| Revision as of 16:06, 19 January 2009 editLilHelpa (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers413,638 editsm spelling: commision -> commission← Previous edit | Revision as of 00:23, 14 August 2009 edit undoJohnbod (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Extended confirmed users, IP block exemptions, Rollbackers280,384 edits no theNext edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| ] | ] | ||
| '''Julius Frederik Macody Lund''' (born ] ] in ], died ] ] in ]) was a controversial ] ], most known and remembered for his engagement in the restoration of |
'''Julius Frederik Macody Lund''' (born ] ] in ], died ] ] in ]) was a controversial ] ], most known and remembered for his engagement in the restoration of ]. | ||
| When architect ] presented his ideas for a restoration of the west section and the west front, an alternative idea was published by Macody Lund, introducing the ] and the rose window, both of these were ideas that were included in ]'s 1907 plan for the cathedral's restoration. | When architect ] presented his ideas for a restoration of the west section and the west front, an alternative idea was published by Macody Lund, introducing the ] and the rose window, both of these were ideas that were included in ]'s 1907 plan for the cathedral's restoration. | ||
| In 1915 Macody Lund published his theory that |
In 1915 Macody Lund published his theory that ] was constructed on the basis of the ideas of the ]. He found support for this idea in the Norwegian parliament, the ], and got funding from the parliament in order to develop an alternative proposal for the restoration of the west section and the west front, in competition with Nordhagen's work. This "system controversies" led to great delays in the work at the cathedral, as no work could be done before this dispute was settled. Macody Lund published his views in ''Ad Quadratum'' (1919). The dispute was settled in 1922, when an international experts commission rejected Macody Lund's theories, and Stortinget in 1923 decided to continue the cathedral's restoration based on Nordhagen's plan. The commission's verdict was, however, without a full argumentation. Macody Lund thus saw an opportunity to continue his argument, which he published in ''Ad Quadratum II: Dom med præmisser over den internasjonale domskommissions dom uten præmisser'' (1928) (translation: ''A verdict with premises on the international experts commission's verdict without premises''). | ||
| He was given a ''Lifetime government grant'' in 1929. | He was given a ''Lifetime government grant'' in 1929. | ||
Revision as of 00:23, 14 August 2009
Julius Frederik Macody Lund (born November 18 1863 in Stavanger, died December 16 1943 in Farsund) was a controversial Norwegian historian, most known and remembered for his engagement in the restoration of Nidaros Cathedral.
When architect Christian Christie presented his ideas for a restoration of the west section and the west front, an alternative idea was published by Macody Lund, introducing the screenfront and the rose window, both of these were ideas that were included in Olaf Nordhagen's 1907 plan for the cathedral's restoration.
In 1915 Macody Lund published his theory that Nidaros Cathedral was constructed on the basis of the ideas of the golden ratio. He found support for this idea in the Norwegian parliament, the Stortinget, and got funding from the parliament in order to develop an alternative proposal for the restoration of the west section and the west front, in competition with Nordhagen's work. This "system controversies" led to great delays in the work at the cathedral, as no work could be done before this dispute was settled. Macody Lund published his views in Ad Quadratum (1919). The dispute was settled in 1922, when an international experts commission rejected Macody Lund's theories, and Stortinget in 1923 decided to continue the cathedral's restoration based on Nordhagen's plan. The commission's verdict was, however, without a full argumentation. Macody Lund thus saw an opportunity to continue his argument, which he published in Ad Quadratum II: Dom med præmisser over den internasjonale domskommissions dom uten præmisser (1928) (translation: A verdict with premises on the international experts commission's verdict without premises).
He was given a Lifetime government grant in 1929.
References
- Seland, J.: Macody Lund. Et hjerte i en kruttønne., 1971 (in norwegian).