| Revision as of 10:59, 7 August 2009 editAtrix20 (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users2,781 edits both links are dead. Also, yes there IS dispute over it. Don't try to pretend there is not← Previous edit | Revision as of 11:17, 7 August 2009 edit undoTiamut (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers31,614 edits you want sources? are you entirely unfamiliar with the literature on this subject? or hopelessly POV - bring your own sources denying they are a "national liberation movement" - the world disagrees with youNext edit → | ||
| Line 55: | Line 55: | ||
| * Many ] and foreign observers consider the ] and ]s to be wars of national liberation against ].<ref>] (2005), ''Chechnya: From Past to Future'', p. 208. Anthem Press, ISBN 184331164X, 9781843311645</ref><ref>Evangelista, Matthew (2002), The Chechen wars: will Russia go the way of the Soviet Union?, p. 142. Brookings Institution Press, ISBN 0815724985, 9780815724988</ref><ref>Dunlop, John B. (1998), ''Russia Confronts Chechnya'', p. 93. ], ISBN 0521636191, 9780521636193</ref> | * Many ] and foreign observers consider the ] and ]s to be wars of national liberation against ].<ref>] (2005), ''Chechnya: From Past to Future'', p. 208. Anthem Press, ISBN 184331164X, 9781843311645</ref><ref>Evangelista, Matthew (2002), The Chechen wars: will Russia go the way of the Soviet Union?, p. 142. Brookings Institution Press, ISBN 0815724985, 9780815724988</ref><ref>Dunlop, John B. (1998), ''Russia Confronts Chechnya'', p. 93. ], ISBN 0521636191, 9780521636193</ref> | ||
| * Some Iraqi insurgent groups, and certain political groups believe that the ] is a war of national liberation against the US-led ]. | * Some Iraqi insurgent groups, and certain political groups believe that the ] is a war of national liberation against the US-led ]. | ||
| * Described as "the best-known national liberation movement," the ] (PLO) was granted permanent observer status by the ] in 1974, also participating in UN Security Council debates, a privilege usually accorded only to states.<ref name=Boczekp86>{{cite book|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=NR7mFXCB-wgC&pg=PA86&dq=%22national+liberation+movement%22+UN+PLO#v=onepage&q=%22national%20liberation%20movement%22%20UN%20PLO&f=false|page=p. 86|title=International law: a dictionary|author=Boleslaw Adam Boczek|publisher=Scarecrow Press|year=2005|ISBN=0810850788, 9780810850781}}</ref> The PLO is the only non-African national liberation movement to hold observer status in the ].<ref name=Shultp100>{{cite book|url=http://books.google.ca/books?id=wtebWixsIdYC&pg=PA100&dq=%22national+liberation+movement%22+UN+PLO#v=onepage&q=%22national%20liberation%20movement%22%20UN%20PLO&f=false|title=The Soviet Union and revolutionary warfare: principles, practices, and regional comparisons|author=Richard H. Shultz|publisher=Hoover Press|year=1988|ISBN=0817987118, 9780817987114}}</ref> | |||
| * Some think that the ] (PLO), dubbed "the official representative of the ]", which was granted observer status in the ] in 1974.<ref>{{cite web|title=Security Council|publisher=WorldMUN2007 - ]|date=26 March - 30 March 2007|accessdate=2007-07-31|url=http://www.worldmun.org/MUNBase2007/files/downloads/guides/SCGuideA.pdf |format=PDF}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |title=Sovereignty Is No Longer Sacrosanct:Codifying Humanitarian Intervention|author=Jarat Chopra et al.|publisher=Humanitarianism and War Project|accessdate=2007-08-21|url=http://hwproject.tufts.edu/publications/electronic/e_sinls.html}}</ref> However, the contention of being a liberation movement is extremely controversial, due to its goals initially of destroying another sovereign state to achieve "liberation." | |||
| * The ] has sought the independence of ] since 1975 and considered its guerilla war against Morocco as national liberation war, while Morocco considered it a ] movement. The hostilities are frozen since the 1991 cease-fire following the settlement plan agreement. | * The ] has sought the independence of ] since 1975 and considered its guerilla war against Morocco as national liberation war, while Morocco considered it a ] movement. The hostilities are frozen since the 1991 cease-fire following the settlement plan agreement. | ||
| * As a result of the ], a group of ethnic-Albanian politicians in ] declared (on ] ]) an independent "Republic of Kosovo" from the ]'s ]. After the dissolution of SFRY, an unofficial referendum was held for independence in 1992 that passed and began a conflict between the Albanian separatists led by the ] and the Yugoslav military and paramilitary armed forces. This lasted until 1999 when a peace was brokered and the province came under ] under the terms of UNSCR 1244. International negotiations between ] and ] are in progress on the future status of Kosovo. The conflict would only count as a war of national liberation if you exclude the fact that an Albanian state already exists, and that ethnic-Albanians in Kosovo seek their own separate nationhood.{{fact|date=April 2009}} | * As a result of the ], a group of ethnic-Albanian politicians in ] declared (on ] ]) an independent "Republic of Kosovo" from the ]'s ]. After the dissolution of SFRY, an unofficial referendum was held for independence in 1992 that passed and began a conflict between the Albanian separatists led by the ] and the Yugoslav military and paramilitary armed forces. This lasted until 1999 when a peace was brokered and the province came under ] under the terms of UNSCR 1244. International negotiations between ] and ] are in progress on the future status of Kosovo. The conflict would only count as a war of national liberation if you exclude the fact that an Albanian state already exists, and that ethnic-Albanians in Kosovo seek their own separate nationhood.{{fact|date=April 2009}} | ||
Revision as of 11:17, 7 August 2009
Wars of national liberation are conflicts fought by indigenous military groups against an imperial power in the name of self-determination, thus attempting to remove that power's influence, in particular during the decolonization period. They are often founded in guerrilla warfare or asymmetric warfare, sometimes with intervention from other states.
According to political scientist Gérard Chaliand, guerrilla wars against European colonial powers were always a political success, although they may have been in some cases a military defeat. However, according to Gwynne Dyer, the tactics and strategies used against colonial powers were almost invariably failures when used against indigenous regimes.
Such wars were supported by the Soviet Union, which claimed to be an anti-imperialist power and by communist parties worldwide. In January 1961 Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev pledged support for "wars of national liberation" throughout the world.
In fact, since the 1917 October Revolution, the revolutionary objectives of communism were shared by many anticolonialist leaders, thus explaining the objective alliance between anticolonialist forces and Marxism. The concept of "imperialism" itself had been which had theorized in Lenin's famous 1916 book, Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism. For example, Ho Chi Minh — who founded the Viet-Minh in 1930 and declared the independence of Vietnam on September 2, 1945, following the 1945 August Revolution — was a founding member of the French Communist Party (PCF) in 1921.
Legal Issues
International law generally holds that a people with a legal right to self-determination are entitled to wage wars of national liberation. While Western states tend to view wars of national liberation as civil wars, Third World and communist states tend to view them as international wars. This difference in classification leads to varying perceptions of which laws of war apply in such situations. However, there is general agreement among all states today in principle that the use of force to frustrate a people's legal right to self-determination is unlawful.
History
Maccabean Revolt
The Maccabean Revolt (167 BC-160 BC) was a war of national liberation fought by the "Judean peasantry." It secured the independence of the Jewish Hasmonean kingdom from the Seleucid Empire.
First Jewish–Roman War
The First Jewish–Roman War (66-73 BC) was a war of national liberation. Jewish freedom fighters attempted to liberate the Jewish people in Judea from occupation by the Roman empire. The effort failed.
Bar Kokhba revolt
The Bar Kokhba revolt of 132-135 BC was a war of national liberation fought to free the Jewish people from the oppressive Roman Empire.
Decolonization of the Americas
Main articles: Decolonization of the Americas and South American Wars of IndependenceFollowing the American War of Independence (1775-1783), the Haitian Revolution (1791-1804), which led to the proclamation of Haiti as the first independent black republic in 1804, and the South American wars of independence from Spain led in the 1810-1820s by famous Libertadores such as Simón Bolívar in North and José de San Martín in the South, led to the decolonization of most of the Americas. Brazil's independence was declared in 1822 by Dom Pedro I.
The Greek War of Independence
The Greek War of Independence, (1821–1829,) was fought to liberate Greece from a centuries-long Ottoman occupation. Independence was secured by the intervention of a combined British-French fleet at the Battle of Navarino.
Irish War of Independence
The Irish War of Independence of 1919-1921 led to the independence of most of Ireland (26 counties out of 32).
First Indochinese War
The First Indochina War (1946-54,) secured the independence of Vietnam from French imperial domination, although liberation from the French was sought as far back as the 1920s by the Viet Quoc.
Africa
The Algerian War of Independence (1954-62) was one of the most famous national liberation wars. The African National Congress (ANC)'s struggle against the apartheid regime is also part of these wars.
Cuba, led by Fidel Castro, supported national liberation movements in Angola and Mozambique.
The Portuguese colonial wars finally led to the recognition of Angola, Mozambique and Guinea-Bissau as independent states in 1975, following the April Carnation Revolution.
China
Attempts to break free of Chinese Imperialism, whether in the Imperial of Communist era, have generally proven unsuccessful. The Panthay Rebellion]] of 1856-1873) succeeded in expelling the Qing Dynasty and establishing a Sultanate of the Muslim Hui people in what is now southwestern Yunnan Province, but the Qing managed a successful re-conquest.
A revolt broke out in Tibet in 1959 against the Communist rule, but the region has not experienced large-scale rebellion since then.
On-going national liberation conflicts
The following current conflicts have sometimes been characterized as wars or struggles of national liberation (such a designation is often subject to controversy):
- Many Chechens and foreign observers consider the First and Second Chechen Wars to be wars of national liberation against Russia.
- Some Iraqi insurgent groups, and certain political groups believe that the Iraq War is a war of national liberation against the US-led coalition.
- Described as "the best-known national liberation movement," the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) was granted permanent observer status by the United Nations General Assembly in 1974, also participating in UN Security Council debates, a privilege usually accorded only to states. The PLO is the only non-African national liberation movement to hold observer status in the Organization of African States.
- The Polisario Front has sought the independence of Western Sahara since 1975 and considered its guerilla war against Morocco as national liberation war, while Morocco considered it a secessionist movement. The hostilities are frozen since the 1991 cease-fire following the settlement plan agreement.
- As a result of the politics of the former Yugoslavia, a group of ethnic-Albanian politicians in Kosovo declared (on 2 July 1990) an independent "Republic of Kosovo" from the Republic of Serbia's Autonomous Province of Kosovo and Metohija. After the dissolution of SFRY, an unofficial referendum was held for independence in 1992 that passed and began a conflict between the Albanian separatists led by the Kosovo Liberation Army and the Yugoslav military and paramilitary armed forces. This lasted until 1999 when a peace was brokered and the province came under UN administration under the terms of UNSCR 1244. International negotiations between Pristina and Belgrade are in progress on the future status of Kosovo. The conflict would only count as a war of national liberation if you exclude the fact that an Albanian state already exists, and that ethnic-Albanians in Kosovo seek their own separate nationhood.
References
- See for example Gérard Chaliand various books; French interview here.
- ^ Malanczuk, 1997, p. 336.
- Bandits, Prophets, and Messiahs: Popular Movements in the Time of Jesus, By Richard A. Horsley, John S. Hanson, Continuum International Publishing Group, 1999, p. 22
- History of the Second Temple Period, Paolo Sacchi, Continuum International Publishing Group, 2004, p. 239
- Between Rome and Jerusalem: 300 Years of Roman-Judaean Relations, Martin Sicker, Greenwood Publishing Group, 2001, p. x
- Law, Politics, and Morality in Judaism, Michael Walzer, Princeton University Press, 2006, p. 154
- The Chinese Sultanate, Atwill, David G.. Stanford University Press, 2005
- Sakwa, Richard (2005), Chechnya: From Past to Future, p. 208. Anthem Press, ISBN 184331164X, 9781843311645
- Evangelista, Matthew (2002), The Chechen wars: will Russia go the way of the Soviet Union?, p. 142. Brookings Institution Press, ISBN 0815724985, 9780815724988
- Dunlop, John B. (1998), Russia Confronts Chechnya, p. 93. Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0521636191, 9780521636193
- Boleslaw Adam Boczek (2005). International law: a dictionary. Scarecrow Press. p. p. 86. ISBN 0810850788, 9780810850781.
{{cite book}}:|page=has extra text (help); Check|isbn=value: invalid character (help) - Richard H. Shultz (1988). The Soviet Union and revolutionary warfare: principles, practices, and regional comparisons. Hoover Press. ISBN 0817987118, 9780817987114.
{{cite book}}: Check|isbn=value: invalid character (help)
External links
Bibliography
- Malanczuk (1997), AKEHURST'S MODERN INTRODUCTION TO INTERNATIONAL LAW, Routledge, ISBN 041511120X, 9780415111201
{{citation}}: Check|isbn=value: invalid character (help); More than one of|author=and|last=specified (help)
See also
- List of historical autonomist and secessionist movements
- List of active autonomist and secessionist movements
- List of unrecognized countries
- List of decolonized nations
- War of Independence
- Independence
- Colonialism & chronology of colonialism
- Civil war
- Guerrilla warfare
- Insurgency and counter-insurgency
- Hukbalahap
- Peninsular War
- Clausewitz's On War (1832) ("war is the continuation of politics by other means")
- Colonialism