| Revision as of 05:05, 24 March 2014 editTheRedPenOfDoom (talk | contribs)Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers135,756 edits Undid revision 600941747 by Intuitive2000 (talk) random blogosmoke← Previous edit | Revision as of 05:06, 24 March 2014 edit undoTheRedPenOfDoom (talk | contribs)Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers135,756 edits Undid revision 600905969 by Intuitive2000 (talk) undue weight to invovled parties self serving claimsNext edit → | ||
| Line 28: | Line 28: | ||
| |eISSN = | |eISSN = | ||
| }} | }} | ||
| '''''Pattern Recognition in Physics''''' was an open-access journal originally published by ] which was established in March 2013 and terminated in January 2014. The ] were Sid-Ali Ouadfeul (]) and ], the latter of whom is a well-known ].<ref>{{cite web |url=http://blogs.nature.com/news/2014/01/climate-comments-push-open-access-publisher-to-terminate-journal.html |title=Climate comments push open-access publisher to terminate journal |work=] Blog |date=20 January 2014 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Castelvecchi, Davide}}</ref> Copernicus ceased its publication due to concerns over the publications views towards the scientific consensus of global climate change and the method of peer review. |
'''''Pattern Recognition in Physics''''' was an open-access journal originally published by ] which was established in March 2013 and terminated in January 2014. The ] were Sid-Ali Ouadfeul (]) and ], the latter of whom is a well-known ].<ref>{{cite web |url=http://blogs.nature.com/news/2014/01/climate-comments-push-open-access-publisher-to-terminate-journal.html |title=Climate comments push open-access publisher to terminate journal |work=] Blog |date=20 January 2014 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Castelvecchi, Davide}}</ref> Copernicus ceased its publication due to concerns over the publications views towards the scientific consensus of global climate change and the method of peer review. | ||
| == History == | == History == | ||
| Copernicus agreed to publish the journal because the editors claimed that its aim would be "to publish articles about patterns recognized in the full spectrum of physical disciplines rather than to focus on climate-research-related topics."<ref name=SI/> Concerns regarding the journal's ] process were first raised in July 2013 by ], an American librarian and critic of ]. Beall wrote on his blog that Ouadfeul's research has "only been cited a couple times," and went on to accuse him of self-plagiarizing from a book he had written in 2012, entitled "Wavelet Transforms and Their Recent Applications in Biology and Geoscience." Beall concluded that "This is not a good start for a journal, and the publisher ought to be concerned and take action."<ref>{{cite web |url=http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/07/16/recognizing-a-pattern-of-problems-in-pattern-recognition-in-physics/ |title=Recognizing a Pattern of Problems in "Pattern Recognition in Physics" |work=Scholarlyoa.com |date=16 July 2013 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Beall, Jeffrey}}</ref> | Copernicus agreed to publish the journal because the editors claimed that the its aim would be "to publish articles about patterns recognized in the full spectrum of physical disciplines rather than to focus on climate-research-related topics."<ref name=SI/> Concerns regarding the journal's ] process were first raised in July 2013 by ], an American librarian and critic of ]. Beall wrote on his blog that Ouadfeul's research has "only been cited a couple times," and went on to accuse him of self-plagiarizing from a book he had written in 2012, entitled "Wavelet Transforms and Their Recent Applications in Biology and Geoscience." Beall concluded that "This is not a good start for a journal, and the publisher ought to be concerned and take action."<ref>{{cite web |url=http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/07/16/recognizing-a-pattern-of-problems-in-pattern-recognition-in-physics/ |title=Recognizing a Pattern of Problems in "Pattern Recognition in Physics" |work=Scholarlyoa.com |date=16 July 2013 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Beall, Jeffrey}}</ref> | ||
| After a special issue of the journal was published in December 2013, which contained a paper in which the authors said they "doubt the continued, even accelerated, warming as claimed by the IPCC project,"<ref>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recogn-phys.net/1/205/2013/prp-1-205-2013.pdf |title=General conclusions regarding the planetary–solar–terrestrial interaction |author=Mörner, Nils-Axel |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=December 2013 |volume=1 |issue=1 |pages=205–206}}</ref> managing director Martin Rasmussen expressed concern regarding this journal; he also said that "the editors selected the referees on a nepotistic basis, which we regard as malpractice in scientific publishing."<ref name=SI>{{cite web |url=http://news.sciencemag.org/physics/2014/01/alleging-malpractice-climate-skeptic-papers-publisher-kills-journal |title=Alleging 'Malpractice' With Climate Skeptic Papers, Publisher Kills Journal |work=] |date=17 January 2014 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Stokstad, Erik}}</ref> On January 17, 2014, Copernicus Publications announced that they were terminating the journal, citing both the statement that questioned the IPCC's prediction of continued global warming and the "nepotistic" appointing of similarly-minded scientists to the journal's editorial board.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/01/20/was-a-scientific-journal-canned-for-disagreeing-with-the-ipcc/ |title=Was a scientific journal canned for disagreeing with the IPCC? |work=] |date=20 January 2014 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Adler, Jonathan H.}}</ref> | After a special issue of the journal was published in December 2013, which contained a paper in which the authors said they "doubt the continued, even accelerated, warming as claimed by the IPCC project,"<ref>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recogn-phys.net/1/205/2013/prp-1-205-2013.pdf |title=General conclusions regarding the planetary–solar–terrestrial interaction |author=Mörner, Nils-Axel |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=December 2013 |volume=1 |issue=1 |pages=205–206}}</ref> managing director Martin Rasmussen expressed concern regarding this journal; he also said that "the editors selected the referees on a nepotistic basis, which we regard as malpractice in scientific publishing."<ref name=SI>{{cite web |url=http://news.sciencemag.org/physics/2014/01/alleging-malpractice-climate-skeptic-papers-publisher-kills-journal |title=Alleging 'Malpractice' With Climate Skeptic Papers, Publisher Kills Journal |work=] |date=17 January 2014 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Stokstad, Erik}}</ref> On January 17, 2014, Copernicus Publications announced that they were terminating the journal, citing both the statement that questioned the IPCC's prediction of continued global warming and the "nepotistic" appointing of similarly-minded scientists to the journal's editorial board.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/01/20/was-a-scientific-journal-canned-for-disagreeing-with-the-ipcc/ |title=Was a scientific journal canned for disagreeing with the IPCC? |work=] |date=20 January 2014 |accessdate=11 February 2014 |author=Adler, Jonathan H.}}</ref> | ||
| In the re-opening editorial of the journal, Nils-Axel Mörner rejected Martin Rasmussen's arguments stating: "In your decision, I think you violate the freedom of science and freedom of speech. I can do nothing but condemn your decision as unjust, unethical and ulti anti-scientific."<ref name=MO1>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recognition-in-physics.com/pub/prp-2-27-2014.pdf |title=Editorial: Re-opening of Pattern Recognition in Physics |author=Mörner, N.-A. |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=07 March 2014 |volume=2 |issue=2 |pages=27–29}}</ref> Mörner explained that: |
In the re-opening editorial of the journal, Nils-Axel Mörner rejected Martin Rasmussen's arguments stating: "In your decision, I think you violate the freedom of science and freedom of speech. I can do nothing but condemn your decision as unjust, unethical and ulti anti-scientific."<ref name=MO1>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recognition-in-physics.com/pub/prp-2-27-2014.pdf |title=Editorial: Re-opening of Pattern Recognition in Physics |author=Mörner, N.-A. |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=07 March 2014 |volume=2 |issue=2 |pages=27–29}}</ref> Mörner explained that: "In the general conclusions of the special issue,<ref name=SI2>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recogn-phys.net/special_issue2.html |title=Pattern in solar variability, their planetary origin and terrestrial impacts |author=Mörner, N.-A., Tattersall, R., Solheim, J.-E. |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date= 2013-2014 |volume=1-2 |issue= Special Issue |pages=}}</ref> 19 scientists had joined in a conclusion that we – from a solar-planetary point of view – are on our way into a grand solar minimum, which 'sheds serious doubts on the issue of a continued, even accelerated, warming as claimed by the IPCC.' In the mind of Rasmussen this logical statement posed an intolerable criticism of the IPCC, and the journal was shut down. If anything in modern society should not be tolerated, it is a censorship in conflict with ethics and scientific norms."<ref name=MO1>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recognition-in-physics.com/pub/prp-2-27-2014.pdf |title=Editorial: Re-opening of Pattern Recognition in Physics |author=Mörner, N.-A. |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=07 March 2014 |volume=2 |issue=2 |pages=27–29}}</ref> Mörner also demonstrated that the original statement published by Rasmussen on the morning of January 17, 2014 to justify the closure of the journal mentioned exclusively Rasmussen's objection that "things had been published which questioned the correctness of the global warming scenarios of the IPCC."<ref name=MO1>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recognition-in-physics.com/pub/prp-2-27-2014.pdf |title=Editorial: Re-opening of Pattern Recognition in Physics |author=Mörner, N.-A. |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=07 March 2014 |volume=2 |issue=2 |pages=27–29}}</ref> About Rasmussen's second concern that "the editors selected the referees on a nepotistic basis" Mörner stated: "in the afternoon of January 17, 2014 an additional `reason' appeared on the online statement – as it seems – in the act of diverging the attention of the public to something else... We certainly do not recall any nomination of reviewers on such a base: on the contrary, only specialists on the issues in question were asked to review the papers."<ref name=MO1>{{cite journal |url=http://www.pattern-recognition-in-physics.com/pub/prp-2-27-2014.pdf |title=Editorial: Re-opening of Pattern Recognition in Physics |author=Mörner, N.-A. |journal=Pattern Recognition in Physics |date=07 March 2014 |volume=2 |issue=2 |pages=27–29}}</ref> | ||
| == References == | == References == | ||
Revision as of 05:06, 24 March 2014
 | This article is an orphan, as no other articles link to it. Please introduce links to this page from related articles; try the Find link tool for suggestions. (March 2014) |
 | Pattern Recogn Phys doesn't exist. Please verify that |abbreviation=Pattern Recogn. Phys. in {{Infobox journal}} is the correct ISO 4 abbreviation. (Or search the LTWA manually, see directions). Then create a redirect to this article by following this link. |
 | |
| Discipline | Physics |
|---|---|
| Language | English |
| Edited by | Sid-Ali Ouadfeul |
| Publication details | |
| History | 2013-2014 |
| Publisher | Copernicus Publications |
| Open access | Yes |
| Standard abbreviations ISO 4 (alt) · Bluebook (alt) NLM (alt) · MathSciNet (alt  ) | |
| ISO 4 | Pattern Recogn. Phys. |
| Indexing CODEN (alt · alt2) · JSTOR (alt) · LCCN (alt) MIAR · NLM (alt) · Scopus | |
| ISSN | 2195-9250 |
| OCLC no. | 858879687 |
Pattern Recognition in Physics was an open-access journal originally published by Copernicus Publications which was established in March 2013 and terminated in January 2014. The editors-in-chief were Sid-Ali Ouadfeul (Algerian Petroleum Institute) and Nils-Axel Mörner, the latter of whom is a well-known climate change skeptic. Copernicus ceased its publication due to concerns over the publications views towards the scientific consensus of global climate change and the method of peer review.
History
Copernicus agreed to publish the journal because the editors claimed that the its aim would be "to publish articles about patterns recognized in the full spectrum of physical disciplines rather than to focus on climate-research-related topics." Concerns regarding the journal's peer-review process were first raised in July 2013 by Jeffrey Beall, an American librarian and critic of predatory open access publishing. Beall wrote on his blog that Ouadfeul's research has "only been cited a couple times," and went on to accuse him of self-plagiarizing from a book he had written in 2012, entitled "Wavelet Transforms and Their Recent Applications in Biology and Geoscience." Beall concluded that "This is not a good start for a journal, and the publisher ought to be concerned and take action."
After a special issue of the journal was published in December 2013, which contained a paper in which the authors said they "doubt the continued, even accelerated, warming as claimed by the IPCC project," managing director Martin Rasmussen expressed concern regarding this journal; he also said that "the editors selected the referees on a nepotistic basis, which we regard as malpractice in scientific publishing." On January 17, 2014, Copernicus Publications announced that they were terminating the journal, citing both the statement that questioned the IPCC's prediction of continued global warming and the "nepotistic" appointing of similarly-minded scientists to the journal's editorial board.
In the re-opening editorial of the journal, Nils-Axel Mörner rejected Martin Rasmussen's arguments stating: "In your decision, I think you violate the freedom of science and freedom of speech. I can do nothing but condemn your decision as unjust, unethical and ulti anti-scientific." Mörner explained that: "In the general conclusions of the special issue, 19 scientists had joined in a conclusion that we – from a solar-planetary point of view – are on our way into a grand solar minimum, which 'sheds serious doubts on the issue of a continued, even accelerated, warming as claimed by the IPCC.' In the mind of Rasmussen this logical statement posed an intolerable criticism of the IPCC, and the journal was shut down. If anything in modern society should not be tolerated, it is a censorship in conflict with ethics and scientific norms." Mörner also demonstrated that the original statement published by Rasmussen on the morning of January 17, 2014 to justify the closure of the journal mentioned exclusively Rasmussen's objection that "things had been published which questioned the correctness of the global warming scenarios of the IPCC." About Rasmussen's second concern that "the editors selected the referees on a nepotistic basis" Mörner stated: "in the afternoon of January 17, 2014 an additional `reason' appeared on the online statement – as it seems – in the act of diverging the attention of the public to something else... We certainly do not recall any nomination of reviewers on such a base: on the contrary, only specialists on the issues in question were asked to review the papers."
References
- Castelvecchi, Davide (20 January 2014). "Climate comments push open-access publisher to terminate journal". Nature News Blog. Retrieved 11 February 2014.
- ^ Stokstad, Erik (17 January 2014). "Alleging 'Malpractice' With Climate Skeptic Papers, Publisher Kills Journal". Science Insider. Retrieved 11 February 2014.
- Beall, Jeffrey (16 July 2013). "Recognizing a Pattern of Problems in "Pattern Recognition in Physics"". Scholarlyoa.com. Retrieved 11 February 2014.
- Mörner, Nils-Axel (December 2013). "General conclusions regarding the planetary–solar–terrestrial interaction" (PDF). Pattern Recognition in Physics. 1 (1): 205–206.
- Adler, Jonathan H. (20 January 2014). "Was a scientific journal canned for disagreeing with the IPCC?". The Washington Post. Retrieved 11 February 2014.
- ^ Mörner, N.-A. (07 March 2014). "Editorial: Re-opening of Pattern Recognition in Physics" (PDF). Pattern Recognition in Physics. 2 (2): 27–29.
{{cite journal}}: Check date values in:|date=(help) - Mörner, N.-A., Tattersall, R., Solheim, J.-E. (2013–2014). "Pattern in solar variability, their planetary origin and terrestrial impacts". Pattern Recognition in Physics. 1–2 (Special Issue).
{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: date format (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)