Revision as of 20:50, 3 August 2011 editDeepdish7 (talk | contribs)884 edits removed vandalism again← Previous edit | Revision as of 20:52, 3 August 2011 edit undoDeepdish7 (talk | contribs)884 editsm removed vandalism againNext edit → | ||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{About|the Russian businessman|the Russian pianist|Boris Berezovsky (pianist)}} | |||
{{WPBiography | |||
|living=yes | |||
{{Infobox person | |||
|class=Start | |||
|name = Boris Berezovsky | |||
|politician-work-group=yes | |||
|image = Boris Berezovsky.jpg | |||
|listas=Berezovsky, Boris | |||
|image_size = 150px | |||
|caption=Boris Berezovsky, 2007 | |||
|birth_date = {{Birth date and age|1946|1|23}} | |||
|birth_place = Moscow, ] | |||
}} | }} | ||
{{POV|date=July 2011}} | |||
{{WikiProject Russia|class=Start|importance=high|pol=yes|econ=yes}} | |||
'''Boris Abramovich Berezovsky''' ({{lang-ru|Бори́с Абра́мович Березо́вский}}; also known as '''Platon Elenin'''; born January 23, 1946) is a ] businessman, ], member of ], who was accused of numerous crimes in Russia and sentenced to several years of imprisonment in absentia. Despite the fact that arrest warrant has been issued to Interpol by Russian and Brazilian authorities, Berezovsky is currently a political ] in Britain, that refused to extradition requests from Russia several times so far. | |||
{{oldpeerreview|archive=1}} | |||
I edited the lead section (which took me six hours) to address some of the criticisms below, ridding it of biased, contentious and potentially libelous statements, removing non-functional and questionable sources, and adding some reliable references to mainstream Western media. Major work is needed on the body of the article to make it compliant with ] and the policy on BLP. Not sure, if I will have time and energy. Readers beware: this remains an exceedingly opinionated and misleading text.--] (]) 02:04, 24 July 2011 (UTC) | |||
I added info to the stub, but all of it is from memory of news articles I've read over the years. It needs fact and date checking. Names of the companies and other industries that Berezovsky invested in would be helpful. | |||
I changed "the most notorious of Russian oligarchs" to "most famous". I don't think there'll be any complaints about that perfect example of bias being removed. | |||
: In the previous version of this page it was written "Berezovsky was born in Moscow into a Jewish family", now just "Berezovsky was born in Moscow". Why have you deleted "jewish family"? Do you think it's a shame or what? | |||
== Deleted excess info == | |||
This was a stand-alone sentence in the "convictions, warrents" section: | |||
"Prosecutors in Russia have accused Berezovsky of a host of crimes, including ], embezzlement and preparing a violent overthrow of Putin's government. Berezovsky denies all the allegations." | |||
The subsection was also entitled "Warrents in Russia and Brazil". This hardly seems necessary, since there's already a section detailing the Russian convictions in detail just a few lines up - why say it again here? The Brazil stuff is good, though, and is not repetitive, so I just changed the title to say "Brazil" only, and deleted the extraneous sentence about Russia. Anyone got a problem with that?] (]) 13:56, 6 January 2009 (UTC) | |||
== Oligarchy? == | |||
What of this "oligarchy?" Who is in it besides Berezovsky and ]? When were they exiled? - ] ] <small>(])</small> 18:32, 25 November 2006 (UTC) | |||
I think that the question, "(Please clarify - what is a rally standpoint shootoff?)" is a valid one, though it must be posted in the talk page instead of in the article itself.] 12:27, 3 December 2006 (UTC) | |||
:Litvinenko was not an oligarch! The term "Oligarchs" in Russia is used in reference to the few people who gained control of the majority of the national wealth after privatization in the early 1990s following the collapse of the Soveit Union. Roman Abramovich and Boris Berezovsky are prime examples. Litvinenko is nothing even close to that. He wasn't even moderately wealthy - he lived on Berezovsky's handouts. | |||
==NPOV & sources== | |||
The tone of this article appears to contravene Misplaced Pages's ] policy, & I have added templates to that effect. There are whole sentences like "Berezovsky's image among Russians is generally poor; many consider him the most unlawful and unethical of the oligarchs and blame him especially for the country's economic collapse", which require references and neutral rephrasing. There are many further minor examples. | |||
I have made a few small changes to the article to move it towards NPOV but lots more needs to be done. I don't want to edit out all the information here, because I believe some of it might be useful with a proper encyclopedic style edit and some decent citations behind it. -- ] 23:48, 25 November 2006 (UTC) | |||
:From my own anecdotal evidence, that paragraph which you quoted is quite true. I'm not sure how it is POV to mention the general opinion among Russian citizens about him. I do agree that some acceptable source needs to be found for it, though. ] 03:28, 28 November 2006 (UTC) | |||
::Mainly, it's not POV if it's sourced or attributed. But I would probably have doubts about statements like "the most unlawful and unethical of the oligarchs" even if it is sourced. How is such a thing to be measured? Are there open, reliable opinion polls of the Russian people in which it is asked "Which oligarch do you consider to be the most unethical?" Surely it's a case of ]. Russia contains something like 150 million people and I doubt that any generalisation of their opinions would be useful or indeed possible. If there is reasonable evidence that Berezovsky is unethical, or specific allegations from a reliable source, let's have that rather than hearsay. -- ] 13:41, 28 November 2006 (UTC) | |||
:I edited out the unsourced POV material, if any sourcing can be found it should be restored -- J.L. 07:28, 28 November 2006 (UTC) | |||
::According to The Wall Street Journal, an opinion poll found that only 0.2 percent of Russians trust Boris. Unfortunately, WSJ archives are closed up unless you give them $ though. Aside from that, I haven't found any polls more recent than 2002 and in that poll it didn't show that many of those polled really disliked Boris. So, unless someone can get at that poll the WSJ is talking about, I think we are still without sources for now. If someone can find the time to dig further I think it would benefit the article greatly to get a better idea of what the general Russian populace really thinks of Boris. I'm getting conflicting results from my limited research so far. ] 16:43, 11 February 2007 (UTC) | |||
:::You can still add the WSJ poll as a source if you know all the relevant information on how to find it. Misplaced Pages accepts payolla sources; the only condition is that they must exist ''somewhere''. Lest we forget, there are still such things as libraries in the world. A source doesn't have to be accessible online. Also, if you can find a reliable article that talks about the poll, you don't necessarily have to link to the actual poll. ] 05:46, 2 April 2007 (UTC) | |||
It is widely known that Berezovsky doesn't have a 'generally poor' image amongst the Russians, but it is an 'abysmal' image. Anyone looking for sources to back up such statements and for inclusive in wikipedia might want to start at http://www.fom.ru/ --] 17:43, 19 April 2007 (UTC) | |||
There are still problems here; there is a whole unsourced section about a living man that essentially brands him as a crook and a liar. That may be true, but since the Litvinenko poisoning, and , I vote for removing unsourced material and placing an edit lock on this article. This could be a first for wikipedia, insofar as there is a distinct possibility of it being used as a basic propaganda tool in a heated diplomatic exchange amid a spate of international assasination attempts. Real cloak and dagger stuff -- but wikipedia does not exist in a vacuum. (anonymous norwegian, 13:21, 18 July 2007 CET) | |||
The problems in the "Business and Political Life in Russia" section persist, and I'm almost in favor of just scratching those first two paragraphs, as there's but one source between them, and they make some controversial, clearly pointed claims about Boris, including two unsourced "allegedly"'s. The bit about his activity in Yeltsin's re-election campaign also should be cited, though this is well-documented, I'll try and dig up an appropriate reference, but the other allegations need some backing, or they'll be deleted forthwith. ] (]) 13:15, 6 January 2009 (UTC) | |||
I removed the statement "According to some sources, Berezovsky was also initially involved in car ] rackets.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.amazon.com/Tycoon-New-Russian-Vladimir-Mashkov/product-reviews/B0001LJCAW |title=Customer Reviews: Tycoon – A New Russian |publisher=Amazon.com |accessdate=14 May 2011}}</ref>" The reference here is a reader comment on Amazon to a film, which is a work of fiction - a totally inappropriate source. | |||
== Platon is Russian for Plato == | |||
Platon is Russian for Plato and it is also Greek for Plato. I think in the context here | |||
(a Russian changing his name) that it is more relevent to note that Platon is a Russian word. | |||
==Unsourced accusation of murder in BLP== | |||
Alex, could you please copy here a segment of text from cited article that accuses Berezovsky of organizing murder of Khlebnikov? | |||
I found only the following: | |||
"Soon after Vladimir Putin stepped into the presidency, Klebnikov and I met in New York. I told him he needed to watch his back with so much change afoot. He shrugged and said he was uniquely positioned to get to the heart of corruption in Russia. "Who else is going to do it?" he asked. I had no answer. | |||
When Forbes announced Klebnikov would lead its new Russian publication and relocate to Moscow, I immediately feared for his safety. A few months later he was dead. I think about him, sprawled bleeding on the sidewalk, coughing his final words to a reporter colleague who found him dying. | |||
Russia hasn't changed in the past decade and at this trajectory it won't be truly civilized for generations. Those who killed Klebnikov are killing today, plan to kill tomorrow, and know they'll roam free to kill for years to come. Hellbent on getting rich, they have no boundaries. Raised in a communist world devoid of morals, they have no soul." | |||
There are no any accusations of Berezovsky here.] 17:38, 24 July 2007 (UTC) | |||
May be you mean the following segment in the Introductory part: | |||
"Had I run across billionaire Boris Berezovsky in my work with the Yeltsin administration? I hadn't. Klebnikov had recently been scratching the surface of Berezovsky's brazen get-rich-quick schemes. He was convinced there was much more to the oligarch. He was in town to investigate him as well as to cover the elections. | |||
Berezovsky was one of several super-wealthy men who had back doors to Yeltsin's Kremlin. His popularity waxed and waned, but as he amassed wealth he gained unparalleled power. Experienced expatriates in Russia shared an essential rule: Don't cross these brutal billionaires, ever, or you're likely to go home in a box." | |||
Here, author only tells that Russian oligarchs are dangerous. His conclusion is summarized in the end of the article: "Those who killed Klebnikov are killing today, plan to kill tomorrow, and know they'll roam free to kill for years to come. Hellbent on getting rich, they have no boundaries. Raised in a communist world devoid of morals, they have no soul." Right. Please see the ] and ].] 17:56, 24 July 2007 (UTC) | |||
== comment == | |||
{{cquote|He is one of the principal financial resources for civic groups and anti-Putin opposition through his ].}} | |||
This passage isn't quite true imho. I don't know of mainstream opposition (democratic or not) parties that are supported by him. Moreover Kasparov and Kasyanov explicitly denied receiving such support . ]<sub>]</sub> 05:03, 19 January 2008 (UTC) | |||
He's widely believed to have heavily funded the opposition party in Ukraine's 2004 Orange Revolution, and personally has declined comment on the issue. There are clear financial records of his transferring money to companies that then sponsored the party, however. It's going to be tough to prove, as foreigners cannot contribute to any campaign under Ukrainian law - hence anyone doing so would, of necessity, be thoroughly discreet about it. This doesn't change the fact that there's a general consensus that he did support the revolution through use of IFCL, though. Furthermore, he HAS been very vocal in his public opposition to Putin, so it should come as no surprise that he's involved in this sort of thing.] (]) 13:20, 6 January 2009 (UTC) | |||
== Dagestan war == | |||
{{cquote|Berezovsky '''asserted that he refused the offer, but "] and ] conspired''' with ] and ] to provoke a war to topple Maskhadov..., but the agreement was for the Russian army to stop at the ]. However, Putin double-crossed the Chechens and started an all-out war" <ref name="Dissident"/>. A transcript of the phone conversation between Berezovsky and Udugov was leaked to one of Moscow tabloids on September 10 ]. <ref> "Death of a Dissident", page 189.</ref>}} | |||
What is this supposed to mean? If Basayev-Stepashin conspiracy is something that Berezovsky 'asserted' then it should be written more clearly. If Berezovsky only asserted he refused the offer then all the following is irrelevant to this article imho. ]<sub>]</sub> 09:16, 6 February 2008 (UTC) | |||
:This direct citation is taken from the book by Goldfarb. This is not a direct citation of Berezovsky words. That is what Berezovsky said to Goldfarb. He said two things: (1) that he refused the offer (it could be described in more detail why and what exactly was the offer), and (2) about the conspiracy. He also said a lot of other things of course.] (]) 16:19, 6 February 2008 (UTC) | |||
:: Oh, I see. Sorry, I've missed the citation marks somehow... ]<sub>]</sub> 16:26, 6 February 2008 (UTC) | |||
== "Converts from Judaism to Christianity" == | |||
What evidence is there that he was ever a practicing Jew? He was most likely a secular person as was dictated by the Soviet government. Unless you can prove Mr Berezovsky wore a ] and went to ] prior to becoming ], I'm removing him from this category. | |||
] (]) 05:41, 14 February 2008 (UTC) | |||
:I agree. This is OR and should be removed.] (]) 05:58, 14 February 2008 (UTC) | |||
And while I'm at it, I'm removing him from the "Israeli Jews" category because by Israeli Law he is not a Jew (because his mother's mother is not a Jew and because he converted to Christianity, he would not have "Jew" printed on his identity card or be counted as a Jew in the census). ] (]) 01:56, 29 March 2008 (UTC) | |||
== Netherlands money laundering investigation == | |||
Now this is a bit awkward. It is true that the Dutch financial police sent people to Russia to investigate what the Russians had on Berezovsky. However, as soon as the news was published in the Russian media, the Dutch government immediately claimed that Berezovsky was NOT being prosecuted or even a suspect in the Netherlands. | |||
Again however, things are not as not as simple as that: the Dutch financial police are indeed investigating some major handling (="heling") or money laundering (="witwassen") scheme, and Berezovski is indeed mentioned in the dossier. (It took me a hell of a time to find that out, but here is a respectable source in Dutch: ). Basically, that coupled with the "démarche" to Russia (one may think that the Dutch would normally find Berezovsky too hot a potato to handle) means that the Dutch DA (="Openbaar Ministerie") is not expecting to prosecute Berezovsky and the belief by some Russian media (one of which we quote here) that Berezovsky may also be put on trial (trail is a rather funny msiprint...) in the Netherlands, is probably (=almost surely) wishful thinking. | |||
The problem with our article as it stands now, is that if we just change that, everybody having read the whole article, may think the Dutch must be doing it to help out Brazil. But that is not necessarily the case: e.g. Berezovsky seems still being investigated by the Swiss Bundesanwaltschaft: | |||
and (German wikipedia's Berezovsky article is also claiming the Swiss investigation continues!) In view of this, I think it may be preferable to combine the Brazilian accusation and this Dutch "angle" with the Swiss accusation into one new major heading (replacing the Brazilian and Dutch headings) on "International money laundering charges". The Weltwoche article also mentions Swiss financier ] and ]. --] (]) 15:17, 26 February 2008 (UTC) | |||
::Done. As a last edit, I added "involving Berezovsky" to the sentence about the Moscow Prosecutor. Without it, it looked like the Russian and Dutch journalists had been working together to embarass the Dutch prosecuting officials (I wanted to put that in my edit summary, but somehow it ended up being uploaded in an imperfect way, a version I was still editing to save text to say more). But that is not what happened: the Russian journalists heard something factual from the Moscow DA about Berezovsky, and embellished it to imply that he was also being investigated in the Netherlands (here I interpret "on trail" as "under investigation", "being prosecuted" or searched, like game or escaped prisoners being "trailed", and not as a misprint for "on trial" - but if Russian editors have arguments otherwise, no problem). The Dutch DA soon intervened to deny everything the Russian media had claimed, but Dutch newspapers soon found out that he/she had been denying too much: the name '''is''' mentioned in the dossier and the investigating team had gone to Moscow to find out what the Berezovsky case in Russia was about. (to know how much money was involved? to understand how the Russians think the moneylaundering was done?) | |||
::The Dutch Prosecutors denied to comment in order not to hinder the investigation at hand. Are they after inhabitants of the Netherlands who performed financial transactions in that country on behalf of the Jenni firms? =OR, of course. Further OR: if Berezovsky has no account in the Netherlands, as he claims, the Dutch FIOD is not going to prosecute him, the Russian media at least got that wrong. I do not know what Brazilian law says about it, but the problem for prosecutors in an international case like this is obviously "non bis in idem". Even Russia has a law on it: Why should the Dutch go after someone already targeted by three other countries? ---] (]) 16:58, 3 March 2008 (UTC) | |||
== WP:BLP and Berezovsky == | |||
not my work but I don't like as well. Could you please explain why ] doesn't allow us to say about his political affiliation with Litvinenko & Co. and about the charges against him (considering that everything that was/is written there is sourced well)? ]<sub>]</sub> 20:08, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:"Litvinenko & Co" is not a political affiliation like "Communist Party". We need a balanced introduction per ]. The selective representation of only negative information in introduction of BLP is not acceptable. We can not simply tell about charges, without explaining another side of the story (all of that is highly controversial). So, I left only facts that are not "charged". If you can produce a more balanced version of the introduction, please do.] (]) 20:22, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::: Well, imho is also not ideal. One gets the impression that he fled to UK because he had gone into opposition. It should also be written that he's accused of various crimes here in Russia (and elsewhere). This is just a fact - we don't say whether these accusations are well-founded or not. | |||
::: On a second thought mentioning Litvinenko and others isn't absolutely necessary in the intro. What needs to be mentioned is his after-emigration political activity. We should think about how to formulate this. ]<sub>]</sub> 20:55, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::Absolutely ridiculous and not at all a valid argument. There is no other side of the story, it's factual information that he has arrest warrants out, and that he's under investigation. You can add "He denies all claims" if you like. (never mind I just did it for you)] (]) 20:44, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::Simply telling "he denies this" is not good enough. So far I avoided editing the article, because this person is very controversial, to tell this politely.] (]) 21:08, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::: Why is it not good enough? Are there any other ''facts'' we're missing? ] (]) 21:10, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::::Of course a lot of facts are missing - about his political activities, business, etc. There is an arbitrary selection of negative facts in the introduction right now. Hence this is against BLP policy.] (]) 23:03, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:You're not making any sense. It may be your POV that these are "negative" facts, but they are indeed facts, and thus there is no legit reason to remove them from the intro. ] (]) 23:30, 3 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::There are two ways to fix the problem. Either we should fairly represent all "positive" and "negative" facts in introduction, or remove any "charged" facts which paint him as a criminal.] (]) 16:24, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::: What positive facts are not mentioned there, in your opinion? ]<sub>]</sub> 18:19, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::::What positive? He was allegedly a man who brought ] to power.] (]) 20:26, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::::: So this is a positive fact, yeah :) I have nothing against mentioning these allegations in the lead actually. ]<sub>]</sub> 21:19, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::::::I have no problem with this either. Anything factual and important should be added to the intro. Remember, add, don't delete, in order to achieve a NPOV. ] (]) 21:37, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::::I think I have to support the apparent majority here. ] is a very serious matter, but the allegations are also very serious and well documented. Quite often - with non-public figures - it might be possible to wait until a conviction in court is reached before publishing this type of '''fact''' here - but BB is a very public figure (by his own choice) and is avoiding court proceeding by having left the country. Even in those cases, we could let documentary sources (e.g. "The Godfather of the Kremlin" BOOK) state their case. | |||
::::Of course put in his own denials and all the "positive facts" but if they are not there... It is not the majority of editors who are at fault here. Let's try to read the facts in a Neutral POV, rather than report a POV that makes BB look neutral. Make sense? ] (]) 18:30, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::::Fine, I have absolutely no problems with negative information in introduction. But then I will include more information there as time allows.] (]) 19:51, 4 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
The final subsection on the alleged connections with the 2 assasinations looked unbalanced to me. there are lots of other people who have been accused, and Berezhovsky isn't the main suspect as far as I can tell. Correct me if I'm wrong. ] (]) 01:42, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:If it looks unbalanced then add material (about Berezovsky) that will balance it. ]. The allegations are quite notable and relevant, there's no reason why they should be excluded from his article. ] (]) 07:54, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::Although I do not like Berezovsky, last edits by Krawndawg (some of them deleted by Smallbones) seem to be bad. Russian state-controlled media can hardly be regarded as reliable sources about Berezovsky. Just imagine that someone would write an article about "vrazina" (]) ] using materials of ] of 1930s. The "archenemy" Berezovsky is now described in Russian media almost as Trotsky in 1930s, or perhaps as ] in ]). ] (]) 19:25, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::: ''"Russian state-controlled media can hardly be regarded as reliable sources about Berezovsky."'' - Says who? Are you saying that their point of view should not be told? I suggest you read ]. If you think the sources are unreliable bring it up ]. I also added many western sources that completely backed up what the Russian ones said in my latest edits. | |||
::: Berezovsky is equally put in bad light in western media. Perhaps you just need to come to terms that he's not a very nice guy. Our job here isn't to make a bad man look good or neutral, it's to present every relevant point of view and let the sources collectively tell the whole story, something I've done by using both Western and Russian sources. Again, if you have anything to add regarding Berezovsky, that perhaps equals out all the negative, please add it! ] (]) 20:39, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::::Why? You painted him as "vrazina" ] from ]. Fine. I am not an administrator to enforce ] policy.] (]) 21:34, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::::What?? You're drawing connections between 1984 and current day Russia? That's funny, but also rather concerning - your personal views on reality (which in my opinion are quite out of touch) should not in any way influence what goes into or stays out of wikipedia. (That's a horrid comparison too. Goldstein really could have been a fabrication, whereas, as far as I know, Berezovsky is a real person who really does speak for himself and make his own accusations. He has admitted himself that he's out to get Putin, that's no state fabricated lie.) | |||
He is best known for his role as a ], media tycoon and infamous politician during the presidency of ] in the 1990s. He has been described by critics as the epitome of Russian "robber capitalism", but he denies having ever taken part in the violence and crime that tainted Russian business during that era.<ref name=profile/> Berezovsky was at the height of his power in the later Yeltsin years, when he was deputy secretary of ], a friend of Boris Yeltsin's daughter ], and a member of the Yeltsin inner circle, or "family".<ref name=profile/> | |||
:::::Again, if you think the sources are unreliable I urge you to bring it up in above mentioned notice board. I'm not here to spread false information. I'm sure that the allegations are very real, and everything in that section is 100% factual. I wouldn't have inserted the information if I thought otherwise. ] (]) 21:54, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Berezovsky made his fortune by capturing state assets at knockdown prices during Russia's rush towards privatisation in very questionable ways.<ref name="plotting"> The Guardian. 2007-04-13</ref> He took ownership of the ] oil company and became the main shareholder in the country's main television channel, ], which he turned into a ] vehicle for Boris Yeltsin in the run-up to the ]. It is said that, in contrast to Russian entrepreneurs such as Vladimir Gusinsky, Berezovsky did not enrich any of the enterprises with which he became involved or took over (e.g. Sibneft, ORT, the car dealership Avtovaz, Omsk Oil Refinery, National Sports Fund, and aluminum smelters Bratsk, Krasnoyarsk, and Novokuznetsk), but instead drained them of cash.<ref name="dermokratizatsiya2003">Johanna Granville, "Dermokratizatsiya and Prikhvatizatsiya: the Russian Kleptocracy and Rise of Organized Crime,"] in ''Demokratizatsiya'' vol. 11, no. 3 (summer 2003): 449-457.</ref> Although he helped ] enter the "family", and funded the party that formed Putin's parliamentary base, Putin moved to regain control of the ORT television station and to curb the political ambitions of Russia's oligarchs, who were extremely unpopular with the Russian public.<ref>, '']'', December 3, 2005</ref> | |||
I'm sorry but I don't really understand what's the problem with (Russian) sources here. I agree that they have to be treated with caution. However state-controlled media are used as sources only two times in the article and each time to reference what some Russian official said. Imho it is absolutely normal to use them this way. ]<sub>]</sub> 21:45, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Following the ], Berezovsky went into opposition and fled the country after being accused of ] a regional government of US$13 million. He was later granted ] in the United Kingdom. He has since publicly stated that he is on a mission to bring down Putin "by force".<ref name=profile>, ], 31 May 2007</ref><ref name=los/> In the UK, he became associated with ], ] and ] in what has become known as "the London Circle" of Russian exiles. He is a founder of ]. | |||
:Right, one could easily find sources in Western press in 1930s that Trotsky was a spy and plotted to kill all Soviet leaders. That is why I am talking about ] from ] (Trotsky was his prototype).] (]) 22:10, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
In 2007, a Moscow court found Berezovsky guilty of massive ] ]. He was sentenced to six years in jail and ordered to repay the $9 million that the court said he had stolen from the state airline ].<ref name=jail>, ], 29 November 2007</ref> He has also been accused by Russian authorities of being involved in the murders of several leading critics of the Putin's government, including Litvinenko and journalist ], in an attempt to destabilize the country and discredit Putin. In response, Berezovsky - amongst others - has attributed the killings to the Putin's government as a means of political intimidation. ]s for him have been issued in Russia<ref name=r/> and ]<ref name=b/> for allegations of ], ], and ]. Berezovsky has been under investigation by ] for money laundering since 1999.<ref name=s/> | |||
:: Again I don't understand what you want to say. Should we not mention that he's accused of killing Politkovskaya at all? If we should not - why? if we should - what kind of references should be used and what else should we write in that section? ]<sub>]</sub> 05:53, 7 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
In 2007 Brazil has issued an arrest warrant to Interpol against Berevozsky on accusations of money laundering through a football club. | |||
I'm sorry, but I'd suggest that everybody take a time out. The Politovskaya section does look unbalanced to me. Berezhovsky isn't the only person accused. ] does require some balance. We don't just want to report the FSB viewpoint. ] (]) 22:28, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Berezovsky survived an assassination attempt in 1994 unharmed. Berezovsky claims that there have been several other assassination attempts directed against him, which he accuses Russian agents of carrying out. | |||
:Actually he is the only person officially accused so far (along with the people connected to him, who ''are'' mentioned.) I added that other third parties accused the Russian government of ordering the hit, but Biophy removed it, which I don't completely disagree with since that's not relevant to Berezovsky at all. ] (]) 22:39, 6 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Berezovsky has been married four times and has six children{{Citation needed|date=April 2009}}. | |||
==Neutrality tag== | |||
==Early life and scientific research== | |||
So is anyone going to actually make any suggestions or attempt to make it neutral? What information is missing, who's point of view are we not including? ] (]) 00:26, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Berezovsky was born in 1946 in Moscow to Abram Markovich Berezovsky, a Jewish civil engineer in construction works, and his wife Anna Gelman. He studied ] and then ], receiving his ] in 1983. After graduating from the Moscow Forestry Engineering Institute in 1968, Berezovsky worked as an ], from 1969 till 1987 filling the positions of an ], research officer and finally the head of a department in the Institute of Management Problems of the ]. Berezovsky did research on ] and ], publishing 16 books and articles between 1975 and 1989; his ] is 4. | |||
:This is getting ridiculous. I made a few very minor changes to improve NPOV a little, but you reverted me twice. After that you ask: why neutrality tag? ] (]) 04:04, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
==Business career in Russia== | |||
::I didn't revert you. I changed a couple NPOV details which I noted in the comment. The majority of your changes stayed, yet you promptly reverted my changes with no explanation; hence why I reverted back. | |||
The foundation of his fortune lay in an arrangement Berezovski forged with the management of Avtovaz, the huge and ramshackle Russian car maker. In exchange for cutting senior management into the action, he was able to get cars straight off the assembly line for far less than the cost of production, which he then sold at immense profit through his newly founded chain of auto dealerships. The factory workers paid the difference by going without pay for months on end.<ref name = "Godfather2">http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1316/is_10_32/ai_66495297/?tag=content;col1 Godfather of the Kremlin: Boris Berezovsky and the Looting of Russia</ref> | |||
The early '90s, when Berezovsky was getting under way, was the time of the great gang wars in Moscow, as rival criminal coalitions shot it out for control of key industries and businesses. Businessmen could only ward off extortion or worse by paying one or other criminal group for a "roof"--protection. On one side in the most important war stood the ], much feared for their ruthlessness, and impenetrable to outsiders. On the other were the "Slavic alliance," native Russian gangsters determined to fight off the Chechen threat. It appears that Berezovsky forged an alliance with the Chechen forces, who provided his roof, a connection that would have terrible consequences in years to come. In the meantime, his fearsome allies took him through some tough times, such as the bloody gun battle on Lenin Prospekt outside one of his showrooms in 1993, or, more seriously, the detonation of a large bomb beside his passing car, which killed his bodyguard, decapitated his driver, and left him badly wounded.<ref name="Godfather2" /> In a week, several people were arrested from the criminal group headed by ] (also known as "Silvestr"). The Moscow Trade Bank controlled by that group shortly returned some funds it owned to Berezovski's conglomerate. In about three months (September 14, 1994) ] was killed by a car explosion, organizers of which have never been found.<ref name=Godfather/> | |||
Now to explain that original edit of mine: | |||
By 1994, Berezovsky had moved beyond dependence on mobster protection. He had forged a more potent alliance by paying for the publication of Boris Yeltsin's memoirs, thus gaining entree to the inner circle around the grateful author/president. This court was populated with strange figures, such as the "hippie journalist" ], through whom Berezovsky obtained his entree; Yeltsin's tennis coach, who ran a large criminal empire of his own from a Kremlin office; not to mention ], for a while the powerful chief of Yeltsin's Praetorian guard who later reported that Berezovsky had asked him to kill a business rival. Korzhakov performed great services to history by his assiduous bugging of everyone's phones, leaking the tapes when it seemed useful, and by his forthcoming reminiscences once he had fallen from his master's graces.<ref name="Godfather2" /> | |||
*"''Rabid critic of Putin''" - Redundant. We know he's a critic of Putin, it is mentioned and implied already. | |||
*"''and others''" - Russian authorities aren't the only ones who have made the accusation. This seems like a "scapegoat" POV push which you admitted to supporting. | |||
*"''Several attempts to assassinate him, allegedly by Russian agents, have failed.''" - This is a fabricated lie to, again, push your POV that he's a scapegoat. Only one assassination attempt was "allegedly" going to be done by Russian secret services, and even that one was officially dismissed as frivolous meaning it is no longer alleged. Berezovsky himself is the only one making this claim, hence why I changed it to say just that. | |||
*"''Swiss investigation"'' - Why delete this? Because it takes away from your POV that he's only picked on by the Russian government? This is notable, factual and important therefore it stays. | |||
Once inside "the family," Berezovsky masterfully parlayed political connections into cash. Key to his modus operandi was the realization (shared by many of his peers in the rising business oligarchy) that it was not necessary to control a business, simply its cash flow. In a remarkably candid 1996 interview with ] he termed this approach the "privatization of profit" A fascinating chapter lays out in detail, complete with the transcripts of bugged phone Calls, how this method was successfully applied to the looting of Aeroflot, the formerly profitable state airline. Thanks in part to the appointment of Yeltsin's son-in-law as the company's head, Berezovsky was able to siphon off huge chunks of Aeroflot's considerable hard currency earnings through a series of shell companies in Switzerland.<ref name="Godfather2" /> | |||
In all, you inserted a whole lotta unsupported original research, so I cleaned it up so to support the citations given in the rest of the article. ] (]) 04:32, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
From aviation, Berezovsky moved on to the really big money in Russia—oil. His entry into the oil business was facilitated by the most egregious of all the great ripoffs that have charactarized post-Soviet Russia, the "loans for shares" scheme by which our hero and his fellow oligarchs helped themselves to priceless chunks of the country's resources, for pennies on the dollar, in return for financing Yeltsin's re-election in 1996. Following that free, but hardly fair, election, the godfathers increased his political profile, taking various high-level government posts (without of course ceasing his business operations for a second). It was at this time that his interest in Chechen matters re-emerged, in the form of lavish ransom payments to kidnappers in Chechnya for the retrieval of their victims. Klebnikov points out that this flow of money to the gangs in the devastated territory effectively made it impossible for the elected Chechen leader to stabilize his country. The consequent anarchy, culminating in the invasion of Dagestan in the summer of 1999 by fundamentalist Islamist Chechens, provided the backdrop for the second Chechen war and the rise to power of Vladimir Putin. Klebnikov suspends judgment as to whether any of the leadership in Moscow had a hand in the terrorist bombings in the capital that provided the final pretext for the invasion of Chechnya last year, although George Soros has been less demure, heavily hinting in an article in the New York Review of Books that Berezovsky deliberately fomented the war in furtherance of his political intrigues.<ref name="Godfather2" /> | |||
: Krawndag, who else accused him of murdering critics of "Putin's regime"? ]<sub>]</sub> 05:21, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
During the presidency of ] from 1991 to 1999, Berezovsky was among the businessmen who gained access to the president. He acquired stakes in state companies including AutoVAZ, Aeroflot, and several oil properties that he (together with ]) organized into ]. Berezovsky established a bank to finance his operations and acquired several news media holdings as well. Berezovsky was a leading proponent of political and economic ] in Russia. He has frequently entered into politics by getting control over the media sources (his holdings included the television channels ] and ] (for which he paid almost nothing but gained control over them with the help of ]), and newspapers '']'', '']'' and '']''), financing political candidates, making political statements, and even seeking office himself. His media holdings provided essential support for ] in 1996. Berezovsky famously boasted how he was part of a small coterie of so-called oligarchs who owned 50 per cent of Russia's wealth.<ref name="marsh"> The Times. 2007-07-30</ref> | |||
::According to the Washington Post: "Kremlin supporters saw it as a conspiracy to smear Russia's reputation by engineering a spectacular murder." ... "Some people in Moscow see Berezovsky's involvement as another campaign to ruin Putin's reputation internationally." ] (]) 05:43, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Later, when in exile, Berezovsky had to fight legal battles over his holdings.<ref name="nyt_bere"/> According to New York Times, there is a suspicion that Berezovsky's later critical activities against the Russian government could simply be an attempt to orchestrate a political crisis for Putin and win political asylum in Britain as a means to protect permanently the wealth he carved out of Russia in the early days, when the pickings were easy.<ref name="nyt_bere"/> | |||
::This article says: "According to The Daily Mail, the British investigators, bringing the case on suspicion in deliberate poisoning of Litvinenko, are going to interrogate Boris Berezovsky who has reportedly bought a house in London for the former FSB officer." - meaning he was a suspect for the British authorities as well. ] (]) 05:48, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
::: I can't agree with you here. Regarding your first source 'Kremlin supporters' != 'others'. We'd have to write 'by Russian authorities and Kremlin supporters' but that would sound strange imho. So I think we should leave only 'Russian authorities'. | |||
::: You don't have to be a suspect to be interrogated - you can be just a witness. So we can't say that 'he was a suspect for the British authorities as well'. ]<sub>]</sub> 07:23, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
==Political career== | |||
:::: Alright, I'll concede that point, you're right; assuming we think of media as a type of "Russian authority". ] (]) 07:35, 8 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
Berezovsky was briefly executive secretary of the ] (CIS) and later a member of the ] (Russia's lower house of ]) from 1999 to July 2000. He survived several assassination attempts,<ref name=finn>, '']'', December 9, 2006</ref>. | |||
In the position of the deputy secretary of the ],<ref>, ], 07.11.1997</ref> he was also involved in talks on freeing Russian and foreign hostages kidnapped in ] and allegedly transferred large sums of money in exchange for hostages. Berezovsky admitted, that in 1997, he gave $2 million of his own money to Chechen field commander ], who was then Prime Minister of Chechnya.<ref name="nyt_bere"></ref> The money was intended for restoration of a cement factory, he said, but he admitted it might have been used for other purposes.<ref name="nyt_bere"/> Berezovsky had strong ties with ] in Moscow. According to ] book "Godfather of Kremlin Boris Berezovsky or looting of Russia", those connections came from Berezovsky's close relations with Chechen mafia, whom he paid for protection against other mafia gangs in early 90s. He said that he "saved at least fifty people, who otherwise would have been killed; most of them were simple soldiers. And believe me, all of this was strictly official, with the full knowledge and consent of the Kremlin."<ref name="dissident"/> However, Chechen president ] accused Berezovsky and the Russian government of collusion with the hostage-takers.<ref name="dissident"/> | |||
:Removed the tag since no one has made any suggestions in many days. If you want to put it back up, specify the problem. ] (]) 04:37, 13 April 2008 (UTC) | |||
The first assault against Berezovsky was launched during Primakov's premiership, when Berezovsky was accused of money laundering when he was | |||
<blockquote> | |||
at the head of Aeroflot. However, in the event it was Primakov who was dismissed.<ref name="sakwa_aeroflot">{{cite book |title=Putin, Russia's choice |last=Sakwa |first=Richard |authorlink=Richard Sakwa |coauthors= |year=2008 |edition=2nd |publisher=Routledge |isbn=978-0-415-40765-6 |page=71 }}</ref> | |||
Berezovsky started in business in 1989 under perestroika by buying and reselling automobiles from state manufacturer AutoVAZ. Officially, Berezovsky was called upon as an expert in development of optimized system of management of the enterprise. In 1992, a new middleman company, LogoVAZ, was created with Berezovsky as its president. LogoVAZ became an exclusive consignment dealer of AutoVAZ, enabling a scheme (named ReExport) in which cars were sold abroad and then bought back for sale on the internal market. Frequently, however, cars were not exported at all and the operations on export and import remained only on paper. In another shady business, May 1994, Berezovsky became head of the notorious Automobile All-Russia alliance "АVVА" ("АВВА" in Russian Cyrillic) and became known as the initiator of "the national car" project. This enterprise turned out to be merely a financial pyramid scheme, as shares of a nonexistent factory which has never been constructed were sold to the investors. | |||
</blockquote> | |||
According to ], an associate of Berezovsky and Litvinenko, in 1999 Berezovsky secured ]'s appointment to the ] position as a result of a secret agreement, where Putin promised his loyalty to Yeltsin and his closest circle including Berezovsky himself.<ref name="dissident"/> In June 2000 '']'' reported that Spanish police discovered Putin secretly visited a villa in Spain belonging to Berezovsky on up to five different occasions in 1999.<ref>, '']'', June 15, 2000</ref> According to ], Berezovsky was strongly opposed to the ] but nevertheless supported Putin's ]. Just before the March 2000 elections, ] wrote, "Berezovsky unleashed a propaganda blitz that obliterated the opposition as surely as Russia's tanks obliterated Grozny." At least two candidates who were widely felt to have a reasonable chance of winning over Putin - the mayor of Moscow, Yuri Luzhkov, and the former premier Yevgeny Primakov - were swiftly eliminated through an elaborate smear campaign.<ref name="al-ahram"> Al-Ahram Weekly, 2002-03-21</ref> However, according to Goldfarb, Putin later broke the agreement with Berezovsky, allegedly when he was infuriated by the critical coverage of the ] by ORT TV channel owned by Berezovsky. Putin forced Berezovsky to sell his ORT shares, partly in exchange for promising to free ], a former manager of Aeroflot company and close associate of Berezovsky, according to Goldfarb.<ref name="dissident"/> | |||
==Neutrality tag part deux== | |||
Mark Kramer, Director of the ] and a Senior Associate at the ] at ], asserts that Berezovsky is "consumed by greed and very short tempered. He is not the type of person that most people would want as a friend."<ref name="al-ahram"/> | |||
OK. How about any sources? A counter opinion - including by Berezovsky himself? --] (]) 21:51, 12 June 2008 (UTC) | |||
Stefanie Marsh of ] wrote in 2007, that Berezovsky was one of the architects of Putin's rise to power and has spent the intervening years grinding an axe about his fall from grace.<ref name="marsh"/> | |||
== Did an article on ] == | |||
==Allegations and convictions of criminal activity== | |||
--] (]) 08:49, 9 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
===Crime accusations in Forbes article, murders of ] and ], interrogation by Russian police in 1995=== | |||
A 1996 ] magazine article titled ''] of ]?'',<ref name=Godfather>, ], December 30, 1996</ref> by the Russian-American journalist ], portrayed Berezovsky as a ] boss who had his rivals murdered, and was involved in fraud, money laundering and had connections with Chechen mafia. In his article among other things Klebnikov accused Berezovsky of organizing murder of ], notorious Russian anchorman whose TV show was the first one to start openly criticizing communism ideology in 1988 and was the most popular by ratings in Russia even 7 years after. Berezovsky was interrogated by police and accepted the fact, that one day before ] was killed he passed US$100,000 to one of the mafia leaders known as Nikolai. Berezovsky acknowledged having passed the money to mafia, but said that he passed the money to Nikolay in order to find out who arranged an assassination attempt on himself a year ago (in 1994). Berezovsky had a great influence on Boris Yeltsin whom he indirectly sponsored by donating on publishing of his autobiography and establishing friendly relationships (often by indirectly sponsoring their activities) with most people who surrounded the president, including his daughter Tatyana Dyachenko (whom he may have earned hundreds of millions of dollars), and convinced Yeltsin that he was an innocent victim of someone else's plot. President support helped Berezovsky to stop criminal investigation against him. | |||
A few months after the article in Forbes was published, Berezovsky sued the magazine for ] (in February 1997) in British court. In 2003 the court ruled that Forbes remove one statement from the article, as it didn't have enough evidence to support the claim that Berezovsky arranged murder of famous anchorman and TV producer ].<ref>{{cite news |first=Michael R. |last=Caputo |title=Same Old Ruthless Russia |url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A45364-2004Jul12.html |work=] |publisher=] |page=A15 |date=2004-07-13 |accessdate=2007-05-31}}</ref> The court didn't order Forbes to remove the rest of the article from the website nor acknowledge that all data contained in it was false, nor forced Forbes to pay a compensation, that Berezovsky wanted when filing his claim. The article is still available online on the Forbes website (with exception of one above mentioned statement).<ref name=Godfather/> Some media sources controlled by Berezovsky though, such as Kommersant magazine, reported, that Forbes "lost the case" and "completely retracted their claims against Berezovsky" which actually never happened. Berezovsky never contested in court the book "Godfather of the Kremlin: Boris Berezovsky and the looting of Russia" that Klebnikov published in 2000, which was a very extended version of the article. | |||
=="Fled to avoid arrest"== | |||
This is OR and POV. He was not officially charged at the time of his departure from Russia. If you think he was charged ''at this time'', please provide some sources.] (]) 21:27, 28 July 2008 (UTC) He was granted the political assylum only much later, allegedly because a Russian agent tried to kill him in London.] (]) 21:33, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
On July 9, 2004, Klebnikov was attacked on a ] street late at night by unknown assailants who fired at least nine shots from a slowly moving car. Klebnikov was shot four times and initially survived, but he bled to death in the hospital because the ] took almost an hour to come, it had no ] bottle, and the hospital elevator that was taking him to the ] broke.<ref></ref> Before he died, Klebnikov described that there were 3 assasins in the car, and that he never met any of them before. The publisher of ''Forbes''' Russian edition has said that the murder is "definitely linked to his professional activity".<ref>, ] ], May 2007</ref> The paper speculated that a list of the 100 wealthiest Russians written by Klebnikov in May 2004 may have motivated the attack, though Klebnikov himself was most afraid of Boris Berezovsky according to his brother <ref name="Paul Klebnikov was killed by the hero of his book, Izvestia newspaper"></ref> | |||
: says: "''Boris Berezovsky was one of the Russian oligarchs who acquired massive wealth by taking control of state assets after the fall of communism. When Mr Berezovsky, who controlled several banks and TV stations, '''was accused''' in Russia of defrauding a regional government of US$13m, '''he fled''' and moved to London, where he now lives under the name Platon Elenin."'' ] (]) 21:37, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
::Berezovsky was indicted for the first time in October 2001 (in the well-known Aeroflot affair rather than some mysterious defrauding of a mysterious regional government), almost a year after he fled Russia. Before that he was considered a witness only. There is no need to rely on hearsays reposted by the BBC without attribution. ] (]) 22:27, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
::Maybe the BBC is not to blame for that. Keep in mind that "accused" is a very vague term. You'd better find something with "charged" or "indicted". ] (]) 22:41, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::O'K, I checked this using a more detailed and reliable source, book ], pages 232-233. It tells that Berezovsky was ] as a witness in the beginning of November 2000, in the ] case (simultaneously with "], who was accuzed of defrauding ] of $300 million via a loan to ]"). Berzovsky was in ] and decided not to return to Russia, on the insistence of Goldfarb. The BBC article is obviously mistaken, as often happens in news reports. This BBC article is very short and does not explain anything about this mysterious defrauding of a mysterious regional government. Apparently, there was no such. He was apparently accused by Putin and C. of defrauding the Aeroflot (see ]) and only when he was already abroad.] (]) 02:39, 29 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
::::I don't know why you would think that book is a more reliable source. It was written by a friend of Berezovsky, one of the "London Circle" folk. Hardly neutral and certainly not more reliable than BBC, one of the most reliable media sources there is.] (]) 17:28, 29 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::::Then would you or the BBC be so kind to point out which regional government Berezovsky has allegedly defrauded and when he was charged? It shouldn't be difficult. ] (]) 17:51, 29 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
:Another BLP problem is the '''Alleged links to assassinations of Alexander Litvinenko and Anna Politkovskaya''' section. This needs to be shortened at least, but I am afraid of edit warriers... ] (]) 03:10, 29 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
::I agree that the Politkovskaya section should be shortened per ]. The Litvinenko section is already pretty short and to the point. ] (]) 16:14, 29 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
===Other early crime allegations in Russia by ] and ]=== | |||
==Alleged funding of terrorists== | |||
On October 16, 1996 ], then Secretary of the Security Council, accused Boris Berezovsky and ] (another oligarch, a president of the MOST financial group, who was one of Berezovsky's main rivals at the time), of making up lists of persons slated for liquidation. At about the same time Alexander Korzhakov, former Chief of Russia President's Security Service, told journalists that Berezovsky had tried to talk him into assassinating ], Moscow Mayor ], singer and Duma deputy ], and others (Novy vzglyad newspaper, 19 October 1996).<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.scandaly.ru/print/news337.html |title=Трудовая Биография Б.Березовского |publisher=Scandaly.ru |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.lebed.com/1997/art5.htm |title=Валерий Лебедев. Парадоксальный Березовский. N 1 от 10 февраля 1997 года |publisher=Lebed.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.compromat.ru/page_9357.htm |title=Компромат.Ru: Березовский Борис // |publisher=Compromat.ru |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.vsp.ru/23409/44-2-3.HTM |title="серый кардинал" XX века | Восточно-Сибирская правда |publisher=Vsp.ru |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref name="guardian-psj.ru">{{cite web|url=http://www.guardian-psj.ru/b-article-9 |title=Guardian || Berezovsky, Boris Abramovich |publisher=Guardian-psj.ru |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> | |||
I was browsing around Biophy and Pieter's favorite propaganda outlet Jamestown, and I came across . I don't have the time or will to get involved in editing right now, but these are some serious allegations by former rebel leaders/warlords that someone may want to know about and include in the article. | |||
"''Baraev said he hoped Zakaev would break his ties with “the extremists’ breadwinner,” Boris Berezovsky.'' | |||
===First probe and arrest warrant in Russia on money laundering in 1999, and start of criminal investigation in Switzerland=== | |||
''Separately, Interfax on February 19 quoted another former rebel leader who switched sides, Magomed Khambiev, as accusing Berezovsky of financing Udugov and the late rebel warlord Shamil Basaev and of broadcasting “Wahabbi ideas.” Khambiev, who was defense minister in the separatist Chechen Republic of Ichkeria (ChRI) government under Aslan Maskhadov, charged that Berezovsky had financed “illegal armed unit” leaders “under the guise of paying ransoms for hostages” as well as the Kavkaz television channel, which he called a “Wahhabi mouthpiece.”'' | |||
In 1999 after ] was appointed ], he started fighting corruption and initiated several criminal investigations. Among those was a probe on Berezovsky for fraud and money laundering in ] car manufacturer and ] airline. It may be worth mentioning that at that time ] was not playing a significant role in Russian politics. | |||
On April 6, 1999 an arrest order in the name of Berezovsky was issued.<ref>{{cite web|last=Starobin |first=Paul |url=http://www.businessweek.com/2000/00_30/b3691184.htm |title=Boris Berezovsky: Tycoon under Siege (int'l edition) |publisher=Businessweek.com |date=2000-07-24 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> (on the same day another arrest warrant has been issued against ]. He was charged with illegal business activities and money laundering). At the time Berezovsky was in Paris and commented, that the case was started by his political opponents and the allegations were false. The prosecutor general ] allowed him to enter the country and not to be arrested despite of the warrant. The arrest warrant was quashed by the mogul's allies in Boris Yeltsin's Kremlin, and on November 5, 1999 the charges were lifted and Berezovsky reclassified from accused person to witness. | |||
''“Not only did Berezovsky provide the money for buying state-of-the-art equipment, but he also financed the TV channel’s work while "being perfectly aware that the channel propagated Wahhabism round-the-clock," Interfax quoted Khambiev as saying.'' | |||
At the same time several investigations have been started in Switzerland against Russians involved in fraud and money laundering. Among those was a case against Switzerland-Albanian construction firm ] which supposedly bribed ] (government official close to Yeltsin responsible for a lot of government property in Russia at that time). Swiss prosecutors also visited companies "Andava", "Forus" and a few others under control of Berezovsky. The bank accounts of Berezovsky, his partner in "Aeroflot" ] and a few other people were arrested with almost US$70 million frozen on them. At the end of summer the entry visa to Switzerland was rejected to Berezovsky.<ref>{{dead link|date=June 2010}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.forbes.com/global/1999/0322/0206020a_print.html |title=Magazine Article |publisher=Forbes.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.sptimes.ru/index.php?action_id=2&story_id=13156 |title=The St. Petersburg Times - Business - The Russian National Airline Taking Off Into Friendlier Skies |publisher=Sptimes.ru |date=2000-11-07 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> The investigation against Berezovsky in Switzerland is still under way. Berezovsky has been investigated by the ] financial authorities for ] and membership of a criminal organization. In 2003, the Swiss Bundesanwaltschaft (General State Prosecutor) started a criminal case against Berezovsky and, amongst others, ], for money laundering through the Swiss firms Ovaco AG, situated at the Monbijoustrasse in ], and Anros SA in the ] World Trade Center.<ref>{{de icon}} , '']'', 09 December 2003</ref> Berezovsky claimed the proceedings were motivated by ].<ref name=s>, '']'', 15/03/2006</ref> In December 2006, as news broke of the death of ], the Bundesanwaltschaft announced that its investigations against Boris Berezovsky were still continuing. | |||
''Khambiev also alleged that Berezovsky has “personally” handed Basaev $1 million upon arriving in Ingushetia after the first Chechen military campaign. “It greatly surprised and outraged me,” Interfax quoted Khambiev as saying. “I was surprised that someone representing a country hostile to Ichkeria and being a deputy head of its Security Council should give money to Basaev. I asked Basaev why Berezovsky had given the money and why Basaev accepted it. He answered that Berezovsky was afraid of him and therefore paid the money," Khambiev said. He claimed that it later turned out that Berezovsky had given Basaev not $1 million, but $2 million while in Ingushetia.''" ] (]) 19:25, 24 February 2009 (UTC) | |||
The Federal Criminal Court of Switzerland on October 27, 2008 ruled to confiscate several million francs from bank accounts in Switzerland, one of whose beneficiaries was or is Berezovsky.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.interfax.com/interview.asp?id=11563 |title=Director of the Swiss Federal Office of Justice: Switzerland is a wrong place for concealing or depositing illegal funds - Interview |publisher=Interfax.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> | |||
==Major POV issues== | |||
===Further criminal investigation and criminal convictions in Russia=== | |||
this page reads like it's come straight out of the kremlin! | |||
On November 1, 2000 Russia's prosecutor general demanded that Boris Berezovsky and Vladimir Gusinsky (at the moment outside of Russia) appeared before the court in Russia by November 13 with the threat of international arrest warrants and prison if they failed to show up. The general prosecutor office said it now had sufficient proof (in the case of Boris Berezovsky) to bring charges of large-scale theft in relation to alleged embezzlement from the state airline Aeroflot<ref>{{cite web|url=http://books.google.ru/books?id=D2KDf0UBUsoC&pg=PA563#v=onepage&q&f=false |title=The new Russia: a handbook of ... - Google йМХЦХ |publisher=Books.google.ru |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/852890.stm |title=EUROPE | Swiss hand over Berezovsky papers |publisher=BBC News |date=2000-07-26 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> Berezovsky who was abroad, decided not to come back to Russia. | |||
On September 20, 2001 Berezovsky was put on Russia's federal warrant list and charged in absentia with assisting fraud, hiding currency operations from Russian regulators and failing to sell on domestic market a part of foreign currency obtained from international trade as was required by currency regulation in Russia, and money laundering.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://articles.latimes.com/2001/oct/23/news/mn-60506 |title=Warrant Is Issued for Berezovsky - Los Angeles Times |publisher=Articles.latimes.com |date=2001-10-23 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> | |||
i've lost count of the uses of 'allegations', 'alleged', 'supposed', 'controversy', 'according to (insert russian government official), etc... | |||
On September 5, 2007, a trial in ] began in Moscow to examine allegations that Berezovsky had embezzled money from the Russian airline carrier Aeroflot in the 1990s.<ref name=r>, '']'', September 5, 2007</ref> On November 29, 2007, a Moscow court found Berezovsky guilty of massive ], and sentenced him to six years in jail. The court found that he had stolen 214 million roubles (nearly $9 million) from Aeroflot through fraud, and ordered him to repay it. Berezovsky called the verdict "a farce".<ref name=jail/> The judge described Berezovsky as part of an organized criminal group that included Aeroflot managers. | |||
terrorism, extortion, crime, political interference, even planning a civil war seem to appear as 'allegations' on this page - and with little or no direct response. for example, 3 paragraphs of various people denouncing him over the Politkovskaya and Litvinenko affairs and only a single line quote in response! | |||
On June 26, 2009, he was convicted in ] court on another charge of stealing 5,500 cars from ] in 1994 and sentenced in absentia to 13 years of imprisonment. His business associate ], who is also in exile in Great Britain, received a 9 years sentence. A fiction book "Bolshaya Paika", loosely based on Berezovsky and written by Dubov, which later served as basis for the movie ], was used as one of the pieces of evidence.<ref name=secondcharge>{{cite news|url=http://www.kommersant.ru/doc.aspx?docsid=1279750|title=Thirteen-year oligarch|date=2009-06-27|publisher=]|accessdate=2009-12-07}}</ref> His appeal in the ] court was rejected on September 17, 2009.<ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.interfax.ru/society/news.asp?id=100947|title=Boris Berezovsky's conviction is now effective|date=2009-09-17|publisher=]|accessdate=2009-12-07}}</ref> | |||
i'm sure there are plenty of 'allegations' against him, but as per ] and ] this needs a serious rewrite for neutrality ] (]) 19:47, 23 July 2009 (UTC) | |||
:The objective of the NPOV policy is to encourage us to present the article by weighing all relevant viewpoints proportionately (not equally). The objective is not to make Berezovsky seem neutral. Feel free to add relevant, sourced information, but using NPOV as an excuse to remove reliably sourced content is against NPOV policy. Your opinion on whether or not someone (like Kadyrov) is a "reliable source" is irrelevant, as his allegations are not presented as fact, but as allegations, and they most certainly are notable. ] (]) 02:31, 24 July 2009 (UTC) | |||
===Allegations by ]=== | |||
::Yes, this article is hardly neutral. How about removing "Death of Anna Politkovskaya" section? The accusations are so ridiculous and hardly notable in ''this'' article. We have a separate article, specifically about her assassination.] (]) 00:19, 11 February 2010 (UTC) | |||
On 28 October 2004 in a popular show «To the barrier» on NTV Russian TV channel a shareholder and CEO of ] ], was invited as a guest and was facing Andrey Vasiliev, then general director of Kommersant Publishing House, the leading source for business news in Russia at the time. In the course of the heated debates, Fridman claimed he was willing to give a loan to Kommersant minors in 1999 so that they could buy out the Publishing House from its principal owner Vladimir Yakovlev. Berezovsky, Fridman claimed, who was himself eyeing Kommersant, was “extremely displeased” and “threatening” when calling him. “Berezovsky was threatening me. In general, he was threatening everybody,” Fridman said the key phrase of the suit.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.kommersant.com/p673468/r_500/Berezovsky_Summons_Fridman_to_Court/ |title=Berezovsky Summons Fridman to Court - Kommersant Moscow |publisher=Kommersant.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://en.rian.ru/world/20060526/48679705.html |title=Tycoon Berezovsky wins slander suit vs. Alfa head in London | World | RIA Novosti |publisher=En.rian.ru |date=2006-05-26 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> On March 31, 2005 Berezovsky submitted a claim to High Court of England to Mihkail Fridman for libel and asked for compensation. Since Mikhail Fridman was unable to provide any proof that Berezovsky threatened him, on May 26 2006 the jury ordered Fridman to pay Berezovsky GBP50,000. | |||
:::I removed this for now. Is anyone who ''strongly'' feels this should be included back? ] (]) 00:28, 11 February 2010 (UTC) | |||
===Criminal probe and arrest warrant in Brazil=== | |||
===Supporting terrorism accusations=== | |||
In May 2006 Berezovsky was detained for several hours in San Paolo airport and questioned about Media Sports Investment (MSI) group financial violations, which was a sponsor of the national Corinthians football club, local media reported. He was later allowed to leave the country.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://en.trend.az/news/world/wnews/956262.html |title=Trend News: Brazil issues arrest warrant for Berezovsky |publisher=En.trend.az |date=2007-07-13 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> | |||
I do not really object . But you should know that such accusations actually came from ]. Zakayev blamed Berezovsky during the period between two Chechen wars as ''an official representative of Russian government'' at this time. He said the Russian government supported (through Berezovsky) a number of international terrorists in Chechnya (old KGB cadres from the Middle East according to him) in order to undermine Chechen government. I do not know if this is true, but that was something he claimed and can be easily sourced.] (]) 02:37, 12 February 2010 (UTC) | |||
On July 12, 2007, a ]ian judge issued an arrest warrant for Berezovsky and a number of other British and Brazilian suspects in connection with an investigation against the Media Sports Investments group, which is suspected of money laundering.Berezovsky is accused of being the main financial backer of MSI. Since Berezovsky, ]ian-born ] and ] were not in Brazil at the time, warrants for their arrest were forwarded to ]. Berezovsky claimed that the Brazilian investigation was a part of the Kremlin's "politicized campaign" against him. Sao Paulo court demanded the detention of Mr Berezovsky and his associates over accusations that money had been laundered through the city's Corinthians football club. The order came after a two-year investigation into large quantities of cash allegedly pumped into the club by an investment group fronted by Mr Berezovsky's long-time associate, the Iranian-born businessman, Kia Joorabchian. A warrant has also been issued for the arrest of Mr Joorabchian, who allegedly oversaw the transfer of Carlos Tevez, an Argentinian football star, from the Corinthians to West Ham United. In the summary of a 15-page report released after the investigation, the Brazilian prosecutor Mr Carneiro said: "There is enough circumstantial evidence indicating that the MSI-Corinthians partnership is being used for the laundering of money, most of which was received from Boris Berezovsky, who is wanted (by Russian authorities) for crimes committed against the Russian financial system."<ref>{{cite web|last=Blomfield |first=Adrian |url=http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1557438/Brazilian-judge-orders-the-arrest-of-Berezovsky.html |title=Brazilian judge orders the arrest of Berezovsky |publisher=Telegraph |date=2007-07-14 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>, '']'', July 13, 2007</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-468161/Brazil-issues-arrest-warrant-Berezovsky-money-laundering-charges.html |title=Brazil issues arrest warrant for Berezovsky on money-laundering charges | Mail Online |publisher=Dailymail.co.uk |date=2007-07-16 |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref name=b>, ], July 13, 2007</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.kommersant.com/p-10999/r_500/Berezovsky_Brazil_Arrest/ |title=Brazilian Court Orders to Arrest Berezovsky - Kommersant Moscow |publisher=Kommersant.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|author=Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro and Saeed Shah |url=http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/jul/14/brazil.russia |title=Berezovsky wanted in Brazil for alleged money laundering | World news |publisher=The Guardian |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/jul/13/brazil.russia |title=Brazilian court seeks Berezovsky's arrest | World news | guardian.co.uk |publisher=Guardian |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> | |||
== cannot believe wiki allowed this article == | |||
===Investigation in Netherlands=== | |||
As a completely unbiased observer, this article reads like RUSSIAN 101 on how to write a smear/discredit campaign. I cannot believe that Wiki allows this type of biased article. I am incredibly disappointed. I am also surprised Wiki isn't handling a libel suit on this one. This article reads like a slanderous piece of writing coming straight from the mouth of the FSB. The Litvinenko section ALONE was enough to make me curious how the very basics were excluded in the "involvement" of Berezovsky- in fact, it was widely reported that Litvinenko and Berezovsky were friends. The article seems to concentrate on quite a bit of hearsay and "excluding important facts" to bring readers to false conclusions. Once again, incredibly surprised and disappointed. If I had not done extensive research on this subject matter, I may have been biased against Berezovsky without the basic relevant facts. <small><span class="autosigned">—Preceding ] comment added by ] (] • ]) 02:20, 13 May 2010 (UTC)</span></small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot--> | |||
In August 2007, the Russian Deputy Prosecutor General announced that the ] tax police had visited Moscow in connection with a ] and money laundering case involving Berezovsky. As Russian media were claiming<ref>, '']'', August 29, 2007</ref> that a criminal case had been initiated against Berezovsky in the Netherlands on a charge of money laundering, the Dutch prosecuting office or Openbaar Ministerie hastened to announce that he was not the object of any criminal investigation in the Netherlands, while Berezovsky himself responded by saying that he had no business in the Netherlands. Several Dutch newspapers counterclaimed that the name Boris Berezovsky was in fact mentioned in the handling and money laundering dossier,<ref>, '']'', August 30, 2007</ref> to which the Dutch prosecution officers in function refused to comment. | |||
:What is "Russian 101"? Nonetheless, I think this article does a good job at representing all the notable aspects of Berezovsky and his affairs, and is in line with mainstream documented views. What would you like added to the article? (please supply ]). As far as libel goes, there is nothing libelous in this article. Everything potentially contentious is properly sourced. ] (]) 02:34, 13 May 2010 (UTC) | |||
===Search in Berezovsky's castle in France=== | |||
== Neutrality? == | |||
On May 11, 2005 French Central Office for Fighting Major Financial Crime (OCRGDF) searched Cote d’-Azur castle of Berezovsky. The castle was searched in the course of investigation of Berezovsky’s suspected involvement in money laundering, AFP reported referring to the sources close to investigation.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://commersant.com/p576777/r_500/OCRGDF_Searches_French_Castle_of_Berezovsky/ |title=OCRGDF Searches French Castle of Berezovsky - Kommersant Moscow |publisher=Commersant.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref> | |||
==Allegations of funding terrorism== | |||
This article has a serious debt of neutral and unbias statements. Claims are made as if they where dogmatic truths, specifically in the the section "Business Career in Russia". In over 100, only 8 references are made and, almost all of them refer to the same source. Boris Berezovsky is refered to as "Berezovsky" and Vladimir Putin as "Mr. Putin". This seems very bias. Also, there are several accusations a subjective data that I don't think belong in an information source such as Misplaced Pages, which aims to provide only proven facts and not opinions or engage in any backstage political games. I think this article should be seriously revised. <span style="font-size: smaller;" class="autosigned">—Preceding ] comment added by ] (]) 18:55, 27 May 2010 (UTC)</span><!-- Template:UnsignedIP --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot--> | |||
There were persistent reports of Berezovsky sponsoring terrorists in Chechnya. In an interview to Forbes magazine Ichkeria's President Aslan Maskhadov referred to Boris Berezovsky as one of the persons most responsible for the war in the Caucasus.<ref>{{cite web|author=Paul Klebnikov, 11.01.99 |url=http://www.forbes.com/forbes/1999/1101/6411090a.html |title=Conflagration in Russia |publisher=Forbes.com |date= |accessdate=2010-06-11}}</ref><ref name="guardian-psj.ru"/> | |||
Yusup Soslambekov, chairman of the Confederation of the Peoples of the Caucasus, regarded Berezovsky as his personal enemy and threatened to disclose evidence of Berezovsky's involvement with certain Chechen warlords whom he hired to help him in his shady dealings with Chechnya's oil, drug trafficking, hostage-taking and similar pursuits. Soon after Yusup Soslambekov fell victim to a contract killing in Moscow. Even before that Akmal Saidov, who had also unearthed facts about Berezovsky's criminal activities in the Caucasus, was kidnapped; his body was later found.<ref name="guardian-psj.ru"/> | |||
-if you go to forbes website and type "berezovsky" and search you'll get a damn lot of articles which can be used as a source if necessary. they were just summed up in Paul Klebnikov book which is used as a source for part of "Business Career in Russia" section. Putin was only once referred as "Mr Putin", removed that. Again, all acusations are not on subjective data but come from official sources (including the book where everything is sourced). Unfortunately the book is only available for free in Russian language. But if you could buy it and read in English you'd see that everything in the book is referenced, and you'd just get a better understanding of how Berezovsky earned his millions. ] (]) 28 May 2010 | |||
According to Chechen President ], Boris Berezovsky encouraged Chechen warlords Shamil Basayev and Salman Raduyev to kidnap people so that Berezovsky could finance them by paying ransoms. Kadyrov said he personally witnessed the agreement. "He couldn’t just give money to the militants, so he invented this mechanism. In my presence, Berezovsky suggested to Raduev and Basaev: ‘Capture people and I’ll ransom them. I’ll get good publicity and you’ll get money.’ He paid millions of dollars to Basaev", ] said in an interview with ] in April, 2009.<ref name="kadyrov"></ref> Kadyrov also said he believed Berezovsky was behind the killing of journalist Anna Politkovskaya.<ref name="kadyrov"/> | |||
== NPOV and anti-semitic bias-Neutrality Tag == | |||
In early 2009, former Chechen separatist ], and brother of the notorious Chechen separatist field commander ], who was killed in 2001, referred to Berezovsky as "the extremists' bread winner".<ref name="switch"> ] Retrieved on July 23, 2009</ref> | |||
The principal source used for many contentious statements in this article is the procuratorial book by ], the murdered Russian-American journalist<Ref>http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1316/is_10_32/ai_66495297/?tag=content;col1</Ref>. Klebnikov's writings have been described as anti-semitically biased by independent observers in the mainstream media, such as the ] (http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/2004/jul/16/guardianobituaries.pressandpublishing) and ] (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/obituaries/paul-klebnikov-550099.html). Here is, for example, a quote from a review in ]: "Although Klebnikov assiduously avoids the word "Jew," an aroma of old, almost religious, anti-Semitism emerges from each page in the book" (http://www.haaretz.com/weekend/week-s-end/ogling-the-moguls-1.144261). | |||
Berezovsky said that he had a conversation with the Chechen ] leader ] in 1999, six months before the beginning of ].<ref name="Dissident">], with ] '']'', The Free Press, 2007, ISBN 1-416-55165-4, page 216.</ref> A transcript of the phone conversation between Berezovsky and Udugov was leaked to one of Moscow tabloids on September 10, 1999.<ref>"Death of a Dissident", page 189.</ref> Udugov proposed to start the Dagestan war to provoke the Russian response, topple the Chechen president Aslan Maskhadov and establish a new Islamic republic of Basayev-Udugov that would be friendly to Russia. Berezovsky asserted that he refused the offer, but "Udugov and Basayev conspired with ] and Putin to provoke a war to topple Maskhadov ... but the agreement was for the Russian army to stop at the ]. However, Putin double-crossed the Chechens and started an all-out war."<ref name="Dissident"/> | |||
Unless Klebnikov's allegations can be independently verified they should be taken with a grain of salt. <small><span class="autosigned">— Preceding ] comment added by ] (] • ]) 15:54, 30 July 2011 (UTC)</span></small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot--> | |||
==Exile in Britain== | |||
*I think that the alleged personal features of Mr. Khlebnikov being them e.g. an irrational fear of Jews (anti-Semitism), fear of open spaces (agarophobia), substance abuse, etc. belong to his own article not to the article on the subjects. Khlebnikov wrote most of his articles for ], quite a reputable publication with a good fact-checking facilities. At the time of publications Berezovsky was known as a litigious with almost unlimited financial resources and a good rapport with all ] organs of Russian Federation. We can safely assume that every Khlebnikov's work published by Forbes was triply fact checked by their fact checkers. ] (]) 00:39, 31 July 2011 (UTC) | |||
In 1999 Russia opened investigations into Berezovsky's business activities. Fearing arrest, Berezovsky fled to London in 2001, where he was granted ], which infuriated the Russian authorities. He has been charged with ] and ], but British courts have rejected all three attempts to get him extradited to Russia.<ref name=time>]'', February 8, 2007</ref> From his new home in the U.K., he has strongly criticized the current Russian administration. | |||
In 2003 Boris Berezovsky formally changed his name to Platon Elenin ("Platon" being ] for ], and Elena is the name of his wife) in the British courts. No reason has been given - but Platon is the name of the lead character in a film '']'' based on his life. In December 2003 he was allowed to travel under his new name to ], provoking a row between Russia and Georgia. | |||
**In fact Berezovsky has sued Forbes for libel, and obtained a retraction. Repeating these libelous claims here contradicts ] and ] policy ] (]) 01:08, 1 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
In recent years, Berezovsky has gone into business with ], the younger brother of the ] ]. Berezovsky has been an investor in Bush's ], an educational software corporation, since at least 2003. In 2005, Neil Bush met with Berezovsky in ], causing tension with Russia due to Berezovsky's ] status.<ref>, '']'', Sep 23, 2005</ref> Neil Bush has also been seen in Berezovsky's box at the ], the home of British football club ], for a game.<ref>, '']'', September 5, 2006</ref> There has been speculations that the relationship may cause tension in Russo-American bilateral relations.<ref>, '']'', October 06, 2005</ref> | |||
*The claim that Klebnikov is an anti-Semitist doesn't make any sense to me either. In none of his articles or books he points attention to (or even mentions, I think) the nationality of Berezovsky. Actually Klebnikov published a book "Conversation with a barbarian" in 2004, where he interviewed Chechen terrorist leader Khozh-Ahmed Noukhayev and provided his own opinion and discourse about nationalities afterwards, which was to a large extent anti-Islamic but there was not even a sign of anti-Semitism. With all due respect, some Israeli people have a habit of calling themselves victims of anti-Semitism when any Israeli person is accused of something, even if it actually happens without any anti-Semitic grounds at all. Like this case - all accusations are of criminal nature, and nationality isn't mentioned anywhere. ] (]) 23:00, 31 July 2011 (UTC) | |||
It has been reported that Berezovsky's funds may have depleted rapidly with the onset of the ].<ref></ref> It may well be true as Berezovsky never proved his ability to manage any assets and was always best at just taking companies' cashflows under control by liaising with the senior management and making those firms which did not formally belong to him his cash cows.<ref name="dermokratizatsiya2003"/> | |||
**The antisemitism of Klebnikov has been noted by reputable, independent third party sources quoted above. The very fact that his antisemitic bias has been discussed in three major newspapers is important in this context because Klebnikov's writings constitute the principal basis for contentious statements that make this article inconsistent with NPOV policy, inaccurate, poorly sourced and potentially libelous. I reinstated the POV tag, and will put back the passage on antisemitism that has been removed. ], please do not remove the tag before the issue is settled - it is against the rules.--] (]) 01:05, 1 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
On February 19, 2009, ] quoted another former Chechen separatist leader who switched sides, ], as accusing Berezovsky of financing the First ] of the ] ], ], as well as the late separatist warlord ], and of broadcasting "] ideas." He alleged that Berezovsky had financed "illegal armed unit" leaders "under the guise of paying ransoms for hostages" as well as the Kavkaz television channel, which he referred to as a "Wahhabi mouthpiece."<ref name="switch"/> Khambiyev also alleged that Berezovsky "personally" handed Basaev $1 million upon arriving in ] after the first Chechen military campaign. He was quoted as saying ''"I asked Basayev why Berezovsky had given the money and why Basaev accepted it. He answered that Berezovsky was afraid of him and therefore paid the money"''. Khambiyev said that it later turned out that Berezovsky had actually given Basayev $2 million while in Ingushetia.<ref name="switch"/> | |||
***Those independent third party sources (which are not actually "major" newspapers) aren't related at all to Russia and cannot have reliable opinion on Klebnikov. I'd like to reiterate that some Israeli people start to shout 'Antisemitism!!!" every time an Israeli person is attacked, and no matter whether he's really guilty or not. Please do not execute vandalism and do not remove whole sections from the article, all of which are supported by media articles (from indeed _major_ newspapers such as Forbes Russia etc) | |||
==Berezovsky's exile statements== | |||
== Unwarranted deletion - request for dispute resolution == | |||
===Appeals for regime change=== | |||
In September 2005, Berezovsky said in an interview with the ]: "I'm sure that Putin doesn't have the chance to survive, even to the ]. I am doing everything in my power to limit his time frame, and I am really thinking of returning to Russia after Putin collapses, which he will."<ref name=los> ] Retrieved on April 5, 2008</ref> In January 2006, Berezovsky stated in an interview to a Moscow-based radio station that he was working on overthrowing the administration of Vladimir Putin by force.<ref>{{ru icon}} , ], 25.01.2006</ref> Berezovsky has also publicly accused Putin of being "a ]"<ref>, '']'', September 4, 2008</ref> and the "terrorist number one".<ref></ref> | |||
On April 13, 2007, in an interview with the British newspaper '']'', Berezovsky declared that he is plotting the violent overthrow of President Putin by financing and encouraging coup plotters in Moscow: "We need to use force to change this regime. It isn't possible to change this regime through democratic means. There can be no change without force, pressure."'<ref>, '']'', April 13, 2007</ref> He also admitted that during the last six years he struggled much to "destroy the positive image of Putin" and said that "Putin has created an ] against the ].... I don't know how it will happen, but authoritarian regimes only collapse by force."<ref>, ], April 13, 2007</ref> Berezovsky said he had dedicated much of the last six years to "trying to destroy the positive image of Putin" that many in the west held, portraying him whenever possible as a dangerously anti-democratic figure.<ref name="plotting"/> | |||
User ] removed a later version of the lead section, which I have edited for ] and ], and replaced it with an older version, restoring the text that has been much criticized as biased, poorly sourced and potentially libelous as can be seen from this talk page. Such removal it totally inappropriate. I reinstated my version, and invite members of the community to comment.--] (]) 00:48, 1 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
] in ]; The Other Russia organizers said that this slogan was a ] carried out by pro-government youth groups<ref>{{ru icon}} </ref>]] | |||
== Removal of poorly sourced potentially libellous statements == | |||
Soon after Berezovsky's 2007 statement, ], an important leader of the opposition movement ] and leader of the ], wrote the following on his website: "Berezovsky has lived in emigration for many years and no longer has significant influence upon the political processes which take place in Russian society. His extravagant proclamations are simply a method of attracting attention. Furthermore, for the overwhelming majority of Russians he is a political symbol of the 90s, one of the "bad blokes" enriching themselves behind the back of president Yeltsin. The informational noise around Berezovsky is specifically beneficial for the Kremlin, which is trying to compromise Russia's real opposition. Berezovsky has not had and does not have any relation to Other Russia or the United Civil Front."<ref>{{ru icon}} , ], 18.04.2007</ref></blockquote> Berezovsky responded in June 2007 by saying that "there is not one significant politician in Russia whom he has not financed" and that this included members of Other Russia. The managing director of the United Civil Front, in turn, said that the organization would consider suing Berezovsky over these allegations.<ref>, ], 28/ 06/ 2007</ref>, but the lawsuit has never been brought before the court. | |||
As per consultation with a legal expert I removed wrongful, poorly sourced and potentially libellous statements, which create an impression that the subject may have been involved in violent crime and linked to organised crime, as follows. | |||
The Russian Prosecutor General's Office has launched a criminal investigation against Berezovsky to find whether his comments can be considered a "seizure of power by force", as outlined in the ]. If convicted, an offender is facing up to 20 years of imprisonment. The ] denounced Berezovsky's statements, warning him that his status of a political refugee may be reconsidered, should he continue to make similar remarks. Furthermore, ] had announced that it would investigate whether Berezovsky's statements were in violation of the law.<ref>, '']'', April 14, 2007</ref><ref>, '']'', April 14, 2007</ref> However in the following July, the ] announced that Berezovsky would not face charges in the UK for his comments. Kremlin officials called it a "disturbing moment" in ].<ref>, '']'', March 20, 2008</ref> | |||
1. Allegation that the subject may have been involved in the murder of ]. | |||
==Alleged assassination attempts in London== | |||
The subject has never been charged or been a suspect in the investigation in this case. The statement that Klebnikov "was afraid" of the subject, which is attributed to a third party, is a hearsay, which does not meet the ] standard | |||
===Alleged 2003 plot=== | |||
According to ], a Russian ] (SVR) agent in London was making preparations to assassinate Berezovsky with a ] in September 2003. This alleged plot was reported to British police.<ref name="dissident">] and Marina Litvinenko. '']: The Poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko and the Return of the KGB'', The Free Press (2007) ISBN 1-416-55165-4</ref> ], then a ] Minister, said that inquiries made were "unable to either substantiate this information or find evidence of any criminal offences having been committed".<ref>, ], 13 Jan 2004</ref> Berezovsky in turn later accused Putin of ordering the deadly ].<ref>, '']'', 19/11/2006</ref> | |||
This was not the first alleged plot to murder Berezovsky that had been announced by Litvinenko. On November 17, 1998, during the period that Vladimir Putin was the ], five high-ranking officers of FSB's Directorate for the Analysis of Criminal Organisations appeared at a ] in the Russian ] news agency. The officers, including the then-] Litvinenko, accused the head of the Directorate and his deputy of ordering them to assassinate Boris Berezovsky and the FSB officer ] in November 1997. | |||
2. Allegations that the subject may have been involved in the murder of ] or was linked to mafia. | |||
These allegations were the subject of a libel suit against ] in London, as the result of which Forbes made a statement in the open court and printed the following retraction: "(1) it was not the magazine's intention to state that Berezovsky was responsible for the murder of Listiev, only that he had been included in an inconclusive police investigation of the crime; (2) there is no evidence that Berezovsky was responsible for this or any other murder; (3) in light of the English court's ruling, it was wrong to characterize Berezovsky as a mafia boss". Therefore, repeating these disavowed allegations here is potentially libellous and contrary to ] policy. | |||
===Alleged 2007 plot=== | |||
3. Allegation that the subject may have threatened ]. | |||
In June 2007 Berezovsky said he fled Britain on the advice of Scotland Yard, amid reports that he was the target of an assassination attempt by a suspected Russian ]. On July 18, 2007, British ] '']'' reported that the alleged would-be assassin was captured by the police at the ] in ].<ref name="foil">, '']'', July 18, 2007</ref><ref name=ooo>, ], 18 July 2007</ref> They reported that the suspect, arrested by the anti-terrorist police after being tracked for a week by ], was ] back to Russia when no weapons were found and there was not enough evidence to charge him with any offence.<ref>, '']'', 29 November 2007</ref> In addition, they said British police placed a squad of uniformed officers around the Chechen ] ]'s house in north London, and also phoned Litvinenko's widow, Marina, to urge her to take greater security precautions.<ref name=g>, '']'', July 22, 2007</ref> Russia's ] to the UK, ], said he was not aware of any such plot and told ]'s ] there was "nothing that could confirm" the plot, although British police did confirm that they had arrested a suspect in an alleged murder plot.<ref name="police"/> | |||
Berezovsky said he was told the assassin would be someone he knew, who would shoot him in the head and then surrender to the police. He again accused Vladimir Putin of being behind a plot to assassinate him.<ref>, '']'', 23/07/200</ref> The Kremlin has denied similar claims in the past.<ref name="police">, '']'', July 19, 2007</ref> According to '']'', there is speculation that Berezovsky leaked details of the alleged attempt to kill him to the media to antagonise Moscow, once the British authorities had returned the suspected hitman to Moscow. The timing of the story has also been seen as suspicious, coming in the middle of a row over Britain's attempts to charge a Russian businessman and former security agent, ], with Litvinenko's murder.<ref name=g/> | |||
This allegation was the subject of a ] suit in London, which has ruled that it was libelous. Therefore it should not be repeated here as per ] | |||
According to the interview given by a high-ranking British security official to the ] in July 2008, the alleged Russian agent, known as "A", was of a Chechen nationality.<ref>{{pl icon}} , ], 08.07.2008</ref> He was identified by ''Kommersant'' as the Chechen ] ]; after returning to Russia, Atlangeriyev ] in January 2008 by the unknown men in Moscow.<ref>, '']'', July 09, 2008</ref> | |||
4. Allegations of plotting murders by subject's political opponents. | |||
==Involvement in Alexander Litvinenko affair== | |||
The allegations from ] and ] were never followed by any investigation. Given the fact that both of them were prominent political opponents of the subject, repeating their groundless and potentially libellous statements here contradicts policy on ]. | |||
<!-- Image with inadequate rationale removed: ]]] --> | |||
{{Main|Alexander Litvinenko poisoning}} | |||
Many publications in Russian media suggested that the death of ] was connected to Berezovsky.<ref>{{cite web | |||
5.Allegations of links with terror groups, hostage trading and of funding terrorists. | |||
| last = Weaver | |||
| first = John | |||
| title = Mafia Hit On The Media | |||
| work = | |||
| publisher = Atlantic Free Press | |||
| date = 24 November 2006 | |||
| url = http://www.atlanticfreepress.com/content/view/262/ | |||
| accessdate = 2006-11-26 }}</ref><ref>{{ru icon}}{{cite web | |||
| last = Alexeev | |||
| first = Petr | |||
| title = Politkovskaya, Litvinenko, who is next? | |||
| work = | |||
| publisher = Electorat. Info | |||
| date = 24 November 2006 | |||
| url = http://www.electorat.info/oligarx/22196-1/ | |||
| accessdate = 2006-11-26 }}</ref> Former FSB chief ], for whom Litvinenko worked, said that the incident "looks like the hand of Berezovsky. I am sure that no kind of ] participated."<ref>{{ru icon}}{{cite web | |||
| last = | |||
| first = | |||
| title = Who orchestrated plan to discredit Russia? | |||
| work = | |||
| publisher = ] | |||
| date = 25 November 2006 | |||
| url = http://www.kommersant.ru/doc-y.html?docId=724957&issueId=30261 | |||
| accessdate = 2006-11-26 }}</ref> This involvement of Berezovsky was alleged by numerous Russian television shows. Kremlin supporters saw it as a conspiracy to smear Russian government's reputation by engineering a spectacular murder of a Russian dissident abroad.<ref name=wash> ] Retrieved on April 6, 2008</ref> | |||
After Litvinenko's death, traces of ] were found in an office of Berezovsky.<ref name="Polonium 210">{{cite web | |||
These allegations, which are sourced to the smear campaign in the Russian state-controlled media, refer to the subject's official dealings with Chechens during his tenure as the Deputy head of Russia's National Security Council in the Yeltsin administration. These included hostage release negotiations, and funding of the separatist government under the provisions of the 1997 Peace Treaty, which the subject helped to negotiate. These allegations should be mentioned (I included them in the Allegations section) but not presented in a potentially slanderous form they were <small><span class="autosigned">— Preceding ] comment added by ] (] • ]) 11:36, 1 August 2011 (UTC)</span></small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot--> | |||
| last = Hall | |||
| first = Ben | |||
| title = Polonium 210 found at Berezovsky's office | |||
| work = | |||
| publisher = ] | |||
| date = November 28, 2006 | |||
| url = http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15923659/ | |||
| accessdate = 2006-12-01 }}</ref> Russian prosecutors were not allowed to investigate the office.<ref></ref> Russian authorities have also been unable to question Berezovsky. The Foreign Ministry complained that Britain was obstructing its attempt to send prosecutors to London to interview more than 100 people, including Berezovsky.<ref> ] Retrieved on April 6, 2008</ref> | |||
==Alleged involvement in the 2004 Ukraine presidential election== | |||
*All of those allegations are properly attributed and not represented as facts. Most of them are done at the time Berezovsky was a prominent member of the governing elite, not a dissident so the question of government-orchestrated attacks on a dissident are not particular actual there. I have restored the romavals ] (]) 22:47, 1 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
In September 2005, soon after the ] led by prime minister ] was dismissed by president ], former president of Ukraine ] accused Berezovsky of financing Yushchenko's presidential election campaign, and provided copies of documents showing money transfers from companies he said are controlled by Berezovsky to companies controlled by Yuschenko's official backers. Berezovsky has confirmed that he met Yushchenko's representatives in London before the election, and that the money was transferred from his companies, but he refused to confirm or deny that the companies that received the money were used in Yushchenko's campaign. Financing of election campaigns by foreign citizens is illegal in Ukraine.<ref>{{ru icon}} , ], 15.09.2005</ref> In September 2007, Berezovsky launched ]s against two Ukrainian politicians, ], a former presidential aid, and ], a former emergencies minister.<ref>, ], September 3, 2007</ref> Berezovsky is suing the men for nearly US$23 million, accusing them of misusing the money he had allocated in 2004 to fund Ukraine's ]. | |||
===2010 Ukraine presidential election=== | |||
**You have reinstated poorly sourced, potentially libelous information, which I had removed. I removed the contentious text for the second time in accord with BLP policy and am reporting the issue to the ].--] (]) 00:44, 2 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
Berezovsky called on the Ukrainian business to support Yushchenko at the ] of January 2010 as a guarantor of debarment of property redistribution after the election.<ref name=welcome>, ] (December 10, 2009)</ref> | |||
On December 10, 2009 the ] ] stated that if the ] would request it Berezovsky would be detained after arriving in Ukraine.<ref name=welcome/> | |||
*** user ] keeps executing acts of vandalism on the page. restored original page <small><span class="autosigned">— Preceding ] comment added by ] (] • ]) 20:57, 2 August 2011 (UTC)</span></small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot--> | |||
==See also== | |||
== Unwarranted deletion by Kolokol1 - request for dispute resolution == | |||
*] - former business partner sued by Berezovsky for approximately $4 billion over the Sibneft share-and business blackmail affair. | |||
*] - important intermediary between Boris Berezovsky and Roman Abramovich who was reportedly paid $500 million by Abramovich for protecting him. | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
*] | |||
==References== | |||
User ] has removed several large sections of the article at his own discretion claiming they're "not supported" by proper links or are "libelous". when they're not represented as facts but only as allegations. when in fact he's using very doubtful links and opinions, such as claims by some Indian professor who can't have any idea about Berezovsky's life in Russia, etcetc ] (]) 23:00, 31 July 2011 (UTC) | |||
{{Reflist|2}} | |||
*I insist the the material in question is questionably sourced and potentially libelous - particularly in view of two successful libel suits brought about by the subject over these same issues. By reinstating the contentious material for the second time you are committing a major offence as per BLP policy. I am therefore reporting the matter to the BLP noticeboard and request intervention by the Misplaced Pages administration <small><span class="autosigned">— Preceding ] comment added by ] (] • ]) 22:44, 2 August 2011 (UTC)</span></small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot--> | |||
**I insist in turn that material in question is very well sourced. It doesn's assert any facts but passeds accusations, which have right to exist. By repeated vandalism you're committing a major offence as per BLP policy. I've also reported the issue to the noticeboard and hope that Misplaced Pages Administration in turn will prevent vandalism from being repeated on this page.] (]) 23:29, 2 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
==External links== | |||
== Repeated insertion of potentially libelous text. == | |||
* , '']'', Mar. 03, 1997 | |||
* , ], July 24, 2000 | |||
* , ], October 2003 | |||
* , ], 27 September 2005 | |||
* , '']'', 25 November 2006 | |||
* , ], 31 May 2007 | |||
* at '']'' | |||
{{Start box}} | |||
Users ] and ] repeatedly reinsert poorly sourced potentially libelous material, which has been removed in accord with the BLP policy. The matter has been reported to BLP noticeboard. In the meantime, will keep restoring the version, which is balanced and corresponds to NPOV.--] (]) 23:19, 2 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
{{Succession box|before=]|after=] (acting) |years= April 29, 1998 – March 4, 1999|title=Executive Secretary of ]}} | |||
{{End box}} | |||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Berezovsky, Boris}} | |||
== Repeated vandalism by user Kolokol1. == | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
User ] repeatedly deletes well sourced (with links to widely recognized newspapers such as Forbes magazine) material, and even whole sections of the page. Comes up with absurd and unfounded accusations of antisemitism to former Forbes Russia general editor. Will keep restoring the original version which corresponds to NPOV. reported issue to BLP noticeboard ] (]) 23:25, 2 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] | |||
] |
Revision as of 20:52, 3 August 2011
This article is about the Russian businessman. For the Russian pianist, see Boris Berezovsky (pianist).Boris Berezovsky | |
---|---|
Boris Berezovsky, 2007 | |
Born | (1946-01-23) January 23, 1946 (age 78) Moscow, USSR |
The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (July 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this message) |
Boris Abramovich Berezovsky (Template:Lang-ru; also known as Platon Elenin; born January 23, 1946) is a Russian businessman, mathematician, member of Russian Academy of Sciences, who was accused of numerous crimes in Russia and sentenced to several years of imprisonment in absentia. Despite the fact that arrest warrant has been issued to Interpol by Russian and Brazilian authorities, Berezovsky is currently a political refugee in Britain, that refused to extradition requests from Russia several times so far.
He is best known for his role as a Russian oligarch, media tycoon and infamous politician during the presidency of Boris Yeltsin in the 1990s. He has been described by critics as the epitome of Russian "robber capitalism", but he denies having ever taken part in the violence and crime that tainted Russian business during that era. Berezovsky was at the height of his power in the later Yeltsin years, when he was deputy secretary of Russia's security council, a friend of Boris Yeltsin's daughter Tatyana Dyachenko, and a member of the Yeltsin inner circle, or "family".
Berezovsky made his fortune by capturing state assets at knockdown prices during Russia's rush towards privatisation in very questionable ways. He took ownership of the Sibneft oil company and became the main shareholder in the country's main television channel, ORT, which he turned into a propaganda vehicle for Boris Yeltsin in the run-up to the 1996 presidential election. It is said that, in contrast to Russian entrepreneurs such as Vladimir Gusinsky, Berezovsky did not enrich any of the enterprises with which he became involved or took over (e.g. Sibneft, ORT, the car dealership Avtovaz, Omsk Oil Refinery, National Sports Fund, and aluminum smelters Bratsk, Krasnoyarsk, and Novokuznetsk), but instead drained them of cash. Although he helped Vladimir Putin enter the "family", and funded the party that formed Putin's parliamentary base, Putin moved to regain control of the ORT television station and to curb the political ambitions of Russia's oligarchs, who were extremely unpopular with the Russian public.
Following the ascent of Putin to the Russian presidency, Berezovsky went into opposition and fled the country after being accused of defrauding a regional government of US$13 million. He was later granted political asylum in the United Kingdom. He has since publicly stated that he is on a mission to bring down Putin "by force". In the UK, he became associated with Akhmed Zakayev, Alexander Litvinenko and Alex Goldfarb in what has become known as "the London Circle" of Russian exiles. He is a founder of International Foundation for Civil Liberties.
In 2007, a Moscow court found Berezovsky guilty of massive embezzlement in absentia. He was sentenced to six years in jail and ordered to repay the $9 million that the court said he had stolen from the state airline Aeroflot. He has also been accused by Russian authorities of being involved in the murders of several leading critics of the Putin's government, including Litvinenko and journalist Anna Politkovskaya, in an attempt to destabilize the country and discredit Putin. In response, Berezovsky - amongst others - has attributed the killings to the Putin's government as a means of political intimidation. Arrest warrants for him have been issued in Russia and Brazil for allegations of fraud, embezzlement, and money laundering. Berezovsky has been under investigation by Swiss federal prosecutors for money laundering since 1999.
In 2007 Brazil has issued an arrest warrant to Interpol against Berevozsky on accusations of money laundering through a football club.
Berezovsky survived an assassination attempt in 1994 unharmed. Berezovsky claims that there have been several other assassination attempts directed against him, which he accuses Russian agents of carrying out.
Berezovsky has been married four times and has six children.
Early life and scientific research
Berezovsky was born in 1946 in Moscow to Abram Markovich Berezovsky, a Jewish civil engineer in construction works, and his wife Anna Gelman. He studied forestry and then applied mathematics, receiving his doctorate in 1983. After graduating from the Moscow Forestry Engineering Institute in 1968, Berezovsky worked as an engineer, from 1969 till 1987 filling the positions of an assistant research officer, research officer and finally the head of a department in the Institute of Management Problems of the USSR Academy of Sciences. Berezovsky did research on optimization and control theory, publishing 16 books and articles between 1975 and 1989; his Erdős number is 4.
Business career in Russia
The foundation of his fortune lay in an arrangement Berezovski forged with the management of Avtovaz, the huge and ramshackle Russian car maker. In exchange for cutting senior management into the action, he was able to get cars straight off the assembly line for far less than the cost of production, which he then sold at immense profit through his newly founded chain of auto dealerships. The factory workers paid the difference by going without pay for months on end.
The early '90s, when Berezovsky was getting under way, was the time of the great gang wars in Moscow, as rival criminal coalitions shot it out for control of key industries and businesses. Businessmen could only ward off extortion or worse by paying one or other criminal group for a "roof"--protection. On one side in the most important war stood the Chechen mafia, much feared for their ruthlessness, and impenetrable to outsiders. On the other were the "Slavic alliance," native Russian gangsters determined to fight off the Chechen threat. It appears that Berezovsky forged an alliance with the Chechen forces, who provided his roof, a connection that would have terrible consequences in years to come. In the meantime, his fearsome allies took him through some tough times, such as the bloody gun battle on Lenin Prospekt outside one of his showrooms in 1993, or, more seriously, the detonation of a large bomb beside his passing car, which killed his bodyguard, decapitated his driver, and left him badly wounded. In a week, several people were arrested from the criminal group headed by Sergey Timofeyev (also known as "Silvestr"). The Moscow Trade Bank controlled by that group shortly returned some funds it owned to Berezovski's conglomerate. In about three months (September 14, 1994) Sergey Timofeev was killed by a car explosion, organizers of which have never been found.
By 1994, Berezovsky had moved beyond dependence on mobster protection. He had forged a more potent alliance by paying for the publication of Boris Yeltsin's memoirs, thus gaining entree to the inner circle around the grateful author/president. This court was populated with strange figures, such as the "hippie journalist" Valentin Yumashev, through whom Berezovsky obtained his entree; Yeltsin's tennis coach, who ran a large criminal empire of his own from a Kremlin office; not to mention Alexander Korzhakov, for a while the powerful chief of Yeltsin's Praetorian guard who later reported that Berezovsky had asked him to kill a business rival. Korzhakov performed great services to history by his assiduous bugging of everyone's phones, leaking the tapes when it seemed useful, and by his forthcoming reminiscences once he had fallen from his master's graces.
Once inside "the family," Berezovsky masterfully parlayed political connections into cash. Key to his modus operandi was the realization (shared by many of his peers in the rising business oligarchy) that it was not necessary to control a business, simply its cash flow. In a remarkably candid 1996 interview with Klebnikov he termed this approach the "privatization of profit" A fascinating chapter lays out in detail, complete with the transcripts of bugged phone Calls, how this method was successfully applied to the looting of Aeroflot, the formerly profitable state airline. Thanks in part to the appointment of Yeltsin's son-in-law as the company's head, Berezovsky was able to siphon off huge chunks of Aeroflot's considerable hard currency earnings through a series of shell companies in Switzerland.
From aviation, Berezovsky moved on to the really big money in Russia—oil. His entry into the oil business was facilitated by the most egregious of all the great ripoffs that have charactarized post-Soviet Russia, the "loans for shares" scheme by which our hero and his fellow oligarchs helped themselves to priceless chunks of the country's resources, for pennies on the dollar, in return for financing Yeltsin's re-election in 1996. Following that free, but hardly fair, election, the godfathers increased his political profile, taking various high-level government posts (without of course ceasing his business operations for a second). It was at this time that his interest in Chechen matters re-emerged, in the form of lavish ransom payments to kidnappers in Chechnya for the retrieval of their victims. Klebnikov points out that this flow of money to the gangs in the devastated territory effectively made it impossible for the elected Chechen leader to stabilize his country. The consequent anarchy, culminating in the invasion of Dagestan in the summer of 1999 by fundamentalist Islamist Chechens, provided the backdrop for the second Chechen war and the rise to power of Vladimir Putin. Klebnikov suspends judgment as to whether any of the leadership in Moscow had a hand in the terrorist bombings in the capital that provided the final pretext for the invasion of Chechnya last year, although George Soros has been less demure, heavily hinting in an article in the New York Review of Books that Berezovsky deliberately fomented the war in furtherance of his political intrigues.
During the presidency of Boris Yeltsin from 1991 to 1999, Berezovsky was among the businessmen who gained access to the president. He acquired stakes in state companies including AutoVAZ, Aeroflot, and several oil properties that he (together with Roman Abramovich) organized into Sibneft. Berezovsky established a bank to finance his operations and acquired several news media holdings as well. Berezovsky was a leading proponent of political and economic liberalization in Russia. He has frequently entered into politics by getting control over the media sources (his holdings included the television channels ORT and TV6 (for which he paid almost nothing but gained control over them with the help of Boris Eltsin), and newspapers Nezavisimaya Gazeta, Novye Izvestiya and Kommersant), financing political candidates, making political statements, and even seeking office himself. His media holdings provided essential support for Yeltsin's re-election in 1996. Berezovsky famously boasted how he was part of a small coterie of so-called oligarchs who owned 50 per cent of Russia's wealth.
Later, when in exile, Berezovsky had to fight legal battles over his holdings. According to New York Times, there is a suspicion that Berezovsky's later critical activities against the Russian government could simply be an attempt to orchestrate a political crisis for Putin and win political asylum in Britain as a means to protect permanently the wealth he carved out of Russia in the early days, when the pickings were easy.
Political career
Berezovsky was briefly executive secretary of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) and later a member of the State Duma (Russia's lower house of parliament) from 1999 to July 2000. He survived several assassination attempts,.
In the position of the deputy secretary of the Security Council of Russia, he was also involved in talks on freeing Russian and foreign hostages kidnapped in Chechnya and allegedly transferred large sums of money in exchange for hostages. Berezovsky admitted, that in 1997, he gave $2 million of his own money to Chechen field commander Shamil Basayev, who was then Prime Minister of Chechnya. The money was intended for restoration of a cement factory, he said, but he admitted it might have been used for other purposes. Berezovsky had strong ties with Chechens in Moscow. According to Paul Klebnikov book "Godfather of Kremlin Boris Berezovsky or looting of Russia", those connections came from Berezovsky's close relations with Chechen mafia, whom he paid for protection against other mafia gangs in early 90s. He said that he "saved at least fifty people, who otherwise would have been killed; most of them were simple soldiers. And believe me, all of this was strictly official, with the full knowledge and consent of the Kremlin." However, Chechen president Aslan Maskhadov accused Berezovsky and the Russian government of collusion with the hostage-takers.
The first assault against Berezovsky was launched during Primakov's premiership, when Berezovsky was accused of money laundering when he was at the head of Aeroflot. However, in the event it was Primakov who was dismissed.
According to Alex Goldfarb, an associate of Berezovsky and Litvinenko, in 1999 Berezovsky secured Vladimir Putin's appointment to the Prime Minister position as a result of a secret agreement, where Putin promised his loyalty to Yeltsin and his closest circle including Berezovsky himself. In June 2000 The Times reported that Spanish police discovered Putin secretly visited a villa in Spain belonging to Berezovsky on up to five different occasions in 1999. According to Ramzan Kadyrov, Berezovsky was strongly opposed to the Second Chechen War but nevertheless supported Putin's 2000 presidential campaign. Just before the March 2000 elections, The New Yorker wrote, "Berezovsky unleashed a propaganda blitz that obliterated the opposition as surely as Russia's tanks obliterated Grozny." At least two candidates who were widely felt to have a reasonable chance of winning over Putin - the mayor of Moscow, Yuri Luzhkov, and the former premier Yevgeny Primakov - were swiftly eliminated through an elaborate smear campaign. However, according to Goldfarb, Putin later broke the agreement with Berezovsky, allegedly when he was infuriated by the critical coverage of the Russian submarine Kursk explosion by ORT TV channel owned by Berezovsky. Putin forced Berezovsky to sell his ORT shares, partly in exchange for promising to free Nikolai Glushkov, a former manager of Aeroflot company and close associate of Berezovsky, according to Goldfarb.
Mark Kramer, Director of the Harvard Project on Cold War Studies and a Senior Associate at the Davis Center for Russian Studies at Harvard University, asserts that Berezovsky is "consumed by greed and very short tempered. He is not the type of person that most people would want as a friend."
Stefanie Marsh of The Times wrote in 2007, that Berezovsky was one of the architects of Putin's rise to power and has spent the intervening years grinding an axe about his fall from grace.
Allegations and convictions of criminal activity
Crime accusations in Forbes article, murders of Paul Klebnikov and Vlad Listyev, interrogation by Russian police in 1995
A 1996 Forbes magazine article titled Godfather of the Kremlin?, by the Russian-American journalist Paul Klebnikov, portrayed Berezovsky as a mafiya boss who had his rivals murdered, and was involved in fraud, money laundering and had connections with Chechen mafia. In his article among other things Klebnikov accused Berezovsky of organizing murder of Vlad Listyev, notorious Russian anchorman whose TV show was the first one to start openly criticizing communism ideology in 1988 and was the most popular by ratings in Russia even 7 years after. Berezovsky was interrogated by police and accepted the fact, that one day before Vlad Listyev was killed he passed US$100,000 to one of the mafia leaders known as Nikolai. Berezovsky acknowledged having passed the money to mafia, but said that he passed the money to Nikolay in order to find out who arranged an assassination attempt on himself a year ago (in 1994). Berezovsky had a great influence on Boris Yeltsin whom he indirectly sponsored by donating on publishing of his autobiography and establishing friendly relationships (often by indirectly sponsoring their activities) with most people who surrounded the president, including his daughter Tatyana Dyachenko (whom he may have earned hundreds of millions of dollars), and convinced Yeltsin that he was an innocent victim of someone else's plot. President support helped Berezovsky to stop criminal investigation against him.
A few months after the article in Forbes was published, Berezovsky sued the magazine for libel (in February 1997) in British court. In 2003 the court ruled that Forbes remove one statement from the article, as it didn't have enough evidence to support the claim that Berezovsky arranged murder of famous anchorman and TV producer Vlad Listyev. The court didn't order Forbes to remove the rest of the article from the website nor acknowledge that all data contained in it was false, nor forced Forbes to pay a compensation, that Berezovsky wanted when filing his claim. The article is still available online on the Forbes website (with exception of one above mentioned statement). Some media sources controlled by Berezovsky though, such as Kommersant magazine, reported, that Forbes "lost the case" and "completely retracted their claims against Berezovsky" which actually never happened. Berezovsky never contested in court the book "Godfather of the Kremlin: Boris Berezovsky and the looting of Russia" that Klebnikov published in 2000, which was a very extended version of the article.
On July 9, 2004, Klebnikov was attacked on a Moscow street late at night by unknown assailants who fired at least nine shots from a slowly moving car. Klebnikov was shot four times and initially survived, but he bled to death in the hospital because the ambulance took almost an hour to come, it had no oxygen bottle, and the hospital elevator that was taking him to the operating room broke. Before he died, Klebnikov described that there were 3 assasins in the car, and that he never met any of them before. The publisher of Forbes' Russian edition has said that the murder is "definitely linked to his professional activity". The paper speculated that a list of the 100 wealthiest Russians written by Klebnikov in May 2004 may have motivated the attack, though Klebnikov himself was most afraid of Boris Berezovsky according to his brother
Other early crime allegations in Russia by Alexander Lebed and Alexander Korzhakov
On October 16, 1996 Alexander Lebed, then Secretary of the Security Council, accused Boris Berezovsky and Vladimir Gusinsky (another oligarch, a president of the MOST financial group, who was one of Berezovsky's main rivals at the time), of making up lists of persons slated for liquidation. At about the same time Alexander Korzhakov, former Chief of Russia President's Security Service, told journalists that Berezovsky had tried to talk him into assassinating Vladimir Gusinsky, Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov, singer and Duma deputy Iosif Kobzon, and others (Novy vzglyad newspaper, 19 October 1996).
First probe and arrest warrant in Russia on money laundering in 1999, and start of criminal investigation in Switzerland
In 1999 after Yevgeny Primakov was appointed Prime Minister of Russia, he started fighting corruption and initiated several criminal investigations. Among those was a probe on Berezovsky for fraud and money laundering in AvtoVAZ car manufacturer and Aeroflot airline. It may be worth mentioning that at that time Vladimir Putin was not playing a significant role in Russian politics.
On April 6, 1999 an arrest order in the name of Berezovsky was issued. (on the same day another arrest warrant has been issued against Alexander Smolensky. He was charged with illegal business activities and money laundering). At the time Berezovsky was in Paris and commented, that the case was started by his political opponents and the allegations were false. The prosecutor general Sergei Stepashin allowed him to enter the country and not to be arrested despite of the warrant. The arrest warrant was quashed by the mogul's allies in Boris Yeltsin's Kremlin, and on November 5, 1999 the charges were lifted and Berezovsky reclassified from accused person to witness.
At the same time several investigations have been started in Switzerland against Russians involved in fraud and money laundering. Among those was a case against Switzerland-Albanian construction firm Mabetex which supposedly bribed Pavel Borodin (government official close to Yeltsin responsible for a lot of government property in Russia at that time). Swiss prosecutors also visited companies "Andava", "Forus" and a few others under control of Berezovsky. The bank accounts of Berezovsky, his partner in "Aeroflot" Nikolay Glushkov and a few other people were arrested with almost US$70 million frozen on them. At the end of summer the entry visa to Switzerland was rejected to Berezovsky. The investigation against Berezovsky in Switzerland is still under way. Berezovsky has been investigated by the Swiss financial authorities for money laundering and membership of a criminal organization. In 2003, the Swiss Bundesanwaltschaft (General State Prosecutor) started a criminal case against Berezovsky and, amongst others, Nikolai Glushkov, for money laundering through the Swiss firms Ovaco AG, situated at the Monbijoustrasse in Bern, and Anros SA in the Lausanne World Trade Center. Berezovsky claimed the proceedings were motivated by antisemitism. In December 2006, as news broke of the death of Alexander Litvinenko, the Bundesanwaltschaft announced that its investigations against Boris Berezovsky were still continuing.
The Federal Criminal Court of Switzerland on October 27, 2008 ruled to confiscate several million francs from bank accounts in Switzerland, one of whose beneficiaries was or is Berezovsky.
Further criminal investigation and criminal convictions in Russia
On November 1, 2000 Russia's prosecutor general demanded that Boris Berezovsky and Vladimir Gusinsky (at the moment outside of Russia) appeared before the court in Russia by November 13 with the threat of international arrest warrants and prison if they failed to show up. The general prosecutor office said it now had sufficient proof (in the case of Boris Berezovsky) to bring charges of large-scale theft in relation to alleged embezzlement from the state airline Aeroflot Berezovsky who was abroad, decided not to come back to Russia.
On September 20, 2001 Berezovsky was put on Russia's federal warrant list and charged in absentia with assisting fraud, hiding currency operations from Russian regulators and failing to sell on domestic market a part of foreign currency obtained from international trade as was required by currency regulation in Russia, and money laundering.
On September 5, 2007, a trial in absentia began in Moscow to examine allegations that Berezovsky had embezzled money from the Russian airline carrier Aeroflot in the 1990s. On November 29, 2007, a Moscow court found Berezovsky guilty of massive embezzlement, and sentenced him to six years in jail. The court found that he had stolen 214 million roubles (nearly $9 million) from Aeroflot through fraud, and ordered him to repay it. Berezovsky called the verdict "a farce". The judge described Berezovsky as part of an organized criminal group that included Aeroflot managers.
On June 26, 2009, he was convicted in Krasnogorsk court on another charge of stealing 5,500 cars from AvtoVAZ in 1994 and sentenced in absentia to 13 years of imprisonment. His business associate Yuli Dubov, who is also in exile in Great Britain, received a 9 years sentence. A fiction book "Bolshaya Paika", loosely based on Berezovsky and written by Dubov, which later served as basis for the movie Tycoon, was used as one of the pieces of evidence. His appeal in the Moscow Oblast court was rejected on September 17, 2009.
Allegations by Mikhail Fridman
On 28 October 2004 in a popular show «To the barrier» on NTV Russian TV channel a shareholder and CEO of Alfa Group Mikhail Fridman, was invited as a guest and was facing Andrey Vasiliev, then general director of Kommersant Publishing House, the leading source for business news in Russia at the time. In the course of the heated debates, Fridman claimed he was willing to give a loan to Kommersant minors in 1999 so that they could buy out the Publishing House from its principal owner Vladimir Yakovlev. Berezovsky, Fridman claimed, who was himself eyeing Kommersant, was “extremely displeased” and “threatening” when calling him. “Berezovsky was threatening me. In general, he was threatening everybody,” Fridman said the key phrase of the suit. On March 31, 2005 Berezovsky submitted a claim to High Court of England to Mihkail Fridman for libel and asked for compensation. Since Mikhail Fridman was unable to provide any proof that Berezovsky threatened him, on May 26 2006 the jury ordered Fridman to pay Berezovsky GBP50,000.
Criminal probe and arrest warrant in Brazil
In May 2006 Berezovsky was detained for several hours in San Paolo airport and questioned about Media Sports Investment (MSI) group financial violations, which was a sponsor of the national Corinthians football club, local media reported. He was later allowed to leave the country.
On July 12, 2007, a Brazilian judge issued an arrest warrant for Berezovsky and a number of other British and Brazilian suspects in connection with an investigation against the Media Sports Investments group, which is suspected of money laundering.Berezovsky is accused of being the main financial backer of MSI. Since Berezovsky, Iranian-born Kia Joorabchian and Noyan Bedru were not in Brazil at the time, warrants for their arrest were forwarded to Interpol. Berezovsky claimed that the Brazilian investigation was a part of the Kremlin's "politicized campaign" against him. Sao Paulo court demanded the detention of Mr Berezovsky and his associates over accusations that money had been laundered through the city's Corinthians football club. The order came after a two-year investigation into large quantities of cash allegedly pumped into the club by an investment group fronted by Mr Berezovsky's long-time associate, the Iranian-born businessman, Kia Joorabchian. A warrant has also been issued for the arrest of Mr Joorabchian, who allegedly oversaw the transfer of Carlos Tevez, an Argentinian football star, from the Corinthians to West Ham United. In the summary of a 15-page report released after the investigation, the Brazilian prosecutor Mr Carneiro said: "There is enough circumstantial evidence indicating that the MSI-Corinthians partnership is being used for the laundering of money, most of which was received from Boris Berezovsky, who is wanted (by Russian authorities) for crimes committed against the Russian financial system."
Investigation in Netherlands
In August 2007, the Russian Deputy Prosecutor General announced that the Dutch tax police had visited Moscow in connection with a handling and money laundering case involving Berezovsky. As Russian media were claiming that a criminal case had been initiated against Berezovsky in the Netherlands on a charge of money laundering, the Dutch prosecuting office or Openbaar Ministerie hastened to announce that he was not the object of any criminal investigation in the Netherlands, while Berezovsky himself responded by saying that he had no business in the Netherlands. Several Dutch newspapers counterclaimed that the name Boris Berezovsky was in fact mentioned in the handling and money laundering dossier, to which the Dutch prosecution officers in function refused to comment.
Search in Berezovsky's castle in France
On May 11, 2005 French Central Office for Fighting Major Financial Crime (OCRGDF) searched Cote d’-Azur castle of Berezovsky. The castle was searched in the course of investigation of Berezovsky’s suspected involvement in money laundering, AFP reported referring to the sources close to investigation.
Allegations of funding terrorism
There were persistent reports of Berezovsky sponsoring terrorists in Chechnya. In an interview to Forbes magazine Ichkeria's President Aslan Maskhadov referred to Boris Berezovsky as one of the persons most responsible for the war in the Caucasus.
Yusup Soslambekov, chairman of the Confederation of the Peoples of the Caucasus, regarded Berezovsky as his personal enemy and threatened to disclose evidence of Berezovsky's involvement with certain Chechen warlords whom he hired to help him in his shady dealings with Chechnya's oil, drug trafficking, hostage-taking and similar pursuits. Soon after Yusup Soslambekov fell victim to a contract killing in Moscow. Even before that Akmal Saidov, who had also unearthed facts about Berezovsky's criminal activities in the Caucasus, was kidnapped; his body was later found.
According to Chechen President Ramzan Kadyrov, Boris Berezovsky encouraged Chechen warlords Shamil Basayev and Salman Raduyev to kidnap people so that Berezovsky could finance them by paying ransoms. Kadyrov said he personally witnessed the agreement. "He couldn’t just give money to the militants, so he invented this mechanism. In my presence, Berezovsky suggested to Raduev and Basaev: ‘Capture people and I’ll ransom them. I’ll get good publicity and you’ll get money.’ He paid millions of dollars to Basaev", Kadyrov said in an interview with Rossiyskaya Gazeta in April, 2009. Kadyrov also said he believed Berezovsky was behind the killing of journalist Anna Politkovskaya.
In early 2009, former Chechen separatist Bukhari Barayev, and brother of the notorious Chechen separatist field commander Arbi Barayev, who was killed in 2001, referred to Berezovsky as "the extremists' bread winner".
Berezovsky said that he had a conversation with the Chechen Islamist leader Movladi Udugov in 1999, six months before the beginning of fighting in Dagestan. A transcript of the phone conversation between Berezovsky and Udugov was leaked to one of Moscow tabloids on September 10, 1999. Udugov proposed to start the Dagestan war to provoke the Russian response, topple the Chechen president Aslan Maskhadov and establish a new Islamic republic of Basayev-Udugov that would be friendly to Russia. Berezovsky asserted that he refused the offer, but "Udugov and Basayev conspired with Stepashin and Putin to provoke a war to topple Maskhadov ... but the agreement was for the Russian army to stop at the Terek River. However, Putin double-crossed the Chechens and started an all-out war."
Exile in Britain
In 1999 Russia opened investigations into Berezovsky's business activities. Fearing arrest, Berezovsky fled to London in 2001, where he was granted political asylum, which infuriated the Russian authorities. He has been charged with fraud and political corruption, but British courts have rejected all three attempts to get him extradited to Russia. From his new home in the U.K., he has strongly criticized the current Russian administration.
In 2003 Boris Berezovsky formally changed his name to Platon Elenin ("Platon" being Russian for Plato, and Elena is the name of his wife) in the British courts. No reason has been given - but Platon is the name of the lead character in a film Tycoon based on his life. In December 2003 he was allowed to travel under his new name to Georgia, provoking a row between Russia and Georgia.
In recent years, Berezovsky has gone into business with Neil Bush, the younger brother of the U.S. President George W. Bush. Berezovsky has been an investor in Bush's Ignite! Learning, an educational software corporation, since at least 2003. In 2005, Neil Bush met with Berezovsky in Latvia, causing tension with Russia due to Berezovsky's fugitive status. Neil Bush has also been seen in Berezovsky's box at the Emirates Stadium, the home of British football club Arsenal F.C., for a game. There has been speculations that the relationship may cause tension in Russo-American bilateral relations.
It has been reported that Berezovsky's funds may have depleted rapidly with the onset of the late 2000s recession. It may well be true as Berezovsky never proved his ability to manage any assets and was always best at just taking companies' cashflows under control by liaising with the senior management and making those firms which did not formally belong to him his cash cows.
On February 19, 2009, Interfax quoted another former Chechen separatist leader who switched sides, Magomed Khambiyev, as accusing Berezovsky of financing the First Deputy Prime Minister of the separatist Chechen Republic of Ichkeria, Movladi Udugov, as well as the late separatist warlord Shamil Basaev, and of broadcasting "Wahabbi ideas." He alleged that Berezovsky had financed "illegal armed unit" leaders "under the guise of paying ransoms for hostages" as well as the Kavkaz television channel, which he referred to as a "Wahhabi mouthpiece." Khambiyev also alleged that Berezovsky "personally" handed Basaev $1 million upon arriving in Ingushetia after the first Chechen military campaign. He was quoted as saying "I asked Basayev why Berezovsky had given the money and why Basaev accepted it. He answered that Berezovsky was afraid of him and therefore paid the money". Khambiyev said that it later turned out that Berezovsky had actually given Basayev $2 million while in Ingushetia.
Berezovsky's exile statements
Appeals for regime change
In September 2005, Berezovsky said in an interview with the BBC: "I'm sure that Putin doesn't have the chance to survive, even to the next election in 2008. I am doing everything in my power to limit his time frame, and I am really thinking of returning to Russia after Putin collapses, which he will." In January 2006, Berezovsky stated in an interview to a Moscow-based radio station that he was working on overthrowing the administration of Vladimir Putin by force. Berezovsky has also publicly accused Putin of being "a gangster" and the "terrorist number one".
On April 13, 2007, in an interview with the British newspaper The Guardian, Berezovsky declared that he is plotting the violent overthrow of President Putin by financing and encouraging coup plotters in Moscow: "We need to use force to change this regime. It isn't possible to change this regime through democratic means. There can be no change without force, pressure."' He also admitted that during the last six years he struggled much to "destroy the positive image of Putin" and said that "Putin has created an authoritarian regime against the Russian constitution.... I don't know how it will happen, but authoritarian regimes only collapse by force." Berezovsky said he had dedicated much of the last six years to "trying to destroy the positive image of Putin" that many in the west held, portraying him whenever possible as a dangerously anti-democratic figure.
Soon after Berezovsky's 2007 statement, Garry Kasparov, an important leader of the opposition movement The Other Russia and leader of the United Civil Front, wrote the following on his website: "Berezovsky has lived in emigration for many years and no longer has significant influence upon the political processes which take place in Russian society. His extravagant proclamations are simply a method of attracting attention. Furthermore, for the overwhelming majority of Russians he is a political symbol of the 90s, one of the "bad blokes" enriching themselves behind the back of president Yeltsin. The informational noise around Berezovsky is specifically beneficial for the Kremlin, which is trying to compromise Russia's real opposition. Berezovsky has not had and does not have any relation to Other Russia or the United Civil Front." Berezovsky responded in June 2007 by saying that "there is not one significant politician in Russia whom he has not financed" and that this included members of Other Russia. The managing director of the United Civil Front, in turn, said that the organization would consider suing Berezovsky over these allegations., but the lawsuit has never been brought before the court.
The Russian Prosecutor General's Office has launched a criminal investigation against Berezovsky to find whether his comments can be considered a "seizure of power by force", as outlined in the Russian Criminal Code. If convicted, an offender is facing up to 20 years of imprisonment. The British Foreign Office denounced Berezovsky's statements, warning him that his status of a political refugee may be reconsidered, should he continue to make similar remarks. Furthermore, Scotland Yard had announced that it would investigate whether Berezovsky's statements were in violation of the law. However in the following July, the Crown Prosecution Service announced that Berezovsky would not face charges in the UK for his comments. Kremlin officials called it a "disturbing moment" in Anglo-Russian relations.
Alleged assassination attempts in London
Alleged 2003 plot
According to Alexander Litvinenko, a Russian Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR) agent in London was making preparations to assassinate Berezovsky with a binary weapon in September 2003. This alleged plot was reported to British police. Hazel Blears, then a Home Office Minister, said that inquiries made were "unable to either substantiate this information or find evidence of any criminal offences having been committed". Berezovsky in turn later accused Putin of ordering the deadly poisoning of Litvinenko.
This was not the first alleged plot to murder Berezovsky that had been announced by Litvinenko. On November 17, 1998, during the period that Vladimir Putin was the head of the FSB, five high-ranking officers of FSB's Directorate for the Analysis of Criminal Organisations appeared at a press conference in the Russian Interfax news agency. The officers, including the then-Lieutenant Colonel Litvinenko, accused the head of the Directorate and his deputy of ordering them to assassinate Boris Berezovsky and the FSB officer Mikhail Trepashkin in November 1997.
Alleged 2007 plot
In June 2007 Berezovsky said he fled Britain on the advice of Scotland Yard, amid reports that he was the target of an assassination attempt by a suspected Russian hitman. On July 18, 2007, British tabloid The Sun reported that the alleged would-be assassin was captured by the police at the Hilton Hotel in Park Lane. They reported that the suspect, arrested by the anti-terrorist police after being tracked for a week by MI5, was deported back to Russia when no weapons were found and there was not enough evidence to charge him with any offence. In addition, they said British police placed a squad of uniformed officers around the Chechen dissident Akhmed Zakayev's house in north London, and also phoned Litvinenko's widow, Marina, to urge her to take greater security precautions. Russia's ambassador to the UK, Yuri Fedotov, said he was not aware of any such plot and told BBC Radio 4's Today programme there was "nothing that could confirm" the plot, although British police did confirm that they had arrested a suspect in an alleged murder plot.
Berezovsky said he was told the assassin would be someone he knew, who would shoot him in the head and then surrender to the police. He again accused Vladimir Putin of being behind a plot to assassinate him. The Kremlin has denied similar claims in the past. According to The Guardian, there is speculation that Berezovsky leaked details of the alleged attempt to kill him to the media to antagonise Moscow, once the British authorities had returned the suspected hitman to Moscow. The timing of the story has also been seen as suspicious, coming in the middle of a row over Britain's attempts to charge a Russian businessman and former security agent, Andrei Lugovoi, with Litvinenko's murder.
According to the interview given by a high-ranking British security official to the BBC2 in July 2008, the alleged Russian agent, known as "A", was of a Chechen nationality. He was identified by Kommersant as the Chechen mobster Movladi Atlangeriyev; after returning to Russia, Atlangeriyev forcibly disappeared in January 2008 by the unknown men in Moscow.
Involvement in Alexander Litvinenko affair
Main article: Alexander Litvinenko poisoningMany publications in Russian media suggested that the death of Alexander Litvinenko was connected to Berezovsky. Former FSB chief Nikolay Kovalev, for whom Litvinenko worked, said that the incident "looks like the hand of Berezovsky. I am sure that no kind of intelligence services participated." This involvement of Berezovsky was alleged by numerous Russian television shows. Kremlin supporters saw it as a conspiracy to smear Russian government's reputation by engineering a spectacular murder of a Russian dissident abroad.
After Litvinenko's death, traces of polonium-210 were found in an office of Berezovsky. Russian prosecutors were not allowed to investigate the office. Russian authorities have also been unable to question Berezovsky. The Foreign Ministry complained that Britain was obstructing its attempt to send prosecutors to London to interview more than 100 people, including Berezovsky.
Alleged involvement in the 2004 Ukraine presidential election
In September 2005, soon after the Ukrainian government led by prime minister Yulia Tymoshenko was dismissed by president Viktor Yushchenko, former president of Ukraine Leonid Kravchuk accused Berezovsky of financing Yushchenko's presidential election campaign, and provided copies of documents showing money transfers from companies he said are controlled by Berezovsky to companies controlled by Yuschenko's official backers. Berezovsky has confirmed that he met Yushchenko's representatives in London before the election, and that the money was transferred from his companies, but he refused to confirm or deny that the companies that received the money were used in Yushchenko's campaign. Financing of election campaigns by foreign citizens is illegal in Ukraine. In September 2007, Berezovsky launched lawsuits against two Ukrainian politicians, Oleksandr Tretyakov, a former presidential aid, and David Zhvaniya, a former emergencies minister. Berezovsky is suing the men for nearly US$23 million, accusing them of misusing the money he had allocated in 2004 to fund Ukraine's Orange Revolution.
2010 Ukraine presidential election
Berezovsky called on the Ukrainian business to support Yushchenko at the 2010 presidential election of January 2010 as a guarantor of debarment of property redistribution after the election.
On December 10, 2009 the Ukrainian minister of interior affairs Yuriy Lutsenko stated that if the Russian interior ministry would request it Berezovsky would be detained after arriving in Ukraine.
See also
- Roman Abramovich - former business partner sued by Berezovsky for approximately $4 billion over the Sibneft share-and business blackmail affair.
- Badri Patarkatsishvili - important intermediary between Boris Berezovsky and Roman Abramovich who was reportedly paid $500 million by Abramovich for protecting him.
- International Foundation for Civil Liberties
- List of Russian billionaires
- Russian oligarchs
- Vladislav Listyev
- Russian Mafia
- The World's 10 Most Wanted
References
- ^ Profile: Boris Berezovsky, BBC News, 31 May 2007
- ^ 'I am plotting a new Russian revolution' The Guardian. 2007-04-13
- ^ Johanna Granville, "Dermokratizatsiya and Prikhvatizatsiya: the Russian Kleptocracy and Rise of Organized Crime,"] in Demokratizatsiya vol. 11, no. 3 (summer 2003): 449-457.
- What a carve-up!, The Guardian, December 3, 2005
- ^ Losing power: Boris Berezovsky BBC News Retrieved on April 5, 2008
- ^ Moscow court convicts Berezovsky, BBC News, 29 November 2007
- ^ "Berezovsky embezzlement trial starts in Moscow", Forbes, September 5, 2007
- ^ "Berezovsky links Brazilian arrest order to Kremlin'", Reuters, July 13, 2007
- ^ "Bundesanwaltschaft has been proceeding against Berezovsky for three years", 20 Minuten, 15/03/2006
- ^ http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1316/is_10_32/ai_66495297/?tag=content;col1 Godfather of the Kremlin: Boris Berezovsky and the Looting of Russia
- ^ Godfather of the Kremlin? Power. Politics. Murder. Boris Berezovsky could teach the guys in Sicily a thing or two., Forbes, December 30, 1996
- ^ Berezovsky is playing us, and it’s embarrassing The Times. 2007-07-30
- ^ Russian Says Kremlin Faked 'Terror Attacks'
- Russian Billionaire's Bitter Feud With Putin A Plot Line in Poisoning, The Washington Post, December 9, 2006
- Chechen leaders deplore dismissal of Berezovskiy, NUPI, 07.11.1997
- ^ Alex Goldfarb and Marina Litvinenko. Death of a dissident: The Poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko and the Return of the KGB, The Free Press (2007) ISBN 1-416-55165-4
- Sakwa, Richard (2008). Putin, Russia's choice (2nd ed.). Routledge. p. 71. ISBN 978-0-415-40765-6.
{{cite book}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|coauthors=
(help) - Leader's secret holidays to Spain, The Times, June 15, 2000
- ^ Berezovsky's revenge Al-Ahram Weekly, 2002-03-21
- Caputo, Michael R. (2004-07-13). "Same Old Ruthless Russia". washingtonpost.com. The Washington Post Company. p. A15. Retrieved 2007-05-31.
- Iron Curtain Redux
- Rough Cut: Russia: Putin vs. NGOs, PBS FRONTLINE, May 2007
- Paul Klebnikov was killed by the hero of his book, Izvestia newspaper
- "Трудовая Биография Б.Березовского". Scandaly.ru. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Валерий Лебедев. Парадоксальный Березовский. N 1 от 10 февраля 1997 года". Lebed.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Компромат.Ru: Березовский Борис //". Compromat.ru. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- ""серый кардинал" XX века | Восточно-Сибирская правда". Vsp.ru. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- ^ "Guardian || Berezovsky, Boris Abramovich". Guardian-psj.ru. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- Starobin, Paul (2000-07-24). "Boris Berezovsky: Tycoon under Siege (int'l edition)". Businessweek.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Magazine Article". Forbes.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "The St. Petersburg Times - Business - The Russian National Airline Taking Off Into Friendlier Skies". Sptimes.ru. 2000-11-07. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- Template:De icon «Der König der Intrige», Die Weltwoche, 09 December 2003
- "Director of the Swiss Federal Office of Justice: Switzerland is a wrong place for concealing or depositing illegal funds - Interview". Interfax.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "The new Russia: a handbook of ... - Google йМХЦХ". Books.google.ru. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "EUROPE | Swiss hand over Berezovsky papers". BBC News. 2000-07-26. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Warrant Is Issued for Berezovsky - Los Angeles Times". Articles.latimes.com. 2001-10-23. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Thirteen-year oligarch". Kommersant. 2009-06-27. Retrieved 2009-12-07.
- "Boris Berezovsky's conviction is now effective". Interfax. 2009-09-17. Retrieved 2009-12-07.
- "Berezovsky Summons Fridman to Court - Kommersant Moscow". Kommersant.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Tycoon Berezovsky wins slander suit vs. Alfa head in London | World | RIA Novosti". En.rian.ru. 2006-05-26. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Trend News: Brazil issues arrest warrant for Berezovsky". En.trend.az. 2007-07-13. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- Blomfield, Adrian (2007-07-14). "Brazilian judge orders the arrest of Berezovsky". Telegraph. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Arrest order issued for Tevez's agent accused of money laundering", The Guardian, July 13, 2007
- "Brazil issues arrest warrant for Berezovsky on money-laundering charges | Mail Online". Dailymail.co.uk. 2007-07-16. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Brazilian Court Orders to Arrest Berezovsky - Kommersant Moscow". Kommersant.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro and Saeed Shah. "Berezovsky wanted in Brazil for alleged money laundering | World news". The Guardian. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Brazilian court seeks Berezovsky's arrest | World news | guardian.co.uk". Guardian. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Berezovsky prosecuted in Holland", Kommersant, August 29, 2007
- "Name of Berezovsky is indeed mentioned in the dossier", Haarlems Dagblad, August 30, 2007
- "OCRGDF Searches French Castle of Berezovsky - Kommersant Moscow". Commersant.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- Paul Klebnikov, 11.01.99. "Conflagration in Russia". Forbes.com. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ Berezovsky financed terrorists by paying ransoms – Chechen prez
- ^ [tt_news]=34538&tx_ttnews[backPid]=24&cHash=aa33b24629 Chechen Separatist Representative Reportedly Switches Sides Jamestown Foundation Retrieved on July 23, 2009
- ^ Alex Goldfarb, with Marina Litvinenko Death of a Dissident: The Poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko and the Return of the KGB, The Free Press, 2007, ISBN 1-416-55165-4, page 216.
- "Death of a Dissident", page 189.
- [http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article1354681.ece Send Berezovsky back and we'll help with Litvinenko case, says Russia, Times Online, February 8, 2007
- Berezovsky, Neil Bush, Latvian businessmen meet, Times, Sep 23, 2005
- Berezovsky and Bush's brother in the crowd at the Emirates, The Guardian, September 5, 2006
- Berezovsky Teams Up With Bush's Brother, The Moscow Times, October 06, 2005
- A Never-Ending War
- Template:Ru icon 18:21 : Борис Березовский в течение последних 1,5 лет готовит силовой захват власти в России. Опальный олигарх считает, что все перемены будет осуществлять активное меньшинство, Ekho Moskvy, 25.01.2006
- Russia’s Oligarchs May Face a Georgian Chill, The New York Times, September 4, 2008
- Putin Is Terrorist Number One
- 'I am plotting a new Russian revolution', The Guardian, April 13, 2007
- Kremlin foe calls for Putin's Ouster, Associated Press, April 13, 2007
- Template:Ru icon Новые подробности по Маршу несогласных.
- Template:Ru icon Неудобные вопросы, Kasparov.ru, 18.04.2007
- Russia's United Civic Front may sue Berezovsky over funding claims, RIA Novosti, 28/ 06/ 2007
- Scotland Yard to Examine Berezovsky’s Interview, Kommersant, April 14, 2007
- Police probe exile's claims about Russian 'revolution', The Guardian, April 14, 2007
- Anglo-Russian relations, The Guardian, March 20, 2008
- House of Commons Hansard Written Answers for 13 Jan 2004 (pt 8), House of Commons of the United Kingdom, 13 Jan 2004
- Putin tried to kill my friend, claims Russian billionaire, The Telegraph, 19/11/2006
- Security services ‘foil plot to kill Berezovsky at the London Hilton’, The Times, July 18, 2007
- Man questioned over tycoon 'plot, BBC News, 18 July 2007
- The plot to kill Boris Berezovsky, The Independent, 29 November 2007
- ^ Police feared assassination for two Russian dissidents, The Guardian, July 22, 2007
- ^ Police Back Berezovsky Murder Story, The Moscow Times, July 19, 2007
- Boris Berezovsky: 'Putin behind plot to kill me', The Telegraph, 23/07/200
- Template:Pl icon Rosjanie: To nie my zabiliśmy Litwinienkę, Polska Agencja Prasowa, 08.07.2008
- Kremlin Fingered in Litvinenko's Murder, The Moscow Times, July 09, 2008
- Weaver, John (24 November 2006). "Mafia Hit On The Media". Atlantic Free Press. Retrieved 2006-11-26.
- Template:Ru iconAlexeev, Petr (24 November 2006). "Politkovskaya, Litvinenko, who is next?". Electorat. Info. Retrieved 2006-11-26.
- Template:Ru icon"Who orchestrated plan to discredit Russia?". Kommersant. 25 November 2006. Retrieved 2006-11-26.
- Russian Billionaire's Bitter Feud With Putin A Plot Line in Poisoning The Washington Post Retrieved on April 6, 2008
- Hall, Ben (November 28, 2006). "Polonium 210 found at Berezovsky's office". MSNBC. Retrieved 2006-12-01.
- Lugovoy case unsubstantial: Russian prosecution
- Send Berezovsky back and we'll help with Litvinenko case, says Russia Times Online Retrieved on April 6, 2008
- Template:Ru icon 25.01.2006 Пан Березовский вершит историю Украины, Lenta.Ru, 15.09.2005
- Two Our Ukraine lawmakers summoned to court upon Berezovskiy`s lawsuit, UNIAN, September 3, 2007
- ^ Police to detain Russian businessman Berezovsky if arrives in Ukraine, Kyiv Post (December 10, 2009)
External links
- Boris Berezovsky, TIME, Mar. 03, 1997
- Boris Berezovsky: Tycoon under Siege, BusinessWeek, July 24, 2000
- Boris Berezovsky: Russia's Fallen Oligarch, PBS, October 2003
- Losing power: Boris Berezovsky, BBC News, 27 September 2005
- Boris Berezovsky: The first oligarch, The Independent, 25 November 2006
- Profile: Boris Berezovsky, BBC News, 31 May 2007
- Boris Berezovsky at Encyclopædia Britannica
Preceded byIvan Korotchenya | Executive Secretary of CIS April 29, 1998 – March 4, 1999 |
Succeeded byIvan Korotchenya (acting) |
- Misplaced Pages neutral point of view disputes from July 2011
- Russian political activists
- Russian immigrants to the United Kingdom
- 1946 births
- 20th-century mathematicians
- Aeroflot
- British Jews
- Converts to Eastern Orthodoxy from Judaism
- Fugitive financiers
- Fugitives wanted by Russia
- Living people
- Members of the Russian Academy of Sciences
- People from Moscow
- Russian billionaires
- Russian businesspeople
- Russian Jews
- Russian mathematicians
- Russian politicians
- Russian white-collar criminals
- Russian newspaper publishers (people)
- Russian mass media owners