| Revision as of 13:44, 3 July 2023 editWikiEditor1234567123 (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users9,838 editsNo edit summaryTags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit← Previous edit | Revision as of 15:37, 3 July 2023 edit undoWikiEditor1234567123 (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users9,838 edits →LocalizationTags: harv-error Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile editNext edit → | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
| === Localization === | === Localization === | ||
| For the first time in 1963, {{ill|V. B. Vinogradov|ru|}} expressed the point of view about the ethnicity of the ''Chamaecoeta'' in his work "Sarmatians of the North-Eastern Caucasus" (''Сарматы Северо-восточного Кавказа''), he associated the ethnonym with the ] tribes.{{sfn|Волкова|1973|p=124}}{{efn|In his work as well as in the works of ] and ] scholars '''''Chamaecoetae''''' are transliterated in ] as '''''Khamekits''''' (''Хамекеты'' |
For the first time in 1963, {{ill|V. B. Vinogradov|ru|}} expressed the point of view about the ethnicity of the ''Chamaecoeta'' in his work "Sarmatians of the North-Eastern Caucasus" (''Сарматы Северо-восточного Кавказа''), he associated the ethnonym with the ] tribes.{{sfn|Волкова|1973|p=124}}{{efn|In his work as well as in the works of ] and ] scholars '''''Chamaecoetae''''' are commonly transliterated in ] as '''''Khamekets''''' and '''''Khamekits''''' (''Хамекеты'' and ''Хамекиты''). Although in the translated work of the book '']'' of {{ill|Fëdor Mishenko|ru|Мищенко, Фёдор Герасимович}}, Chamaecoetae are instead transliterated in Russian as '''''Khamaykoytes''''' (''Хамайкойты'').{{sfn|Мищенко|1879|pp=, }}}} Further on, he and {{ill|Z. K. Chokaev|ru|Чокаев, Каты Зайндинович}} again spoke about the connection of this ethnonym with the ] and localizaed Chamaecoetae in ]:{{sfn|Виноградов|Чокаев|1966|pp=, }} | ||
| {{Block quote|text="''Another ethnonym, Khamekets, turns out to be comparable with the name of one of the most ancient powerful Ingush taips, eponymous to its center, the mountain village of Khamkhi in the Assinsky Gorge.''"}} | {{Block quote|text="''Another ethnonym, Khamekets, turns out to be comparable with the name of one of the most ancient powerful Ingush taips, eponymous to its center, the mountain village of Khamkhi in the Assinsky Gorge.''"}} | ||
Revision as of 15:37, 3 July 2023
Ancient tribe during first century AD, mentioned by StraboChamaecoetae (Template:Lang-grc) were an ancient tribe mentioned by Greek geographer Strabo in his work Geographica during the first century AD. Some researchers connect them with the Ingush and localize them in mountainous Ingushetia, in Khamkhi, while others question these theories and argue that more arguments are needed.
Ethnonym and localization
First and only mention
The first and only mention of the tribe is in work of the Greek geographer Strabo, Geographica. He stated in his work as follows:
"After the Troglodytae one comes to certain Chamaecoetae and Polyphagi, as they are called, and to the villages of the Eisadici, who are able to farm because they are not altogether exposed to the north."
Localization
For the first time in 1963, V. B. Vinogradov [ru] expressed the point of view about the ethnicity of the Chamaecoeta in his work "Sarmatians of the North-Eastern Caucasus" (Сарматы Северо-восточного Кавказа), he associated the ethnonym with the Vainakh tribes. Further on, he and Z. K. Chokaev [ru] again spoke about the connection of this ethnonym with the Ingush and localizaed Chamaecoetae in Khamkhi:
"Another ethnonym, Khamekets, turns out to be comparable with the name of one of the most ancient powerful Ingush taips, eponymous to its center, the mountain village of Khamkhi in the Assinsky Gorge."
E. I. Krupnov [ru] first localized the Chamaecoetae in mountainous Chechnya, but later agreed with B. V. Vinogradov and K. Z. Chokaev about the location near the Ingush village of Khamkhi. However, there were scholars like the Caucasologist N. G. Volkova [ru] who questioned these theories and argued that:
(...) "despite the great temptation of such comparisons, they require more argumentation."
See also
Notes
- In his work as well as in the works of Soviet and Russian scholars Chamaecoetae are commonly transliterated in Russian as Khamekets and Khamekits (Хамекеты and Хамекиты). Although in the translated work of the book Geographica of Fëdor Mishenko [ru], Chamaecoetae are instead transliterated in Russian as Khamaykoytes (Хамайкойты).
References
- Мищенка 1879, p. 516.
- ^ Strabo 1928, p. 241.
- ^ Виноградов & Чокаев 1966, pp. 25, 67.
- ^ Крупнов 1971, p. 28.
- Anchabadze 2001, p. 34.
- ^ Волкова 1973, p. 124.
- Мищенко 1879, pp. 516, CLXIII. sfn error: no target: CITEREFМищенко1879 (help)
Bibliography
- Anchabadze, George (2001). Vainakhs (The Chechen and Ingush). Tbilisi: Caucasian House. pp. 1–76.
- Виноградов, В. Б.; Чокаев, К. 3. (1966). Виноградов, В. Б. (ed.). "Древние свидетельства о названиях и размещении нахских племен" [Ancient evidence of the names and location of the Nakh tribes]. Известия ЧИНИИИЯЛ (in Russian). Vol. 8, no. 1. Грозный: Чечено-Ингушское Книжное Издательство.
{{cite magazine}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - Волкова, Н. Г. (1973). Этнонимы и племенные названия Северного Кавказа [Ethnonyms and tribal names of the North Caucasus] (in Russian). Москва: Наука. pp. 1–210.
- Jaimoukha, A. M. (2005). The Chechens: A Handbook. Psychology Press. pp. 1–320. ISBN 0415323282.
- Крупнов, Е. И. (1971). Средневековая Ингушетия [Medieval Ingushetia] (in Russian). Москва: Наука. pp. 1–211.
- Мищенка, Ф. Г. (1879). География Страбона в семнадцати книгах [Geography of Strabo in seventeen books] (in Russian). Москва: К. Т. Солдатенков. pp. 1–1177.
- Strabo (1928) . Geography Of Strabo: in 8 volumes (in English and Ancient Greek). Vol. 5. Translated by Jones, H. L. London: W. Heinemann Ltd. pp. 1–541.
- Тесаев, Амин. К вопросу локализации племен Содов-Исадиков и Хамекитов античных авторов [On the issue of localization of the Sodov-Isadik and Khamekite tribes of ancient authors] (in Russian). pp. 35–39.