| Revision as of 01:01, 23 May 2016 editStumink (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users3,573 editsNo edit summary← Previous edit | Revision as of 21:46, 24 June 2016 edit undoEthiopianHabesha (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users1,312 editsNo edit summaryNext edit → | ||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
| See . There were no Muslims subject to organized killings and it's misleading and ] to compare with the Armenian Genocide, similar to comparing German casualties to the Holocaust. Plus, Ungor's writing is very similar to Armenian Genocide denialists and Rummel threw away his credibility by suggesting the amount of Armenians killed is exaggerated. He does make some good point but the fact he couldn't get a book published and had to make his own website is telling. --] (]) 23:03, 22 May 2016 (UTC) | See . There were no Muslims subject to organized killings and it's misleading and ] to compare with the Armenian Genocide, similar to comparing German casualties to the Holocaust. Plus, Ungor's writing is very similar to Armenian Genocide denialists and Rummel threw away his credibility by suggesting the amount of Armenians killed is exaggerated. He does make some good point but the fact he couldn't get a book published and had to make his own website is telling. --] (]) 23:03, 22 May 2016 (UTC) | ||
| == Menelik Biography == | |||
| I want to let you know in advance before I revert back your last edits in the next few hours | |||
| Under Menelik's talk page I have raised a serious concern regarding to death toll claim, many unanswered questions needs to be answered before it is re-added. I have also issues with the sources used to make the claim like page numbers are not provided. Please see them and comment about it there in the article's talk page so that other users also engages in the discussion. What you have re-added is a very serious topic and needs a lot of discussion before it is re-added. Know that adding them in the article also guarantees the claim made by the 16th century Bermudes which is referenced by primary reliable source as well as secondary reliable sources like Richard and Mohamed to be added on other related hstory of the Oromo people in wikipedia articles as well as in Menelik's biography just to bring balance to the death toll you re-added. Misplaced Pages says biased statements can be balanced by other equivalent opposing statement. To make it balanced I could say like this: in retaliation for 16th centuary ............ hapened as claimed by Bermudes then during Menelik's era .......... hapened as claimed by X writer, just to make it balanced, even-though I personally believe it's inappropriate to add such things nowhere in Misplaced Pages articles, but since it needs to be balanced then if that claim is in then Bermudes claim should be in. — Thank you ] (]) 21:45, 24 June 2016 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 21:46, 24 June 2016
Caucasus Campaign
See this discussion. There were no Muslims subject to organized killings and it's misleading and WP:UNDUE to compare with the Armenian Genocide, similar to comparing German casualties to the Holocaust. Plus, Ungor's writing is very similar to Armenian Genocide denialists and Rummel threw away his credibility by suggesting the amount of Armenians killed is exaggerated. He does make some good point but the fact he couldn't get a book published and had to make his own website is telling. --Hyrudagon (talk) 23:03, 22 May 2016 (UTC)
Menelik Biography
I want to let you know in advance before I revert back your last edits in the next few hours
Under Menelik's talk page I have raised a serious concern regarding to death toll claim, many unanswered questions needs to be answered before it is re-added. I have also issues with the sources used to make the claim like page numbers are not provided. Please see them and comment about it there in the article's talk page so that other users also engages in the discussion. What you have re-added is a very serious topic and needs a lot of discussion before it is re-added. Know that adding them in the article also guarantees the claim made by the 16th century Bermudes which is referenced by primary reliable source as well as secondary reliable sources like Richard and Mohamed to be added on other related hstory of the Oromo people in wikipedia articles as well as in Menelik's biography just to bring balance to the death toll you re-added. Misplaced Pages says biased statements can be balanced by other equivalent opposing statement. To make it balanced I could say like this: in retaliation for 16th centuary ............ hapened as claimed by Bermudes then during Menelik's era .......... hapened as claimed by X writer, just to make it balanced, even-though I personally believe it's inappropriate to add such things nowhere in Misplaced Pages articles, but since it needs to be balanced then if that claim is in then Bermudes claim should be in. — Thank you EthiopianHabesha (talk) 21:45, 24 June 2016 (UTC)