| Revision as of 14:05, 8 July 2005 editNetoholic (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users39,916 edits rvt. Is the creator of a template considered a vote to keep unless explicitly stated otherwise?← Previous edit | Revision as of 14:11, 8 July 2005 edit undoRadiant! (talk | contribs)36,918 edits Like on VFD, a nomination may be considered a delete vote. Or not, depending on the wording. Closing admin's discretion.Next edit → | ||
| Line 64: | Line 64: | ||
| Debates can be closed after seven days of discussion, at which point they are archived, and the template listed for further processing (e.g. orphaning/deleting, rewriting, or removing its TFD template if kept). Because of backlogs, the page may sometimes hold older discussions. | Debates can be closed after seven days of discussion, at which point they are archived, and the template listed for further processing (e.g. orphaning/deleting, rewriting, or removing its TFD template if kept). Because of backlogs, the page may sometimes hold older discussions. | ||
| As on ], the discussion is the most important part, as it serves to show consensus. The votes are a means to this end. In terms of votes, at least a two-thirds majority is required to delete a template. However, it is possible that the arguments given during discussion overrides this principle - especially if, halfway through the vote, an important argument was made and the votes made later take that argument into account (e.g. a vote pattern such as ''del del del del '''argument''' keep''). | As on ], the discussion is the most important part, as it serves to show consensus. The votes are a means to this end. In terms of votes, at least a two-thirds majority is required to delete a template. Dependent on the wording, the nomination itself may be considered a vote to delete. However, it is possible that the arguments given during discussion overrides this principle - especially if, halfway through the vote, an important argument was made and the votes made later take that argument into account (e.g. a vote pattern such as ''del del del del '''argument''' keep''). | ||
| Rewriting, renaming and conversion to category or list are not considered forms of deletion since no information is lost, and thus can pass with a lower amount of support. Indeed, if five people vote to keep and one votes to rename, it may make good sense to rename the template unless some of the other voters explicitly objected to that. | Rewriting, renaming and conversion to category or list are not considered forms of deletion since no information is lost, and thus can pass with a lower amount of support. Indeed, if five people vote to keep and one votes to rename, it may make good sense to rename the template unless some of the other voters explicitly objected to that. | ||
Revision as of 14:11, 8 July 2005
How to list templates for deletion
- Misplaced Pages:Votes (articles) for deletion.
- Misplaced Pages:Images and media for deletion.
- Misplaced Pages:Categories for deletion.
- Misplaced Pages:Redirects for deletion.
- Misplaced Pages:Votes for Undeletion.
To list a template for deletion, follow this three-step process: (replace TemplateName with the name of the template to be deleted — do not include the namepace identifier "Template:")
| I. | Edit the template.
Enter the following text in the top of the template or inside the box (where applicable):
Please include "tfd" or similar in the edit summary, and don't mark the edit as minor. Also, try to minimise page disruption, by using the Preview button to check the revised template, as its new look will be visible on all pages that use it. Do not blank the template. |
| II. | Create its TfD subsection.
You willl have to create a section on the Templates for deletion page, under the subheading for 'today's date' (December 26). You may have to create the heading for today's date. Add this text to the section, at the top:
Suggest what action should be taken for the template. |
| III. | Give due notice.
Add {{subst:tfdnotice|TemplateName}} on relevant talk pages, which will create a section, warning other editors. |
Also consider adding to your watchlist any articles you nominate for TfD. This will help ensure that your TfD tag is not removed by a vandal.
Deletion criteria
Deletion of templates may be appropriate if the template does not conform to the following.
- Templates should be helpful and noteworthy;
- Templates should not be redundant;
- Templates should be used (note however that the opposite cannot be concluded from the absence of backlinks, it may be used with "subst:";
- Templates should not be POV;
- Templates should not generally be used within other templates - see Misplaced Pages:Avoid using meta-templates.
If you want a template changed or reworded, or its layout changed, please discuss that on the template's talk page rather than listing it for deletion here.
If a template is part of (the functioning of) a Misplaced Pages policy or guideline, the template can not be listed for deletion on TfD separately, the template should be discussed where the discussion for that guideline is taking place.
Voting and discussion
Anyone can vote, but please give a reason when doing so. Please explain how, in your opinion, the Template does not meet the criteria above. Comments such as "I like it," or "I find it useful," while potentially true, generally do not fulfill this requirement. It also helps if you Bold your actual vote (i.e. Keep or Delete).
Nominating stub templates for deletion should instead be done at the new process WP:WSS. Templates that reside in userspace should instead be nominated on the regular WP:VFD page, but please note that Misplaced Pages is very lenient about userspace. Templates that reside in mainspace should also go on WP:VFD, and Misplaced Pages is not very lenient about those.
Examples of votes
- Keep
- Delete
- Convert to category (categorify); to indicate that you feel that all pages containing this (article series box) template should be moved into a single category. The template can then be deleted.
- Convert to list (listify); to indicate that you feel that all pages containing this (article series box) template should be moved into a single list. The template can then be deleted.
- Redirect redirect to more popular or fitting title.
- Rewrite suggests that the template serves a purpose (thus should be kept), and that it could do this more elegantly.
- Retitle / rename / move; usually for offensive, overly lengthy, or otherwise poorly chosen titles.
- Userfy suggests that the template should be moved to a user's subpage. Used for personal templates.
- Subst: single-use templates can be replaced by the template values by using the subst: parameter in the template (e.g. {{subst:templatename}}). Then the template can be deleted.
- BJAODN Copy to Bad jokes and other deleted nonsense before deletion.
Closing
Debates can be closed after seven days of discussion, at which point they are archived, and the template listed for further processing (e.g. orphaning/deleting, rewriting, or removing its TFD template if kept). Because of backlogs, the page may sometimes hold older discussions.
As on WP:VFD, the discussion is the most important part, as it serves to show consensus. The votes are a means to this end. In terms of votes, at least a two-thirds majority is required to delete a template. Dependent on the wording, the nomination itself may be considered a vote to delete. However, it is possible that the arguments given during discussion overrides this principle - especially if, halfway through the vote, an important argument was made and the votes made later take that argument into account (e.g. a vote pattern such as del del del del argument keep).
Rewriting, renaming and conversion to category or list are not considered forms of deletion since no information is lost, and thus can pass with a lower amount of support. Indeed, if five people vote to keep and one votes to rename, it may make good sense to rename the template unless some of the other voters explicitly objected to that.
This process relies on the discretion and common sense of the user closing a debate, generally an admin. If you disagree with a decision, please discuss it with that user.