| Revision as of 17:43, 26 June 2013 editSlimVirgin (talk | contribs)172,064 edits →Archived disputes: + Misplaced Pages:Requests for comment/Folken de Fanel← Previous edit | Revision as of 16:25, 27 July 2013 edit undoBDD (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Administrators111,920 edits →Archived disputes: Baboon43Next edit → | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
| | Issues | | Issues | ||
| | Outcome of the Rfc (agreement, arbitration, mediation, etc).--> | | Outcome of the Rfc (agreement, arbitration, mediation, etc).--> | ||
| |- | |||
| |] | |||
| |22 June 2013 | |||
| |Uncivil behavior, edit warring, and sock puppetry, mostly related to Islam topics | |||
| |Discussion went stale after a few weeks, with Baboon43 refusing to participate, before the issue was taken to AN, resulting in an indefinite block. | |||
| |- | |- | ||
| |] | |] | ||
| Line 34: | Line 39: | ||
| |Problematic behaviour around AfDs and notabilty issues related to Dungeons & Dragons | |Problematic behaviour around AfDs and notabilty issues related to Dungeons & Dragons | ||
| |There was consensus that Folken's approach needs to change. The closing admin suggested that he agree to a voluntary topic ban regarding deletion issues in the problem area. | |There was consensus that Folken's approach needs to change. The closing admin suggested that he agree to a voluntary topic ban regarding deletion issues in the problem area. | ||
| |- | |- | ||
| |] | |] | ||
Revision as of 16:25, 27 July 2013
 Archives |
This page is for archiving user conduct disputes listed on Misplaced Pages:Requests for comment. Archived disputes should not be added to. Disputes should be archived under any of the following circumstances:
- If no additional complaints are registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
- The parties to the dispute agree.
- The dispute proceeds to another method of dispute resolution, such as mediation or arbitration.
If the dispute is handled in mediation or arbitration, please make a note of where the dispute resolution process continued.
Archived disputes
- Newer entries towards the top
- This page only displays user RFCs from the most recent year and the current year, older discussions can be found in the archives, a search box is provided above
- As of March 25, 2013, the names of the certifiers are no longer a required field. You can find this information easily by clicking the link to the RFC itself.
| Name | Start date | Description | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baboon43 | 22 June 2013 | Uncivil behavior, edit warring, and sock puppetry, mostly related to Islam topics | Discussion went stale after a few weeks, with Baboon43 refusing to participate, before the issue was taken to AN, resulting in an indefinite block. |
| Folken de Fanel | 30 April 2013 | Problematic behaviour around AfDs and notabilty issues related to Dungeons & Dragons | There was consensus that Folken's approach needs to change. The closing admin suggested that he agree to a voluntary topic ban regarding deletion issues in the problem area. |
| Jax 0677 | 29 March 2013 | Problematic creation of navboxes and other content | some progress, later apparenrlty reversed. a proposal for a formal topic ban is anticipated |
| Arzel | 13 May 2013 | Talk page and behavioral issues | Withdrawn after discussion on talk page of RfC/U |
| Will Beback | 23 March 2013 | To discuss whether Will should be allowed back to edit | No consensus to overturn Arbcom decision |
| Apostle12 | 21 December 2012 | Soapboxing, personal attacks, unreliable sources, canvassing | Closed due to inactivity |
| CartoonDiablo | 20 January 2013 | Tendentious editing/POV issues | All participants other than the certifiers felt that this dispute was about content, not conduct |
| Name | Start date | Description | First two certifiers | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cantaloupe2 | 31 January 2013 | Concerns about civility, battlegrounding, and related conduct issues | AndrewDressel, CorporateM | Serious and valid problems with Cantaloupe2's conduct exist. The matter might be taken up by ArbCom. |
| Epeefleche | 15 January 2013 | Removal of unsourced content from articles | Danjel, Graham87 | Epeefleche is broadly correct to remove unsourced content, and Danjel has often acted wrongly in restoring unsourced content. Also, Danjel's conduct is widely seen as hounding. |
| Morriswa | 29 December 2012 | Mass edits at high speed, improper use of rollback, deficient listening skills | Rschen7754, Imzadi1979 | Broad consensus that Morriswa's work was indeed problematic, a problem now recognized by Morriswa. Good will and good faith all around, fortunately. |
| Johnpacklambert | 12 December 2012 | excessive editing of the category namespace | Purplebackpack89, Ephebi | No users endorsed the certifier's position, only statements critical of the certifiers and the process received significant support. |
| Rhode Island Red 2 | 21 November 2012 | Civility, misuse of edit summaries, sopaboxing, biting the newcomers | GeorgeLouis, Collect | No consensus, closing admin suggested taking larger issues to arbitration |
| Bluerim | 29 November 2012 | Civility, edit warring, consensus | Sjones23, JDC808 | Closed due to inactivity; Bluerim's last edit was two months before closure |
| Niemti | 01 November 2012 | Incivility, ownership, Good articles, lack of edit summaries, Anita Sarkeesian article | Bridies, GamerPro64 | Topic ban from Anita Sarkeesian at ANI |
| Apteva | 30 November 2012 | Concerns strongly asserted opinions about en dashes and the Manual of Style, and allegations of disruption | Dicklyon, SMcCandlish | Taken to WP:AN for action (diff; closing summary). |
| Darkstar1st | 19 November 2012 | To determine whether editor fails to "get the point" in discussions about article content. | R-41, Kierzek | Closed a second time. RfC/U of limited scope concluded there were behavioral problems. |
| RidjalA | 3 November 2012 | Concerns regarding possible personal attacks, Possible ownership, and disruptive behavior as a result of bias against the LDM church. | Fordx12, Ajaxfiore | Delisted due to inactivity |
| Paul Bedson | 3 December 2012 | Lack of compliance with verifiability and sourcing policies and guidelines, and original research. | Mike Christie, Ealdgyth | Unanimous consensus that the problems identified in the RfC exist. Paul Bedson was indefinitely blocked. |
| SchuminWeb | 3 December 2012 | Accountability for Administrative Actions | Ironholds, GiantSnowman | Several highly endorsed viewpoints. Referred to Arbitration. |
| HiLo48 | 30 October 2012 | Civility, Use of offensive language | Surturz, Skyring | no consensus achieved. |
| Mmarque | 19 October 2012 | Personal attacks on several users | Joel B. Lewis, ArthurPSmith | no consensus due achieved. |
| Wikiwatcher1 | 6 August 2012 | Copyright verification, disruption | Moonriddengirl, We hope | no consensus due to lack of community input |
| Kurmaa | 24 August 2012 | Disruptive interactions at talk pages | Aeusoes1, Chaipau | User indef blocked for sockpuppetry |
| Bittergrey | 28 July 2012 | Battleground mentality, COI/activism, off-wiki harassment of an editor | WLU, Saedon | Suspended due to Bittergrey being blocked for disruption on 30 July 2012 |
| Offender9000 | 25 June 2012 | Outing, violations of neutrality/weight and battleground-like conduct | Daveosaurus, Stuartyeates | No consensus achieved |
| Youreallycan | 5 August 2012 | Edit warring and personal attack | Prioryman, Magog the Ogre | Agreement. One month break followed by 3 month BLP restriction and 6 month 1RR and civility parole |
| Agent00f | 12 May 2012 | Talk page disruption | Hasteur | No consensus achieved. |
| TenPoundHammer | 7 March 2012 | Article deletion nominations | Andy Dingley, Ruud Koot | User offered to be more in line with community consensus |
| Vision Thing | 20 March 2012 | Biased editing | Hipocrite, Lawrencekhoo | Delisted due to inactivity |
| TBrandley | 29 February 2012 | Excessive article creation, disruption | Logical Cowboy, JayJay | Closed due to editor indef blocked |
| Kolins | 10 January 2012 | Potential editing against consensus and lack of discussion on talk pages. | GiantSnowman, Drmies | Closed after expiring without any response from Kolins |
| Fæ | 25 January 2012 | Various | Delicious carbuncle, Aaron Brenneman | No consensus was reached |
| DocKino | 14 January 2012 | alleged persistently uncivil edit summaries | Mmyers1976, Dolphin | DocKino has acknowledged that editing Misplaced Pages with frustration and anger is not conductive to a collaborative editing environment and will endeavor to refrain from said commentary in the future. |