Nahum Shahaf: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively ← Previous edit Next edit →Content deleted Content addedVisual WikitextInline

Revision as of 20:37, 25 March 2010 editGeorge (talk \| contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers10,550 edits Moving this to talk for discussion.← Previous edit		Revision as of 05:58, 28 March 2010 edit undoSmackBot (talk \| contribs)3,734,324 editsm Date maintenance tags and general fixes: build 402:Next edit →
Line 4:		Line 4:
	According to Israeli reporter ], Shahaf worked for the optical intelligence unit of the ] (IDF) as a physicist, and contributed to the development of ] and video instrumentation. During the 1991 ], he investigated the damage done by Iraqi ] missiles fired against Israel, and concluded that ]s contributed to the damage.<ref name="Lord"></ref> He received an ] award for creativity in 1997 for his work on compressed digital video transmission.<ref name=Fallows />		According to Israeli reporter ], Shahaf worked for the optical intelligence unit of the ] (IDF) as a physicist, and contributed to the development of ] and video instrumentation. During the 1991 ], he investigated the damage done by Iraqi ] missiles fired against Israel, and concluded that ]s contributed to the damage.<ref name="Lord"></ref> He received an ] award for creativity in 1997 for his work on compressed digital video transmission.<ref name=Fallows />

	Shahaf describes himself as "a scientist, a physicist specialized in ballistics and the technology of filming images."<ref name="Guysen">{{~~dead~~ link\|date=March 2010}} ] interviews Nahum Shahaf ()</ref>		Shahaf describes himself as "a scientist, a physicist specialized in ballistics and the technology of filming images."<ref name="Guysen">{{Dead link\|date=March 2010}} ] interviews Nahum Shahaf ()</ref>

	==Al-Durrah investigation==		==Al-Durrah investigation==
	{{~~main~~\|Muhammad al-Durrah incident}}		{{Main\|Muhammad al-Durrah incident}}
	Shortly after the al-Durrah shooting in September 2000, for which the ] had initially admitted responsibility, Shahaf approached IDF ] head Major General ]. Shahaf was already well known to Samia, having previously done work for the IDF.<ref>{{cite book\|last1=Cordesman\|first1=Anthony\|last2=Moravitz\|first2=Jennifer\|title=The Israeli-Palestinian war: escalating to nowhere\|page=372\|publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group\|year=2005\|isbn=9780275987589}}</ref> Shahaf proposed that he and Joseph Doriel, an engineer with whom Shahaf had previously collaborated during work on ], should undertake an investigation into the shooting on behalf of Samia.<ref name=Cygielman /> Samia agreed, and on October 23, 2000, Shahaf helped to arrange a re-enactment of the shooting on an IDF shooting range, in front of a CBS '']'' camera crew. In late November 2000, at the conclusion of the inquiry, Samia presented his findings at a press conference, explaining that the findings were "based on measurements, bullet angles and evidence that the Palestinian boy was hit by a volley of gunfire while Israeli soldiers were firing only single shots."<ref name="CNN">{{~~dead~~ link\|~~Date~~=March 2010}} AP - November 27, 2000</ref>		Shortly after the al-Durrah shooting in September 2000, for which the ] had initially admitted responsibility, Shahaf approached IDF ] head Major General ]. Shahaf was already well known to Samia, having previously done work for the IDF.<ref>{{cite book\|last1=Cordesman\|first1=Anthony\|last2=Moravitz\|first2=Jennifer\|title=The Israeli-Palestinian war: escalating to nowhere\|page=372\|publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group\|year=2005\|isbn=9780275987589}}</ref> Shahaf proposed that he and Joseph Doriel, an engineer with whom Shahaf had previously collaborated during work on ], should undertake an investigation into the shooting on behalf of Samia.<ref name=Cygielman /> Samia agreed, and on October 23, 2000, Shahaf helped to arrange a re-enactment of the shooting on an IDF shooting range, in front of a CBS '']'' camera crew. In late November 2000, at the conclusion of the inquiry, Samia presented his findings at a press conference, explaining that the findings were "based on measurements, bullet angles and evidence that the Palestinian boy was hit by a volley of gunfire while Israeli soldiers were firing only single shots."<ref name="CNN">{{Dead link\|date=March 2010}} AP - November 27, 2000</ref>

	The investigation met with a mixed response. Doriel had been dismissed by Samia during the course of the investigation and when the results were announced, it was strongly criticised by some in the Israeli media. The Israeli newspapers ''Haaretz'' and the ''Jerusalem Post'' argued that Shahaf had no ballistics experience and ''Haaretz'' described his investigation as "dubious."<ref name=Cygielman>.</ref> His previous involvement in raising doubts about the identity of Rabin's killer became the subject of controversy.<ref>Schwartz, Adi (2007). "", ''Haaretz'', November 8, 2007, accessed January 24, 2010.</ref> Shahaf, however, pursued the case and devoted years to the matter,<ref name="Levy">Levy, Gideon. . ''Haaretz'', October 7, 2007, accessed October 23, 2008.</ref> having "spent months painstakingly collecting, wheedling, even buying footage from reluctant cameramen, and then spliced the pieces together in rough temporal order in an attempt to make an unbroken film of the day."<ref>''The other war: Israelis, Palestinians, and the struggle for media supremacy'', Stephanie Gutmann, Encounter Books, 2005, p. 75.</ref> He has promoted a theory that al-Durrah was not killed by the IDF and may still be alive.<ref>{{cite news\|last=Temple-Raston\|first=Dina\|title=Engineer Casts Doubt on Veracity of Claims That Israelis Killed Palestinian Boy in 2000\|url=http://www.nysun.com/foreign/engineer-casts-doubt-on-veracity-of-claims-that/10581/\|work=The New York Sun\|date=March 15, 2005}}</ref> Following ''Haaretz's'' reporting of his work on the al-Durrah case, which editor ] criticised as an "eccentic obsession" in an October 2007 article,<ref name="Levy" /> Shahaf filed a ] lawsuit against the newspaper in December 2007 charging that ''Haaretz's'' coverage had "led investors to flee" from one of his inventions and demanding 400 million ] (US $103 million) in damages.<ref>{{cite news\|title=400 million lawsuit against Haaretz\|url=http://www.nrg.co.il/online/4/ART1/667/290.html\|work=NRG\|language=Hebrew\|date=December 5, 2007}}</ref>		The investigation met with a mixed response. Doriel had been dismissed by Samia during the course of the investigation and when the results were announced, it was strongly criticised by some in the Israeli media. The Israeli newspapers ''Haaretz'' and the ''Jerusalem Post'' argued that Shahaf had no ballistics experience and ''Haaretz'' described his investigation as "dubious."<ref name=Cygielman>.</ref> His previous involvement in raising doubts about the identity of Rabin's killer became the subject of controversy.<ref>Schwartz, Adi (2007). "", ''Haaretz'', November 8, 2007, accessed January 24, 2010.</ref> Shahaf, however, pursued the case and devoted years to the matter,<ref name="Levy">Levy, Gideon. . ''Haaretz'', October 7, 2007, accessed October 23, 2008.</ref> having "spent months painstakingly collecting, wheedling, even buying footage from reluctant cameramen, and then spliced the pieces together in rough temporal order in an attempt to make an unbroken film of the day."<ref>''The other war: Israelis, Palestinians, and the struggle for media supremacy'', Stephanie Gutmann, Encounter Books, 2005, p. 75.</ref> He has promoted a theory that al-Durrah was not killed by the IDF and may still be alive.<ref>{{cite news\|last=Temple-Raston\|first=Dina\|title=Engineer Casts Doubt on Veracity of Claims That Israelis Killed Palestinian Boy in 2000\|url=http://www.nysun.com/foreign/engineer-casts-doubt-on-veracity-of-claims-that/10581/\|work=The New York Sun\|date=March 15, 2005}}</ref> Following ''Haaretz's'' reporting of his work on the al-Durrah case, which editor ] criticised as an "eccentic obsession" in an October 2007 article,<ref name="Levy" /> Shahaf filed a ] lawsuit against the newspaper in December 2007 charging that ''Haaretz's'' coverage had "led investors to flee" from one of his inventions and demanding 400 million ] (US $103 million) in damages.<ref>{{cite news\|title=400 million lawsuit against Haaretz\|url=http://www.nrg.co.il/online/4/ART1/667/290.html\|work=NRG\|language=Hebrew\|date=December 5, 2007}}</ref>

Revision as of 05:58, 28 March 2010

Nahum Shahaf (Template:Lang-he) is an Israeli physicist, best known for his role in an October 2000 Israel Defense Forces (IDF) investigation surrounding the shooting of a 12-year-old Palestinian boy, Muhammad al-Durrah. Prior to the investigation, Shahaf had worked with the IDF on the design of unmanned aerial vehicles, and had been known primarily as an inventor, having received an Israeli Ministry of Science award for creativity in 1997 for his work on compressed digital video transmission.

Background

According to Israeli reporter Amnon Lord, Shahaf worked for the optical intelligence unit of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) as a physicist, and contributed to the development of unmanned air vehicles and video instrumentation. During the 1991 Gulf War, he investigated the damage done by Iraqi Scud missiles fired against Israel, and concluded that Patriot missiles contributed to the damage. He received an Israeli Ministry of Science award for creativity in 1997 for his work on compressed digital video transmission.

Shahaf describes himself as "a scientist, a physicist specialized in ballistics and the technology of filming images."

Al-Durrah investigation

Main article: Muhammad al-Durrah incident

Shortly after the al-Durrah shooting in September 2000, for which the Israel Defence Force had initially admitted responsibility, Shahaf approached IDF Southern Command head Major General Yom Tov Samia. Shahaf was already well known to Samia, having previously done work for the IDF. Shahaf proposed that he and Joseph Doriel, an engineer with whom Shahaf had previously collaborated during work on conspiracy theories concerning the killing of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, should undertake an investigation into the shooting on behalf of Samia. Samia agreed, and on October 23, 2000, Shahaf helped to arrange a re-enactment of the shooting on an IDF shooting range, in front of a CBS 60 Minutes camera crew. In late November 2000, at the conclusion of the inquiry, Samia presented his findings at a press conference, explaining that the findings were "based on measurements, bullet angles and evidence that the Palestinian boy was hit by a volley of gunfire while Israeli soldiers were firing only single shots."

The investigation met with a mixed response. Doriel had been dismissed by Samia during the course of the investigation and when the results were announced, it was strongly criticised by some in the Israeli media. The Israeli newspapers Haaretz and the Jerusalem Post argued that Shahaf had no ballistics experience and Haaretz described his investigation as "dubious." His previous involvement in raising doubts about the identity of Rabin's killer became the subject of controversy. Shahaf, however, pursued the case and devoted years to the matter, having "spent months painstakingly collecting, wheedling, even buying footage from reluctant cameramen, and then spliced the pieces together in rough temporal order in an attempt to make an unbroken film of the day." He has promoted a theory that al-Durrah was not killed by the IDF and may still be alive. Following Haaretz's reporting of his work on the al-Durrah case, which editor Gideon Levy criticised as an "eccentic obsession" in an October 2007 article, Shahaf filed a defamation lawsuit against the newspaper in December 2007 charging that Haaretz's coverage had "led investors to flee" from one of his inventions and demanding 400 million shekels (US $103 million) in damages.

Notes

^ Fallows 2003.
Who Killed Muhammad Al-Dura? Blood Libel-- Model 2000 Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs Amnon Lord 15 July 2002
The Mohamad A-Dura affair: a gross imposture? MENA interviews Nahum Shahaf (Copy)
Cordesman, Anthony; Moravitz, Jennifer (2005). The Israeli-Palestinian war: escalating to nowhere. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 372. ISBN 9780275987589.
^ Cygielman 2000.
Israel claims Palestinian gunmen may have shot boy in high-profile killing AP - November 27, 2000
Schwartz, Adi (2007). "In the footsteps of the al-Dura controversy", Haaretz, November 8, 2007, accessed January 24, 2010.
^ Levy, Gideon. Mohammed al-Dura lives on. Haaretz, October 7, 2007, accessed October 23, 2008.
The other war: Israelis, Palestinians, and the struggle for media supremacy, Stephanie Gutmann, Encounter Books, 2005, p. 75.
Temple-Raston, Dina (March 15, 2005). "Engineer Casts Doubt on Veracity of Claims That Israelis Killed Palestinian Boy in 2000". The New York Sun.
"400 million lawsuit against Haaretz". NRG (in Hebrew). December 5, 2007.

References

Cygielman, Anat (2000). "IDF keeps shooting itself in the foot", Haaretz, November 7, 2000, accessed March 22, 2010.
Fallows, James (2003). "Who shot Mohammed al-Durra?", The Atlantic, June 2003, accessed March 21, 2010.

External websites

Categories:

Revision as of 20:37, 25 March 2010 editGeorge (talk \| contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers10,550 edits Moving this to talk for discussion.← Previous edit		Revision as of 05:58, 28 March 2010 edit undoSmackBot (talk \| contribs)3,734,324 editsm Date maintenance tags and general fixes: build 402:Next edit →
Line 4:		Line 4:
	According to Israeli reporter ], Shahaf worked for the optical intelligence unit of the ] (IDF) as a physicist, and contributed to the development of ] and video instrumentation. During the 1991 ], he investigated the damage done by Iraqi ] missiles fired against Israel, and concluded that ]s contributed to the damage.<ref name="Lord"></ref> He received an ] award for creativity in 1997 for his work on compressed digital video transmission.<ref name=Fallows />		According to Israeli reporter ], Shahaf worked for the optical intelligence unit of the ] (IDF) as a physicist, and contributed to the development of ] and video instrumentation. During the 1991 ], he investigated the damage done by Iraqi ] missiles fired against Israel, and concluded that ]s contributed to the damage.<ref name="Lord"></ref> He received an ] award for creativity in 1997 for his work on compressed digital video transmission.<ref name=Fallows />

	Shahaf describes himself as "a scientist, a physicist specialized in ballistics and the technology of filming images."<ref name="Guysen">{{~~dead~~ link\|date=March 2010}} ] interviews Nahum Shahaf ()</ref>		Shahaf describes himself as "a scientist, a physicist specialized in ballistics and the technology of filming images."<ref name="Guysen">{{Dead link\|date=March 2010}} ] interviews Nahum Shahaf ()</ref>

	==Al-Durrah investigation==		==Al-Durrah investigation==
	{{~~main~~\|Muhammad al-Durrah incident}}		{{Main\|Muhammad al-Durrah incident}}
	Shortly after the al-Durrah shooting in September 2000, for which the ] had initially admitted responsibility, Shahaf approached IDF ] head Major General ]. Shahaf was already well known to Samia, having previously done work for the IDF.<ref>{{cite book\|last1=Cordesman\|first1=Anthony\|last2=Moravitz\|first2=Jennifer\|title=The Israeli-Palestinian war: escalating to nowhere\|page=372\|publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group\|year=2005\|isbn=9780275987589}}</ref> Shahaf proposed that he and Joseph Doriel, an engineer with whom Shahaf had previously collaborated during work on ], should undertake an investigation into the shooting on behalf of Samia.<ref name=Cygielman /> Samia agreed, and on October 23, 2000, Shahaf helped to arrange a re-enactment of the shooting on an IDF shooting range, in front of a CBS '']'' camera crew. In late November 2000, at the conclusion of the inquiry, Samia presented his findings at a press conference, explaining that the findings were "based on measurements, bullet angles and evidence that the Palestinian boy was hit by a volley of gunfire while Israeli soldiers were firing only single shots."<ref name="CNN">{{~~dead~~ link\|~~Date~~=March 2010}} AP - November 27, 2000</ref>		Shortly after the al-Durrah shooting in September 2000, for which the ] had initially admitted responsibility, Shahaf approached IDF ] head Major General ]. Shahaf was already well known to Samia, having previously done work for the IDF.<ref>{{cite book\|last1=Cordesman\|first1=Anthony\|last2=Moravitz\|first2=Jennifer\|title=The Israeli-Palestinian war: escalating to nowhere\|page=372\|publisher=Greenwood Publishing Group\|year=2005\|isbn=9780275987589}}</ref> Shahaf proposed that he and Joseph Doriel, an engineer with whom Shahaf had previously collaborated during work on ], should undertake an investigation into the shooting on behalf of Samia.<ref name=Cygielman /> Samia agreed, and on October 23, 2000, Shahaf helped to arrange a re-enactment of the shooting on an IDF shooting range, in front of a CBS '']'' camera crew. In late November 2000, at the conclusion of the inquiry, Samia presented his findings at a press conference, explaining that the findings were "based on measurements, bullet angles and evidence that the Palestinian boy was hit by a volley of gunfire while Israeli soldiers were firing only single shots."<ref name="CNN">{{Dead link\|date=March 2010}} AP - November 27, 2000</ref>

	The investigation met with a mixed response. Doriel had been dismissed by Samia during the course of the investigation and when the results were announced, it was strongly criticised by some in the Israeli media. The Israeli newspapers ''Haaretz'' and the ''Jerusalem Post'' argued that Shahaf had no ballistics experience and ''Haaretz'' described his investigation as "dubious."<ref name=Cygielman>.</ref> His previous involvement in raising doubts about the identity of Rabin's killer became the subject of controversy.<ref>Schwartz, Adi (2007). "", ''Haaretz'', November 8, 2007, accessed January 24, 2010.</ref> Shahaf, however, pursued the case and devoted years to the matter,<ref name="Levy">Levy, Gideon. . ''Haaretz'', October 7, 2007, accessed October 23, 2008.</ref> having "spent months painstakingly collecting, wheedling, even buying footage from reluctant cameramen, and then spliced the pieces together in rough temporal order in an attempt to make an unbroken film of the day."<ref>''The other war: Israelis, Palestinians, and the struggle for media supremacy'', Stephanie Gutmann, Encounter Books, 2005, p. 75.</ref> He has promoted a theory that al-Durrah was not killed by the IDF and may still be alive.<ref>{{cite news\|last=Temple-Raston\|first=Dina\|title=Engineer Casts Doubt on Veracity of Claims That Israelis Killed Palestinian Boy in 2000\|url=http://www.nysun.com/foreign/engineer-casts-doubt-on-veracity-of-claims-that/10581/\|work=The New York Sun\|date=March 15, 2005}}</ref> Following ''Haaretz's'' reporting of his work on the al-Durrah case, which editor ] criticised as an "eccentic obsession" in an October 2007 article,<ref name="Levy" /> Shahaf filed a ] lawsuit against the newspaper in December 2007 charging that ''Haaretz's'' coverage had "led investors to flee" from one of his inventions and demanding 400 million ] (US $103 million) in damages.<ref>{{cite news\|title=400 million lawsuit against Haaretz\|url=http://www.nrg.co.il/online/4/ART1/667/290.html\|work=NRG\|language=Hebrew\|date=December 5, 2007}}</ref>		The investigation met with a mixed response. Doriel had been dismissed by Samia during the course of the investigation and when the results were announced, it was strongly criticised by some in the Israeli media. The Israeli newspapers ''Haaretz'' and the ''Jerusalem Post'' argued that Shahaf had no ballistics experience and ''Haaretz'' described his investigation as "dubious."<ref name=Cygielman>.</ref> His previous involvement in raising doubts about the identity of Rabin's killer became the subject of controversy.<ref>Schwartz, Adi (2007). "", ''Haaretz'', November 8, 2007, accessed January 24, 2010.</ref> Shahaf, however, pursued the case and devoted years to the matter,<ref name="Levy">Levy, Gideon. . ''Haaretz'', October 7, 2007, accessed October 23, 2008.</ref> having "spent months painstakingly collecting, wheedling, even buying footage from reluctant cameramen, and then spliced the pieces together in rough temporal order in an attempt to make an unbroken film of the day."<ref>''The other war: Israelis, Palestinians, and the struggle for media supremacy'', Stephanie Gutmann, Encounter Books, 2005, p. 75.</ref> He has promoted a theory that al-Durrah was not killed by the IDF and may still be alive.<ref>{{cite news\|last=Temple-Raston\|first=Dina\|title=Engineer Casts Doubt on Veracity of Claims That Israelis Killed Palestinian Boy in 2000\|url=http://www.nysun.com/foreign/engineer-casts-doubt-on-veracity-of-claims-that/10581/\|work=The New York Sun\|date=March 15, 2005}}</ref> Following ''Haaretz's'' reporting of his work on the al-Durrah case, which editor ] criticised as an "eccentic obsession" in an October 2007 article,<ref name="Levy" /> Shahaf filed a ] lawsuit against the newspaper in December 2007 charging that ''Haaretz's'' coverage had "led investors to flee" from one of his inventions and demanding 400 million ] (US $103 million) in damages.<ref>{{cite news\|title=400 million lawsuit against Haaretz\|url=http://www.nrg.co.il/online/4/ART1/667/290.html\|work=NRG\|language=Hebrew\|date=December 5, 2007}}</ref>