Misplaced Pages

Revision as of 22:43, 18 February 2017

A request that this article title be changed to Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections is under discussion. Please do not move this article until the discussion is closed.

The United States government has accused the Russian government of interfering in the 2016 United States elections. The US intelligence community has stated that "Russian President Vladimir Putin ordered an influence campaign in 2016 aimed at the US presidential election. Russia’s goals were to undermine public faith in the US democratic process, denigrate Secretary Hillary Clinton, and harm her electability and potential presidency." Further, the US intelligence community stated "Putin and the Russian Government developed a clear preference for President-elect Trump." It further stated that these assessments were made with "high confidence." The Office of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), representing 17 intelligence agencies, and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) jointly stated that Russia hacked the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and leaked its documents to WikiLeaks. In early January 2017, Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper testified before a Senate committee that Russia’s alleged meddling in the 2016 presidential campaign went beyond hacking, and included disinformation and the dissemination of fake news often promoted on social media. The Russian government continually denied it had any involvement. WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange said that Russia was not involved in the leaks.

U.S. intelligence agencies said that Russian President Vladimir Putin "personally directed" the operation. Russia disputed Putin's involvement. CIA Director John Brennan, FBI Director James Comey and DNI James R. Clapper agreed on the "scope, nature and intent" of Russia's alleged interference to assist Trump. Several cybersecurity firms stated that the cyberattacks were committed by Russian intelligence groups Fancy Bear and Cozy Bear. In October 2016, President Barack Obama used the red phone line to directly contact Putin and warn him from cyber attacks.

Obama ordered a report on foreign interventions in elections. U.S. senators called for a bipartisan investigation. President-elect Donald Trump initially rejected the report, saying that Democrats were reacting to their election loss, and attacked the intelligence agencies in a transition team statement. Senate Majority Leader Republican Mitch McConnell expressed confidence in U.S. intelligence and supported a bipartisan investigation, as did the Senate Intelligence Committee. On December 29, 2016, the U.S. expelled 35 Russian diplomats, denied access to two Russia-owned compounds, and broadened existing sanctions on Russian entities and individuals.

Background

Hostility between Putin and Clinton

Russian President Vladimir Putin repeatedly accused Hillary Clinton, who served as U.S. Secretary of State from 2009 to 2013, of interfering in Russia’s internal affairs, and Clinton accused Putin of having a personal grudge against her. Michael McFaul, who was U.S. ambassador to Russia, said that " was very upset and continued to be for the rest of the time that I was in government. One could speculate that this is his moment for payback." NBC News reported: "Several former Obama administration officials said that when Clinton was secretary of state, she was by far the most aggressive and outspoken U.S. official when it came to countering Putin's efforts to consolidate his power domestically, and to expand his sphere of influence in the region and beyond. And when she left government, they say, Clinton became even more combative".

According to Russian security expert and investigative journalist Andrei Soldatov, one of the reasons Russia might try to sway the US presidential election is perceived antipathy between Clinton and the Russian government. Soldatov stated that according to Russia, the US is "trying to interfere in our internal affairs so why not try to do the same thing to them?"

Democratic National Committee email leak

On July 22, 2016, WikiLeaks released approximately 20,000 emails sent from or received by Democratic National Committee (DNC) personnel, On October 7, 2016, WikiLeaks started releasing series of emails and documents sent from or received by Hillary Clinton campaign manager John Podesta.

Counter-Disinformation Team scrapped pre-election

The International Business Times reported that the United States Department of State planned to use a unit formed with the intention of combating disinformation from the Russian government, and that it was disbanded in September 2015 after department heads missed the scope of propaganda before the 2016 U.S. election. The unit had been in development for 8 months prior to being scrapped. Titled the Counter-Disinformation Team, it would have been a reboot of the Active Measures Working Group set up by the Reagan Administration. It was created under the Bureau of International Information Programs. Work began in 2014, with the intention of countering propaganda from Russian sources such as TV network RT (formerly called Russia Today). A beta website was ready, and staff were hired by the U.S. State Department for the unit prior to its cancellation. U.S. Intelligence officials explained to former National Security Agency analyst and counterintelligence officer John R. Schindler that the Obama Administration decided to cancel the unit, as they were afraid of antagonizing Russia. A State Department representative told the International Business Times after being contacted regarding the closure of the unit, that the U.S. was disturbed by propaganda from Russia, and the strongest defense was sincere communication. U.S. Undersecretary of State for Public Diplomacy Richard Stengel was point person for the unit before it was canceled. Stengel previously wrote about disinformation by RT. After U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry called RT a Kremlin propaganda arm, RT insisted that the State Department respond. Stengel wrote that RT had engaged in a disinformation campaign.

Russian trolls

Andrew Weisburd and Foreign Policy Research Institute fellow and senior fellow at the Center for Cyber and Homeland Security at George Washington University, Clint Watts, wrote for The Daily Beast in August 2016 that Russian propaganda fabricated articles were popularized by social media. They wrote that disinformation spread from government-controlled outlets, RT and Sputnik to pro-Russian accounts on Twitter. Citing research by Adrian Chen, they compared Russian tactics during the 2016 U.S. election to Soviet Union Cold War strategies. They referenced the 1992 United States Information Agency report to the U.S. Congress, which warned about Russian propaganda called active measures. They wrote active measures were made easier with social media. Institute of International Relations Prague senior fellow and scholar on Russian intelligence, Mark Galeotti, agreed the Kremlin operations were a form of active measures. The Guardian wrote in November 2016 the most strident Internet promoters of Trump were paid Russian propagandists, estimating several thousand trolls involved.

In a followup article, together with colleague J. M. Berger, Weisburd and Watts said they had monitored 7,000 pro-Trump social media accounts over a two-and-a-half year period, and found that such accounts denigrated critics of Russian activities in Syria and propagated falsehoods about Clinton's health. Watts said the propaganda targeted the alt-right movement, the right wing, and fascist groups.

On November 24, 2016, The Washington Post echoed Watts' findings that Russian propaganda exacerbated criticism of Clinton and support for Trump, via social media, Internet trolls, botnets, and websites denigrating Clinton. Watts stated that Russia's goal was to "erode faith in the U.S. government". The Post cited similarity with online propaganda methods previously researched by the Elliott School of International Affairs at George Washington University and the RAND Corporation.

Allegations of collusion between Trump and Putin

In July 2016, U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack accused Donald Trump of encouraging the Russian government to hack the email of Hillary Clinton, Trump's opponent in the 2016 Presidential Election. Several other Democratic Senators claimed Trump's comments appeared to violate the Logan Act. Laurence Tribe, a professor of constitutional law at Harvard Law School, also commented on the incident saying, "Trump's "jokes" inviting an adversary to wage cyberwar against the U.S. appear to violate the Logan Act and might even constitute treason."

Cybersecurity analysis

In June and July 2016, Cybersecurity experts and firms, including CrowdStrike, Fidelis, Mandiant, SecureWorks and ThreatConnect, stated the leak of emails in the 2016 U.S. elections was part of a series of cyberattacks on the DNC committed by two Russian intelligence groups, called Fancy Bear and Cozy Bear, also known respectively as APT28 and APT29. Other actors working in connection with APT28 were called Sofacy, Sednit and Pawn Storm, collectively labeled by SecureWorks as Threat Group 4127 (TG-4127). ThreatConnect also noted possible links between the DC Leaks project and Russian intelligence operations because of a similarity with Fancy Bear attack patterns. DC Leaks had published material from NATO General Philip Breedlove and from George Soros' Open Society Foundations. Fancy Bear was also suspected of hacking the world anti-doping agency in relation with the expulsion of Russian athletes from the 2016 Olympic Games.

In December 2016, Ars Technica IT editor Sean Gallagher refuted Donald Trump's attempts to disredit and discount the intelligence community's reports that linked the hacking to Russia, and he wrote that the hacking was tracked real-time by both law enforcement and private security firms.

U.S. intelligence analysis

Director of National Intelligence, Homeland Security and CIA

October 2016 joint statement

Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper said after the 2011–13 Russian protests, Putin's confidence in his viability as a politician was damaged, and Putin responded with the propaganda operation. Former Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) officer Patrick Skinner explained the goal was to spread uncertainty. In July 2016, consensus grew within the CIA that Russia hacked the DNC.

In a joint statement on October 7, 2016, the Department of Homeland Security and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence issued a statement on Russian influence on the 2016 U.S. presidential election. The statement expressed confidence Russia interfered in the election by stealing emails from politicians and U.S. groups and publicizing the information. By December 2, 2016, intelligence sources told CNN the U.S. Intelligence Community gained confidence Russia's efforts were aimed at helping Trump win the election.

December 2016 CIA report

On December 9, the CIA told U.S. legislators the U.S. Intelligence Community concluded Russia conducted operations during the 2016 U.S. election to assist Donald Trump in winning the presidency. Multiple U.S intelligence agencies concluded people with direct ties to the Kremlin gave WikiLeaks hacked emails from the DNC and sources such as John Podesta, campaign chairman for Hillary Clinton. These intelligence organizations concluded Russia hacked the RNC as well as the DNC—and chose not to leak information obtained from the RNC. This was based on evidence obtained before the election. A senior U.S. official said this was the consensus of multiple intelligence agencies. The CIA said the foreign intelligence agents were Russian operatives previously known to the U.S. The CIA told U.S. Senators it was strongly apparent Russia's intentions were to help Trump.

Vladimir Putin involvement

NBC News reported two senior federal employees said post-election intelligence led officials to believe Vladimir Putin personally controlled the operation. They said Putin's motives started as a feud against Hillary Clinton, and grew into a desire to foment global distrust of the U.S. They said the operation needed approval by top Russian officials, as Putin maintained absolute control. Officials made similar statements to CBS and ABC News. According to U.S. foreign and intelligence officials, the operation began with low-level Russian military, as an effort to penetrate computers belonging to Democratic and Republican politicians, and Putin became personally involved after Russia accessed the DNC. Two senior officials told CNN the scale of the operation required support from the Russian government's top authority. U.S. officials said that under Putin's direction, the goals evolved from criticizing American democracy to attacking Clinton. U.S. officials further said that Putin's aims shifted to help elect Trump during 2016, as he felt the candidate would favor Russia with regards to U.S. financial sanctions. A U.S. intelligence official said to Reuters that due to Putin's prior experience as an operative for the KGB, he maintained tighter control over Russian intelligence operations.

Deputy National Security Adviser Ben Rhodes appeared on MSNBC on December 15, 2016 and agreed with this assessment, saying operations of this magnitude required Putin's consent. White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest noted in a December 15 press conference that the U.S. Intelligence Community reached similar conclusions, and he quoted from the October 2016 joint-letter by the Director of National Intelligence and Department of Homeland Security, saying the operation required top-level Russian government approval.

Federal Bureau of Investigation

In June 2016, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) notified the Illinois Republican Party in June that some of its email accounts may have been hacked. On October 31, 2016, The New York Times stated that the FBI had been examining possible connections between Trump and Russia, but did not find a connection. At the time FBI officials thought Russia was motivated to create chaos generally and not specifically elect Trump. An unnamed official disputed the RNC servers were hacked, and stated that Russian attempts to access the RNC server were unsuccessful. In a December 11, 2016 interview with George Stephanopoulos of ABC News, RNC chair Reince Priebus stated they communicated with the FBI when they learned about hacking of the DNC, and after a review it was determined their servers were secure. During a House Intelligence Committee hearing, the FBI said they were unclear as to motive.

On December 16, 2016, Director of the Central Intelligence Agency John O. Brennan stated the FBI and Director of National Intelligence supported the CIA's conclusion that the Russian government interfered in the U.S. elections in 2016 with the motive of assisting Donald Trump in securing the White House, and attacking U.S. democratic values. Brennan sent a letter to his staff saying he held a meeting with Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation James Comey and Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper, and that all were in agreement about these conclusions. Brennan's letter stated: "Earlier this week, I met separately with (Director) FBI James Comey and DNI Jim Clapper, and there is strong consensus among us on the scope, nature, and intent of Russian interference in our presidential election." Brennan said the FBI, CIA, and DNI all acknowledged the importance of working together to complete the president's order to investigate.

December 2016 Joint Analysis Report

On December 29, 2016 the FBI and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) released a Joint Analysis Report titled "GRIZZLY STEPPE – Russian Malicious Cyber Activity". It gave new technical details regarding methods used by Russian intelligence services for affecting the U.S. election, government, political organizations and private sector.

The report included malware samples and other technical details as evidence that the Russian government had hacked the Democratic National Committee. Alongside the report, DHS "released an extensive list of Internet Protocol addresses, computer files, malware code and other 'signatures' that it said the Russian hackers have used."

An article in the Süddeutsche Zeitung discussed the difficulty of proof in matters of cybersecurity. Multiple security experts told the paper that evidence provided by the Joint Analysis Report was weak, and did not provide proof of Russian culpability. One analyst told the Süddeutsche Zeitung that US intelligence services could be keeping some information secret to protect their sources and analysis methods. It also notes that the comments of some providers of cybersecurity services may be overstated due to self-promotion. An article in Ars Technica cited some cybersecurity commentators who expressed concerns about the report. ZDNet noted that the PHP malware included in the JAR is "an out-of-date, web-shell hacking tool," which—according to Rob Graham, CEO of Errata Security—is "used by hundreds if not thousands of hackers, mostly associated with Russia, but also throughout the rest of the world." Other experts cited by Fortune called the Grizzly Steppe report “poorly done” and “fatally flawed,”.

Kevin Poulsen, writing for The Daily Beast, stated that while there is a "ton of" solid evidence of Russia's interference, the incompleteness of the report encouraged "Trump-friendly conspiracy theorists" – despite years of cybersecurity industry research that invalidates their claims. According to The Daily Beast, the report "was widely criticized by cybersecurity experts for being little more than a hodge-podge of random Internet Protocol addresses and code names for hacker gangs suspected of having ties to Moscow."

January 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment

On January 6, 2017, after briefing the president, the president-elect, and members of the Senate and House, US intelligence agencies released a de-classified version of the report on Russian activities. The report asserted that Russia had carried out a massive cyber operation on orders by Russian President Putin with the goal to sabotage the 2016 US elections. The agencies concluded that Putin and the Russian government tried to help Trump win the election by discrediting Hillary Clinton and portraying her negatively relative to Trump, and that Russia had conducted a multipronged cyber campaign consisting of hacking and the extensive use of social media and trolls, as well as open propaganda on Russian-controlled news platforms. A large part of the report was dedicated to criticizing Russian TV channel RT America, which it described as a "messaging tool" for the Kremlin.

On January 10, 2017, FBI Director James Comey told the Senate Intelligence Committee that FBI "did not develop any evidence that the Trump campaign or the current RNC was successfully hacked." He added that Russia succeeded in "... collecting some information from Republican-affiliated targets but did not leak it to the public ...".

Investigation into financial flows

On January 18, 2017, McClatchy reported that an investigation into "how money may have moved from the Kremlin to covertly help Trump win" had been conducted over several months by six federal agencies: the FBI, the CIA, the NSA, the Justice Department, the FCEN and representatives of the DNI. The New York Times confirmed this investigation into Carter Page, Paul Manafort and Roger Stone on January 19, 2017; the eve of the presidential inauguration.

Dossier about alleged Russian connections

On October 31, 2016, a week before the election, David Corn of Mother Jones magazine, reported that an unnamed former intelligence officer had produced a report (later referred to as a dossier) based on Russian sources and had turned it over to the FBI. Corn said the main points in the unverified report were that Moscow had tried to cultivate Donald Trump for years; that it possessed compromising or potentially embarrassing material about him that could possibly be used to blackmail him; and that there had been a flow of information between the Trump campaign and the Kremlin, which also involved multiple in-person meetings between Russian government officials and individuals working for Trump. It said the Kremlin's goal had been to encourage splits and divisions in the Western alliance.

On January 10, 2017, CNN reported that classified documents presented to Obama and Trump the previous week included allegations that Russian operatives possess "compromising personal and financial information" about Trump. CNN stated that it would not publish specific details on the memos because they had not yet "independently corroborated the specific allegations." Following CNN's report, BuzzFeed then published a 35-page dossier that it said was the basis of the briefing. It included unverified claims that Russian operatives had worked with the Trump campaign to help him get elected. It also alleged that Russia had collected "embarrassing material" involving Trump that could be used to blackmail him. Trump denounced the unverified claims as false, saying that it was "disgraceful" for U.S. intelligence agencies to report them.

Government response

U.S. Senate

Members of the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee traveled to Ukraine and Poland in 2016 and learned about supposed Russian operations to influence their elections. U.S. Senator Angus King said tactics used by Russia during the 2016 U.S. election were analogous to those used against other countries. King said the problem frustrated both political parties. On November 30, 2016, seven members of the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee asked President Obama to declassify and publicize more information on Russia's role in the U.S. election. Representatives in the U.S. Congress took action to monitor the national security of the United States by advancing legislation to monitor propaganda. On November 30, 2016, legislators approved a measure within the National Defense Authorization Act to ask the U.S. State Department act against propaganda with an inter-agency panel. The initiative was developed through a bipartisan bill, the Countering Foreign Propaganda and Disinformation Act, written by U.S. Senators Republican Rob Portman and Democrat Chris Murphy. U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee member Ron Wyden said frustration over covert Russian propaganda was bipartisan.

Republican U.S. Senators stated they planned to hold hearings and investigate alleged Russian influence on the 2016 U.S. elections. By doing so they went against the preference of incoming Republican President-elect Trump, who downplayed Russian interference. U.S. Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman John McCain and U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Richard Burr planned investigations of Russian cyberwarfare. U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Bob Corker planned a 2017 investigation. Senator Lindsey Graham indicated he would conduct an investigation in the 115th Congress. On December 11, 2016, top-ranking bipartisan members of the U.S. Senate issued a joint statement together on December 11, 2016 responding to the intelligence assessments Russia influenced the election. The two Republican signers were Senators Graham and McCain, both members of the Armed Services Committee; the two Democratic signers were incoming Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, and Senator Jack Reed, the ranking member of the Armed Services Committee. They said Russian interference was deeply troubling and a bipartisan concern.

In a response to Trump's disregard for the U.S. intelligence assessments on Russia, Republican Senator John McCain said: "The facts are there." Senator McCain called for a special select committee of the U.S. Senate to investigate Russian meddling in the election. Republican Senator and Intelligence Committee member James Lankford agreed looking into Russian influence on the elections should be cooperative between parties. According to McCain, Russia's meddling in the election was an "act of war." Republican Senator Susan Collins said a bipartisan investigation should improve proactive cyber defence. Outgoing Senate Democratic Caucus leader Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid said the FBI covered up information about Russian interference in a bid to swing the election for Trump. Reid accused FBI Director James Comey of partisanship, and called for his resignation.

On December 12, 2016, Senate Majority Leader Republican Mitch McConnell disagreed with Trump and expressed confidence in U.S. intelligence. McConnell added that investigation of Russia's actions "should not be a partisan issue" and said that it "defies belief" that some members of the Republican Party would not want such an investigation. McConnell announced the Senate intelligence panel would conduct an investigation into Russian interference.

In a joint bipartisan letter issued on December 18, Senators McCain, Graham, Schumer, and Reed urged McConnell to create a new, select committee to undertake a "comprehensive investigation of Russian interference" and develop "comprehensive recommendations and, as necessary, new legislation to modernize our nation’s laws, governmental organization, and related practices to meet this challenge." McConnell, by contrast, has thus far held that the Senate Intelligence Committee is "more than capable of conducting a complete review" and that creating a select committee was unnecessary.

In a December 14, 2016 interview with Wolf Blitzer on CNN, Senator Lindsey Graham said Russians hacked into his Senate campaign email. Graham said the FBI contacted his campaign in August 2016 to notify them of the breach in security which occurred in June to his campaign vendor. On December 15, 2016, Senator Graham stated in order for Trump's nominee for United States Secretary of State, Rex Tillerson, to earn his confirmation vote, Tillerson would need to acknowledge his belief Russia interfered in the 2016 elections. On December 16, 2016, U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Richard Burr said he supported the U.S. intelligence community conclusions. Burr stated intelligence employees working for the U.S. are diverse and hold varied political views. The U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee issued a release emphasizing they earnestly took into consideration the fact that both the Senate Majority and Minority Leaders were in agreement a bipartisan investigation should take place.

U.S. House of Representatives

U.S. Representative Adam Schiff, Ranking Member of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, commented on Putin's aims, and said U.S. intelligence agencies were concerned with Russian propaganda. Speaking about disinformation that appeared in Hungary, Slovakia, the Czech Republic, and Poland, Schiff said there was an increase of the same behavior in the U.S. Schiff concluded Russian propaganda operations would continue against the U.S. after the election. He put forth a recommendation for a combined House and Senate investigation similar to the Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Community Activities before and after the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001.

Republican U.S. Speaker of the House Paul Ryan said external interference in U.S. elections was intolerable. Ryan said an investigation should be conducted by U.S. House Intelligence Committee chairman Representative Devin Nunes, and stated interference from Russia was troubling due to Putin's activities against the U.S. On December 12, 2016, Nunes emphasized that at the time he had only viewed circumstantial evidence Russia intended to assist Trump win. On December 14, Nunes requested a formal briefing gain more information about assertions officials had revealed to the media; the DNI refused, citing the ongoing review ordered by President Obama.

Obama administration

U.S. President Obama and Vladimir Putin had a discussion about computer security issues in September 2016, which took place over the course of an hour and a half. During the discussion, which took place as a side segment during the then-ongoing G20 summit in China, Obama made his views known on cyber security matters between the U.S. and Russia. Obama said Russian hacking stopped after his warning to Putin. One month after that discussion the email leaks from the DNC cyber attack had not ceased, and President Obama decided to contact Putin via the Moscow–Washington hotline, commonly known as the "red phone", on October 31, 2016. Obama emphasized the gravity of the situation by telling Putin: "International law, including the law for armed conflict, applies to actions in cyberspace. We will hold Russia to those standards."

On December 9, 2016, Obama ordered the U.S. Intelligence Community to investigate Russian interference in the election and report before he leaves office on January 20, 2017. U.S. Homeland Security Advisor and chief counterterrorism advisor to the president Lisa Monaco announced the study, and said foreign intrusion into a U.S. election was unprecedented and would necessitate investigation by subsequent administrations. The intelligence analysis would cover malicious cyberwarfare occurring between the 2008 and 2016 elections. A senior administration official told CNN the White House was confident Russia interfered in the election. The official said the ordered by President Obama would be a lessons learned report, with options including sanctions and covert cyber response against Russia.

On December 12, 2016, White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest was critical of Trump's rejection of the idea that Russia used cyber-attacks to influence the election. Earnest contrasted Trump's comments on Twitter with the October 2016 conclusions of the U.S. Intelligence community. At a subsequent White House press conference on December 15, Earnest said Trump and the public were aware prior to the 2016 election of Russian interference efforts, calling these undisputed facts. United States Secretary of State John Kerry spoke on December 15, 2016, about President Obama's decision to approve the October 2016 joint statement by the Department of Homeland Security and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. Kerry stated the president's decision was deliberative and relied upon information cautiously weighed by the intelligence agencies. He said the president felt a need to warn the U.S. public and did.

Obama was interviewed about the Russian covert operation on December 15, 2016 in an interview with National Public Radio journalist Steve Inskeep for the next day's Morning Edition program. Obama said the U.S. government would respond via overt and covert methods. The president said the government would be better able to speak to motive behind the Russian operation after the intelligence report he ordered was completed. Obama emphasized Russian efforts caused more harm to Clinton than Trump during the campaign. At a press conference the following day, President Obama highlighted his September 2016 admonition to Putin to cease engaging in cyberwarfare against the U.S. Obama explained the U.S. did not publicly reciprocate against Russia's actions due to a fear such choices would appear partisan. He said the U.S. would respond in order to send an unambiguous symbol to the world there were harsh consequences for such interference. President Obama minimized conflict between his administration and the Trump transition, stressing cyber warfare against the U.S. should be a bipartisan issue.

Sanctions imposed on Russia

On December 29, 2016, the U.S. government announced a series of punitive measures against Russia that were said to be "the biggest retaliatory move against Russian espionage since the Cold War" and "the strongest American response yet to a state-sponsored cyberattack". Namely, the Obama administration imposed sanctions on four top officials of the GRU and declared persona non grata 35 Russian diplomats suspected of spying: they were ordered to leave the country within 72 hours. Further sanctions against Russia were announced, both overt and covert. A White House statement said that "Russia's cyberactivities were intended to influence the election, erode faith in US democratic institutions, sow doubt about the integrity of our electoral process, and undermine confidence in the institutions of the US government." President Obama said "these actions follow repeated private and public warnings that we have issued to the Russian government, and are a necessary and appropriate response to efforts to harm US interests in violation of established international norms of behavior."

On December 30, two waterfront compounds used by families of Russian embassy personnel were shut down on orders of the US government, citing spying activities: one in Upper Brookville, New York, on Long Island, and the other in Centreville, Maryland, on the Eastern Shore. They had served as luxury retreats for various Russian diplomats over several decades.

Russian response to sanctions

On 30 December 2016, commenting on his eventual decision to refrain from retaliatory measures, Russia′s president Vladimir Putin released a published statement that his government, while reserving its legitimate right to respond adequately to "the new unfriendly actions by the outgoing U.S. administration" undertaken to "further undermine U.S.–Russia relations", would not "stoop to the level of irresponsible ‘kitchen' diplomacy"; he also invited all the children of the U.S. diplomats accredited in Russia to New Year's and Christmas celebrations at the Kremlin. The statement went on to say that Russia would take "further steps towards the restoration of Russian-American relations depending on the policy that the administration of President D. Trump will conduct".

Commentary and reactions

Hillary Clinton

Hillary Clinton appeared on December 15, 2016 at the Plaza Hotel in Midtown Manhattan, New York City and gave a gratitude speech to her campaign donors in which she reflected on Putin's motivations for the covert operation. She partially attributed her loss in the 2016 election to Russian meddling organized by Putin. Clinton said Putin had a personal grudge against her, and linked his feelings to her criticism of the 2011 Russian legislative election and that he felt she was responsible for fomenting the 2011–13 Russian protests. She drew a specific connection from her 2011 assertions as U.S. Secretary of State in 2011 that Putin rigged the elections that year, to his actions in the 2016 U.S. elections. Clinton said that by personally attacking her through meddling in the election Putin additionally took a strike at the American democratic system. She said the cyber warfare was a larger issue than herself personally, and called them an attempt to attack the national security of the United States. Clinton noted she was unsuccessful in sufficiently publicizing to the media the cyber attacks against her campaign in the months leading up to the election. She voiced her support for a proposal put forth by U.S. Senators from both parties, to set up an investigative panel to look into the matter akin to the 9/11 Commission.

Republican National Committee

The RNC said there was no intrusion into its servers, while acknowledging email accounts of individual Republicans (including Colin Powell) were breached. Over 200 emails from Colin Powell were posted on the website DC Leaks. Chief of staff-designate for Trump and outgoing RNC Chairman Reince Priebus appeared on Meet the Press on December 11, 2016, and discounted the CIA conclusions. Priebus said the FBI had investigated and found that RNC servers had not been hacked. When asked by Chuck Todd whether Russia interfered in the election, Priebus stated there had been "no conclusive or specific report" demonstrating Russian involvement — a statement rated "False" by PolitiFact, who noted Priebus neglected conclusions from the Director of National Intelligence and Department of Homeland Security from October 2016.

Donald Trump

Prior to his presidential run, Donald Trump made statements to Fox News in 2014 in which he agreed with an assessment by FBI director James Comey about hacking against the US by Russia and China. Trump was played a clip of Comey from 60 Minutes discussing the dangers of cyber attacks. Trump stated he agreed with the problem of cyber threats posed by China, and went on to emphasize there was a similar problem towards the US posed by Russia: "No, I think he's 100% right, it's a big problem, and we have that problem also with Russia. You saw that over the weekend. Russia's doing the same thing."

In September 2016, during the first presidential debate, Trump said he doubted whether anyone knew who hacked the DNC, and disputed Russian interference. During the second debate, Trump said there might not have been hacking at all, and questioned why accountability was placed on Russia. After the election, Trump rejected the CIA analysis. Trump's transition team drew attention to prior errors emanating the CIA, namely stating: "These are the same people that said Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction." The intelligence analysts involved in monitoring Russian activities are most likely different from those who assessed that Iraq had stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction. Responding to The Washington Post, Trump dismissed reports of Russia's interference, calling them "ridiculous"; he placed blame on Democrats upset over election results for publicizing these reports. Trump cited Julian Assange's statement that "a 14-year-old kid could have hacked Podesta."

After Obama expelled 35 Russian diplomats and announced further sanctions on Russia, Trump commended Putin for refraining from retaliatory measures against the United States until the Trump administration would lay out its policy towards Russia.

On January 6, 2017, after meeting with members of U.S. intelligence agencies, Trump released a statement saying:

"While Russia, China, other countries, outside groups and people are consistently trying to break through the cyber infrastructure of our governmental institutions, businesses and organizations including the Democrat National Committee, there was absolutely no effect on the outcome of the election including the fact that there was no tampering whatsoever with voting machines."

In the same statement, he vowed to form a national cybersecurity task force to prepare an anti-hacking plan within 90 days of taking office.

Referring to the Office of Personnel Management data breach in 2015, Trump told The New York Times: "China, relatively recently, hacked 20 million government names. How come nobody even talks about that? This is a political witch hunt."

Two days later, Reince Priebus reported that Trump began to acknowledge that "entities in Russia" were involved in the DNC leaks. On January 11, 2017, Trump finally admitted that Russia was probably the source of the leaks, although he also said it could have been another country.

WikiLeaks

In July 2016, WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange said he had not seen evidence emails leaked from the DNC were traceable to Russia. In November 2016, Assange said Russia was not the source of John Podesta's hacked emails published by Wikileaks. On January 3, 2017, he said that a "14-year-old kid could have hacked Podesta’s emails.

On January 6, 2017, Reuters reported on a secret briefing given to Barack Obama by U.S. intelligence agencies on January 5, and scheduled to be shown to Trump a few days later. According to this assessment, the CIA had identified specific Russian officials who provided hacked e-mails to WikiLeaks in an effort to influence the presidential election. The hacked material sometimes followed "a circuitous route" from Russia's military intelligence services (GRU) to WikiLeaks, thus enabling WikiLeaks to claim that the Russian government was not the source of the material published on its website.

Russian government

The Russian government repeatedly denied any involvement in the US presidential election. Already in June 2016, in a statement to Reuters, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov "completely ruled out" any connection of Russian government bodies to the DNC hacks that had been blamed on Russia. When a new intelligence report surfaced in December 2016, Sergei Lavrov, Foreign Minister of Russia, rejected the accusations again, calling them "silly". When ABC News wrote that Russian President Vladimir Putin was directly involved in the covert operation, Peskov called this report "amusing rubbish that has no basis in fact". On December 16, 2016, Peskov called on the U.S. government to cease discussion of the topic unless they provide evidence to back up their assertions. According to The New Yorker, while "Russian officials on all levels have denied the hacking allegations," a pro-Kremlin MP justified them as a possible counterpunch to US "meddling" in foreign elections via color revolutions.

At the Valdai forum in October 2016, Vladimir Putin denounced American "hysteria" over accusations of Russian interference. During his December 23 press conference, Putin deflected questions on the issue by accusing the US Democratic Party of scapegoating Russia after losing the presidential election, saying they should "know how to lose with dignity." He also remarked that the Republicans won control of the House and Senate in state elections and wondered if Russia was deemed responsible for this as well.

Electoral College

On December 10, ten electors, headed by Christine Pelosi, wrote an open letter to the Director of National Intelligence James Clapper demanding an intelligence briefing on investigations into foreign intervention in the presidential election. Fifty-eight additional electors subsequently added their names to the letter, bringing the total to 68 electors from 17 different states. The Clinton campaign supported the call for a classified briefing for electors, with John Podesta saying: "Electors have a solemn responsibility under the Constitution and we support their efforts to have their questions addressed."

On December 16, the briefing request was denied.

Intelligence community

Current members

The CIA assessment, and Trump's dismissal of it, created an immediate and unprecedented rupture between the president-elect and the intelligence community. On December 11, 2016, U.S. intelligence officials responded to Trump's denunciation of its findings in a written statement, and expressed dismay Trump disputed their conclusions as politically motivated or inaccurate. They wrote that intelligence officials were motivated to defend U.S. national security. On the same day, The Guardian reported that members of the intelligence community feared reprisals from Donald Trump once he takes office. Questioned by The Guardian, two serving intelligence officers said they had not heard such concerns internally, one of them "noted that civil-service laws prevented Trump from launching a purge", while unnamed former officers stated that "retaliation by Trump all but a certainty".

Former members

Former CIA director Michael Morell said foreign interference in U.S. elections was an existential threat and called it the "political equivalent" of the September 11 attacks. In a Washington Post op-ed, former NSA director and CIA director Michael V. Hayden wrote that Trump's attack on the Intelligence Community's findings diminished the chances that the incoming administration would use intelligence for logical policy-making decisions. Former CIA spokesman George E. Little condemned Trump for dismissing the CIA assessment, saying that the president-elect's atypical response was disgraceful and denigrated the courage of those who serve in the CIA at risk to their own lives. Another former CIA spokesman, Bill Harlow, said that the dispute between Trump and the CIA was a hideous development and unheard of to occur publicly.

Independent presidential candidate and former CIA intelligence officer Evan McMullin criticized the Republican leadership for failing to respond adequately to Russia's meddling in the election process, "for fear of hurting Trump's chances". McMullin said Republican politicians were aware that publicly revealed information about Russia's interference was likely the tip of the iceberg relative to the actual threat. He said that he felt distressed by the CIA revelations.

William Binney, a former high-ranking official in the NSA, expressed doubt about reports of Russian involvement in the DNC leaks. In Harper's Magazine, he told Andrew Cockburn, "Saying it does not make it true They have to provide proof....So let’s see the evidence." Writing in the Baltimore Sun, William Binney and Ray McGovern criticized the report published by the FBI and DHS on December 29, commenting that it "fell embarrassingly short" of the goal of proving Russian hacking. Binney and McGovern proposed that the DNC emails were leaked by an insider, rather than hacked and exfiltrated by an outside group.

Former UN weapons inspector Scott Ritter called the CIA's assessment "flawed on several levels", stating that "there is no direct evidence linking Russia to the hacks," and that the attribution to Russia rests on unverified assumptions made by German intelligence in a previous hacking case.

Media commentary

Military historian Max Boot, writing in USA Today, stated that while "the intelligence community has made mistakes in the past", in this "case, it is obvious the spies have such a high degree of proof — including, one suspects, electronic intercepts of conversations and human intelligence reports to go along with forensic investigation of the hacked computers — that there is no disputing their bottom line."

Russian-American journalist Masha Gessen, a vocal critic of Putin, wrote that the unclassified ODNI report was "vague" and inconclusive as to whether Putin tried to help Donald Trump. She noted that Putin, in a June 2016 panel discussion, toned down his praise of Trump. Gessen conceded that the classified version of the report may make a stronger case, but called this a "charitable reading".

Journalist Glenn Greenwald, writing for The Intercept on December 10, 2016, criticized the Washington Post and The New York Times, stating that their reports on Russian involvement in the presidential election relied on anonymous sources within the CIA and did not provide any evidence or proof. Jeremy Scahill and John Schwarz, also writing for The Intercept, urged President Obama to declassify evidence of Russian hacking.

Theodore R. Johnson, Eric & Wendy Schmidt Fellow at the non-partisan think tank New America, writes that Russia targeted voters' decision-making processes by doxxing DNC emails and other hacked documents and intentionally spreading, if not originating, fake news. By manipulating the information voters consumed, they may have sown "... enough doubt in the minds of undecided and tentatively committed voters ..." to influence the outcome of the election.

See also

• Cyberwarfare by Russia
• Foreign electoral intervention
• Operation Aurora
• Russian espionage in the United States

Notes

1. APT is an acronym for Advanced Persistent Threat.
2. In 2001, the U.S. government expelled 51 Russian diplomats out of the country in retaliation for Moscow’s alleged recruitment of FBI special agent Robert Hanssen

References

1. Nakashima, Ellen (October 7, 2016). "U.S. government officially accuses Russia of hacking campaign to interfere with elections". Washington Post. Retrieved January 25, 2017.
2. Jackson, David (December 29, 2016). "Obama sanctions Russian officials over election hacking". USA Today. Retrieved January 25, 2017.
3. Ryan, Missy; Nakashima, Ellen; DeYoung, Karen (December 29, 2016). "Obama administration announces measures to punish Russia for 2016 election interference". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 30, 2016.
4. "Intelligence Report on Russian Hacking". The New York Times. January 6, 2017. p. 11. Retrieved January 8, 2017.
5. Blake, Aaron. "The 11 most important lines from the new intelligence report on Russia's hacking". No. January 6, 2017. The Washington Post. Retrieved January 31, 2017.
6. ^ Nakashima, Ellen. "U.S. government officially accuses Russia of hacking campaign to interfere with elections". The Washington Post. Retrieved October 7, 2016.
7. ^ Ackerman, Spencer; Thielman, Sam. "US officially accuses Russia of hacking DNC and interfering with election". The Guardian. Retrieved October 7, 2016.
8. ^ CNN, Evan Perez and Theodore Schleifer. "US accuses Russia of trying to interfere with 2016 election". CNN. Retrieved October 7, 2016. {{cite news}}: |last= has generic name (help)
9. "Top U.S. intelligence official: Russia meddled in election by hacking, spreading of propaganda". The Washington Post. January 5, 2017.
10. ^ "Moscow denies Russian involvement in U.S. DNC hacking". Reuters. June 14, 2016.
11. ^ "WikiLeaks' Assange denies Russia behind Podesta hack". Politico. November 3, 2016. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
12. ^ Alex Johnson, WikiLeaks' Julian Assange: 'No Proof' Hacked DNC Emails Came From Russia, NBC News (July 25, 2016).
13. ^ William M. Arkin, Ken Dilanian and Cynthia McFadden (December 14, 2016), U.S. Officials: Putin Personally Involved in U.S. Election Hack, NBC News, retrieved December 14, 2016
14. ^ Brian Ross; Rhonda Schwartz; James Gordon Meek (December 15, 2016), "Officials: Master Spy Vladimir Putin Now Directly Linked to US Hacking", ABC News, retrieved December 15, 2016
15. ^ Entous, Adam; Nakashima, Ellen (December 16, 2016), "FBI backs CIA view that Russia intervened to help Trump win election", The Washington Post, retrieved December 16, 2016
16. ^ Lederman, Josh; Klapper, Bradley (December 16, 2016). "Official: FBI Backs CIA Conclusion on Russian Hacking Motive". ABC News. Associated Press. Archived from the original on December 17, 2016. Retrieved December 16, 2016.
17. ^ Dilanian, Ken (December 16, 2016), "FBI Agrees with CIA Assessment That Russia Wanted to Help Trump", NBC News, retrieved December 16, 2016
18. ^ Thielman, Sam (July 26, 2016). "DNC email leak: Russian hackers Cozy Bear and Fancy Bear behind breach". The Guardian.
19. ^ Arkin, William M.; Dilanian, Ken; McFadden, Cynthia (December 19, 2016), "What Obama Said to Putin on the Red Phone About the Election Hack", NBC News, retrieved December 22, 2016
20. ^ Sanger, David E.; Shane, Scott (December 9, 2016). "Russian Hackers Acted to Aid Trump in Election, U.S. Says". The New York Times. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
21. ^ Washington, Spencer Ackerman and David Smith (December 9, 2016). "Barack Obama orders 'full review' of possible Russian hacking in U.S. election". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
22. ^ CNN, Tal Kopan, Kevin Liptak and Jim Sciutto. "Obama orders review of Russian election-related hacking". CNN. Retrieved December 10, 2016. {{cite news}}: |last= has generic name (help)CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
23. ^ Seung Min Kim; Burgess Everett (December 11, 2016), "Trump vs. Congress on Russian hacking", Politico
24. ^ Levine, Sam (December 10, 2016). "Chuck Schumer Calls For Investigation Into Russian Interference In The Election". The Huffington Post. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
25. ^ Eric Bradner, Trump on Russian hacking: 'I don't believe it', CNN (December 11, 2016).
26. ^ Nicholas Fando, Trump Links C.I.A. Reports on Russia to Democrats’ Shame Over Election, New York Times (December 11, 2016).
27. ^ Sanger, David E. (December 10, 2016). "Trump, Mocking Claim That Russia Hacked Election, at Odds with G.O.P." The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
28. ^ "Team Trump Mocks Suggestion of Russian Meddling in Election". Bloomberg.com. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
29. ^ "McConnell, Differing With Trump, Says He Has 'Highest Confidence' In Intel Agencies". Retrieved December 12, 2016.
30. ^ Rhodan, Maya. "Sen. Mitch McConnell: "The Russians are not our friends."". Retrieved December 12, 2016.
31. ^ Keith, Tamara (December 16, 2016), "In Leaked Remarks, Hillary Clinton Explains Putin's 'Beef' With Her", National Public Radio, retrieved December 17, 2016
32. Lee, Carol E.; Sonne, Paul (December 30, 2016). "U.S. Sanctions Russia Over Election Hacking; Moscow Threatens to Retaliate" – via Wall Street Journal.
33. "Vladimir Putin accuses Hillary Clinton of encouraging Russian protests". The Guardian. December 8, 2011.
34. "The roots of the hostility between Putin and Clinton". The Washington Post. July 28, 2016.
35. "The top four reasons Vladimir Putin might have a grudge against Hillary Clinton". National Post. December 16, 2016.
36. "Why Putin hates Hillary". Politico. July 25, 2016.
37. "DNC Email Hack: Why Vladimir Putin Hates Hillary Clinton". NBC News. July 27, 2016.
38. "'Pro-Kremlin youth groups' could be behind DNC hack". Deutsche Welle. July 27, 2016.
39. "The 4 Most Damaging Emails From the DNC WikiLeaks Dump". ABC News. July 25, 2015.
40. "18 revelations from Wikileaks' hacked Clinton emails". BBC News. October 27, 2016.
41. ^ Porter, Tom (November 28, 2016), "How US and EU failings allowed Kremlin propaganda and fake news to spread through the West", International Business Times, retrieved November 29, 2016
42. ^ Schindler, John R. (November 5, 2015), "Obama Fails to Fight Putin's Propaganda Machine", New York Observer, retrieved November 28, 2016
43. ^ Schindler, John R. (November 26, 2016), "The Kremlin Didn't Sink Hillary—Obama Did", New York Observer, retrieved November 28, 2016
44. ^ LoGiurato, Brett (April 29, 2014), "Russia's Propaganda Channel Just Got A Journalism Lesson From The US State Department", Business Insider, retrieved November 29, 2016
45. LoGiurato, Brett (April 25, 2014), "RT Is Very Upset With John Kerry For Blasting Them As Putin's 'Propaganda Bullhorn'", Business Insider, retrieved November 29, 2016
46. ^ Stengel, Richard (April 29, 2014), "Russia Today's Disinformation Campaign", Dipnote, United States Department of State, retrieved November 28, 2016
47. ^ Dougherty, Jill (December 2, 2016), The reality behind Russia's fake news, CNN, retrieved December 2, 2016
48. ^ Weisburd, Andrew; Watts, Clint (August 6, 2016), "Trolls for Trump – How Russia Dominates Your Twitter Feed to Promote Lies (And, Trump, Too)", The Daily Beast, retrieved November 24, 2016
49. Ali Watkins; Sheera Frenkel (November 30, 2016), "Intel Officials Believe Russia Spreads Fake News", BuzzFeed News, retrieved December 1, 2016
50. Benedictus, Leo (November 6, 2016), "Invasion of the troll armies: from Russian Trump supporters to Turkish state stooges", The Guardian, retrieved December 2, 2016
51. Andrew Weisburd; Clint Watts; JM Berger (November 6, 2016), "Trolling for Trump: How Russia is Trying to Destroy Our Democracy", War on the Rocks, retrieved December 6, 2016
52. "U.S. officials defend integrity of vote, despite hacking fears", WITN-TV, November 26, 2016, retrieved December 2, 2016
53. ^ Timberg, Craig (November 24, 2016), "Russian propaganda effort helped spread 'fake news' during election, experts say", The Washington Post, retrieved November 25, 2016
54. Lesniewski, Niels (July 28, 2016). "Reid Says Trump Should Get Fake Intel Briefings". United States: Roll Call. Retrieved February 12, 2017.
55. Noble, Jason (July 28, 2016). "Trump's Russia comments could be a felony, Vilsack charges". The Des Moines Register. Retrieved February 12, 2017.
56. Kelly, Caroline (July 28, 2016). "Former Obama mentor: Trump's Russian hack 'jokes' could 'constitute treason'". Politico. Retrieved February 12, 2017.
57. ^ Alperovitch, Dmitri (June 15, 2016). "Bears in the Midst: Intrusion into the Democratic National Committee". CrowdStrike. Retrieved December 24, 2016.
58. ^ U. S. Department of Homeland Security and Federal Bureau of Investigation (December 29, 2016). "GRIZZLY STEPPE – Russian Malicious Cyber Activity" (PDF). US-CERT. United States Computer Emergency Readiness Team. Retrieved January 2, 2017.
59. "Threat Group-4127 Targets Hillary Clinton Presidential Campaign". SecureWorks. June 16, 2016. Retrieved January 23, 2017.
60. "Does a BEAR Leak in the WoodOpen s?". Threat Connect. August 12, 2016.
61. Riley, Michael (August 11, 2016). "Russian Hackers of DNC Said to Nab Secrets From NATO, Soros". Bloomberg News. Retrieved August 30, 2016.
62. Meyer, Josh (August 27, 2016). "Experts: Same Russians hacked Olympic whistleblower, Democrats". NBC News. Retrieved August 30, 2016.
63. Gallagher, Sean. "Recapping the facts — Did the Russians "hack" the election? A look at the established facts". ArsTechnica. Retrieved December 31, 2016.
64. ^ "Vladimir Putin Wins the Election No Matter Who The Next President Is", The Daily Beast, November 4, 2016, retrieved December 2, 2016
65. Schatz, Bryan, "The Kremlin Would Be Proud of Trump's Propaganda Playbook", Mother Jones, retrieved December 2, 2016
66. "Spy Agency Consensus Grows That Russia Hacked D.N.C." New York Times. Retrieved July 26, 2016.
67. ^ Greenberg, Jon (December 11, 2016), "Reince Priebus falsely claims no conclusive report whether Russia tried to influence election", PolitiFact.com, retrieved December 12, 2016
68. Jim Sciutto & Manu Raju, Democrats want Russian hacking intelligence declassified, CNN (December 2, 2016).
69. ^ Entous, Adam; Nakashima, Ellen; Miller, Greg (December 9, 2016). "Secret CIA assessment says Russia was trying to help Trump win White House". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
70. ^ Chris Sanchez; Bryan Logan (December 9, 2016), "The CIA says it has evidence that Russia tried to help Trump win the US election", Business Insider, retrieved December 10, 2016
71. Sommerfeldt, Chris (December 9, 2016), "Russia intervened in the 2016 election to help Donald Trump win the White House: report", New York Daily News, retrieved December 10, 2016
72. David E. Sanger & Scott Shane, Russian Hackers Acted to Aid Trump in Election, U.S. Says, New York Times (December 9, 2016).
73. Mazzetti, Mark; Lichblau, Eric (December 11, 2016). "C.I.A. Judgment on Russia Built on Swell of Evidence". New York Times. Retrieved December 12, 2016.
74. Mary Louise Kelly (December 10, 2016), CIA Concludes Russian Interference Aimed To Elect Trump, NPR
75. ^ Pegues, Jeff (December 14, 2016), More details on U.S. probe of Russian hacking of DNC (video), CBS News, retrieved December 15, 2016 – via YouTube
76. ^ Barbara Starr; Pamela Brown; Evan Perez; Jim Sciutto; Elise Labott (December 15, 2016), Intel analysis shows Putin approved election hacking, CNN, retrieved December 15, 2016
77. ^ "Putin turned Russia election hacks in Trump's favor: U.S. officials", Reuters, December 15, 2016, retrieved December 16, 2016
78. ^ Lawler, David (December 15, 2016), "Vladimir Putin 'personally directed Russian hack of US election'", The Daily Telegraph, retrieved December 15, 2016
79. ^ Kreiter, Marcy (December 14, 2016), "Russia Election Hack Update: Putin Reportedly Directed Effort To Undermine US Election", International Business Times, retrieved December 15, 2016
80. Kathy Gilsinan; Krishnadev Calamur (December 14, 2016), "Did Putin Direct Russian Hacking? And Other Big Questions", The Atlantic, retrieved December 15, 2016
81. ^ "White House suggests Putin involved in hacking, ups Trump criticism", Fox News, Associated Press, December 15, 2016, retrieved December 15, 2016
82. Pearson, Rick. "FBI told state GOP in June its emails had been hacked". chicagotribune.com.
83. ^ Lichtblau, Eric; Myers, Steven Lee (October 31, 2016). "Investigating Donald Trump, F.B.I. Sees No Clear Link to Russia". The New York Times. Retrieved December 11, 2016.
84. ^ Rossoll, Nicki (December 11, 2016). "Reince Priebus: 'RNC Was Not Hacked'". ABC News. Retrieved December 12, 2016.
85. Seipel, Brooke (December 11, 2016). "US intelligence split on motive for Russian election interference". Retrieved December 12, 2016.
86. ^ Strohm, Chris (December 30, 2016). "Russia 'Grizzly Steppe' Hacking Started Simply, U.S. Says". Bloomberg. Retrieved January 4, 2017.
87. Joint DHS, ODNI, FBI Statement on Russian Malicious Cyber Activity, FBI National Press Office (December 29, 2016).
88. ^ Sanger, David E. (December 29, 2016). "Obama Strikes Back at Russia for Election Hacking". The New York Times. Retrieved December 29, 2016.
89. Brühl, Jannis; Tanriverdi, Hakan (December 30, 2016). "Viele Indizien gegen Russland, aber kaum Beweise". Süddeutsche Zeitung. Retrieved January 1, 2017.
90. Goodin, Dan (December 30, 2016). "White House fails to make case that Russian hackers tampered with election". Ars Technica. Retrieved January 1, 2016.
91. Vaughan-Nichols, Steven J. (January 2, 2017). "No smoking gun for Russian DNC hacks". ZDNet. Retrieved January 3, 2017.
92. David Z. Morris. "Grizzly Misstep: Security Experts Call Russia Hacking Report "Poorly Done," "Fatally Flawed"". Retrieved January 3, 2017. Jeffrey Carr, author of Inside Cyber Warfare, wrote on Friday that the report "adds nothing to the call for evidence that the Russian government was responsible" for the campaign hacks. Robert Lee, a former Air Force cyberwarfare officer and cybersecurity fellow at New America, argues that the report is of limited use to security professionals, in part because of poor organization and lack of crucial details.
93. Poulsen, Kevin (January 6, 2017). "How the U.S. Hobbled Its Hacking Case Against Russia and Enabled Truthers". The Daily Beast. Retrieved January 8, 2017.
94. Dozier, Kimberly; Shachtman, Noah; Weiss, Michael (January 6, 2017). "U.S. Spy Report Blames Putin for Hacks, But Doesn't Back It Up". The Daily Beast. Retrieved January 7, 2017.
95. "Background to 'Assessing Russian Activities and Intentions in Recent US Elections': The Analytic Process and Cyber Incident Attribution" (PDF). Office of the Director of National Intelligence. January 6, 2017.
96. Miller, Greg; Entous, Adam (January 6, 2017). "Declassified report says Putin 'ordered' effort to undermine faith in U.S. election and help Trump". The Washington Post.
97. Hess, Peter (January 6, 2017). "RT America Is Put in the Spotlight on Damning Intelligence Report". Inverse.
98. ^ FBI Director: No Evidence Russia Successfully Hacked Trump Campaign, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, January 10, 2017, retrieved January 12, 2017
99. "FBI, 5 other agencies probe possible covert Kremlin aid to Trump". mcclatchydc. Retrieved January 18, 2017.
100. Wood, Paul (January 12, 2017). "Trump 'compromising' claims: How and why did we get here?". BBC News. Retrieved January 18, 2017.
101. Goldman, Michael S. Schmidt, Matthew Rosenberg, Adam; Apuzzo, Matt (January 19, 2017). "Intercepted Russian Communications Part of Inquiry Into Trump Associates". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved January 20, 2017.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
102. ^ Corn, David (October 31, 2016), A Veteran Spy Has Given the FBI Information Alleging a Russian Operation to Cultivate Donald Trump, Mother Jones, retrieved January 12, 2017 {{citation}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |publisher= (help)
103. Corn, David (January 14, 2017), Meeting the man behind the Trump memos, BBC, retrieved January 14, 2017
104. "'It Is Fake News Meant to Malign Mr. Trump'". The Atlantic. January 10, 2017. Retrieved January 12, 2017.
105. "What We Know and Don't Know About the Trump-Russia Dossier". The New York Times. January 11, 2017. Retrieved January 12, 2017.
106. "Intel chiefs presented Trump with claims of Russian efforts to compromise him". CNN.com. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
107. ^ "BuzzFeed's ridiculous rationale for publishing the Trump-Russia dossier". Washington Post. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
108. ^ Sutton, Kelsey. "Trump calls CNN 'fake news,' as channel defends its reporting on intelligence briefing". Politico. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
109. Jeff Stein (January 10, 2017). "Trump, Russian Spies, and the Infamous "Golden Showers" Memos". Newsweek.
110. "U.S. Spies Warn Trump and GOP: Russia Could Get You Next". The Daily Beast. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
111. "Trump Received Unsubstantiated Report That Russia Had Damaging Information About Him". The New York Times. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
112. Rascoe, Ayesha (January 11, 2017). "Trump assails 'phony' Russia dossier in chaotic news conference". Reuters. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
113. ^ Miller, Kevin (December 1, 2016), "Angus King: Russian involvement in U.S. election 'an arrow aimed at the heart of democracy'", Portland Press Herald, retrieved December 2, 2016
114. Jim Sciutto; Manu Raju (December 3, 2016), Democrats want Russian hacking intelligence declassified, CNN, retrieved December 3, 2016
115. Staff report (November 30, 2016), "Angus King among senators asking president to declassify information about Russia and election", Portland Press Herald, retrieved December 2, 2016
116. ^ Timberg, Craig (November 30, 2016), "Effort to combat foreign propaganda advances in Congress", The Washington Post, retrieved December 1, 2016
117. ^ Porter, Tom (December 1, 2016), "US House of representatives backs proposal to counter global Russian subversion", International Business Times UK edition, retrieved December 1, 2016
118. ^ Demirjian, Karoun (December 8, 2016), "Republicans ready to launch wide-ranging probe of Russia, despite Trump's stance", Chicago Tribune, The Washington Post, retrieved December 10, 2016
119. Senate Republicans join Democrats in calling for probe of Russian electioneering hacks, CBS News, December 11, 2016, retrieved December 11, 2016 {{citation}}: Unknown parameter |agency= ignored (help)
120. Peralta, Eyder (December 11, 2016), "As Trump Dismisses CIA, Congress Looks To Confront Russian Cyberattacks", National Public Radio, retrieved December 11, 2016
121. John McCain, Lindsey Graham, Chuck Schumer, Jack Reed (December 11, 2016), McCain, Graham, Schumer, Reed Joint Statement on Reports That Russia Interfered with the 2016 Election, United States Senate Committee on Armed Services, retrieved December 11, 2016{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
122. Seung Min Kim & Burgess Everett, Trump vs. Congress on Russian hacking, Politico (December 11, 2016).
123. McCain to Trump on Russian hacking: 'The facts are there' – CBS, December 11, 2016, retrieved December 11, 2016 {{citation}}: Unknown parameter |agency= ignored (help)
124. Meyer, Theodoric (December 11, 2016), "McCain wants select committee to investigate Russian hacking", Politico {{citation}}: |access-date= requires |url= (help)
125. Brown, Greg (December 11, 2016), "Lankford joins in call for bipartisan investigation into Russian election interference", KOKI-TV, retrieved December 11, 2016
126. CNN, Theodore Schleifer and Deirdre Walsh. "McCain: Russian cyberintrusions an 'act of war'". CNN. Retrieved January 14, 2017. {{cite news}}: |last= has generic name (help)
127. Elise Viebeck; Karoun Demirjian (December 11, 2016), "Key GOP senators join call for bipartisan Russia election probe, even as their leaders remain mum", The Washington Post, retrieved December 12, 2016
128. David Smith, FBI covered up Russian influence on Trump's election win, Harry Reid claims, The Guardian (December 10, 2016).
129. O'Keefe, Ed; Kane, Paul (December 12, 2016). "McConnell announces Senate probe of suspected Russian election interference: 'The Russians are not our friends'". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 12, 2016.
130. ^ Nicholas Fandos, Bipartisan Letter Seeks Single Inquiry Into Russian Hacking Claims, New York Times (December 18, 2016).
131. ^ Diaz, Daniella (December 14, 2016), "Graham: Russians hacked my campaign email account", CNN, retrieved December 15, 2016
132. ^ Blitzer, Wolf (December 14, 2016), "Graham: Russians hacked my campaign", CNN (video), YouTube, retrieved December 15, 2016
133. Williams, Katie Bo (December 15, 2016), "Graham: Tillerson must say Russia hacked US to earn his confirmation vote", The Hill, retrieved December 16, 2016
134. Harris, Shane (December 11, 2016), "Donald Trump Fuels Rift With CIA Over Russian Hack", The Wall Street Journal, retrieved December 12, 2016
135. Rachael Bade, Ryan stops short of call for Russia probe, Politico (December 12, 2016).
136. Steinhauer, Jennifer (December 12, 2016), "McConnell and Ryan Back Russia Inquiries, Raising Potential Clash With Trump", The New York Times, retrieved December 12, 2016
137. Ellen Nakashima; Adam Entous (December 10, 2016), "FBI and CIA give differing accounts to lawmakers on Russia's motives in 2016 hacks", The Washington Post, retrieved December 12, 2016
138. Jones, Susan (December 15, 2016). "Intelligence Agencies Refuse to Brief House Intelligence Committee on Russian Hacking". The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved December 16, 2016. cf. Kelly, Erin (December 14, 2016). "Intelligence officials refuse to brief House panel on Russian hacking". USA Today. Retrieved December 16, 2016. cf. "Intelligence Community Statement on Review of Foreign Influence on U.S. Elections". Office of the Director of National Intelligence. December 14, 2016. Retrieved December 16, 2016.
139. ^ Sanger, David E. (December 9, 2016), "Obama Orders Intelligence Report on Russian Election Hacking", The New York Times, retrieved December 10, 2016
140. ^ Detrow, Scott (December 15, 2016), "Obama On Russian Hacking: 'We Need To Take Action. And We Will'", National Public Radio, retrieved December 16, 2016
141. "Obama says he told Putin to 'cut it out' on Russia hacking". Politico. December 16, 2016.
142. Elizabeth Weise; Gregory Korte (December 9, 2016), "Obama orders review of foreign attempts to hack U.S. election", USA Today, retrieved December 10, 2016
143. Josh Gerstein; Jennifer Scholtes; Eric Geller; Martin Matishak (December 9, 2016), "Obama orders 'deep dive' of election-related hacking", Politico, retrieved December 10, 2016
144. ^ Elise Labott, Official: Probe 'solely about lessons learned' on foreign hacking, CNN (December 10, 2016).
145. ^ Griffiths, Brent (December 12, 2016), "White House rails against Trump for not accepting evidence of Russia hacking", Politico, retrieved December 13, 2016
146. ^ Shear, Michael D.; Landler, Mark (December 16, 2016), "Obama Says He Told Putin: 'Cut It Out' on Hacking", The New York Times, retrieved December 16, 2016
147. Fabian, Jordan (December 16, 2016), "Obama turns down temperature on Trump fight", The Hill, retrieved December 17, 2016
148. Greenberg, Andy. "US Hits Russia With Biggest Spying Retaliation "Since the Cold War"". Wired.
149. ^ "Obama Strikes Back at Russia for Election Hacking". The New York Times. December 29, 2016.
150. Cowan, Richard. (December 31, 2016) Trump praises Putin for holding back in U.S.-Russia spy dispute. Reuters. Retrieved on 2017-02-07.
151. Russia retaliates against US 'spy' expulsions The Guardian, March 22, 2001.
152. "U.S. imposes sanctions on Russia over election interference". CBS News. December 29, 2016. Retrieved December 29, 2016.
153. "US expels 35 Russian diplomats, closes two compounds: report". DW.COM. December 29, 2016. Retrieved December 29, 2016.
154. "Russia sanctions announced by White House". CNN. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |authors= ignored (help)
155. "Obama authorises US sanctions against Russia". December 29, 2016.
156. Mark Mazzetti & Michael S. Schmidt, Two Russian Compounds, Caught Up in History’s Echoes, New York Times (December 29, 2016).
157. Ian Duncan, Shut down Russian Eastern Shore retreat offers glimpse at spy battles, Baltimore Sun (December 30, 2016).
158. "U.S. shuts Russian compounds in Maryland, New York over hacking". CBS News. Associated Press. December 30, 2016. Retrieved December 30, 2016.
159. Заявление Президента Российской Федерации Kremlin.ru, 30 December 2016.
160. Путин решил не высылать американских дипломатов Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 30 December 2016.
161. Plane with Russian diplomats expelled from US lands in Moscow. TASS. January 2, 2017.
162. ^ Chozick, Amy (December 17, 2016), "Clinton Says 'Personal Beef' by Putin Led to Hacking Attacks", The New York Times, p. A12, retrieved December 17, 2016
163. ^ Abdullah, Halimah (December 16, 2016), "Hillary Clinton Singles Out Putin, Comey in Election Loss", NBC News, retrieved December 17, 2016
164. cf. Tau, Byron (September 14, 2016). "Colin Powell Blasts Donald Trump, Criticizes Hillary Clinton in Leaked Messages". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved December 11, 2016.
165. ^ Kaczynski, Andrew (December 19, 2016), "Trump said in 2014 that Russian hacking was a 'big problem'", CNN, retrieved December 20, 2016
166. Pramuk, Jacob (September 26, 2016). "Trump: DNC hacker could have been 400 pounds and sitting in bed". CNBC. Retrieved December 14, 2016.
167. Fox-Brewster, Thomas (October 10, 2016). "Clinton Claims Putin's Hackers Are Punting For Trump". Forbes. Retrieved December 14, 2016.
168. Kessler, Glenn (December 13, 2016). "The pre-war intelligence on Iraq: Wrong or hyped by the Bush White House?". Washington Post. Retrieved December 19, 2016.
169. Flores, Reena (December 11, 2016). "Donald Trump weighs in on Russia hacking election, CIA intelligence". CBS News. Retrieved December 13, 2016.
170. Gittens, Hasani; Dilanian, Ken (January 4, 2017). "Trump Takes Jab at 'Intelligence' Officials for Allegedly Delaying 'Russian Hacking' Briefing". NBC News. Retrieved January 5, 2017.
171. "Trump praises 'very smart' Putin for not expelling US diplomats". The Guardian. December 30, 2016.
172. "Trump to order anti-hacking plan within 90 days of taking office – statement". Yahoo News. January 6, 2017.
173. "After Security Meeting, Trump Admits Possibility of Russian Hacking". The New York Times. January 6, 2017.
174. Clarke, Toni; Volz, Dustin (January 8, 2017). "Trump acknowledges Russia role in U.S. election hacking: aide". Reuters. Retrieved January 9, 2017.
175. Shear, Michael D.; Weisman, Jonathan (January 11, 2017). "Trump Says 'I Think It Was Russia' That Hacked the Democrats". The New York Times. Retrieved January 11, 2017.
176. "WikiLeaks' Assange: 'A 14-year-old kid could have hacked Podesta' emails". FoxNews.com. January 4, 2017.
177. "U.S. intel report identifies Russians who gave emails to WikiLeaks -officials". Reuters. January 6, 2017. Retrieved February 12, 2017.
178. ^ Mills, Curt (December 15, 2016), "Kremlin Denies Putin's Involvement in Election Hacking", U.S. News & World Report, retrieved December 16, 2016
179. Sanger, David E.; Rick Corasaniti (June 14, 2016). "D.N.C. Says Russian Hackers Penetrated Its Files, Including Dossier on Donald Trump". The New York Times. New York City. Retrieved July 24, 2016.
180. Henry Meyer; Stepan Kravchenko (December 15, 2016), "Russia Rejects as 'Rubbish' Claims Putin Directed U.S. Hacking", Bloomberg News, retrieved December 16, 2016
181. Smith, Allan (December 16, 2016), "Russia responds to reports it hacked US election: Prove it", Business Insider, retrieved December 16, 2016
182. "Russia's View of the Election Hacks: Denials, Amusement, Comeuppance". The New Yorker. December 20, 2016. Retrieved January 14, 2017.
183. Doroshev, Anton; Arkhipov, Ilya (October 27, 2016). "Putin Says U.S. Isn't Banana Republic, Must Get Over Itself". Bloomberg News. Retrieved February 2, 2017.
184. Filipov, David (December 23, 2016). "Putin to Democratic Party: You lost, get over it". The Washington Post. Retrieved December 26, 2016.
185. Cheney, Kyle (December 12, 2016). "Electors demand intelligence briefing before Electoral College vote". Politico.
186. ^ Pelosi, Christine. "Bipartisan Electors Ask James Clapper: Release Facts on Outside Interference in U.S. Election".
187. Pete Williams, Coming Soon: The 'Real' Presidential Election, NBC News (December 15, 2016).
188. • Gabriel Debenedetti & Kyle Cheney, Clinton campaign backs call for intelligence briefing before Electoral College vote, Politico (December 12, 2016).
     • Dan Merica, Clinton campaign backs intelligence briefing for Electoral College electors, CNN (December 13, 2016).
189. "Electors won't get intelligence briefing: report". The Hill. December 16, 2016. Retrieved February 12, 2017.
190. ^ Shane Harris, Donald Trump Fuels Rift With CIA Over Russian Hack, Wall Street Journal (December 11, 2016).
191. ^ Brian Ross, James Gordon Meek, Mike Levine & Justin Fishel, Trump Engages CIA in War of Words Over Russian Election Hacking, ABC News (December 12, 2016).
192. John Cassidy, Trump Isolates Himself With C.I.A. Attack, The New Yorker (December 12, 2016).
193. Ackerman, Spencer (December 11, 2016), "Intelligence figures fear Trump reprisals over assessment of Russia election role", The Guardian, retrieved December 11, 2016
194. "Morell calls Russia's meddling in U.S. elections 'political equivalent of 9/11'". Politico. December 13, 2016.
195. Michael V. Hayden, Trump is already antagonizing the intelligence community, and that’s a problem, Washington Post (December 12, 2016).
196. Rebecca Savransky, Former CIA spokesman: Trump's disrespect for intelligence community is 'shameful', The Hill (December 12, 2016).
197. ^ Nelson, Louis (December 14, 2016). "McMullin: GOP ignored Russian meddling in presidential election". Politico. Retrieved December 15, 2016.
198. Cockburn, Andrew (December 2016). "The New Red Scare: Reviving the art of threat inflation". Harper's Magazine. Retrieved January 4, 2017.
199. ^ Binney, William; McGovern, Ray (January 5, 2017). "Emails were leaked, not hacked". The Baltimore Sun. Retrieved January 5, 2017.
200. Ritter, Scott (December 12, 2016). "The 'Slam Dunk' That Isn't – The CIA, Russia And The Hacking Of The 2016 Presidential Election". Huffington Post. Retrieved January 4, 2017.
201. "Trump is way off on Russia hack report: Max Boot". USA TODAY. Retrieved January 14, 2017.
202. Gessen, Masha (January 9, 2017). "Russia, Trump & Flawed Intelligence". The New York Review of Books. A close reading of the report shows that it barely supports such a conclusion . Indeed, it barely supports any conclusion.
203. Greenwald, Glenn. "Anonymous Leaks to the WashPost About the CIA's Russia Beliefs Are No Substitute for Evidence". The Intercept. Retrieved December 10, 2016.
204. Scahill, Jeremy; Schwarz, John (January 6, 2017), "OBAMA MUST DECLASSIFY EVIDENCE OF RUSSIAN HACKING", The Intercept, retrieved January 12, 2017
205. Johnson, Theodore R. (December 12, 2016), "Russia Didn't Hack the U.S. Election. It hacked the voters.", Slate (magazine), retrieved February 6, 2017 {{citation}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |1= (help)

Further reading

• Andrew Weisburd; Clint Watts; JM Berger (November 6, 2016), "Trolling for Trump: How Russia is Trying to Destroy Our Democracy", War on the Rocks, retrieved December 6, 2016
• Strohm, Chris (December 1, 2016), "Russia Weaponized Social Media in U.S. Election, FireEye Says", Bloomberg News, retrieved December 1, 2016
• Demirjian, Karoun (December 8, 2016), "Republicans ready to launch wide-ranging probe of Russia, despite Trump's stance", Chicago Tribune, The Washington Post, retrieved December 10, 2016
• Porter, Tom (December 1, 2016), "US House of representatives backs proposal to counter global Russian subversion", International Business Times UK edition, retrieved December 1, 2016

External links

• U.S. Department of Homeland Security and Director of National Intelligence (October 7, 2016), Joint Statement from the Department Of Homeland Security and Office of the Director of National Intelligence on Election Security, archived from the original on December 10, 2016, retrieved December 11, 2016
• John McCain, Lindsey Graham, Chuck Schumer, Jack Reed (December 11, 2016), McCain, Graham, Schumer, Reed Joint Statement on Reports That Russia Interfered with the 2016 Election, United States Senate Committee on Armed Services, retrieved December 11, 2016{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)

• Donald Trump controversies
• Espionage in the United States
• Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation
• Foreign influence in national elections
• Information technology in Russia
• Internet in Russia
• Internet manipulation and propaganda
• Propaganda in Russia
• Russia–United States relations
• Russia intelligence operations
• United States presidential election, 2016