| Revision as of 04:44, 3 December 2006 editThe Filmaker (talk | contribs)Pending changes reviewers7,873 editsNo edit summary← Previous edit | Revision as of 17:24, 27 March 2008 edit undo195.8.161.226 (talk)No edit summaryNext edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| I would like the following text to be included in the article, in the 'Cinematic and literary allusions' section... | |||
| "One of the most controversial sources in Star Wars is the infamous Nazi propaganda movie '', by , which glamorizes Hitler's triumphant arrival at the 1934 . It is the primary source for the final scene in which Hans, Luke and Chewbacca walk through a hall of assembled rebel soldiers to receive their medals. There is a striking similarity to Hitler’s arrival at the Nuremberg podium. There is no reason to suppose Lucas was attempting to promote Nazi ideology, it would seem he merely replicated a very powerful image from what is widely regarded as a brilliant, if very misguided, film." | |||
| This is not a hysterical claim, it is verifiable and deserves to be included. Triumph of The Will, while it was a Nazi Propaganda film, was a massively influential and brilliant piece of cinematography and there is no doubt that Lucas took the imagery of the Nurenberg film and copied it almost completely. There is a Wiki page on 'Triumph of The Will', take a look and you will see the similarity confirmed there. | |||
| Please respond because i wish this to be included and it already has been removed once. | |||
| Maintain for featured status. | Maintain for featured status. | ||
Revision as of 17:24, 27 March 2008
I would like the following text to be included in the article, in the 'Cinematic and literary allusions' section...
"One of the most controversial sources in Star Wars is the infamous Nazi propaganda movie '', by , which glamorizes Hitler's triumphant arrival at the 1934 . It is the primary source for the final scene in which Hans, Luke and Chewbacca walk through a hall of assembled rebel soldiers to receive their medals. There is a striking similarity to Hitler’s arrival at the Nuremberg podium. There is no reason to suppose Lucas was attempting to promote Nazi ideology, it would seem he merely replicated a very powerful image from what is widely regarded as a brilliant, if very misguided, film."
This is not a hysterical claim, it is verifiable and deserves to be included. Triumph of The Will, while it was a Nazi Propaganda film, was a massively influential and brilliant piece of cinematography and there is no doubt that Lucas took the imagery of the Nurenberg film and copied it almost completely. There is a Wiki page on 'Triumph of The Will', take a look and you will see the similarity confirmed there.
Please respond because i wish this to be included and it already has been removed once.
Maintain for featured status.