| Revision as of 04:53, 11 April 2006 editAnirvan (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers6,007 edits Added information about Stanford Daily apology← Previous edit | Revision as of 05:01, 11 April 2006 edit undoAnirvan (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers6,007 edits →Criticism: Include quote from Stanford Daily apologyNext edit → | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
| ==Criticism== | ==Criticism== | ||
| Friends of South Asia is frequently criticized by ] ]n nationalists, who claim that the organization is leftist, Communist, Islamist, or anti-Hindu. | Friends of South Asia is frequently criticized by ] ]n nationalists, who claim that the organization is leftist, Communist, Islamist, terrorist, or anti-Hindu. | ||
| In May 2003, FOSA organized a "Ind-Pak Peace Solidarity March in San Francisco" <ref name="fosa-peacemarch-2003">{{cite web | title=Ind-Pak Peace Solidarity March in San Francisco | work=Friends of South Asia (FOSA) | url=http://www.friendsofsouthasia.org/events/indpakpeace/ | accessdate=2006-04-11}}</ref> with the help of seven co-sponsors, including the ] (PAA). Anonymous critics pointed out that the Pakistan American Alliance's website included an image of a man holding a placard reading "Allah will destroy the terrorist state of India." <ref name="aidindiainfo-antiindians">{{cite web | title="Allah will destroy the terrorist state of India" | work=AID (Association for India's Development) Documents Repository | url=http://www.geocities.com/aid_india_info/AID_DOC.html#anti_Indians | accessdate=2006-04-11}}</ref> FOSA responded by deleting references to the Pakistan American Alliance from their website, and issuing an update stating that they were disturbed by the photo, and had been unaware of PAA's politics, which were contrary to their own. <ref name="fosa-paa">{{cite web | title= | In May 2003, FOSA organized a "Ind-Pak Peace Solidarity March in San Francisco" <ref name="fosa-peacemarch-2003">{{cite web | title=Ind-Pak Peace Solidarity March in San Francisco | work=Friends of South Asia (FOSA) | url=http://www.friendsofsouthasia.org/events/indpakpeace/ | accessdate=2006-04-11}}</ref> with the help of seven co-sponsors, including the ] (PAA). Anonymous critics pointed out that the Pakistan American Alliance's website included an image of a man holding a placard reading "Allah will destroy the terrorist state of India." <ref name="aidindiainfo-antiindians">{{cite web | title="Allah will destroy the terrorist state of India" | work=AID (Association for India's Development) Documents Repository | url=http://www.geocities.com/aid_india_info/AID_DOC.html#anti_Indians | accessdate=2006-04-11}}</ref> FOSA responded by deleting references to the Pakistan American Alliance from their website, and issuing an update stating that they were disturbed by the photo, and had been unaware of PAA's politics, which were contrary to their own. <ref name="fosa-paa">{{cite web | title= | ||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
| During the 2006 ], ] president Mihir Meghani was quoted in '']'' saying that "It's pretty well known that they're tied with the Communist Party in India...It's really a ploy to break down and dissemble Hinduism." ''Metroactive'' also reported on an anonymous threat received by FOSA: "Many of you could be product of rapist sulemans or pedophile pastors. Many of you use Hindu names and backstab Hindus. You shit mongrels. God give me strength to slaughter you. He will." <ref name="metroactive"/> | During the 2006 ], ] president Mihir Meghani was quoted in '']'' saying that "It's pretty well known that they're tied with the Communist Party in India...It's really a ploy to break down and dissemble Hinduism." ''Metroactive'' also reported on an anonymous threat received by FOSA: "Many of you could be product of rapist sulemans or pedophile pastors. Many of you use Hindu names and backstab Hindus. You shit mongrels. God give me strength to slaughter you. He will." <ref name="metroactive"/> | ||
| In May 2006, the ''Stanford Daily'' (the ] student newspaper) ran a story critical of a planned FOSA event, based on an anonymous email claiming that there were simultaneous "Islamist and Communist sympathies within the organization." The anonymous correspondent also claimed that invited speaker Professor ] (]) supported the ] and other terrorist groups.<ref name="stanford-orig">{{cite news | author=Patrick Leahy | title=Leftist speaker sparks debate | date=April 7, 2006 | publisher=Stanford Daily | url=http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=19951&repository=0001_article }}</ref> |
In May 2006, the ''Stanford Daily'' (the ] student newspaper) ran a story critical of a planned FOSA event, based on an anonymous email claiming that there were simultaneous "Islamist and Communist sympathies within the organization." The anonymous correspondent also claimed that invited speaker Professor ] (]) supported the ] and other terrorist groups.<ref name="stanford-orig">{{cite news | author=Patrick Leahy | title=Leftist speaker sparks debate | date=April 7, 2006 | publisher=Stanford Daily | url=http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=19951&repository=0001_article }}</ref> In response to public criticism <ref name="stanford-criticism">{{cite news | title=Letters to the editor | date=April 10, 2006 | publisher=Stanford Daily | url=http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=19960&repository=0001_article }}</ref>, the ''Stanford Daily'' retracted the story and printed an apology in the subsequent issue, stating that "FOSA does not have any ties to Communist or terrorist groups." <ref name="stanford-apology">{{cite news | title=Apology | date=April 10, 2006 | publisher=Stanford Daily | url=http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=19961&repository=0001_article }}</ref> | ||
| ==References== | ==References== | ||
Revision as of 05:01, 11 April 2006
Friends of South Asia (FOSA, established 2001) is a volunteer South Asian American peace organization based in the San Francisco Bay Area. The group's basic mission is to "achieve a peaceful, prosperous, and hate-free South Asia...work through people-to-people contacts, dialog, and other non-violent, non-exclusionary means."
FOSA was founded in 2001 by Indian and Pakistani expatriates concerned about the threat of impending war between their two nations. Members organized candlelight vigils and letter-writing campaigns for peace .
According to its website, FOSA has also been involved with campaigns in opposition to the Iraq War, and human rights abuses in Maharashtra (India) and Balochistan (Pakistan). FOSA was also an active participant in the Californian Hindu textbook controversy, in which it joined a number of groups petitioning California's Curriculum Commission to reject allegedly revisionist edits to California's textbook curriculum on Hinduism and India, suggested by two Hindu organizations.
Criticism
Friends of South Asia is frequently criticized by Hindu Indian nationalists, who claim that the organization is leftist, Communist, Islamist, terrorist, or anti-Hindu.
In May 2003, FOSA organized a "Ind-Pak Peace Solidarity March in San Francisco" with the help of seven co-sponsors, including the Pakistan American Alliance (PAA). Anonymous critics pointed out that the Pakistan American Alliance's website included an image of a man holding a placard reading "Allah will destroy the terrorist state of India." FOSA responded by deleting references to the Pakistan American Alliance from their website, and issuing an update stating that they were disturbed by the photo, and had been unaware of PAA's politics, which were contrary to their own.
During the 2006 Californian Hindu textbook controversy, Hindu American Foundation president Mihir Meghani was quoted in Metroactive saying that "It's pretty well known that they're tied with the Communist Party in India...It's really a ploy to break down and dissemble Hinduism." Metroactive also reported on an anonymous threat received by FOSA: "Many of you could be product of rapist sulemans or pedophile pastors. Many of you use Hindu names and backstab Hindus. You shit mongrels. God give me strength to slaughter you. He will."
In May 2006, the Stanford Daily (the Stanford University student newspaper) ran a story critical of a planned FOSA event, based on an anonymous email claiming that there were simultaneous "Islamist and Communist sympathies within the organization." The anonymous correspondent also claimed that invited speaker Professor Biju Mathew (Rider University) supported the Unabomber and other terrorist groups. In response to public criticism , the Stanford Daily retracted the story and printed an apology in the subsequent issue, stating that "FOSA does not have any ties to Communist or terrorist groups."
References
- ^ "Friends of South Asia". Friends of South Asia (FOSA). Retrieved 2006-04-11.
- Suzanne Lee (February 1, 2002). "Bay Area South Asians Kick-off Monthly Global Peace Vigils". AsianWeek.
- Ryan Kim, Matthew B. Stannard and Charles Burress, Chronicle Staff Writers (June 2, 2002). "Kashmir tension watched closely by Bay relatives". San Francisco Chronicle.
{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ Vrinda Normand (February 1, 2006). "Battling the Past: Indian parents and scholars go to war over how Hindu history is taught in California schools". Metroactive.
- "Speak Out Against the Hindutva Assault on California's History Textbooks". Friends of South Asia (FOSA). Retrieved 2006-04-11.
- Californian Hindu textbook controversy
- "Ind-Pak Peace Solidarity March in San Francisco". Friends of South Asia (FOSA). Retrieved 2006-04-11.
- ""Allah will destroy the terrorist state of India"". AID (Association for India's Development) Documents Repository. Retrieved 2006-04-11.
- "Statement of Clarification by the Friends of South Asia, on Pakistan American Alliance's co-sponsorship". Friends of South Asia (FOSA). Retrieved 2006-04-11.
- Patrick Leahy (April 7, 2006). "Leftist speaker sparks debate". Stanford Daily.
- "Letters to the editor". Stanford Daily. April 10, 2006.
- "Apology". Stanford Daily. April 10, 2006.