| Revision as of 21:18, 29 May 2009 editGreenman (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Event coordinators, Extended confirmed users61,087 edits Reverted to revision 293148217 by Greenman; rv. (TW)← Previous edit | Revision as of 21:30, 29 May 2009 edit undoVerbal (talk | contribs)Pending changes reviewers21,940 edits rm template as I've removed the section contested on talkNext edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| {{NPOV}} | |||
| '''Patrick Holford''' is a British ], author, and the founder and director of the ] in London. He is the Chief Executive Officer and co-founder (with Professor ] of the ]) of the special interest group that developed into ], a registered charity which has the stated aim of promoting mental health through nutrition <ref></ref>. He is also director of the Brain Bio Centre, which specializes in a nutrition-based approach to ] problems. He appears regularly on television and radio in the UK. | '''Patrick Holford''' is a British ], author, and the founder and director of the ] in London. He is the Chief Executive Officer and co-founder (with Professor ] of the ]) of the special interest group that developed into ], a registered charity which has the stated aim of promoting mental health through nutrition <ref></ref>. He is also director of the Brain Bio Centre, which specializes in a nutrition-based approach to ] problems. He appears regularly on television and radio in the UK. | ||
| His claims about ] and ] are |
His claims about ] and ] are not in line with modern medical thought, and have been criticised as putting people in danger or damaging public health. | ||
| Holford has written over thirty-five books, which have been translated into 17 languages. His fourth book, ''The Optimum Nutrition Bible'', has sold more than 500,000 copies worldwide. {{Fact|date=May 2009}} | |||
| == Career == | == Career == | ||
| Holford obtained a |
Holford obtained a BSc in ] from the ] in 1976.<ref name="profile">Holford, Patrick. ''''. patrickholford.com. Accessed 6 January 2007.</ref> As a psychology student, he became interested in the biochemistry of mental health problems. His research brought him in contact with Dr Carl Pfeiffer and Dr ], both of whom claimed success in treating ] with nutritional therapy. However, he did not graduate from the University of York until 1979, leading critics such as HolfordWatch to challenge the veracity of his ]. | ||
| In 1984, Holford founded the ] (ION). At that institute, he has worked on nutritional approaches to ], ], and ]s. In 1995, the Board of Trustees of ION (of which he was a director) awarded him an Honorary Diploma in Nutritional Therapy.<ref name="profile"/> | In 1984, Holford founded the ] (ION). At that institute, he has worked on nutritional approaches to ], ], and ]s. In 1995, the Board of Trustees of ION (of which he was a director) awarded him an Honorary Diploma in Nutritional Therapy.<ref name="profile"/> | ||
| Line 18: | Line 15: | ||
| Holford replied<ref name=HolfordGuardianreply>Holford, Patrick. , 16 February 2007. Accessed 19 March 2007.</ref> to '']'' newspaper that: <blockquote>"As well knows, the author of the research — Dr Raxit Jariwalla — wrote to the ''Guardian'' (January 20 2005)<ref>Jariwalla, Raxit. , 20 January 2005. Accessed 19 March 2007.</ref> the last time Goldacre made this claim, to confirm that my statement is correct on the basis of two studies on HIV-infected cells. The real crime here is that no full-scale human trials have been funded on vitamin C to follow up Jariwalla's important finding because it is non-patentable and hence not profitable. Goldacre seems unconcerned about the way commercial interests distort scientific research."</blockquote> | Holford replied<ref name=HolfordGuardianreply>Holford, Patrick. , 16 February 2007. Accessed 19 March 2007.</ref> to '']'' newspaper that: <blockquote>"As well knows, the author of the research — Dr Raxit Jariwalla — wrote to the ''Guardian'' (January 20 2005)<ref>Jariwalla, Raxit. , 20 January 2005. Accessed 19 March 2007.</ref> the last time Goldacre made this claim, to confirm that my statement is correct on the basis of two studies on HIV-infected cells. The real crime here is that no full-scale human trials have been funded on vitamin C to follow up Jariwalla's important finding because it is non-patentable and hence not profitable. Goldacre seems unconcerned about the way commercial interests distort scientific research."</blockquote> | ||
| === Advertising === | |||
| ⚫ | There has also been an adjudication by the ] against Patrick Holford's 100% Health leaflet. "On this point, the ad breached CAP Code clauses 3.1 (Substantiation), 7.1 (Truthfulness), 50.1 (Health & beauty products and therapies - General) and 50.20 (Health & beauty products and therapies - Vitamins, minerals and other food supplements)." | ||
| ⚫ | <ref></ref> | ||
| ⚫ | A previous adjudication by the ASA also went against Mr Holford. | ||
| ⚫ | <ref></ref> | ||
| === Autism === | === Autism === | ||
| Holford has also claimed that ''"We’ve learned about what it is that makes some kids develop autism and also how to bring them back."'' |
Holford has also claimed that ''"We’ve learned about what it is that makes some kids develop autism and also how to bring them back."'' This directly contradicts organisations devoted to ] such as the ] which says: ''"There is no known single cause for autism...Researchers are investigating a number of theories, including the link between heredity, genetics and medical problems."'' and the ] which states: ''"There is currently no known 'cure' for autism."'' | ||
| ⚫ | Holford is also one of the main supporters of the hypothesis that there is a link between the ] and autism. This is against the overwhelming opposition to the hypothesis by the scientific community. The Wakefield ''et al.'' paper upon which this hypothesis was based has been discredited by the scientific community and 10 of the 12 co-authors have formally retracted the paper. Furthermore, ], the Institute of Medicine of the ], the UK ] and the ] have all concluded that there is no evidence of a link between the MMR vaccine and autism. (See ]) | ||
| ⚫ | Catherine Collins, chief ] at ], reported that - due to following Holford's advice to adopt a restricted diet - a young ] girl participating in one of Holford's experiments suffered dramatic weight loss and sleep problems <ref>Goodchild, Sophie and Owen, Jonathan. “”. ''The Independent on Sunday'', 7 January 2007. Accessed 18 January 2007.</ref>. Holford has argued that the allegations result from “professional jealousy”, stating that "his girl hasn't suffered. She's got better and is behaving better. Her parents are delighted with the results. It's only Catherine Collins who is not." The Independent on Sunday have since clarified this story, noting that - when placed on a less restrictive diet - the girl was able to regain the weight she lost<ref></ref>. | ||
| ⚫ | Holford is also one of the main supporters of the hypothesis that there is a link between the ] and autism |
||
| The Cochrane Library's systematic review also concluded that the vaccine has prevented diseases that still carry a heavy burden of death and complications, and that the lack of confidence in the vaccine has damaged public health.<ref name=Cochrane>{{cite journal |doi=10.1002/14651858.CD004407.pub2 |pmid=16235361 |title= Vaccines for measles, mumps and rubella in children |author=Demicheli V, Jefferson T, Rivetti A, Price D |journal= Cochrane Database Syst Rev |year=2005 |volume=19 |issue=4 |laysummary=http://www.cochrane.org/press/MMR_final.pdf |laydate=2005-10-19 |laysource=Press release}}</ref> | The Cochrane Library's systematic review also concluded that the vaccine has prevented diseases that still carry a heavy burden of death and complications, and that the lack of confidence in the vaccine has damaged public health.<ref name=Cochrane>{{cite journal |doi=10.1002/14651858.CD004407.pub2 |pmid=16235361 |title= Vaccines for measles, mumps and rubella in children |author=Demicheli V, Jefferson T, Rivetti A, Price D |journal= Cochrane Database Syst Rev |year=2005 |volume=19 |issue=4 |laysummary=http://www.cochrane.org/press/MMR_final.pdf |laydate=2005-10-19 |laysource=Press release}}</ref> | ||
| ⚫ | Catherine Collins, chief ] at ], reported that - due to following Holford's advice to adopt a restricted diet - a young ] girl participating in one of Holford's experiments suffered dramatic weight loss and sleep problems <ref>Goodchild, Sophie and Owen, Jonathan. “”. ''The Independent on Sunday'', 7 January 2007. Accessed 18 January 2007.</ref>. Holford has argued that the allegations result from “professional jealousy”, stating that "his girl hasn't suffered. She's got better and is behaving better. Her parents are delighted with the results. It's only Catherine Collins who is not." The Independent on Sunday have since clarified this story, noting that - when placed on a less restrictive diet - the girl was able to regain the weight she lost<ref></ref>. | ||
| ⚫ | There has also been an adjudication by the ] against Patrick Holford's 100% Health leaflet. "On this point, the ad breached CAP Code clauses 3.1 (Substantiation), 7.1 (Truthfulness), 50.1 (Health & beauty products and therapies - General) and 50.20 (Health & beauty products and therapies - Vitamins, minerals and other food supplements)." | ||
| ===Miscellaneous === | |||
| ⚫ | <ref></ref> | ||
| ⚫ | A previous adjudication by the ASA also went against Mr Holford. | ||
| Holford has taken a number of other controversial stances, some of which might be considered{{Weasel-inline|date=May 2009}} ]. | |||
| ⚫ | <ref></ref> | ||
| * Holford calls ] the best marker of aging, claims that lowering your homocysteine will reduce all kinds of mortality and has even written a book on it.{{Fact|date=May 2009}} | |||
| * Holford endorses home-testing kits enthusiastically{{Clarify me|date=May 2009}}. {{Fact|date=May 2009}} | |||
| * Holford claims that high levels of ] are something to worry about and caused by foods such as dairy products.{{Fact|date=May 2009}} | |||
| == Books == | == Books == | ||
| Line 81: | Line 67: | ||
| * ''Smart Food for Smart Kids'' (2007) | * ''Smart Food for Smart Kids'' (2007) | ||
| * ''New Optimum Nutrition for the Mind'' (2007) | * ''New Optimum Nutrition for the Mind'' (2007) | ||
| * ''The Holford 9-Day Liver Detox'' ( |
* ''The Holford 9-Day Liver Detox'' (2008) | ||
| * ''Optimum Nutrition Made Easy: How to Achieve Optimum Health'' (2008) | |||
| * ''Optimum Nutrition For Your Child'' (2008) | |||
| * ''How to Quit without Feeling S**t: The Fast, Highly Effective Way to End Addiction to Caffeine, Sugar, Cigarettes, Alcohol, Illicit or Prescription Drugs'' (2008) | |||
| * ''Food Glorious Food: Incredibly Delicious Low-GL Recipes for Friends and Family'' (2008) | |||
| * ''The Low-GL Diet Bible by Patrick Holford'' (2009) | |||
| * ''The 10 Secrets of 100% Healthy People: Live Longer, Look Younger, Feel Great!'' (to be published in 2009) | |||
| * ''The Optimum Nutrition Perfect Pregnancy Plan: Recipes to Boost Your Fertility and Promote a Healthy Pregnancy'' (to be published in 2010) | |||
| == References == | == References == | ||
Revision as of 21:30, 29 May 2009
Patrick Holford is a British nutritionist, author, and the founder and director of the Institute for Optimum Nutrition in London. He is the Chief Executive Officer and co-founder (with Professor André Tylee of the Institute of Psychiatry) of the special interest group that developed into Food for the Brain Foundation, a registered charity which has the stated aim of promoting mental health through nutrition . He is also director of the Brain Bio Centre, which specializes in a nutrition-based approach to mental health problems. He appears regularly on television and radio in the UK.
His claims about HIV and autism are not in line with modern medical thought, and have been criticised as putting people in danger or damaging public health.
Career
Holford obtained a BSc in experimental psychology from the University of York in 1976. As a psychology student, he became interested in the biochemistry of mental health problems. His research brought him in contact with Dr Carl Pfeiffer and Dr Abram Hoffer, both of whom claimed success in treating mental illness with nutritional therapy. However, he did not graduate from the University of York until 1979, leading critics such as HolfordWatch to challenge the veracity of his CV.
In 1984, Holford founded the Institute for Optimum Nutrition (ION). At that institute, he has worked on nutritional approaches to clinical depression, schizophrenia, and eating disorders. In 1995, the Board of Trustees of ION (of which he was a director) awarded him an Honorary Diploma in Nutritional Therapy.
Holford is a Fellow of the British Association for Nutritional Therapy (BANT), one of a number of professional bodies that seek to represent nutritional therapists in the UK.
Criticism
HIV
Holford's claim in The New Optimum Nutrition Bible that "AZT, the first prescribable anti-HIV drug, is potentially harmful, and proving less effective than vitamin C" has been criticised by Ben Goldacre. Goldacre writes that Holford based this conclusion on a non-clinical study where "you tip lots of vitamin C onto HIV-infected cells and measure a few things related to HIV replication". Goldacre notes that the paper does not compare vitamin C to AZT for efficacy. He argues that "Holford was guilty of at least incompetence in claiming that this study demonstrated vitamin C to be a better treatment than AZT." Prof David Colquhoun argues that Holford's "advocacy of vitamin C as better than conventional drugs to treat Aids is truly scary".
Holford replied to The Guardian newspaper that:
"As well knows, the author of the research — Dr Raxit Jariwalla — wrote to the Guardian (January 20 2005) the last time Goldacre made this claim, to confirm that my statement is correct on the basis of two studies on HIV-infected cells. The real crime here is that no full-scale human trials have been funded on vitamin C to follow up Jariwalla's important finding because it is non-patentable and hence not profitable. Goldacre seems unconcerned about the way commercial interests distort scientific research."
Autism
Holford has also claimed that "We’ve learned about what it is that makes some kids develop autism and also how to bring them back." This directly contradicts organisations devoted to autism such as the Autism Society of America which says: "There is no known single cause for autism...Researchers are investigating a number of theories, including the link between heredity, genetics and medical problems." and the National Autistic Society which states: "There is currently no known 'cure' for autism."
Holford is also one of the main supporters of the hypothesis that there is a link between the MMR vaccine and autism. This is against the overwhelming opposition to the hypothesis by the scientific community. The Wakefield et al. paper upon which this hypothesis was based has been discredited by the scientific community and 10 of the 12 co-authors have formally retracted the paper. Furthermore, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences, the UK National Health Service and the Cochrane Library review have all concluded that there is no evidence of a link between the MMR vaccine and autism. (See MMR vaccine controversy)
The Cochrane Library's systematic review also concluded that the vaccine has prevented diseases that still carry a heavy burden of death and complications, and that the lack of confidence in the vaccine has damaged public health. Catherine Collins, chief dietician at St George's Hospital, reported that - due to following Holford's advice to adopt a restricted diet - a young autistic girl participating in one of Holford's experiments suffered dramatic weight loss and sleep problems . Holford has argued that the allegations result from “professional jealousy”, stating that "his girl hasn't suffered. She's got better and is behaving better. Her parents are delighted with the results. It's only Catherine Collins who is not." The Independent on Sunday have since clarified this story, noting that - when placed on a less restrictive diet - the girl was able to regain the weight she lost.
There has also been an adjudication by the Advertising Standards Authority against Patrick Holford's 100% Health leaflet. "On this point, the ad breached CAP Code clauses 3.1 (Substantiation), 7.1 (Truthfulness), 50.1 (Health & beauty products and therapies - General) and 50.20 (Health & beauty products and therapies - Vitamins, minerals and other food supplements)." A previous adjudication by the ASA also went against Mr Holford.
Books
- The Family Nutrition Workbook (1988)
- The Whole Health Manual: Comprehensive Guide to Nutrition and Better Health (1988)
- The Better Pregnancy Diet: The Definitive Guide to Having a Healthy Baby (1993)
- The Optimum Nutrition Bible (1997)
- Say No to Heart Disease (1998)
- Boost Your Immune System (1998)
- Balancing Hormones Naturally (1998)
- 30-Day Fatburner Diet (1999)
- 100% Health (1999)
- Beat Stress and Fatigue (1999)
- Say No to Cancer (1999)
- The Optimum Nutrition Cookbook (1999)
- Improve Your Digestion (2000)
- Say No to Arthritis (2000)
- Supplements for Superhealth (2000)
- Solve Your Skin Problems (2001)
- Six Weeks to Superhealth (2002)
- Optimum Nutrition for the Mind (2002)
- Natural Highs: Chill - 25 Ways to Stay Relaxed and Beat Stress (2003)
- Natural Highs: Energy - 25 Ways to Increase Your Energy (2003)
- The H Factor - Homocysteine - the biggest breakthrough of the century (2003)
- Boost Your Child's Immune System (2003)
- 500 Health and Nutrition Questions Answered (2004)
- New Optimum Nutrition Bible (2004)
- Optimum Nutrition Before, During and After Pregnancy (2004)
- The Alzheimer's Prevention Plan (2005)
- The Holford Low-GL Diet (2005)
- The Holford Low-GL Diet Cookbook (2005)
- Hidden Food Allergies (2005)
- The Holford Diet GL Counter (2006)
- The Holford Low-GL Diet Made Easy (2006)
- Optimum Nutrition For Your Child's Mind (2006)
- Food is Better Medicine Than Drugs (2006)
- Smart Food for Smart Kids (2007)
- New Optimum Nutrition for the Mind (2007)
- The Holford 9-Day Liver Detox (2008)
References
- ^ Holford, Patrick. Patrick Holford: Profile. patrickholford.com. Accessed 6 January 2007.
- The British Association of Nutrition Therapy, “About BANT”. Accessed 7 January 2007
- Holford, Patrick. The New Optimum Nutrition Bible, Chapter 24. Accessed 19 March 2007.
- ^ Goldacre, Ben. “Vitamin deficiency”. The Guardian, 6 January 2005. Accessed 6 January 2007.
- ^ Goldacre, Ben. “Working papers”. The Guardian, 20 January 2005. Accessed 6 January 2007.
- Holford, Patrick. Letter to The Guardian, 16 February 2007. Accessed 19 March 2007.
- Jariwalla, Raxit. Letter to The Guardian, 20 January 2005. Accessed 19 March 2007.
- Demicheli V, Jefferson T, Rivetti A, Price D (2005). "Vaccines for measles, mumps and rubella in children". Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 19 (4). doi:10.1002/14651858.CD004407.pub2. PMID 16235361.
{{cite journal}}: Unknown parameter|laydate=ignored (help); Unknown parameter|laysource=ignored (help); Unknown parameter|laysummary=ignored (help)CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - Goodchild, Sophie and Owen, Jonathan. “Doctors warn against food fad dangers”. The Independent on Sunday, 7 January 2007. Accessed 18 January 2007.
- Doctors warn against food fad dangers - a clarification
- ASA 2007 Judgement
- ASA 2003 Judgement
External links
- Patrick Holford's Website
- Food for the Brain
- The Brain Bio Centre
- Ben Goldacre's blog posts on Patrick Holford
- HolfordWatch, a critical blog
- HolfordMyths, an offshoot of Holford's main site providing answers to some of his criticisms