Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 22:33, 7 November 2007

It has been suggested that this article be split into articles titled Ritual slaughter in Judaism and Islam and Animal sacrifice. (discuss)

Ritual slaughter is the practice of slaughtering livestock for meat in a ritual manner, e.g. prescribed by a religious dietary laws, notably Jewish Shechita and Islamic Ḏabīḥah.

In Animal sacrifice in general, the ritual aspect predominates over the food production aspect, but since typical animal sacrifices also yield meat consumed by the sacrificers, a clear line cannot be drawn between ritual slaughter and generic animal sacrifice.

History

Walter Burkert in Homo Necans discusses animal sacrifice as arising from the anthropological transition to hunting. With the domestication of livestock, the hunt was gradually replaced by the slaughter or livestock, and hunting rituals were consequently transformed to the context of slaughter.

In antiquity, ritual slaughter and animal sacrifice was one and the same. Thus, as argued by Detienne et al. (1989), for the Greeks, consumption of meat not slaughtered ritually was unthinkable, so that beyond being a tribute to the gods, Greek animal sacrifice marked a cultural boundary, separating "Hellenes" from "barbarians". Greek animal sacrifice was Christianized into slaughter ceremonies involving Greek Orthodox Christian ritual.

Ancient Egyptian slaughter rituals are frequently depicted in tombs and temples from the Old Kingdom onwards. The standard iconography of the ritual involves a bull lying fettered on the ground with the butcher standing over it cutting its foreleg. The scene is attended by a woman and two priests.

In Judaism and Islam

It has been suggested that Islamic and Jewish dietary laws compared and Talk:Ritual slaughter be merged into this article. (Discuss) Proposed since October 2007.

Jewish Shechita

Shechita (Hebrew:שחיטה) is the ritual slaughter of mammals and birds according to Jewish dietary laws. The act is performed by drawing a very sharp knife across the animal's throat and allowing the blood to drain out. Islamic dietary laws require a similar procedure.

The animal must be killed with respect and compassion by a "shochet" (ritual slaughterer), a pious Jew who has in mind the life of the animal as he draws the knife across its neck. The animal can be in a number of positions; when the animal is lying on its back, this is referred to as shechita munachat.

If the hindquarters (or sirloin) of kosher mammals are to be eaten by Jews, they must be 'porged' - stripped of veins, fats and sinews in accordance with a strict procedure. Because of the expense of porging and the skill required to properly separate out the forbidden parts, a large portion of the meat of kosher mammals slaughtered through shechita in the United States winds up on the non-kosher market.

Islamic Ḏabīḥah

Ḏabīḥah (ذَبِيْحَة) is the prescribed method of slaughtering all animals excluding fish and most sea-life per Islamic law. This method of slaughtering animals consists of a swift, deep incision with a sharp knife on the neck, cutting the jugular veins and carotid arteries of both sides but leaving the spinal cord intact. The objective of this technique is to more effectively drain the body of the animal's blood, resulting in more hygienic meat, and to minimize the pain and agony for the animal. Detractors, most notably animal rights groups, contend that this method of slaughter 'causes severe suffering to animals'.

Modern bans

It has been suggested that Legal aspects of ritual slaughter and Talk:Ritual slaughter be merged into this article. (Discuss) Proposed since October 2007.

Bans on ritual slaughter have been proposed or enacted in a number of European countries, from the late 1890s onward. The issue is complicated by allegations of antisemitism and islamophobia.

The initial ban on kosher slaughter in modern Europe originated in the late 19th century in 1897 in Switzerland. Later bans were enacted in Bavaria in 1930, in Norway, Germany and Sweden in the mid-1930s.

Debate on the issue has shifted over time such that modern debate focuses primarily on balancing concerns for animal welfare with concerns over limiting freedom of religion. Additionally, proponents of ritual slaughter argue that their practice is humane and that objections are based on misconceptions.

The above is from the article "Bans on ritual slaughter": my note starts below:

The EU does not use "ritual slaughter" any more. One reason is objections from the religious communities, and accusations against Jewish shohtim of ritual murder. Googe gives about 1 000 000 hits for ritual slaughter and about 1 000 000 hits for religious slaughter. There is kosher, or Jewish slaughter, halal or Muslim slaughter, and Sikh Jhakta slaughter. Religous slaughter covers all three. Ritual slaughter is avoided in most of the literature mentioned in the footnotes nowadays. What responsible authorities use this term nowadays given in the references in the footnotes to the article? In the paper Religiös slakt (Religious slaughter) there is an introductory note explaining this terminology by an Ethnologist. I will find it and put it here. RPSM 22:33, 7 November 2007 (UTC)

Africa

Ritual slaughter is practiced in various African traditional religions. Zulu slaughter rituals have led to controversy in South Africa.

Monica Hunter in her 1936 study of the Mpondo people of the Transkei described the ritual:

"When speaking to the ancestors was finished Sipopone took the sacrificial spear of the umzi , passed it between the forelegs of the animal, and between its back legs, which were tied, then stabbed it in the stomach over the aorta muscle. The beast bellowed horribly, and lay in agony for about five minutes before it died."

The bellowing of the animal is supposed to represent communication with the ancestors. (David Welsh 2007 )

References

1. Eberhard Otto, An Ancient Egyptian Hunting Ritual, Journal of Near Eastern Studies (1950).
2. Deut. 12:21, Deut. 14:21, Num. 11:22
3. Mishneh Torah Kedushah, Forbidden Foods 8:1
4. Mishneh Torah Kedushah, Forbidden Foods 6:1
5. Eisenstein, Judah David (1901–1906). "PORGING". Jewish Encyclopedia. New York. LCCN:16014703. Retrieved 2006-07-23.{{cite encyclopedia}}: CS1 maint: date format (link) CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
6. Halal/Haram/Zabiha, ISNA Halal Certification Agency.
7. Transcription: Ritual Slaughter Ban, Living on Earth, republished by Vegans Represent June 10 2003, accessed September 18 2006

Literature

• M. Detienne, J.-P. Vernant (eds.), The Cuisine of Sacrifice among the Greeks, trans. Wissing, University of Chicago Press (1989).
• Roy A. Rappaport , Pigs for the Ancestors: Ritual in the Ecology of a New Guinea People (1969, 2000), ISBN 978-1577661016.

See also

• Ritual killing
• Religion and violence
• Islamic and Jewish dietary laws compared

• Articles to be merged from October 2007
• Ritual
• Meat processing
• Animal sacrifice
• Religion based diets
• Religious law