Talk:Dutch dialects and varieties: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively ← Previous edit Next edit →Content deleted Content addedVisual WikitextInline

Revision as of 03:38, 29 March 2021 edit2003:de:371c:3d30:4890:bc59:6f39:b6ee (talk)No edit summary← Previous edit		Revision as of 22:02, 23 November 2023 edit undoSarcelles (talk \| contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers9,112 edits →Groups of dialects: additional contentTag: Disambiguation links addedNext edit →
Line 67:		Line 67:
	] (]) 17:58, 19 January 2021 (UTC)		] (]) 17:58, 19 January 2021 (UTC)

			http://www.wjheeringa.nl/thesis/thesis09.pdf has the following places as having ''Frisian mixed varieties'' classified as ''town Frisian varieties'', the other ''Frisian mixed varieties'' being stellingweerfs:
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			*]
			https://www.researchgate.net/publication/240956524_To_What_Extent_are_Surnames_Words_Comparing_Geographic_Patterns_of_Surname_and_Dialect_Variation_in_the_Netherlands There are two dialect maps of the Netherlands, labelled 4 and 5. 4 has the following clusters: Low Saxon, Friso-Saxon, Low Franconian, Central Gelderland, Zeeland, Low Franconian as well as the three, remote, quite neighbouring clusters Frisian, Franco-Frisian and Archaic Frisisan (in Hindeloopen, Schiermonnikoog and Terschelling) 5 has Limburg North of Venlo as a separate dialect area.

			Clustering in this article includes the following possible categories not mentioned hitherto:

			''Zeeland'' and ''Central Gelderland''.
			], ] island and ] can be grouped together.

			Leeuwarden and possibly ] can be grouped together. Dokkum, Stavoren, Kollum and possibly Heerenveen can have single varieties.

			The varieties in the Netherlands can be grouped into a major Low Franconian group, the one around ] and the rest. Limburg is divided into a small area around Weert, a large area until Venlo and an area North of this. There is another major group: Low Saxon divided into three areas. ] is separate. ] hosts many of the varieties obtained. They can be divided into



			Frisian, archaic Frisian (], ] and ] island),


	-
			] varieties (Frisian cities, ], ] island and ]) and ] (in ] and variously also ]).

			Possible clustering includes the following possible categories not mentioned hitherto:

			''Zeeland'' and ''Central Gelderland''.

			], ] island and ] can be grouped together.
			Leeuwarden and possibly ] can be grouped together. Dokkum, Stavoren, Kollum and possibly Heerenveen can have single varieties.
			<ref>https://www.academia.edu/3130916/De_analyse_van_taalvariatie_in_het_Nederlandse_dialectgebied_methoden_en_resultaten_op_basis_van_lexicon_en_uitspraaken</ref>
			has the following views:
			Bildts, Midslands, ], and Amelands can be grouped with
			] of ]. The closest cluster to this cluster is that formed by ] and ].
			Hollandic, ] and ] can be grouped as ''Centraal westelijke dialecten''.
			Among those, not only Hollandic borders to ''Centraal zuidelijke dialecten'', which encompasses Brabantic and parts of Northern Dutch Limburg and Northern Belgium Limburg.
			The group, but not Hollandic, borders to non-Groningian ] and ].
			The dialect of ] is closest to the group.
			The clusters grouping with the group including Hollandic are:
			''Zuidwest-Limburg'' and ''Centraal zuidelijke dialecten'' as well as ''Tienen''.

Revision as of 22:02, 23 November 2023

This article has not yet been rated on Misplaced Pages's content assessment scale.
It is of interest to the following WikiProjects:

Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.

Languages Low‑importance

	Language portal This article is within the scope of WikiProject Languages, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of languages on Misplaced Pages. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.LanguagesWikipedia:WikiProject LanguagesTemplate:WikiProject Languageslanguage
Low	This article has been rated as Low-importance on the project's importance scale.

Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.

Netherlands

This article falls within the scope of WikiProject Netherlands, an attempt to create, expand, and improve articles related to the Netherlands on Misplaced Pages. If you would like to participate, visit the project page where you can join the project or contribute to the discussion.NetherlandsWikipedia:WikiProject NetherlandsTemplate:WikiProject NetherlandsNetherlands

Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.

Belgium Low‑importance

	Belgium portal This article is within the scope of WikiProject Belgium, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of Belgium on Misplaced Pages. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.BelgiumWikipedia:WikiProject BelgiumTemplate:WikiProject BelgiumBelgium-related
Low	This article has been rated as Low-importance on the project's importance scale.

Attribution

Page was created as summary-style article split from Dutch language. Diff: CIreland (talk) 18:10, 15 March 2008 (UTC)

Unmotivated tag

As far as I can see, there is no contradiction whatsoever between the content of this article and that of nl:Nederlandse dialecten, let alone a serious one. Who is responsible for this tag and on what grounds could it have been assigned? I am very curious to hear which reservations on whose side there possibly could be here. It looks like some unexplicable mystery. -- Ad43 (talk) 14:58, 31 December 2008 (UTC)

Focus

Dutch
This article is a part of a series on
Languages of the Netherlands Dutch dialects Afrikaans
Low Saxon dialects
Northern Low Saxon Gronings Westphalian Achterhooks Drèents Veluws Sallaands Stellingwarfs Tweants
West Low Franconian dialects
West Flemish/French Flemish East Flemish Zeelandic Central Dutch Hollandic Indonesian Dutch Kleverlandish Surinamese Dutch Brabantian Antwerpian Brusselian Stadsfries Bildts
East Low Franconian dialects
Limburgish Southeast Limburgish
v t e

The whole article lacks focus. Its subject is not clearly defined. It should about either:

Dialects of the Dutch language; or
Dialects of the Netherlands

The definition:

Dutch dialects are primarily the dialects that are both cognate with the Dutch language

and are spoken in the same language area as the Dutch standard language.

does not make much sense. By this definition French Flemish would not be a Dutch dialect, while Lower Saxon would arguably be. Then the article goes on to mention several dialects outside the area of the Dutch standard language.

So what should it be? All dialects spoken in the Netherlands (including Frisian), or, as I would suggest, all dialect varieties of modern Lower Frankish (of which Dutch is the only official standard language). This would exclude Frisian and Lower Saxon.--Joostik (talk) 19:00, 10 May 2010 (UTC)

I think the template {{Dutch dialects}} (displayed on the right) covers most dialects. Frisian is not a dialect - it's a language. If Frisian would be mentioned in the article, than for that reason and that reason only. Low Saxon should be included, though. Richard 07:02, 11 May 2010 (UTC)

Re: Across the borders

The previous text read:

'Zeelandic (Zeeuws) is spoken in most of Zeeland (Netherlands) and is a transitional regional language between West Flemish and Hollandic. In the eastern part of Zeelandic Flanders, East Flemish is spoken.'

Zeelandic, however, does not cross a border. East Flemish, on the other hand, does so I have changed the text accordingly. Collideascope (talk) 20:49, 2 August 2013 (UTC)

Groups of dialects

http://www.wjheeringa.nl/thesis/thesis09.pdf is a scientfic study. It has the following groups, which should -apart from the Frisian varieties- entered into the article, but changed formally.

Frisian, doesn't fit into the article
Frisian mixed varieties, imho doesn't fit into the article either
Groningen
Overijssel, also including large parts of Gelderland
Southwest Limburg, Belgium only
Brabant, also including most of Antwerp Province
Central Dutch varieties, nearly entire Holland and Utrecht Province, as well as large parts of North Brabant and Gelderland
Urk
East Flanders
West Flanders, up to France
Zeeland
Limburg, also nearly all of North Limburg. This part of North Limburg has a long border with Germany. For the most part, the places on the German side of this part of the border are in the Kleverlandish dialect area. The term

Limburgish would therefore be too narrow. I therefore suggest using the term Meuse-Rhenish.

Northeast Luik, including Kerkrade and Eupen, could also be given as Southeast Limburgish.

Sarcelles (talk) 06:11, 5 July 2020 (UTC)

The general pattern with studies is to have Southwest Limburg within Limburgish. Furthermore, above study doesn't include Germany. The reference on Ripuarian dialects given below has Ripuarian-Low Franconian transition area without North Bergish area and

North Bergish area, usually seen as Limburgish. However, it only includes Germany. Dialektologie. 2. Halbband Werner Besch, Ulrich Knoop, Wolfgang Putschke, Herbert E. Wiegand Walter de Gruyter, 2008 p. 858/859 has Ripuarian as to include

Nördliche Eifel
Mittleres Erft- und Rurgebiet
Aachener Land
Bergisches Land
Ripuarisch-niederfränkisches Übergangsgebiet ohne nordbergischen Raum
Nordbergischer Raum

Sarcelles (talk) 17:58, 19 January 2021 (UTC)

http://www.wjheeringa.nl/thesis/thesis09.pdf has the following places as having Frisian mixed varieties classified as town Frisian varieties, the other Frisian mixed varieties being stellingweerfs:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/240956524_To_What_Extent_are_Surnames_Words_Comparing_Geographic_Patterns_of_Surname_and_Dialect_Variation_in_the_Netherlands There are two dialect maps of the Netherlands, labelled 4 and 5. 4 has the following clusters: Low Saxon, Friso-Saxon, Low Franconian, Central Gelderland, Zeeland, Low Franconian as well as the three, remote, quite neighbouring clusters Frisian, Franco-Frisian and Archaic Frisisan (in Hindeloopen, Schiermonnikoog and Terschelling) 5 has Limburg North of Venlo as a separate dialect area.

Clustering in this article includes the following possible categories not mentioned hitherto:

Zeeland and Central Gelderland. Midsland, Ameland island and Het Bildt can be grouped together.

Leeuwarden and possibly Sneek can be grouped together. Dokkum, Stavoren, Kollum and possibly Heerenveen can have single varieties.

The varieties in the Netherlands can be grouped into a major Low Franconian group, the one around Almere and the rest. Limburg is divided into a small area around Weert, a large area until Venlo and an area North of this. There is another major group: Low Saxon divided into three areas. Urk is separate. Friesland hosts many of the varieties obtained. They can be divided into

Frisian, archaic Frisian (Hindeloopen, Schiermonnikoog and Terschelling island),

Friso-Franconian varieties (Frisian cities, Midsland, Ameland island and Het Bildt) and Friso-Saxon (in Stellingwerf and variously also Westerkwartier).

Possible clustering includes the following possible categories not mentioned hitherto:

Zeeland and Central Gelderland.

Midsland, Ameland island and Het Bildt can be grouped together. Leeuwarden and possibly Sneek can be grouped together. Dokkum, Stavoren, Kollum and possibly Heerenveen can have single varieties. has the following views: Bildts, Midslands, Stadsfries, and Amelands can be grouped with Frisian varieties of Friesland. The closest cluster to this cluster is that formed by Westerkwartier and Stellingwerf. Hollandic, Zeelandic and West-Veluws can be grouped as Centraal westelijke dialecten. Among those, not only Hollandic borders to Centraal zuidelijke dialecten, which encompasses Brabantic and parts of Northern Dutch Limburg and Northern Belgium Limburg. The group, but not Hollandic, borders to non-Groningian Low Saxon and Flemish dialects. The dialect of Urk is closest to the group. The clusters grouping with the group including Hollandic are: Zuidwest-Limburg and Centraal zuidelijke dialecten as well as Tienen.

https://www.academia.edu/3130916/De_analyse_van_taalvariatie_in_het_Nederlandse_dialectgebied_methoden_en_resultaten_op_basis_van_lexicon_en_uitspraaken

Categories: