| Revision as of 04:49, 17 May 2015 editKasparBot (talk | contribs)1,549,811 edits embed authority control with wikidata information← Previous edit | Revision as of 21:20, 2 August 2015 edit undo98.202.131.126 (talk) →Criticism: satel's politics are irrelevant to this article; stick to the facts. if someone refuted her data or conclusions, cite it.Next edit → | ||
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
| In 1977, scholar Susan Thomas argued that feminist therapy was "more part of a social movement than type of psychotherapy," and was so intimately tied to broader social and political feminism that its legitimacy as a therapeutic school was questionable.<ref>quoted in Becker, Dana. (2005). The Myth of Empowerment: Women and the Therapeutic Culture in America. New York: New York University Press, 2005. p 148</ref> | In 1977, scholar Susan Thomas argued that feminist therapy was "more part of a social movement than type of psychotherapy," and was so intimately tied to broader social and political feminism that its legitimacy as a therapeutic school was questionable.<ref>quoted in Becker, Dana. (2005). The Myth of Empowerment: Women and the Therapeutic Culture in America. New York: New York University Press, 2005. p 148</ref> | ||
| Psychiatrist ] of Yale University has been critical of feminist therapy since the late 1990s, characterizing it as promoting a ] ].<ref>Satel, Sally (1998) , Originally published in The Women's Freedom Network Newsletter September/October, 1998, Vol. 5, Number 5.</ref> Satel argued in her 2000 book ''P.C. MD: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine'' that the very concept of feminist therapy is contrary to the methods and goals of psychotherapy, sometimes so far as to veer into potential ].<ref>Satel, Sally, M.D. (2000) P.C., M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine. Basic Books, ISBN 0-465-07182-1</ref> Traditionally, notes Satel, the goal of therapy is to help the patient understand and alter unrealistic thinking and unhealthy behaviors to improve the patient's confidence, interpersonal skills, and quality of life. Traditional therapy, while rooted in well-tested methods, must also be flexible enough to adapt to each patient's unique experiences, personality and needs. In contrast, Satel notes that feminist therapy promotes a one-size-fits-all approach that presumes that many of a patient's problems stem from her living in an oppressive, sexist, or patriarchal culture. Satel agrees that sexism and discrimination might be a factor in some patients' problems, but also expresses alarm that feminist therapy minimizes or ignores other potential problem sources such as family dynamics, ], drug/alcohol abuse, ], or even criminal acts by the patient. Additionally, Satal argues that the feminist presumption that women are oppressed can actually worsen a patient's feelings of helplessness by placing the patient's ] outside herself. Furthermore, Satel notes that some feminist therapists so substantially alter their treatment practices as to risk professional misconduct or other censure. For example, in overcorrecting to avoid the perceived problems in a hierarchical therapist-patient relationship, feminist therapists have violated standard policies by sharing intimate details of their own lives in a manner considered unthinkable by traditional therapists who strive to maintain objectivity.<ref>Satel, p. 211</ref> Feminist therapy has also generally avoided rigorous ] or other scrutiny to test for ], Satel notes. Finally, Satel contends that in blaming a sexist culture for the patient's problems, feminist psychology potentially refuses to hold women accountable for their own actions or misdeeds. Although, critics{{who|date=August 2014}} argue that Satel cannot speak for all women using this approach<!--which approach, specifically? This section outlines several major objections Satel raises to feminist therapy; if a notable critic has responded to Satel, then by all means put his or her responses here-->; some{{cn|date=August 2014}} agree with her{{who?|date=August 2014}} views.{{Cn|date=January 2015}} | |||
| Other critics have argued that feminist therapy embraces and promotes a number of inaccurate and discredited '']'' assumptions, such as the belief that men are responsible for initiating, perpetrating and perpetuating most interpersonal violence, when research has consistently shown that women tend to instigate and inflict domestic violence at least as often as men.<ref>Dutton, D. G. (1994). Patriarchy and wife assault: The ecological fallacy. Violence and Victims, 9, 125-140.</ref><ref></ref> | Other critics have argued that feminist therapy embraces and promotes a number of inaccurate and discredited '']'' assumptions, such as the belief that men are responsible for initiating, perpetrating and perpetuating most interpersonal violence, when research has consistently shown that women tend to instigate and inflict domestic violence at least as often as men.<ref>Dutton, D. G. (1994). Patriarchy and wife assault: The ecological fallacy. Violence and Victims, 9, 125-140.</ref><ref></ref> | ||
Revision as of 21:20, 2 August 2015
Feminist therapy is a set of related therapies arising from what proponents see as a disparity between the origin of most psychological theories and the majority of people seeking counseling being female. It focuses on societal, cultural, and political causes and solutions to issues faced in the counseling process. It openly encourages the client to participate in the world in a more social and political way.
Feminist therapy contends that women are in a disadvantaged position in the world due to sex, gender, sexuality, race, ethnicity, religion, age and other categories. Feminist therapists argue that many problems that arise in therapy are due to disempowering social forces; thus the goal of therapy is to recognize these forces and empower the client. In a feminist therapy setting the therapist and client work as equals. The therapist must demystify therapy from the beginning to show the client that she is her own rescuer, and the expectations, roles, and responsibilities of both client and therapist must be explored and equally agreed upon. The therapist recognizes that with every symptom a client has, there is a strength.
Feminist therapy grew out of concerns that established therapies were not helping women. Specific concerns of feminist therapists included gender bias and stereotyping in therapy; blaming victims of physical abuse and sexual abuse; the assumption of a traditional nuclear family; and the ongoing erasure of women from the psychological discourse.
Principles of Feminist Therapy
- An egalitarian relationship (a relationship in which the participants have equal status) between therapist and client is key in feminist therapy, utilizing the therapist’s psychological knowledge and the client’s knowledge of herself. The inherent power differentials between therapist and client are addressed, and the client must realize that the therapist is not giving her power, but power comes from within herself. This relationship provides a model for women to take responsibility in making all of their relationships egalitarian. Feminist therapists focus on embracing the client’s strengths rather than fixing their weaknesses, and accept and validate the client’s feelings.
- Feminist Therapy Theory is always being revised and added to as social contexts change and the discourse develops.
- The therapist always retains accountability.
- The feminist therapy model is non-victim blaming.
- The client’s well-being is the leading principle in all aspects of therapy.
Feminist Therapists' Responsibilities
- Feminist therapists must integrate feminist analysis in all spheres of their work.
- Feminist therapists must recognize the client’s socioeconomic and political circumstances, especially with issues in access to mental health care.
- Feminist therapists must be actively involved in ending oppression, empowering women and girls, respecting differences, and social change.
- Feminist therapists must be aware of their own situated experience (their own socioeconomic and political situations as well as sex, gender, race, sexuality, etc.) and is constantly self-evaluating and remedying their own biases and oppressive actions. As well as must be learning about other dominant and non-dominant cultural and ethnic experiences.
- Feminist therapists must accept and validate their client’s experiences and feelings.
Contributors to Feminist Therapy
- Judith Worrell
- Pam Remer
- Sandra Bem
- Laura Brown
- Jean Baker Miller
- Carolyn Enns
- Ellyn Kaschak
- Bonnie Burstow
- Judith V. Jordan
- Mary N. Russell
Criticism
In 1977, scholar Susan Thomas argued that feminist therapy was "more part of a social movement than type of psychotherapy," and was so intimately tied to broader social and political feminism that its legitimacy as a therapeutic school was questionable.
Psychiatrist Sally Satel of Yale University has been critical of feminist therapy since the late 1990s, characterizing it as promoting a paranoid conspiracy. Satel argued in her 2000 book P.C. MD: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine that the very concept of feminist therapy is contrary to the methods and goals of psychotherapy, sometimes so far as to veer into potential malpractice. Traditionally, notes Satel, the goal of therapy is to help the patient understand and alter unrealistic thinking and unhealthy behaviors to improve the patient's confidence, interpersonal skills, and quality of life. Traditional therapy, while rooted in well-tested methods, must also be flexible enough to adapt to each patient's unique experiences, personality and needs. In contrast, Satel notes that feminist therapy promotes a one-size-fits-all approach that presumes that many of a patient's problems stem from her living in an oppressive, sexist, or patriarchal culture. Satel agrees that sexism and discrimination might be a factor in some patients' problems, but also expresses alarm that feminist therapy minimizes or ignores other potential problem sources such as family dynamics, cognitive distortions, drug/alcohol abuse, mental illness, or even criminal acts by the patient. Additionally, Satal argues that the feminist presumption that women are oppressed can actually worsen a patient's feelings of helplessness by placing the patient's locus of control outside herself. Furthermore, Satel notes that some feminist therapists so substantially alter their treatment practices as to risk professional misconduct or other censure. For example, in overcorrecting to avoid the perceived problems in a hierarchical therapist-patient relationship, feminist therapists have violated standard policies by sharing intimate details of their own lives in a manner considered unthinkable by traditional therapists who strive to maintain objectivity. Feminist therapy has also generally avoided rigorous peer review or other scrutiny to test for efficacy, Satel notes. Finally, Satel contends that in blaming a sexist culture for the patient's problems, feminist psychology potentially refuses to hold women accountable for their own actions or misdeeds. Although, critics argue that Satel cannot speak for all women using this approach; some agree with her views.
Other critics have argued that feminist therapy embraces and promotes a number of inaccurate and discredited a priori assumptions, such as the belief that men are responsible for initiating, perpetrating and perpetuating most interpersonal violence, when research has consistently shown that women tend to instigate and inflict domestic violence at least as often as men.
References
- Rowan, John. "AHP A Guids to Humanistic Psychology." 2001. Association for Humanistic Psychology. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.ahpweb.org/rowan_bibliography/chapter16.html>.
- Rowan, John. "AHP A Guids to Humanistic Psychology." 2001. Association for Humanistic Psychology. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.ahpweb.org/rowan_bibliography/chapter16.html>.
- Byram Fowles, Tammie. "Contributions to Feminist Therapy." Psych-Net- UK. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.psychnet-uk.com/readers_articles/contributions%20of%20feminist%20theory.htm>.
- Walker, Lenore. “A Feminist Therapist Reviews the Case.” Women As Therapists. Cantor, Dorothy. 1990. as cited in Byram Fowles, Tammie. "Contributions to Feminist Therapy." Psych-Net- UK. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.psychnet-uk.com/readers_articles/contributions%20of%20feminist%20theory.htm>.
- "Foundations of Feminist Therapy." 25 Nov. 2008 <http://media.wiley.com/product_data/excerpt/69/04713743/0471374369.pdf>.
- Walker, Lenore. “A Feminist Therapist Reviews the Case.” Women As Therapists. Cantor, Dorothy. 1990. as cited in Byram Fowles, Tammie. "Contributions to Feminist Therapy." Psych-Net- UK. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.psychnet-uk.com/readers_articles/contributions%20of%20feminist%20theory.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- Walker, Lenore. “A Feminist Therapist Reviews the Case.” Women As Therapists. Cantor, Dorothy. 1990. as cited in Byram Fowles, Tammie. "Contributions to Feminist Therapy." Psych-Net- UK. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.psychnet-uk.com/readers_articles/contributions%20of%20feminist%20theory.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- "Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics." Feminist Therapy Institute: Feminist Therapy Code of Ethics. 1999. Feminist Therapy Institute. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.feminist-therapy-institute.org/ethics.htm>.
- Walker, Lenore. “A Feminist Therapist Reviews the Case.” Women As Therapists. Cantor, Dorothy. 1990. as cited in Byram Fowles, Tammie. "Contributions to Feminist Therapy." Psych-Net- UK. 25 Nov. 2008 <http://www.psychnet-uk.com/readers_articles/contributions%20of%20feminist%20theory.htm>.
- official website.
- official website.
- Jean Baker Miller on Wellesley College.
- Carolyn Enns on Cornell College.
- Ellyn Kaschak official website.
- Bonnie Burstow on Ontario Institute for Studies in Education
- quoted in Becker, Dana. (2005). The Myth of Empowerment: Women and the Therapeutic Culture in America. New York: New York University Press, 2005. p 148
- Satel, Sally (1998) The Patriarchy Made Me Do It, Originally published in The Women's Freedom Network Newsletter September/October, 1998, Vol. 5, Number 5.
- Satel, Sally, M.D. (2000) P.C., M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine. Basic Books, ISBN 0-465-07182-1
- Satel, p. 211
- Dutton, D. G. (1994). Patriarchy and wife assault: The ecological fallacy. Violence and Victims, 9, 125-140.
- Straus, Murray A. 2007. "Conflict Tactics Scales." Pp. 190 - 197 in Encyclopedia of Domestic Violence, N. A. Jackson. New York: Routledge: Taylor & Francis Group.
