Misplaced Pages

Quranism: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 03:52, 30 January 2006 editDavid.ilyas (talk | contribs)152 edits →Absolutist rejection of hadith and sunnah← Previous edit Revision as of 12:57, 2 February 2006 edit undoPepsidrinka (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users5,829 editsm AWB assisted Quran -> Qur'anNext edit →
Line 2: Line 2:


==Absolutist rejection of hadith and sunnah== ==Absolutist rejection of hadith and sunnah==
] Muslims reject the alleged hadith and sunnah of the prophet Muhammad in accordance with the Quran's teaching that the sole duty of Muhammad was to the deliver the Quran, as per: ] Muslims reject the alleged hadith and sunnah of the prophet Muhammad in accordance with the Qur'an's teaching that the sole duty of Muhammad was to the deliver the Qur'an, as per:


42:48 "You (Muhammad) have NO duty EXCEPT DELIVERING the message." 42:48 "You (Muhammad) have NO duty EXCEPT DELIVERING the message."
Line 10: Line 10:
5:99 "The messenger (Muhammad) has NO function EXCEPT delivery of the message." 5:99 "The messenger (Muhammad) has NO function EXCEPT delivery of the message."


Furthermore, they observe Muhammad's only message as the Quran, as per: Furthermore, they observe Muhammad's only message as the Qur'an, as per:


21:10 "We (God and the angels) have sent down to you a scripture containing YOUR MESSAGE. Do you not understand?" 21:10 "We (God and the angels) have sent down to you a scripture containing YOUR MESSAGE. Do you not understand?"
Line 16: Line 16:
69:44-46 "Had he (Muhammad) uttered any other teachings. We would have punished him. We would have stopped the revelations to him." 69:44-46 "Had he (Muhammad) uttered any other teachings. We would have punished him. We would have stopped the revelations to him."


] Muslims uphold only one hadith (narration) and only one sunnah (system); the Quran. ] Muslims uphold only one hadith (narration) and only one sunnah (system); the Qur'an.


==Groups of Qur'an-alone Muslims== ==Groups of Qur'an-alone Muslims==
=== Rashad Khalifa and the Submitters === === Rashad Khalifa and the Submitters ===
The term is closely associated with the late ], a Muslim immigrant to the ]. He founded a mosque in ], ], and initially attracted many followers and much interest in Muslim circles. He popularized the phrase: the Quran, the whole Quran, and nothing but the Quran. After he declared himself a Messenger of God, he was rejected as an apostate by all save his followers. He was assassinated in 1990. The term is closely associated with the late ], a Muslim immigrant to the ]. He founded a mosque in ], ], and initially attracted many followers and much interest in Muslim circles. He popularized the phrase: the Qur'an, the whole Qur'an, and nothing but the Qur'an. After he declared himself a Messenger of God, he was rejected as an apostate by all save his followers. He was assassinated in 1990.


Khalifa's followers have organized as the ] and usually describe themselves as Qur'an Alone Muslims. They derive their version of ] from a belief in the mathematical preservation since the time of Abraham, based on the number 19 . Khalifa's followers have organized as the ] and usually describe themselves as Qur'an Alone Muslims. They derive their version of ] from a belief in the mathematical preservation since the time of Abraham, based on the number 19 .
Line 33: Line 33:
Those are Muslims who accept Khalifa's original arguments regarding hadith, and still believe that hadith are unnecessary, while rejecting Khalifa's later claims to be a Messenger from God and other elements which are specific of the Submitters. These Muslims have a web presence on the Internet which can be found at their Free Minds website . Those are Muslims who accept Khalifa's original arguments regarding hadith, and still believe that hadith are unnecessary, while rejecting Khalifa's later claims to be a Messenger from God and other elements which are specific of the Submitters. These Muslims have a web presence on the Internet which can be found at their Free Minds website .
Closely related to them are the '''Progressive Muslims''' website , and the Muslims Against Stoning website , an action committee from Muslims who reject the ] punishment of ] (stoning) as contradictory to the Qur'an. Closely related to them are the '''Progressive Muslims''' website , and the Muslims Against Stoning website , an action committee from Muslims who reject the ] punishment of ] (stoning) as contradictory to the Qur'an.
] and ] opponents call them as '''Quraniyyin''', loosely translated as Qur'an people or '''Qur'anites'''. Sunni clerics have directed several ] against them. ] and ] opponents call them as '''Qur'aniyyin''', loosely translated as Qur'an people or '''Qur'anites'''. Sunni clerics have directed several ] against them.


Some of these "disorganized" Quran-only Muslims have been criticized by more orthodox Muslims for practices such as conducting the Friday sermon with people sitting at tables instead of lined up on the floor and not enforcing the Islamic dress codes in mosques. Some of these "disorganized" Qur'an-only Muslims have been criticized by more orthodox Muslims for practices such as conducting the Friday sermon with people sitting at tables instead of lined up on the floor and not enforcing the Islamic dress codes in mosques.


== Qur'an only Islam in history == == Qur'an only Islam in history ==
The Quran alone movement is not a recent phenomenon. In fact, the anti-hadith movement is as old as Hadith itself, e.g. the ] accepted only hadith which were mass-transmitted and shared many viewpoints with the contemporary Qur'an only Muslims, e.g. their emphasis on rationality and ]s. Hadith adherents credit ] for defeating these groups around the 8th centrury AD. From his writings, one can see his stance against the anti-hadith groups at that time. The Qur'an alone movement is not a recent phenomenon. In fact, the anti-hadith movement is as old as Hadith itself, e.g. the ] accepted only hadith which were mass-transmitted and shared many viewpoints with the contemporary Qur'an only Muslims, e.g. their emphasis on rationality and ]s. Hadith adherents credit ] for defeating these groups around the 8th centrury AD. From his writings, one can see his stance against the anti-hadith groups at that time.


Another early group which rejected hadiths were the ] (also known as the "Khawarij"). They argued that it was impossible to know whether a statement had actually issued from the Prophet or not, even if it was mass-transmitted. A more moderate branch of the Kharijites which still survives today are the ]s, who do accept some hadiths. Another early group which rejected hadiths were the ] (also known as the "Khawarij"). They argued that it was impossible to know whether a statement had actually issued from the Prophet or not, even if it was mass-transmitted. A more moderate branch of the Kharijites which still survives today are the ]s, who do accept some hadiths.
Line 45: Line 45:


*Most ] and ] Muslims (who combined form more than 95% of the world's Muslim population) are in agreement that hadith are an integral part of understanding and implementing Islamic teachings. They point out the fact that the Qur'an itself stresses the fact that both ] and the messenger (]) are to be obeyed, as no less than verses in the Qur'an stress obedience to Allah and the messenger. *Most ] and ] Muslims (who combined form more than 95% of the world's Muslim population) are in agreement that hadith are an integral part of understanding and implementing Islamic teachings. They point out the fact that the Qur'an itself stresses the fact that both ] and the messenger (]) are to be obeyed, as no less than verses in the Qur'an stress obedience to Allah and the messenger.
**The Quran Alone Muslims counter this by saying that the Qur'an doesn't say to obey Allah and Muhammad but to obey Allah and the message of Allah's messenger. There's a clear difference between these two statements according to Quran Aloners. They claim that the usage of the term messenger refers to the Message which he delivered i.e. Quran. There is no text in the Qur'an which can be translated literally as 'Obey God and Obey Muhammad'. Also it is a rule in Arabic language that after the death of the physical messenger the term messenger applies to the message itself which is logical. **The Qur'an Alone Muslims counter this by saying that the Qur'an doesn't say to obey Allah and Muhammad but to obey Allah and the message of Allah's messenger. There's a clear difference between these two statements according to Qur'an Aloners. They claim that the usage of the term messenger refers to the Message which he delivered i.e. Qur'an. There is no text in the Qur'an which can be translated literally as 'Obey God and Obey Muhammad'. Also it is a rule in Arabic language that after the death of the physical messenger the term messenger applies to the message itself which is logical.
* Qur'an alone Muslims contend that ] and ] Muslims attribute divine qualities to Muhammad (which is considered by Sunni and Shi'a Muslims as a divine source himself, apart from the Qur'anic texts), which they equalize to ]. * Qur'an alone Muslims contend that ] and ] Muslims attribute divine qualities to Muhammad (which is considered by Sunni and Shi'a Muslims as a divine source himself, apart from the Qur'anic texts), which they equalize to ].
* Moreover, Quran Alone Muslims claim that obeying the messenger by no means can refer to the hadith besides Quran because those, according to them, were sayings falsely attributed to the Prophet Muhammad by the hypocrites at that time. * Moreover, Qur'an Alone Muslims claim that obeying the messenger by no means can refer to the hadith besides Qur'an because those, according to them, were sayings falsely attributed to the Prophet Muhammad by the hypocrites at that time.


== See also == == See also ==


* ] * ]
* ] (, and "held that the legal system is to be derived from Quran only") * ] (, and "held that the legal system is to be derived from Qur'an only")
* ] * ]


Line 72: Line 72:


===Qur'anic resources=== ===Qur'anic resources===
* *
* *
* *
* *
* *
* *
* *


] ]

Revision as of 12:57, 2 February 2006

Qur'an alone Muslims, Qur'anic Muslims or sometimes, anti-hadith are those Muslims who reject hadith, sunnah and abrogation of Qur'anic verses, or recorded Islamic traditions, and follow the Qur'an, Islam's sacred text, without any further additions.

Absolutist rejection of hadith and sunnah

Qur'an Alone Muslims reject the alleged hadith and sunnah of the prophet Muhammad in accordance with the Qur'an's teaching that the sole duty of Muhammad was to the deliver the Qur'an, as per:

42:48 "You (Muhammad) have NO duty EXCEPT DELIVERING the message."

13:40 "(Muhammad) Your ONLY duty is delivering, we (God and the angels) will call them (the people) to account."

5:99 "The messenger (Muhammad) has NO function EXCEPT delivery of the message."

Furthermore, they observe Muhammad's only message as the Qur'an, as per:

21:10 "We (God and the angels) have sent down to you a scripture containing YOUR MESSAGE. Do you not understand?"

69:44-46 "Had he (Muhammad) uttered any other teachings. We would have punished him. We would have stopped the revelations to him."

Qur'an Alone Muslims uphold only one hadith (narration) and only one sunnah (system); the Qur'an.

Groups of Qur'an-alone Muslims

Rashad Khalifa and the Submitters

The term is closely associated with the late Rashad Khalifa, a Muslim immigrant to the United States. He founded a mosque in Tucson, Arizona, and initially attracted many followers and much interest in Muslim circles. He popularized the phrase: the Qur'an, the whole Qur'an, and nothing but the Qur'an. After he declared himself a Messenger of God, he was rejected as an apostate by all save his followers. He was assassinated in 1990.

Khalifa's followers have organized as the United Submitters International and usually describe themselves as Qur'an Alone Muslims. They derive their version of salat from a belief in the mathematical preservation since the time of Abraham, based on the number 19 .

Dissident Submitters

There are a number of Submitters who feel that the Submitter group has gone astray. The Submitters, they say, are devoting themselves to Rashad Khalifa rather than to God. There is evidence of one petition presented to the Submitters and one website maintained by Edip Yuksel, either formerly or currently a member of the Submitters . It is not at all clear that there are more than a handful of these dissidents, or that they have formally withdrawn from the Submitters.

This splinter group, by the evidence of Yuksel's website, has not abandoned any of the Submitter beliefs, such as the Messengership of Khalifa, the rejection of hadith, and the organization of the Qur'an by the number 19. They object merely to the current emphasis of the group.

Non-organised Qur'anic Muslims

Those are Muslims who accept Khalifa's original arguments regarding hadith, and still believe that hadith are unnecessary, while rejecting Khalifa's later claims to be a Messenger from God and other elements which are specific of the Submitters. These Muslims have a web presence on the Internet which can be found at their Free Minds website . Closely related to them are the Progressive Muslims website , and the Muslims Against Stoning website , an action committee from Muslims who reject the shariah punishment of rajam (stoning) as contradictory to the Qur'an. Sunni and Shi'a opponents call them as Qur'aniyyin, loosely translated as Qur'an people or Qur'anites. Sunni clerics have directed several fatwas against them.

Some of these "disorganized" Qur'an-only Muslims have been criticized by more orthodox Muslims for practices such as conducting the Friday sermon with people sitting at tables instead of lined up on the floor and not enforcing the Islamic dress codes in mosques.

Qur'an only Islam in history

The Qur'an alone movement is not a recent phenomenon. In fact, the anti-hadith movement is as old as Hadith itself, e.g. the Mutazilites accepted only hadith which were mass-transmitted and shared many viewpoints with the contemporary Qur'an only Muslims, e.g. their emphasis on rationality and scientific methods. Hadith adherents credit Imam Shafi for defeating these groups around the 8th centrury AD. From his writings, one can see his stance against the anti-hadith groups at that time.

Another early group which rejected hadiths were the Kharijites (also known as the "Khawarij"). They argued that it was impossible to know whether a statement had actually issued from the Prophet or not, even if it was mass-transmitted. A more moderate branch of the Kharijites which still survives today are the Ibadis, who do accept some hadiths.

Opposing viewpoints

  • Most Sunni and Shi'ite Muslims (who combined form more than 95% of the world's Muslim population) are in agreement that hadith are an integral part of understanding and implementing Islamic teachings. They point out the fact that the Qur'an itself stresses the fact that both Allah and the messenger (Muhammad) are to be obeyed, as no less than a dozen verses in the Qur'an stress obedience to Allah and the messenger.
    • The Qur'an Alone Muslims counter this by saying that the Qur'an doesn't say to obey Allah and Muhammad but to obey Allah and the message of Allah's messenger. There's a clear difference between these two statements according to Qur'an Aloners. They claim that the usage of the term messenger refers to the Message which he delivered i.e. Qur'an. There is no text in the Qur'an which can be translated literally as 'Obey God and Obey Muhammad'. Also it is a rule in Arabic language that after the death of the physical messenger the term messenger applies to the message itself which is logical.
  • Qur'an alone Muslims contend that Sunni and Shi'a Muslims attribute divine qualities to Muhammad (which is considered by Sunni and Shi'a Muslims as a divine source himself, apart from the Qur'anic texts), which they equalize to shirk.
  • Moreover, Qur'an Alone Muslims claim that obeying the messenger by no means can refer to the hadith besides Qur'an because those, according to them, were sayings falsely attributed to the Prophet Muhammad by the hypocrites at that time.

See also

Further reading

Daniel Brown, Rethinking Tradition in Modern Islamic Thought ISBN 0521653940

External links

Groups and communities of Qur'an-alone Muslims

Qur'anic resources

Category: