ram group promulgated ideas which it described as national anarchist and anarcho-nationalist. However, the present usage derives from the French National-Anarchist Hans Cany, who first made use of this term in the early 1990s, along with the related terms national-libertarian and anarcho-identitarian. Around the same time, Richard Hunt left the editorial board of Green Anarchist, due to a disagreement over political strategies, and formed his own journal, Alternative Green. The remaining Green Anarchist staff constantly accused Hunt of supporting fascism, while the left-wing writer/activist Stewart Home accused both Alternative Green and Green Anarchist of supporting ecofascism.

In the mid-1990s, Troy Southgate, a Strasserite former member of the British National Front and International Third Position, began to move towards Hunt's green anarchism, and fused it with racial separatism (which Hunt did not support) to create a newer form of National-Anarchism. In 1998 Southgate formed the National Revolutionary Faction (NRF), officiating as its national secretary. For a period, he was also a member of Alternative Green's editorial board. Later, Southgate disavowed the concept of the revolutionary cell-group and in 2003 the NRF disbanded, shortly after he and other NRF associates had become involved with a UK-based countercultural forum, the Cercle de la Rose Noire, of which Southgate is president. Southgate is also an organiser for the New Right, a group which is inspired by the French Nouvelle Droite movement.

Template:Third Position

Views

National-Anarchists see the hierarchies inherent in government and capitalism as oppressive. They advocate collective action organized along the lines of nationality, identity, and tribes, and advocate for a decentralised social order wherein like-minded individuals maintain distinct communities.

National-Anarchism shares with most strains of anarchism a desire to reorganize human relationships, with an emphasis on replacing the hierarchical structures of government and capitalism with local, communal decision-making. Troy Southgate has stated:

We believe in political, social and economic decentralisation. In other words, we wish to see a positive downward trend whereby all bureaucratic concepts such as the UN, NATO, the EU, the World Bank and even nation-states like England and Germany are eradicated and consequently replaced by autonomous village-communities.

The revolutionary conservative concept of the Anarch is central to National-Anarchism.

National-Anarchists view liberalism as a primary cause of the social decline of nations and cultural identity. National-Anarchists also reject fascism and Communism as statist and totalitarian, and reject National Socialism as a failed dictatorship of a totalitarian government.


Autonomy and separatism

According to Keith Preston, National-Anarchists advocate a model of society in which communities that practice separatism along the lines of ethnicity, religion, or sexual orientation, are able to coexist alongside mixed or integrated communities without requiring force. He claims that "autonomous zones" could exist with their own rules for permanent residence in a community without the strict ethnic divisions and violence advocated by other racist nationalism. National-Anarchists consider genocide, murder, and social conformity to be unnecessary, tyrannical and an affront to "libertarian minded people".

Some proponents of National-Anarchism claim that racial separatism can be achieved without racial hatred or racial supremacy. Southgate states that National Anarchists are racial separatists who oppose "miscegenation" but do not seek to impose their views on others. Southgate writes, "we are seeking our own space in which to live according to our own principles".

In terms of the practical implementation of these views, National-Anarchists believe that areas without significant human development and borderlands would be maintained collectively, and the existence of free zones allowing trade and sharing between communities would be established with the agreement of all parties involved.

The Bay Area National Anarchist (BANA) network foresees the development of National Autonomous Zones (NAZ) and promotes them as a model of administration suggesting that National-Anarchists can achieve "autonomy amidst adversity." NAZ theory "makes no specific demands...that adhere to a particular political ideology" or organize in a particular way. A NAZ may contain one or more of the following characteristics:

  • a homogeneous representation of spoken language, culture, religion, and ethnicity.
  • the organized delegation of tasks and economy.
  • a pre-defined relationship regulating behavior with outsiders of the NAZ.
  • a system of standard operating procedures for self-defense.
  • collective and informal decision making processes.

A mature NAZ is considered to have one or more traits of the Vietnamese Military Fortress concept for national defense.

Criticism

Critics of National Anarchism argue that they are deceptive and practice crypto-fascism while pretending to be anarchists. Green Anarchist published an article accusing the National-Anarchists of being fascists with the goal of discrediting mainstream anarchism. Antifa, a militant anti-fascist network, advocates violent physical confrontation with National-Anarchists, whom it considers to be part of the far right.

Anarchist Nick Griffin (not to be confused with BNP leader Nick Griffin) argues that National-Anarchism's concept of racial separation is intrinsically linked to racial hatred.

The groupuscular right... is a constantly growing, mutating, protean counter-culture... segments of which seem to be evolving towards a synthesis of neo-anarchism.

— Roger Griffin

See also

References

  2. ^ Southgate, Troy (January 2002). "Transcending the Beyond: From Third Position to National-Anarchism". Synthesis. Circle de la Rose Noire. Retrieved 2009-02-18.
  3. ^ Fyodorov, Miron (February 2006). "Interview with Troy Southgate for Kinovar, Russia". New Right.
  4. ^ Unattr. "NA-Internationale, der internationale Nationalanarchismus und etwas zu seiner Geschichte". Nationalanarchismus.
  5. Black Ram 1: 12, 18.
  6. Cany, Hans (2004). "Zur Geschichte und heutigen Situation des National-Anarchismus in Frankreich". Nationalanarchismus.
  7. An Interview with Richard Hunt
  8. Stewart Home Society - Green Anarchist Documents
  9. Sturgeon, Wayne John (2001). "Synthesis editor Troy Southgate interviewed by Wayne John Sturgeon". Synthesis.
  10. ^ Macklin, Graham D. (September 2005). "Co-opting the counter culture: Troy Southgate and the National Revolutionary Faction". Patterns of Prejudice. 39 (3): 301–326. doi:10.1080/00313220500198292. ISSN 0031-322X. Retrieved 2009-02-17. Cite error: The named reference "nur53" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
  11. S Y N T H E S I S - Journal du Cercle de la Rose Noire
  12. Macklin, Graham (n.d.). "An Interview with Troy Southgate". Synthesis.
  13. ^ Southgate, Troy. "What is National-Anarchism?" (in question-and-answer format). Folk and Faith.
  14. ^ Unattr. (March 2008). "Doing the New Right thing by people: An interview with a key organiser for the New Right and National Anarchist movements in Australia" (reprint). Destiny. No. 3. Australian Protectionist Party.
  15. ^ Preston, Keith (2003). "National-Anarchism and Classical American Ideals: Is A Reconciliation Possible?". Food for the European Mind. Archived from the original (WebCite) on 2008-02-18. Retrieved 2008-02-18.
  16. National-Anarchist-Online : National-Anarchist-Online
  17. Southgate 2007, p. 34
  18. ^ Unattr. (May 2008). "National Autonomous Zones: Castles without walls". Bay Area National Anarchist.
  19. Unattr. (May 2008). "Inside the Gates: the Vietnamese Military Fortress". Inside the Gates.
  20. ^ Griffin, Nick. "National Anarchism - Trojan Horse for White Nationalism". Green Anarchy.
  21. Unattr. "Anarchists against Nationalism".
  22. Manson, Peter (2000-12-07), "No case to answer", Weekly Worker, no. 363
  23. Unattr. "The opposition". Antifa Britain.
  24. http://www.publiceye.org/magazine/v23n4/rebranding_fascism.html
  25. Griffin, Roger (March 2003). "From slime mould to rhizome: an introduction to the groupuscular right" (PDF 285.9 KB). Patterns of Prejudice. 37 (1): 27–63. doi:10.1080/0031322022000054321. ISSN 0031-322X. Retrieved 2008-12-18.

Bibliography


External links


Nationalism
Development
By type
Organizations
Related concepts
Categories: