| Revision as of 17:04, 9 October 2004 editDori (talk | contribs)9,615 edits this is not an encyclopedic article | Revision as of 17:26, 9 October 2004 edit undoBogdangiusca (talk | contribs)39,816 edits replyNext edit → | ||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| This article is nothing but speculation. I would say it's not encyclopedic, and I am contemplating whether I should list it for VFD. It has the tone of an essay, but without the sources that usually go with such essay. IMO it is within the original research bound, and it doesn't have the sources to back even that up, making it downright conjecture. ] | ] 17:04, Oct 9, 2004 (UTC) | This article is nothing but speculation. I would say it's not encyclopedic, and I am contemplating whether I should list it for VFD. | ||
| : Do you think that "Origin of Albanians" is not worthy of having an article, especially when it is such a disputed matter ? Why ? | |||
| It has the tone of an essay, but without the sources that usually go with such essay. IMO it is within the original research bound, and it doesn't have the sources to back even that up, making it downright conjecture. ] | ] 17:04, Oct 9, 2004 (UTC) | |||
| : What are you exactly disputing ? Misplaced Pages does not currently require a reference for each sentence. The "Place of origin" and "Ethnic origin" information can be found in any extensive description of these languages. And I can find references for each argument in the Illyrian/Thracian origin, if you want them. ] | ] 17:26, 9 Oct 2004 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 17:26, 9 October 2004
This article is nothing but speculation. I would say it's not encyclopedic, and I am contemplating whether I should list it for VFD.
- Do you think that "Origin of Albanians" is not worthy of having an article, especially when it is such a disputed matter ? Why ?
It has the tone of an essay, but without the sources that usually go with such essay. IMO it is within the original research bound, and it doesn't have the sources to back even that up, making it downright conjecture. Dori | Talk 17:04, Oct 9, 2004 (UTC)
- What are you exactly disputing ? Misplaced Pages does not currently require a reference for each sentence. The "Place of origin" and "Ethnic origin" information can be found in any extensive description of these languages. And I can find references for each argument in the Illyrian/Thracian origin, if you want them. Bogdan | Talk 17:26, 9 Oct 2004 (UTC)