Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 19:34, 21 September 2007

Italian conquest of British Somaliland
Part of East African Campaign, World War II
The Italian invasion of British Somaliland in August 1940
Date 3 August 1940-17 August 1940 Location British Somaliland Result Italian victory, fall of British Somaliland
Belligerents
United Kingdom File:Imperial-India-Blue-Ensign.svg British India British Somaliland N. Rhodesia British East Africa	Italy Italian East Africa
Commanders and leaders
Alfred Godwin-Austen Arthur Chater	Guglielmo Nasi Carlo De Simone
Strength
4,000	24,000
Casualties and losses
38 killed 71 wounded 49 missing Not officially:1000 "Irregulars" Bands	Total:205 Not officially:2000 "Irregulars" Bands

The Italian conquest of British Somaliland was a campaign in the Horn of Africa which took place in the summer of 1940 and was part of the East African Campaign.

Background

When Italy declared war on 10 June 1940, the Italian troops were not prepared for a prolonged war in North Africa or East Africa. As a consequence, Italian dictator Benito Mussolini ordered only some limited aggressive actions to capture territory along the borders of Egypt, Kenya, and Sudan.

Later in June, Amedeo, Duke of Aosta, the Governor-General of Italian East Africa, convinced the Italian Supreme Command (Commando Supremo) to plan a campaign to conquer British Somaliland. Victor Emmanuel III, the King of Italy, and Mussolini agreed with the Duke of Aosta and by the beginning of August the campaign was ready to start.

Order of Battle

The Italian force attacking British Somaliland in August 1940 was commanded by General Guglielmo Nasi. The force included five colonial brigades, three Blackshirt battalions, and three bands (bande) of native troops. The Italians also had armoured vehicles (a small number of both light and medium tanks), artillery, and, most important, superior air support. The Italians numbered about 24,000.

The Italians were opposed by a British contingent of about 4,000 soldiers consisting of the Somaliland Camel Corps (commanded by Colonel Arthur Reginald Chater), elements of the 2nd (Nyasaland) Battalion King's African Rifles (KAR) and the 1st Battalion Northern Rhodesian Regiment, the 3rd Battalion 15th Punjab Regiment, and the 2nd Battalion Black Watch.

Initial Offensive

In the early hours of 3 August 1940, the Italian army crossed the border between Italian East Africa (called by the Italians Africa Orientale Italiana, AOI) and British Somaliland.

The Italians advanced with three columns attacking in three directions. The column to the north attacked toward the port of Zeila. The column to the center attacked toward Adadlek. And the column to the south attacked toward Odweina.

On 5 August, the port of Zeila was occupied after heavy fighting by the Italian northern column. Any possibility of help from French Somaliland for the retreating British was cut. The northern column then proceeded south along the coast and occupied the village of Bulhar.

The Italian central column, commanded by Lieutenant-General Carlo De Simone, faced more difficulties because of the mountanous terrain through which it advanced. The column was stopped by the British at the Karrin Pass, before Hargeisa.

Colonel Chater, used his camel corps to skirmish with and screen against the advancing Italians as the other British and Commonwealth forces pulled back towards Tug Argan.

Battle of Tug Argan

On 6 August, within three days of the invasion, the towns of Zeila and Hargeisa were taken by the Italians. Odweina fell the following day and the Italian central and southern columns combined to launch attacks against the main British and Commonwealth positions at Tug Argan.

On 7 August, the British and Commonwealth forces in British Somaliland received reinforcements with the arrival of the 1st Battalion 2nd Punjab Regiment. On 11 August, a new commander, Major-General Alfred Godwin-Austen, reached Tug Argan.

The defensive positions of the British army were centered around six hills overlooking the only road toward Berbera. On 11 August, an Italian brigade commanded by De Simone attacked the hill defended by the 3rd Battalion 15th Punjab Regiment and captured it with heavy casualties. The British launched two unsuccessful counterattacks, but the next day were forced to abandon two other nearby hills.

On 14 August, the Italians began to encircle the British defenders from their eastern positions, and the defenders' situation started to look critical.

After three days of battle, early on 15 August, Godwin-Austen (fearing an inminent encirclement) concluded that further resistance at Tug Argan would be futile. He contacted the British Middle East Command headquarters in Cairo, Egypt and requested and received permission to withdraw his forces from British Somaliland.

The determined effort of the Black Watch battalion, which covered the retreat, allowed the entire British and Commonwealth contingent to withdraw to Berbera with minimal losses.

British evacuation from Berbera

Whilst the British made their fighting retreat to Berbera, the Royal Navy had constructed an all-tide jetty and had commenced evacuating civilian and administrative officials. The two main Italian columns (the central and the southern) were united at the village of La Farruk, approximately 30 kilometers south of Berbera.

From Bulhar, the Italian northern column reached the area of Berbera on 14 August. But the British defenders were able to hold them off. On 16 August, the British started to embark troops onto the waiting ships. The British had completed the evacuation by the afternoon of the following day. The ships departed for Aden.

On 15 August, Amedeo, Duke of Aosta personally ordered General Guglielmo Nasi to allow the British to evacuate without too much fighting. He did this in the hope of a possible future peace agreement, that was being promoted through the Vatican mediation, between Italy and Great Britain.

The British defenders had little interference in this operation even after a fierce bayonet charge against the Italians by the Black Watch at Barkasan. The Somaliland Camel Corps, rather than evacuate, was disbanded and dispersed.

On 19 August, the Italians took control of Berbera and then moved down the coast to complete their conquest of British Somaliland. The British colony was annexed by Mussolini to the Italian Empire in Italian East Africa.

Casualties

According to Italian historians , during the campaign to conquer British Somaliland the casualties were 250 for the British army and 205 for the Italian.

But according to the British account of events total British casualties were 158 and Italian losses were estimated at between ten and twenty times higher.

Not officially, the Italian officer Carlo De Simone estimated that nearly one thousand Colonial British soldiers were casualties during the campaign. These "armed men" operated as local "Bande", with only minimal control from British officers (like Colonel Chater).Even the fascist Gentile and general Frusci wrote about this thousand casualties, and they believed that there were nearly 2000 casualties between the Somalis of Somaliland that fought as "armed Bands" for the Italians (the most popular local tribe chief - named: Afchar - greeted the Italians after the conquest of Zeila and offered his men against the British).

The Irregulars Somalis against the British were the descendants of the Dervish fighters of Mohammed Abdullah Hassan (called Sayyid Mohammed Hassan by the Somali patriots and "Mad Mullah" by the British colonialists), a somali hero against the english colonial occupation of Somaliland in the nineteenth century. Indeed, in the beginning of 1920, the British struck the Dervish settlements with a well-coordinated land, sea and air attack and gave them a stunning defeat. The forts of Sayyid Mohammed were damaged and his army suffered great losses. They hastily fled to Ogaden. Here, again with the help of Mohammed Hassan patriotic poetry and charisma, he tried to rebuild his army and accomplish the coalition of Ogadeen clans which made him a power in Somaliland once again. Unfortunately, Sayyid died in 1921 and the British maintained the Somaliland in their hands but with frequent local rebellions. On the other side, there were many Irregulars (Ethiopians and Somalis) fighting a guerrilla war in Ogaden (and even in deserted eastern Somaliland) against the Italians after their conquest of Ethiopia in 1936. Those Irregulars (even if not officially recognized by the British authorities) had nearly 1000 casualties fighting the Italians on the side of the British in 1940. They had verbal (as Somalis used to do) agreements with Colonel Chater and his Camel Corps, but after the dismantlement of the Camel Corp on August 17 they were denyed by the British the recognition of their help and casualties.

Aftermath

The conquered port of Berbera was used by the italian submarines of the Red Sea Flotilla as a small base in the last months of 1940 .

The British Prime Minister, Sir Winston Churchill, criticized General Archibald Wavell concerning the loss of British Somaliland. It was Wavell's Middle East Command which was responsible for the loss of the colony. Because of the low casualty rate, Churchill fretted that the British had abandoned the colony without enough of a fight.

In response to this criticism, Wavell claimed that Somaliland was a textbook withdrawal in the face of superior numbers. He pointed out to Churchill that “A bloody butcher’s bill is not the sign of a good tactician.” According to Churchill's staff, Wavell's retort moved Churchill to greater fury than they had ever seen before.

British Somaliland remained part of the Italian East Africa until March 1941 when the 1st/2nd Punjab Regiment and the 3rd/15th Punjab Regiment returned from Aden to re-occupy the territory.

Insights

The conquest of the British Somaliland was the only campaign victory Italy achieved — without the support of German troops — during World War II against the Allies.

The campaign in Somaliland was like all the others of the Axis: it initially started with a victory, then after a period of time (like the campaigns in the Balkans, in the Philippines or in Russia), finished with a complete defeat. But in the specific case of the Italian conquest of British Somaliland, the defeat (that happened in spring 1941) was followed by nearly two years of Italian guerrilla warfare.

Other main insights from this campaign are the following:

• The invasion of British Somaliland showed that Italian forces could co-ordinate columns separated by many miles of desert.
• British forces showed good discipline in the retreat and were able to salvage most of their forces.
• The invasion of British Somaliland was the first campaign the Italians won in World War II.
• British Somaliland was the first British colony to fall to enemy forces in World War II.
• After the first months of the war were over, Mussolini boasted that Italy had conquered a territory (made of British Somaliland, the Sudan area around the border outposts of Karora, Gallabat, Kurmak and Kassala, and the area in Kenya around Moyale and Buna) the size of England in the Horn of Africa.
• The campaign of British Somaliand in August 1940 was the only in which the British army could not get strong support from the R.A.F., showing the importance of the air forces in the Allies victories.

See also

• East African Campaign (World War II)

Sources

• Antonicelli, Franco. Trent'anni di storia italiana 1915 - 1945 (in Italian). Mondadori ed. Torino, 1961.
• Del Boca, Angelo. Italiani in Africa Orientale: La caduta dell'Impero (in Italian). Laterza. Roma-Bari, 1986. ISBN 884202810X
• Mackenzie, Compton (1951). Eastern Epic. London: Chatto & Windus.
• Mockler, Anthony. Haile Selassie's War: The Italian-Ethiopian Campaign, 1935-1941. Random House. New York, 1984. ISBN 0-394-54222-3
• Rovighi, Alberto. Le Operazioni in Africa Orientale (in Italian). Stato Maggiore Esercito,Ufficio storico. Roma, 1952.

Notes

1. ^ Compton Mackenzie, Eastern Epic, p. 23
2. Rovighi, Alberto. Le operazioni in Africa orientale. Stato Maggiore Esercito,Ufficio storico
3. Mockler, Haile Selassie's War: The Italian-Ethiopian Campaign, 1935-1941, pp. 243-45.
4. ^ Compton Mackenzie, Eastern Epic, p. 22
5. Del Boca, Angelo. Italiani in Africa Orientale: La caduta dell'Impero
6. Rovighi, Alberto. Le operazioni in Africa orientale. Stato Maggiore Esercito,Ufficio storico
7. Mockler, Haile Selassie's War: The Italian-Ethiopian Campaign, 1935-1941, pp. 245-49.
8. Rovighi, Alberto. Le operazioni in Africa orientale Stato Maggiore Esercito,Ufficio storico
9. Compton Mackenzie, Eastern Epic. pp. 23-24
10. Rovighi, Alberto. Le operazioni in Africa orientale Stato Maggiore Esercito,Ufficio storico
11. Mockler, Haile Selassie's War: The Italian-Ethiopian Campaign, 1935-1941, p. 251.
12. Antonicelli, Franco. Trent'anni di storia italiana 1915 - 1945
13. Antonicelli, Franco. Trent'anni di storia italiana 1915 - 1945

Links

• Photos of the italian conquest of Somaliland
• Maps and articles on the war in Italian East Africa (in Italian)
• WWII in the italian colonies (in Italian)

• Campaigns and theatres of World War II
• History of Italy
• History of Somalia
• Wars involving Italy
• Wars involving the United Kingdom