Misplaced Pages

:Deletion review/Log/2013 January 4: Difference between revisions - Misplaced Pages

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
< Misplaced Pages:Deletion review | Log Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 16:13, 4 January 2013 editThryduulf (talk | contribs)Oversighters, Administrators99,009 edits →Keymon Ache: endorse. given sources are not independent and thus not sufficient to suggest recreation← Previous edit Revision as of 16:47, 4 January 2013 edit undoDoncram (talk | contribs)203,830 edits request DRV for Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio)Next edit →
Line 4: Line 4:


Add a new entry BELOW THIS LINE copying the format: {{subst:drv2|page=<PAGE NAME>|xfd_page=<XFD PAGE NAME>|reason=<REASON>}} ~~~~ --> Add a new entry BELOW THIS LINE copying the format: {{subst:drv2|page=<PAGE NAME>|xfd_page=<XFD PAGE NAME>|reason=<REASON>}} ~~~~ -->
====]====
:{{DRV links|Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio)|xfd_page=|article=}}
Request restoration of article twice deleted by editor/adminstrator Nyttend. Article was deleted on Sept 28 with edit summary "deleted page ] (]: Article that has no meaningful, substantive content). IMO, that was invalid, the Speedy deletion of "No content" was not justified. I requested copy to my userspace, subsequently developed it further and restored it to mainspace. Second it was deleted a month later, on Oct 28, with edit summary "deleted page Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio) (]: Unambiguous copyright infringement)", and Nyttend subsequently refused to even share a copy of the deleted page.

The first deletion was discussed 28 September 2012 at Nyttend's Talk page (halfway down within archived section ]). He had deleted this plus 3 covered bridge articles, all Ohio NRHP articles. I believed then and now that all 4 deletions were invalid. However I discussed them pleasantly IMHO, obtained Nyttend's restoration of them to userspace, and I edited all four further before restoring to mainspace. It was an accomodation to Nyttend that I developed them further using a source that he seems to like. I also edited mention of that source into general resource ]. I was trying to be nice.

The second deletion was discussed in now-archived ]. The reader must "unhide" section hidden and labelled as "Copyright infringement is illegal, and attempting to convince me otherwise is unwelcome." and must unhide section hidden and labelled as "TLDR". Please, Nyttend and others, read those. In these sections two editors, Cbl62 and Mercy11, disagree with Nyttend and ask him to restore the article. Reference was made to a previous discussion at ], where Nyttend had unusual views on copyright, and editors Moonriddengirl and Dirtlawyer1 commented. I tried to be nice and explain further how I was seeking some compromise with Nyttend accomodating to his concern about quality of articles in his domain of Ohio and Indiana, and I suggested i would drop it for a while until a deletion review would be necessary. It was ended, i guess, by Nyttend closing it up with "too long didn't read" summary.

This is related to similar DRV, non-yet-closed, at ], where 7 editors have so far called for Overturn of Nyttend's similar deletion of other Ohio/Indiana articles/redirects created by me.

This DRV, anyhow, to discuss restoration of this article, please. (Side question on process: is it appropriate to copy the deleted text to here? I don't see how this DRV process works if all cannot see the deleted item.) ]]] 16:47, 4 January 2013 (UTC)

====]==== ====]====
:{{DRV links|Keymon Ache|xfd_page=Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Keymon Ache|article=}} :{{DRV links|Keymon Ache|xfd_page=Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Keymon Ache|article=}}

Revision as of 16:47, 4 January 2013

< 2013 January 3 Deletion review archives: 2013 January 2013 January 5 >

4 January 2013

Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio)

Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio) (talk|edit|history|logs|links|watch) (restore)

Request restoration of article twice deleted by editor/adminstrator Nyttend. Article was deleted on Sept 28 with edit summary "deleted page Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio) (A3: Article that has no meaningful, substantive content). IMO, that was invalid, the Speedy deletion of "No content" was not justified. I requested copy to my userspace, subsequently developed it further and restored it to mainspace. Second it was deleted a month later, on Oct 28, with edit summary "deleted page Old Union School (Chesterville, Ohio) (G12: Unambiguous copyright infringement)", and Nyttend subsequently refused to even share a copy of the deleted page.

The first deletion was discussed 28 September 2012 at Nyttend's Talk page (halfway down within archived section User talk:Nyttend/Archive 24#Hobart Welded Steel House Co. articles and other Ohio NRHP articles). He had deleted this plus 3 covered bridge articles, all Ohio NRHP articles. I believed then and now that all 4 deletions were invalid. However I discussed them pleasantly IMHO, obtained Nyttend's restoration of them to userspace, and I edited all four further before restoring to mainspace. It was an accomodation to Nyttend that I developed them further using a source that he seems to like. I also edited mention of that source into general resource wp:NRHPhelpOH. I was trying to be nice.

The second deletion was discussed in now-archived User talk:Nyttend/Archive 25#please provide copy of page you just deleted. The reader must "unhide" section hidden and labelled as "Copyright infringement is illegal, and attempting to convince me otherwise is unwelcome." and must unhide section hidden and labelled as "TLDR". Please, Nyttend and others, read those. In these sections two editors, Cbl62 and Mercy11, disagree with Nyttend and ask him to restore the article. Reference was made to a previous discussion at Talk:C. Ferris White, where Nyttend had unusual views on copyright, and editors Moonriddengirl and Dirtlawyer1 commented. I tried to be nice and explain further how I was seeking some compromise with Nyttend accomodating to his concern about quality of articles in his domain of Ohio and Indiana, and I suggested i would drop it for a while until a deletion review would be necessary. It was ended, i guess, by Nyttend closing it up with "too long didn't read" summary.

This is related to similar DRV, non-yet-closed, at Misplaced Pages:Deletion review/Log/2012 December 29#House at 1022 West Main Street, where 7 editors have so far called for Overturn of Nyttend's similar deletion of other Ohio/Indiana articles/redirects created by me.

This DRV, anyhow, to discuss restoration of this article, please. (Side question on process: is it appropriate to copy the deleted text to here? I don't see how this DRV process works if all cannot see the deleted item.) doncram 16:47, 4 January 2013 (UTC)

Keymon Ache

Keymon Ache (talk|edit|history|logs|links|watch) (XfD|restore)

This show is notable after the release of movie in theatres:

http://www.indiantelevision.com/headlines/y2k12/nov/nov62.php
http://www.exchange4media.com/48689_nick%E2%80%99s-keymon-ache-to-make-its-movie-debut.html
http://www.tellychakkar.com/releases/keymon-ache-release-70mm

Please decide. Thank you Forgot to put name 10:43, 4 January 2013 (UTC)

  • Endorse closure. That discussion could not have been closed any other way, given that it was unanimous. As for the sources above, they are not sufficient alone to determine notability as they are all essentially reprints of the same copy and therefore count only as a single source. Thryduulf (talk) 16:13, 4 January 2013 (UTC)