Misplaced Pages

Perfect 10 (gymnastics): Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 07:36, 20 March 2021 editQuakerIlK (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users1,016 editsm →"Meta-Perfect" Scores of 20, 30, and 40← Previous edit Revision as of 07:46, 20 March 2021 edit undoQuakerIlK (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users1,016 editsm →"Meta-Perfect" Scores of 20, 30, and 40Next edit →
Line 566: Line 566:
== "Meta-Perfect" Scores of 20, 30, and 40 == == "Meta-Perfect" Scores of 20, 30, and 40 ==


Although virtually hundreds of perfect scores of 10 were given at various levels of competition throughout the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s, "meta-perfect" scores of 20, 30, or 40 were much, much more rare. A "meta-perfect" score would be an instance where a gymnast received multiple perfect scores of 10 throughout a competition on an apparatus, or in a segment of a competition. Although virtually hundreds of perfect scores of 10 were given at various levels of competition throughout the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s, "meta-perfect" scores of 20, 30, or 40 were much, much more rare. A "meta-perfect" score would be an instance where a gymnast received multiple perfect scores of 10 throughout a competition on an apparatus (culminating in a "meta-perfect" score of 20 in the Event Finals), or on every apparatus in a segment of a competition. To date, ] seems to have been the only gymnast to do the latter at a major international competition. ] has achieved this more prolifically than any other gymnast at the highest levels of international competition. Only 3 men (men were awarded scores of 10 significantly more rarely than women) have managed to do this at the Olympic/World/European level: ], ], and ].


=== Olympics === === Olympics ===

Revision as of 07:46, 20 March 2021

For other uses, see Perfect 10 (disambiguation).
Nadia Comăneci poses beside the scoreboard that recorded her perfect 10 as 1.00 (with no Olympic precedent, the hardware was not capable of displaying 10.00).

A perfect 10 is a score of 10.000 for a single routine in artistic gymnastics, which was once thought to be unattainable—particularly at the Olympic Games—under the code of points set by the International Gymnastics Federation (FIG). It is generally recognized that the first person to score a perfect 10 at the Olympic Games was Romanian Nadia Comăneci, at the 1976 Games in Montreal. Other women who accomplished this feat at the Olympics include Nellie Kim, also in 1976, Mary Lou Retton in 1984, Daniela Silivaș and Yelena Shushunova in 1988, and Lavinia Miloșovici in 1992. The first man to score a perfect 10 is considered to be Alexander Dityatin, at the 1980 Olympics in Moscow. (However, in the 1924 Paris Olympics, 22 men achieved a mark of 10 in rope-climbing, with one Albert Séguin getting a second 10 in the sidehorse vault, events that are no longer part of artistic gymnastics.)

The FIG changed its code of points in 2006. There are now different top scores, all greater than 10, for the various events, based upon difficulty and artistic merit; there is no consistent perfect score. Execution scores are still out of 10, so the theoretical possibility exists for a gymnast to get a "perfect 10" for execution in addition to whatever number they get for difficulty, but no such score has been awarded in decades.

History

Men's Artistic Gymnastics had been an Olympic sport since the beginning of the modern games. Women's gymnastics were introduced as a single (team) event in the 1928 games, but were not expanded until the 1952 games, when there were seven events. The International Federation of Gymnastics first drew up a code of points—for men—in 1949.

Although the code of points was based on a maximum of 10, until 1976 it was considered impossible to achieve a score of greater than 9.95, particularly at the Olympic Games.

At the World Championships or Olympics beginning when increased standardization of competition format and scoring (which was capped at a 10, a trend which would not be changed until 2006) was introduced at the 1952 Olympics, the very highest scores tended to be in the 9.400 - 9.600 range, and over the next few World and Olympic cycles through the 1950, 1960s, and 1970s, the top scores gradually got higher through the 9.700 and 9.800 range.

During the post-1952 era, a couple of very early scores, essentially extreme outliers, that came very close to the 10.000 mark were Armenian-Soviet Hrant Shahinyan's score of 9.950 on optional rings at the 1952 Olympics and Armenian-Soviet Albert Azaryan's score of 9.950, also on the optional still rings exercise, at the 1954 World Championships. On the men's side, these scores might not have been surpassed, or even equaled, at a World Championships or Olympics until 1980, as even scores of 9.900 were extremely rare and, in some Worlds and Olympics throughout the 1950s -1970s, scores of 9.900 seem to have been non-existent for the men. Perhaps the first woman gymnast to break the 9.900 score barrier at a World Championships or Olympics was Soviet Zinaida Druzhinina-Voronina who scored a 9.933 at the 1966 World Championships in the Floor Exercise Event Finals, the very highest mark of any competitor at that competition.

An often glossed-over fact when discussing the Perfect 10 is that Věra Čáslavská of Czechoslovakia was the first gymnast to achieve perfect 10s at a major competition in the post-1952 era, which she did twice at the 1967 European Championships, which were displayed on a manual scoreboard. Prior to the 1976 Olympics in Montreal, Omega, the official timers, asked the International Olympic Committee how many digits it should allow on the electronic scoreboard, and were told that three digits would be sufficient, as a score of 10.00 would not be possible.

On 18 July 1976, 14-year-old Romanian gymnast Nadia Comăneci performed in the uneven bars event, and was awarded a score of 10. Because the scoreboard only allowed three digits, it had to display her score as 1.00. This led to confusion, with even Comăneci unsure of what it meant, until the announcer informed the elated crowd that she had scored a perfect 10. An iconic press photograph (pictured above) shows a beaming Comăneci, arms upraised, beside the scoreboard. Comăneci scored a total of seven 10s at the 1976 Olympics—four on the uneven bars and three on the balance beam. Her main rival, Russian Nelli Kim, scored two 10s in the same competition, in the vault and floor exercise. Comăneci's coach, Béla Károlyi, having defected to the United States in 1981, subsequently coached Mary Lou Retton to gold at the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles, where she scored 10s in the vault and floor exercise.

The first man to score a perfect 10 in Olympic competition was the Russian Alexander Dityatin, who received the score in the vault on the way to a record-breaking eight medals in the 1980 Olympics in Moscow. Among other men to achieve the score was Comăneci's future husband, Bart Conner, who received two 10s in Los Angeles in 1984.

Change in scoring

The code of points came under review as a result of separate incidents during the 2004 Summer Olympics in Athens, in which gymnasts were believed to have received excessively low scores. A new scoring system was introduced in 2006. It consists of an "A" score, based on the difficulty of elements, and a "B" score, based on artistic impression. While the B score still has a maximum of 10, it is only a part of the overall score.

The change had its share of critics. Béla Károlyi said of it: "It's crazy, terrible, the stupidest thing that ever happened to the sport of gymnastics.". Mary Lou Retton remarked: "It's hard to understand. I don't even understand it." Nadia Comăneci commented, "It's so hard to define sports like ours and we had something unique. The 10, it was ours first and now you give it away."

List of perfect 10s

This list may be incomplete.

Olympics

Paris 1924

Montreal 1976

Women
  • Nadia Comăneci - team compulsory uneven bars, team optional uneven bars, team optional balance beam, all around uneven bars, all around balance beam, uneven bars event final, balance beam event final
  • Nellie Kim - all around vault, floor exercise event final

(Olympic database; Women's individual results; women's all-around results; women's team results)

Moscow 1980

Men

(Men's all-around results; men's individual event results)

Women

Los Angeles 1984

Men
  • Peter Vidmar - team compulsory pommel horse, all around high bar, pommel horse event final
  • Bart Conner - team optional parallel bars, parallel bars event final
  • Mitch Gaylord - team compulsory parallel bars, team optional rings
  • Tim Daggett - team optional high bar
  • Li Ning - team compulsory pommel horse, team optional rings, floor exercise event final, pommel horse event final
  • Tong Fei - team compulsory high bar, team optional rings, all around high bar, high bar event final
  • Xu Zhiqiang - team compulsory high bar
  • Lou Yun - team compulsory vault, team optional vault
  • Li Xiaoping - team compulsory pommel horse
  • Koji Gushiken - team compulsory high bar, all around vault, high bar event final
  • Shinji Morisue - team compulsory high bar, team optional high bar, high bar event final
  • Nobuyuki Kajitani - parallel bars event final
Women
  • Ecaterina Szabo - team compulsory floor exercise, team optional vault, all around balance beam, floor exercise event final
  • Simona Păucă - team optional balance beam
  • Mary Lou Retton - team optional vault, all around vault, all around floor exercise
  • Julianne McNamara - team optional uneven bars, team optional floor exercise, all around uneven bars, uneven bars event final, floor exercise event final
  • Ma Yanhong - team optional uneven bars, all around uneven bars, uneven bars event final

(Men's results; women's results)

Seoul 1988

Men
Women
  • Yelena Shushunova - team compulsory vault, team optional vault, team optional uneven bars, team optional floor exercise, all around vault, all around floor exercise, uneven bars event final
  • Daniela Silivaș - team compulsory uneven bars, team compulsory floor exercise, team optionals uneven bars, team optionals balance beam, all around uneven bars, all around floor exercise, uneven bars event final
  • Dagmar Kersten - team compulsory uneven bars, uneven bars event final

(Men's results; women's results)

Barcelona 1992

Women

(Women's results)

Alternate Olympics

Olomouc 1984

Men
  • Dmitry Bilozerchev - team optional pommel horse, team optional rings, team optional parallel bars, team optional high bar, all around pommel horse, all around vault, all around parallel bars, all around high bar, pommel horse event final, rings event final, high bar event final
  • Vladimir Artemov - team optional pommel horse, team optional rings, team optional vault, all around rings
  • Yuri Balbanov - team compulsory rings, team optional high bar, all around parallel bars
  • Holger Behrendt - team optional rings
  • Sylvio Kroll - team compulsory vault, team optional vault, vault event final
  • Roland Brückner - team optional floor exercise
Women
  • Olga Mostepanova - team compulsory vault, team compulsory uneven bars, team compulsory balance beam, team optional vault, team optional balance beam, team optional floor exercise, all around vault, all around uneven bars, all around balance beam, all around floor exercise, balance beam event final, floor exercise event final
  • Natalia Yurchenko - team compulsory uneven bars, team optional vault, all around vault, all around balance beam, uneven bars event final
  • Yelena Shushunova - team optional vault
  • Maxi Gnauck - team compulsory uneven bars, team optional vault, team optional uneven bars, all around floor exercise, uneven bars event final, floor exercise event final
  • Gabriele Fähnrich - team compulsory uneven bars, uneven bars event final
  • Hana Říčná - team optional balance beam, all around vault, all around uneven bars
  • Martina Koblizkova - team optional vault
  • Alena Dřevjaná - all around balance beam
  • Franka Voigt - all around vault
  • Boriana Stoyanova - all around uneven bars
  • Miroslava Koblizkova - all around uneven bars

Goodwill Games

1986 Goodwill Games

Women

1990 Goodwill Games

Women

World Championships

1934 World Championships

1950 World Championships

1981 World Championships

Men
Women

1983 World Championships

Men
  • Tong Fei - team compulsory parallel bars, floor exercise event final
  • Li Ning - team optional rings, pommel horse event final
  • Lou Yun - team optional parallel bars, parallel bars event final
  • Dmitry Bilozerchev - team compulsory pommel horse, team optional pommel horse, all around floor exercise, all around vault, all around high bar, pommel horse event final, rings event final, high bar event final
  • Vladimir Artemov - team optional parallel bars, parallel bars event final
  • Shinji Morisue - team optional high bar
  • György Guczoghy - all around pommel horse, pommel horse event final
  • Alexander Pogorelov - all around rings
  • Li Xiaoping - pommel horse event final
  • Koji Gushiken - rings event final
  • Koji Sotomura - rings event final
Women
  • Natalia Yurchenko - team optional vault, team optional balance beam, all around vault, all around floor exercise
  • Olga Mostepanova - team optional vault, all around vault, floor exercise event final
  • Olga Bicherova - team optional vault
  • Lavinia Agache - team optional uneven bars
  • Ecaterina Szabo - team optional uneven bars, team optional floor exercise, all around vault, all around floor exercise, floor exercise event final
  • Mirela Barbălată - team optional vault
  • Maxi Gnauck - team optional uneven bars, all around uneven bars, uneven bars event final

1985 World Championships

Men
Women

1987 World Championships

Men
Women
  • Aurelia Dobre - team optional vault, team optional balance beam, team optional floor exercise, all around vault, balance beam event final
  • Daniela Silivaș - team compulsory balance beam, team compulsory floor exercise, team optional uneven bars, team optional floor exercise, floor exercise event final
  • Camelia Voinea - team optional floor exercise
  • Eugenia Golea - team optional vault
  • Yelena Shushunova - team compulsory vault, team compulsory floor exercise, team optional floor exercise, all around floor exercise, floor exercise event final
  • Dörte Thümmler - team optional uneven bars
  • Gabriele Fähnrich - team optional uneven bars
  • Fan Di - team optional uneven bars

1989 World Championships

Men
  • Valentin Mogilny - team optional pommel horse, all around pommel horse, pommel horse event final
Women
  • Natalia Laschenova - team optional vault, all around vault, all around uneven bars
  • Svetlana Boginskaya - team optional uneven bars, team optional floor exercise, all around vault, all around floor exercise, floor exercise event final
  • Olesya Dudnik - team compulsory floor exercise, team optional vault, team optional balance beam
  • Daniela Silivaș - team compulsory vault, team optional uneven bars, team optional floor exercise, uneven bars event final, floor exercise event final
  • Cristina Bontaș - all around floor exercise
  • Fan Di - uneven bars event final

1991 World Championships

Women

European Championships

1967 European Championships

Women

1977 European Championships

Women

1981 European Championships

Women

1985 European Championships

Women

1987 European Championships

Women

1989 European Championships

Women

1990 European Championships

Women

U.S. National Championships

1984 National Championships

Men
Women

1988 National Championships

Men

1990 National Championships

Men

1992 National Championships

Women

U.S. Olympic Trials

1984 Olympic Trials

Men

1988 Olympic Trials

Women

1992 Olympic Trials

Women

Moscow News/World Stars

1979 Moscow News

Women

1988 Moscow News

Women

1989 Moscow News

Women

1991 World Stars

Men

1992 World Stars

Women

American Cup

New York City 1976

Women

New York City 1980

Men

New York City 1984

Men
Women

Orlando 1991

Women

Orlando 1992

Men

European Cup

1988 European Cup

Women

DTB Cup

1984 DTB Cup

Women
  • Maxi Gnauck - all around uneven bars, all around floor exercise, uneven bars event final, floor exercise event final

1987 DTB Cup

Men

1988 DTB Cup

Men
Women

1989 DTB Cup

Women

Cottbus International

1984 Cottbus International

Women

1985 Cottbus International

Women

1992 Cottbus International

Women

World Cup

1979 World Cup

Women

1982 World Cup

Men

1986 World Cup

Women

Tokyo Cup

1985 Tokyo Cup

Women

1988 Tokyo Cup

Women

Chunichi Cup

1976 Chunichi Cup

Women

1988 Chunichi Cup

Women

University Games

1987 University Games

Women
  • Yelena Shushunova - all around uneven bars, all around balance beam, all around floor exercise

"Meta-Perfect" Scores of 20, 30, and 40

Although virtually hundreds of perfect scores of 10 were given at various levels of competition throughout the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s, "meta-perfect" scores of 20, 30, or 40 were much, much more rare. A "meta-perfect" score would be an instance where a gymnast received multiple perfect scores of 10 throughout a competition on an apparatus (culminating in a "meta-perfect" score of 20 in the Event Finals), or on every apparatus in a segment of a competition. To date, Olga Mostepanova seems to have been the only gymnast to do the latter at a major international competition. Daniela Silivaș has achieved this more prolifically than any other gymnast at the highest levels of international competition. Only 3 men (men were awarded scores of 10 significantly more rarely than women) have managed to do this at the Olympic/World/European level: Dmitry Bilozerchev, Valentin Mogilny, and Shinji Morisue.

Olympics

1976 Olympics

  • Nadia Comaneci - 40/40 on Uneven Bars (every segment of the competition)

1984 Olympics

  • Shinji Morisue - 30/30 on Horizontal Bar (Team Compulsories, Team Optionals, Event Finals; he did not compete in the all-around, so no opportunity to achieve 40/40, but he did get a 10 every time he competed on the apparatus)

1988 Olympics

Alternate Olympics

Olomouc 1984

  • Maxi Gnauck - 30/40 on Uneven Bars (in Team Compulsories, Team Optionals, and Event Finals; not a 10 in the All-Around, but a 10 in both segments of the team competition that carried over to Event Finals where Gnauck also got another 10 to create a "meta-perfect" score)
  • Olga Mostepanova - 40/40 in the All-Around (all 4 apparatuses), 40/40 on Balance Beam (in every segment of the competition)

World Championships

1934 Worlds

  • Eugen Mack - 20/20 on Vault (exact details unknown but all of the highest scores in the competition were in the 18s and 19s, and his was the only 20)

1983 Worlds

  • Dmitry Bilozerchev - 30/40 on Pommel Horse (not in the All-Around, but in both Team Compulsories and Team Optionals which carried over to Event Finals where he also got a 10, creating a "meta-perfect" score)

1987 Worlds

  • Yelena Shushunova - 40/40 on Floor Exercise (in every segment of the competition)
  • Daniela Silivaș - 30/40 on Floor Exercise (not in the All-Around, but in both Team Compulsories and Team Optionals which carried over to Event Finals where she got also got a 10, creating a "meta-perfect" score)

1989 Worlds

  • Valentin Mogilny - 30/40 on Pommel Horse (not in Team Compulsories, but all 3 times he competed his optional exercise on Pommel Horse throughout the competition, he got a Perfect 10)

European Championships

1987 Europeans

  • Daniela Silivaș - 20/20 on Floor Exercise (in both the All-Around and Event Finals)

1989 Europeans

See also

References

  1. "The first Olympic gymnast to score a perfect 10". BBC News. 20 July 2016.
  2. Jamie Clarke (19 August 2015). "1976: First Gymnast to Score a Perfect 10 at an Olympics Games". Guinness World Records.
  3. William D. Murray (9 January 1986). "Soviet gymnast Aleksandr Dityatin, the winner of a record..." United Press International.
  4. "Moscow 1980 - Key Moments: The first male "perfect 10"". ESPN.
  5. "History of Artistic Gymnastics at the Olympic Games" (PDF). Olympic.org. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  6. "Milestones". International Federation of Gymnastics. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  7. Brown, Gene (1979). The New York Times encyclopedia of sports, Volume 11: Indoor Sports. Arno Press. p. 132. ISBN 0405126379. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  8. Fulton-Smith, Graham; Sampson, James M.; Wange, Willy B. (1976). Olympics 1976: Montreal, Innsbruck. New York: C. N. Potter. p. 25. ISBN 051752743X. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  9. 1966 Gymnastics World Championships, women's EF (Video). MizMamie. Event occurs at 16:00. Retrieved January 15, 2021. There's the mark. 9.933. And that is the highest mark of any competitor, man or woman, at these World Championships.
  10. Tatlow, Peter (1979). Gymnastics: all the beauty and skills of this thrilling sport. Chartwell Books, Inc. p. 143. ISBN 9780711100046.
  11. European Ladies Gymnastics In Amsterdam (1967). British Pathé. 13 Apr 2014. Event occurs at 1 min 32 sec. Retrieved 3 September 2016.
  12. ^ "50 stunning Olympic moments No5: Nadia Comaneci scores a perfect 10". 14 December 2011. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  13. Brady, Rachel (6 July 2012). "Nadia Comaneci: From a perfect 10 in Montreal to a busy broadcaster in London". Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  14. Marsden, Rhodri (17 July 2015). "Rhodri Marsden's Interesting Objects: The gymnastics scoreboard at the Montreal Olympics". Independent. Retrieved 6 November 2015.
  15. Buchanan, Ian; Mallon, Bill (2005). Historical Dictionary of the Olympic Movement. Scarecrow Press. p. 149. ISBN 0810865246. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  16. Boyer Sagert, Kelly; Overman, Steven J. (2012). Icons of Women's Sport. ABC-CLIO. pp. 443, 448–9. ISBN 0313385491. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  17. Nauright, John (2012). Sports around the World: History, Culture, and Practice. ABC-CLIO. p. 334. ISBN 159884301X. Retrieved 4 November 2015.
  18. ^ Diane Pucin (August 6, 2008). "A 10-shun Deficit". Los Angeles Times.
  19. Dan Baynes (August 6, 2008). "Olympic Gymnasts Won't Chase Perfect 10 as New Scoring Debuts". bloomberg.com. Retrieved February 14, 2010.
  20. ^ Jordan Ellenberg (August 12, 2008). "Down With the Perfect 10!". Slate. Archived from the original on February 12, 2010. Retrieved February 14, 2010.
  21. "Gymnastics results for the 1976 Summer Olympics". www.databaseolympics.com. Archived from the original on December 25, 2010. Retrieved May 6, 2011.
  22. "Games of the 21st Olympiad 1976 Artistic Gymnastics / All-Around Final Women". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on July 15, 2009. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  23. "Games of the 21st Olympiad 1976 Artistic Gymnastics / All-Around Final Women". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on February 19, 2010. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  24. "Games of the 21st Olympiad 1976 Artistic Gymnastics / Teams Women". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on July 21, 2013. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  25. "All-Around Final Men - Games of the 22nd Olympiad Moscow 1980". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on July 21, 2013. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  26. "Games of the 22nd Olympiad 1980 Artistic Gymnastics / Events Finals Men". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on April 15, 2010. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  27. "The Games of 23rd Olympiad / Men's Artistic Gymnastics". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on April 15, 2010. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  28. "The Games of 23rd Olympiad / Women's Artistic Gymnastics". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on February 5, 2016. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  29. "The Games of 24th Olympiad / Men". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on November 6, 2013. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  30. "The Games of 24th Olympiad / Women". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on July 12, 2016. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
  31. "The Games of 25th Olympiad / Women". gymnasticsresults.com. Archived from the original on September 22, 2008. Retrieved February 16, 2010.
Nadia Comăneci
Gymnastics
Honors and awards
Related people
Categories: