Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 22:35, 21 June 2011

X!'s Edit Counter
Username:	Guoguo12
User groups:	reviewer, rollbacker
First edit:	Mar 14, 2008 20:01:25
Unique pages edited:	6,560
Average edits per page:	1.69
Live edits:	10,284
Deleted edits:	771
Total edits (including deleted):	11,055
Namespace Totals
Article	5212	50.68%
Talk	203	1.97%
User	286	2.78%
User talk	2928	28.47%
Misplaced Pages	1240	12.06%
Misplaced Pages talk	270	2.63%
File	10	0.10%
MediaWiki talk	3	0.03%
Template	89	0.87%
Template talk	31	0.30%
Help	3	0.03%
Help talk	4	0.04%
Category	5	0.05%
Namespace Totals Pie Chart
Month counts
2008/03	1 	
2008/04	0 	
2008/05	0 	
2008/06	0 	
2008/07	0 	
2008/08	0 	
2008/09	0 	
2008/10	0 	
2008/11	0 	
2008/12	0 	
2009/01	2 	
2009/02	2 	
2009/03	7 	
2009/04	15 	
2009/05	27 	
2009/06	0 	
2009/07	9 	
2009/08	3 	
2009/09	0 	
2009/10	1 	
2009/11	23 	
2009/12	2 	
2010/01	6 	
2010/02	14 	
2010/03	85 	
2010/04	30 	
2010/05	65 	
2010/06	546 	
2010/07	572 	
2010/08	687 	
2010/09	893 	
2010/10	717 	
2010/11	903 	
2010/12	880 	
2011/01	1424 	
2011/02	688 	
2011/03	701 	
2011/04	606 	
2011/05	919 	
2011/06	456 	
Top edited pages
Article
    69 - Hollywood_Walk_of_Fame
    63 - Table_tennis
    59 - Battle_of_Atlanta
    57 - USA_Table_Tennis
    49 - Southeast_Asia_Treaty_Organization
    34 - Women's_rights_in_Saudi_Arabia
    15 - Herbert_Hoover_Middle_School_(Potomac,_Maryland)
    15 - Maryland_Classic_Youth_Orchestras
    14 - 1578_in_art
    12 - Julian_Allen
Talk
    20 - Hollywood_Walk_of_Fame
    10 - Southeast_Asia_Treaty_Organization/GA1
    8 - Battle_of_Atlanta
    8 - Table_tennis
    8 - Battle_of_Atlanta/GA1
    4 - Love_Lost_(Four_Freshmen_album)
    4 - P_versus_NP_problem
    3 - The_Virginian_(character)
    2 - Tesco_Clubcard
    2 - TAI_Hürkuş
User
    172 - Guoguo12
    38 - Guoguo12/monobook.js
    5 - Guoguo12/huggle2.css
    5 - Guoguo12/huggle.css
    4 - Supernova2244/Galaxy_legion
    4 - Guoguo12/Sandbox
    3 - Cogware
    3 - Guoguo12/Essays
    2 - Guoguo12/Editnotice
    2 - JNW
User talk
    178 - Guoguo12
    33 - Sumsum2010
    20 - Nolelover
    12 - WikiCopter
    8 - Picopa
    7 - Cogware
    7 - Wayne_Slam
    6 - Katharineamy
    6 - Glimmer721
    6 - Balksoinw
Misplaced Pages
    69 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism
    50 - Graphic_Lab/Photography_workshop/Top_4/2010_Users_...
    42 - Huggle/Whitelist
    32 - Graphic_Lab/Photography_workshop/Eight_Requests
    30 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2011/March_Mini
    29 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2010/October
    29 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2011/April/Log
    29 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/Instructions
    28 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2011/February/Track
    26 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2011/April/Track
Misplaced Pages talk
    115 - WikiProject_Wikify
    13 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2010/December
    9 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2011/February
    7 - Requests_for_adminship
    7 - WikiProject_Wikify/Coordination/2011_Voting
    6 - WikiProject_Wikipedia_Awards
    5 - WikiProject_Wikify/Drives/2011/April
    4 - WikiProject_Table_tennis
    3 - Wikipedia_Signpost/2011-01-03/In_the_news
    3 - RfA_reform_2011/Radical_alternatives
File
    4 - Usatt-small.gif
    3 - Washington_Middle_School_NJ.JPG
    2 - Health_South_Largo_pmr01.jpg
    1 - MCYO_LOGO_small.gif
MediaWiki talk
    3 - Recentchangestext
Template
    33 - Vandalism_information
    10 - Backlog_progress_bar
    6 - Backlog_progress_bar/doc
    5 - Announcements/Community_bulletin_board
    3 - Wikify/tutorial
    2 - X1
    2 - Centralized_discussion
    2 - Template_sandbox
    2 - Wikify/doc
    1 - Wikify_Badge
Template talk
    21 - Did_you_know
    6 - Wikify
    2 - Editnotices/Page/Wikipedia_talk:RfA_reform_2011/Ra...
    1 - Battles_of_the_War_of_1812
    1 - Feedbackreply-sm
Help
    2 - Misplaced Pages:_The_Missing_Manual
    1 - Pending_changes
Help talk
    3 - Misplaced Pages:_The_Missing_Manual
    1 - Editing
Category
    2 - WikiProject_Wikify_participants
    1 - Actor_stubs
    1 - Ancient_Egyptian_musical_instruments
    1 - English_politician_stubs

removed from discussion at Oppose !Vote #1

1. You do realize that without any rationale at all, your opinion will hold no weight when the RfA is closed? --The Σ _contribs 00:41, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

   Er, I would not suggest laying into any of the opposes like that. FWIW, we could apply that same rational to the supports. :P Nolelover 00:46, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

   Amusing. Like your logic Nolelover! OrangeMarlin 00:59, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

   We'd better stop this before it gets out of hand. Either take it to a talk page or stop altogether. The Utahraptor/_Contribs 01:02, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

   If you're talking about what he said to me, I took it as a compliment, so no problems here. Just trying to calm things down. Nolelover 01:06, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

   Definitely a compliment Nolelover. I never answer these questions, so not sure why it was asked. OrangeMarlin 01:07, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

   Come on, y'all. Feel the love. If you need to spin up at anyone do it to me. I get off on it! TCO (talk) 01:13, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

I'm stepping away now... --The Σ _contribs 01:13, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

You know what a sadist does to a masochist? TCO (talk) 01:24, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

Reign it in, TCO-- inappropriate. SandyGeorgia (Talk) 09:10, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

--Kudpung กุดผึ้ง (talk) 03:10, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

Lighten up Sandy. I'm as concerned about this candidacy as you are, but picking unnecessary fights with other editors will only lead to unnecessary drama which might distract from the matters at hand. Miss E. Lovetinkle (talk) 09:24, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

As an oppose vote with no rationale is not harming the candidate very much (unlike, say, a "neutral" comment with some out-of context diffs that supposedly show the candidate's poor judgement: other people will use that as a reason to vote oppose), it is usually good for the candidate if no oppose rationales are given. And that is independent of the question whether the bureaucrats will count the vote or not. (They should: "I do not trust the candidate, but want others to make up their own mind about him/her instead of considering what I think" is a perfectly good reason to oppose without making the reason public). —Kusma (t·c) 07:05, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

And...

...for anyone not watching his page, it appears he has also retired. Damnit -- Nolelover 18:30, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

^ What he said. --The Σ _contribs 20:43, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

It's always the same. A good user tries for adminship once, fails, tries again, fails again, and retires. It's a shame to see Misplaced Pages's finest go this way. The Utahraptor/_Contribs 20:48, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

Actually, it seems to happen a lot more when a user has accidentally made copyvios. I am reminded of former arbitrator Rlevse. And there's multiple other examples of users retiring when copyvios are found. Hopefully, he'll return soon enough. Silverseren 21:22, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

(edit conflict) Yes indeed...Although, in fairness to Guoguo, I don't think he left so much because of what the opposes said (copyvio concerns), as much as the whole personal info/borderline WP:outing thing. He's a smart chap. Nolelover 21:25, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

• This whole "copyvio" and "close paraphrasing" thing needs a better review. If a source says "John Brown died in 1885" there's precious few other ways of writing that John Brown died in 1885 yet Sandy Georgia in her intemperate hot-headed hatred will call you on it, because of the surreal hidden agenda she seems to have. Nevertheless SG made some fair points in this instance, and I don't dispute her oppose as such - but the vitriolic way she made it was exceptionally disgusting, for many reasons; however this is not the venue to use to discuss that (if indeed there is any venue). Pedro :  Chat  21:37, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

  Outing! When did that happen??? --The Σ _contribs 21:47, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

  It's been deleted. 28bytes (talk) 21:51, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

• The issues SandyGeorgia brought up were much more specific than "John Brown died in 1885", and yes there are ways of not using the language in the source. SandyGeorgia's concerns were valid given that the material ended up on the main page. I don't see it as being vitriolic - it is what it is, and there's no good way to say to someone, "hey you need to take care in how you present your material". The copyvio/plagiarism issue is a learning curve that's sometimes difficult, but nonetheless a Misplaced Pages policy and not one to be unaware of while seeking adminship. Truthkeeper88 (talk) 21:56, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

Disagree (and clearly I was using the John Brown bit as an obvious artifice to make a point). There's plenty of ways to say to someone "hey you need to take care in how you present your material" because you just did it yourself Truthkeeper!! - tactfully and with restraint. SG (as usual) invoked hyperbole, screaming into the tea-cloth actions which were utterly unwaranted. The fact she suspected that the candidate was a minor, indeed used it as part of her oppose rationale, just shows her despicable character and why her venemous attitude all over the work is slowly making it less fun for the rest of us. However, I repeat, this is not the venue to discuss that; I suspect there will never be a venue to discuss her poisonous evil attitude whilst she courts the wiki fraternity to be honest. Pedro :  Chat  22:07, 21 June 2011 (UTC)

My sense is that this is creating unnecessary drama when drama should be avoided. My sense is that it's time to drop the stick, and take it up directly with SandyGeorgia if you feel so strongly. Anyway, myself, I'll drop it. Truthkeeper88 (talk) 22:35, 21 June 2011 (UTC)