Encyclopaedia Metallum: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively ← Previous edit Next edit →Content deleted Content addedVisual WikitextInline

Revision as of 04:37, 29 September 2006 editOurs18 (talk \| contribs)Extended confirmed users1,013 edits →Bands excluded by the website: nit-picky grammar change← Previous edit		Revision as of 11:34, 29 September 2006 edit undoDaddy Kindsoul (talk \| contribs)19,776 edits removing article blanking as per simple vandalism.. and adding some information provided by Evenfiel on the talkpage.Next edit →
Line 15:		Line 15:
	The site is known for its extremely strict rules, especially those which mandate band submissions. Encyclopaedia Metallum only accepts bands which it deems metal, but many bands that once were rejected were accepted later on, and vice versa. The only exceptions are: side projects of members of metal bands that were released by a label with worldwide distribution, bands that are no longer considered to be metal, but were in the past and ] bands that bear close similarities to ].		The site is known for its extremely strict rules, especially those which mandate band submissions. Encyclopaedia Metallum only accepts bands which it deems metal, but many bands that once were rejected were accepted later on, and vice versa. The only exceptions are: side projects of members of metal bands that were released by a label with worldwide distribution, bands that are no longer considered to be metal, but were in the past and ] bands that bear close similarities to ].

	Additionally, there are some non-metal bands featured on the site that are considered to be part of the metal scene despite not being metal themselves (usually ] and ] bands, examples being ], ], ], ], etc). These bands are selected by the moderators in an admittedly arbitrary fashion, and their submission by normal users is discouraged.<ref></ref>		Additionally, there are some non-metal bands featured on the site that are considered to be part of the metal scene despite not being metal themselves (usually ] and ] bands, examples being ], ], ], ], etc). These bands are selected by the moderators in an admittedly arbitrary fashion, and their submission by normal users is discouraged.<ref></ref>

	===Bands excluded by the website===		===Bands excluded by the website===
	Genres that are sometimes associated with extreme metal, such as ] and ], are also absent as they are seen to have more in common with ] than metal. ] is rejected if the website owners consider the band more hard rock than metal. ] is only allowed if the site' staff consider it "more metal related than industrial", for example; the ~~band~~ ] is ~~not~~ ~~allowed,~~ ~~while~~ ] is.		Genres that are sometimes associated with extreme metal, such as ] and ], are also absent as they are seen to have more in common with ] than metal. ] is rejected if the website owners consider the band more hard rock than metal. ] is only allowed if the site's staff consider it "more metal related than industrial", for example; the website owners refuse to accept the world famous ] act ] into their ].

	Bands that are associated with the ] or ] labels are completely forbidden and have been since the website started. Many users believe that ] bands have been completely banned from the website since a bulletin was posted that simply stated, "''Please stop submitting -core bands. Please.''" However, this is false; many metalcore bands appear on the archives and many more have been added since the bulletin was posted, but the moderators have become more strict on what metalcore bands can be added and generally work case-by-case rather than saying all, or zero, metalcore bands will be accepted. Most of the metalcore bands that are allowed are the ones heavily influenced by ]. The metalcore bands that typically get rejected are ones that sound like ], ], ], ] and ].		Bands that are associated with the ] or ] labels are completely forbidden and have been since the website started. Many users believe that ] bands have been completely banned from the website since a bulletin was posted that simply stated, "''Please stop submitting -core bands. Please.''" However, this is false; many metalcore bands appear on the archives and many more have been added since the bulletin was posted, but the moderators have become more strict on what metalcore bands can be added and generally work case-by-case rather than saying all, or zero, metalcore bands will be accepted. Most of the metalcore bands that are allowed are the ones heavily influenced by ]. The metalcore bands that typically get rejected are ones that sound like ], ], ], ] and ].

			Unlike ], ], and some of the extreme metal related bands that fall into ], ], ], ] and ] (with the exception of ]) genres, which have no further specific restrictions aside from "''proof of existence''".
	The site runners have excluded some of what are considered by some sites <ref> </ref> as founding and definitive<ref></ref> heavy metal acts, such as ] and ]; the website's runners consider these acts as simply ], despite their influence and history. However, there are some websites concentrating on rock and metal music that, like Encyclopaedia Metallum, just mention Led Zeppelin as "hard rock". <ref></ref> <ref></ref>

			], ] and ] genres have stringent rulings; users are warned in the rules section, to consider bands submitted under these classifications as "''ambiguous''", in the sense that if a band is submitted with these terms as their genre, the music will be extensively reviewed by the website owners before they decide whether or not to accept the band onto the website.<ref></ref>

			====Led Zeppelin====
			The site runners have excluded some of what are considered by some prominent sites (such as ],<ref></ref>],<ref></ref>,],<ref></ref>],<ref></ref>],<ref></ref>]<ref></ref> and others.) as founding and definitive<ref></ref> heavy metal acts, such as ] and ]; the website's runners consider these acts as simply ], despite their influence and history.

			Although there are some websites concentrating on rock and metal music that just mention Led Zeppelin as "hard rock"; however, unlike Encyclopaedia Metallum, these metal sites such as ] who classifiy the band as just "hard rock" include a profile of them in their ].<ref></ref> <ref></ref> <ref>http://www.anus.com/metal/about/history</ref>

			Encyclopaedia Metallum's opinions are not representative of the ] related community as a whole on the band, it should be noted, for example; ] of ] and ] of ] have both stated that they consider Led Zeppelin as one of the greatest ] bands of all-time.<ref></ref>

	== History ==		== History ==
Line 34:		Line 43:
	* Industrial metal band ] was originally rejected since it was believed they were not metal enough. Recently, the band was accepted after their two recent albums.		* Industrial metal band ] was originally rejected since it was believed they were not metal enough. Recently, the band was accepted after their two recent albums.
	* There have been cases in which bands originally accepted have been later rejected. One example was ] band, ]. Another was ] band, ], for the belief they were "too ]".		* There have been cases in which bands originally accepted have been later rejected. One example was ] band, ]. Another was ] band, ], for the belief they were "too ]".
			* Most bands from the site are related to death, black, thrash, doom metal and variants, but the non-] genres, like gothic, power, speed, traditional metal and variants, are also included.

	==Notes==		==Notes==

Revision as of 11:34, 29 September 2006

Encyclopaedia Metallum: The Metal Archives is a website which lists bands from various froms of heavy metal music. However, there are exceptions; for heavy metal subgenres which are not accepted by the website, see the site rules for further information.

Encyclopaedia Metallum attempts to provide additional information on each band, such as a discography, logos, pictures, lyrics, line-ups, biography, trivia and user-submitted reviews.

The site also provides a system for submitting bands to the archives, and users are encouraged to use it. As of September 2006, the site boasts +40,000 bands listed, +96,000 albums, +22,000 reviews and +80,000 registered users (+59,000 of which are "currently active")

User interaction

As an incentive to get people to submit data, the site uses a "point" system, in which registered users gain points and move up ranks with the amount and value of data and information they submit. The more valuable and complete the information, the more points are awarded.

The website is notably completely free of advertisements, and as of September 2006 is run completely independently. Some however, question whether or not this affects the quality of the website. Since the middle of 2005, frequent visitors noticed that the site was often down.

Accepted bands

The site is known for its extremely strict rules, especially those which mandate band submissions. Encyclopaedia Metallum only accepts bands which it deems metal, but many bands that once were rejected were accepted later on, and vice versa. The only exceptions are: side projects of members of metal bands that were released by a label with worldwide distribution, bands that are no longer considered to be metal, but were in the past and grindcore bands that bear close similarities to death metal.

Additionally, there are some non-metal bands featured on the site that are considered to be part of the metal scene despite not being metal themselves (usually dark ambient and folk bands, examples being Mortiis, Elend, Autumn Tears, Stille Volk, etc). These bands are selected by the moderators in an admittedly arbitrary fashion, and their submission by normal users is discouraged.

Bands excluded by the website

Genres that are sometimes associated with extreme metal, such as grindcore and hardcore, are also absent as they are seen to have more in common with punk than metal. Glam metal is rejected if the website owners consider the band more hard rock than metal. Industrial metal is only allowed if the site's staff consider it "more metal related than industrial", for example; the website owners refuse to accept the world famous Industrial metal act Rammstein into their database.

Bands that are associated with the nu metal or mallcore labels are completely forbidden and have been since the website started. Many users believe that metalcore bands have been completely banned from the website since a bulletin was posted that simply stated, "Please stop submitting -core bands. Please." However, this is false; many metalcore bands appear on the archives and many more have been added since the bulletin was posted, but the moderators have become more strict on what metalcore bands can be added and generally work case-by-case rather than saying all, or zero, metalcore bands will be accepted. Most of the metalcore bands that are allowed are the ones heavily influenced by melodic death metal. The metalcore bands that typically get rejected are ones that sound like Hatebreed, Zao, Diecast, The Dillinger Escape Plan and Avenged Sevenfold.

Unlike power metal, gothic metal, and some of the extreme metal related bands that fall into black metal, death metal, thrash metal, speed metal and doom metal (with the exception of drone doom) genres, which have no further specific restrictions aside from "proof of existence".

Traditional metal, heavy metal and NWOBHM genres have stringent rulings; users are warned in the rules section, to consider bands submitted under these classifications as "ambiguous", in the sense that if a band is submitted with these terms as their genre, the music will be extensively reviewed by the website owners before they decide whether or not to accept the band onto the website.

Led Zeppelin

The site runners have excluded some of what are considered by some prominent sites (such as VH1,BBC,,Misplaced Pages,AOL,The Guardian,About.com and others.) as founding and definitive heavy metal acts, such as Led Zeppelin and Blue Cheer; the website's runners consider these acts as simply hard rock, despite their influence and history.

Although there are some websites concentrating on rock and metal music that just mention Led Zeppelin as "hard rock"; however, unlike Encyclopaedia Metallum, these metal sites such as BNR Metal who classifiy the band as just "hard rock" include a profile of them in their database.

Encyclopaedia Metallum's opinions are not representative of the extreme metal related community as a whole on the band, it should be noted, for example; Dave Mustaine of Megadeth and Mikael Åkerfeldt of Opeth have both stated that they consider Led Zeppelin as one of the greatest heavy metal bands of all-time.

History

The Encyclopaedia Metallum was founded in 2002 by two Canadians using the pseudonyms HellBlazer and Morrigan. They have been interviewed twice about their site. The first interview was given to the now defunct MetalGospel.com site, and the second interview was given to the Finnish magazine Miasma during May and June of 2005, and the issue was published in mid-October of the year.

Trivia

The process of being banned from contributing to the site has been nicknamed "Dursted", named after Fred Durst (lead singer of Limp Bizkit). Durst is cited as an "enemy" of metal, and thus, an enemy to members of the site.
All new members starts off with the ranking of "mallcore kid" when joining as a member of the site. Some people get upset about being labeled as a mallcore kid on the website, but it's just a ranking on the site refering to the amount of points you have (the aforementioned are 0-point accounts).
Finnish band Amorphis was the first band to be entered into the database. According to administrator Morrigan, there was no particular reason for this.
Bands, such as Def Leppard, are on the website, due to only one of the bands' albums meeting the websites specifications.
Industrial metal band Ministry was originally rejected since it was believed they were not metal enough. Recently, the band was accepted after their two recent albums.
There have been cases in which bands originally accepted have been later rejected. One example was pornogrind band, Cock and Ball Torture. Another was groove metal band, Skinlab, for the belief they were "too mallcore".
Most bands from the site are related to death, black, thrash, doom metal and variants, but the non-extreme metal genres, like gothic, power, speed, traditional metal and variants, are also included.

Notes

External links

Categories: