Derek Smart: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively ← Previous edit Next edit →Content deleted Content addedVisual WikitextInline

Revision as of 13:48, 17 October 2006

Derek K. Smart Ph.D.' is an independent software designer and Internet personality. He is the creator of the Battlecruiser 3000AD and Universal Combat video game series and the President/Lead Developer of 3000AD, Inc. a Florida corporation.

Game industry history

Pre-1996

Smart envisioned a space craft (Battlecruiser) simulation which would encompass various game types with features ranging from space and planatary air combat to ground combat and strategy elements. His game development efforts center on realizing this vision.

1996 - 1997

Smart's first game, Battlecruiser 3000AD which was marketed by then publisher Take Two Interactive as "The last thing you will ever desire." was released unfinished by Take Two Interactive in 1996, after a seven year developement. The unfinished product release contained many bugs that made it almost entirely unplayable. The initial release of the game was "a train wreck", according to a reviewer who later commented that "Smart consistently overrates his own products and his own abilities."

In early 1997, Smart sued Take Two in relation to their release of the game in its then unfinished form. The lawsuit was later settled out of court. In late 1998 in a statement released by both parties, the then Take Two president Ryan Brant lauded Smart's work and efforts and further announced that the matter had been resolved. Take Two later went public and in its SEC filings listed Smart's first game as accounting for 14.2% of its yearly earnings.

A constant stream of patches and upgrades were later released for the product over the next few months and, eventually, a final patch was released to fix some of the major bugs. Smart then later released the game for free on the Internet and hosted on the popular download sites.

1998

In 1998 Smart, who had continued to develop the game, announced a deal with Interplay. Interplay would distribute an improved version of the original game (dubbed BC3K v2.0) through its Value Product Division. After its retail run, Smart also released that product on the Internet for free.

2001

Smart continued to work on selling his product and later entered into an exclusive distribution deal with Electronics Boutique for his next game, Battlecruiser Millennium, which his company 3000AD, Inc self-published and released later that year.

Asked by the media about his thoughts on the deal, Smart stated "I'm paying for everything. I bear all the risk. I pay for the cost of goods, including the boxes and manuals.". Apparently this was a straight distribution deal in which Smart called all the shots as to the development and publishing of his new game.

From the statement released by Jerry Madaio vice president of merchandise for the PC Division of EB, in which he said "We're thrilled to be the exclusive retailer for the eagerly anticipated release of Battlecruiser Millennium, which promises to build upon Derek's successful franchise that has captivated and immersed gamers for years" one can say that the success of the Interplay retail release of the previous game, resulted in this exclusive deal with EB.

The game was reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazins . .

After its retail run, Smart also released that product on the Internet for free. He has mentioned that he intends to keep up this practice of releasing his products for free once their shell life expires.

2003 - 2004

In 2003 Smart signed a two product deal with Dreamcatcher Games for Battlecruiser Millennium Gold and Battlecruiser Generations. The latter being a brand new addition to the series, with newer technologies than its predecessors. A few months later, the publisher had discussions with Smart that resulted in a decision to change the premise to be more action-based than the Battlecruiser series had been known for. The name was changed to Universal Combat.

The game was not ready in time for the 2003 holidays and was shipped in early 2004 at half of the originally announced price. Smart took legal action against the publisher to stop shipment of the game which was still in final Beta stages as he felt that the budget price of $19.95 would be unprofitable for his company. He failed to obtain a temporary restraining order to prevent the publisher from releasing the unfinished game which was still in Beta.

The game was reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazines. Gamespot, in their 59% review score, summarized their experience with the game by saying "This wildly ambitious simulation is torpedoed by an almost incomprehensible interface, the absence of a tutorial, numerous bugs, and many fit and finish issues, including dated production values." PC Gamer, the largest gaming magazine in the world, in their 75% review of their experience with the game said "...for the latter niche of hardcore space-simmers, Derek Smart's Battlecruiser series has been going strong for eight solid years. Over that time, the idiosyncratic space-combat franchise has transformed itself from a bug-ridden lemon to a respected genre contender. Universal Combat is the latest chapter in this reecently rebranded series (with new publisher Dreamcatcher), and though the game remains an acquired taste, its better than ever."

2005 - 2006

Despite an earlier 2005 announcement by Dreamcatcher Games to publish Smart's next sequel, Smart later terminated his publishing deal with the publisher and severed all ties with Dreamcatcher Games. Smart's 2005 game, Universal Combat: A World Apart is a full sequel to the original Universal Combat with a variety of revisions and enhancements especially to the graphics engine.

The game was also reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazines.

Smart also released Universal Combat Gold in 2005. This is an updated version of the original Universal Combat with new scenarios and graphics enhancements. Both of the 2005 games can currently only be purchased via online resellers.

In late 2006 Smart released Universal Combat: Special Edition for online purchase only through retailers.

Online controversy

Derek Smart is a controversial online personality who in the past has engaged in various controversal discussions on Usenet and game forums. His notoriety for this was such that Gamespy lampooned him for it in its Daily Victim column.

In an interview about his online persona featured on the cover page of Computer Gaming World, Smart said: "Sometimes when I get online, and it's quiet, and I see something that attracts my attention, I'll post just to piss these guys off. That's why I do it. Because I'm in a good mood that day, I go in there and I start trouble." This tendency to create controversy led web site Something Awful, in their satirical "Completely Libelous review of Universal Combat" to opine: "Dr. Smart is a man so entrenched in controversy that he is unable to accomplish virtually any task without volunteering to submerge it in tomes of ridiculous lawsuits, Internet threats, and a general cesspit of idiocy."

Smart was reported to be seeking to license the Freespace IP to develop a game based on the popular space-sim previously published by the ailing Interplay. This sparked a controversy between both Smart's supporters and detractors in which the rumor was further debunked by Yahoo video game news who wrote "Following Bethesda Softworks' acquisition of the Fallout license earlier this week, word spread that cash-strapped publisher Interplay is having a franchise fire sale. So the rumors started a-flyin' when Smart posed the question, "Would you buy Freespace 3 if I made it?" However, those who took the effort to look at the next paragraph would have seen that Smart is still only "seriously considering" licensing the space sim. However, the very possibility of Smart taking over the series has generated a strong reaction, prompting him to post a typically verbose response to his critics."

Published games

Title	Released	Publisher
Battlecruiser 3000AD (U.S.)	1996	Take Two Software
Battlecruiser 3000AD (UK)	1997	GameTek
Battlecruiser 3000AD v2.0	1999	Interplay
Battlecruiser Millennium	2001	3000AD
Battlecruiser Millennium Gold	2003	Dreamcatcher Games
Universal Combat	2004	Dreamcatcher Games
Universal Combat Gold	2005	3000AD
Universal Combat: A World Apart	2005	3000AD
Universal Combat: Special Edition	2006	3000AD

References

External links

The relevance of particular information in (or previously in) this article or section is disputed. The information may have been removed or included by an editor as a result. Please see discussion on the talk page considering whether its inclusion is warranted.

Categories:

Revision as of 13:11, 17 October 2006 view sourceSupreme Cmdr (talk \| contribs)583 edits rv Every single WP:RS linked to in the article, agrees that the product was released unfinished. Please do research before making unwarranted edits and reverts.← Previous edit		Revision as of 13:48, 17 October 2006 view source Supreme Cmdr (talk \| contribs)583 editsm varous npov and minor edits. see talkNext edit →
Line 12:		Line 12:

	Smart's first game, '']'' which was marketed by then publisher ] as "The last thing you will ever desire." was released unfinished by ] in 1996, after a seven year developement. The unfinished product release<ref></ref> contained many bugs that made it almost entirely unplayable. <ref></ref> <ref></ref> <ref></ref>		Smart's first game, '']'' which was marketed by then publisher ] as "The last thing you will ever desire." was released unfinished by ] in 1996, after a seven year developement. The unfinished product release<ref></ref> contained many bugs that made it almost entirely unplayable. <ref></ref> <ref></ref> <ref></ref>
	<ref> </ref> The initial release of the game was "a train wreck", according to ~~analysts~~ who later commented that "Smart consistently overrates his own products and his own abilities."<ref name="Gamespy"></ref>		<ref> </ref> The initial release of the game was "a train wreck", according to a reviewer who later commented that "Smart consistently overrates his own products and his own abilities."<ref name="Gamespy"></ref>

	In early 1997, Smart sued Take Two in relation to their release of the game in its then unfinished form. The lawsuit was later settled out of court.<ref></ref> In late 1998 in a released by both parties, the then Take Two president Ryan Brant lauded Smart's work and efforts and further announced that the matter had been resolved. Take Two later went public and in its listed Smart's first game as accounting for 14.2% of its yearly earnings.		In early 1997, Smart sued Take Two in relation to their release of the game in its then unfinished form. The lawsuit was later settled out of court.<ref></ref> In late 1998 in a released by both parties, the then Take Two president Ryan Brant lauded Smart's work and efforts and further announced that the matter had been resolved. Take Two later went public and in its listed Smart's first game as accounting for 14.2% of its yearly earnings.
Line 33:		Line 33:
	Asked by the media about his thoughts on the deal, Smart stated "I'm paying for everything. I bear all the risk. I pay for the cost of goods, including the boxes and manuals."<ref name="gamespin2"></ref>. Apparently this was a straight distribution deal in which Smart called all the shots as to the development and publishing of his new game.{{fact}}		Asked by the media about his thoughts on the deal, Smart stated "I'm paying for everything. I bear all the risk. I pay for the cost of goods, including the boxes and manuals."<ref name="gamespin2"></ref>. Apparently this was a straight distribution deal in which Smart called all the shots as to the development and publishing of his new game.{{fact}}

	From the statement released by Jerry Madaio vice president of merchandise for the PC Division of EB, in which he said "We're thrilled to be the exclusive retailer for the eagerly anticipated release of Battlecruiser Millennium, which promises to build upon Derek's successful franchise that has captivated and immersed gamers for years" one can say that the success of the ] retail release of the previous game, resulted in this exclusive deal with EB.		From the statement released by Jerry Madaio vice president of merchandise for the PC Division of EB, in which he said "We're thrilled to be the exclusive retailer for the eagerly anticipated release of Battlecruiser Millennium, which promises to build upon Derek's successful franchise that has captivated and immersed gamers for years" one can say that the success of the ] retail release of the previous game, resulted in this exclusive deal with EB.{{fact}}

	The game ~~received~~ a ~~better~~ ~~score ratings~~ in several ~~game~~ ~~magazine~~ ~~reviews.~~ <ref></ref>. <ref></ref>.		The game was reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazins <ref></ref>. <ref></ref>.

	After its retail run, Smart also . He has mentioned that he intends to keep up this practice of releasing his products for free once their shell life expires.		After its retail run, Smart also . He has mentioned that he intends to keep up this practice of releasing his products for free once their shell life expires.
Line 45:		Line 45:
	The game was not ready in time for the ] holidays and was shipped in early ] at half of the originally announced price. Smart took legal action against the publisher to stop shipment of the game which was still in as he felt that the budget price of $19.95 would be unprofitable for his company.{{citeneeded}} He failed to obtain a temporary restraining order to prevent the publisher from releasing the unfinished game which was still in Beta.		The game was not ready in time for the ] holidays and was shipped in early ] at half of the originally announced price. Smart took legal action against the publisher to stop shipment of the game which was still in as he felt that the budget price of $19.95 would be unprofitable for his company.{{citeneeded}} He failed to obtain a temporary restraining order to prevent the publisher from releasing the unfinished game which was still in Beta.

	The game ~~received~~ ~~mediocre~~ to ~~average reviews~~ in several ~~game~~ ~~magazine~~ ~~reviews~~. <ref></ref> Gamespot, in their 59% review score, summarized their experience with the game by saying "This wildly ambitious simulation is torpedoed by an almost incomprehensible interface, the absence of a tutorial, numerous bugs, and many fit and finish issues, including dated production values."<ref name="Gamespot-uc-review"></ref> PC Gamer, the largest gaming magazine in the world{{citeneeded}}, in their 75% review of their experience with the game said "...for the latter niche of hardcore space-simmers, Derek Smart's Battlecruiser series has been going strong for eight solid years. Over that time, the idiosyncratic space-combat franchise has transformed itself from a bug-ridden lemon to a respected genre contender. Universal Combat is the latest chapter in this reecently rebranded series (with new publisher Dreamcatcher), and though the game remains an acquired taste, its better than ever."<ref name="PC-Gamer-uc-review"></ref>		The game was reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazines. <ref></ref> Gamespot, in their 59% review score, summarized their experience with the game by saying ''"This wildly ambitious simulation is torpedoed by an almost incomprehensible interface, the absence of a tutorial, numerous bugs, and many fit and finish issues, including dated production values."''<ref name="Gamespot-uc-review"></ref> PC Gamer, the largest gaming magazine in the world{{citeneeded}}, in their 75% review of their experience with the game said ''"...for the latter niche of hardcore space-simmers, Derek Smart's Battlecruiser series has been going strong for eight solid years. Over that time, the idiosyncratic space-combat franchise has transformed itself from a bug-ridden lemon to a respected genre contender. Universal Combat is the latest chapter in this reecently rebranded series (with new publisher Dreamcatcher), and though the game remains an acquired taste, its better than ever.''"<ref name="PC-Gamer-uc-review"></ref>

	====2005 - 2006====		====2005 - 2006====

	Despite an earlier ] by ] to publish Smart's next sequel, Smart later his publishing deal with the publisher and severed all ties with ].		Despite an earlier ] by ] to publish Smart's next sequel, Smart later his publishing deal with the publisher and severed all ties with ].
	Smart's ] game, '']'' is a full sequel to the original '']'' with a especially to the graphics engine. ~~Despite~~ ~~the~~ ~~enhancements,~~ it ~~received~~ ~~average~~ to ~~mediocre~~ ~~reviews~~. <ref></ref> <ref></ref>		Smart's ] game, '']'' is a full sequel to the original '']'' with a especially to the graphics engine.

			The game was also reviewed and rated in several print and online game magazines. <ref></ref> <ref></ref>

	Smart also released '']'' in 2005. This is an updated version of the original ''Universal Combat'' with new scenarios and graphics enhancements. Both of the 2005 games can currently only be purchased via online resellers.<ref></ref>		Smart also released '']'' in 2005. This is an updated version of the original ''Universal Combat'' with new scenarios and graphics enhancements. Both of the 2005 games can currently only be purchased via online resellers.<ref></ref>