| Revision as of 21:39, 14 November 2006 editDaddy Kindsoul (talk | contribs)19,776 edits →not exactly npov← Previous edit | Revision as of 22:03, 14 November 2006 edit undoBlipblip (talk | contribs)137 editsNo edit summaryNext edit → | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
| :"None" is not a viable genre. The discography on the version you keep pushing is a mess, the language is awfully ] reading more like a ] and it mentions little to nothing of their history. If you feel something is inacurate, then correct it cite a source. - ] 21:25, 14 November 2006 (UTC) | :"None" is not a viable genre. The discography on the version you keep pushing is a mess, the language is awfully ] reading more like a ] and it mentions little to nothing of their history. If you feel something is inacurate, then correct it cite a source. - ] 21:25, 14 November 2006 (UTC) | ||
| Deathrocker, just a few quick notes; LAM was a very political project from the beginning. Your posting of "fan frustration" is speculative and misleading. LAM is a solo project (Brennan). It was formed by Brennan. LAM was not formed with Tamlyn as you stated. The fact that you are unaware of this is evidence that you shouldn't be contributing to this page. Live members come and go and are not involved in the creative process. Hardly relevent except for noting live concerts, but you can list the various live members if you feel the need - but why focus on one bass player (Arklette) who was kicked out of the live band? Do you know anything about Covet and Arklette? If you did I think you'd likely not be pushing him. You read the Covet page and took that as fact, but it's not fact. No "Covet" songs were ever meant for LAM. Arklette was removed from the live lineup of LAM for some serious reasons, so why you feel the need to push him here is kind of strange, with a whole paragraph on his defunct side project (which by the way he took thousands of dollars to produce and never released "frustrating" people who he'd promised the CD to). Its clear you have very superficial knowledge of LAM with the various edits and misinformation you keep posting, so I suggest a little research or just bowing out to work on other pages. The discography was originally posted by someone else. I just cleaned it up and corrected it, you should have seen it before. It could be deleted but you wanted history and that is a history of releases that contain LAM music. | |||
Revision as of 22:03, 14 November 2006
 | Rock music Unassessed | |||||||||
| ||||||||||
possible copyvio
A lot of the text seems to be taken directly from the band's history page on their website. I think that the page can be edited so as to be okay, but I checked out the instructions at Misplaced Pages:Copyright problems which say that you should blank the page and put up a copyvio notice...? Not sure what to do here - I'm going to wait a day or so and see if anyone has any ideas. Cantara 19:53, 30 March 2006 (UTC)
What's your concern? The guy who does the web work for LAM wrote that article which was used with permission. The text was ok'd by the band to be presented here on Misplaced Pages.
Okay then. I wasn't aware of that. Perhaps mention of this should be made somewhere on the page, e.g. some text courtesy of LAM, can also be found . Also, would you mind signing your messages? It's a little annoying to have to look at the history to see who left me a note. Thanks! Cantara 20:32, 5 April 2006 (UTC)
not exactly npov
what are adjectives like "funny" and "touching" doing in what's supposed to be an encyclopedic article? this reads like a fan's praise rather than a fact-based, informative article. -supine 07:17, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
- I edited out the biased stuff. - 67.40.171.141 (talk · contribs)
It really reads like a Press Realease. - 200.122.45.7 (talk · contribs)
- That is because it was taken from a press release, I've improved the article now, however. - Deathrocker 21:35, 14 November 2006 (UTC)
- Deathrocker- I suggest that you actually inform yourself about LAM before continually editing the page. The info you provide isn't accurate. Please leave the page alone. - 24.205.68.235 (talk · contribs)
- I suggest you view other band articles on here to see how they are set out, this is not an overblow fan article or a promo slot. It is meant to be an encyclopediac article on a musical band.
- "None" is not a viable genre. The discography on the version you keep pushing is a mess, the language is awfully POV reading more like a hagiography and it mentions little to nothing of their history. If you feel something is inacurate, then correct it cite a source. - Deathrocker 21:25, 14 November 2006 (UTC)
Deathrocker, just a few quick notes; LAM was a very political project from the beginning. Your posting of "fan frustration" is speculative and misleading. LAM is a solo project (Brennan). It was formed by Brennan. LAM was not formed with Tamlyn as you stated. The fact that you are unaware of this is evidence that you shouldn't be contributing to this page. Live members come and go and are not involved in the creative process. Hardly relevent except for noting live concerts, but you can list the various live members if you feel the need - but why focus on one bass player (Arklette) who was kicked out of the live band? Do you know anything about Covet and Arklette? If you did I think you'd likely not be pushing him. You read the Covet page and took that as fact, but it's not fact. No "Covet" songs were ever meant for LAM. Arklette was removed from the live lineup of LAM for some serious reasons, so why you feel the need to push him here is kind of strange, with a whole paragraph on his defunct side project (which by the way he took thousands of dollars to produce and never released "frustrating" people who he'd promised the CD to). Its clear you have very superficial knowledge of LAM with the various edits and misinformation you keep posting, so I suggest a little research or just bowing out to work on other pages. The discography was originally posted by someone else. I just cleaned it up and corrected it, you should have seen it before. It could be deleted but you wanted history and that is a history of releases that contain LAM music.
Categories: